Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:28730
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE N.NAGARESH
FRIDAY, THE 4TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 14TH CHAITHRA, 1947
RSA NO. 685 OF 2017
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT DATED 17.08.2016 IN AS NO.150 OF 2009 OF
SUB COURT, NEYYATTINKARA ARISING OUT OF THE ORDER DATED 13.03.2009
IN IA. NO.4435/2008 OS NO.329 OF 1962 OF I ADDITIONAL MUNSIFF
COURT, NEYYATTINKARA
APPELLANT/APPELLANT/84TH DEFENDANT:
MADHAVAN
S/O.PODIKUTTY NADAR, KALLUVETTANKUZHI,
MEKKEPUTHEN VEEDU, CHENKAL DESOM,
KOLLAMKODE PAKUTHY.
BY ADV SRI.G.S.REGHUNATH
RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS/PLAINTIFF & DEFENDANTS:
* 1
NAGAMONY NADAR
(DELETED)
S/O.DANIEL NADAR,MELEKUZHINJAMVILA,
THEKKEKARA PUTHEN VEEDU,KARODE DESOM,
KARODE P.O., PIN - 695 506.
(RESPONDENT NO.1 IS DELETED FROM THE PARTY ARRAY AT THE
RISK OF THE APPELLANT AS PER THE ORDER DATED 4/4/2019
IN IA NO.1/2019)
KALARANI
D/O.LEELA BAI, KAKKAVILA VEEDU, KARODE DESOM,
KAKKAVILA P.O., PIN - 695 506.
MUTHU ROSAMMA
W/O.RAYAPPAN NADAR, MELEKUZHINJAMVILA VEEDU,
KARODE DESOM, KARODE P.O., PIN - 695 506.
RAYAPPAN NADAR JUSTER
2025:KER:28730
RSA No.685/2017
:2:
MELEKUZHINJAMVILA VEEDU,KARODE DESOM,
KARODE P.O., PIN - 695 506.
GEORGE STEPHEN
S/O.RAYAPPAN NADAR, MELEKUZHINJAMVILA VEEDU,
KARODE DESOM, KARODE P.O., PIN - 695 506.
CHELLAYYAN NADAR CHRISTHUDAS
AGED 32 YEARS
MELEKUZHINJAMVILA,THEKKEKARA VEEDU,
KARODE, KARODE P.O.,PIN - 695 506.
CHELLAYYAN NADAR FRANCIS
MELEKUZHINJAMVILA,THEKKEKARA VEEDU, KARODE,
KARODE P.O.,PIN - 695 506.
MARIYA THANKAM
AGED 48 YEARS
THEKKEKARA PUTHEN VEEDU,MELEKUZHINJAMVILA,
KARODE DESOM,KARODE P.O., PIN - 695 506.
CHELLAN NADAR LAWRENCE
AGED 23 YEARS
MELEKUZHINJAMVILA, THEKKEKARA VEEDU, KARODE,
KARODE P.O.,PIN - 695 506.
CHELLAN NADAR STANLY
MELEKUZHINJAMVILA, THEKKEKARA VEEDU,
KARODE, KARODE P.O., PIN - 695 506.
CRYSTAL THANKOM
AGED 47 YEARS
MELEKUZHINJAMVILA, THEKKEKARA VEEDU,
KARODE, KARODE P.O., PIN - 695 506.
JEEVANSON
AGED 21 YEARS
S/O.PONNAYYAN NADAR, AGED 21,
MELEKUZHINJAMVILA, THEKKEKARA VEEDU,
KARODE, KARODE P.O., PIN - 695 506.
ALDRINE
S/O.PONNAYYAN NADAR,
2025:KER:28730
RSA No.685/2017
:3:
MELEKUZHINJAMVILA,THEKKEKARA VEEDU,
KARODE, KARODE P.O.,PIN - 695 506.
* 14
AMMALU THANKOM,
(DIED)
AGED 45 YEARS
MELEKUZHINJAMVILA, THEKKEKARA VEEDU,
KARODE, KARODE P.O., PIN - 695 506.
JOHNSON
AGED 23 YEARS
MELEKUZHINJAMVILA, THEKKEKARA PUTHEN VEEDU,
KARODE, KARODE P.O., PIN - 695 506.
AUGUSTHYANOSE
AGED 36 YEARS
S/O.CHELLAKKANNU NADAR,
MELEKUZHINJAMVILA VEEDU, KALLAMPOTTA,
KARODE, KARODE P.O., PIN - 695 506.
ALIAS RAJAM
KEEZHEKUZHINJANVILA VEEDU,
KARODE P.O.,PIN - 695 506.
BEULA
D/O.RAJAM, KEEZHEKUZHINJANVILA VEEDU,
KARODE, KARODE P.O., PIN - 695 506.
LEELA BAI JALARANI
THEKKEKARA PUTHEN VEEDU,KEEZHEKUZHINJANVILA,
KARODE DESOM, KARODE P.O.,PIN- 695 506.
RAJADAS
THEKKEKARA PUTHEN VEEDU,
KEEZHEKUZHINJANVILA, KARODE DESOM,
KARODE VILLAGE, TRIVANDRUM - 695 506.
ADDL.21 SHAJI,
MELEKUZHINJAMVILA,THEKKEKARA VEEDU,KARODE,
KAKKAVILA P.O.,PINCODE-695506.
(THE
LEGAL
HEIR
OF
THE
DECEASED
14TH
RESPONDENT IS IMPLEADED AS THE ADDITIONAL 21ST
RESPONDENT AS PER ORDER DATED 11.10.2019 IN
IA.NO.3180/2017)
2025:KER:28730
RSA No.685/2017
:4:
BY ADVS.
SRI.A.R.DILEEP
DR.ELIZABETH VARKEY
SRI.GEORGE VARGHESEPERUMPALLIKUTTIYIL
SRI.P.J.JOE PAUL
SRI.JITHIN SAJI ISAAC
SRI.MANU SEBASTIAN
SRI.K.J.SAJI ISAAC
THIS REGULAR SECOND APPEAL HAVING COME UP
ADMISSION ON 04.04.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME
DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
FOR
DAY
2025:KER:28730
RSA No.685/2017
:5:
N. NAGARESH, J.
`````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````
R.S.A. No.685 of 2017
`````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````
Dated this the 4th day of April, 2025
JUDGMENT
~~~~~~~~~
The 84th defendant in OS No.329/1962 of
the Munsiff's Court, Neyyattinkara is the appellant in this
RSA. The appeal is against judgment dated 17.08.2016 in
AS No.150/2009 of the Sub Court, Neyyattinkara arising
from the order dated 13.03.2009 in IA No.4435/2008 in OS
No.329/1962 which is a suit for partition and redemption.
2.
Defendant No.84, who is the appellant
herein, is the son of deceased defendant Nos.24 and 25.
As per the preliminary decree, the right of defendant Nos.2,
25, 26 and 34 were declared. The mortgage pertaining to
the property was redeemed by the 25 th defendant.
2025:KER:28730
RSA No.685/2017
:6:
Ext.C1(a) is the property under the possession of defendant
Nos.24 and 25 having an extent of 10.2 Cents.
3.
Neyyattinkara
The Court of the 1st Additional Munsiff,
passed
a
preliminary
judgment
dated
22.12.1971 in the suit for partition and redemption wherein
the rights of defendants 2, 24, 25 and 34 were declared.
The trial court further declared that the 3 rd defendant is
entitled to 1/12 share in the property comprised in Survey
No.138/1A. The 16th defendant was declared as entitled to
19 Cents described in Exts.D9 and D10. The 17 th defendant
was declared entitled to 30 and 3/8 Cents described in
Exts.D27 to D29. The 20th defendant was held entitled to
65½ Cents and a building as described in Exts.D37 and
D38.
4.
A final decree was also passed in AS
No.17/1994 on 16.01.1986. As per the preliminary decree,
the rights of defendants 2, 25, 26 and 34 were declared.
The 25th defendant redeemed the mortgaged property. A
2025:KER:28730
RSA No.685/2017
:7:
property having an extent of 10.2 Cents was allotted to
defendant No.25.
The 24th defendant was allotted plot
No.18.
5.
The final decree was challenged by the
plaintiffs filing AS No.17/1994. The appeal was allowed and
the matter was remitted to the trial court on the ground that
the Commissioner has shown a lesser extent of property as
available for partition. After remand, the Munsiff's Court set
aside the Commission report and appointed a new Advocate
Commissioner.
The new Commissioner, Sri. Simon,
measured the property and filed a report and plan.
The
property of the 25th defendant was not shown in the report
and plan on the ground that the said defendant did not file a
commission
application.
The
appellant
states
that
defendants 24 and 25 had filed IA No.2428/1972 and
consequently, the plots of defendants 24 and 25 were
shown in the plan submitted by the former Advocate
Commissioner.
2025:KER:28730
RSA No.685/2017
:8:
6.
During examination in the court, Advocate
Commissioner Sri. Simon admitted that the 10.2 Cents is
located by him in the plan. The said plan ought to have
been set aside by the court. The appellant again filed IA
No.1842/2007. The IA was dismissed by the Munsiff's Court
holding that appellant has no right to get partition of the
property allotted to the 25th defendant in the preliminary
decree.
7.
The appellant filed W.P.(C) No.32945/2007
aggrieved by the order of the Munsiff's Court. Though this
Court dismissed the writ petition, this Court observed that
the Munsiff's Court should change its stand and allot the
share to the 84th defendant if the 84 th defendant can
convince the court that he is entitled to actual possession of
the 10.2 Cents claimed by him under the 25th defendant.
8.
The
appellant
thereafter
filed
IA
No.4435/2008 praying for passing a final decree in his
favour so that the 10.2 Cents obtained by him from the 25 th
2025:KER:28730
RSA No.685/2017
:9:
defendant, is allotted to him as his share. The appellant
also filed IA No.57/2008 for directing the Commissioner to
identify and locate the 10.2 Cents claimed by him.
9.
The trial court dismissed IA No.4435/2008
and IA No.57/2008 filed by the appellant for passing a final
decree and for identifying the property. A final decree was
passed in favour of the plaintiffs and the final decree
application filed by the 84th defendant was dismissed as per
separate orders.
10.
Aggrieved
by
the
said
orders
dated
13.03.2009, the appellant filed AS No.150/2009 in the Sub
Court, Neyyattinkara.
The Sub Court, Neyyattinkara
dismissed the appeal as per judgment dated 17.08.2016.
The appellant states that a decree was passed in the suit
declaring that defendants 24 and 25 are entitled to 10.25
Cents and 14.25 Cents respectively. None of the parties
claim tenancy right over the properties allocated to
defendants 24 and 25. The appellant-84 th defendant is the
2025:KER:28730
RSA No.685/2017
: 10 :
son of defendants 24 and 25 and he has obtained all the
rights of defendants 24 and 25 as per registered documents.
11.
Defendants
and
had
filed
commission application for partitioning their share and the
said application was allowed and the Commissioner had
allotted plots to defendants 24 and 25.
The said
commission report was set aside for a different reason and
the subsequent Advocate Commissioner appointed by the
Court did not locate or mark the property allocated to
defendants 24 and 25. When this fact was brought to the
notice of the court by the 84 th defendant filing IA
No.1842/2007, the Commissioner demarcated the property
claimed by the 84th defendant as BCDEFG plot. The trial
court, however, ignored these facts.
The appellate court
also failed to discharge its duty in considering the rights of
the 84th defendant on the basis of the preliminary decree.
The appellant therefore seeks to set aside the judgment
dated 17.08.2016 in AS No.150/2009 of the Sub Court,
2025:KER:28730
RSA No.685/2017
: 11 :
Neyyattinkara arising from order dated 13.03.2009 in IA
No.4435/2008 in OS No.329/1962.
12.
Heard.
13.
In OS No.329/1962, the Munsiff's Court,
Neyyattinkara passed a preliminary judgment and decree on
22.12.1971.
The appellant filed IA No.4435/2008 for
passing final decree. The said application was dismissed by
the Munsiff's Court.
Against the said order in IA
No.4435/2008, the appellant filed AS No.150/2009 in the
Sub Court, Neyyattinkara. The Sub Court also dismissed
the appeal.
14.
The
Munsiff's
Court,
Neyyattinkara
dismissed IA No.4435/2008 holding that the appellant had
earlier filed IA No.1842/2007 to appoint an Advocate
Commissioner to prepare a plan with respect to the plots the
petitioner is entitled to get as per the preliminary decree.
The plaintiff also had filed IA No.57/2008 to declare that he
is entitled to get actual possession of 10.2 Cents of
2025:KER:28730
RSA No.685/2017
: 12 :
property. Both the said IAs were dismissed and in view of
the findings in those IAs, the appellant is not entitled to get
final decree for partition.
15.
The said order dated 13.03.2009 in IA
No.4435/2008 in OS No.329/1962 was taken in appeal by
the appellant as AS No.150/2009 before the Sub Court,
Neyyattinkara. The learned Sub Judge noted that since IA
No.4435/2008 was one for passing final decree and since
the said IA stands dismissed, the order under challenge has
to be construed as a final judgment since the rights of the
appellant are finally determined by the order under
challenge.
16.
IA No.4435/2008 was dismissed by the
Munsiff's Court holding that IA No.1842/2007 earlier filed by
the petitioner was dismissed.
In IA No.1842/2007, the
appellant sought to appoint Advocate Commissioner to
prepare plan regarding the plots claimed by the appellant.
Though the order in the said IA was challenged before this
2025:KER:28730
RSA No.685/2017
: 13 :
Court filing W.P.(C) No.32945/2007, this Court dismissed
the writ petition granting liberty to the appellant to urge any
further contentions before the court below.
17.
The appellate court gone through the
available materials in order to find out whether the appellant
is entitled to allotment and separate possession of 10.2
Cents of property.
The appellate court noted that the
preliminary decree did not declare the rights of defendants
24 and 25 with regard to a property having extent of 10.2
Cents. Therefore, the claim raised by the appellant in the
application for final decree was not in accordance with the
preliminary decree.
18.
The
appellate
court
considered
the
relevant portion of the preliminary judgment incorporated in
paragraph 20 which reads as follows:
The rights of these defendants are therefore
declared as provided in Ext.D30 decree.
However, in Ext.D30, it is stated that defendants
therein are in possession of the property as
Kuttikuzhikanamdars since 1057. Therefore, as
per Section 2(57)(d) read with Section 13 of the
2025:KER:28730
RSA No.685/2017
: 14 :
Act 1/1964 as amended by Act 35/1969,
defendants 2, 24 to 26 and 34 are not entitled to
redeem the plaint schedule property outstanding
in the possession of Kuttikuzhikanamdars.
The said finding by the Munsiff's Court disentitled the
appellant to get separate possession of 10.2 Cents of
property.
19.
Though the appellant would contend that
the said findings are unsustainable, the argument cannot be
accepted since defendants 24 and 25 or the appellant did
not challenge the preliminary judgment. The appellant is
therefore bound by the findings in the preliminary judgment.
20.
Allotment of shares in the final decree can
be made only as per the findings and directions in the
preliminary decree. The application of the appellant for final
decree is not in accordance with the preliminary decree.
Therefore, the appellate court dismissed AS No.150/2009.
21.
The
appellant
would
urge
that
the
statements in the preliminary judgment and decree are
baseless. It is to be noted that defendants 24 or 25 or the
2025:KER:28730
RSA No.685/2017
: 15 :
appellant did not challenge the preliminary judgment and
hence they are bound by the findings and conclusions in the
preliminary judgment.
Allotment of shares in the final
decree can only be as per the preliminary decree.
The
preliminary judgment shows that the claim raised by the
petitioner in IA No.4435/2008 is not in accordance with the
preliminary decree.
The claim of the appellant therefore
cannot be allowed.
In view of the afore facts, the order passed
by the Munsiff's Court and the judgment of the Sub Court do
not require any interference.
The second appeal is
therefore dismissed. All pending interlocutory applications
are closed.
Sd/N. NAGARESH, JUDGE
aks/02.04.2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review