Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
(2026:JHHC:26882)
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
Cr.M.P. No.269 of 2026
-----Mahendra Kumar Agarwalla @ Mahendra Kumar Agarwal, Aged
about 67 years, son of Prayag Lal Agarwala, Resident of Mohalla
Shivpuri, Bhuiphore, Opposite Annpurna Shop, P.O. K.G. Ashram,
P.S. Saraidhela, District Dhanbad (Jharkhand) …
Petitioner
Versus
1. The State of Jharkhand
2. Pawan Kumar Paswan, Aged about 36 years, Son of Late Laddu
Ram, Resident of New Colony, Jagjiwan Nagar, Saraidhela, Near
Durga Mandap, P.O. and P.S. Saraidhela, District Dhanbad
…
Opposite Parties
-----For the Petitioner
For the State
For the O.P. No.2
: Mr. P. K. Mukhopadhyay, Advocate
: Ms. Shweta Singh, Addl.P.P.
: Mr. Pratyush, Advocate
-----PRESENT
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KUMAR CHOUDHARY
By the Court:-
I.A. No.12548 of 2026
Heard the parties.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that this interlocutory
application has been filed for early hearing of this Cr.M.P.
Since, the hearing of this Cr.M.P. is taken up today, hence, this
interlocutory application stands disposed of being infructuous.
(Anil Kumar Choudhary, J.)
Cr.M.P. No.269 of 2026
This Criminal Miscellaneous Petition has been filed invoking the
jurisdiction of this Court under Section 528 of the Bharatiya Nagarik
Cr. M.P. No.269 of 2026
(2026:JHHC:26882)
Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 with the prayer to quash the order dated
24.09.2025 passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge-I, Dhanbad
in Criminal Revision No.214 of 2023 whereby and where under the
learned Additional Sessions Judge-I, Dhanbad dismissed the Criminal
Revision and affirmed the order dated 21.08.2023 passed by the learned
Judicial Magistrate-1st Clas, Dhanbad in Complaint Case No.6061 of
2022 by which the learned Judicial Magistrate-1st Class, Dhanbad has
rejected the petition dated 13.07.2023 filed under Section 45 of the
Indian Evidence Act for sending the Exhibit C-2/CW-1 i.e., the
agreement dated 01.06.2021 executed by the petitioner inter alia being
the complainant of the case; to the Handwriting Expert, i.e. F.S.L.,
Ranchi to verify the signature of the petitioner in the Agreement for
sale dated 01.06.2021.
2.
The brief fact of the case is that the petitioner is an accused of
Complaint Case No.6061 of 2022 of the court of learned Judicial
Magistrate-1st Class, Dhanbad involving the offence punishable under
Section 138 of N.I. Act. The complainant of the said case examined
himself as C.W.-1. He proved the agreement for sale entered into
between the petitioner as the seller and the complainant himself along
with two persons namely Raju Kumar Singh and Anjani Kumar Singh
together as purchasers and the case of the complainant is that the
cheque in question which was dishonoured, was issued by the
petitioner herein, who is the accused person of the said case, in
discharge of his debt towards the return of the advance amount he has
taken in terms of the said agreement. It is the undisputed fact that
Cr. M.P. No.269 of 2026
(2026:JHHC:26882)
though the C.W.-1 was cross-examined at length, the petitioner who
was the accused person of the said case, did not chose to challenge the
portion of the testimony in the examination-in-chief filed in shape of
affidavit to the effect that it is the petitioner who is the signatory of the
said agreement as the seller; as neither any question in that respect has
been put to the C.W.-1 nor any suggestion that the signature of the
petitioner does not appear on the agreement, was given to the C.W.-1.
In the statement recorded under Section 311 of the Cr.P.C. of the
petitioner, the petitioner has also not taken any plea that his signature is
not appearing in the said agreement which has been marked as Exhibit
C-2/CW-1.
3.
When the case was fixed for defence evidence, the petitioner, on
13.07.2023 filed a petition and claimed that he has never put his
signature on Exhibit C-2/CW-1 at any point of time and the purported
signature of the petitioner appearing in the said Exhibit is a forged one,
prepared by the complainant and made a prayer for sending the Exhibit
C-2/CW-1 along with the cheque which has been marked as Exhibit C3/CW-1. Though in the prayer portion of the said petition, it has not
been mentioned as to where the document is to be sent but at the
beginning of the petition the nomenclature of the petition has been
mentioned “petition for sending documents- Exhibit C-2/CW-1 i.e., the
agreement dated 01.06.2021 to the F.S.L., Ranchi.”
4.
The learned Judicial Magistrate-1st Class, Dhanbad vide order
dated 21.08.2023 passed in Complaint Petition No.6061 of 2022
considered that the petitioner who is the accused person of the case, has
Cr. M.P. No.269 of 2026
(2026:JHHC:26882)
not denied his signature either on the cheque or in the agreement which
are respectively the Exhibits C-3/CW-1 and C-2/CW-1 and in his
statement recorded under Section 313 of Cr.P.C., the accused-petitioner
has put his full signature. The learned Judicial Magistrate-1st Class,
Dhanbad relied upon the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of
India in the case of Bir Singh vs. Mukesh Kumar reported in (2019) 4
SCC 197 wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India has held that a
presumption arises that the cheque, duly signed and voluntarily made
over to the payee, was made in discharge of debt or liability irrespective
of whether the cheque was post-dated or blank cheque for filling by
payer or any other person. Hence, the learned Magistrate was of the
opinion that there was no requirement to seek the opinion of the
handwriting expert of the F.S.L., Ranchi and dismissed the prayer.
5.
The petitioner filed Criminal Revision No.214 of 2023 against the
said order dated 21.08.2023 passed by the learned Judicial Magistrate-1st
Class, Dhanbad in Complaint Petition No.6061 of 2022. The learned
Additional Sessions Judge-I, Dhanbad vide judgment dated 24.09.2025
dismissed the Criminal Revision. The learned Additional Sessions
Judge considered that the complainant who was examined as C.W-1,
has proved the agreement which has been marked as Exhibit C-2/CW1. The learned Additional Sessions Judge also considered that the
petitioner, in his statement recorded under Section 313 of Cr.P.C., has
not questioned his signature on the agreement marked as Exhibit C2/CW-1. The learned Additional Sessions Judge also considered that
the signature of the petitioner in the cheque concerned which has been
Cr. M.P. No.269 of 2026
(2026:JHHC:26882)
marked as Exhibit C-3/CW-1 is not in dispute. In the bare eyes, the
admitted signature of the petitioner appearing in his statement under
Section 313 of Cr.P.C. appears to be similar to that of his agreement in
Exhibit C-2/CW-1. The learned Additional Sessions Judge also
considered the statutory presumption as envisaged under Section 139 of
the N.I. Act and formed an opinion that the petition filed by the
petitioner, was fit to be rejected and dismissed the Criminal Revision.
6.
Learned counsel for the petitioner relies upon the judgment of
the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the case of Kalyani Baskar
(Mrs.) vs. M. S. Sampoornam (Mrs.) reported in (2007) 2 SCC 258 and
submits that in para-12 thereof, the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India has
held that Section 243 (2) of the Cr.P.C. is clear that a Magistrate holding
an inquiry under Cr.P.C. in respect of an offence triable by him does not
exceed his powers under Section 243 (2) of the Cr.P.C. if, in the interest
of justice, he directs to send the document for enabling the same to be
compared by a handwriting expert because even in adopting this
course, the purpose is to enable the Magistrate to compare the disputed
signature or writing with the admitted writing or signature of the
accused and to reach his own conclusion with the assistance of the
expert.
7.
Learned counsel for the petitioner next relies upon the judgment
of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the case of T. Nagappa vs.
Y.R. Muralidhar reported in (2008) 5 SCC 633 and submits that in the
said judgment, the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India has also approbated
and relied upon paragraph-12 of the Judgment of Kalyani Baskar
Cr. M.P. No.269 of 2026
(2026:JHHC:26882)
(Mrs.) vs. M. S. Sampoornam (Mrs.) (supra) and in paragraph-8, the
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India has also observed that an accused has
a right to fair trial. He has a right to defend himself as a part of his
human as also fundamental right as enshrined under Article 21 of the
Constitution of India. The right to defend oneself and for that purpose
to adduce evidence is recognised by Parliament in terms of Section 243
(2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
8.
Learned counsel for the petitioner next relies upon the judgment
of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the case of The State (Delhi
Administration) vs. Pali Ram reported in (1979) 2 SCC 158 paragraph30 of which reads as under:“30. The matter can be viewed from another angle, also.
Although there is no legal bar to the Judge using his own
eyes to compare the disputed writing with the admitted
writing, even without the aid of the evidence of any
handwriting expert, the Judge should, as a matter of
prudence and caution, hesitate to base his finding with
regard to the identity of a handwriting which forms the
sheet-anchor of the prosecution case against a person
accused of an offence, solely on comparison made by himself.
It is therefore, not advisable that a Judge should take upon
himself the task of comparing the admitted writing with the
disputed one to find out whether the two agree with each
other; and the prudent course is to obtain the opinion and
assistance of an expert.” (Emphasis supplied)
and submits that therein the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India has
observed that although there is no legal bar to the Judge using his own
eyes to compare the disputed writing with the admitted writing, even
without the aid of the evidence of any handwriting expert, the Judge
should, as a matter of prudence and caution, hesitate to base his finding
with regard to the identity of a handwriting which forms the sheet-
Cr. M.P. No.269 of 2026
(2026:JHHC:26882)
anchor of the prosecution case against a person accused of an offence,
solely on comparison made by himself.
9.
It is next submitted that the learned trial court has tried to
compare the signature of the petitioner, as was appearing in the
statement recorded under Section 313 of the Cr.P.C. with the signature
appearing in the Exhibit C-2/CW-1 which is the agreement in which the
purported signature of the petitioner is appearing and there the learned
trial court has committed a grave error which was also overlooked by
the learned Revisional Court. Hence, it is submitted that the prayer, as
prayed for in this Criminal Miscellaneous Petition, be allowed.
10.
Learned Addl. P. P. appearing for the State and the learned
counsel for the opposite party No.2 on the other hand vehemently
oppose the prayer of the petitioner made in the instant Criminal
Miscellaneous Petition and submit that the consequence of not crossexamining the witness in respect of any portion of his examination-inchief amounts to admission of the said portion of examination-in-chief
and the undisputed fact remains that the C.W.-1 who has introduced
the agreement in question in evidence by proving the same, which has
been marked as Exhibit C-2/CW-1 and has stated that the same is the
agreement entered into between the petitioner on one part and the
opposite party No.2 herein who is the complainant of the case as well as
the two co-purchasers on the other part. It is then submitted that since
there is absolutely no cross-examination of the C.W.-1 regarding the
contention of the petitioner made as an afterthought that the signature
of the petitioner is not appearing on the Exhibit marked C-2/CW-1, the
Cr. M.P. No.269 of 2026
(2026:JHHC:26882)
consequence is that the same is to be accepted to be true and in view of
this overwhelming evidence, the opinion of handwriting expert which
is considered to be a weak piece of evidence, is irrelevant and hence, the
learned Magistrate in its discretion having thought it fit not to seek the
opinion of the handwriting expert and thus the order of the learned
Magistrate was unwarranted to be interfered with by the learned
Revisional Court, hence, neither the order of the learned Magistrate
which was impugned in the Criminal Revision No.214 of 2023 nor the
order of the learned Additional Sessions Judge-I, Dhanbad passed in
the said criminal revision is suffering from any illegality, therefore, this
Criminal Miscellaneous Petition, being without any merit, be dismissed.
11.
Having heard the rival submissions made at the Bar and after
carefully going through the materials available in the record, it is
pertinent to mention here that it is a settled principle of law as has been
held by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the case of Laxmibai
(Dead) Through LRs. & Another. vs. Bhagwantbuva (Dead) Thr. LRs.
& Ors. reported in AIR 2013 (SC) 1204 paragraph-31 of which read as
under:31. Furthermore, there cannot be any dispute with respect
to the settled legal proposition, that if a party wishes to raise
any doubt as regards the correctness of the statement of a
witness, the said witness must be given an opportunity to
explain his statement by drawing his attention to that part
of it, which has been objected to by the other party, as being
untrue. Without this, it is not possible to impeach his
credibility. Such a law has been advanced in view of the
statutory provisions enshrined in Section 138 of the
Evidence Act, 1872, which enable the opposite party to
cross-examine a witness as regards information tendered in
evidence by him during his initial examination-in-chief, and
the scope of this provision stands enlarged by Section 146 of
Cr. M.P. No.269 of 2026
(2026:JHHC:26882)
the Evidence Act, which permits a witness to be questioned,
inter alia, in order to test his veracity. Thereafter, the
unchallenged part of his evidence is to be relied upon, for the
reason that it is impossible for the witness to explain or
elaborate upon any doubts as regards the same, in the
absence of questions put to him with respect to the
circumstances which indicate that the version of events
provided by him is not fit to be believed, and the witness
himself, is unworthy of credit. Thus, if a party intends to
impeach a witness, he must provide adequate opportunity to
the witness in the witness box, to give a full and proper
explanation. The same is essential to ensure fair play and
fairness in dealing with witnesses. (See Khem
Chand v. State of H.P. [1994 Supp (1) SCC 7 : 1994 SCC
(Cri) 212 : AIR 1994 SC 226] , State of U.P. v. Nahar
Singh [(1998) 3 SCC 561 : 1998 SCC (Cri) 850 : AIR 1998
SC 1328] , Rajinder Pershad v. Darshana Devi [(2001) 7
SCC 69 : AIR 2001 SC 3207] and Sunil Kumar v. State of
Rajasthan [(2005) 9 SCC 283 : 2005 SCC (Cri) 1230 : AIR
2005 SC 1096] .)
wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India settled the principle
of law that if a party wishes to raise any doubt as regards the
correctness of the statement of a witness, the said witness must be given
an opportunity to explain his statement by drawing his attention to that
part of it, which has been objected to by the other party, as being untrue
and without this, it is not possible to impeach his credibility.
12.
It is pertinent to mention here that there are instances galore
where the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India has held that in the absence
of cross-examination of a witness, the evidence of such witness remains
unchallenged and ought to be believed. In the case of State of U.P v.
Nahar Singh reported in AIR 1998 SC 1328, the Hon’ble Supreme
Court of India in paragraph No-13 and 14 held as under:“13. It may be noted here that that part of the statement of
PW 1 was not cross-examined by the accused. In the
absence of cross-examination on the explanation of delay,
the evidence of PW 1 remained unchallenged and ought to
have been believed by the High Court. Section 138 of the
Cr. M.P. No.269 of 2026
(2026:JHHC:26882)
Evidence Act confers a valuable right of cross-examining
the witness tendered in evidence by the opposite party. The
scope of that provision is enlarged by Section 146 of the
Evidence Act by allowing a witness to be questioned:
(1) to test his veracity,
(2) to discover who he is and what is his position in
life, or
(3) to shake his credit by injuring his character,
although the answer to such questions might tend
directly or indirectly to incriminate him or might
expose or tend directly or indirectly to expose him to
a penalty or forfeiture.
14. The oft-quoted observation of Lord Herschell, L.C.
in Browne v. Dunn [(1893) 6 R 67] clearly elucidates the
principle underlying those provisions. It reads thus:
“I cannot help saying, that it seems to me to be
absolutely essential to the proper conduct of a cause,
where it is intended to suggest that a witness is not
speaking the truth on a particular point, to direct his
attention to the fact by some questions put in crossexamination showing that that imputation is
intended to be made, and not to take his evidence and
pass it by as a matter altogether unchallenged, and
then, when it is impossible for him to explain, as
perhaps he might have been able to do if such
questions had been put to him, the circumstances
which, it is suggested, indicate that the story he tells
ought not to be believed, to argue that he is a witness
unworthy of credit. My Lords, I have always
understood that if you intend to impeach a witness,
you are bound, whilst he is in the box, to give an
opportunity of making any explanation which is
open to him; and, as it seems to me, that is not only a
rule of professional practice in the conduct of a case,
but it is essential to fair play and fair dealing with
witnesses.”
This aspect was unfortunately missed by the High Court
when it came to the conclusion that explanation for the
delay is not at all convincing. This reason is, therefore, far
from convincing.
13.
It is also a settled principle of law that as has been held by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the case of Smt. Bhagwan Kaur vs.
Shri Maharaj Krishan Sharma & Others reported in AIR 1973 1346 as
also in the case of Murari Lal vs. State of Madhya Pradesh reported in
AIR 1980 SC 531 wherein it was held that:10
Cr. M.P. No.269 of 2026
(2026:JHHC:26882)
(a) evidence of a handwriting expert, unlike that of
a fingerprint expert, is generally of a frail character
and its fallibilities have been quite often noticed.
(b) imperfect nature of the science of handwriting,
the approach, should be one of caution and the
reasons for the opinion must be carefully probed and
examined and
(c) only in cases where the reasons for the opinion
are convincing and there is no reliable evidence
throwing a doubt, the uncorroborated testimony of a
handwriting expert may be accepted.
14.
It is also a settled principle of law that the testimony of the
handwriting expert is a weak type of evidence and it is highly unsafe to
pass conviction on such type of evidence as has been held by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the case of Fakhruddin vs. The
State of Madhya Pradesh reported in AIR 1967 SC 1326 as also in the
case of Jagmal Singh Yadav vs. Aimaduddin Ahmed Khan reported in
1994 Supp (2) SCC 308.
15.
In the case of Shashi Kumar Banerjee & Others vs. Subodh
Kumar
Banerjee
since
deceased
and
after
him
his
legal
representatives & Others reported in AIR 1964 SC 529, it was held by
the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India that when there is substantial
evidence available on record, it has not been shattered by other
materials, the substantial evidence shall prevail over handwriting
expert evidence.
16.
Now, coming to the facts of the case, as already indicated above,
the C.W.-1 who has proved the Exhibit C-2/CW-1, has absolutely not
been cross-examination regarding the genuineness of the signature put
by the petitioner thereon though the C.W.-1 in his examination-in-chief
Cr. M.P. No.269 of 2026
(2026:JHHC:26882)
has categorically stated that it is the petitioner who has signed the said
agreement marked Exhibit C-2/CW-1 as the seller of the land.
17.
Under such overwhelming evidence, this Court do not find any
illegality either in the order dated 21.08.2023 passed by the learned
Judicial Magistrate-1st Class, Dhanbad in Complaint Case No.6061 of
2022 or in the order dated 24.09.2025 passed by the learned Additional
Sessions Judge-I, Dhanbad in Criminal Revision No.214 of 2023
warranting interference of this Court in exercise of its power under
Section 528 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 in view of
the settled principle of law, as discussed above.
18.
Accordingly, this Criminal Miscellaneous Petition, being without
any merit, is dismissed.
19.
In view of disposal of the instant Criminal Miscellaneous
Petition, I.A. No.11468 of 2026 stands disposed of being infructuous.
(Anil Kumar Choudhary, J.)
High Court of Jharkhand, Ranchi
Dated the 07th of September, 2026
AFR/ Animesh
Uploaded on- 09/09/2026
Cr. M.P. No.269 of 2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review