The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
12. 01.2023 (Annexure-12) may be set aside. [6] Learned counsel for the State has opposed the prayer. He relies upon the averments made in the counter affidavit to justify the cancellation of letter of acceptance and letter for commencement of work on the ground that the Tender Evaluation Committee reviewed the decision of the 1st meeting of the committee recommending the petitioner as the lowest tenderer as the papers submitted by the petitioner along with his tender documents indicated that there were no valid copy of enlistment of appropriate class registered with PWD /TTAADC /MES /CPWD/ Railway/ Govt. Organization of other State and Central that was issued in favour of M/S United Construction i.e. the petitioner. He has been requested to submit those shortfall documents i.e. enlistment of appropriate class registered with either of the aforesaid authorities in his favour by 25.01.2023 positively for finalization of the tender vide letter dated 12.01.2023 (Annexure-13). Learned counsel for the respondent has also sought to raise a plea that the letter for commencement of work was never communicated to the petitioner. [7] Learned counsel for the petitioner, however, submits that the aforesaid plea is factually incorrect. If the letter for commencement of work was only lying in the official files and never issued in favour of the petitioner, there was no occasion to issue a corrig…
889. The aforesaid decision lays down the ratio that a concluded contract could come into existence only upon communication of the decision of acceptance of the offer by the employer. In the absence of such a communication, the correspondence made internally between the officials of the employer department could not result in any concluded contract between the parties. [9] In the present case, the situation is otherwise. Upon a conscious decision of the competent authority, letter of acceptance and letter for commencement of work has been issued in favour of the petitioner. The contents of the letter of acceptance have been referred to in the foregoing paragraph which clearly indicates that it would amount to a legally binding contract between the petitioner and the Government of Tripura. Once a legally binding contract came into existence, the respondents could not have revoked it or cancelled it without proper notice. The plea of the respondents that the bid documents of the petitioner suffered from certain shortfall documents which led to review of the earlier decision of the Tender Evaluation Committee would not amount to clothing them with a right to revoke the legally binding contract between the parties without even an opportunity of show-cause to the petitioner. [10] In such circumstance, we are left with no option but to quash the corrigendum dated 12.01.2023 (Annexure-12).…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
_A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A_
WP(C) No.565 of 2023
M/S United Construction
...... Petitioner(s)
VERSUS
State of Tripura and others
..…. Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. T.D. Majumder, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. Tapash Halam, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. Karnajit De, Addl. G.A.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
=O=R=D=E=R=
22.05.2024
Heard Mr. T.D. Majumder, learned senior counsel assisted by
Mr. Tapash Halam, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner. Also heard
Mr. Karnajit De, learned Additional Government appearing for the Staterespondents.
[2]
A letter of acceptance (LOA) was issued on 6th December, 2022
(Annexure-8) by the Executive Engineer, Sonamura Division, PWD (R&B),
Sepahijala, Tripura in favour of the petitioner on acceptance of his tender, on
behalf of the Governor of Tripura at the quoted tendered amount of
Rs.2,40,81,067.00 which was 2.70% below the estimated cost of tender of
Rs.2,47,49,298.00 under a DNIT No.86/CE/PWD(R&B)/SE (P&DU)/202223 dated 28th September, 2022 in respect of the work of strengthening of
road from Mayarani to Bgamara (upto Melaghar-Bishramganj road) under
Sonamura Constituency Assembly (L-5.80 km). There were two bidders in
the fray in which the petitioner turned out to be successful. Petitioner was
asked to submit the performance guarantee of Rs.12,04,053/- within 10 days
i.e. 16th December, 2022 which was submitted on 17th December, 2022. The
letter also indicated that on receipt of the prescribed performance guarantee,
necessary letter to commence the work shall be issued and the site of work
will be handed over to the petitioner thereafter. The letter further indicated
that this notification concludes the legally binding contract between the
petitioner and the Government of Tripura till issue of a formal contract.
Upon submission of the performance guarantee the letter for commencement
of work was issued in favour of the petitioner on 21st December, 2022
(Annexure-10) by the same Executive Engineer. The contents of the letter
for commencement of work once again indicates the nature of work, the
estimated work put to tender, the quoted tender value, the percentage of rate
and time for completion i.e. 360 days. Petitioner was requested to contact the
SDO, PWD(R&B), Melaghar Sub-Division for taking possession of work
site and starting the work at once. In continuance of the letters referred to
above, he was requested to attend the office of the Executive Engineer to
complete the formal agreement within 7 days from the date of issue of this
letter. It was further indicated that the LOA will be a part of the agreement.
[3]
Petitioner claimed to have commenced the work but was
surprised to receive the corrigendum issued by the same officer on 12th
January, 2023 by which the letter of acceptance dated 6th December, 2022
and letter for commencement of work dated 21st December, 2023 were
cancelled. The corrigendum at (Annexure 12) is reproduced hereunder:
“Government of Tripura
Office of the Executive Engineer
Sonamura Division, PWD(R&B)
Sonamura, Sepahijala Tripura
CORRIGENDUM
As per recommendation of the Techinical/Financial Bid Evaluation Committee of
PWD(R&B) in the 2nd meeting held on 5th December, 2022 at 11.00 AM in the
chamber of the Chief Engineer, PWD(R&B), Tripura for Re-Evaluation of the
Technical/Financial Bid and review of the earlier technical/Financial Bid in the 1 st
meeting of the committee communicated vide No.F.29(4)-ACE(P&DU)PWD(R&B)-2022/5341-44 dt.03.12.2022 for the work “Strengthening of road
from Mayarani to Bgamara (upto melaghar-Bishramganj road) under Sonamura
Constituency Assembly (L-5.80 km)”. vide DNIeT No.86/CE/PWD (R&B)/SE
(P&DU)/2022-23 PNIeT No: 18/EE/SNM/PWD/2022-23, Dt. 28-09-2022
Circulated Memo No. F.10(17)/EE/SNM/PWD/3910-82, Dt. 28.09.2022. Tender
ID: 2022_CEPWD_32587_1.
On review of the decision of the 1st meeting of the committee and after reevaluation of the tenders it has been decided by the committee to cancel earlier
decision communicated on 03.12.2022 recommending lowest tender of M/S
United construction for acceptance by the competent authority.
Therefore, the Letter of Acceptance (LOA) which was issued vide this office letter
No. F.10(19)/EE/SNM/PWD/5808-14 dt. 06.12.2022 and Letter for
Commencement of Work vide No. F.10(30)/EE/SNM/PWD/6344-58, dt.
21.12.2022 are hereby CANCELLED.
S/d
(Er. S. Paul)
Executive Engineer
Sonamura Division, PWD(R&B)
Sonamura, Sepahijala, Tripura.”
[4]
The challenge to the cancellation of letter of acceptance and
letter for commencement of work by the petitioner is based primarily on lack
of any show-cause notice when as per the terms of the LOA and letter for
commencement of work the LOA amounted to a legally binding contract
between the petitioner and the Government of Tripura.
[5]
It is submitted by learned counsel for the petitioner that the
impugned decision is in violation of principles of natural justice since
adverse consequences flow out of cancellation of a legally binding contract
between the petitioner on issuance of the letter of acceptance which vested a
legal right in favour of the petitioner. In support of his contention, learned
counsel for the petitioner relies upon a decision of the Apex Court in case of
State of Uttar Pradesh versus Sudhir Kumar Singh and others, reported in
(2021) 19 SCC 706. He has also relied upon a decision of this Court in
WP(C) No.455 of 2023 dated 21.08.2023. For the purposes of demonstrating
the ingredients of a proper show-cause notice, he relies upon a decision of
the Apex Court in case of Gorkha Security Services versus Government
(NCT of Delhi) and others, reported in (2014) 9 SCC 105. Learned counsel
for the petitioner submits that having submitted performance guarantee and
having invested funds and also started execution of the work, cancellation of
the contract without proper show-cause notice is arbitrary and violation of
principles of natural justice. Therefore, the impugned corrigendum dated
12.01.2023 (Annexure-12) may be set aside.
[6]
Learned counsel for the State has opposed the prayer. He relies
upon the averments made in the counter affidavit to justify the cancellation
of letter of acceptance and letter for commencement of work on the ground
that the Tender Evaluation Committee reviewed the decision of the 1st
meeting of the committee recommending the petitioner as the lowest
tenderer as the papers submitted by the petitioner along with his tender
documents indicated that there were no valid
copy of enlistment of
appropriate class registered with PWD /TTAADC /MES /CPWD/ Railway/
Govt. Organization of other State and Central that was issued in favour of
M/S United Construction i.e. the petitioner. He has been requested to submit
those shortfall documents i.e. enlistment of appropriate class registered with
either of the aforesaid authorities in his favour by 25.01.2023 positively for
finalization of the tender vide letter dated 12.01.2023 (Annexure-13).
Learned counsel for the respondent has also sought to raise a plea that the
letter for commencement of work was never communicated to the petitioner.
[7]
Learned counsel for the petitioner, however, submits that the
aforesaid plea is factually incorrect. If the letter for commencement of work
was only lying in the official files and never issued in favour of the
petitioner, there was no occasion to issue a corrigendum to cancel the letter
of acceptance and the letter for commencement of work vide impugned
corrigendum dated 12.01.2023 (Annexure-12). Moreover, petitioner had
submitted the performance guarantee and started execution of the work as
the LOA clearly showed that it was a legally binding contract.
[8]
We have considered the submissions of learned counsel for the
parties and gone through the materials on record. In the canvas of the brief
facts narrated hereinabove, the only issue which requires answer is whether
after issuance of the letter of acceptance and letter for commencement of
work in favour of the petitioner, „the legally binding contract‟ which came
into existence created a vested legal right in favour of the petitioner which
could not have been cancelled without a proper show-cause notice. In this
regard, reliance is placed upon a decision of the Apex Court in case of
Haridwar Singh v. Bagun Sumbrui and Others reported in (1973) 3 SCC
889. The aforesaid decision lays down the ratio that a concluded contract
could come into existence only upon communication of the decision of
acceptance of the offer by the employer. In the absence of such a
communication, the correspondence made internally between the officials of
the employer department could not result in any concluded contract between
the parties.
[9]
In the present case, the situation is otherwise. Upon a conscious
decision of the competent authority, letter of acceptance and letter for
commencement of work has been issued in favour of the petitioner. The
contents of the letter of acceptance have been referred to in the foregoing
paragraph which clearly indicates that it would amount to a legally binding
contract between the petitioner and the Government of Tripura. Once a
legally binding contract came into existence, the respondents could not have
revoked it or cancelled it without proper notice. The plea of the respondents
that the bid documents of the petitioner suffered from certain shortfall
documents which led to review of the earlier decision of the Tender
Evaluation Committee would not amount to clothing them with a right to
revoke the legally binding contract between the parties without even an
opportunity of show-cause to the petitioner.
[10]
In such circumstance, we are left with no option but to quash
the corrigendum dated 12.01.2023 (Annexure-12). However, liberty is
reserved with the respondents to take a fresh decision, in accordance with
law, after due opportunity to the petitioner to show-cause within a
reasonable time.
[11]
The writ petition is allowed in the manner and to the extent
indicated above. Let it be made clear that we have not made any comments
on the merits of the case.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
(ARINDAM LODH), J
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
Dipesh
SIDDHARTHA LODH LODH
Date: 2024.05.24 15:56:18 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review