Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 10th December, 2025
Pronounced on: 10th March, 2026
%
+
1.
W.P. (CRL) 2840/2017 & CRL.M.A. 16415/2017
MADHURI COMMODITIES PRIVATE LTD.
Through its Director,
Having its Registered Office at:
16-B, Dover Lane,
Kolkata, West Bengal - 700029
2.
MR. PRAVEEN KUMAR AGARWAL
Managing Director
16-B, Dover Lane,
Kolkata, West Bengal - 700029
3.
MR. RAJ KUMAR AGARWAL
Director,
16-B, Dover Lane,
Kolkata, West Bengal - 700029
Through:
.....Petitioners
Mr. Awanish Kumar and Ms Garima,
Advocates.
Versus
1.
2.
M/S SONY INDIA PVT. LTD.
Through its authorized representative
Mr. Gurmeet Singh
A-31, Mohan Co-operative Industrial Estate
Mathura Road, New Delhi - 110044
.....Respondent No. 1
GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI
Through SHO Parliament Street
Police Station Sansad Marg
Connaught Place, near Patel Chowk,
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:21:42
W.P. (CRL) 2840/2017
New Delhi, Delhi 110001
Through:
.....Respondent No. 2
Ms. Shweta Bharti, Mr. J.K.
Chaudhary and Ms. Vanshika Gupta,
Advocates.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M
E N T
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
1.
The present Petition has been preferred under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India read with Section 482 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1973 (hereinafter referred to as “CrPC”), seeking the quashing
of the Complaint filed under Section 138 read with Section 141 of the
Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 (hereinafter referred to as „NI Act‟), the
summoning Order dated 10.04.2017, pending before the Court of the Ld.
CMM, Patiala House Courts, New Delhi.
2.
The present Petition arises out of a Complaint bearing CC No.
4570/2017 titled M/s Sony India Pvt. Ltd. vs. Madhuri Commodities & Ors.
under Section 138 NI Act, concerning the alleged misuse of a security
cheque and its dishonour.
3.
Petitioner No. 1/Madhuri Commodities Private Ltd. is a Company
engaged as a distributor/channel partner for Sony India Pvt. Ltd. in North
West Bengal. Petitioner No. 2/Mr. Praveen Kumar Agarwal and Petitioner
No. 3/Mr. Raj Kumar Agarwal are its Managing Director and the Director,
respectively.
4.
Respondent/M/s
Sony
India
Pvt.
Ltd.
is
the
Principal
Company/Complainant, represented by Mr. Gurmeet Singh.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:21:42
W.P. (CRL) 2840/2017
5.
The facts as stated in the Complaint are that on 01.12.2008,
Petitioner No. 1 submitted its Know Your Customer (KYC) documentation
to the Respondent to become its authorized channel partner for North West
Bengal. As a precondition for the grant of distributorship, blank security
cheques were furnished by the Petitioners, a fact expressly acknowledged in
the Respondent’s KYC checklist dated 17.12.2008. On account of
outstanding Liability, the cheque of Rs. 1,22,91,473/-for encashment, was
presented on 02.02.2017, which was dishonoured on 04.02.2017, for the
reason “exceeds arrangement”. The Respondent issued a Statutory Notice
under Section 138 NI Act on 18.02.2017, which was received by the
Petitioners on 21/22.02.2017, after which the Complaint under Section 138
NI Act was filed.
6.
The Petitioners were summoned vide Order dated 10.04.2017, by the
Ld. MM.
7.
The present Petition has been filed to Challenge the Complaint as
well as the summoning Order.
8.
The Petitioners assert that it became the authorized channel partner
for North West Bengal, of the respondent. As a pre-condition for the grant of
distributorship, blank security cheques were furnished by the Petitioners. It
is asserted that notably, at the time of issuance of the cheque in December,
2008 (last replaced in 2013 upon request), no goods had been supplied by
the Respondent, and consequently, there existed no legally enforceable debt
or liability within the meaning of Section 138 NI Act.
9.
The business relationship between the parties functioned smoothly
until 2013, when the Respondent began engaging in unilateral and
commercially detrimental conduct. This included the forced “dumping” of
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:21:42
W.P. (CRL) 2840/2017
excess stock beyond the Petitioners’ Purchase Orders, imposition of
arbitrary minimum Inventory requirements (e.g., 650 units in October,
2013), repeated failures to adhere to delivery timelines, and direct dealings
with downstream dealers, in breach of the exclusive distributorship protocol.
These actions severely disrupted the Petitioners’ cash flow and undermined
their performance-linked claims, under various incentive schemes. Despite
repeated written protests via email (e.g., dated 30.10.2013, 08.11.2013,
21.07.2015, and 16.11.2016), the Respondent failed to rectify its conduct.
10.
By late 2016, significant financial discrepancies emerged between the
parties. While the Respondent claimed an outstanding amount of
approximately Rs. 1.22 crores, the Petitioners asserted legitimate
counterclaims, including trade claims of Rs. 36,53,707/- stock-in-hand
valued at Rs. 42,59,184/- and sundry debtors worth Rs. 1,26,27,902/-,
resulting in a net receivable of over Rs. 86 lakhs in their favour. These
claims were communicated through a series of emails between December
2016 and January 2017; yet the Respondent ignored them and on
02.02.2017, dishonestly presented the security cheque for encashment, after
unilaterally filling the inflated amount of Rs. 1,22,91,473/-.
11.
It is claimed that this cheque was never issued against any subsisting
debt; rather, it was provided solely as a documentary formality for
distributorship and was never intended for actual payment.
12.
Following dishonour, the Respondent issued a statutory Notice under
Section 138 on 18.02.2017, which was received by the Petitioners on
21/22.02.2017. Simultaneously, on 27.02.2017, the Respondent terminated
the Petitioners’ Agency without settling their legitimate dues.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:21:42
W.P. (CRL) 2840/2017
13.
In response, the Petitioners instituted a Civil Suit bearing No.
49/2017 before the Court of the Ld. Civil Judge, Alipur in early March
2017, prior to the expiry of the 15-day statutory period under Section 138
and well before the filing of the Criminal Complaint. The Civil Court,
recognizing the Petitioners’ protectable interest in the Agency under Section
202 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, granted an ex-parte Injunction on
04.03.2017 and later confirmed it on 18.09.2017, restraining the Respondent
from appointing a new Distributor.
14.
Despite these developments, the Respondent filed Complaint Case
No. 4570/2017 under Sections 138 and 141 NI Act before the Chief
Metropolitan Magistrate, Delhi, on 21.03.2017. The Complaint suffers
from multiple legal infirmities.
15.
First, it fails to disclose any legally enforceable debt at the time of
issuance or presentation of the cheque, rendering it non-maintainable under
settled law in a catena of judgments like Bishanwaruparam Krishan vs. STC
of India Ltd., ILR (2009) V Delhi 205; Indus Airways Pvt. Ltd. vs. Magnum
Aviation Pvt. Ltd., (2014) 12 SCC 539.
16.
Second, the Complaint constitutes a gross abuse of the Criminal
process, as it seeks to weaponize a security instrument, to coerce settlement
in a purely Civil dispute involving complex accounting and contractual
issues already pending adjudication in a Civil Court; for which reliance is
placed on Madhavrao Jiwaji Rao Scindia vs. Sambhajirao Chandrojirao
Angre, AIR 1988 SC 709 and Kamal Kishor vs. D.S. Dhawde, (2004) 2
MhLJ 465).
17.
Third, the Complaint mechanically impleads Petitioners Nos. 2 and 3
as accused persons under Section 141 NI Act, without specifying their roles
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:21:42
W.P. (CRL) 2840/2017
or responsibilities in the day-to-day conduct of the Company’s business,
contrary to the strict requirements laid down in National Small Industries
Corporation Ltd. vs. Harmeet Singh Paintal, (2010) 3 SCC 330.
18.
Fourth, Petitioner No. 3 is not even the signatory of the impugned
cheque, and thus, cannot be prosecuted under Section 138, as only the
drawer of the cheque may be held liable as per Aparna A. Shah vs. M/s Sheth
Developers Pvt. Ltd., Criminal Appeal No. 813 of 2013.
19.
Fifth, the Complaint was filed by a power of attorney holder who
lacks personal knowledge of the underlying transactions and is therefore,
incompetent to depose on behalf of the principal, as held in Janki Vashdeo
Bhojwani vs. Indusind Bank Ltd., (2005) 2 SCC 217.
20.
Lastly, the Summoning Order dated 10.04.2017 reflects no
application of judicial mind, as required by M/s Pepsi Foods Ltd. vs. Special
Judicial Magistrate, (1997) 4 SCC 579, and ignores the protective
framework of Section 202 of the Contract Act, which safeguards an Agent’s
interest in stocks, receivables, and claims during pendency of Agency
disputes.
21.
In light of these facts and legal principles, the criminal proceedings
are manifestly unsustainable, oppressive, and constitute a misuse of judicial
process aimed solely at harassing the Petitioners and undermining their
legitimate civil claims.
22.
Thus, it is prayed that the Petition be allowed and the Complaint as
well as the impugned summoning Order, be set aside.
23.
Reply has been filed on behalf of the Respondent/Sony India Pvt.
Ltd., wherein it is stated that the Petition is not only legally untenable, but
also constitutes a gross abuse of the judicial process. The Petitioners have
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:21:42
W.P. (CRL) 2840/2017
deliberately suppressed material facts and documents, misrepresented the
nature of their commercial relationship with the Respondent, and falsely
projected themselves as “Agents” under the Indian Contract Act, 1872, in a
calculated attempt to evade their admitted financial liability. In truth, the
relationship between the parties was purely that of seller and purchaser;
specifically, that of a principal selling goods to an independent Distributor,
and never that of Principal and Agent.
24.
The Petitioners were appointed as one, amongst several distributors in
the North Bengal region, with no exclusivity or control by the Respondent
over their pricing, sales strategy, or downstream dealings. Critically, the
Respondent never authorized the Petitioners to act on its behalf, nor did it
pay any commission; instead, the Petitioners purchased goods outright and
resold them at their own risk and profit, which negates any claim of Agency.
25.
The Respondent further refutes the Petitioners’ core contention that
the dishonoured cheque was issued merely as “security” and therefore,
outside the purview of Section 138 NI Act. Relying on the judgment of the
Apex Court in Sampelly Satyanarayana Rao vs. Indian Renewable Energy
Development Agency Ltd., AIR 2016 SC 4363, the Respondent emphasized
that a post-dated cheque given as security attracts Section 138, provided a
legally enforceable debt subsisted on the date of presentation.
26.
In the present case, the Petitioners had consistently acknowledged an
outstanding liability of approximately Rs.1.23 crores, through multiple email
communications spanning from 2015 to January 2017, including specific
offers dated 16.05.2015, 24.12.2016, and 21.01.2017, to repay the amount in
tranches, which conclusively establishes the existence of a subsisting debt.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:21:42
W.P. (CRL) 2840/2017
27.
The presumption under Sections 138 and 139 NI Act thus, operates
squarely against the Petitioners, and any dispute regarding the quantum or
offset of alleged counterclaims is a matter for trial, not for pre-trial quashing
under Article 226 or Section 482 Cr.P.C.
28.
The Respondent categorically denies the Petitioners’ belated and
unsubstantiated claims of trade credits, stock valuation, and sundry debtors
aggregating to over Rs.86 lakhs, asserting that these were fabricated only
after repeated defaults and solely to avoid payment. Notably, no such claims
were raised when the Petitioners first acknowledged their dues in 2015, and
even as late as 21.01.2017, when they offered unconditional payment
without mentioning any set-off. The sudden assertion of inflated
counterclaims in December 2016, appears to be an afterthought, especially
in light of years of default and following the Respondent’s demand for
clearance of the same.
29.
Moreover, the Civil Suit bearing No. 49/2017 was instituted by the
Petitioners, as a tactical counterblast to shield themselves from the
consequences of cheque dishonour, and the interim Injunction obtained
therein, was subsequently varied by the Calcutta High Court in FMAT
1116/2017, by observing that the trial court had failed to return any prima
facie finding on the existence of an Agency relationship, which undermines
the Petitioners‟ reliance on Section 202 of the Contract Act.
30.
Furthermore, Section 202 of the Contract Act is wholly inapplicable,
as it protects only an Agent’s interest in the “subject-matter of the Agency,”
which typically relates to immovable property or specific entrusted assets
and not general inventory of movable goods purchased in a commercial
transaction. The stocks held by the Petitioners, were bought outright under
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:21:42
W.P. (CRL) 2840/2017
sale Invoices and remained their absolute property; no equitable interest in
favour of the Petitioners, nor did the Respondent retain any title or control
over those goods, after the sale.
31.
Consequently, the termination of the Distributorship arrangement on
20.02.2017, after persistent payment defaults and non-performance, did not
violate any statutory protection, and the Petitioners’ invocation of Section
202 Contract Act is legally misconceived.
32.
On the procedural and evidentiary front, the Respondent asserts that
the Criminal Complaint under Section 138 and 141 NI Act, is fully
compliant with legal requirements. Petitioner No. 2, as the signatory of the
dishonoured cheque, is rightly arrayed as an accused, and Petitioner No. 3,
being a Director actively involved in the Company’s day-to-day affairs at
the relevant time, falls squarely within the scope of vicarious liability under
Section 141.
33.
It is submitted that the Complaint explicitly links both Directors to the
conduct of business, satisfying the principles laid down in National Small
Industries Corporation Ltd. vs. Harmeet Singh Paintal, (supra).
34.
Furthermore, the Complaint was filed by a duly Authorized
Representative of the corporate Respondent, whose capacity to depose on
the basis of Company records and official knowledge, is well recognized in
law; the Petitioners’ reliance on Janki Vashdeo Bhojwani, (supra) is
misplaced, as that judgment pertains to natural persons, not juristic entities
acting through authorized officers.
35.
Finally, the Respondent submits that the Summoning Order dated
10.04.2017 reflects proper application of judicial mind, as mandated by
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:21:42
W.P. (CRL) 2840/2017
Pepsi Foods Ltd. (supra), and that the Petitioners’ attempt to bypass the trial,
in which they may rebut the statutory presumptions, is impermissible.
36.
The pendency of a Civil Suit does not ipso facto, bar Criminal
proceedings for cheque dishonour, especially where the debt is admitted and
the defences are essentially civil in nature.
37.
It is submitted that the Writ Petition has been filed mala fide to delay
and derail legitimate legal recourse, which deserves to be dismissed with
exemplary costs.
38.
A Rejoinder to the Reply has been filed wherein the Petitioner has
reiterated the contentions raised in the Petition. It is additionally stated that
the Respondent’s Reply is full of misstatements, deliberate omissions, and
presents a distorted narrative, aimed at masking its own commercial
misconduct and the mala fide initiation in initiating criminal proceedings
under Section 138 NI Act. The Respondent has failed to rebut the
foundational fact that the impugned Cheque was issued purely a security
instrument, given in December 2008 and was never intended as a payment
mechanism against any subsisting debt.
39.
The Respondent’s reliance on Sampelly Satyanarayana Rao v. Indian
Renewable Energy Development Agency Ltd. is misplaced, as that judgment
explicitly requires the existence of a “legally enforceable debt or liability”
on the date of presentation of the cheque.
40.
In the present case, no such debt existed because the Petitioners’
legitimate Counterclaims, including stock-in-hand, trade incentives, and
receivables from downstream dealers, collectively exceed the amount
unilaterally inscribed by the Respondent on the blank security cheque. Far
from being an “afterthought,” these claims were consistently communicated
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:21:42
W.P. (CRL) 2840/2017
through email correspondence beginning December, 2016 and were formally
quantified only after the Respondent abruptly terminated the Agency
without settlement, thereby crystallizing the Petitioners’ financial exposure.
41.
The Petitioners further emphasize that the Calcutta High Court, in
FMAT No. 1116 of 2017 dated 17.10.2017, while modifying the interim
injunction granted by the Trial Court, expressly recognized the Petitioners’
“interest” in the Agency; a finding that directly contradicts the Respondent‟s
bald assertion that no principal-agent relationship ever existed. Although
the High Court declined to affirm exclusivity or quantify the interest at the
interim stage, it directed the Petitioners to return unsold stock to the
Respondent, in exchange for depositing equivalent value in a Fixed Deposit
Account, thereby implicitly acknowledging that the Petitioners held assets
belonging to or representing the business of the Respondent. This judicial
recognition negates the Respondent’s attempt to characterize the relationship
as a mere Buyer-Seller arrangement. The operational control exercised by
the Respondent by way of dictating pricing, imposing minimum inventory
norms, managing Incentive Schemes, and directly intervening in dealer
relationships, demonstrates the aspects of an Agency, and not that of an
arms-length commercial sale.
42.
Furthermore, it is asserted that the Respondent’s claim that the
Petitioners were in persistent default, is misleading. All payment delays
arose directly from the Respondent’s unilateral practices, such as forced
stock dumping beyond Purchase Orders, erratic supply during peak seasons
(notably Durga Puja), and failure to issue timely Invoices and unjustified
reduction of credit limits from Rs. 4 crores to Rs.1.5 crores in 2015. These
actions disrupted the Petitioners’ cash flow and undermined their ability to
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:21:42
W.P. (CRL) 2840/2017
collect from Dealers, who themselves were pressured by the Respondent’s
field staff to bypass the Petitioners, post-termination.
43.
The emails cited by the Respondent as “admissions of debt” were sent
in the context of ongoing negotiations and were always qualified by
references to pending trade claims, and none constitute unconditional
acknowledgment of liability. Critically, even in the email dated 21.01.2017,
the Petitioners wrote that only on final reconciliation, will the payment be
made, which was also ignored by the Respondent, who proceeded to fill and
present the security cheque with an inflated, unsubstantiated figure.
44.
The Petitioners also clarify that the Civil Suit No. 49/2017 was filed
immediately upon illegal termination of the Agency on 27.02.2017, well
before the expiry of the 15-day statutory window under Section 138 and
prior to the filing of the Criminal Complaint, on 21.03.2017. This sequence
disproves the Respondent’s allegation that the Suit was a counterblast.
45.
Rather, it was a necessary step to preserve the Petitioners’ statutory
interest under Section 202 of the Indian Contract Act, which protects an
Agent’s stake in the subject matter of the Agency, until accounts are settled.
Contrary to the Respondent’s assertion, Section 202 is not limited to
immovable property; it applies equally to goods, receivables, and
promotional investments integral to the Agency’s operation, the assets now
in dispute.
46.
Finally, the Petitioners reiterate that the Criminal Complaint suffers
from incurable legal defects, namely: (i) Petitioner No. 3, not being the
signatory of the cheque, cannot be prosecuted under Section 138; (ii) the
Complaint fails to specify how both Directors were “in charge of and
responsible for” the Company’s day-to-day affairs, as mandated by NSIC vs.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:21:42
W.P. (CRL) 2840/2017
Harmeet Singh Paintal, (supra).; and (iii) the Power of Attorney holder who
filed the Complaint, lacks personal knowledge of the underlying transactions
and is legally incompetent to depose on behalf of the corporate
Complainant, in view of Janki Vashdeo Bhojwani, (supra).
47.
In view of the pending Civil adjudication of the very debt in question,
and the absence of any prima facie offence, the continuation of Criminal
proceedings constitutes a manifest abuse of process and warrants quashing.
Submissions heard and record perused.
I.
Whether Security Cheque can be a Basis for Complaint under
Section 138 NI Act?:
48.
The first issue is whether the said cheque was a security cheque and
thus, could not have been presented, unless there was an occasion for its
presentment.
49.
Before assessing the merits of the issue, we may refer to the law in
this regard.
50.
Where a cheque is given as security for a contract or a loan and the
liability arising from that contract or loan, crystallizes into a legally
enforceable debt at a later date, the cheque, even if originally a “security”
one, assumes the character of a cheque issued in discharge of that debt for
the purpose of Section 138.
51.
PDCs (Post-Dated Cheques) issued as security for financial
liability, mature into an actual outstanding liability. The determining factor
is whether a legally enforceable debt or liability exists on the date the
cheque is presented for encashment, and not on the date it was drawn or
handed over.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:21:42
W.P. (CRL) 2840/2017
52.
In this regard reference may be made to the judgement of the Apex
Court in Indus Airways Private Limited versus Magnum Aviation Private
Limited, (2014) 12 SCC 539, wherein the Court considered the question
whether post-dated cheque issued by way of advance payment for a
Purchase Order, could be considered for discharge of legally enforceable
debt. It was held that while the purchaser may be liable for breach of the
contract, when a contract provides that the purchaser has to pay in advance.
53.
This proposition was reiterated by the Apex Court in Sampelly
Satyanarayana Rao vs. Indian Renewable Energy Development Agency
Limited, (2016) 10 SCC 458, wherein it was observed by the Court that the
question whether a post-dated cheque is for “discharge of debt or liability”
depends on the nature of the transaction. If on the date of the cheque,
liability or debt exists or the amount has become legally recoverable,
Section 138 is attracted.
54.
The concept of Security Cheques was explained by the Apex Court in
the case of Sripati Singh vs. State of Jharkhand, (2022) 18 SCC 614,
wherein it was observed:
“21. A cheque issued as security pursuant to a financial transaction
cannot be considered as a worthless piece of paper under every
circumstance. “Security” in its true sense is the state of being safe and
the security given for a loan is something given as a pledge of payment.
It is given, deposited or pledged to make certain the fulfilment of an
obligation to which the parties to the transaction are bound. If in a
transaction, a loan is advanced and the borrower agrees to repay the
amount in a specified time-frame and issues a cheque as security to
secure such repayment; if the loan amount is not repaid in any other
form before the due date or if there is no other understanding or
agreement between the parties to defer the payment of amount, the
cheque which is issued as security would mature for presentation and
the drawee of the cheque would be entitled to present the same. On
such presentation, if the same is dishonoured, the consequences
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:21:42
W.P. (CRL) 2840/2017
contemplated under Section 138 and the other provisions of the NI
Act would flow.”
55.
Furthermore, the liability under a signed blank cheque was discussed
in the case of Bir Singh vs. Mukesh Kumar, (2019) 4 SCC 197, wherein the
Apex Court observed:
“33. A meaningful reading of the provisions of the Negotiable
Instruments Act including, in particular, Sections 20, 87 and 139,
makes it amply clear that a person who signs a cheque and makes it
over to the payee remains liable unless he adduces evidence to rebut
the presumption that the cheque had been issued for payment of a debt
or in discharge of a liability. It is immaterial that the cheque may have
been filled in by any person other than the drawer, if the cheque is duly
signed by the drawer. If the cheque is otherwise valid, the penal
provisions of Section 138 would be attracted.
34. If a signed blank cheque is voluntarily presented to a payee,
towards some payment, the payee may fill up the amount and other
particulars. This in itself would not invalidate the cheque. The onus
would still be on the accused to prove that the cheque was not in
discharge of a debt or liability by adducing evidence.
.....
36. Even a blank cheque leaf, voluntarily signed and handed over by
the accused, which is towards some payment, would attract
presumption under Section 139 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, in
the absence of any cogent evidence to show that the cheque was not
issued in discharge of a debt.”
56.
The Security Cheques are only given to be utilised if subsequently,
during the business transactions, certain liabilities arise which are not
fulfilled by the Petitioners.
57.
Applying the above principles to the present case, even assuming
arguendo that the Cheque was originally furnished as a security instrument
in 2008, the critical question is whether liability had crystallized on the date
of its presentation in February 2017.
58.
The record reveals multiple email communications from the
Petitioners acknowledging substantial outstanding dues and proposing
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:21:42
W.P. (CRL) 2840/2017
repayment schedules. Emails dated 16.05.2015, 24.12.2016 and 21.01.2017,
relied upon by the Respondent, show that the Petitioners themselves referred
to the pending outstanding amounts and expressed willingness to liquidate
the same in tranches. Such correspondence prima facie indicates the
existence of a subsisting and legally recoverable liability on the date the
cheque was presented. Consequently, even if the cheque had originally been
issued as a security instrument, it matured into a Cheque issued towards
discharge of debt.
59.
Thus, this contention of the Petitioner that the impugned Cheque was
merely a security cheque and could not have been presented, is untenable.
60.
Moreover, in Bir Singh, (supra) the Apex Court held that even a
signed blank cheque, if voluntarily handed over, carries a presumption under
Sections 118 and 139 of the NI Act that it was issued in discharge of debt or
liability. The mere fact that particulars were filled in by the payee, does not
invalidate the instrument. The burden squarely lies upon the drawer to rebut
the statutory presumption through evidence, at trial.
61.
In the present matter, the Petitioners admittedly signed and handed
over the Cheque. Once execution is admitted, the statutory presumption
operates in favour of the Respondent. The Petitioners’ alleged counterclaims
to extinguish or reduce liability, is a matter of evidence and reconciliation,
which cannot be adjudicated in a petition under Article 226 or Section 482
Cr.P.C.
62.
The defence that the cheque was only a “security cheque” is,
therefore, not a ground for quashing at the threshold.
II.
Whether the Complaint is Maintainable against Managing
Director/Director?:
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:21:42
W.P. (CRL) 2840/2017
63.
The second issue is whether the Directors of the Company i.e.
Petitioner No. 2/Mr. Praveen Kumar Agarwal (Managing Director) and
Petitioner No. 3/Mr. Raj Kumar Agarwal (Director) are vicariously liable
for the offence under Section 138 NI Act, by virtue of Section 141 thereof.
64.
Section 141 NI Act provides that where the offence under Section 138
is committed by a Company, every person who at the time of the offence,
was in charge of and responsible to the Company for the conduct of its
business, shall also be deemed to be guilty of that offence.
65.
The Apex Court, in National Small Industries Corporation Ltd.,
(supra), held that the Complaint must contain specific averments disclosing
how and in what manner each Director was in charge of and responsible for
the conduct of the Company’s business.
66.
Similar observations have been made by the Apex Court in the case of
K.S. Mehta vs. M/s Morgan Securities and Credits Pvt. Ltd., 2025 INSC 315
wherein the Complaint lacked specific averments that would have
established a direct nexus between the Appellants and the financial
transactions in question or demonstrate their involvement in the Company’s
financial affairs. Where the documents on record confirmed the nonexecutive status of the Appellants/Directors, underscoring their limited role
in governance without any Executive decision-making authority, they cannot
be considered as involved in the affairs of the Company. It was held that
merely because the Appellants/Directors attended Board Meetings, does
not automatically translate into control over financial operations. Hence,
unless direct involvement of the Directors is established, they cannot be held
vicariously liable under the Act, 1881.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:21:42
W.P. (CRL) 2840/2017
67.
At this stage, it is also relevant to note that under Section 149(1) of the
Companies Act, 2013, a private Company is statutorily required to have a
minimum of only two Directors on its Board of Directors.
68.
Law in regard to the liability of Directors stands settled in S.M.S.
Pharmaceuticals Ltd. vs. Neeta Bhalla, (2005) 8 SCC 89 wherein Apex
Court had reiterated and clarified that essentially in a case under Section
141, there ought to be a specific averment in the pleadings of the
Complainant that at the time the Offence was committed, the person accused
was in charge of and responsible for the conduct of the business of the
Company. To hold a Director liable, it needs to be shown that the Director
being made liable, should be in charge of and responsible for the conduct of
the business of the Company at the time of committing the offence. Further,
that the persons holding the office of “Managing Director” or “Joint
Managing Director”, by virtue of the very nature of their role, renders them
in charge of and responsible for the conduct of the business of the Company
and liable under Section 141. Similar observations were made by the Apex
Court in Sunita Palita vs. Panchami Stone Quarry, in SLP (Crl.) No. 10396
of 2019 decided on 01.08.2022.
69.
In the present case, the record indicates that Petitioner No. 2 and
Petitioner No. 3 are the Managing Director and Director respectively of
Petitioner No. 1 Company, which is a private limited Company. In such a
closely held corporate structure, where the Board itself comprises of only
two directors, the assertion in the Complaint that both Directors were
actively involved in the day-to-day affairs and financial management of the
Company, cannot be said to be inherently improbable.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:21:42
W.P. (CRL) 2840/2017
70.
Turning to the Complaint, it states, “Accused No. 2 and 3 are
Managing Director and Director, respectively and are actively involved and
responsible for day-to-day business operations and management, including
the financial affairs of the Accused No. 1.” It is further stated that “the said
cheque was issued on behalf of the Accused No. 1 due to the working
relationship entered into by the Accused No. 2 and 3.” These averments,
read together, go beyond a mere recitation of statutory language. They
specifically attribute active involvement in financial and day-to-day
management to both Directors, and connect the issuance of the cheque to the
working relationship established by them.
71.
So far as Petitioner No. 2/Mr. Praveen Kumar Agarwal is concerned,
he is both the Managing Director and the signatory of the dishonoured
cheque. The act of signing the cheque on behalf of the Company is itself a
direct act of commission. His liability under Sections 138 and 141 NI Act is,
therefore, unimpeachable at this stage.
72.
So far as Petitioner No. 3/Mr. Raj Kumar Agarwal is concerned, the
Petitioners have pressed the argument, that since he is not the signatory of
the cheque, he cannot be prosecuted. However, a non-signatory Director is
not ipso facto immune from prosecution; what is required is the presence of
adequate averments in the Complaint establishing his charge and
responsibility over the Company’s affairs. As noted above, the Complaint
specifically avers that Petitioner No. 3 was actively involved and responsible
for day-to-day business operations and financial affairs of the Company, and
was part of the working relationship.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:21:42
W.P. (CRL) 2840/2017
73.
Accordingly, the implication of both Petitioner No. 2 and Petitioner
No. 3 as accused persons in the Complaint does not, on the present record,
warrant interference at this stage.
74.
In the present Petition, the Court is only required to examine whether
the allegations in the Complaint, taken at face value, disclose the
commission of an offence under Section 138 NI Act. The defence sought to
be raised by the Petitioners, involves disputed questions of fact requiring
appreciation of evidence, which must necessarily be tested during trial.
Conclusion:
75.
In light of the foregoing discussion, this Court finds no merit in the
Petition.
76.
The Petition is dismissed and accordingly disposed of, along with
pending Application(s), if any.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
MARCH 10, 2026
Va
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:21:42
W.P. (CRL) 2840/2017
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review