Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:MHC:4101
WP Nos. 49325 & 49330 of 2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
ORDERS RESERVED ON
: 27.08.2026
ORDERS PRONOUNCED ON
: 06.10.2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE D.BHARATHA CHAKRAVARTHY
WP Nos. 49325 & 49330 of 2025
and
WMP Nos. 55096 & 55099 of 2025
WP No.49325 of 2025
S.Sekhar
..Petitioner
Vs
The State of Tamilnadu,
Rep. by its Additional Chief Secretary,
Natural Resources Department,
Namakkal Kavignar Malligai,
Fort St. George, Chennai - 600 009.
..Respondent
WP No. 49330 of 2025
S.Sekhar
..Petitioner
Vs
The State of Tamilnadu
Rep. by its Additional Chief Secretary,
Natural Resources Department,
Namakkal Kavignar Maligai,
Fort St. George, Chennai - 600 009.
..Respondent
WP No. 49325 of 2025
Prayer: Writ Petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India for the
issuance of Writ of Certiorarified Mandamus, calling for the entire records of
the case including those files and records regarding the personal hearing held on
23.05.2025 relating to the culmination of the passing of the order dated
__________
Page1 of 22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:4101
WP Nos. 49325 & 49330 of 2025
31.10.2025 bearing G.O.(Ms) No.79 and passed by the Additional Chief
Secretary to Government (FAC), Natural Resources (MMA-2) Department, the
Respondent herein and quash the same and consequently direct the respondent
herein to issue a non-lapse order.
WP No. 49330 of 2025
Prayer: Writ Petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India for the
issuance of Writ of Certiorarified Mandamus, calling for the entire records of
the case including those files and records regarding the personal hearing held on
23.05.2025 relating to the culmination of the passing of the order dated
31.10.2025 bearing G.O.(Ms) No.78 and passed by the Additional Chief
Secretary to Government (FAC), Natural Resources (MMA-2) Department, the
Respondent herein and quash the same and consequently direct the respondent
herein to issue a non-lapse order.
For Petitioner:
Mr.S.Haja Mohideen Gisthi (in both W.Ps.)
For Respondent:
Dr.R.Gouri
Special Government Pleader (in both W.Ps.)
COMMON ORDER
These two writ petitions are connected, as they have been filed by the
same petitioner challenging identical orders in respect of two mining leases.
A. W.P.No.49325 of 2025:
2. The brief facts in this writ petition are that on 04.10.1995, a mining
lease was granted to the petitioner under non-captive mines vide G.O.(3D)
No.292 dated 04.10.1995 for a period of 20 years from the date of execution of
__________
Page2 of 22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:4101
WP Nos. 49325 & 49330 of 2025
the lease deed for quarrying limestone. Pursuant thereto, the lease was executed
for quarrying an extent of 2.24 hectares covering S.F.Nos.835/3, 836(part) and
837/1B of Varavanai Village, Kadavur Taluk, Karur District, for a period of 20
years from 18.11.1995 to 17.11.2015. Twelve months before the expiry of the
lease, on 28.07.2014, the petitioner submitted an application for renewal of the
mining lease under Section 8A(3)(6) of the Mines and Minerals (Development
and Regulation) Act, 1957, read with Rule 24A of the Mineral Concession
Rules, 1960. No express orders were passed, and when the said application was
pending, the petitioner continued quarrying activity until January 2016, after
which the mining operations were stopped, as the petitioner did not apply for
and obtain environmental clearance. Thereafter, the petitioner applied for
environmental clearance on 15.02.2017, and a physical application was also
made on 13.04.2018 by payment of the statutory fee of Rs.1 lakh. When the
environmental clearance application was pending, the District Collector issued a
show cause notice on 09.06.2020 to the petitioner seeking an explanation for the
non-operation of the mining lease area for more than two years, as per Section
4A(4) of the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957
(hereinafter referred to as the MMDR Act), read with Rule 20(2) of the
Minerals (Other than Atomic and Hydrocarbon Energy Minerals) Concession
Rules, 2016 (hereinafter referred to as the MC Rules, 2016).
__________
Page3 of 22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:4101
WP Nos. 49325 & 49330 of 2025
2.1 The petitioner submitted an explanation on 26.06.2020. Thereafter, on
04.07.2020, the Director of Geology and Mining, Chennai, forwarded a
proposal to the Government to declare the quarry licence in the lease as having
lapsed. On 04.07.2020, a demand notice was also issued to the petitioner for
Rs.2,84,100/- for quarrying the mineral without environmental clearance during
the period from 15.01.2016 to 31.08.2016, amounting to about 600 metric
tonnes of limestone. The petitioner remitted the amount on 20.02.2024.
Thereafter, on 25.07.2024, the State Level Environmental Impact Assessment
Authority granted environmental clearance to the petitioner. On 13.09.2024, the
petitioner also obtained consent from the Tamil Nadu Pollution Control Board,
which was valid up to 31.03.2025. Thereafter, on 24.10.2024, the petitioner
made an application under Rule 20(5)(3)(7) and (9) of MC
Rules, 2016,
remitting the requisite fee of Rs.1,00,000/-. It is stated that the petitioner also
submitted an application on 22.01.2025.
2.2 In that regard, under the said circumstances, the Government afforded
the petitioner an opportunity of personal hearing on 19.05.2025. On 02.06.2025,
the petitioner attended the personal hearing and submitted his written statement.
Even thereafter, no orders were passed, and the petitioner approached this Court
by way of W.P. No.36779 of 2025. By an order dated 06.10.2025, this Court
directed the Government of Tamil Nadu to pass orders within six weeks of
receipt of the order. Thereafter, the impugned G.O.Ms.No.79 dated 31.10.2025
__________
Page4 of 22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:4101
WP Nos. 49325 & 49330 of 2025
was passed, accepting the proposal of the District Collector and the
recommendation of the Director of Geology and Mining, and declaring the
mining lease granted to the petitioner as having lapsed under Section 4A(4) of
the MMDR Act. Aggrieved, the petitioner has filed the writ petition.
B. W.P.No. 49330 of 2025:
3. A mining lease was granted to the petitioner as a non-captive mine for
quarrying limestone vide G.O.Ms. No.162 dated 14.06.1994 for a period of 20
years from the date of execution of the lease deed. Pursuant to the order, the
lease deed was executed, permitting the petitioner to quarry limestone for 20
years from 10.08.1994 to 09.08.2014, in S.F. Nos. 833/4B, 836(P) and 843/2 of
Varavanai Village, Kadavur Taluk, in Karur District. Twelve months before the
lease expired, the petitioner filed an application on 22.07.2013 for renewal
under Section 8(2) of the MMDR Act, read with Rules 22, 22-A, 27(3) and 45
of the Mineral Concession Rules, 1960. No orders were passed on the renewal
of this lease either. However, the petitioner continued quarrying operations till
January 2016, when the mining operations were stopped for want of
environmental clearance. The petitioner therefore applied for environmental
clearance online on 15.02.2017 and followed it with a physical application on
13.04.2018, paying the requisite fee of Rs.1,00,000. While the application was
pending, on 02.08.2019, the District Collector, Karur, issued a demand notice
__________
Page5 of 22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:4101
WP Nos. 49325 & 49330 of 2025
demanding Rs.69,300/- for quarrying and dispatch of 150 metric tonnes of
limestone without environmental clearance during the period from 15.01.2016
to 10.02.2016. Thereafter, on 09.06.2020, the District Collector issued a showcause notice to the petitioner seeking his explanation for the non-operation of
the mining lease area for more than two years, as per Section 4-A(4) of the
MMDR Act, read with Rule 20(2) of the MCR, 2016. On 26.06.2020, the
petitioner submitted his explanation. Thereafter, on 04.07.2020, the District
Collector forwarded the proposal to declare the licence as having lapsed to the
Director of Geology and Mining.
3.1 On 08.07.2020, the Director forwarded the proposal to the
Government. On 18.06.2024, the petitioner remitted Rs.69,300/- as demanded
by the District Collector. Thereafter, on 24.10.2024, the petitioner paid the fee
of Rs.1,00,000/- for the non-lapse application under the MC Rules, 2016. The
application was submitted on 22.01.2025. On 12.01.2025, the petitioner
obtained environmental clearance from the State Level Environmental Impact
Assessment Authority. Thereafter, the petitioner filed an application for nonlapse on 22.01.2025. On 12.05.2025, the authority granted an opportunity of
personal hearing, and the petitioner attended the hearing on 23.05.2025 and
submitted his written statement. Even thereafter, no order was passed, and the
petitioner approached this Court by way of W.P. No.36777 of 2025. This Court
directed the respondent to conclude the proceedings based on the application
__________
Page6 of 22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:4101
WP Nos. 49325 & 49330 of 2025
submitted by the petitioner on 22.01.2025 and to pass orders within six weeks
from the date of receipt of a copy of the order. Thereafter, the impugned order
in G.O. Ms. No.78 was passed on 31.10.2025. The impugned order holds that
the lessee failed to submit any application with reference to non-lapse within
time under Rule 20(3) of the MC Rules, 2016 and, after examining the proposal
of the District Collector and the recommendation of the Director of Geology
and Mining, decided to accept the proposal and declared that the mining lease
granted to the petitioner had lapsed, as against which the writ petition is filed.
C. The State’s Version :
4. The writ petitions are resisted by separate counter-affidavits. The
respondents’ stand is that the petitioner applied for renewal of the mining lease
within the period, i.e., one year prior to the expiry of the mining lease, as per
Rule 24A(6) of the Mineral Concession Rules, 1960 (hereinafter MC Rules,
1960). Accordingly, under Section 8A(3) of the MMDR Act, all mining leases
granted prior to 2015 have been deemed extended for 50 years, and the
petitioner's mining lease was also eligible for such deemed extension. However,
the Honourable Supreme Court of India, by judgment dated 27.02.2012 in
Deepak Kumar v. State of Haryana and others, (2012) 4 SCC 629, ordered that
leases of minor minerals, including renewals for areas less than 5 hectares, be
granted by the State/Union Territory only after obtaining environmental
clearance from the Ministry of Environment and Forests.
__________
Page7 of 22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:4101
WP Nos. 49325 & 49330 of 2025
4.1 On 18.05.2012, the Ministry of Environment and Forests issued an
Office Memorandum mandating that all mining projects involving minor
minerals, including renewals, irrespective of the size of the lease, would require
prior environmental clearance. Subsequently, on 05.01.2016, the Ministry of
Environment, Forest and Climate Change issued S.O. 141(E), dated 15.01.2016,
constituting the District Level Environmental Impact Assessment Authority to
consider projects for mining minor minerals in areas of 5 hectares or less. On
04.05.2016, the National Green Tribunal, in Ramakant Gautam v. State of
Madhya Pradesh, ordered that all mine owners who had not submitted an
application to the appropriate authority for environmental clearance by
31.03.2016 be shut down and not permitted to carry on any mining activity. As
per the said order, from 11.01.2017, circulars were issued with reference to all
quarries within the State of Tamil Nadu, and operations without environmental
clearance were stopped. The Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate
Change also clarified, by order dated 03.04.2017, that all mining regions, major
as well as minor, operating in the country are required to obtain environmental
clearance after 15.01.2016, and that no mining unit shall operate without prior
environmental clearance. It further stated that mining leases operating beyond
15.01.2016 can be treated as violation cases. Since the petitioners' respective
leases operated beyond 15.01.2016, an appropriate penalty was imposed with
reference to both the leases. Even when submitting the renewal application in
2013, the petitioner did not submit any application for environmental clearance.
__________
Page8 of 22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:4101
WP Nos. 49325 & 49330 of 2025
4.2 By the judgment dated 02.08.2017 in Common Cause v. Union of
India, (2017) 9 SCC 499, the Honourable Supreme Court mandated that a
holder of a mining lease must adhere to the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986,
the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980, the Water (Prevention and Control of
Pollution) Act, 1974, and the Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act,
1981. If any mining operation is conducted in violation of any of these
requirements, that operation is deemed illegal and unlawful, and any extraction
of mineral through the illegal and unlawful mining operation is an illegally and
unlawfully extracted mineral. The Supreme Court held that there can be no
compromise on the quantum of compensation and that 100% value of the
mineral has to be recovered.
4.3 As per the same, the 100% value of the mineral was recovered from
the petitioners in both cases. Since the petitioners' operations stopped in January
2016 and the period mandated under Section 4A(4) of the MMDR Act had
expired, the District Collector issued appropriate notices seeking the petitioners’
explanation as to why the lease should not be treated as lapsed. The petitioners
did not submit any application under Rule 20(3) of the MC Rules, 2016,
explaining the reason for non-operation of the mining lease within the time
limit. Accordingly, it was recommended that the lease be declared lapsed; only
thereafter, in 2024, did the petitioners obtain environmental clearance and remit
the non-lapse application fee. Therefore, after providing an opportunity of
__________
Page9 of 22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:4101
WP Nos. 49325 & 49330 of 2025
personal hearing and concluding that the subject mining leases were in a
condition of non-production and non-dispatch of minerals for more than two
years, and that the application for non-lapse was also not filed within time, the
impugned orders were passed, treating the mines as lapsed. Henceforth, as per
Section 10B of the MMDR Act, 1957, since the subject area comprises
limestone mineral, concessions can be granted only through competitive bidding
by way of re-auction methodology as per the Mineral (Auction) Rules, 2015.
D. The Arguments:
5. Mr S. Haja Mohideen Gisthi, the learned counsel for the petitioner,
would submit, making common arguments in respect of both the cases, that the
petitioner's leases stood extended as per the deeming provision under Section
8A(3) of the MMDR Act. The petitioner did not voluntarily abandon mining
operations. The stoppage was only due to the intervening rules that came into
force, requiring environmental clearance, and was therefore beyond the control
of the petitioner.
5.1 The learned counsel, by placing reliance on the order dated
04.04.2016 of the Honourable Supreme Court of India in Common Cause v.
Union of India and Others, reported in (2016) 11 SCC 455, would submit that,
having been found eligible for deemed extension, the petitioner’s leases would
lapse only upon an express order to that effect. Therefore, the petitioner made
__________
Page10 of 22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:4101
WP Nos. 49325 & 49330 of 2025
the applications for non-lapse before the lease lapsed. In any event, the two-year
period will not start running until the grant of environmental clearance. The
learned counsel would rely upon the judgment of JSW Steel Limited v. Union
of India and Others in W.P. (Civil) No. 4817 of 2022 for the said proposition.
The learned counsel would then rely on G.O. (3D) No. 12 dated 15.07.2024,
where, under identical circumstances, the lease was treated as non-lapsed in
respect of Murali Enterprises, and would plead that different and discriminatory
treatment is adopted only against the petitioner. The respondents did not even
consider the petitioner's non-lapse application, and it must be seen that they
took an unduly long time to process the environmental clearance application. He
would therefore contend that the impugned order is a non-speaking order and
stands vitiated.
5.2 Per contra, Dr.R.Gouri, the learned Special Government Pleader
appearing for the respondent, would contend that the two-year period is
statutory and begins to run once mining operations are stopped. Obtaining
environmental clearance is a legal obligation known to the petitioner and to the
similarly situated mine operators, who chose to take the risk by opting for
protracted litigation rather than applying for environmental clearance while
submitting the renewal application. Therefore, if their calculations and
strategies ultimately fail, it cannot be said that the reason was beyond the
petitioner's control. Only because the petitioners failed to obtain environmental
__________
Page11 of 22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:4101
WP Nos. 49325 & 49330 of 2025
clearance did their leases lapse in 2018; to claim non-lapse, the application
should have been made three months before the date of lapse. Nothing
prevented the petitioner from making the application. The application was made
only after seven years, in the year 2025. Therefore, this is not a case where this
Court should interfere. With reference to the G.O. granted in respect of Murali
Enterprises, she would submit that unless the petitioner establishes a right under
the Rules, relying on the order granted to Murali Enterprises would only
perpetuate the illegality.
5.3 The learned Special Government Pleader appearing for the respondent
would rely upon the judgment of the Full Bench of this Court in Government of
Tamil Nadu vs. P.L.S.Palaniappan and others(2026 MHC 2255). The learned
Special Government Pleader would also rely upon the judgment of the Supreme
Court of India in Sulekhan Singh & Co. and Others v. State of U.P. and
Others, reported in 2016(3) CTC 758, to contend that the State is expected to
act in a prudent manner and that no one had a vested right in these cases for
extension, renewal, non-lapse etc.
E. Analysis & Findings:
6. I have considered the rival submissions made on either side and
perused the material records of the case.
__________
Page12 of 22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:4101
WP Nos. 49325 & 49330 of 2025
6.1 Firstly, it can be seen that both the leases of the petitioner were
granted in the year 1994/1995 for a period of 20 years in respect of limestone
and were to expire in the year 2014-2015. The petitioner had made the
application for renewal well before the period of one year before the date of
expiry, and as such, it can be seen that the petitioner is entitled to the deemed
extension under the amended Section 8A(3)(6) of the MMDR Act. This position
is no longer res integra and has been admitted and declared by the Honourable
Supreme Court of India in Common Cause v. Union of India, reported in
(2016) 11 SCC 455. More specifically, in paragraph Nos. 37, 37.1, 37.2, 37.4
and 37.6, the same is extracted hereunder:
“37. Based on the considerations recorded above, we
summarise our conclusions as under:
37.1 A leaseholder would have a subsisting mining lease, if
the period of the original grant was still in currency on
12.1.2015. Additionally, a leaseholder whose original lease has
since expired, would still have a subsisting lease, if the original
lease having been renewed, the renewal period was still in
currency on 12.1.2015. Such a leaseholder, would be entitled to
the benefit of Section 8A of the amended MMDR Act.
37.2 A leaseholder who had not moved an application for
renewal of a mining lease (which was due to expire, prior to
__________
Page13 of 22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:4101
WP Nos. 49325 & 49330 of 2025
12.1.2015), at least twelve months before the existing lease was
due to expire, under the provisions of the unamended MMDR
Act and the Mineral Concession Rules, will be considered as
not a valid/subsisting leaseholder, after the expiry of the lease
period. The provisions of the amended MMDR Act will
therefore not enure to the benefit of such leaseholder.
37.4 A leaseholder who has moved an application for “first
renewal” of the original mining lease, at least twelve months
before the original lease was due to expire, and such
application has not been rejected, will be considered to be a
valid leaseholder having a subsisting right to carry on mining
operations, till the expiry of two years after 18.7.2014, i.e., up
to 17.7.2016, as is apparent from a conjoint reading of the
unamended and amended Rule 24-A of the Mineral Concession
Rules. Such leaseholder would have the benefit of sub-sections
(5) and (6) of Section 8A of the amended MMDR Act.
37.6 Consequent upon the amendment of Section 8-A of the
MMDR Act, the regime introduced through sub-sections (5) and
(6) thereof, provides for three contingencies where benefits
have been extended to leaseholders whose lease period had
earlier been extended by a renewal. Firstly, for a leaseholder
whose renewal period had expired before 12.1.2015, and the
leaseholder had moved an application for renewal at least
twelve months before the leaseholder’s existing lease was due to
expire, and whose application has not been considered and
rejected, the lease period would stand extended up to
__________
Page14 of 22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:4101
WP Nos. 49325 & 49330 of 2025
31.3.2030/31.3.2020 (in the case of captive/non-captive mines,
respectively). Additionally, a leaseholder whose period of
renewal
would
expire
after
12.1.2015,
but
before
31.3.2030/31.3.2020, the lease period would stand extended up
to 31.3.2030/31.3.2020 (in the case of captive/non-captive
mines, respectively). Secondly, where the renewal of the mining
lease already extends to a period beyond 31.3.2030/31.3.2020
(in the case of captive/non-captive mines, respectively), the
lease period of such leaseholders, would continue up to the
actual period contemplated by the renewal order. Thirdly, a
leaseholder would have the benefit of treating the original lease
period as of fifty years. Accordingly, even during the renewal
period, if the period of the mining lease would get extended
(beyond the renewal period) by treating the original lease as of
fifty years, the leaseholder would be entitled to such benefit.
Out of the above three contingencies provided under subsections (5) and (6) of Section 8A, the contingency as would
extend the lease period farthest, would enure to the benefit of
the leaseholder.”
6.2 Thus, during the currency of the lease, the extraction and transport of
minerals ceased in the year 2016 because the petitioner did not possess
environmental clearance. As per Section 4A(4), if mining operations are
discontinued for a period of two years, the lease shall lapse on the expiry of two
years from the date of discontinuance of the mining operations. However, on an
application made by the holder of the lease before its expiry, and upon being
satisfied about the reasons adduced by the licensee that it was not possible for
__________
Page15 of 22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:4101
WP Nos. 49325 & 49330 of 2025
the licensee to undertake mining operations or that it was beyond his control,
the State Government can order that the lease shall not lapse. Further, under the
second proviso, the leaseholder may also apply within six months of the lease
lapsing by adducing reasons and upon being satisfied that non-commencement
or discontinuance was due to reasons beyond the control of the leaseholder, the
Government can revive the lease from such prospective or retrospective date,
but not earlier than the date of lapse.
6.3 In this regard, Rule 28 of the MC Rules, 2016 mandates that the State
Government shall, by an order, declare that the mining lease has lapsed and
communicate the declaration to the lessee in such cases. The Honourable
Supreme Court of India, in Common Cause, considered the issue of when the
lease would lapse and, after considering the above provisions, held in paragraph
35 that the mining lease, as per Section 4A(4), would not be deemed to have
lapsed till the State Government passes an order declaring the mining lease to
have lapsed and further communicates the same to the leaseholder. The relevant
portion of paragraph 35 is extracted hereunder for ready reference.
“It is apparent from a perusal of sub-rule (1) extracted
above, that the State Government is mandated to pass an
order, and thereby, declare that a mining lease had lapsed.
It is also the mandate of sub-rule (1) aforesaid, that such an
order
passed
by
the
State
Government,
must
be
communicated to the leaseholder. On a conjoint reading of
__________
Page16 of 22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:4101
WP Nos. 49325 & 49330 of 2025
Section 4-A(4) and Rule 28(1), we are satisfied to hold, that
a mining lease under Section 4-A(4) would not be deemed to
have lapsed, till the State Government passes an order,
declaring the mining lease to have lapsed, and further
communicates the same to the leaseholder.”
(Emphasis supplied)
6.4 In view thereof, in this case, the order was passed by the State
Government only by the orders impugned in the writ petitions, that is, vide G.O.
(Ms.) Nos. 78 and 79 dated 31.10.2025. Thus, the application for non-lapse was
made before the said date. In this regard, it is essential to extract Rule 20(3) of
the MC Rules, 2016, as it stands after the amendment in the year 2021:
“(3) Where a lessee is unable to commence the
production and dispatch within a period of two years from
the date of execution of mining lease or discontinuation of
production and dispatch for reasons beyond its control, he
may submit an application to the State Government,
explaining the reasons for the same and stating the time
required, at least three months before the expiry of such
period of two years;
Provided that where the lessee has failed to make the
application within the time stipulated above due to reasons
beyond his control but has made application before the
lapse of lease under sub-rule(1), the State Government may
condone the delay in making the application and in such
case the State Government shall pass an order under sub__________
Page17 of 22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:4101
WP Nos. 49325 & 49330 of 2025
section(6) before the lapse of lease;
Provided further that where the lessee has failed to
make the application within the time stipulated above or
delay in making the application has not been condoned by
the State Government, the lease shall lapse in accordance
with sub-rule(1).”
6.5 In this case, the two-year period expires in January 2018. As per Rule
20(3), the lessee should have made the non-lapse application at least three
months before expiry, but it did not. However, as per the proviso, the lessee is
given an option where, even though he has not made the application within the
stipulated time, if he has made the application before the lapse of the lease, the
State Government may condone the delay in making the application and
proceed to pass an order under sub-rule (6). That is, after examining the
adequacy and genuineness of the reasons for the non-commencement of
production and dispatch or discontinuance thereof, the State Government may
pass an order within three years from the date of such request.
6.6 In the present case, the fee was paid with reference to both leases on
24.10.2024, and the applications were made on 22.01.2025. The applications
were made before the written order was passed by the State Government, and as
such, the State Government ought to have considered the applications with
__________
Page18 of 22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:4101
WP Nos. 49325 & 49330 of 2025
reference to two aspects: first, condonation of delay in filing the applications,
and upon being satisfied with the adequacy of the reasons as mentioned in the
rule, thereafter further examine the reasons for non-extraction of the minerals
and the stopping of the activity, and if only they find an acceptable reason as per
sub-rule (6), can pass the non-lapse order, as the case may be.
6.7 It is evident that the applications filed by the petitioner were
completely ignored, and the impugned government orders refer only to the
proposal and recommendation of the District Collector and the Director. The
Government’s earlier letter requesting the petitioner's appearance does not even
take into account the application submitted by the petitioner. Further, in
paragraph 4, in a single sentence, it is stated that the lessee had failed to submit
the application to the State Government within the time stipulated under Rule
20(3) of the MC Rules, 2016, and the orders simply proceed to accept the
proposal of the Collector and the recommendation of the Director of Geology
and Mining. The respondent ought to have considered the petitioner's
application under the proviso to Rule 20(3), inasmuch as the application was
made well before the written order was passed declaring the petitioner's lease as
having lapsed.
6.8 With reference to the other contentions, namely, whether the
petitioner has a reasonable cause for the delay in making the application,
__________
Page19 of 22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:4101
WP Nos. 49325 & 49330 of 2025
whether the delay is fit to be condoned, and whether the stoppage of the quarry
was for reasons beyond the control of the petitioner, the matter has to be
decided by the first respondent in accordance with law, and therefore this Court
is not expressing any opinion on the same.
F. The Result:
7. In view thereof, these writ petitions are allowed on the following
terms:
(i) G.O.Ms.No.78 dated 31.10.2025 and G.O.Ms.No. 79 dated 31.10.2025
shall stand quashed;
(ii) The matter shall stand remanded to the file of the respondent for fresh
consideration;
(iii) The respondent shall first consider the merits or otherwise of the
applications dated 22.01.2025 made by the petitioner to treat the leases as not
having lapsed under the proviso to Rule 20(3) of the MC Rules, 2016 and pass
orders thereon in accordance with law; The said exercise shall be carried out
within three months from the date of receipt of the web copy of the order.
__________
Page20 of 22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:4101
WP Nos. 49325 & 49330 of 2025
(iv) Depending on the decision on the petitioner's applications, the
consequential orders regarding the lapsing or non-lapsing of the leases shall be
passed either in a composite order or in a separate order, as the case may be.
(iv) Consequently, connected miscellaneous petitions are closed. No
costs.
06.10.2026
Index: Yes
Speaking Order
NSL
To
The Additional Chief Secretary,
Natural Resources Department,
Namakkal Kavignar Maligai,
Fort St. George, Chennai - 600 009.
__________
Page21 of 22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:4101
WP Nos. 49325 & 49330 of 2025
D.BHARATHA CHAKRAVARTHY J.
NSL
WP Nos. 49325 & 49330 of 2025
and
WMP Nos. 55096 & 55099 of 2025
06.10.2026
__________
Page22 of 22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review