Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
WP No. 34048 of 2024
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
Reserved on
06.07.2026
Pronounced on
31.08.2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MR JUSTICE KRISHNAN RAMASAMY
WP Nos. 34048 & 38692 of 2024 & 47016 of 2025
36863, 36864, 41880, 41881, 41882 of 2024,
52527, 52530 & 52531 of 2025
WP.No.34048 of 2024
M/s.Gestione Consulting India Private Limited
Formerly Rangaswamy Naidu Orchards Pvt Ltd,
Rep By Its Director, A.P.Ramachndran
New No.8, Old No.34, Dhamu Nagar,
Coimbatore- 641 045.
..Petitioner(s)
Vs
1. Union Of India
Rep By Its Ministry Of Defence
Defence Estate Office, Madras Circle,
306 Anna Salai, Teynampet, Chennai.
2. The District Collector
Coimbatore District, Collectorate Office,
State Bank Road, Gopalapuram,
Coimbatore- 641 018.
3. Revenue Divisional Officer
Coimbatore South, State Bank Road,
Gopalapuram, Coimbatore- 641 018.
4. The Sub Registrar,
Madukarai, Coimbatore.
(r4-suo Motu Impleaded As Per Order Dated
12.12.2024 In Wp.34048/2024 By Ptaj)
__________
Page1 of 47
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 34048 of 2024
5. Siddarth,
S/o.Sathyanarayana, No.273, G.V.Residency,
Sowripalayam, Coimbatore.641 028.
(r5-impleaded As Per Order Dated 13.03.2025
In Wmp.41983/2024 In Wp.34048/2024)
6. The Executive Engineer,
Operation And Maintenance,
Distribution Circle, South,
Tamil Nadu Power Distribution Corporation
Ltd, Coimbatore. 641 008.
(r6-impleaded As Per Order Dated 13.03.2025
In Wmp.5059/2025)
7. E.Sathyanarayana, S/o.Ethirajalu Naidu
8. S.Shilpa, D/o.Sathyanarayana
R7 & 8 residing at
New No.19, Old.No.94, AB Block, 1st Street,
Anna Nagar, Chennai 600 040
[r7 & 8 impleaded as per order dated
31.08.2026 passed in WMP.NO.7793 of 2026]
..Respondent(s)
WP No. 38692 of 2024
Aged Home Trust
Rep. By Its Manager
K.M.Venkatachalam,
No.1-A/5, Srinivasa Nagar,
Podanur, Coimbatore-641 023.
..Petitioner(s)
Vs
1. Commissioner Of Land Administration
Ezhilagam, Chepauk, Chennai-600 005.
2. District Revenue Officer,
Coimbatore-641 018.
3. Revenue Divisional Officer,
Coimbatore South, Coimbatore-6411 018.
__________
Page2 of 47
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 34048 of 2024
4. Tahsildar
Office Of The Tahsildar,
Madukarai Taluk,
(previously Coimbatore South Taluk)
Coimbatore641 105.
5. District Collector
Coimbatore-641 018.
6. Union Of India
Rep. By Ministry Of Defence,
Defence Estate Officer, Madras Circle,
306, Anna Salai, Teynampet,
Chennai-600 018.
7. The Executive Engineer,
Operation And Maintenance,
Distribution Circle, South,
Tamil Nadu Power Distribution
Corporation Ltd, Coimbatore. 641 008.
(r7-impleaded As Per Order Dated 13.03.2025
In Wmp.5060/2025 In Wp.38692/2024)
..Respondent(s)
WP No. 47016 of 2025
M/s.Tarun Residency Welfare Association (reg)
Rep. By Its President
Devaraj S/o.Seerangan,
Site No.294, Tarun Residency,
Eachanari (po), Coimbatore-641 021.
..Petitioner(s)
Vs
1. Union Of India
Rep. By Its Ministry Of Defence,
Defence Estate Office, Madras Circle
306, Anna Salai, Teynampet,
Chennai-600 018.
2. Commissioner Of Land Administration,
Ezhilagam, Chepauk, Chennai-600 005.
__________
Page3 of 47
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 34048 of 2024
3. The District Collector
Coimbatore District, Collectorate Office,
State Bank Road, Gopalapuram,
Coimbatore-641 018.
4. District Revenue Officer
Coimbatore District, Coimbatore-641 018.
5. Revenue Divisional Officer,
Coimbatore South, Coimbatore 641 018
6. Tahsildar
Office Of The Tahsildar,
Madukarai Taluk,
(previously Coimbatore South Taluk)
Coimbatore-641 105.
7. Sub Registrar
Madukarai, Coimbatore.
8. The Executive Enginer
Operation And Maintenance,
Distribution Circle South,
Tamil Nadu Power Distribution Corporation
Ltd., Coimbatore-641 008.
..Respondent(s)
Common Prayer:
Writ petitions filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, praying
to issue a Writ of Certiorari,
to call for the records of the proceedings No. Ref. No. 5519/ 2024 /
B2 dated 17.10.2024 on the file of the 3rd respondent and quash the same as
illegal and without jurisdiction
Calling for the records of the 3rd respondent dated 17.10.2024
bearing reference No.5519/2024/B2 and quash the same and consequently direct
the 2nd respondent to issue patta in favour of the petitioner for the lands in
S.No.603/1B, 603/3B1 and 603/3A1 altogether admeasuring an extent of 13.27
__________
Page4 of 47
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 34048 of 2024
Acres in Kurichi Village, Coimbatore South Taluk, Coimbatore District, with a
further direction to the respondents 1-5 to mutate all revenue records in favour
of the petitioner
Calling for the records of the 4th respondent dated 17.10.2024
bearing reference No.5519/2024/B2 and quash the same and consequently direct
the 3rd respondent to issue patta in favour of the Members of petitioner
Association for the lands situated within S.No.603/5, 603/3B and 603/A, 604/3,
604/4A, 605/1A, 606/1B and 606/4 in Kurichi Village, Coimbatore south Taluk,
Coimbatore District
For Petitioner(s):
Mr.Sharath Chandran in WP.No.34048 of 2024
Mr.Sathish Parasaran, Sr. counsel
for Mr.Rahul Balaji in WP.No.38692 of 2024
Mr.P.Premkumar in WP.No.47016 of 2025
For Respondent(s):
Mr.AR.L.Sundaresan,
Additional Solicitor General,
Asst. by Mr.J.Madhanagopal Rao, SPC
for R1 in WP.No.34048 & R6 in 38692 of 2024
Mr.T.Gowthaman,
Additional Advocate General,
Asst. by Mr.B.Pachaiyappan, Govt. counsel,
for R2 & 3 in WP.No.34048 of 2024
for R2 to 6 in WP.No.47016 of 2025
for R2 to 5 in WP.No.38692 of 2024
Mr.Vijay Narayan, Advocate General,
Asst.by Mr.D.R.Arunkumar, St.counsel
for R6 in WP.No.34048 of 2024 &
for R8 in WP.No.47016 of 2025
for R7 in WP.no.38692 of 2024
Mr.Abdul Saleem, Sr.counsel,
for Mr.C.Tirumaran, for R5
in WP.No.34048 of 2024
__________
Page5 of 47
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 34048 of 2024
Mr.P.T.Ramkumar, CGC
for R1 in WP.No.47016 of 2025
Mr.Dominic S.David, Govt. counsel
for R4 in WP.No.34048 of 2024
for R7 in WP.No.47016 of 2025
Common Order
The challenge involved in all these writ petitions is with regard to the
impugned proceedings dated 17.10.2024 issued by the Revenue Divisional
Officer.
2. Out of these 3 writ petitions, this Court hereinafter refer the status of
the parties as mentioned in the W.P.No.34048 of 2024.
3. Brief facts of the cases are as follows:
3.1 Initially, at the instance of 1st respondent, in the year 1929, the then
Government (now called as Government of Tamil Nadu) had acquired the land
to the total extent of 245.05 Acres, under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894. Out
of the aforesaid extent, 191.66 Acres of lands are patta land and the remaining
53.39 Acres of lands are Poromboke land, which belongs to the Government of
Tamil Nadu. Subsequent to the said acquisition, those lands were transferred, by
the Government of Tamil Nadu, to the 1 st respondent after collecting the land
value for the acquired patta land as well as Poromboke land.
__________
Page6 of 47
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 34048 of 2024
3.2 As per the extract of Military Land Register, Madras Circle, the value
of land acquired, to an extent of 245.05 Acres, in the year 1929 was mentioned
as a sum of Rs.16,557/-. Thereafter, the entire extent of 245.05 Acres of land,
i.e., an extent of 122.98 Acres of lands from Malumichampatti Village and
remaining extent of 122.07 Acres of lands from Kurichi Village, were owned
and possessed by the Ministry of Defence, Government of India, classified as
Rifle Range at Podanur in the erstwhile Coimbatore Taluk, Coimbatore District.
3.3 Later, in the year 1952, the aforesaid lands were treated and declared
as “surplus lands” to Army requirements and the 1st respondent, vide letter dated
27.05.1952, awarded sanction for outright sale of the said lands through public
auction. Subsequently, the auction news was published in Tamil Daily
newspaper “Swadesamithran” on 03.07.1952 and the auction notice was issued
on 05.07.1952. Thereafter, the 245.05 Acres of lands were divided into three
lots and it was sold through public auction, which was conducted on
25.07.1952.
3.4 In the said auction, the said three lots were sold to three successful
bidders, i.e., (i) an extent of 36.47 Acres of lands were sold to M/s.Asbestos
Cement Limited vide sale deed dated 02.02.1953 and the same was registered
on 26.03.1953 as Document No.893/1953; (ii) an extent of 122.98 Acres of
lands were sold to Mr.A.R.Govindarajalu vide sale deed dated 02.02.1953 and
__________
Page7 of 47
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 34048 of 2024
the same was registered on 30.03.1953 as Document No.597/1953; (iii) an
extent of 85.60 Acres of lands were sold to one R.Ethirajulu Naidu vide sale
deed dated 02.02.1953 and the same was registered on 24.03.1953 as Document
No.885/1953. All these transactions were updated to the extract of Military
Land Register.
3.5 Subsequent to the sale of lands, the Military Estate Officer, Madras
Circle, had sent a letter dated 20.01.1953 to the Collector of Coimbatore, in
regard to the said sale of 245.05 Acres of land and seeks for necessary changes
in the revenue records.
3.6 In the year 1958, the aforesaid Mr.Ethirajalu Naidu had executed an
exchange deed dated 30.11.1958, to transfer an extent of 47.11 Acres of land
from and out of 85.6 Acres of land, to and in favour of his brotherR.Krishnaswamy Naidu. Thereafter, the said Krishnaswamy Naidu had retained
an extent of 1.43 Acres and sold an extent of 45.68 Acres of land in favour of
Rangaswamy Naidu Orchards Private Limited (later merged with petitioner in
WP.No.34048 of 2024) vide sale deed dated 20.02.1959. Subsequently, the
petitioner in WP.No.34048 of 2024 had retained 33.84 Acres of land and sold
an extent of 13.27 Acres of land to an Old Age Home in Coimbatore, namely
Aged Home Trust (petitioner in W.P.No.38692 of 2024) vide sale deed date
16.02.1981.
__________
Page8 of 47
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 34048 of 2024
3.7 In the meantime, the patta, pertaining to the extent of 33.84 Acres of
land, was issued in favour of the petitioner in WP.No.34048 of 2024 after a
long-drawn verification process. Initially, the Tahsildhar, Coimbatore (South),
vide letter dated 05.03.2004 & 06.08.2004, had sought for the opinion from the
Station Commander, Redfields, Coimbatore, with regard to the genuineness of
the auction sale, which occurred on 25.07.1952. In reply, the Station
Commander had vouched for the genuineness of the same vide letter dated
20.08.2004. Thereafter, the 1st respondent, vide proceedings dated 05.06.2008,
had also intimated the petitioner about the genuineness of transaction, which
was taken place about 5 decades ago. Based on all these documents, the
Tahsildar, Coimbatore South, had finally granted patta to the rightful owners of
the properties in the year 2009.
3.8 After obtaining patta, the petitioner in WP.No.34048 of 2024 had
obtained LPA and DTCP approvals for conversion of 33.84 Acres of lands into
318 house sites, out of which, various sites were sold from the year 2011 and as
on date, only 10 vacant sites exist. The purchasers of the plots, i.e., plot owners,
formed an Association, namely M/s.Tarun Residency Welfare Association
(petitioner in WP.No.47016 of 2025).
__________
Page9 of 47
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 34048 of 2024
3.9 Under these circumstances, one Sathyanarayana, S/o.Ethirajalu
Naidu, who initially acquired the subject land vide public auction, had filed a
suit in OS.No.827 of 2004, against the rejection of request for issuance of patta,
pertaining to a portion of subject property. However, the said suit was dismissed
vide judgement and decree dated 29.09.2011 for non-production of evidences.
Aggrieved over the same, AS.No.113 of 2012 was filed and the same was also
dismissed vide judgement and decree dated 28.01.2015, against which
SA.No.208 of 2016 was filed. However, the said second appeal was also
dismissed vide judgement and decree dated 24.09.2019.
3.10 By citing the dismissal of the above suits, now, the patta, pertaining
to the subject property, was cancelled by the RDO vide the impugned order
dated 17.10.2024, due to which, the petitioners’ right over the subject property
was affected. Hence, these petitions were filed against the said impugned order
issued by the Revenue Divisional Officer (RDO).
4. The submissions made on behalf of the Petitioners:
4.1 Mr.Sathish Parasaran, learned Senior counsel, appearing on behalf of
the petitioners would submit that in these cases, the subject lands were
purchased by virtue of a public auction, whereby one Ethirajalu Naidu was
__________
Page10 of 47
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 34048 of 2024
declared as successful bidder and accordingly, the sale deed, pertaining to an
extent of 85.60 Acres of land, was executed on 02.02.1953 and registered on
24.03.1953 vide Doc.No.885/1953.
4.2
Thereafter,
the
said
Ethirajalu
Naidu
had
executed
a
Partition/Exchange deed dated 30.11.1958, to and in favour of his brotherKrishnaswamy Naidu, for an extent of 47.11 Acres and retained the remaining
extent of 38.49 Acres of land. Subsequently, the said Krishnaswamy Naidu had
retained an extent of 1.43 Acres and sold an extent of 45.68 Acres of land in
favour of Rangaswamy Naidu Orchards Private Limited (later merged with the
petitioner in WP.No.34048 of 2024) vide sale deed dated 20.02.1959.
Thereafter, they had retained 33.84 Acres of land and sold an extent of 13.27
Acres of land to an Old Age Home in Coimbatore, namely Aged Home Trust
(petitioner in W.P.No.38692 of 2024) vide sale deed date 16.02.1981.
4.3 The retained portion of 33.84 Acres were converted into 318 house
sites, for which, the petitioner in WP.No.34048 of 2024 had obtained LPA and
DTCP approvals. Out of the total 318 house sites, various sites were sold from
the year 2011 and as on date, only 10 vacant sites exist. The purchasers of the
plots, i.e., plot owners, formed an Association, namely M/s.Tarun Residency
Welfare Association (petitioner in WP.No.47016 of 2025).
__________
Page11 of 47
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 34048 of 2024
4.4 Prior to the obtaining of LPA and DTCP approvals, the patta,
pertaining to the extent of 33.84 Acres of land, was issued after a long-drawn
verification process. Initially, the Tahsildhar, Coimbatore (South), vide letter
dated 05.03.2004 & 06.08.2004, had sought for the opinion from the Station
Commander, Redfields, Coimbatore, with regard to the genuineness of the
auction sale, which occurred on 25.07.1952. In reply, the Station Commander
had vouched for the genuineness of the same vide letter dated 20.08.2004.
Thereafter, the 1st respondent, vide proceedings dated 05.06.2008, had also
intimated the petitioner about the genuineness of transaction, which was taken
place about 5 decades ago. Based on all these documents, the Tahsildar,
Coimbatore South, had finally granted patta to the rightful owners of the
properties in the year 2009.
4.5 On the other hand, on the strength of sale deed dated 02.02.1953
executed by the 1st respondent, a patta application was filed by Ethirajalu Naidu,
who acquired the subject property by way of public auction. However, the same
was rejected by the Revenue Authorities. Against the said rejection order,
OS.No.827 of 2004 was filed by one Sathyanarayana, the legal heir of
Ethirajalu Naidu, was dismissed vide judgement and decree dated 29.09.2011
for non-production of relevant evidences. Further, in the said suit, it has been
__________
Page12 of 47
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 34048 of 2024
stated that in the copy of the sale deed, which were said to have executed in
favour of the plaintiff's father, it has been referred as “Indenture”, i.e., it is not a
sale deed but an agreement for sale. Therefore, it has been held that no such sale
had taken place and thus, no patta can be issued. Subsequently, the said order
was confirmed vide judgements and decree dated 28.01.2015 & 24.09.2019
passed in AS.No.113 of 2012 and SA.No.208 of 2016 respectively. By citing
the dismissal order passed in the aforesaid suit, now, the impugned order dated
17.10.2024 was passed, pertaining to the entire extent of 85.60 Acres.
4.6 Further, he would contend that since the petitioners herein were not
impleaded as parties in the aforesaid suits, the judgement and decree passed in
those suits will not bind the petitioners in terms of Section 34 & 35 of the
Specific Relief Act.
4.7 That apart, in these cases, the subject property was originally sold by
the 1st respondent. In such case, no doubt, the 1st respondent is the rightful
person to depose before the Court with regard to the sale of property by way of
public auction, however, they were also not impleaded as parties in the said
suits. Thus, it is clear that without hearing the necessary parties, the judgement
and decree came to be passed in OS.No.827 of 2004 and the same was further
confirmed vide the judgement and decree passed in AS.No.113 of 2012 and
SA.No.208 of 2016.
__________
Page13 of 47
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 34048 of 2024
4.8 If a sale was duly confirmed by the seller, the same cannot be denied.
In such view of the matter, in the counter filed by the 1 st respondent, who is
none other than the vendor of the subject property, it has been categorically
mentioned that the sale deed, pertaining to the extent of 85.60 Acres of land,
was executed in favour of Ethirajalu Naidu. Even in the sale deed, it has been
stated that the title was handed over to the concerned person and hence, the 1 st
respondent had relinquished all their rights over the subject property. However,
without considering all these aspects in a proper manner, the RDO had issued
the impugned order and cancelled the patta, which was issued after thorough
verification.
4.9 There is no dispute on the aspect that the subject lands were initially
acquired by the 1st respondent for defence purpose after the payment of
consideration to the then Government (now called as Government of Tamil
Nadu) in terms of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894. Thereafter, it was sold to
Ethirajalu Naidu by way of public auction. When such being the case, without
hearing the vendors of the subject property, it is not proper to arrive at a
decision that the sale deed dated 02.02.1953 is not a sale deed but merely an
agreement. Hence, he requests this Court to quash the impugned proceedings
dated 17.10.2024.
__________
Page14 of 47
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 34048 of 2024
4.10 In support of his contentions, he referred to the following
judgements, rendered by the Hon’ble Apex Court:
i) Deccan Paper Mills Company Limited vs. Regency
Mahavir Properties and others reported in (2021) 4 SCC 786;
ii) Hero Vinoth (Minor) vs. Seshammal reported in
(2006) 5 SCC 545;
iii) Distributors (Baroda) Pvt. Ltd. vs. Union of India,
reported in (1986) 1 SCC 43;
iv) Vishwas Footwear Company Ltd. vs. District
Collector, Kancheepuram, reported in 2011 SCC OnLine
Mad 939;
v) The Secretary of State for India in Council vs. Syed
Ahmad Badsha Bahadur (SA.No.15 of 1920 order dated
11.04.1921);
5. The submissions made by the 1st respondent:
5.1 Mr.AR.L.Sundaresan, learned Additional Solicitor General, appearing
for the 1st respondent had confirmed the submissions made by the learned
counsel appearing for the petitioners and would submit that in the year 1929, the
land to an extent of 245.05 Acres was acquired by the then Government (now
called as Government of Tamil Nadu) and the same was handed over to the 1 st
respondent for defence purpose. In the year 1952, an extent of 245.05 Acres of
land was treated as surplus land and the same was brought for sale vide public
auction. The aforesaid land was divided as three lots and sold to three successful
bidders vide sale deeds dated 02.02.1953 in the following manner:
__________
Page15 of 47
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 34048 of 2024
(i) an extent of 36.47 Acres of land was sold to
M/s.Asbestos Cement Limited
(ii) an extent of 122.98 Acres of land was sold to
Mr.A.R.Govindarajalu
(iii) an extent of 85.60 Acres of land was sold to one
R.Ethirajulu Naidu
5.2 The above transactions were duly registered in the Military Land
Register. Subsequently, on 20.01.1953, the Military Estate Officer had sent a
letter to the Collector, Coimbatore, as an intimation with regard to the sale of
land and sought for necessary changes in the revenue records.
5.3 Even in the year 2009, the 1 st respondent, vide his letter dated
20.08.2004, had ascertained with regard to the genuineness of sale of subject
property vide the public auction. In such case, the petitioners and their vendors
are certainly entitled for patta, pertaining to their respective entitlement.
However, without considering all these aspects, the revenue officials had
refused to issue patta for one portion of subject land and cancelled the patta,
which was already issued for other portion of subject land. Hence, he requests
this Court to pass appropriate orders.
__________
Page16 of 47
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 34048 of 2024
6. The submissions made on behalf of the Revenue Officials:
6.1 The learned Additional Advocate General appearing on behalf of the
respondents 3 & 4 would submit that the subject land was originally acquired by
the then Government (Government of Tamil Nadu) in the year 1929 in terms of
Land Acquisition Act, 1894 and the same was handed over to the Defence
Department. In such case, if the said land is declared as surplus, the same
should have been reverted back to the then Government (now called as
Government of Tamil Nadu) and the 1st respondent has no authority to conduct
public auction for sale of the said land.
6.2 Further, he would contend that one Sathyanarayana, S/o.Ethirajalu
Naidu, had filed a suit in OS.No.827 of 2004 against the rejection of patta
application. However, the said suit was dismissed, vide judgement and decree
dated 29.09.2011, whereby it has been held that the plaintiff therein had failed
to produce the original title deeds and the documents, which were said to have
executed in favour of the purchaser. It was also stated that in the copy of
document produced by the plaintiff, it has been referred as “Indenture”, which
means, it is not a sale deed but it is only an agreement for sale. The said
dismissal order was confirmed vide judgement and decree dated 28.01.2015 &
24.09.2019 passed in AS.No.113 of 2012 and SA.No.208 of 2016. Therefore, he
would submit that the rights of the parties were already decided and the same
had attained its finality at the level of second appeal. In such case, unless and
__________
Page17 of 47
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 34048 of 2024
otherwise the judgement and decree dated 24.09.2019 passed in SA.No.208 of
2016 is challenged and set aside, the question of claiming right over the subject
property by the petitioners would not at all arise.
6.3 He would also submit that the patta was issued to the petitioners by
wrongly construing the document dated 02.02.1953 as sale deed. Subsequent to
the dismissal of suits, the revenue authorities had rightly cancelled the aforesaid
patta, issued in favour of the petitioners, vide the impugned proceedings dated
17.10.2024 and thus, there is no error on the part of the revenue officials.
Therefore, he prays for dismissal of these petitions.
6.4 In support of his contentions, he referred to the following judgements,
rendered by the Hon'ble Apex Court:
(i) Pandit Ishwardas vs. State of Madhya Pradesh and
others reported in (1979) 4 SCC 163;
(ii) Radhey Shyam and another vs. Chhabi Nath and
others reported in (2015) 5 SCC 423;
(iii) Mary Pushpam vs. Telvi Curusumary and others
reported in (2024) 3 SCC 224;
7. The submissions made on behalf of the 5th respondent:
7.1 The learned Senior counsel appearing for the 5 th respondent (son of
Sathyanarayana/plaintiff in the aforesaid suit) would submit that in this case, the
__________
Page18 of 47
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 34048 of 2024
subject property was acquired by Ethirajalu Naidu, who is none other than the
grandfather of 5th respondent, vide public auction. In this regard, the sale deed
dated 02.02.1953 was executed by the 1st respondent in favour of Ethirajalu
Naidu. At the same time, two other lots of land was also sold to other two
successful bidders vide sale deeds dated 02.02.1953. The intimation with regard
to all the three transactions were communicated to the Collector by the 1 st
respondent vide letter dated 20.01.1953, whereby they had also sought for
changes in the revenue records, pertaining to the subject property. Though the
mutation was carried out in respect of other two transactions, the revenue
officials had acted in biased manner and failed to mutate the revenue records,
pertaining to the lot, which was purchased by 5th respondent’s grandfather.
7.2 Under these circumstances, an application for issuance of patta was
filed by the 5th respondent’s grandfather. However, the same was rejected by the
Revenue officials. Aggrieved over the rejection of application, the 5 th
respondent’s father-Sathyanarayana had filed the suit in OS.No.827 of 2004,
which was dismissed vide judgement and decree dated 29.09.2011 on the
ground of non-production of evidences and original documents.
7.3 He would further contend that the said suit was filed without
impleading the necessary party, i.e., 1st respondent, who is the seller of subject
property. In such case, it is clear that the judgement and decree was passed in
__________
Page19 of 47
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 34048 of 2024
the absence of original documents and without hearing the necessary parties and
hence, the same is liable to be set aside. Hence, he requests this Court to pass
appropriate orders.
8. I have given due consideration to the learned Senior counsel appearing
on behalf of the petitioner and the learned Additional Solicitor General, learned
Additional Advocate General and all other learned counsel appearing on behalf
of the respondents and also perused the entire materials available on record.
9. There is no dispute on the aspect that at the instance of 1 st respondent,
the subject land, to an extent of 245.05 Acres, was acquired by the then
Government (now called as Government of Tamil Nadu) in the year 1929 by
invoking the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, for the benefit of 1 st respondent. Out
of those lands, an extent of 191.66 Acres are patta lands and the remaining
extent of 53.39 Acres are Poromboke lands. The said lands were handed over by
the then Government (now called as Government of Tamil Nadu) to the 1 st
respondent upon the payment of entire consideration of a sum of Rs.16,557/and subsequently, those lands were duly registered as the lands of 1 st respondent
in the Military Land Register.
10. In the year 1952, the aforesaid lands were declared as “surplus lands”
and hence, the 1st respondent had decided to sell the same by virtue of
__________
Page20 of 47
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 34048 of 2024
conducting public auction. The sanction for sale of those lands were issued by
the Government of India on 27.05.1952. Subsequently, on 03.07.1952, the
auction details were published in the Tamil Daily, namely “Swadesamitran” and
on 05.07.1952, the public auction notice was also issued.
11. The entire land was divided into three lots and the auction was
conducted by the 1st respondent on 25.07.1952. In the said auction, the sale was
confirmed in favour of the three successful bidders in the following manner:
(i) an extent of 36.47 Acres of lands were sold to
M/s.Asbestos Cement Limited vide sale deed dated
02.02.1953 and the same was registered on 26.03.1953 as
Document No.893/1953;
(ii) an extent of 122.98 Acres of lands were sold to
Mr.A.R.Govindarajalu vide sale deed dated 02.02.1953 and
the same was registered on 30.03.1953 as Document
No.597/1953;
(iii) an extent of 85.60 Acres of lands were sold to one
R.Ethirajulu Naidu vide sale deed dated 02.02.1953 and the
same was registered on 24.03.1953 as Document
No.885/1953.
12. Prior to the aforesaid process of registering the sale deed, initially, the
certificate for handing over land was issued in favour of the Ethirajulu Naidu on
14.11.1952. Subsequently, on 17.12.1952, the sale of lands was duly registered
in the Military Land Register. On 20.01.1953, the Military Estate Officer had
__________
Page21 of 47
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 34048 of 2024
sent a communication to the Collector with regard to the aforesaid transactions
and sought for mutation of revenue records, pertaining to the subject properties.
On 02.02.1953, the sale deed vide Document No.885/1953 was executed in
favour of the said Ethirajalu Naidu and it was duly registered on 24.03.1953.
13. On 08.02.1965, the Revenue Department of Government of Tamil
Nadu, had issued GO(Ms)No.2871 as an order for change of classification in the
revenue records from “Rifle Range Poromboke” into “Assessed Waste Dry” to
an extent of 122.98 Acres on the basis of the sale deed executed in favour of
M/s.Importers Private Limited, Coimbatore. Similarly, the land to an extent of
36.47 Acres, at Kurichi Village, was also re-classified and the revenue records,
pertaining to those lands, were mutated in the name of M/s.Asbestos Cement
Limited. In such case, no doubt, the revenue officials are supposed to have
changed the classification of the subject lands at par with the aforesaid two
extents of land, since the same were purchased vide the very same public
auction. However, the officials had acted in a biased manner and refused to
change the classification of the subject land.
14. As narrated above, originally, 5th respondent’s grandfather-Ethirajalu
Naidu had acquired the subject property through public auction in the year 1953
by virtue of sale deed dated 02.02.1953 to an extent of 85.60 Acres of land.
Thereafter, in the year 1958, Ethirajalu Naidu had executed an exchange
__________
Page22 of 47
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 34048 of 2024
deed/partition deed dated 30.11.1958, to transfer an extent of 47.11 Acres of
land from and out of 85.6 Acres of land, to and in favour of his brotherR.Krishnaswamy Naidu. Thereafter, the said Krishnaswamy Naidu had retained
an extent of 1.43 Acres and sold an extent of 45.68 Acres of land in favour of
Rangaswamy Naidu Orchards Private Limited (later merged with petitioner in
WP.No.34048 of 2024 by virtue of order dated 22.06.2023) vide sale deed dated
20.02.1959. Subsequently, the said Rangaswamy Naidu Orchards Private
Limited had retained 33.84 Acres of land and sold an extent of 13.27 Acres of
land to an Old Age Home in Coimbatore, namely Aged Home Trust (petitioner
in W.P.No.38692 of 2024) vide sale deed date 16.02.1981.
15. After thorough verification, patta was issued by the Revenue Officials
in favour of the petitioners in the year 2009. Thereafter, after getting all the
approval, including DTCP and LPA, the petitioner in WP.No.34048 of 2024
had formed a layout with 318 housing plots, out of which 308 plots were sold
from the year 2011 and as on date, only 10 plots are now available for sale. The
purchasers of the plots, i.e., plot owners, formed an Association, namely
M/s.Tarun Residency Welfare Association (petitioner in WP.No.47016 of
2025).
16. Under these circumstances, the impugned order came to be passed
against the petitioners, cancelling the patta, issued in their names. The main
__________
Page23 of 47
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 34048 of 2024
ground for issuance of the said impugned order is nothing but the dismissal of
the suit, which was filed by the 5th respondent’s father, who is none other than
the legal heir of Ethirajalu Naidu (one of the successful bidders in the auction
conducted in the year 1952).
17. At this juncture, it would be pertinent to mention that initially, a suit
was filed in OS.No.827 of 2004 by one Sathyanarayana, who is father of 5 th
respondent and son of Ethirajalu Naidu, against the rejection of patta
application. However, the said suit was dismissed vide judgement and decree
dated 29.09.2011 for non-production of evidences and original documents.
Aggrieved over the same, AS.No.113 of 2012 was filed and the same was also
dismissed vide judgement and decree dated 28.01.2015, against which
SA.No.208 of 2016 was filed. However, the said second appeal was also
dismissed vide judgement and decree dated 24.09.2019. The relevant portion of
the judgement and decree passed in the aforesaid suits were duly extracted in
the impugned notice issued by the RDO and the same reads as follows:
“The following are the related extract of the order
passed on this case on 29.09.2011 as found from page 8 to 11
of the verdict.
gj;jpu vz;/885-1953 ehs ; 02/02/1953 (85/60
Vf;fUf;fhd
Mtzk;)
Mtzthrfj;jpypUe;J
th/rh/M/1 fpiua Mtzk;”my;y vd;Wk;”xU
xg;ge;jk;”vd;Wk;”bjspthf
bjupfpwJ/
th/rh/M/1?,d;”Kfg;gpnyna
fz;Ls;s Indenture
__________
Page24 of 47
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 34048 of 2024
Oxford Advanced Learners Dictionary-y ; “a
type of contract in the past that forced a servant or apprentice
towards for their employer for a particular period of time”
vd;gjw;F
vd;W
mu;j;jk;”fhl;lg;gl;Ls;sJ/
brd;id
gy;fiyf;fHfmfuhjpapy;”“bjhHpy;”Kiwf;”fl;L
g;ghl;L
xg;ge;jk;”(et;d;).
bjhHpy”mog;gilapy;
xg;ge;jgpizg;g[“bra;Jbfhs;”(bth;g;)”
vd
mu;j;jk;”fhl;lg;gl;Ls;sJ/
vdnt.
th/rh/M/?1
(02/02/1953?k;”njjpafpiuag;”gj;jpuj;jpd;”‘efy;)
xUbjhHpy;”Kiwf;fhd
xg;ge;jnk
vd;w
Kotpw;F ,e;ePjpkd;wk; tUfpwJ/
nkYk;.
th/rh/M?1
(02/02/1953?Mk;”njjpa
fpiuag;”gj;jpuj;jpd;”efy;)
go
jhth
brhj;Jf;fis
thjpapd;”jfg;gdhUf;F
cupik ,y;yhjnghJ gp ml;ltiz brhj;ij
Fwpj;J
th/rh/M
(30/11/1985?e;njjpa
guptu;j;jid
gj;jpuefy;)
kw;Wk;”th/rh/M?3
(03/12/1958 njjp gjpt [ bra;ag;gl;l ghfg;gj;jpuk;)
Mfpait K:yKk; thjpf;F cupik ,y;iy/
nkw;fz;l
r';fjpfs;”kw;Wk;
rhl;rpa';fs;”Ma;t[f;F
gpd”
jhth
brhj;J
thjpf;F ghj;jpag;gl;ljy;y vd vGtpdh 1?f;F
jPh;t[“fhzg;gLfpwJ/
jhth
brhj;jpy;”thjp
RthjPdj;jpy;”,Ug;gjw;fhd Mtznkh rhl;rpankh
vJt[k;”jhf;fy;”bra;ag;glhjjhy;.
thjpjhth
brhj;jpy;”,y;iy vd vGtpdh 2?f;Fk;. thjp
nfhhpa[s;s
tpsk;g[if
ghpfhuk;”thjpf;F
fpilf;fj;jf;fjy;y
vd
vGtpdh
3?f;F
jPu;t[“fhzg;gLfpwJ/ vGtpdh 1 Kjy ; 3 Koa
thjpf;F
vjpuhf
jPu;khdpf;fg;gl;Ls;s
epiyapy;”braYWj;Jf;fl;lis gupfhuk;”thjpf;F
fpilf;fj;jf;fjy;y vd vGtpdh 4?f;Fk;. Vdnt
thjp nfhhpa[s;s epue;ju cWj;Jf;fl;lis ghpfhuk;
bgwj;jf;fjy;y vd vGtpdh 5?f;Fk;. gupfhuk;
__________
Page25 of 47
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 34048 of 2024
Vjkpy;iy vd vGtpdh 6?f;Fk; jPu;t[“fhzg;gl;L
tHf;F js;Sgo bra;J jPu;g;gspf;fg;gLfpwJ/
Aggrieved by the above order passed in Os.No.827/2004
in the file of the II Additional District Munsif Court, an appeal
was filed by E.Sathyanarayana before the III Additional SubCourt, Coimbatore in AS.No.113/2012 and the above Court
dismissed the appeal confirming the order passed by the lower
Court as below:
“9. The lower court in its Judgement came to the
conclusion that the Ex.A1 is not at all a sale deed and it is an
agreement only The lower Court has given an explanation that
the Ex.A1 was titled as deed of ‘Indenture’ only which means a
contract only as per the dictionary meaning. The learned
counsel for the appellate/plaintiff argued that the above
finding of the lower Court is not acceptable since the Ex.A.1 is
a registered sale deed and executed on behalf of the President
of India. As already stated that the appellant has not produced
the original of Ex.A1 and the correspondence with regard to
the same. Further the appellant miserably failed to prove the
alleged possession of his family over the same is in accordance
with the Ex.A.1 only. The appellant family though claimed that
the suit lands are agricultural lands with their exclusive
possession, they have not produced any/document to prove the
same. No supporting evidence was let in this regard. Above all,
the appellant himself concedes that he has been paying penal
tax only by way of ‘B’ memos raised by the government which
is admittedly issued against the persons who are in unlawful
possession of a property belonged to the government. Even if
__________
Page26 of 47
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 34048 of 2024
the Ex.A.1 is admitted to be a sale deed, there is no piece of
evidence it was acted upon. The defendants have specifically
averred in the written statement that the application seeking
issuance of patta was rejected by the competing authorities…
… In the result, Appeal is dismissed by confirming the decree
and judgement dated 29.09.2011 in OS.No.827 of 2004 of the
learned II Additional District Munsif, Coimbatore. No cost.”
In
the
2nd
appeal
No.208/2016
filed
by
E.Sathyanarayana before the Hon’ble High Court of Madras,
the appeal was dismissed on 24.09.2019 observing that
“...15…. I do not find any valid reason to interfere with
the concurrent judgement and decree of the Courts below for
declining the reliefs prayed for by the plaintiff…
...17. For the reasons afore stated, the substantial
questions of law formulated in the second appeal are
accordingly answered against the plaintiff and in favour of the
defendants.
In conclusion, the second appeal fails and is
accordingly, dismissed with costs. Consequently, connected
miscellaneous petition, if any, is closed.”
18. By referring the above findings of the Trial Court and Appellate
Court, the RDO had recorded the following in the impugned notice dated
17.10.2024:
“In view of the judgement delivered in the Original Suit,
Appeal Suit and Second Appeal, an extent of 85.60 Acre of
land in S.F.No.603/1B and others which was transacted
__________
Page27 of 47
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 34048 of 2024
between Ministry of Defence and Thiru.Ethirajalu Naidu by
way of Indenture deed, is not a sale document, merely an
agreement. Hence, the main ground of the petitioner that they
purchased the land from B.Rangaswamy Naidu Orchards Pvt
Ltd vide sale deed No.1171/1981 dated 16.02.1981 is itself
failed in the test as per Latin Maxim ‘Nemo dat quod non
habet’ which generally means ‘that a person cannot by
transfer or otherwise confer a better title on another than he
himself has’, since the Sale Deed as claimed by the Petitioner
is observed by various Civil Court as well as the Hon’ble High
Court of Madras in SA.No.208/2016 as an Indenture and not a
sale deed. Further more, verdict passed in OS.No.827/2004
observing that sale deed dated 02.02.1953 is an “Indenture”, a
type of agreement only and the 1 st appeal AS.No.113/2012 and
the 2nd appeal No.208/2018 were dismissed confirming the
order of the lower Courts and after perusal of the relevant
court orders and related revenue records, it is concluded that
the Patta transfer order passed by the Tahsildar is in
contravention to the Government procedures, i.e., the
Tahsildar, erstwhile Coimbatore south taluk, during the
pendency of court proceedings in OS.No.827/2004 has
exercised extra jurisdictional power on passing Patta transfer
orders on 29.12.2009.”
19. Upon perusal, it appears that in the suits filed by the father of 5 th
respondent, the vendor (1st respondent) was not impleaded as party. No doubt
that the seller-1st respondent is the right person to appear before the Court and
__________
Page28 of 47
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 34048 of 2024
depose with regard to the nature and genuineness of sale deed, which was
executed on 02.02.1953 and registered on 24.03.1953 vide Document No.885 of
1953. However, in this case, the judgement and decree for dismissal of the suits
were passed without hearing the necessary parties.
20. Further, while dismissing the suits, filed by the 5th respondent’s father,
the Trial Court had perused the photocopy of the sale deed dated 02.02.1953
and by referring the usage of the said word “indenture” in the said photocopy,
the Trial Court had arrived at a conclusion that the said deed is not a sale deed
but merely an agreement.
21. On the other hand, upon perusal of the said document, it appears that
in the title of the document, it was clearly stated as “sale deed No.885/1953”,
and in 1st portion, though it has been mentioned as “indenture”, it further speaks
with regard to the consent between the parties for sale of property. Thereafter, it
has been mentioned with regard to the transfer of rights, title, etc., in favour of
the purchaser (5th respondent’s grandfather), whereby the 1st respondent had
relinquished their rights over the said land. When such being the case, the Trial
Court is supposed to have taken into consideration of the entire document.
However, without doing so, by merely citing the usage of the word “indenture”,
it was held by the Trial Court that Document No.885 of 1953 is not a sale deed
but an agreement.
__________
Page29 of 47
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 34048 of 2024
22. If the parties intend to execute an indenture to enter into an
agreement, there is no necessity to mention it as “sale deed” at the title of the
said document. To substantiate the said aspect, it would be apposite to refer the
relevant portions of counter, filed by the 1st respondent, which read as follows:
“4. I submit that with regard to averments made in para
5, 6 & 7 of the affidavit, it is an admitted fact that as per the
Military Land Register (MLR), the extent of 245.05 acres in
Kurichi village, Podanur Rifle range, Coimbatore was
acquired in the year 1927 by the Govt. of India, Ministry of
Defence. The MLR extract is annexed as A-1. On declaration
of surplus land for Army use, said Defence land measuring
245.05 acres kept under the management of Military Estates
Officer (now Defence Estates Officer) for its disposal.
Sanction for conduct of public auction of the above said land
was issued by the Ministry of Defence vide letter No. dated
27.05.1952. The Copy of the letter is annexed as A-2. It is
admitted that, the public auction was conducted by Military
Estates Officer and the military lands known as "Podanur
Rifle Range" measuring 245.05 acres has been sold in an
open auction in three lots. The auction notice issued by the
Military Estates Office dated 05.07.1952 is annexed as A-3
and the auction news were published in Tamil daily
newspaper "Swadesamithran" on 03.07.1952 is annexed as
A-4.
5. I submit that with regard to averments made in para 8
of the affidavit, it is an admitted fact that the defence land i.e.
Podanur Rifle range in Kurichi village, Coimbatore District
__________
Page30 of 47
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 34048 of 2024
admeasuring 245.05 acres was sold by Govt. of India,
Ministry of Defence in three lots viz, land measuring-36.47
acres, 85.60 acres and 122.98 acres. On successful of auction,
85.60 acres of land was handed over to one Mr. R. Ethirajalu
Naidu on 14.11.1952 by the Rep. of Military Estates Officer,
Madras circle. Copy of handing/taking over certificate is
annexed as A-5.
6. I submit that with regard to averments made in para 9
of the affidavit, the Defence land known as Podanur Rifle
range measuring 245.05 acres has been sold in three lots. As
stated above an extent of 36.47 acres of land sold to M/s
Asbestos cement Ltd, an extent of 85.60 acres sold to Mr.R.
Ethirajalu Naidu and an extent of 122.98 acres sold to
Mr.A.R.Govindarajalu) The updated extract of the Military
Land Register regarding sale of above said lands at Podanur
Rifle Range, Coimbatore dated 17.12.1952 is annexed as A-6.
7. I submit that with regard to averments made in para
10 of the affidavit, the proceedings of patta which was
mentioned in the affidavit by the petitioner are not aware of
this respondent as the land was sold and handed over to the
succeed bidders. However, the Military Estates Officer,
Madras Circle letter dated 20.01.1953 addressed to the
Collector of Coimbatore regarding the sale of 245.05 Acres of
defence land and to make necessary changes in revenue
records. The copy of the letter is annexed as A-7.
8 to 16. ……………….
17. I submit that with regard to avermentsmade in Para
I of the affidavit, it is an admitted fact which was already
intimated to the petitioner through letter dated 20.05.2024
__________
Page31 of 47
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 34048 of 2024
and clarified that after the sale of the said property by the
Govt. of India, Ministry of defence has relinquished all its
rights over the said land in favour of the purchasers and has
no dues against them as per the official records.
18. I submit that with regard to averments made in Para
J of the affidavit, it is an admitted fact that the defence land
i.e. Podanur Rifle Range in Kurichi village, Coimbatore
District measuring 245.05 acres was sold by Govt. of India,
Ministry of Defence in three parts measuring 36.47 acres,
85.60 acres and 122.98 acres. The 85.60 acres part of land
handed over to Mr. R. Ethirajalu Naidu on 14.11.1952 by the
Rep. of Military Estates Officer, Madras Circle. However, the
Military Estates Officer, Madras Circle addressed to the
Collector of Coimbatore on 20.01.1953 regarding the sale of
245.05 Acres of defence land and to make necessary changes
in revenue records.”
23. A reading of the above counter filed by the 1st respondent confirms
that the Document No.885 of 1953 is a sale deed, which was executed in favour
of Ethirajalu Naidu. It was also stated that from the date of execution of said
sale deed, the 1st respondent had relinquished all their rights over the property
with regard to the 245.05 Acres of lands. Even the extract of Military Land
Register would show that the land was sold on 02.02.1953 by way of public
auction. Thus, it is clear that the vendor (1st respondent) had categorically
confirmed that they have sold the lands in the year 1952 by way of public
auction and consequently, relinquished their rights over the property.
__________
Page32 of 47
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 34048 of 2024
24. As stated above, if any judgment is passed without impleading and
hearing the necessary parties to the suit, the same would be considered as bad in
law and thus, it cannot be enforced against the others, who are not parties to the
said suit. In such case, it is clear that the judgement and decree, which was
passed by the Trial Court without impleading the vendors of the subject
property, suffers from a fatal procedural defect and hence, the same will not
bind the petitioners and the 5th respondent.
25. At this juncture, it would be apposite to refer the judgement, rendered
by the Hon’ble constitution Bench of the Hon’ble Apex Court in Distributors
(Baroda) Pvt. Ltd., vs. Union of India and others reported in (1986) 1 SCC 43,
wherein it has been held as follows:
“19. But, even if in our view the decision in Cloth
Traders case is erroneous, the question still remains whether
we should over-turn it. Ordinarily we would be reluctant to
over-turn a decision given by a Bench of this Court, because it
is essential that There should be continuity and consistency in
judicial decisions and law should be certain and definite. It is
almost as important that the law should be settled permanently
as that it should be settled correctly. But there may be
circumstances where public interest demands that the previous
decision be reviewed and reconsidered. The doctrine of
stare decisis should not deter the Court from over-ruling an
__________
Page33 of 47
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 34048 of 2024
earlier decision, if it is satisfied that such decision is manifestly
wrong or proceeds upon a mistaken assumption in regard to the
existence or continuance of a statutory provision or is contrary
to another decision of the Court. It was Jackson, J. who said in
his dissenting opinion in Massachusetts v. United States: "I see
no reason why I should be consciously wrong today because I
was unconsciously wrong yesterday". Lord Denning also said
to the same effect when he observed in Ostime v. Australian
Mutual Provident Society: "The doctrine of precedent does not
compel Your Lordships to follow the wrong path until you fall
over the edge of the cliff". Here we find that there are overriding considerations which compel us to reconsider and
review the decision in Cloth Traders case. ……………….”
26. A reading of the above judgement would clearly reveal that normally,
the Court would be reluctant to over-turn a decision given by a Bench of this
Court, because it is essential that there should be continuity and consistency in
judicial decisions and law should be certain and definite. It is almost as
important that the law should be settled permanently as that it should be settled
correctly. But there may be circumstances where public interest demands that
the previous decision be reviewed and reconsidered. The doctrine of
stare decisis should not deter the Court from over-ruling an earlier decision, if it
is satisfied that such decision is manifestly wrong or proceeds upon a mistaken
assumption in regard to the existence or continuance of a statutory provision or
is contrary to another decision of the Court. The doctrine of precedent does not
__________
Page34 of 47
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 34048 of 2024
compel the Court to follow the wrong path until you fall over the edge of the
cliff.
27. Therefore, as observed above, in the present case, it is not proper to
rely upon the judgement and decree dated 29.09.2011 rendered in OS.No.827 of
2004 since it was passed in lack of primary evidence and without impleading
the necessary parties.
28. Now, the necessary party, i.e., vendors-1st respondent, was duly
impleaded in these petitions and they had clearly filed a detailed counter
(extracted supra) by stating that they have executed the sale deed dated
02.02.1953 in favour of Ethirajalu Naidu, for an extent of 85.60 Acres of land
and consequently, they had relinquished all their rights over the said property.
However, due to the failure in impleading the aforesaid necessary party (1st
respondent) in the suit filed by the 5 th respondent’s father, the Trial Court had
erred in depriving the plaintiff’s right over the subject property, by a mere
misinterpretation of the word 'Indenture' in the sale deed dated 02.02.1953.
29. Even in the judgement rendered by the Hon’ble Apex Court in Hero
Vinoth (Minor) vs. Seshammal reported in (2006) 5 SCC 545, it has been held
that if there is any misinterpretation in considering the document, which was
produced before the Trial Court, the judgement and decree passed by the said
__________
Page35 of 47
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 34048 of 2024
Trial Court can be interfered in terms of Section 100 of the Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908. The relevant portion of the said judgement reads as follows:
“16. It is now well settled that an inference of fact from
a document is a question of fact. But the legal effect of the
terms or a term of a document is a question of law.
Construction of a document involving the application of a
principle of law, is a question of law. Therefore, when there is
a misconstruction of a document or wrong application of a
principle of law while interpreting a document, it is open to
interference under Section 100 CPC. If a document creating an
easement by grant is construed as an 'easement of necessity'
thereby materially affecting the decision in the case, certainly
it gives rise to a substantial question of law.”
30. However, in this case, even the Appellate Court in Second Appeal
also had failed to consider the above aspect and confirmed the judgement and
decree dated 29.09.2011 passed by the Trial Court in OS.No.827 of 2004.
31. That apart, it appears that the sale was effected by virtue of Act
No.XV of 1895, which means, the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 would not
apply for the sale deed dated 02.02.1953. In such case,
For better
understanding, the relevant portion of Act No.XV of 1985 is extracted
hereunder:
“ACT No. XV OF 1895.
PASSED BY THE GOVERNOR GENERAL OF INDIA IN COUNCIL.
(Received the assent of the Governor General
on the 10th October, 1895.)
__________
Page36 of 47
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 34048 of 2024
An Act to explain the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, so
far as relates to grants from the Crown, and to remove certain
doubts as to the powers of the Crown in relation to such
grants.
WHEREAS doubts have arisen as to the extent and
operation of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, and as to the
power of the Crown to impose limitations and restrictions
upon grants and other transfers of land made by it or under
its authority, and it is expedient to remove such doubts; It is
hereby enacted as follows :1. (1) This Act may be called the Crown Grants Act,
1895.
(2) It extends to the whole of British India; and
(3) It shall come into force at once.
2. Nothing in the Transfer of Property Act, 1882,
contained shall apply or be deemed ever to have applied to
any grant or other transfer of land or of not any interest
therein heretofore made or hereafter to be made by or out
behalf of Her Majesty the Queen Empress, her heirs or
successors, or by or on behalf of the Secretary of State for
India in Council to, or in favour of, any person whomsoever;
but every such grant and transfer shall be construed and take
effect as if the said Act had not been passed.
3. All provisions, restrictions, conditions and limitations
over contained in any such grant or transfer according to as
aforesaid shall be valid and take effect according to their
tenor, any rule of law, statute or enactment of the Legislature
to the contrary notwithstanding.”
__________
Page37 of 47
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 34048 of 2024
32. As stated above, since the aforesaid sale deed was executed in terms
of Act No.XV of 1895, the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, will not apply. The
said aspect was also held vide the judgement rendered by the Hon’ble Apex
Court in TATA Steel Limited vs. State of Jharkhand and others reported in
(2015) 15 SCC 55. The relevant portion of the said judgement reads as follows:
“16. ………………. In other words, when the
Government transfers land or any interest therein to any
person, such a transfer is not governed by the Transfer of
Property Act, 1882. The rights and obligations flowing from
the transfer of either a piece of land or an interest therein by
the Government cannot be determined on the basis of the
rights and obligations specified under the Transfer of
Property Act, 1882. They are to be ascertained only from the
tenor of the document made by the Government evidencing
such a transfer……………...”
33. Further, it was also held by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the judgement
rendered in Hajee S.V.M.Mohamed Jamaludeen Bros & Co. vs. Government
of Tamil Nadu reported in (1997) 3 SCC 466. The relevant portion of the said
judgement reads as follows:
“10. The combined effect of the above two sections of the
Grants Act is that terms of any grant of terms of any transfer of
land made by a government would stand insulted from the
tentacles of any statutory law. Section 3 places the terms of such
grant beyond the reach of any restrictive provision contained n
any enacted law or even the equitable principles of justice equity
and good conscience adumbrated by common law if such
principles are inconsistent with such terms. The two provisions
are so framed as to confer unfettered discretion on the
government to enforce any condition or limitation or restriction
__________
Page38 of 47
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 34048 of 2024
in all types of grants made by the government to any person. In
other words, the rights, privileges and obligations of any grantee
of the government would be completely regulated by the terms of
the grant, even if such terms are inconsistent with the provisions
of any other law.”
34. Apart from the above, in this case, the impugned notice came to be
issued by the RDO only by citing the dismissal of suit in OS.No.827 of 2004.
However, in terms of Section 34 & 35 of Specific Relief Act, since the
petitioners were not impleaded as parties to the said suit, the judgement and
decree dated 29.09.2011 passed by the Trial Court will not bind the petitioners
and other persons, who are all not parties to the said suit.
35. The above aspect was clearly held in the judgement, rendered by the
Hon’ble Apex Court in Deccan Paper Mills Company Limited vs. Regency
Mahavir Properties and others reported in (2021) 4 SCC 786 and the relevant
portion of the same reads as follows:
“29. When sections 34 and 35 are seen, the position
becomes even clearer. Unlike section 31, under section 34, any
person entitled to any legal character may institute a suit for a
declaration that he is so entitled. Considering that it is
possible to argue on a reading of this provision that the legal
character so declared may be against the entire world, section
35 follows, making it clear that such declaration is binding
only on the parties to the suit and persons claiming through
them, respectively. This is for the reason that under section
__________
Page39 of 47
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 34048 of 2024
4 of the Specific Relief Act, specific relief is granted only for
the purpose of enforcing individual civil rights. The principle
contained in section 4 permeates the entire Act, and it would
be most incongruous to say that every other provision of
the Specific Relief Act refers to in personam actions, section
31 alone being out of step, i.e., referring to in rem actions.”
36. A reading of the above paragraph would make it clear that a
judgement would certainly bind only the persons, against whom it was passed.
In such view of the matter, it is needless to say that the judgements dated
29.09.2011, 28.01.2015 & 24.09.2019 passed in OS.No.827 of 2004,
AS.No.113 of 2012 & SA.No.208 of 2016 will not bind the petitioners herein
since the petitioners are not parties to the said suit and appeals.
37. Further, in the judgement rendered by the Hon’ble Apex Court in
Vishwas Footwear Company Ltd. vs. District Collector, Kancheepuram,
reported in 2011 SCC OnLine Mad 939, it has been held as follows:
“17. The question as to whether the revenue authorities
be it the Tahsildar exercising power under section 3 or
under section 5 or under section 10 or the Revenue Divisional
Officer exercising power under section 12, can consider only a
prima facie case as to the entitlement of a person or persons
for issuance of patta. In the event such officers encounter a
dispute which could be resolved only by a competent civil
Court, they would not have jurisdiction to enter into such civil
__________
Page40 of 47
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 34048 of 2024
dispute for adjudication. To this extent, the judgments
in Kuppuswami Nainar's case followed in Chockkappan'c case
may be relied upon. The learned Judge in the order under
appeal has also relied upon those judgments and we are in
agreement with the same.”
38. As held in the above judgement, the title dispute has to be resolved
only by the appropriate Court of law and thus, the revenue officials has no
authority of jurisdiction to decide the title or rights of the concerned parties over
a property. However, in this case, the RDO had decided the title dispute and
cancelled the patta, which was issued in favour of the petitioners after a
thorough and deep verification. Therefore, the impugned order passed by the
RDO is liable to be set aside on this ground also.
39. Three judgements were referred by the learned Additional Advocate
General. Firstly, in the judgement rendered by the Hon’ble Apex Court in
Radhey Shyam and another vs. Chhabi Nath and others reported in (2015) 5
SCC 423, it has been held as follows:
“27. Thus, we are of the view that judicial orders of civil
courts are not amenable to a writ of certiorari under Article
226. We are also in agreement with the view of the referring
Bench that a writ of mandamus does not lie against a private
person not discharging any public duty. Scope of Article 227 is
different from Article 226.
__________
Page41 of 47
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 34048 of 2024
28. We may also deal with the submission made on
behalf of the respondent that the view in Surya Dev Rai stands
approved by larger Benches in Shail, Mahendra Saree
Emporium and Salem Advocate Bar Assn and on that ground
correctness of the said view cannot be gone into by this Bench.
In Shail, though reference has been made to Surya Dev Rai,
the same is only for the purpose of scope of power
under Article 227 as is clear from para 3 of the said judgment.
There is no discussion on the issue of maintainability of a
petition under Article 226. In Mahendra Saree Emporium,
reference to Surya Dev Rai is made in para 9 of the judgment
only for the proposition that no subordinate legislation can
whittle down the jurisdiction conferred by the Constitution.
Similarly, in Salem Bar Assn. in para 40, reference to Surya
Dev Rai is for the same purpose. We are, thus, unable to
accept the submission of learned counsel for the respondent.”
40. Secondly, in the judgement rendered by the Hon’ble Apex Court in
Mary Pushpam vs. Telvi Curusumary and others reported in (2024) 3 SCC
224, it has been held as follows:
“17. In the light of the above facts, arguments and
findings recorded by the High Court in its judgment dated
30.03.1990, apparently no defence was left for the respondents
to take as it was already held that the appellant had perfected
her rights by adverse possession over the suit property which
was 8 cents of land. The construction of the appellant was
standing over the 8 cents of land may be on part of it but she
was found in possession of the entire 8 cents.”
__________
Page42 of 47
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 34048 of 2024
41. Thirdly, in the judgement rendered by the Hon’ble Apex Court in
Pandit Ishwardas vs. State of Madhya Pradesh and others reported in (1974) 4
SCC 163, it has been held as follows:
“7. The plaintiff in both the suits was the same. The
contesting defendant was also the same, namely the State of
Madhya Pradesh. In the present suit Melaram and the Chief
Conservator of Forests were also impleaded as parties
whereas in the other suit some other person was a party. We
do not see that it makes any difference. In order to sustain the
plea of res judicata it is not necessary that all the parties to
the two litigations must be common. All that is necessary is
that (he issue should be between the same parties or between
parties under whom they or any of them claim. The issue in
the present suit and the issue in the Dewas suit were between
the same parties namely the appellant and the State of
Madhya Pradesh. The submission that the subject matters of
the two suits were different because the present suit was for a
declaration and the other suit was for damages is equally
without substance since the issue between the parties was
identical in both the suits. The question at issue in both the
suits was whether the agreement between Melaram and the
Government and the surety bond executed by the plaintiff
were not enforceable because of the failure to comply
with Article 299 of the Constitution. The ground on which the
agreement and the surety bond were sustained in the Bewas
suit was that the Raj Pramukh had ratified the same. The fact
that the ratification by the Raj Pramuka was not expressly
mentioned in the present suit does not make any difference to
__________
Page43 of 47
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 34048 of 2024
the plea of res judicata. Once the questions at issue in the two
suits are found to be the same, the fact that the material which
led to the decision in the earlier suit was not again placed
before the Court in the second suit cannot make the slightest
difference. The plea of res-judicata may be sustained, without
anything more if the questions at issue and the parties are the
same, subject of course to the other conditions prescribed
by Section 11 Civil Procedure Code. The submission of the
learned Counsel that the decision of the Dewas Court and the
High Court in the other suit were non est because they upheld
an illegal contract has only to be noticed to be rejected.”
42. A perusal of the above portions of the three judgements referred by
the learned Additional Advocate General, makes it clear that those judgements
will not be applicable for the present case.
43. For all the above reasons, this Court finds that the Revenue Divisional
Officer had committed a serious fault in the decision making process and
therefore, the said impugned proceedings issued by the RDO dated 17.10.2024
is liable to be set aside.
44. Accordingly, this Court passes the following orders:
i) The impugned proceedings dated 17.04.2024 issued by
the Revenue Divisional Officer is hereby set aside.
__________
Page44 of 47
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 34048 of 2024
ii) Consequently, the original patta issued in favour of the
petitioners and other land owners of the subject land, under sale
deed dated 02.02.1953, stands restored and the same can be
used for all practical purposes.
iii) Further, if the patta was not already issued to the land
comprised in the sale deed dated 02.02.1953, the concerned
Revenue Authorities (Tahsildhar) shall issue patta, in favour of
all the respective land owners, who are currently in possession
of the lands, including the 5th respondent, within a period of 2
weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.
iv) The concerned Revenue Authorities are directed to
make suitable corrections in their records to give immediate
effect to this order.
45. With the above directions, these writ petitions are disposed of. No
cost. Consequently, the connected miscellaneous petitions are also closed.
31-08-2026
Index: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
nsa
__________
Page45 of 47
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 34048 of 2024
To
1. Union Of India
Rep By Its Ministry Of Defence Defence
Estate Office, Madras Circle,
306 Anna Salai, Teynampet, Chennai.
2. The District Collector
Coimbatore District, Collectorate Office,
State Bank Road, Gopalapuram,
Coimbatore- 641 018.
3. Revenue Divisional Officer
Coimbatore South, State Bank Road,
Gopalapuram, Coimbatore- 641 018.
4. The Sub Registrar,
Madukarai, Coimbatore.
5. The Executive Engineer,
Operation And Maintenance,
Distribution Circle, South,
Tamil Nadu Power Distribution Corporation
Ltd, Coimbatore. 641 008.
6. Commissioner Of Land Administration
Ezhilagam, Chepauk, Chennai-600 005.
7. Tahsildar
Office Of The Tahsildar, Madukarai Taluk,
(previously Coimbatore South Taluk)
Coimbatore641 105.
8. District Revenue Officer,
Coimbatore-641 018.
__________
Page46 of 47
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 34048 of 2024
KRISHNAN RAMASAMY J.
nsa
WP No. 34048 & 38692 of 2024 & 47016 of 2025
31-08-2026
__________
Page47 of 47
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review