The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
17. Viewed in the aforesaid context, the impugned order of detention becomes unsustainable in law and the same is accordingly quashed. The respondents are directed to release the petitioner from the preventive custody forthwith, provided he is not required in connection with any other case.
17. The petition stands allowed in the above terms. The record be returned to learned counsel for the respondents.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
HCP No. 91/2025
Reserved on: 05.02.2026
Pronounced on : 13.02.2026
Uploaded on : 13.02.2026
Whether the operative part or full
judgment is pronounced: Full
Makhan Lal @ Makhni
….Petitioners
Through:-
Mr. Mohinder Kumar, Advocate.
V/s
UT of J&K & Ors
…..Respondents
Through:-
Mr. Sumeet Bhatia, GA.
\
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY DHAR, JUDGE
(JUDGMENT)
01.
The petitioner, through the medium of the present
petition, has challenged Order No. 06-PSA of 2025 dated
13.06.2025
issued
by
District
Magistrate,
Udhampur-
respondent No. 2 herein whereby the petitioner, namely,
Makhan Lal @ Makhni has been placed under preventive
detention so as to prevent him from acting in any manner
prejudicial to maintenance of public order.
02.
The
impugned
order
of
detention
has
been
challenged by the petitioner on the grounds that the same has
been passed by the detaining authority without application of
mind. It has been contended that there were no compelling
HCP No. 91/2025
reasons with the detaining authority to pass the impugned
order of detention when the petitioner was already facing
prosecution in some of the FIRs registered against him.
According to the petitioner, the allegations leveled against him
in the grounds of detention are fabricated and concocted and
even if the same are taken to be true still then having regard to
the nature of these allegations, it cannot be stated that
activities of the petitioners are prejudicial to the maintenance
of public order. It has been further contended that the
petitioner was not informed of the grounds of detention in a
language which he understands. It has also been contended
that representation of the petitioner against the impugned
order of detention was considered belatedly by the respondents
as a result of which the impugned detention order is vitiated.
03.
The respondents have contested the writ petition by
filing counter affidavit.
In the counter affidavit, it has been
submitted that the petitioner is a hardened criminal involved
in numerous cases of bovine smuggling and assault.
It has
been alleged that activities of the petitioner have disrupted
public order and instilled fear among local citizen. According
to the respondents, the petitioner, by forming a nexus with
other criminals and organizing bovine smuggling operations,
posed a threat to the co-existence of the community and his
being at large could lead to disturbances and exacerbate the
prevailing law and order situation in Udhampur district. It has
been contended that impugned order of detention has been
HCP No. 91/2025
passed by the detaining authority after drawing subjective
satisfaction
from
the
dossier
submitted
by
the
police
authorities and the material on record after proper application
of mind.
04.
It has been further contended that all the statutory
and constitutional imperatives have been adhered to by the
respondents while detaining the petitioner pursuant to the
impugned order of detention. It has further been contended
that grounds of detention were read over and explained to the
petitioner in dogri language which he understands. Regarding
the representation of the petitioner, it has been submitted that
the same was considered and rejected by the Government,
whereafter information was conveyed to the petitioner in terms
of communication dated 04.08.2025. To lend support to their
contentions, the respondents have produced the detention
record.
05.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and
perused record of the case including the detention record.
06.
Learned counsel for the petitioner while seeking
quashment of the impugned detention order has projected
various grounds but his main thrust during the course of the
arguments was on the following grounds:
(i)
That the activities in which the petitioner is
alleged to have been involved cannot form a basis
for passing an order of preventive detention as the
same, at worst, can have an effect on law and order
HCP No. 91/2025
but do not have potential to disturb the public
order and
(ii)
That the representation of the petitioner against
the impugned order of detention has not been
considered by the respondents with promptitude.
07.
So far as the first ground projected by the learned
counsel for the petitioner is concerned, the grounds of
detention would reveal that the petitioner is shown to have
been involved in as many as four FIRs. FIR No. 177/2023 of
Police Station, Rehmbal pertains to involvement of the
petitioner in bovine smuggling.
He is stated to have been
convicted for offences under Section 188 IPC and section 11 of
Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act in the said FIR. FIR No.
207/2023 of Police Station, Rehmbal also pertains to bovine
smuggling and in the said case also, the petitioner has been
convicted and fine has been imposed upon him. The third and
fourth FIRs bearing Nos. 76/2024 and 56/2025 of Police
Station, Ramnagar pertain to alleged attack by the petitioner
upon the respective complainants with sharp edged weapons.
In FIR No. 76/2024, the challan is stated to have been filed
while FIR No. 56/2025 is stated to be still under investigation.
08.
The question that arises for determination is as to
whether on the basis of two instances of bovine smuggling and
two
instances
of
attack
by
the
petitioner
upon
the
complainants, it can be stated that activities of the petitioner
had potential of endangering public order.
HCP No. 91/2025
09.
In order to find an answer to the aforesaid question,
it would be necessary to understand the concept of public
order in distinction to the concept of law and order. This issue
has been dealt with by the Supreme Court in the case of K.K.
Saravana
Babu
Vs.
State
of
Tamil
Nadu
and
anr
(2008) 9 SCC 89. In the said case, the Supreme Court has
observed that public order would mean the tempo of the life of
the community taking the country as a whole or even a
specified locality whereas law and order has been set up in the
hierarchy below the public order. Security of the State has
been set up above the public order in the hierarchy.
Thus, activities which tend to disturb the society as a whole
would constitute a threat to the public order whereas, acts
which are directed against an individual cannot be stated to be
endangering the public order though their acts may disturb
the law and order.
10.
A Single Bench of this Court in HCP No. 4/2024
decided on 06.08.2024 while dealing with the issue as to in
what circumstances, a person can be detained for endangering
the public order has made the following observations:“Maintenance of Public Order as being one of the
grounds
of
subjecting
a
person
to
preventive
detention is not to be easily assumed to be readily
available by a just reference to series of FIRs
reporting crimes against a particular individual which
would at the most render him to be branded as a
habitual offender for which the Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1973 in itself has conceived a preventive
measure under section 110 which enlists a number of
HCP No. 91/2025
categories
for
an
Executive
Magistrate
to
take
cognizance and bind a person so as to prevent him
from indulging in repeat of the alleged activities.
What is meant to be effectively cured and dealt with
under section 110 of the Code of Criminal Procedure,
1973 cannot be diverted to be dealt with by the
application of prevention detention mode of J&K
Public Safety Act, 1978 by depriving a person of his
personal liberty for any given period of time.
A
preventive detention cannot be resorted to by the
debunking ordinary criminal procedure and trial of
cases.”
11.
In view of the foregoing analysis of the legal
position, it is clear that it is only if the activities of a person
sought to be detained under J&K Public Safety Act are of such
a degree as would endanger the public order meaning thereby
disturb the society to the extent of causing disturbance to the
public tranquility, that preventive detention order can be
passed against such person.
12.
In the
instant case, as
already noticed, the
allegations against the petitioner are that he has indulged in
bovine smuggling on two occasions. Both these instances
pertain to the year 2023 and there is nothing on record to
suggest that anybody has complained about the apprehension
of breach of public order on account of these two incidents. In
any case, both these incidents are stale in nature when read in
context of the date of passing of the impugned order of
detention.
13.
So far as the other two incidents in which the
petitioner is stated to be involved, which are more recent in
HCP No. 91/2025
time, the same relate to alleged attack on the complainants by
the petitioner.
These activities of the petitioner cannot be
bracketed in the category of activities endangering the public
order. These activities of the peitioner are directed against a
particular individual and not against the society as a whole.
Therefore, by no stretch of reasoning, it can be stated that the
recent activities of the petitioner have the potential of
endangering the public order.
14.
While this Court is conscious of the legal position
that subjective satisfaction of the detaining authority cannot
be a subject matter of judicial review but at the same time, the
detaining authority cannot pass an order of preventive
detention on flimsy grounds, which appear to be irrational and
extraneous to the object sought to be achieved. In the present
case, the recent activities of the petitioner can, by no stretch of
reasoning, be stated to be a danger to the public order.
Therefore, the impugned order of detention passed by the
detaining authority is not sustainable in law.
15.
So far as the second ground urged by learned
counsel for the petitioner is concerned, it is to be noted that
the petitioner has posted the representation against the
impugned order of detention on 28.06.2025. The detention
record produced by the respondents would reveal that upon
receipt of the said representation by the Government, vide
communication dated 03.07.2025, the Home Department of
the Government sought comments of Additional Director of
HCP No. 91/2025
Police, CID. It was only on 04.08.2025 that the representation
of the petitioner was rejected by the Government and a
communication was sent to the District Magistrate, Udhampur
informing about the result of consideration. The petitioner, it
appears, has been informed about the disposal of his
representation
thereafter.
Thus,
the
respondents
have
consumed more than one month in deciding the representation
of the petitioner.
16.
The Supreme Court in the case of Sarabjeet Singh
Mokha
vs.
District
Magistrate,
Jabalpur
and
others,
(2021) 20 SCC 98 has held that failure to decide the
representation of a detenue within a reasonable time in an
expeditious manner strikes at the valuable right of the
detenue. This position of law has been consistently followed
by this Court in a number of judgments and in this regard,
observations made by this Court in Mohd. Tahir Pall Vs. UT
of J&K & ors (HCP No. 114/2025) are quoted below:
“From the foregoing analysis of law on the subject, it
is
manifest
that
representation
of
delaying
the
of
decision
on
the
detenue
amounts
to
an
infringement of a valuable right which is available to
a detenue in terms of
provisions contained in
Section 13 of the Jammu & Kashmir Public Safety
Act, which makes it obligatory on the detaining
authority to communicate to the detenue the grounds
on which the order of detention has been made
within a maximum period of ten days from the date of
detention and to afford him the earliest opportunity
of
making
representation
against
the
order
of
detention. The purpose of furnishing the grounds of
detention within a maximum period of ten days is to
HCP No. 91/2025
enable a detenue to make a representation against
the order of detention at the earliest opportunity.
Thus, a duty is cast upon the detaining authority or
the government to consider the said representation
at the earliest opportunity. Failure to decide the
representation of a detenue within a reasonable time
in an expeditious manner strikes at the valuable right
of a detenue emanating from the provisions of
Section 13 of the Jammu & Kashmir Public Safety
Act.”
16.
In the present case, the respondents have decided
the representation of the petitioner after more than one month.
This slackness on the part of the respondents to decide the
representation of the petitioner renders the impugned order of
detention illegal.
17.
Viewed in the aforesaid context, the impugned order
of detention becomes unsustainable in law and the same is
accordingly quashed. The respondents are directed to release
the petitioner from the preventive custody forthwith, provided
he is not required in connection with any other case.
17.
The petition stands allowed in the above terms.
The record be returned to learned counsel for the respondents.
(SANJAY DHAR)
JUDGE
JAMMU
13.02.2026
Naresh/Secy.
Whether the judgment is speaking: Yes
Whether the judgment is reportable: Yes
Naresh Kumar
2026.01.29 03:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
HCP No. 91/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review