Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[1]
signed by
SHOUGRAKPA Digitally
SHOUGRAKPAM
M DEVANANDA DEVANANDA SINGH
Date: 2024.09.06 12:36:31
SINGH
+05'30'
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No. 894 of 2022
M/s Vijay Nirman Company Private Ltd., a company incorporated
under the Companies Act, 1956, represented by its authorised
representative, having its registered office at 11-9-16, Daspalla Hills,
Vishakhapatnam – 530003, Andhra Pradesh, India.
Email ID: bmuralivnc@gmail.com
... Petitioner
-VersusUnion of India, represented by the Executive Engineer, Manipur
Project Division, Central Public Works Department, Tulihal Airport,
Imphal, Manipur – 795041.
Main Office at: 14, HUDCO Vishala Building
B Wing, BhikajiCama Place
New Delhi 110066
Email ID: ddo.mcdicpwd-mn@gov.in – himanshu.mehta@gov.in
… Respondent
B E F O R E
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE AHANTHEM BIMOL SINGH
For the petitioner
::
For the respondent
::
Date of hearing
Date of judgment & order
::
::
Ms. Jyoti Mendiratta, Advocate asstd.
by Mr. T. Momo, Advocate
Mr. Kh. Samarjit, DSGI asstd. by
Mr. N. Nongdamba, Advocate
27-06-2024
06-09-2024
JUDGMENT & ORDER
[1]
Heard Ms Jyoti Mendiratta, learned counsel assisted by
Mr. T. Momo, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner and
WP(C) No. 894 of 2022
Contd…/-
[2]
Mr. Kh. Samarjit, learned DSGI assisted by Mr. N. Nongdamba, learned
counsel appearing for respondent.
The present writ petition had been filed challenging the Demand
Letter dated 20-04-2021 of the Executive Engineer, Manipur, CPWD,
Tulihal Airport, Imphal, to claim and recover from the petitioner the
alleged mobilization advance along with the interest amounting to
Rs. 17,17,91,085/- coupled with the prayer for quashing the Memorandum
dated 18-07-2022 issued by the said E.E. under Clause 29 of the General
Conditions of Contract for withholding and recovery of departmental dues
from the dues payable to the petitioner.
[2]
The brief facts of the present case are that on behalf of the
President of India, the respondent issued a Tender Notice dated
09-12-2014 along with information and instruction for bidders inviting
e-tenders from interested and eligible tenderers for construction of a
multipurpose building for the National Institute of Technology (NIT) at
Langol, Imphal. The components of work includes pile foundation, internal
water supply, sanitary installations, UG Sump, development and bulk
services, internal electrical installations, HVAC Electric Sub-station, lifts,
DG sets, fire alarm and fire fighting system.
The bids were invited by the respondent on a lumpsum basis and
the petitioner submitted lumpsum bid for all the works specified in the
tender documents altogether amounting to Rs. 2,10,22,70,513/- (Rupees
two hundred ten crores twenty two lakhs seventy thousand five hundred
WP(C) No. 894 of 2022
Contd…/-
[3]
and thirteen only) which included both civil and electrical works for the
multipurpose building at NIT on the understanding that the time frame
detailed in the tender and the contract provisions prescribed will be adhered
to by the respondent. The bid submitted by the petitioner was accepted by
the respondent and the same was communicated to the petitioner by a
letter dated 02-03-2015. Pursuant thereto, an agreement was executed
between the petitioner and the respondent for carrying out both civil and
electrical works and the stipulated time for completion of the contract work
was 730 days commencing from 24-03-2015.
[3]
Clause 10B(ii) of the General Conditions of Contract (GCC)
provides for availing mobilization advance by the Contractor not exceeding
10 percent of the tender value in the manner prescribed therein. For ready
reference, the provision of Clause 10B(ii) of the GCC is reproduced
hereinbelow:“10B(ii) Mobilization advance not exceeding 10% of the tendered value may be
given, if requested by the contractor in writing within one month of the
order to commence the work. Such advance shall be in two or more
installments to be determined by the Engineer-in-Charge at his sole
discretion. The first installment of such advance shall be released by
the Engineer-In-charge to the contractor on a request made by the
contractor to the Engineer-in-Charge in this behalf. The second and
subsequent installments shall be released by the Engineer-in-Charge
only after the contractor furnishes a proof of the satisfactory utilization
of the earlier installment to the entire satisfaction of the Engineer-inCharge.
Before any installment of advance is released, the contractor shall
execute a Bank Guarantee Bond from Scheduled Bank for the amount
equal to 110% of the amount of advance and valid for the contract
period. This (Bank Guarantee from Scheduled Bank for the amount
equal to 110% of the balance amount of advance) shall be kept renewed
WP(C) No. 894 of 2022
Contd…/-
[4]
from time to time to cover the balance amount and likely period of
complete recovery.
Provided always that provision of Clause 10B(ii) shall be applicable
only when so provided in 'Schedule F'.”
[4]
Soon after issuance of the work order, the petitioner submitted
an application dated 28-03-2015 to the Executive Engineer, Manipur
Project Division, CPWD, Imphal (hereinafter referred to as Engineer-inCharge) requesting for grant of 5 per cent mobilization advance amounting
to Rs. 10,50,00,000/-( Rupees ten crores fifty lakhs only) by submitting four
bank guarantees altogether amounting to Rs. 11,55,00,000/- (Rupees
eleven crores fifty five lakhs only) having the validity of 36 months and the
same was granted to the petitioner on 31-03-2015. There is also no dispute
with regard to the fact that the petitioner had been subsequently granted
the remaining mobilization advance and as such, the petitioner have
availed 10 per cent of the tender value of the contract, altogether amounting
to Rs. 21 crores as mobilization advance in terms of the provisions of
Clause 10B(ii) of the GCC.
[5]
The case of the petitioner is that immediately on commencement
of the work on 24-03-2015, the petitioner faced multiple hindrances on
account of infrastructural challenges at the site resulting in enlargement of
scope of work. Some of the said challenges are:a) The machinery at the construction site at NIT could not be set up
due to non-availability of transport routes that could support
the load of trucks/ tippers. The alternative route suggested by the
WP(C) No. 894 of 2022
Contd…/-
[5]
respondent was the main NIT gate, which provided restricted
access to the petitioner;
b) The architectural and structural drawings were handed over to
the petitioner only on 30-05-2015;
c) The work site remained submerged under water for more than 3
months whereafter also considerable water logging persisted at
the Construction site which made the site inaccessible and unfit
for construction work;
d) IIT Guwahati, which was required to test the materials from the
construction site, which were crucial to continuation of work, did
not give the reports promptly; and
e) The nature of the soil was very weak, the water table was
extremely high which caused the soil to be looser and made
piling very difficult, requiring 50-55% more concrete and that due
to the high-water table, a permanent liner in the soil was
recommended by the Petitioner to be installed to maintain
integrity, however, the Respondent failed to address the said
concern.
[6]
It is also the case of the petitioner that despite challenges and
difficulties faced by the petitioner, it continued with executing the contract
work and completed a substantial portion of the work and submitted seven
RA Bills for a net amount of Rs. 27 crores which are as under:-
WP(C) No. 894 of 2022
Contd…/-
[6]
RA Bill
No.
Submission
date
Amount raised
Amount paid
RA Bill
No. 1
30.03.2015
Rs. 10,50,00,000/- as
mobilization advance
Paid full amount
40-43
of W.P.
RA Bill
No. 2
07.09.2015
Rs. 10,50,00,000/- as
mobilization advance
Paid full amount
53-56
of W.P.
RA Bill
No. 3
17.12.2015
Rs. 8,00,52,429/-
Paid 7,63,85,750/-
57-59
of W.P.
RA Bill
No. 4
12.02.2016
Rs. 7,72,79,816/-
Paid full amount
64-69
of W.P.
RA Bill
No. 5
07.03.2016
Rs. 5,05,37,124/-
Paid Rs. 4,33,08,901/-
72-77
of W.P.
RA Bill
No. 6
30.03.2016
Rs. 7,00,64,508/-
No payment received
82-84
of W.P.
RA Bill
No. 7
06.06.2016
ADJUSTED MOB.
ADVANCE
Rs. 5,17,58,357/-
No payment received
ADJUSTED MOB.
Pages
91-96
of WP
ADVANCE
[7]
It is also the case of the petitioner that the petitioner sent multiple
letters and representations to the respondent seeking release of the funds
withheld against work done since February, 2016 and that it was facing a
serious cash flow constraint which affected the payments to vendors,
procurement of materials and labour, etc. The petitioner also incurred
an unstipulated cost on account of requirements of excess concrete and
therefore, it faced financial hindrances. The petitioner stated that the
respondent had merely paid a sum of Rs. 13,69,00,000/- (Rupees thirteen
crore sixty nine lakhs only) as against the work done for a value of
Rs. 36,87,00,000/- (Rupees thirty six crores eighty seven lakhs only). It has
also been stated that due to local bandhs and strikes, frequent closure of
highways and inclement weather conditions, the petitioner faced immense
loss of work and materials and on account of stoppage of work due to
WP(C) No. 894 of 2022
Contd…/-
[7]
non-availability of funds owing to non-release of payments by the
respondent, the petitioner also incurred idle charges.
[8]
It is also the case of the petitioner that the respondent accepted
and acknowledged that the respondent had not cleared the dues of the
petitioner pertaining to the period of February, 2016 to 15-05-2016 but
sought to justify the non-payment alleging non-deposit of funds by the NIT,
however, the respondent undertook to defray the same fully in the first
week of September, 2016 on disbursement of funds by NIT. The petitioner
stated that the respondent sought to undermine the financial constraints
being faced by the petitioner by claiming that part payment of running bills
was sufficient to deal with the difficulties faced by the petitioner. It is the
case of the petitioner that in response to the various claims made by the
petitioner, the respondent stated that bandhs were common in the area
and necessary hindrances in relation thereto had been recorded in the
hindrances register thereby acknowledging the same as one of the reasons
for delay in completion of work. It has also been stated that the respondent
accepted and acknowledged that the inclement weather was the primary
reason the site become unworkable and work could not proceed. However,
the respondent arbitrarily held that no idle overheads were to be granted
and the respondent also categorically refused to reimburse the additional
cost of the extra concrete borne by the petitioner. Subsequently, the
respondent unilaterally issued an order dated 03-10-2016 directing that
no further work should be executed on the project site till further orders
and the reasons given for issuing the suspension order was due to
WP(C) No. 894 of 2022
Contd…/-
[8]
non-depositing of project funds and some administrative reasons informed
by the NIT, Imphal.
[9]
Later on, the Engineer-in-Charge issued a Memorandum by
which it was intimated that due to administrative reasons, it has been
decided by the competent authority to foreclose the NIT Project work under
CPWD and also requesting the petitioner to contact the Engineer-in-Charge
for joint measurement of unpaid works so that necessary formalities can be
completed for closure. Thereafter, the Engineer-in-Charge issued a letter
dated 13-02-2017 for closing the contract work on ground of large scale
change in scope of work due to poor soil condition and abnormal increase
in cost, however, on the next date i.e., on 14-02-2017, the Engineer-inCharge issued another Memorandum withdrawing the said foreclosure
letter dated 13-02-2017. After the withdrawal of the foreclosure letter, the
respondent granted extension of time upto 31-12-2017 for completion of the
work, however, the work remained suspended on account of non-deposit
of funds by the NIT and lack of any further instructions by the respondent.
[10]
It is also the case of the petitioner that to the utter shock of the
petitioner, the respondent issued a letter dated 18-12-2019 by way of which,
the respondent sought to foreclose the work under Clause 13 of the GCC,
however, the respondent acknowledged that the work had been stopped
for approximately three years due to non-payment of funds by the NIT
resulting in foreclosure of the work. The petitioner submitted that joint
measurement of the work was conducted in February, 2020, whereafter,
WP(C) No. 894 of 2022
Contd…/-
[9]
the respondent unilaterally and illegally raised and certified the final eight
Running Account Bills on 19-04-2021 without any audit of the work
executed in terms of the joint measurement and without any reconciliation
of accounts. Thereafter, the respondent issued the impugned Demand
Letter dated 20-04-2021 demanding recovery of mobilization advance to
the tune of Rs. 8,68,23,060/- (Rupees eight crores sixty eight lakhs twenty
three thousands and sixty only), secure advance for an amount of
Rs. 86,91,829/- (Rupees eighty six lakhs ninety one thousand eight
hundred and twenty nine only) and interest on mobilization advance
amounting to Rs. 7,62,76,196/- (Rupees seven crores sixty two lakhs
seventy six thousand one hundred and ninety six only). In the said Demand
Letter, the petitioner was given an ultimatum by the respondent that in
the event of non-payment of the demanded amount, the same would be
recovered from other works being carried out by the petitioner as per
Clause 29 of the GCC. Thereafter, the respondent issued the impugned
Memorandum dated 18-07-2022 for withholding the demanded amount
from the dues payable to the petitioner in connection with any other contract
works.
[11]
The learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that recovery of
the mobilization advance and/or interest thereon cannot be made by the
respondent as provided under Clause 10B(iv) of the GCC for the reason
that Clause 10B(iv) pre-supposes complete execution of the work and
recovery of the entire mobilization advance by the time 80 per cent of the
gross value of the contract is executed and as such, it has no application in
WP(C) No. 894 of 2022
Contd…/-
[10]
the present case when the work was suspended and finally foreclosed on
the direction of the respondent and was not allowed to be fully executed.
[12]
It has also been submitted that, in such a situation, the manner
of recovery of the mobilization advance is governed as per the mode
prescribed by Clause 13 of the GCC. Clause 13 of the GCC, inter alia,
provides that after abandonment of the work, the Contractor is entitled to
be paid at contract rates, full amount of works executed at site and in
addition, a reasonable amount to be certified by the Engineer-in-Charge
for the items mentioned therein which could not be utilised on the work to
the full extent in lieu of the foreclosure. It has further been submitted that
Clause 13 categorically stipulates that it is only after such determination
and against any payment found due to the Contractor, the Engineer-inCharge is entitled to recover or be credited with any outstanding balance
due from the Contractor including towards mobilization advance.
[13]
The learned counsel also submitted that in the present case, the
petitioner has made certain claims and notified the respondent that in the
event of non-settlement of dues, the matter will be treated as a dispute and
that since the claims made by the petitioner has not been settled by the
respondent, the dispute is pending for settlement before the arbitration
proceedings as provided under Clause 25 of the GCC. The learned counsel
further submitted that unless and until the dispute is settled as provided
under Clause 25 of the GCC, the respondent cannot take any action for
recovery of the mobilization advance from the petitioner. It has also been
WP(C) No. 894 of 2022
Contd…/-
[11]
submitted that the demand raised by the respondent by way of impugned
Demand Letter dated 20-04-2021 and impugned internal Memorandum
dated 18-07-2022 purporting to recover the alleged departmental dues
from the petitioner and directing the Chief Engineers/ Superintending
Engineers of the Department to withhold the payments pursuant to different
agreements entered with the petitioner in order to recover the alleged dues
of Rs. 18,18,05,473/- is illegal, arbitrary, unreasonable and contrary to the
principle of natural justice. As such, the said impugned Demand Letter and
the impugned Memorandum are liable to be quash and set aside.
[14]
It has also been submitted that invocation of Clause 29 of the
GCC is manifestly based on illegal and untenable demand, the same having
been arrived at without first computing the sums due to the petitioner under
various acts in terms of Clause 13 of the GCC. The learned counsel also
submitted that while dealing with the similar facts, the Hon'ble Delhi High
Court in the case of "Shapoorji Pallonji & Co. Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Union of
India" reported in 2018 SCC Online Del. 12911 held that invocation of
Clause 29 to be illegal by observing that the provision of Clause 29(ii) have
to be read in conjunction with Clause 29(i) and that in terms of the said
sub-clause (ii), if, as a result of audit and technical examination, any sum
was found to be overpaid in respect of the work done or the work claimed
to have been done and found not to have been executed, the Contractor is
liable to refund the same. It has been forcefully submitted by the learned
counsel that in the present case, as no audit of work or accounts have been
WP(C) No. 894 of 2022
Contd…/-
[12]
done finding any sum to be due, the invocation of Clause 29 is manifestly
illegal and unsustainable.
[15]
The learned counsel lastly submitted that the withholding of
the above-mentioned amount from the dues payable to the petitioner in
pursuance to the impugned Memorandum is ex-facie without legal authority
inasmuch as, in accordance with Clause 29 of the GCC, assuming without
admitting that the same can be invoked at all, the Engineer-in-Charge or
the Government is entitled to withhold and have a lien to retain to the extent
of claimed amount from any sum payable to the Contractor under the same
contract or any other Contract with the Engineer-in-Charge of the
Government. The Engineer-in-Charge has been defined in Clause 2(v) of
the GCC to mean the Engineer officer who shall supervise and be in-charge
of the work and who shall sign the contract on behalf of the President
of India as mentioned in Scheduled F. Therefore, Clause 29 has no
application in the present case as the petitioner has no other contract with
the Engineer-in-Charge of the instant contract.
[16]
Mr. Kh. Samarjit, learned DSGI appearing for the respondent
submitted that the contract was foreclosed under Clause 13 of the GCC
due to lack of funds and non-deposition of amount by the NIT, the client of
the project and that after foreclosure of the work, joint measurements were
conducted at the site in the presence of the petitioner's representative.
Thereafter, the final bill was prepared and passed based on the joint
measurements. It has also been submitted that after finalizing the final bill,
WP(C) No. 894 of 2022
Contd…/-
[13]
it was found out that some amounts from the petitioner, such as mobilization
advance along with interest needs to be recovered as per the provisions of
the agreement and Clause 10B(iv) of the GCC. Accordingly, deductions
were made from the bills payable to the petitioner in accordance with the
contractual provisions.
[17]
It has also been submitted that even after such deduction, it was
found out that some amount of the mobilization advance along with interest
still needs to be recovered from the petitioner and as such, the impugned
demand Letter dated 20-04-2021 had been issued requesting the petitioner
to deposit the outstanding balance amount within 15 days with the
ultimatum that in the event of failure to deposit the amount, the same will
be recovered from other works carried out by the petitioner as per Clause
29 of the General Conditions of Contract (GCC). When the petitioner failed
to deposit the said amount, the impugned Memorandum was issued for
withholding the demanded amount from dues payable to the petitioner as
provided under Clause 29 of the GCC, which allowed the respondent to
withhold or retain any sum of money due to the petitioner under any contract
with the Government until the dispute is settled by arbitration or court.
[18]
It has also been submitted that restricted meaning should not be
given to the word ‘Engineer-in-Charge and the Government’, rather normal
and general meaning should be adhered thereto and that on general
reading of Clause 29(ii) of GCC as well as from operandi modus of Clause
29 of the CPWD, it is unambiguous that Engineer-in-Charge can withheld
WP(C) No. 894 of 2022
Contd…/-
[14]
any amount from dues of any company working under CPWD from
different divisions/ branches as the authorities, while dealing with public
money, cannot be rendered remediless. It has also been submitted that
the impugned Memorandum is an internal document and was circulated
within the Department and that no amount has yet been withheld by the
Department and it is only in the process of ascertaining whether any money
are lying due to be paid to the petitioner. The learned counsel submitted
that the dispute resolution is under process and all claims will be
adjudicated upon and settled as provided under Clause 25 of the GCC and
pending such resolution, resorting to the present proceedings under Article
226 of the Constitution of India is highly misconceived and misplaced. The
learned counsel, accordingly, prays for dismissing the present writ petition.
[19]
I have heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties at
length and considered their submissions. The admitted facts in the present
case are that the petitioner availed mobilization advance of Rs. 21 crores
as provided under Clause 10B(ii) of the GCC and the petitioner executed
some portion of the contract work. The petitioner had also submitted seven
Running Account Bills and out of which, the respondent released the bills
amount in respect of RA Bills No. 1 to 5. It is also an admitted fact that the
respondent suspended the work by issuing an order dated 03-10-2016 on
account of alleged administrative reasons and non-deposit of funds by the
NIT. After suspending the execution of the contract work for about three
years, the respondent ultimately foreclosed the work under Clause 13 of
WP(C) No. 894 of 2022
Contd…/-
[15]
the GCC by issuing an order dated 18-12-2019 due to non-deposit of funds
by the NIT. Thereafter, the respondent unilaterally prepared the final bill.
[20]
The mode of recovery of the mobilization advance is provided
under Clause 10B(iv) of the GCC, which reads as under:“(iv) The mobilization advance and plant and machinery advance in (ii) &
(iii) above bear simple interest at the rate of 10 per cent per annum and
shall be calculated from the date of payment to the date of recovery,
both days inclusive, on the outstanding amount of advance. Recovery
of such sums advanced shall be made by the deduction from the
contractors bills commencing after first ten per cent of the gross value
of the work is executed and paid, on pro-rata percentage basis to the
gross value of the work billed beyond 10% in such a way that the entire
advance is recovered by the time eighty per cent of the gross value of
the contract is executed and paid, together with interest due on the
entire outstanding amount up to the date of recovery of the
installment."
[21]
The respondent withheld the bill amount in respect of RA Bills
No. 6 and 7 and the final bill prepared by the respondent and adjusted the
said bill amount by way of recovery of the mobilization advance as provided
under Clause 10B (iv) of the GCC. Thereafter, the respondent issued the
impugned Letter dated 20-04-2021 requesting the petitioner to deposit the
amount of Rs. 17,17,91,085/- as balance due amount of the outstanding
mobilization advance, which also include interest of the mobilization
advance. When the petitioner failed to deposit the said balance amount of
the the mobilization advance, the respondent issued the impugned
Memorandum dated 18-07-2022 for withholding the said balance
mobilization advance from any dues payable to the petitioner by invoking
the provisions of Clause 29 of the GCC.
WP(C) No. 894 of 2022
Contd…/-
[16]
[22]
It is the case of the respondent that as the petitioner had availed
mobilization advance and as the total amount of the mobilization advance
has not been fully recovered, the respondent is entitled to recover the
balance amount of the mobilization advance from the petitioner along with
interest in terms of the contract agreement and as such, no illegality has
been committed in issuing the impugned Demand Letter as well as the
impugned Memorandum. On the other hand, the case of the petitioner is
that there was no delay on its part in executing the contact work and the
delay was solely attributable to the respondent and as such, the petitioner
is not liable to pay interest. It is also the case of the petitioner that the
execution of the work was suspended by the respondent on ground of nondeposit of the funds by the NIT and after suspending the work for about
three years, the respondent unilaterally foreclosed the work under Clause
13 of the GCC for the same reason the work was initially suspended. It is
also the case of the petitioner that if the respondent have to foreclose the
contract work on ground of non-release of funds by NIT, the respondent
ought to have done the same at the time of issuing the suspension order
instead of waiting for three years, which resulted in incurring losses to the
petitioner.
[23]
It is an undisputed fact that the petitioner have raised certain
claims against the respondent and the respondent have also raised certain
claims against the petitioner and that the process for settlement of the
dispute amongst the parties in terms of Clause 25 of the GCC is pending.
It is also an admitted fact that there has been no audit of the work executed
WP(C) No. 894 of 2022
Contd…/-
[17]
in terms of joint measurements and no reconciliation of the accounts. In
such a situation, the question which arose for consideration is whether the
respondent can unilaterally issue the impugned Letter dated 20-04-2021
demanding the alleged balance amount of mobilization advance from the
petitioner and also to issue the impugned Memorandum dated 18-07-2022
for withholding the said balance amount of mobilization advance from any
dues payable to the petitioner by invoking the provisions of Clause 29 of
the GCC.
[24]
As the full amount of the mobilization advance was not recovered
from the petitioner as provided under Clause 10B(iv) of the GCC on account
of foreclosure of the work by the respondent, there is now no possibility of
recovering the alleged balance amount of mobilization advance from the
petitioner as provided under Clause 10B(iv) of the GCC. In such a situation,
the only remedy available to the respondent under the contract agreement
for recovery of the said balance amount from the petitioner is as provided
under Clause 13 of the GCC. Clause 13 of the GCC, inter alia, provides
that against any payment due to the Contractor as provided under the said
Clause 13 or otherwise, the Engineer-in-Charge shall be entitled to recover
or be credited with any outstanding balances due from the Contractor for
advance paid in respect of any tools, plants and materials and any other
sums which at the date of termination were recoverable by the Government
from the Contractor under the terms of the contract.
WP(C) No. 894 of 2022
Contd…/-
[18]
[25]
In my considered view, such recovery as provided under Clause
13 can be made only after final settlement of the amount due payable to
the petitioner as provided under the said clause. In the present case, the
dispute with regard to the claims made by the respondent against the
petitioner and the counter claims made by the petitioner against the
respondent is pending for settlement in terms of Clause 25 of the GCC and
as such, it will not be wrong to arrive at a conclusion that no final settlement
has been made as yet with regard to either any dues payable to the
petitioner or any balance amount which is recoverable from the petitioner.
Accordingly, this court is of the considered view that the respondent cannot
initiate recovery of any balance amount from the petitioner as provided
under Clause 13. In the result, it is hereby held that the impugned Letter
dated 20-04-2021 had been issued by the respondent without any authority
of law and in violation of the contract agreement and the same is not
sustainable and liable to be quashed and set aside.
[26]
So far as the impugned Memorandum dated 18-07-2022 is
concerned, this court is of the considered view that the said Memorandum
is also not sustainable and deserves to be quashed and set aside for the
following reasons:(i) As this court had held that the impugned Letter dated 20-04-2021
demanding for recovery of the alleged outstanding balance
amount of mobilization advance from the petitioner is not
sustainable in the eyes of law, there is no question of withholding
WP(C) No. 894 of 2022
Contd…/-
[19]
the said outstanding balance amount of mobilization advance
from any dues payable to the petitioner by invoking Clause 29 of
the GCC.
(ii) Clause 29 of the GCC, inter alia, specifically provides that the
Government shall be entitled to withhold and have a lien to
retain any claimed amount against the Contractor from any sum
payable to the said Contractor under the same contract or any
other contract with the Engineer-in-Charge. Accordingly, in my
considered view, the Government can only withhold the claimed
amount against the petitioner from any sum payable to the
petitioner under the present contract or any other contract with
the same Engineer-in-Charge. In the present case, it has been
submitted by the parties that there is no other contract executed
by the petitioner under the same Engineer-in-Charge and as
such, the provisions of Clause 29 cannot be involved in the
present case.
[27]
In view of the facts and circumstances of the present case and
for the findings and reasons given hereinabove, this court is of the
considered view that the petitioner has made out a strong case for
interfering with the impugned demand Letter and the impugned
Memorandum. Accordingly, the present writ petition is allowed by quashing
and setting aside the impugned demand Letter dated 20-04-2021 and the
impugned Memorandum dated 18-07-2022. However, it is made clear that
WP(C) No. 894 of 2022
Contd…/-
[20]
the respondent is at liberty to initiate recovery of any outstanding amount
of mobilization advance from the petitioner in terms of any remedy as
available under the contract agreement.
With the aforesaid direction, the present wit petition is disposed
of. Parties are to bear their own cost.
JUDGE
FR / NFR
Devananda
WP(C) No. 894 of 2022
Contd…/-
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review