Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE ANIL VERMA
ON THE 18th OF JANUARY, 2024
SECOND APPEAL No. 2557 of 2022
BETWEEN:1. MAJID KHAN S/O BASHIR KHAN, AGED ABOUT 60
YEARS, R/O – MOMIN PURA, MAHESHWAR,
TEHSIL MAHESHWAR, DISTRICT KHARGONE
(MADHYA PRADESH)
2. AJIJ KHAN S/O BASHIR KHAN, AGED ABOUT 65
YEARS, R/O – MOMIN PURA, MAHESHWAR,
TEHSIL MAHESHWAR, DISTRICT KHARGONE
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....APPELLANTS
(BY SHRI HEM NARAYAN GIRI - ADVOCATE)
AND
HASAN KHAN S/O MUNNU KHAN, AGED ABOUT 45
YEARS, R/O – MOMIN PURA, MAHESHWAR,
1. TEHSIL MAHESHWAR, DISTRICT KHARGONE
(MADHYA PRADESH)
KHERUN BI D/O MUNEER ANSARI, AGED ABOUT
60 YEARS, R/O – MOMIN PURA, MAHESHWAR,
2.
TEHSIL MAHESHWAR, DISTRICT KHARGONE
(MADHYA PRADESH)
...RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI JYOTI SWAROOP DAVE - ADVOCATE)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------This appeal coming on for admission this day, the court passed the
following:
JUDGMENT
Heard on admission.
1.
This second appeal has been preferred by the appellants/plaintiffs
under Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (in short
“CPC”) against the impugned judgment and decree dated 2.8.2022
passed by the 1st District Judge, West Nimar, Mandleshwar (M.P.) in
RCA No.4/2019 affirming the judgment and decree dated 1.12.2018
passed by the 2nd Civil Judge, Class-2, Maheshwar, West Nimar in
RCSA No.100060/2012 filed by the appellants/plaintiffs, whereby the
suit for mandatory injunction and possession has been dismissed.
2.
The facts of the case, in brief, are that the appellants/plaintiffs
have filed a civil suit for decree of mandatory injunction regarding his
ancestral property situated in Maheshwar at Ward No.15 Survey
No.321, 322 House No.187 (New No.297/2 and 297/3) total area
2932.10 sq.ft. against the defendants, who were illegally encroached a
part which was 1332 sq.ft. of the plaintiff’s land by constructing house
on the basis that the above suit property belongs to the defendants.
Plaintiffs requested the defendants to remove their encroachment, but
they denied. Therefore, plaintiffs preferred a civil suit against them.
3.
The respondents/defendants have filed their written statement
before the trial Court and denied all the allegations and pleadings of the
plaint by stating that defendants and their forefather were in possession
of the suit land since last 25 years in the knowledge of the plaintiffs and
their father, therefore, on the basis of the adverse possession, the
defendants became owner of the suit land.
4.
On the basis of the aforesaid pleadings, the trial Court framed the
issues and permitted both the parties to lead their evidence. Trial court
after recording the evidence and hearing both the parties, dismissed the
suit filed by the appellants/plaintiffs. Then the appellants preferred First
Appeal, but the first appellate court upon re-appreciating the entire
evidence available on record, affirmed the findings of fact so recorded
by the trial Court. Therefore, the appellants have preferred this second
appeal.
5.
Learned counsel for the appellants contended that the judgment
and decree passed by both the courts below are illegal and are not based
upon the proper appreciation of evidence. Both the courts below have
failed to consider the oral as well as the documentary evidence adduced
by both the parties. The trial court has overlooked the Jaanch Register
of 1974 (Ex.P/1) and Trace Map (Ex.P/2), which clearly shows that the
disputed land belongs to the father of the appellants and the
construction done by the respondents was never sanctioned by the
Municipal Corporation. On the basis of the electricity bill and tax
receipts of the Municipal Council, no one can claim ownership on any
property. The respondents have illegally constructed the house besides
appellants which is in land belonging to Survey No.187, and Survey
No.297/2 & 297/3 is very far from that place. Thus, in the light of the
aforesaid, he prays that the appeal deserves to be admitted on the
substantial questions of law as proposed by the appellants.
6.
Learned counsel for the respondents opposed the prayer and
prayed for its rejection by submitting that the trial court as well as the
first appellate court after considering the evidence adduced by both the
parties, has passed the impugned judgment and decree which is based
upon cogent evidence. The concurrent finding of fact recorded by both
the courts below do not deserve for any interference. Hence, he prays
that the appeal be dismissed at motion stage.
7.
I have gone through the judgment and decree passed by both the
courts below and also perused the entire record with due care.
8.
From
perusal
of
the
record,
it
appears
that
the
respondents/defendants claims title over the suit land on the basis of
adverse possession.
9.
The law with regard to perfecting title by adverse possession is
well settled. A person claiming title by adverse possession has to prove
three "neck" - nec vi, nec clam and nec precario. In other words, he
must show that his possession is adequate in continuity in publicity and
in extent. Adverse possession must be adequate in continuity, in
publicity and extent and a plea is required at the least to show when
possession becomes adverse so that the starting point of limitation
against the party affected can be found.
10.
In the case of Ravinder Kaur Grewal and others Vs. Manjit
Kaur and others reported in 2019(2) RN 129 (SC), it has been held
that:“48. The statute does not define adverse possession, it is a
common law concept, the period of which has been prescribed
statutorily under the law of limitation Article 65 as 12 years.
Law of limitation does not define the concept of adverse
possession nor anywhere contains a provision that the plaintiff
cannot sue based on adverse possession. It only deals with
limitation to sue and extinguishment of rights. There may be a
case where a person who has perfected his title by virtue of
adverse possession is sought to be ousted or has been
dispossessed by a forceful entry by the owner or by some
other person, his right to obtain possession can be resisted
only when the person who is seeking to protect his possession,
is able to show that he has also perfected his title by adverse
possession for requisite period against such a plaintiff.
49. Under Article 64 also suit can be filed based on the
possessory title. Law never intends a person who has
perfected title to be deprived of filing suit under Article 65 to
recover possession and to render him remediless. In case of
infringement of any other right attracting any other Article
such as in case the land is sold away by the owner after the
extinguishment of his title, the suit can be filed by a person
who has perfected his title by adverse possession to question
alienation and attempt of dispossession.
50. Law of adverse possession does not qualify only a
defendant for the acquisition of title by way of adverse
possession, it may be perfected by a person who is filing a
suit. It only restricts a right of the owner to recover possession
before the period of limitation fixed for the extinction of his
rights expires. Once right is extinguished another person
acquires prescriptive right which cannot be defeated by reentry by the owner or subsequent acknowledgment of his
rights. In such a case suit can be filed by a person whose right
is sought to be defeated.”
11.
It is noteworthy that the appellants/plaintiffs have filed the civil
suit for only mandatory injunction and possession over the suit land, but
the defendants have claimed title over the suit land on the basis of the
adverse possession, but the appellants/plaintiffs did not prefer the suit
for declaration of title over the suit land. As per the provisions of
Article 64 of the Limitation Act, suit should be filed within 12 years of
dispossession.
12.
Plaintiff Majid Khan (PW-1) has been examined before the trial
court. In his evidence he proved Panchshala Register (Ex.P/1) in which
in respect of the land of Survey No.187 name of Bashir Khan who is the
father of the appellant Majid Khan, is mentioned as owner of the land.
Plaintiff Majid Khan in his cross-examination categorically admits that
defendants have constructed house over the suit land about 10 years
ago, but they did not give any notice to the defendants. Gulsher Ahmed
(PW-2) in Para-9 of his cross-examination admits that the plaintiff’s
father and defendant’s father both are the real brothers and about 25 to
30 years ago plaintiffs came to Maheshwar, but they do not know when
did plaintiffs constructed the house. Nazeer (PW-5) also admits that
defendant Hasan has constructed his house since he became major.
13.
Defendant Hasan (DW-1) categorically stated in his deposition
that he has constructed his house about 35 years ago. Wasal (DW-2)
also corroborated the statement of the defendant Hasan. Defendant has
produced the notice (Ex.D/1) which was issued by the dk;kZy; fo’ks"k
{ks= fodkl izkf/kdj.k] egs’oj in the name of Munnu Khan, which was
issued prior to 1.4.1984. Mangilal (DW-3) and Rajesh (DW-4) have
also corroborated that House No.297/2 and 297/3 has been registered in
the name of Munnu Khan, who happens to be father of the defendant
Hasan, since 1970-71 which is also corroborated by the receipt of
property tax issued by the Municipal Corporation.
14.
On the basis of the aforesaid cogent evidence, both the courts
below have rightly given the concurrent finding that the defendant’s
house was constructed on the suit land prior to 1978 and plaintiffs have
filed this civil suit on 4.8.2009, after lapse of 31 years. Therefore, the
respondents/defendants have perfected their title over the suit land on
the basis of the adverse possession and the appellants/plaintiffs have
filed the suit after loosing their possession over the suit land for
possession of more than 12 years. Therefore, both the courts below
have rightly given the concurrent finding that the appellant’s suit is time
barred as per Article 64 of the Limitation Act.
15.
It is a settled principle of law of adverse possession that the
person, who claims title over the property on the strength of adverse
possession and thereby wants the Court to divest the true owner of his
ownership rights over such property, is required to prove his case only
against the true owner of the property. In the present case, defendants
have proved their adverse possession against the true owner of the
property i.e. father of the appellants. Therefore, citation produced by
learned counsel for the appellants in the case of Dagadabai (dead) by
LRs Vs. Abbas @ Gulab Rustum Pinjari reported in (2017) 13 SCC
705 and the judgment dated 29.10.2018 passed by the coordinate
bench of this Court in First Appeal No.826/2000 (Harish Vs. Smt.
Indirakumari) is not applicable in the instant case.
16.
In the light of the aforesaid discussion, this Court is of the
considered opinion that the impugned judgment passed by both the
courts below are well reasoned and based upon the due appreciation of
oral as well as documentary evidence available on record. The findings
recorded by both the courts below are concurrent findings of facts. The
appellant has failed to show that how the findings of facts recorded by
both the courts below are illegal, perverse and based on no evidence.
Thus, no substantial question of law arises for consideration in the
present second appeal.
17.
Enunciation of law by the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Hari
Narayan Bansal Vs. Dada Dev Mandir Prabandhak Sabha (Barah
Gaon) Patam, reported in (2015) 16 SCC 540 empowers this Court to
finally dispose of this appeal without framing the substantial questions
of law at the admission stage itself. The observation made by Hon'ble
Supreme Court is reproduced hereinbelow :“In our opinion, a substantial question of law is not required to
be framed if the High Court decides to dismiss the second
appeal at an admission stage. Only in a case where the second
appeal is admitted or is decided finally by allowing the same, a
substantial question of law is required to be framed by the
High Court. In the instant case, no substantial question of law
was involved in the second appeal and therefore, the High
Court had rightly dismissed the second appeal at the admission
stage by passing the impugned order. We, therefore, see no
reason to entertain this Petition.”
18.
The Supreme Court in number of cases has held that in exercise
of powers under Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure can
interfere with the findings of fact only if the same is shown to be
perverse and based on no evidence. Some of these judgments are
Hajazat Hussain vs. Abdul Majeed & others, 2011 (7) SCC, 189 and
Union of India vs. Ibrahim Uddin, 2012 (8) SCC 148.
19.
Accordingly, present second appeal sans merit and is hereby
dismissed at the admission stage for the reasons indicated above.
C.C. as per rules.
(ANIL VERMA)
JUDGE
Trilok/-
SAVNER
Date: 2024.01.23 11:10:51 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review