The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
13. On perusal of rule 27(2)(b) of the Viniyam of 1998 as well as condition No. 9 of the appointment order, it is clear that before tendering resignation, an employee is required to intimate the employer of his intention to resign three months prior. However, in the present case, the respondent No.1 continued for about an year i.e. upto 13.12.2019 even after intimation but never submitted the resignation letter. However, the resignation letter was submitted on 13.12.2019. The learned Single Judge erred in interpreting the rule 27(2)(b) of the Viniyam of 1998 as well as condition No. 9 of the appointment order in as much as the intimation cannot be treated to be a resignation letter. Admittedly, there was no resignation letter till 13.12.2019. In such a situation, learned Single Judge could not have allowed the writ petition and direct refund of Rs. 1,26,654/- to the respondent No.1 within 60 days and also impose cost against the appellants. In fact, on proper appreciation of the fact and proper interpretation of rule 27(2)(b) of the Viniyam of 1998 as well as condition No. 9 of the appointment letter, it was imperative for respondent No.1 to furnish the resignation letter before expiry of 90 days which he did not do. The actual resignation letter was submitted after the lapse of 90 days, therefore, the benefit of salary would not be available to respondent No.1. The learned Single …
14. Resultantly, the order impugned dated 10.07.2023 passed in W.P.No. 452/2022 is hereby set aside. Accordingly, the writ appeal stands allowed and disposed of.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN
THE
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE SUSHRUT ARVIND DHARMADHIKARI
&
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE DEVNARAYAN MISHRA
ON THE 10th OF JANUARY, 2024
WRIT APPEAL No. 1856 of 2023
BETWEEN:1.
MADHYA PRADESH STATE AGRICULTURE
MARKETING BOARD THROUGH MANAGING
DIRECTOR 26, KISAN BHAWAN, ARERA HILLS
BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
JOINT DIRECTOR, M.P. STATE AGRICULTURAL
MARKETING BOARD, ZONAL OFFICE, IN FRONT
OF NEW GIRLS DEGREE COLLEGE, KILA MAIDAN
VIP ROAD, INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
S ECR ETARY, KRISHI UPAJ
INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
MANDI
SAMITI,
.....APPELLANTS
(SHRI ABHINAV DHANODKAR, COUNSEL FOR THE APPELLANTS).
AND
1.
PRADEEP SINGH DAWAR, S/O KALU SINGH
DAWAR, AGED ABOUT 36 YEARS, OCCUPATION:
SERVICE R/O 351 MANSAROWAR NAGAR
DEOGURADIA INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
SUB DIVISIONAL OFFICER, THE STATE OF
MADHYA PRADESH M.P. STATE AGRICULTURAL
MARKETING BOARD 26 KISAN BHAWAN ARERA
HILLS BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(SHRI ABHISHEK TUGNAWAT, COUNSEL FOR RESPONDENTS)
This appeal coming on for admission this day, Justice Sushrut Arvind
Dharmadhikari passed the following:
Signed by: SREEVIDYA
Signing time: 11-012024 16:38:45
JUDGMENT
Heard on I.A.No. 8713/2023, application for condonation of delay.
2. For the reasons stated in the application, the same is allowed. Delay
of 10 days in filing the appeal is hereby condoned.
3.
Heard on the question of admission.
4 . The present writ appeal filed under Section 2(1) of the M.P.Uchha
Nyayalaya (Khand Nyayapeeth Ko Appeal) Adhiniyam 2006 assails the order
dated 10.07.2023 passed in W.P.No. 452/2022.
5. The brief facts of the case are that the respondent No.1 herein had
filed the writ petition praying for the following reliefs :
(a) To direct respondents to release the salary of the petitioner of the sum of Rs.
1,26,654/-.
(b) To direct respondents to pay simple interest at the rate of 6% p.a. on the
salary kept by the respondents from the date of discharge of the petitioner from his
post i.e. 13.12.2019 till the date of judgment in the present writ petition.
(c) To issue any writ, order, direction and/or declaration which this Hon'ble Court
may be deem fit, just and proper in the facts and circumstances of the case in
favour of petitioners.
(d) To direct respondents to bear cost of this petition.''
6.
Learned Single Judge while allowing the writ petition passed the
order, relevant portion of which is reproduced as hereunder :
''[8] After one year, the appointment order was issued, therefore, he sought for
relieving on 13.12.2019 and the same was accepted and he was relieved. The
petitioner had already informed his intention to resign to the respondents on
20.08.2018 but continued into the service till 13.12.2019 when the appointment
order was received, therefore, as per Clause No. 9 of the appointment the
petitioner gave notice much prior to three months about the intention to resign,
therefore, he was not liable to deposit the three months' salary which has wrongly
been got deposited by him.
[9] In view of the above, the present petition is allowed. The amount of Rs.
1,26,654/- be refunded to the petitioner within 60 days from the production of a
certified copy of this order failing which he shall be entitled to interest at the rate of
6% from the date of deposit till payment. The Writ Petition is allowed with a cost
of Rs. 10,000/- payable to the petitioner.''
7.
Signed by: SREEVIDYA
Signing time: 11-012024 16:38:45
Learned counsel for the appellant submitted that from the face of the
record, it is very clear that the learned Single Judge erred in comprehending
Rule 27(2)(b) of the Mandi Board Seva Viniyam 1998 (hereinafter referred to as
the Viniyam of 1998) and Condition No. 9 of the appointment order of the
respondent No.1 dated 15.07.2011. For the sake of convenience, the aforesaid
provisions are reproduced as hereunder :
''2 कितपय मामल म सेवािनवृत ्त :
2. नवीन ावधान :
(क) राज्य मंडी बोड सेवा के सदस्य को, उसक 20 वष क पशन के लए अहकारी
सेवा पूण करने या उसक 50 वष क आयु हो चुकने के पश्चात िकसी भी समय, िबना
कोई कारण बतलाये, उसे ल खत सूचना देकर, लोकिहत म सेवािनवृत ्त िकया जा
सकेगा।
(ख) उक्त ल खत सूचना क कालाव ध तीन मास क होगी, परंत ु ऐसे सदस्य को
तत्काल सेवािनवृत ्त िकया जा सकेगा और इस कार सेवािनवृत ्त िकये जाने पर वह
सदस्य यथा थित, सूचना क कालाव ध के लए अपने वेत न तथा भत्त को, या उतनी
कालाव ध के लए अपने वेत न तथा भत्त को या उतनी कालाव ध के लए जतनी से िक
ऐसी सूचना तीन माह से कम क होती है अपने वेत न तथा भत्त को, जो िक उन्ही दर से
आह रत िकये जायेगे जन पर िक वह अपने सेवािनवृ के ठीक पूव अपने वेत न तथा
भत्ते ाप्त कर रहा था, रकम के समतुल्य रािश का दावा करने का हकदार होगा''
Condition 9 of appointment order of the respondent no. 1 dated 15.05.2011, excerpts of
the same are here under :
9. स्थाई सेवा का कोई भी सदस्य सेवा छोड़ने या त्याग प देने संबध
ं ी आशय क सूचना
तीन केले न्डर माह क ल खत सूचना बंध संचालक या िनयुक्त ा धकारी को उिचत
माध्यम से िदये िबना अपनी सेवा नह छोड़ेगा या त्याग प नह देगा। सेवा के िकसी भी
सदस्य ारा उपयुक्त उपबंध को भंग िकया जाने पर वह ऐसे भंग के लये ितकार के प
म उतनी कालावधी के जतने से क वस्त ुत : दी गई सूचना कालाव ध िविहत क गई
कालाव ध के कम पड़ती हो, वेत न के बराबर क रकम बोड को चुकाने का उत्त रदायी होगा ''
8.
Learned counsel for the appellants submitted that from the aforesaid
provisions, it is clear that the employee, before resigning has to intimate the
appellant regarding resignation prior to three months. In the present case, on
20.08.2018 respondent No.1 intimated the appellants about willingness to resign
with the condition that as and when he is selected on the post of Assistant
Professor (Commerce), he would resign. However, he continued in service.
Thereafter on 07.09.2018, the appellant No.3 informed appellant No.1 about the
Signed by: SREEVIDYA
Signing time: 11-012024 16:38:45
selection of respondent No.1. On 14.12.2018, appellant No.2 issued a No
Objection Certificate regarding the aforesaid resignation subject to fulfilling the
condition mentioned in Rule 27(2)(b) of the Viniyam of 1998 and Condition No.
9 of the appointment order dated 15.07.2011. Ultimately, respondent No. 1
submitted his resignation letter before appellant No.3 on 13.12.2019. Since
respondent No.1 violated the Rule 27(2)(b) of the Viniyam of 1998 and
Condition No.9 of the appointment order, hence his salary for three months was
forfeited by the appellants.
9 . Being aggrieved, respondent No.1 had filed the writ petition. The
petition came to be allowed on 10.07.2023.
10. Learned counsel for the appellants contended that the learned Single
Judge erred in allowing the writ petition because as per Rule 27(2)(b) of the
Viniyam 1998 and Condition No. 9 of the appointment order, the respondent
No.1 was obliged to give resignation after expiry of three months from the date
of intimation for resignation, however, in the present case the respondent No.1
continued upto 13.12.2019 and thereafter submitted the resignation letter. In
such as situation, the benefit of Rule 27(2)(b) of the Viniyam of 1998 as well as
condition No. 9 of the appointment order would not be available to respondent
No.1 and as such, the appellants have rightly forfeited his salary of three
months.
11 .
Per contra, learned counsel for respondent No.1 supported the
order passed by the learned Single Judge and contended that the learned Single
Judge has rightly allowed the writ petition in as much as the intimation itself is a
resignation letter and treating it to be a resignation letter, respondent No.1
prayed for relieving him from services. Hence, no interference is called for in
the order impugned and this appeal, being misconceived, is liable to be
Signed by: SREEVIDYA
Signing time: 11-012024 16:38:45
dismissed.
12.
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
13.
On perusal of rule 27(2)(b) of the Viniyam of 1998 as well as
condition No. 9 of the appointment order, it is clear that before tendering
resignation, an employee is required to intimate the employer of his intention to
resign three months prior. However, in the present case, the respondent No.1
continued for about an year i.e. upto 13.12.2019 even after intimation but never
submitted the resignation letter. However, the resignation letter was submitted
on 13.12.2019. The learned Single Judge erred in interpreting the rule 27(2)(b)
of the Viniyam of 1998 as well as condition No. 9 of the appointment order in
as much as the intimation cannot be treated to be a resignation letter.
Admittedly, there was no resignation letter till 13.12.2019. In such a situation,
learned Single Judge could not have allowed the writ petition and direct refund
of Rs. 1,26,654/- to the respondent No.1 within 60 days and also impose cost
against the appellants. In fact, on proper appreciation of the fact and proper
interpretation of rule 27(2)(b) of the Viniyam of 1998 as well as condition No. 9
of the appointment letter, it was imperative for respondent No.1 to furnish the
resignation letter before expiry of 90 days which he did not do. The actual
resignation letter was submitted after the lapse of 90 days, therefore, the benefit
of salary would not be available to respondent No.1. The learned Single Judge
has erred in coming to the conclusion.
14.
Resultantly, the order impugned dated 10.07.2023 passed in
W.P.No. 452/2022 is hereby set aside. Accordingly, the writ appeal stands
allowed and disposed of.
Signed by: SREEVIDYA
Signing time: 11-012024 16:38:45
(S. A. DHARMADHIKARI)
JUDGE
vidya
Signed by: SREEVIDYA
Signing time: 11-012024 16:38:45
(DEVNARAYAN MISHRA)
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review