The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
23. 01.2024 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------This revision having been heard and reserved for judgment, coming on for pronouncement this day, Justice Sanjeev S Kalgaonkar pronounced the following: This criminal revision is filed assailing the judgment of conviction and order of sentence dated 17.11.2006 passed by Additional Judge to the Court of IVth Additional Sessions Judge, Shivpuri in Criminal Appeal No.306 of 2006 whereby the First Appellate Court affirmed judgment of conviction and order of sentence dated 12.07.2006 passed in Regular Criminal Case No.658 of 2004 by Shri Dinesh Kumar Sharma, Judicial Magistrate First Class, Kolaras, Shivpuri. For the sake of convenience, revision petitioner- Mahendra Singh shall be referred to as accused and convict hereinafter. The exposition of facts, giving rise to present revision petitioner, is as under:(i) As per the case of prosecution, on 18.05.1999, Hariram, Lokpal and Sukhlal were returning to their village from hospital by Bus No. MP084669 of Surya Bus Company. They deboarded the bus at Debri triangle. When Sukhlal was deboarding, the bus driver Mahendra suddenly moved the bus negligently in a fast speed. Sukhlal came under front wheel of bus and sustained grievous injury. Sukhlal died on spot. Bus driver Mahendra fled away with the bus. Hariram (PW-2) lodged report (Ex.P-1) at P…
17. 11.2006 and the judgment dated 12.07.2006 be set aside and the revision petitioner be acquitted. Learned counsel for the revison petitioner referring to the statements of witnesses recorded during trial contends that all the eye-witnesses are relatives of the deceased. They are interested witnesses. There are material inconsistencies in the statements of witnesses. Both the Courts committed error in ignoring these aspects of the matter and recorded the finding of conviction against the revision petitioner. Learned counsel further requests that almost 24 years have elapsed since the incident took place. Petitioner has suffered agony of long trial and appeal, therefore, a lenient view be adopted and his sentence of imprisonment be reduced. Per contra, learned counsel for the State contends that both the Courts have committed no error in convicting and sentencing the petitioner for offence punishable under Section 304-A of IPC. The concurrent finding are based on proper appreciation of evidence, therefore, no interference in exercise of revisional jurisdiction is called for. Heard both the parties and perused the record. Under Section 397 of the Cr.P.C, the Court is vested with the power to call for and examine the record of any inferior Court for the purpose of satisfying itself as to legality and regularity of any proceedings or order made in a case. The object of this provision…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGHCOURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT G WA L I O R
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE SANJEEV S KALGAONKAR
CRIMINAL REVISION No.942 OF 2006
BETWEEN:1.MAHENDRAS SINGH RAGHUVANSHI S/O SHRI
KISHAN SINGH AGED ABUT 37 YEARS OCCUPATIONDRIVER R/O ASHOK NAGAR THANA ASHOK NAGAR
DISTRICT ASHOK NAGAR (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI SHVENDRA SINGH RAGHUVANSHI- ADVOCATE)
AND
TH
ES
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH THROUGH THE
STATION HOUSE OFFICER POLICE THANA INDAR
DISTRICT SHIVPURI
.....RESPONDENT
(BY SHRI RAJENDRA SINGH YADAV- PUBLIC PROSECUTOR)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Reserved on
:
16.01.2024
Pronounced on :
23.01.2024
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------This revision having been heard and reserved for judgment,
coming on for pronouncement this day, Justice Sanjeev S Kalgaonkar
pronounced the following:
ORDER
This criminal revision is filed assailing the judgment of conviction
and order of sentence dated 17.11.2006 passed by Additional Judge to the
Court of IVth Additional Sessions Judge, Shivpuri in Criminal Appeal
No.306 of 2006 whereby the First Appellate Court affirmed judgment of
conviction and order of sentence dated 12.07.2006 passed in Regular
Criminal Case No.658 of 2004 by Shri Dinesh Kumar Sharma, Judicial
Magistrate First Class, Kolaras, Shivpuri.
For the sake of convenience, revision petitioner- Mahendra Singh
shall be referred to as accused and convict hereinafter.
The exposition of facts, giving rise to present revision petitioner, is
as under:(i)
As per the case of prosecution, on 18.05.1999, Hariram, Lokpal
and Sukhlal were returning to their village from hospital by Bus No.
MP084669 of Surya Bus Company. They deboarded the bus at Debri
triangle. When Sukhlal was deboarding, the bus driver Mahendra
suddenly moved the bus negligently in a fast speed. Sukhlal came under
front wheel of bus and sustained grievous injury. Sukhlal died on spot.
Bus driver Mahendra fled away with the bus. Hariram (PW-2) lodged
report (Ex.P-1) at Police Station Indar. On completion of investigation,
Police Station Indar submitted final report with the Court of Judicial
Magistrate First Class, Kolaras, District Shivpuri.
(ii)
On completion of trial, learned Judicial Magistrate First Class
Kolaras convicted Mahendra Singh for offence punishable under Section
304-A of IPC and sentenced him for rigorous imprisonment for one year
vide judgment dated 12.07.2006 passed in Regular Criminal Case No.658
of 2004.
(iii) Feeling aggrieved by the judgment of conviction and order of
sentence, Mahendra Singh submitted appeal before the Sessions Judge,
Shivpuri. Learned Additional Judge to the Court of IV th Additional
Sessions Judge, Shivpuri, after hearing both the parties rejected the
appeal and affirmed the judgment of trial Court vide impugned judgment
dated 17.11.2006 passed in Criminal Appeal No.306 of 2006.
Feeling aggrieved by concurrent finding of conviction and sentence,
this criminal revision is filed on following grounds:(i)
The impugned judgment and order of sentence is contrary to the
evidence on record. The prosecution had failed to establish its case
beyond reasonable doubt. The learned Courts below committed error in
punishing the revision petitioner.
(ii)
No independent witness was produced by the prosecution. The
conviction is based on statements of interested witnesses. Revision
petitioner is falsely implicated to take benefit of compensation under the
provisions of Motor Vehicles Act. He has no direct or indirect relation
with the alleged offence.
(iii) There is material contradiction in the statements of prosecution
witnesses.
On these grounds, it is requested that impugned judgment dated
17.11.2006 and the judgment dated 12.07.2006 be set aside and the
revision petitioner be acquitted. Learned counsel for the revison
petitioner referring to the statements of witnesses recorded during trial
contends that all the eye-witnesses are relatives of the deceased. They are
interested witnesses. There are material inconsistencies in the statements
of witnesses. Both the Courts committed error in ignoring these aspects
of the matter and recorded the finding of conviction against the revision
petitioner.
Learned counsel further requests that almost 24 years have elapsed
since the incident took place. Petitioner has suffered agony of long trial
and appeal, therefore, a lenient view be adopted and his sentence of
imprisonment be reduced.
Per contra, learned counsel for the State contends that both the
Courts have committed no error in convicting and sentencing the
petitioner for offence punishable under Section 304-A of IPC. The
concurrent finding are based on proper appreciation of evidence,
therefore, no interference in exercise of revisional jurisdiction is called
for.
Heard both the parties and perused the record.
Under Section 397 of the Cr.P.C, the Court is vested with the
power to call for and examine the record of any inferior Court for the
purpose of satisfying itself as to legality and regularity of any
proceedings or order made in a case. The object of this provision is to
correct the patent defect or an error of jurisdiction or the perversity
which has crept in the proceedings.
However, this Court, in revision, exercises supervisory jurisdiction
of restricted nature. It cannot re-appreciate the evidence, as second
Appellate Court, for the purposes of determining whether the concurrent
finding of fact reached by the learned Magistrate and the learned
Additional Sessions Judge was correct. Recently, in case of Malkeet
Singh Gill v. State of Chhattisgarh, reported in (2022) 8 SCC 204, the
Supreme Court observed as under“10.Before adverting to the merits of the contentions,at the
outset, it is apt to mention that there are concurrent findings
of conviction arrived at by two courts after detailed
appreciation of the material and evidence brought on record.
The High Court in criminal revision against conviction is
not supposed to exercise the jurisdiction alike to the
appellate court and the scope of interference in revision is
extremely narrow. Section 397 of the Criminal Procedure
Code (in short “CrPC”) vests jurisdiction for the purpose of
satisfying itself or himself as to the correctness, legality or
propriety of any finding, sentence or order, recorded or
passed, and as to the regularity of any proceedings of such
inferior court. The object of the provision is to set right a
patent defect or an error of jurisdiction or law. There has to
be well-founded error which is to be determined on the
merits of individual case. It is also well settled that while
considering the same, the Revisional Court does not dwell at
length upon the facts and evidence of the case to reverse
those findings.”
(Duli Chand v. Delhi Admn.(1975) 4 SCC 649; State of Maharashtra v.
Jagmohan Singh Kuldip Singh Anand (2004) 7 SCC 659 also relied).
In the backdrop of aforesaid proposition of law, the contentions of
both the parties are considered.
Hariram (PW-2) and Lokpal Singh (PW-3) have stated that they
were returning by Surya Bus from Bahiriya Hospital. Petitioner
Mahendra Singh was driving the bus. They deboarded the bus on Devri
Triangle. Shukhlal deboarded from front gate as they were moving
towards front of the bus. Driver Mahendra Singh suddenly moved the
bus. Shukhlal came below the front wheel of the bus and died. Both of
them are natural witnesses who were escorting the deceased from
Bahiriya Hospital in the bus. Their evidence cannot be discarded merely
on the ground that they are related to the deceased. Musab Singh (PW-1)
and Balveer Singh (PW-4) generally supported this testimony. No
material inconsistency or contradiction was found in aforementioned
evidence. Dr. L.S.Uchariya (PW-7) conducted the post-mortem
examination of dead body of Shukhlal. Dr. Uchariya deposed that he
found multiple injuries on the body of Shukhlal and opined that Shukhlal
has died due to shock of multiple injuries and internal bleeding within 12
to 24 hours of the post-mortem examination i.e. 19.05.1999. The medical
evidence corroborates ocular evidence. Both the Courts on critical
examination of record, concluded that the accused Mahendra Singh has
negligently moved the bus which resulted in death of Shukhlal. The
concurrent finding of conviction of Mahendra Singh for offence
punishable under Section 304-A IPC is based on proper and appropriate
reasons and critical analysis of evidence on record. The finding cannot
said to be perverse or manifestly illegal being against the evidence on
record. No interference in exercise of supervisory jurisdiction is called for
in concurrent finding of conviction under Section 304-A of IPC.
The petitioner was sentenced to imprisonment for one year vide
trial Court judgment dated 12.07.2006 which was affirmed by the learned
First Appellate Court vide its judgment dated 17.11.2006. The incident
relates to year 1999 when the petitioner was aged 37 years. Now, the
petitioner is aged around 60 years. Almost 24 years have passed since the
incident. The sad memories and pain of the incident must have
diminished with the afflux of time. Petitioner has undergone the vagaries
of trial and the appeal. He must have suffered financially and undergone
mental agony for years together.
On consideration of these aspects, this Court is of the view that
reduction in sentence of imprisonment would serve the ends of justice. In
such a scenario, this revision is allowed only on the point of propriety of
sentence and the sentence is amended accordingly. The revision
petitioner/accused Mahendra Singh is sentenced to two month of rigorous
imprisonment for offence punishable under Section 304-A of IPC.The
period of custody undergone by the petitioner during the trial and during
hearing of appeal and revision shall be set off against the amended
sentence of imprisonment.
The revision is disposed of accordingly.
Let the copy of this order be forwarded to the First Appellate
Court, the Trial Court and concerned authorities for necessary action
along with relevant records.
C.C. as per rules.
VIJAY
Avi/vijay
TRIPAT
HI
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF
MADHYA PRADESH BENCH GWALIOR,
ou=HIGH COURT OF MADHYA
PRADESH BENCH GWALIOR,
2.5.4.20=663cb09dd950bfc3ea7ed4f0
2d97ddae5364f1d4b042dbc59921b7
6e812d2d6b, postalCode=474001,
st=Madhya Pradesh,
serialNumber=58392D8C4E7C9693BF
EEB5B46B3CA006F1127E89008952BB
EC528CE4D82551BD, cn=VIJAY
TRIPATHI
Date: 2024.01.23 18:09:50 +05'30'
(SANJEEV S KALGAONKAR)
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review