Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
JOHN
JOHN TELEN KOM
2023.08.16
TELEN KOM Date:
11:06:40 +05'30'
Item No. 79
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C)No.223 of 2023
Shri Maisnam Lukhoi Singh, aged about 65 years, S/o (Late) M. Bina
Singh, resident of Awang Sekmai Bazar, PO & PS Sekmai, Imphal
West District, Manipur-795136 & 11 Ors.
…Petitioners
- Versus -
1.
The
State
of
Manipur,
represented
through
Commissioner/Secretary(Revenue),
Government
of
the
Manipur,
Manipur Secretariat, Babupara PO & PS Imphal, Imphal District,
Manipur-795001 & 4 Ors.
…Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M.V.MURALIDARAN
ORDER
29.03.2023
1.
Heard Dr. RK Deepak, learned counsel for the petitioners;
Mr. M. Devananda, learned Additional Advocate General for the
respondents 1 to 4 and Mr. S. Kaminikumar, learned Central
Government Counsle for the fifth respondent.
2. This writ petition has been filed by the petitioners seeking to
quash the impugned eviction orders dated 23.2.2023 issued by the
third respondent and to direct the respondents to follow the due
process of law relating to acquisition of land and thereafter pay fair
compensation in accordance with law.
3. Assailing the impugned eviction orders, the learned counsel
for the petitioners submitted that in the case of petitioners 1 to 4, their
lands were notified for acquisition and were included in the schedule
of land intended to be acquired by the competent authority vide
Gazette notification dated 7.4.2021 and 14.10.2021 respectively.
Thereafter, neither any further proceedings were initiated, nor they
were informed of any such proceedings by the competent authority for
acquisition of the land like determination of award, deposit of
compensation and possession thereof, thereby allowed the authorities
to lapse the notification. In the case of petitioners 5 to 12, they were
never informed or notified by the competent authority for acquisition of
land under any relevant rules or laws. Therefore, the competent
authorities cannot just grab the lands belonging to private ownership
in the guise of infrastructure development without following the due
process of law.
4. The learned counsel for the petitioners further submitted that
the provisions invoked by the competent authority in the eviction
orders are not applicable to the petitioners who are legal owners of the
lands intended for acquisition.
Therefore, the action of the
respondents in issuing the impugned eviction orders even before
notifying their intention for acquisition of lands mandated by the Acts
enacted for the said purpose is illegal and void abi initio.
5. The learned counsel for the petitioners would submit that as
evident from the similar cases of acquisition of law along the stretch
NH-2, the competent authority has acquired the land for the purpose
of expansion of National Highways by invoking the relevant provisions
of the National Highways Act, 1956 [for short, “the Act of 1956”].
Assuming but not admitting that the petitioners’ lands are intended to
be acquired under the Act of 1956, the competent authorities ought to
have issued a notification declaring its intention to acquire the land
under Section 3A of the Act of 1956. However, in the instant case,
except for petitioners 1 to 4, the competent authority never issued any
such notification in complete violation of relevant provisions of the Act
of 1956. Thus, the action of the third respondent is arbitrary and,
therefore, the same is liable to be interfered with by this Court.
6. Arguing so, the learned counsel added that the competent
authorities failed to issue any order to surrender or deliver possession
of the lands to them as is required under Section 3E of the Act of 1956
and had also failed to determine the amount payable as compensation
to the affected land owners and make deposits of the same, as
required under Sections 3G and 3H of the Act of 1956. On the other
hand, the third respondent issued eviction orders, violating the
procedures laid down for taking possession of the lands intended to
be acquired under Section 3E of the Act of 1956. Therefore, the action
of the third respondent is illegal and cannot be sustainable in the eye
of law.
7. The learned Additional Advocate General, by producing the
written instructions dated 27.3.2023 received from the office of the
second respondent, submitted that the complaints in respect of the
petitioners have already been examined and after due consideration,
it was found that additional funds would be required to pay
compensation to the land owners and the second respondent
requested the fourth respondent the required funds vide letter dated
24.2.2023. Therefore, the second respondent is awaiting the arrival
of the required funds for payment of compensation amount and once
the amount is received, then the same will be disbursed to the
concerned affected pattadars/land owners.
8. This Court considered the submissions raised by learned
counsel appearing on either side and also perused the materials
available on record.
9. The case of the petitioners is that barring petitioners 1 to 4,
the competent authority never issued any such notification for
acquisition of the lands of petitioners 5 to 12 and, on the other hand,
the competent authority issued eviction orders which are illegal,
illogical and cannot be sustained in the eye of law.
10. Sections 3A to 3J of the Act of 1956 stipulate process of
notification and acquisition of private land for public purpose.
Particularly, Section 3E reads as under:
“3E. Power to take possession.- (1) Where any land has
vested in the Central Government under sub-section (2) of
section 3D, and the amount determined by the competent
authority under section 3G with respect to such land has been
deposited under sub-section (1) of section 3H, with the
competent authority by the Central Government, the
competent authority may by notice in writing direct the owner
as well as any other person who may be in possession of such
land to surrender or deliver possession thereof to the
competent authority or any person duly authorized by it in this
behalf within sixty days of the service of the notice.
(2) If any person refuses or fails to comply with any direction
made under sub-section (1), the competent authority shall
apply(a) in the case of any land situated in any area falling
within the metropolitan area, to the Commissioner of
Police;
(b) in case of any land situated in any area other than the
area referred to in clause (a), to the Collector of a District,
and such Commissioner or Collector, as the case may
be, shall enforce the surrender of the land, to the
competent authority or to the person duly authorized by
it.”
11. It appears that after issuance of the eviction orders dated
23.2.2023 by the third respondent, the petitioners through their
advocate sent a reply on 6.3.2023, inter alia, stating that the provisions
invoked by the competent authority in issuing the eviction orders are
not applicable to the case of the petitioners, who are owners of the
lands under acquisition and have not been granted any compensation.
12. It is the say of the second respondent that the complaints in
respect
of
the
petitioners
have
been
examined
and
after
consideration, additional funds were called for from the fourth
respondent and once funds are received by the second respondent,
the same will then be disbursed to the concerned affected pattadars.
The aforesaid statement is also reflected in the written instruction of
the Deputy Commissioner, Imphal West dated 27.3.2023 sent to the
learned Additional Advocate General. For proper appreciation, the
same is quoted hereunder:
“Sir,
In inviting a reference to our office letter dated 13/03/2023 on
the above subject, I have the honour to state that the
complaints in respect of the petitioner have already been
examined.
After due consideration, it was found that
additional funds would be required to pay their compensation
amounts. The required funds have already been requested
from NHIDCL vide Deputy Commissioner, Imphal West letter
no.DC(IW)/6/7/I-K/LA/2019(Pt. III) dated 24/02/2023 (copy
enclosed) as shown below:
Sl.
No
.
Name
Details
Smt.
(O)
Devi,
and Compensation Status
Shri Meisnam
Lukhol Singh,
Patta No.80(O)
484/963(N)
covered by CS
Dag No.310
Eviction
Status
Land is to be freshly Not evicted
acquired for which
compensation amount
of Rs.50,005/- has
already been called for
(Annexure H-S. No.2)
Soibam Compensation amount Not evicted
Tombi of Rs.96,27,0006/- for
Patta standing
structures
No.318(O)
118/937(N)
covered by CS
Dag No.2920
has
already been
called for. Amount to
be
shared
with
Khwairakpam Amitabh
Singh (Annexure F1 –
Sl.No.10)
Shri
Khwairakpam
Amitabh Singh,
Patta
No.931(O)
1083/4340(N)
covered by CS
Dag No.3285
Compensation amount Not evicted
of Rs.96,27,006/- for
standing
structures
has
already been
called for. Amount to
be shared with Soibam
(O)
Tombi
Devi
(Annexure
F1
–
Sl.No.10
Smt.
Angom
(O)
Kamala
Devi,
Ptta
No.507(O)
215(N) covered
by CS Dag
No.2933
Compensation amount
of
Rs.3,95,377/already available while
additional amount of
Rs.25,86,897/-0
for
standing
structures
has
already been
called for. (Annexure
F2 – Sl. No.8)
Smt. Laimayum
Kumu
Devi,
Patta No.325
(O) 859/964(N)
covered by CS
Dag No.2857
Compensation amount Not evicted
of Rs.29,75,541/0 for
standing
structures
has
already been
called for. (Annexure
F1 – Sl. No.2)
Shri
Kajam
Ramchandra
Singh,
Patta
No.16
(O)
1287(N)
covered by CS
Dag No.2849
Shri
Kshtrimayum
Compensation amount Not evicted
of Rs.14,28,032/- for
standing
structures
has
already been
called for. (Annexure f
– Sl. No.6)
Standing
structures
built
on
governmen
t Khas land
demolished
with
the
consent of
the
encroacher
Compensation amount Not evicted
of Rs.11,45,672/- for
Kirankumar
Singh,
Patta
No.1128/1514
(N) covered by
CS
Dag
No.2846
Smt.
Khwairampam
Tombi
Devi,
Patta
No.483/1671(N
) covered by
CS
Dag
No.2922/336
standing
structures
has
already been
called for. (Annexure
F1 – Sl. No.6)
Shri
Usham
Deva
Singh,
patta
No.483/1670
(N) covered by
CS
Dag
No.2922/3335
Compensation amount Not evicted
of
Rs.23,60,664/already available while
additional amount of
Rs.11,65,455/for
standing
structures
has
already been
called for (Annexure
F2 – sl. No.6)
ShirThangjam
Bhudachandra
Singh,Patta
No.1822/1842
(N) covered by
CS
Dag
No.3383/3391
Smt.
Usham
Amubi
Devi,
Patta No.1100
(O) 105 (N)
covered by CS
Dag No.2847
Compensation amount Not
of Rs.27,01,099/- for evicted
standing
structures
has
already been
called for (Annexure
F1 – Sl. No.7 & 8)
Shri
Khwairampam
Yaiskul, Patta
No.857/964 (N)
Compensation amount Not evicted
of Rs.3,04,674/- for
standing
structures
has
already been
Compensation amount Not evicted
of
Rs.25,95,313/already available while
additional amount of
Rs.5,63,107/for
standing
structures
has
already been
called for. (Annexure
F2 – Sl. No.7)
Compensation amount Not evicted
of Rs.11,44,195/- for
standing
structures
has
already been
called for. (Annexure F
– Sl. No.5)
covered by CS called for. Amount to
Dag No.2857
be
shared
with
KhwairakpamDebendr
a (Annexure F1 – Sl.
No.4)
This office is awaiting the arrival of the required funds for
payment of compensation amounts.
The compensation
amounts, once received by the office of the undersigned will
then be disbursed to the concerned affected pattadars at the
earliest.”
13. In view of the subsequent development, stated supra, now
the impugned eviction notices issued by the third respondent are not
sustainable in the eye of law, as the competent authority after due
consideration of the complaints made by the petitioners has sought
funds from the fourth respondent to pay compensation to the land
owners. Whatever be the process, for acquisition of the lands for
expansion of the National Highways in question, the respondent
authorities have to follow the procedure contemplated under law and
pay
fair
compensation
to
the
land
owners.
Forceful
dispossession/eviction of the land owners from the land owned by
them till proper notification for acquisition and payment of fair
compensation shall be avoided by the respondent authorities. It is
reiterated that the respondent authorities have to follow due process
of law relating to acquisition of the lands and thereafter pay fair
compensation in accordance with law.
14. In view of the above, the writ petition is disposed of. The
respondent authorities are directed not to evict the petitioners from the
lands in question, except by following the due process of law. No
costs.
ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
NFR/FR
[[
John Kom
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review