The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
15. With the observations made in the preceding paragraph, the CMP application stands disposed of. ( Aditya Kumar Mohapatra) Judge Rubi Reason: Authentication Location: OHC Page 6 of 6.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
CMP No.2127 of 2025
Maa Jagat Janani, Presiding
.....
Petitioners
Deity Of Maa Jagat Janani
Temple Bije, Unchabali & Ors.
Represented by Adv. Alok Kumar Mohanty
State Of Odisha & Ors.
-versus.....
Opposite Parties
Represented by Adv. –
Mr. U.C.Jena, A.S.C.
CORAM:
THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ADITYA KUMAR
MOHAPATRA
ORDER
16.01.2026
Order No.
01.
1.
This matter is taken up through Hybrid Arrangement (Virtual/
Physical Mode).
2.
This matter has been listed on the Court’s own motion as the
learned counsel for the Petitioner pointed out certain inadvertent
typographical errors in order dated 12.01.2026. Perused the order
dated 12.01.2026, it appears that the order has been typed out
wrongly. Accordingly, the earlier order dated 12.01.2026 is recalled
and in its place the following order be passed and uploaded in the
website.
3.
Heard learned counsel for the Petitioners as well as learned
Addl. Standing Counsel for the pro forma-Plaintiff. Perused the
application.
4.
By filing the present application under Article 227 of the
Page 1 of 6.
Constitution of India, the Petitioner has prayed for setting aside of the
order dated 14.11.2025 passed by the learned Civil Judge (Senior
Division), Champua in C.S. No.28 of 2013 thereby rejecting the
application of the plaintiff-Petitioner under Order 39 Rule 7 of the
CPC.
5.
Learned counsel for the Petitioners at the outset contended that
the Petitioner as plaintiff filed a suit for declaration of right, title and
interest over the suit land by way of adverse possession and he has
also prayed for confirmation of his possession and for injunction.
During the pendency the aforesaid suit, the Plaintiff-Petitioner moved
an application under Order 39 Rule 7 of CPC for local inspection
through the Court appointed Survey Knowing Commissioner. It was
further submitted that such local inquiry is for a just decision in the
suit. It was also contended that such inquiry would assist the Court in
deciding the suit and that the same will not cause any prejudice to the
defendants. On such ground, learned counsel for the Petitioner
contended that the learned trial court has committed an illegality in
rejecting the prayer for appointment of Survey Commissioner for the
local inspection.
6.
Further, referring to the impugned order dated 14.11.2025 at
Annexure-6, learned counsel for the Petitioners submitted before this
Court that it was only on the objection of the learned AGP, that the
application of the Petitioner under Order 39 Rule 7 was rejected by
the learned trial court. He further submitted that no doubt Order 39
Rule 7 of CPC confers a discretion, however, such power can only
be exercised to assist the Court to come to a just conclusion. The
prayer made in the application filed under Order 39 Rule 7 is only to
assist the Court and to find out regarding the possession of the
Page 2 of 6.
Plaintiff-Petitioners over the suit land. At this juncture learned
counsel for the Petitioners submitted that the possession of the
plaintiff over suit land is for several decades. Therefore, a local
inquiry would clarify the aforesaid fact and would help the Court to
arrive at a just conclusion in this case. He further contended that the
learned trial Court has dismissed the application filed by the plaintiff
based on the objection of the learned AGP to the effect that the same
would expand the scope of the suit and any order passed on such
application would assist the plaintiff in collecting evidence in
support of his claim.
7.
Perused the impugned order dated 14.11.2025 which has been
assailed by the plaintiff-Petitioners in the present CMP application.
The plaintiff-Petitioners being aggrieved by rejection of his
application under order 39 Rule 7 for local inspection of the suit
scheduled property has approached this Court with a prayer for
setting aside order dated 14.11.2025 and for a further direction to the
learned trial court to allow local inspection of the suit scheduled
property through a Pleader Commissioner. The application of the
plaintiff-Petitioners was objected to by the learned AGP. It was the
specific stand of the defendant No.3 that he had leased out the land
by virtue of lease deed dated 01.08.1943 in favour of the M/s ESSEL
Mining and such lease deed was renewed subsequently from time to
time. The plaintiff contended before the learned trial court that the
inspection is necessary to ascertain the nature of the suit land and the
presence of a temple thereon and that such inspection would aid the
Court in proper adjudication of the dispute involved in the suit.
8.
According to the learned trial court, the issue which is to be
determined in the suit is with regard to the claim of the plaintiff of
adverse possession over the suit scheduled land for a period of 70
Page 3 of 6.
years. On the contrary, the defendants put forth a plea regarding a
subsisting lease in favour of a third party. The learned trial court has
prima facie held that the issue is primarily to be decided on the basis
of documentary evidence. Moreover, the claim of the Petitionersplaintiff regarding continuous open and hostile possession can only
be established by the adducing evidence in that regard. Thus, it was
held by the learned trial court that a local inspection at this stage
would not assist the learned trial court for a just and fair adjudication
of the dispute. On the contrary, the same would amount to permitting
the plaintiff to collect evidence through the Court machinery.
Moreover, the learned trial court has specifically observed that the
plaintiff has failed to demonstrate any specific or exceptional reason
as to why the physical features of the suit land cannot be proved
through evidence in Court. With the aforesaid observation the
learned trial court has dismissed the application of the plaintiff filed
under order 39 Rule 7.
9.
Order 39 Rule 7 of the CPC, indisputably, confers a
discretionary power on the trial court for detention, preservation,
inspection etc of subject matter of suit. Looking at the application
filed by the plaintiff-Petitioner, this Court observed that the
Petitioner has prayed for inspection of the subject matter of the suit.
One of the basic requirements for passing order under order 39 Rule
7 is that the plaintiff is incapable of inspecting the subject matter of
the suit or it is difficult on his part to adduce evidence in respect of
the suit property. In either case, the objective is to assist the Court
for a just and fair adjudication of the dispute involved in the suit. In
other words to get an order under order 39 Rule 7 the plaintiff has to
establish that he is incapable of having the knowledge of the subject
matter of dispute in view of the nature of the suit property or is
Page 4 of 6.
prevented from having such knowledge.
10.
In the present case, the plaintiff claims title through adverse
possession over the suit scheduled land. Thus, the trial court has to
proceed, at that stage, on the basis of the plaintiffs pleadings that the
plaintiff is in possession over the suit land. In such a scenario, there
is no difficulty on the part of the plaintiff to either have the
knowledge of the subject matter of the dispute or to establish the
nature and identity of the suit property before the learned trial court,
by adducing evidence. The assistance of the Pleader Commissioner
would be required only in a scenarios where the plaintiff is
incapacitated or incapable of having the full knowledge of the
subject matter of dispute.
11.
It is also the settled possession of law that the report of the
commissioner appointed order under 39 Rule 7 is not legal evidence
unless the same is proved legally by examining witnesses. The
aforesaid view of this Court gets support from the decision of this
Court reported in 1990 Vol 1 OLR 247, AIR 80 Odisha 98, 1992 (2)
OLR 14, 2013 (Supp) 1 OLR 253.
12.
Similarly, it is also a settled principle of law that order of
inspection under order 39 Rule 7 cannot be directed for collecting
evidence for the party. Assistance of the Court would be necessary
only where the party is incapable of having the knowledge or
inspection in view of the nature of the suit land. When the land is
open and witnesses are available, no commissioner is to be appointed
under order 39 Rule 7. This view of the Court get support from the
judgment reported in Vol 62 (1986) CLT 201.
13.
In the ultimate analysis of the factual as well as the legal
aspects involved in the present matter this Court is of the considered
view that the learned trial court has not committed any illegality in of
Page 5 of 6.
exercising in its discretion under order 39 Rule 7. As such, no fault
can be found in order dated 14.11.2025 so as to compel this Court to
interfere with the impugned order in exercise of its power of
superintendency under article 227 of the Constitution of India.
Accordingly, this Court finds no merit in the present application.
Hence, the same is dismissed.
14.
However, while dismissing the present application this Court
makes it clear that irrespective of rejection of his application under
order 39 Rule 7 of the CPC, it is open to the Petitioners to engage a
Private Commissioner for inspection of the suit subject matter, and if
required, such report may be cited as evidence from the side of the
plaintiff subject to formal prove thereof by the plaintiff.
15.
With the observations made in the preceding paragraph, the
CMP application stands disposed of.
( Aditya Kumar Mohapatra)
Judge
Rubi
Digitally Signed
Signed by: RUBI BEHERA
Reason: Authentication
Location: OHC
Date: 21-Jan-2026 10:56:23
Page 6 of 6.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review