Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
SHARMA
Date: 2023.06.07 12:32:32 +05'30'
SHAMURAILATPAM SUSHIL
SHARMA
Page |1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No. 819 of 2022
M/S Zenith Enterprise, having its Branch Office at
M.G. Avenue, P.O & P.S. Imphal through its
Proprietor namely Johnson Keishing, aged about
58 years old, S/O (L) Miba Keishing, a permanent
resident of Marung Lane, New Checkon, P.O. &
P.S. Porompat, Imphal East District, Manipur –
795002.
… Petitioner
-Versus1. The Food Corporation of India through the Chairman
& Managing Director, 16/20 Barakhamba Lane, New
Delhi- 110001.
2. The Executive Director (Zone), Food Corporation of
India (NE), Zonal Office (NE), Publication Building,
G.S. Road Lachit Nagar, Guwahati, Assam-7.
3. The Deputy General Manager (R), Food Corporation
of India, Regional Office, Manipur, Old Assembly
Complex, Imphal, Manipur – 795001.
4. The General Manager (R), Food Corporation of
India, Regional Office, Nagaland, Regional Office,
House No. 105, Bank Colony, Dimapur, Nagaland –
797112.
...... Respondents
WP(C) No. 819 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
Page |2
WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
M/S Zenith Enterprise, having its Branch Office at
M.G. Avenue, P.O & P.S. Imphal through its
Proprietor namely Johnson Keishing, aged about
58 years old, S/O (L) Miba Keishing, a permanent
resident of Marung Lane, New Checkon, P.O. &
P.S. Porompat, Imphal East District, Manipur –
795002.
… Petitioner
-Versus1. The Food Corporation of India through the Chairman
& Managing Director, 16/20 Barakhamba Lane, New
Delhi- 110001.
2. The Executive Director (Zone), Food Corporation of
India (NE), Zonal Office (NE), Publication Building,
G.S. Road Lachit Nagar, Guwahati, Assam-7.
3. The Deputy General Manager (R), Food Corporation
of India, Regional Office, Manipur, Old Assembly
Complex, Imphal, Manipur – 795001.
4. The General Manager (R), Food Corporation of
India, Regional Office, Nagaland, Regional Office,
House No. 105, Bank Colony, Dimapur, Nagaland –
797112.
5. The W.A.C. Enterprises through its proprietor,
having its Head Office at Tushen Chanhong Village,
Ukhrul District, Manipur – 795142.
...... Respondents
WP(C) No. 819 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
Page |3
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE M.V. MURALIDARAN
For the Petitioners
::
Mr. HS Paonam, Sr. Adv.,
Mr. S. Gunabanta, Adv.
For the Respondents
::
Mr. W. Darakishwor, Sr.PCCG
Date of Hearing and
reserving Judgment & Order ::
21.04.2023
Date of Judgment & Order
03.05.2023
::
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
(CAV)
Heard Mr. H.S. Paonam, learned Senior Advocate
for the petitioner and Mr. W. Darakishwor, Senior Panel Counsel
for Central Government for the respondents.
2.
W.P.(C) No.819 of 2022 has been filed by the
petitioner to quash the impugned third re-tender NIT dated
29.8.2022 issued by the Regional Office of the FCI at Dimapur,
Nagaland for appointment of Road Transport Contractor for the
route Ex-Dimapur to FSD Thoubal as the same is illegal and to
direct the respondents for providing reasonable allocation of
work to the petitioner in terms of the appointment order dated
6.12.2021.
3.
W.P.(C) No.1012 of 2022 has been filed by the
petitioner to quash the impugned order dated 30.5.2022
appointing the respondent WAC Enterprises as ad-hoc road
WP(C) No. 819 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
Page |4
transport contract from RH, Dimapur to FSD Thoubal so far as
the contract period extendable by three months in terms of the
speaking order dated 20.9.2022 and the RTI reply dated
20.9.2022 and to direct the respondents allowing allocation of the
work program for transportation of rice from Railhead, Jiribam to
FSD Thoubal to the petitioner.
4.
Brief facts are as follows:
The Regional Office of FCI at Imphal issued a
Notice Inviting Tender (NIT) on 7.9.2021 for appointment of road
transport contractor for transportation of food grains from
RH/FSD Jiribam to FCI, FSD Churachandpur and FSD Thoubal.
The petitioner has participated in the tender process and
successful in the bid and was appointed as road transport
contractor of FCI for a period of two years for the route RH/FSD
Jiribam to FSD Thoubal vide letter/order dated 6.12.2021 and the
term would expire in December, 2023.
4.1.
The petitioner submitted a bank guarantee for a
sum of Rs.2,64,24,045/- on 31.1.2022 and have started
execution of the transportation work. There is no any blemish
remark from any corner and the work of the petitioner in
discharging its duties to the satisfaction of all concerned.
The
Model Tender Form Road Transport Contract for the route
WP(C) No. 819 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
Page |5
RH/FSD Jiribam to FSD Thoubal have clearly indicated that the
godown capacity of FSD Thoubal is 3132 MT only. The petitioner
have been successfully feeding 3132 MT required at FSD
Thoubal without any disturbances. While being so, the
appointment of another road transport contractor for FSD
Thoubal would be meaningless and it would be only to deprive
the petitioner to continue with the transportation work.
Due to
bad connectivity transportation, transportation work was stopped
and, at present, the road/route become motorable and the
petitioner is ready to continue in terms of the appointment order
dated 6.12.2021.
4.2.
After about four months of transportation work
executed by the petitioner from RH/FSD Jiribam to FSD Thoubal
and despite decision of the Regional Office of FCI at Imphal, the
Regional Office at Dimapur, Nagaland have floated NIT dated
4.5.2022 for appointment road transport contractor for the route
Ex-Dimapur to FSD Thoubal/FSD Churachandpur is nothing but
an arbitrary exercise and violative of its own decision of FCI
thereby depriving the petitioner the basic fundamental right of
freedom of trade and commerce, as the transportation is to be
polarized from Ex-Dimapur for vested interest and for favouring
contractors and others at Dimapur, Nagaland. Challenging the
NIT dated 4.5.2022, the petitioner has filed W.P.(C) No.348 of
WP(C) No. 819 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
Page |6
2022 and due to no response to the NIT dated 4.5.2022 from
anyone, the aforesaid NIT was scrapped and consequently, by
the order dated 1.8.2022, W.P.(C) No.348 of 2022 was closed as
infructuous.
4.3.
In the meanwhile due to collapse of the Irang Balley
Bridge on Jiribam road and disruption of railway line in LamdingBadarpur Section, NIT dated 17.5.2022 was floated for
appointment of adhoc road transport contractor from RH Dimapur
to FSD Thoubal for a period of six months and the respondent
WAC Enterprises was appointed as adhoc road transport
contractor from RH Dimapur to FSD Thoubal for a period of six
months or until finalization of regular tender whichever is earlier
vide impugned order dated 30.5.2022. Assailing the same, the
petitioner filed W.P.(C) No.1012 of 2022.
4.4.
To the shock and surprise of the petitioner, the FCI,
Regional Office, Nagaland have issued re-tender NIT dated
28.5.2022 by reducing the estimated contract value from
Rs.42,03,13,701/- to Rs.29,89,00,000/- for favouring other
contractors who have persuaded the FCI for their vested interest.
The aforesaid re-tender NIT dated 28.5.2022 was also
challenged by the petitioner in W.P.(C) No.452 of 2022 and due
to non-response from anyone, the aforesaid re-tender NIT dated
WP(C) No. 819 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
Page |7
28.5.2022 was scrapped and in the view of the above W.P.(C)
No.452 of 2022 was closed.
4.5.
After scrapping the 1st NIT dated 4.5.2022 and the
re-tender NIT dated 28.5.2022, the FCI, Dimapur with the design
of favouring contractors from Dimapur have issued the impugned
NIT dated 29.8.2022 by reducing the estimated contract work
value from 42.03 crore to Rs.17.68 crore.
Challenging the 3 rd
re-tender NIT dated 29.8.2022, the petitioner has filed W.P.(C)
No.819 of 2022.
5.
Resisting the writ petitions, the respondents filed
affidavits-in-opposition, inter alia, stating that tenders were
invited with bona fide intention to cater to the un-interrupted
supply for National Food Security Act, 2013 on least cost basis
in public interest and to optimize the use of public exchequer.
There is no question of favouring any influential contractor.
Further the impugned NIT dated 29.8.2022 has been invited with
an estimated value of contract of Rs.17.68 crore after taking into
consideration the present ad hoc transportation rate and the
stocks likely to be included during the two year contract period.
The primary objective of FCI is not only to cater to the NFSA
requirement, but also to undertake movement of stock on least
WP(C) No. 819 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
Page |8
cost basis, as FCI is run and financed by the Government of
India.
5.1.
It is further stated that following the disruption of rail
connectivity in the Lumding Badarpur section and collapse of
Irang Bridge during mid-May 2022 till last part of July, 2022, there
was utmost necessity to feed FSD Thoubal by road from Dimapur
and, accordingly, FCI, RO Nagaland has positioned Limited
adhoc transport contracts within the DoP of GM (R) for a period
of 6 months, extendable by another three months @ Rs,3768/per MT for entire distance vide appointment order dated
30.5.2022. The period of the said contract is from 2.6.2022 to
1.12.2022. On the other hand, the existing transport contract of
the petitioner from Jiribam to FSD Thoubal was awarded @
Rs.4071/- per MT for the entire distance. Therefore, the prayer
of the petitioner to allot work to them is fit to be out rightly
rejected.
The petitioner just to serve their personal interest is
praying to allot work to them at higher rate and the
private/personal interest cannot be considered above public
interest. Hence, prayed for dismissal of the writ petitions.
6.
Assailing the impugned NIT, Mr. HS Paonam, the
learned senior counsel for the petitioner submitted that despite
the petitioner being appointed as regular road transport
WP(C) No. 819 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
Page |9
contractor of FCI for the route RH Jiribam to FSD Thoubal vide
appointment order dated 6.12.2021 for a period of two years, the
respondent authorities have failed to allocate any quota of work
for the reasons best known to them. He would submit that the
impugned NIT is meant for the State of Nagaland that too despite
the existence of Regional Office of FCI at Imphal for catering the
need of the State of Manipur is indicative of ill-motive, mala fide
and favourtism warranting interference by this Court.
7.
The learned senior counsel would submit that the
petitioner, who is a regular transport contractor of FCI for the
route RH Jiribam to FSD Thoubal, has not been allotted any work
during the months June, July, August and September, 2022 for
the reason either for non-operational of Jiribam route or for any
other reasons.
The FCI has failed to allocate any work to the
petitioner despite the route becoming operational and the terms
of contract of the petitioner is due for expiry only in December,
2023.
8.
The learned senior counsel further submitted that
the Regional Office at Dimapur, Nagaland without appreciating
the ground realities of Manipur that the petitioner is already
operating for the route RH Jiribam to FSD Thoubal for the
godown capacity of 3132 MT only for vested interest and for
WP(C) No. 819 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
P a g e | 10
favouring contractors and others who are influential in Dimapur
has issued the impugned NIT for depriving the petitioner its basic
fundamental rights of freedom of trade and commerce.
9.
The learned senior counsel added that the
petitioner is still continuing as regular transport contractor from
RH Jiribam to FSD Thoubal for the small godown capacity of
3132 MT and there is no need of another contractor for feeding
the same godown. The petitioner would suffer loss once another
contractor is appointed to feed the small godown at FSD Thoubal
which the petitioner is continuing to feed without any complaint.
10.
Adding further, Mr. HS Paonam, the learned senior
counsel for the petitioner submitted that the impugned order
dated 30.5.2022 so far as the condition that the contract period
of private respondent being extendable for another three months
despite being expired on 29.11.2022 is arbitrary and mala fide.
Arguing so, the learned senior counter prayed for setting aside
the impugned NIT and order and to direct the respondent
authorities for providing reasonable allocation of work to the
petitioner in terms of the appointment order dated 6.12.2021.
11.
Panel
Per contra, Mr. W. Darakishwor, the learned Senior
Central
Government
Counsel
appearing
for
the
respondent authorities contended that there is no question of
WP(C) No. 819 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
P a g e | 11
favouring any contractor by the FCI and the primary object of the
FCI is to cater to the NFSA requirement and the food grains are
issued form the FCI godowns under the FCI Regional Office,
Manipur. There are 8 FCI godowns in Manipur Region, namely
FSD Sangaiporou; FSD Bishnupur; FSD Senapati; FSD Ukhrul;
FSD Jiribam; FSD Sangaiprou; FSD Sawombung; FSD Thoubal
and FSD Churachandpur and the regular road transport
contractor is already in position from Dimapur. Further, for FSD
Thoubal and Churachandpur, there are adhoc transport
contractors in position from Dimapur.
12.
The learned panel counsel would submit that NH-
37 was completed cut-off for almost three months from mid-May,
2022 to last part of July, 2022 and the rail line was also cut-off
due to heavy rain and, therefore, it become imperative that in
order to tide over such an unfortunate situation and to meet
NFSA requirement, the FCI needs to position regular road
transport contractor Ex-Dimapur to FSD Thoubal. According, the
FCI Regional Office, Dimapur being the dispatching Region,
invited the tender for appointment of regular road transport
contractor Ex-Dimapur to FSD Thoubal for a period of two years
vide NIT dated 4.5.2022. However, no bids were received, which
necessitated issuance of re-tender dated 28.5.2022 and this time
also no bids were received.
Again, tender was invited on
WP(C) No. 819 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
P a g e | 12
21.7.2022, but again no bids were received. Therefore, finally,
fourth NIT dated 29.8.2022 was invited wherein M/s.SA Ngamo
Agency participated and the value of the tender has been
estimated at Rs.17.68 crore after considering the adhoc
transportation rate and stocks likely to be inducted during the two
years contract period.
13.
The learned senior panel counsel further submitted
that the existing transport rate from RH/FSD Jiribam to FSD
Thoubal is Rs.4071/- per MT for the entire distance awarded to
the petitioner, whereas the rate quoted by M/s. SA Ngamo
Enterprise from Dimapur to FSD Thoubal which was kept under
abeyance by this Court Rs.3763/- per MT for the entire distance
which is lower by Rs.308/- per MT.
14.
The learned senior panel counsel next submitted
that the petitioner has no locus standi to challenge the impugned
NIT dated 29.8.2022 issued by the Regional Office, Dimapur for
appointment of road transport contractor from Dimapur to FSD
Thoubal because the petitioner never participated in the NIT
dated 29.8.2022 floated by the FCI Regional Office, Dimapur
and, hence, the petitioner has no legal right to challenge the
impugned NIT.
WP(C) No. 819 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
P a g e | 13
15.
The learned panel counsel then submitted that in
the re-tender dated 29.8.2022 M/s.Ngamo Agency had
participated and the said agency became a successful bidder
both in technical bid and the financial bid and the petitioner
knowingly failed to implead the said agency as party respondent
in the writ petition.
16.
The learned panel counsel would submit that
because of the interim order dated 28.9.2022 passed in W.P.(C)
No.819 of 2022, the respondent FCI incurred loss of about Rs.30
lakh per month and if it continued for one year, then the FCI will
cause loss for more than Rs.1.37 crore. That apart, vide the
interim order dated 28.9.2022, the respondent FCI was allowed
to take the food grains at higher rates from FSD Jiribam despite
having cheaper rates of transportation from FSD Dimapur to
Thoubal.
17.
According to learned panel counsel, presently the
petitioner is carrying food grains from FSD Dimapur to Ukhrul
Depot on the basis of least cost policy and, in addition that, the
petitioner is also carrying food grains from FSD Jiribam to
Sangaiprou Depot and FSD Jiribam to Sawombung on the basis
of the least cost policy despite having existing contractor
M/s.WAC & MS WI Enterprises from FSD Dimapur to Sangaiprou
WP(C) No. 819 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
P a g e | 14
and FSD Dimapur to Sawombung. In fact, the petitioner cannot
dictate the respondent FCI to do what they want by thinking for
their benefit.
18.
This Court considered the rival submissions and
also perused the materials available on record.
19.
The grievance of the petitioner is that despite being
appointed as a regular transport contractor of FCI for the route
RH Jiribam to FSD Thoubal vide appointment order dated
6.12.2021 for two years, the FCI authority has failed to allocate
any work for the reason best known to them and, therefore,
appropriate direction may be issued to the FCI authority for
providing reasonable allocation of work to the petitioner.
It is
also the prima facie case of the petitioner that they are still
continuing as regular transport contractor from RH Jiribam to
FSD Thoubal for the small godown capacity of 3132 MT and,
therefore, there is no need of another contractor for feeding the
same godown.
20.
According to the petitioner, after scrapping first two
NIT, the FCI Dimapur office with a design of favouring contractors
from Dimapur and others have issued the impugned NIT dated
29.8.2022 by reducing the estimated contract work value from
Rs.42.03 crore to Rs.17.68 crore and, therefore, the same is
WP(C) No. 819 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
P a g e | 15
liable to be set aside. By filing W.P.(C) No.1012 of 2022, the
petitioner challenged the issuance of impugned order dated
30.5.2022 appointing the private respondent as adhoc road
transport contractor from RH Dimapur to FSD Thoubal for a
period of three months extendable by another three months.
21.
On 28.9.2022, when W.P.(C) No.819 of 2022 came
up for admission, this Court passed the following interim order:
“[1] Head Mr. HS Paonam, learned senior
counsel for the petitioner and perused the
record.
[2] Admit.
[3] Notice returnable by 10.10.2022.
[4] Mr. D.JuliusRiamei, learned counsel takes
notice for the FCI and hence, no formal notice
is required.
[5] Post this matter on 10.10.2022 as first item.
[6] Registry is directed to delete the name of
Mr. W.Darakishwor, learned Sr.PCCG and
print the name of Mr.D.JuliusRiamei, learned
counsel for the respondents.
[7] Till such time, the respondents are directed
not to finalize the tender.”
WP(C) No. 819 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
P a g e | 16
22.
Similarly, on 30.11.2022, when W.P.(C) No.1012 of
2022 came up for admission, this Court passed the following
order:
“[1] Heard Mr. S.Gunabanta, learned Jr.
counsel to Mr. HS. Paonam, learned senior
counsel for the petitioner and perused the
records.
[2] Admit.
[3] Issue notice, returnable by 20.12.2022.
[4] Since Mr. W.Darakishwor, learned senior
panel counsel takes notice, no formal notice is
required.
[5] Mr. S.Gunabanta, learned counsel for the
petitioner prayed this Court for interim order
whereas Mr. W.Darakishwor, learned senior
panel counsel for the respondents has
strongly objected for granting the interim order
stating that as per the contract rule, the period
for contract may be extended for further period
of 3 (three) months, apart from this, the
Hon’ble Supreme Court passed an order in
favour of respondents, Mr.W. Darakishwor,
learned
senior
panel
counsel
for
the
respondents also pointed out that this writ
petitioner
has
not
participated
in
the
proceedings and hence, he has no right to file
the writ petition and therefore, he seeks time
WP(C) No. 819 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
P a g e | 17
to file counter affidavit by praying not to grant
any interim order.
[6] The prima-facie, it is made clear that the
contract given to the private respondents is
expired on 29.11.2022 and from today
onwards, there is no order of extending the
period for contract to the private respondents.
Therefore, the private respondents have no
right to continue the work. Therefore, there
shall be an interim order directing the
respondents not to extend the period of
contract till the next date of hearing.
[7] The respondents are at liberty to file an
application for vacating the interim order along
with counter affidavit.
[8] Post the matter on 20.12.2022 as first item
after the motion cases.”
23.
Aggrieved by the said interim orders passed by this
Court, the respondent FCI has filed MC (WP) Nos.398 and 399
of 2022 and, by a common order dated 14.3.2023, this Court
dismissed the said miscellaneous cases and the interim orders
are made absolute. While dismissing the miscellaneous cases,
this Court directed the writ petitions to be listed for hearing on
11.4.2023 as the tender awarded in favour of the petitioner is
going to expire on 6.12.2023.
WP(C) No. 819 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
P a g e | 18
24.
Uninfluenced
by
the
common
order
dated
14.3.2023 passed by this Court in MC (WP) Nos.398 and 399 of
2022 in W.P.Nos.819 and 1012 of 2022, when this Court
examined the issue involved, it is clear that on 6.12.2021 the
petitioner
was
appointed
as
transport
contractor
for
transportation of food grains/allied materials etc. from RH/FSD
Jiribam to FSD Thoubal for a period of two years on regular basis.
Paragraph 2 of the appointment order clearly indicates that the
petitioner was appointed as regular transport contractor for
transportation of food grains from RH/FSD Jiribam to FSD
Thoubal at the quoted rate of Rs.4071/- per MT for the entire
distance for a period of two years with effect from 07.12.2021 to
06.12.2023. The appoint order dated 6.12.2021 further stipulates
that the stocks loaded at RH/FSD Jiribam are required to be
transported form RH/FSD Jiribam and delivered at FSD Thoubal
within normal transit period without resorting to temporary
storage or without transhipment to other trucks/vehicles en-route
without prior permission of the Dy. General Manager (R), FCI RO
Manipur or his authorized officer. The contract will expire on
06.12.2023.
25.
According to the respondent FCI, since NH-37 was
completely cut-off for almost three months from mid-May 2022 to
last part of July, 2022 and the rail line was also cut-off due to
WP(C) No. 819 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
P a g e | 19
heavy rain, it become imperative that in order to tide over such
an unfortunate situation and to meet NFSA requirement, the FCI
needs to position regular road transport contract Ex-Dimapur to
FSD Thoubal. Accordingly, FCI Regional Office, Dimapur being
the dispatching region, invited tender for appointment of regular
road transport contract Ex-Dimapur to FSD Thoubal for a period
of two years and the private respondent has been declared as
the highest bidder.
26.
Between mid-May 2022 and last part of July, 2022
there was a complete cut-off of the road due to heavy rain and
that is the reason for appointing the private adhoc contractor is
not a ground for appointing the private respondent, when the
existing contract in favour of the petitioner has not been
terminated and the same subsists till 6.12.2023.
27.
When the petitioner has been appointed as road
transport contractor for transportation of food grains/allied
materials for the entire distance of RH/FSD Jiribam to FSD
Thoubal for a period of two years from 6.12.2021 to 6.12.2023 at
the quoted rate of 4071/ per MT, the appointment of adhoc
contractor to move stocks from Dimapur to FSD Thoubal citing
the cheaper rate quoted by the adhoc contractor is against the
WP(C) No. 819 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
P a g e | 20
principle of the FCI and against the terms and conditions of the
tender.
28.
Without terminating the contract of the petitioner,
appointment another contractor whether adhoc or regular is an
arbitrary exercise adopted by the FCI authorities and the same
cannot be endorsed by this Court. It is not the case of the
respondent FCI that the petitioner has violated the tender
conditions. Similarly, nothing on record to show that due prior
notice was given to the petitioner before adhoc appointment was
made in favour of the private respondent.
29.
It is admitted by the FCI that the petitioner who is a
regular road transport contractor for the route RH Jiribam to FSD
Thoubal has not been allotted any work from June to September,
2022 for the reason of non-operational of Jiribam route. It is not
the case of the respondent FCI that despite the Jiribam route
operational, the petitioner has failed to supply the food grains.
On the other hand, only due to non-allocation of quota of work,
the petitioner was not able to do transportation.
30.
When the existing contract in favour of the petitioner
subsists till 6.12.2023, the unilateral decision of the FCI in
appointing another contractor is unacceptable.
Taking into
consideration the ground reality and eligibility criteria after
WP(C) No. 819 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
P a g e | 21
fulfillment of the terms and conditions of the tender, once the
tender has been awarded in favour of the petitioner, without
terminating such contract, changing their mind, the FCI for one
reason or the other cannot award adhoc tender to the private
respondent or any other person.
31.
The impugned re-tender dated 29.8.2022 issued by
the Regional Office of FCI at Dimapur, Nagaland is against the
decision of the Regional Office of FCI at Imphal, Manipur despite
the fact that the Regional Office at Imphal, Manipur is for catering
the need of the State of Manipur. As rightly argued by the learned
counsel for the petitioner, the Regional Office of Dimapur,
Nagaland without appreciating the ground realities that the
petitioner is already operating for the route RH Jiribam to FSD
Thoubal for the godown capacity of 3132 MT, issued the
impugned NIT dated 29.8.2022 for depriving the petitioner and
for favouring the contractors who are influential in Dimapur.
32.
The rate aspect canvassed by the FCI, cannot be
believed for the simple reason that in W.P.(C) No.326 of 2020,
the authorities of the FCI contended that handling charges at
Dimapur is very high. When such being plea of the authorities of
the FCI in the earlier round of litigation, it cannot be contended
that the rate quoted by the petitioner at Rs.4071/- per MT is high.
WP(C) No. 819 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
P a g e | 22
Accepting the rate quoted by the petitioner as reasonable, the
respondent FCI awarded contract to the petitioner. While so, the
respondent FCI later on cannot contend that the rate of Rs.4071/per MT for the entire period quoted by the petitioner is very high.
Such plea raised by the FCI is misconceived.
33.
As could be seen from the records, on 31.10.2022,
the petitioner submitted a representation to the respondent
authorities for allotment of monthly work for the Sector RH
Jiribam to FSD Thoubal with a request to cancel the interim
adhoc road transport contract for the route Ex-Dimapur to FSD
Thoubal as the time expired on 29.11.2022. It is alleged by the
petitioner that despite receipt of the said representation, the
same has not been considered and a decision thereon has not
been communicated to the petitioner.
34.
As stated supra, the interim adhoc contract was
awarded to the private respondent for the reason of the road not
being operational. When the road is now operational, it is the
bounden duty of the FCI authorities to allocate work to the
petitioner till the expiry of the term as per the terms and
conditions of the contract. Therefore, the act of the authorities of
the FCI is contrary to the terms and conditions of the contract.
That apart, the contract period of the petitioner exist till
WP(C) No. 819 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
P a g e | 23
6.12.2023. Further, without terminating the contract awarded to
the petitioner, awarding of adhoc contract to the private
respondent amounts to unfair acts of the FCI. Since the contract
between the petitioner and the FCI is due to expire in December,
2023 and the inaction on the part of the FCI for non-sanctioning
of the work as contemplated in the contract till date is a clear case
of arbitrary exercise of power acted in breach of law and violative
of the freedom of trade and commerce. Despite the existence of
Regional Office of FCI at Imphal, the Regional Office at Dimapur
has no authority in appointing adhoc contractor whether as
interim or permanent.
Nothing has been produced by the
respondent FCI to show that with the consent and knowledge of
the Regional Office at Imphal and as per the direction of the said
authority, adhoc contractor was appointed.
35.
As stated supra, by the interim order dated
28.9.2022 in W.P.(C) No.819 of 2022, this Court directed the
respondents not to finalize the tender. Similarly, by the interim
order dated 30.11.2022 in W.P.(C) No.1012 of 2022, this Court
directed the respondents not to extend the period of contract till
the next date on 20.12.2022 and the said order was thereafter
extended from time to time. When the respondent FCI filed
petitions to vacate the said interim orders in MC (WP) Nos.398
and 399 of 2022, this Court, by order dated 14.3.2023 dismissed
WP(C) No. 819 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
P a g e | 24
the petitions and against the said order, no appeal has been
preferred by the respondent FCI and allowed to attain finality.
This has been recorded only for the sake and, as stated supra,
this Court uninfluenced by the interim order dated 28.9.2022 and
the final order in the miscellaneous cases dated 14.03.2023,
considered the writ petitions and this Court finds that there is
merit in the contentions raised by the petitioner.
36.
In the result,
(i)
W.P.(C) No.819 of 2022 is allowed.
(ii)
The impugned re-tender NIT dated
29.8.2022 issued by the Regional
Office of FCI at Dimapur, Nagaland for
appointment
of
road
transport
contractor for the route Ex-Dimapur to
FSD Thoubal is quashed.
(iii)
The respondent authorities are directed
for providing reasonable allocation of
work to the petitioner in terms of the
appointment order dated 6.12.2021
within a period of two weeks from the
date of receipt of a copy of this order,
WP(C) No. 819 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
P a g e | 25
as the period in favour of the petitioner
is going to expire on 6.12.2023.
(iv)
Since the adhoc road transportation
contract from RH, Dimapur to FSD
Thoubal in favour of the private
respondent has not been extended
from 29.11.2022, W.P.(C) No.1012 of
2022 is disposed of with a direction to
the
respondent
authorities
not
to
extend the contract period in favour of
the private respondent as the contract
is subsisting in favour of the petitioner
till 6.12.2023.
(v)
There will be no order as to costs.
ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
FR/NFR
Sushil
WP(C) No. 819 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 1012 of 2022
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review