Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
WP No.123 of 2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
Reserved on : 17-06-2026
Pronounced on : 21-09-2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE MOHAMMED SHAFFIQ
WP No.123 of 2026
and
WMP Nos.109 and 111 of 2026
Air India SATS Airport Services Private Limited
Having its Registered Office at A-18 Street No.2,
Mahipalpur, New Delhi-110 037.
through Its Authorised Signatory
Mr. Virendra Gupta
..Petitioner(s)
Vs
1. Union of India
Through Ministry of Civil Aviation,
Represented by its Secretary,
Rajiv Gandhi Bhawan, Block-B, Jor Bagh,
Safdarjung Airport Area, New Delhi- 110 003.
2. Airports Authority of India
Having its Principal Office at
Rajiv Gandhi Bhawan, Safdarjung Airport,
New Delhi-110 003.
3. Airport Authority of India
Through Regional Executive Director,
Southern Region, Having Regional
Headquarters at Anna International Airport,
Chennai- 600 027.
4. Chennai International Airport
Through its Airport Director, Great Southern
Trunk Road, Meenambakkam, Chennai,
Tamil Nadu – 600 027, India.
..Respondent(s)
__________
Page1 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
PRAYER: Writ Petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India,
praying for a writ of Certiorarified Mandamus, to call for the records of the
respondent Nos.2 and 3, relating to the Tender ID.2025-AAI-256733-1 dated 12
December, 2025 and quash clause 2.2.1(f) contained thereunder and
consequential direct respondent Nos.2 to 4 to receive, consider and evaluate the
bid of the petitioner in accordance with the other conditions imposed in Tender
ID.2025-AAI-256733-1 dated 12 December, 2025.
For Petitioner(s):
Mr. Sankaranarayanan,
Senior Counsel and
Mr. P.V.Balasubramanian,
Senior Counsel
for Mr.Thriyambak J.Kannan
For Respondent(s):
Mr.A.R.L.Sundaresan,
Additional Solicitor General of India
Assisted by Mr.Arun C.Mohan,
Mr.K.Venkatesan, for R2 to R4
ORDER
The present writ petition has been filed to quash Clause 2.2.1(f)
("hereinafter
referred
to
as
“Impugned
ID:2025_AAI_256733_1 dated 12 December 2025,
Clause")
of
Tender
issued by Respondent
Nos.2 and 3, and consequently direct Respondent Nos. 2 to 4 to receive,
consider and evaluate the bid of petitioner.
2. Brief Facts:
2.1.
Petitioner is a 50-50 Joint Venture between Air India Limited, and
SATS Limited. Petitioner is the largest “Ground Handling Service Provider”,
__________
Page2 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
in India, having valid contracts with various airlines, across multiple airports in
India. Petitioner is not an "Airline Operator" but a “Ground Handling Services
Agency”.
2.2. Petitioner was incorporated on 20th April 2010, with main objects
inter-alia being establishment, development and carrying on all aspects of
airport and air transport handling services including, inter alia, ground handling
business connected with air terminal services, passenger handling services,
ramp handling services, cargo handling services, baggage handling services,
aircraft interior cleaning services, technical ramp services, cabin services, apron
services, aircraft dispatch services, load control services, flight operation
services, aircraft loading services, departure control services, flight preparation
services, in-flight assistance, post flight activities, passenger lounge operation
services, and liaison and administrative services.
2.3.
At the time of incorporation of Petitioner as a Private Limited
Company in 2010, 50% of the shares was owned by Air India (Government of
India), a Public Sector Undertaking. After its disinvestment in 2022, petitioner's
shareholding continues to be held equally by Air India Limited, now part of
Tata Group of Companies, along with Joint Venture Partner, SATS Limited.
2.4.
It is stated that petitioner is a globally recognized accredited
“Ground Handling Agency”, currently providing “Ground Handling Services”,
at 6 (Six) leading airports in India viz. Bengaluru, Hyderabad, Delhi,
Thiruvananthapuram, Mangalore, and Cochin.
__________
Page3 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
2.5. Petitioner provides “Cargo Handling Services”, at Ranchi and
Raipur. Airports at Ranchi and Raipur are run by subsidiaries of Respondent
No. 2, AAI-Cargo Logistics and Allied Services Company Limited. Petitioner
is currently establishing a Multi-modal Cargo Hub at NOIDA's Jewar Airport,
integrating multiple modes of transportation with consolidated ancillary and
value-added services.
2.6. Clause similar to impugned clause was included in previous tender
for Ground Handling Services at Chennai Airport in IS 2025_AAI_240128_1
dated 03 July 2025 ("Previous Tender"). The said clause was challenged in
W.P. No. 27390 of 2025. When the case came up for hearing on 13.08.2025,
this court disposed of the Writ Petition by giving liberty to the Petitioner to
submit their bid and the second and third respondents therein were directed to
receive and deal the tender in accordance with the Request For Proposal, no
finding was rendered on validity of the clause.
2.7 It must be made clear that respondent would however contradict the
same by submitting that no such undertaking was given before this court.
Shortly thereafter, Petitioner's bid was rejected relying on the above
disqualification clause contained in the Previous Tender. Petitioner initiated
contempt proceedings for violating the judgment dated 13.08.2025 against
Respondents No. 2, 3 and 4 in Contempt Petition No. 4229 of 2025. The said
Contempt Petition was closed by this court vide order dated 13.03.2026.
__________
Page4 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
2.8. As stated supra petitioner's shareholding continues to be held equally
by Air India Limited, now part of TATA Group of Companies, along with Joint
Venture Partner, SATS Limited, whileso respondent Nos. 2 and 3 issued Tender
[ID:2025_AAI_256733_1 dated 12 December 2025], containing Clause 2.2.1.
(f) which provides that no bidder shall be:
(i) a scheduled or non-scheduled air carrier; or
(ii) any entity in which a scheduled or non-scheduled air carrier, or
its promoter(s), directly or indirectly holds any interest; or
(iii) any entity which is otherwise an associate of a scheduled air carrier
2.9. By virtue of Clause 2.2.1(f) as AISATS petitioner being a 50:50 joint
venture between Air India Limited and SATS Limited stands disqualified.The
present writ petition is filed challenging Clause 2.2.(1)(f).
3. Case of petitioner:
a. Clause 2.2.1.(f) provides that no bidder shall be:
(i) a scheduled or non-scheduled air carrier; or
(ii) any entity in which a scheduled or non-scheduled air
carrier, or its promoter(s), directly or indirectly holds any
interest; or
(iii) any entity which is otherwise an associate of a scheduled
air carrier
__________
Page5 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
b. Petitioner is not an airline operator but operates solely as a ground
handling agency. This would be evident from the fact that petitioner does not
have an Airline Operator License issued by Directorate General of Civil
Aviation ("DGCA"), which is essential to operate as an Air Line Operator.
Petitioner has obtained clearance from Bureau of Civil Aviation and Security
("BCAS"), essential for Ground Handling Agency.
c. That restriction/ ineligibility prescribed in terms of Clause 2.2.1.(f) of
Tender which imposes restrictions for participating in the tender is not traceable
to Airport Authority of India Act, 1994 or 2023 Regulations, that governs
provision of Ground Handling Services. In other words, there is no legal basis
for the impugned clause. Impugned clause does not align with other clauses of
the subject tender.
d. Impugned clause prohibits petitioner from participating in tender
issued by 2nd and 3rd Respondents, in effect excluding it from Ground
Handling Business, despite its proven expertise and track record. This
constitutes a direct violation of Petitioner's Fundamental Rights under Article
19(1)(g), as it would drive the Petitioner out of business in this sector,
foreclosing legitimate commercial opportunities without due process or
reasonable justification.
e. That impugned clause is not a mere eligibility stipulation, but also a
prohibitive disqualification which results in excluding Petitioner and any other
__________
Page6 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
similarly functioning Ground Handling Agency. Restriction operates at
threshold on account of its shareholding structure, even without finding any
misconduct, demonstrated airport-specific harm nor is such exclusion based on
a Regulation. Clause of this nature is ex facie arbitrary, disproportionate and
fails the test of reasonableness under Article 14 and Article 19(1)(g) of the
Constitution of India, 1950.
f. That attempt by respondent to justify impugned clause on the premise
that it is meant to avoid “conflict of interest”, in the absence of any material
much less verifiable data being placed by Respondents in support thereof, but is
based on conjectures and baseless apprehension is arbitrary thereby offends
Article 14. Arbitrariness is even more evident and glaring if one bears in mind
petitioner's established track record, and the availability of contractual
enforcement measures including monitoring, penalties and termination under
the concession framework, an absolute bar is manifestly disproportionate.
Restriction imposed vide impugned clause is manifestly arbitrary, baseless,
unreasonable fails to pass the muster under Article 14 of the Constitution of
India.
g. Impugned clause has the effect of closing down the business of the
Petitioner, for the sole reason that its shareholder is an Airline, a restriction not
contained in any statute, rule or regulation governing “Ground Handling
__________
Page7 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
Operations”. Restriction being absolute, does not pass the test of reasonableness
as contemplated under Article 19(1)(g) of the Constitution of India.
h. That impugned clause is not made applicable to cargo handling tenders,
where Petitioner demonstrated competence, imposition of such restriction
selectively only with regard to ground handling services is irrationale and
arbitrary. That such differential treatment lacks any nexus with the object of
tender, rendering the clause discriminatory, unreasonable and violative of
Article 14 of the Constitution of India, 1950.
i. That petitioner stands disqualified only on the premise that 50% of
petitioners shares are held by Air India taken over by TATA group of
companies pursuant to disinvestment thereby attracting the disqualification
under Clause 2.2.1.(f) of tender, as an entity in which a scheduled or nonscheduled air carrier, or its promoter(s), directly or indirectly holds any interest.
j. Neither AAI Act, 2018 or 2023 Regulations disqualifies an entity in
which a Scheduled Air Carrier or a Non-Scheduled Carrier or its Promoter(s)
directly or indirectly holds any interest or is otherwise an Associate of a
Scheduled Air Carrier from participating in the bidding process for appointment
as a Ground Handling Agency for AAI Airports across the country. There is no
explanation/reason provided for such disqualification clause in the tender.
k. That the term 'any interest' in the impugned clause is not defined and
is therefore vague and arbitrary. Basis for introduction of the term "any interest"
__________
Page8 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
in Clause 2.2.1(f) of the Tender is not provided, thereby rendering it open to
abuse.
l. "Associate" is defined to mean in relation to the Bidder/Consortium
member, a person who controls, is controlled by, or is under common control
with such Bidder/Consortium. Control is then defined to mean with respect to a
Company or Corporation the ownership directly or indirectly, of more than 50
per cent of the voting share of such person. The same yardstick ought to be
applied while considering the disqualification of an entity in which a Scheduled
Air Carrier or a Non-Scheduled Carrier or its Promoter(s) directly or indirectly
holds “any interest” to mean an entity holding more than 50 per cent stake
thereon. Applying the above logic/reasoning petitioners shall not stand
disqualified inasmuch as only 50 per cent of the shares is admittedly held by
Air India now taken over Tata Groups.
m. Clause 2.2.1(f) in effect is ultra vires the Regulation itself. Any
restriction contained in the Tender, necessarily ought to be in confirmity with
applicable Regulations. Respondents are bound by the powers conferred to it
under applicable laws and cannot seek to introduce a limitation or restriction
that is not contained in the Regulations.
n. Petitioner has been in existence since 2010 providing Ground Handling
Services. At the time of disinvestment of Government of India in Air India,
Petitioner was under legitimate belief that it would be allowed to participate in
__________
Page9 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
tenders where ground handling services were being offered by an airport under
the auspices of Respondent No. 2 and/ or a private airport operator.
o. That while Regulation 3 of 2018 Regulations, provided petitioner an
assured position as a Ground Handling Agency being a Joint Venture of Air
India. Consequent to 2023 Regulations said right/privilege was taken away.
However, petitioner like every other entity which wanted to offer ground
handling services at airports, was entitled to participate in tender process and be
selected in a manner that uniformly applied to all.
p. That the only disqualification provided under 2018 and 2023
Regulations was covered in Regulation 3(6), which provided that any Ground
Handling Agency, with foreign ownership of fifty percent or more of its paid-up
capital would not be allowed to undertake such services at a Civil Enclave,
beyond that no other restriction is contemplated except for a “transparent
bidding process”. Importantly, even under 2023 Regulations introduced after
disinvestment of Air India, there was no bar against petitioner's participating in
tenders.
q. Respondent’s contention that similar clause relating to conflict of
interest was part of various other tenders since 2020 is factually incorrect, that
apart, contention that no challenge was made to similar provisions in the earlier
tenders, thus, Petitioner is estopped from challenging the same overlooks the
fact that impugned clause could have been in any tender only after passing of
the 2023 Regulations and not prior thereto. Respondents failed to substantiate
__________
Page10 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
that similar clause was employed in previous tenders by producing any material
to support. Further, petitioner did not participate in prior tenders, thus there was
no occasion to challenge the same. In any view failure to challenge a tender
clause which is otherwise arbitrary would not preclude petitioner from
challenging the clause in present Tender.
3.1.
Petitioner relied on following precedents which hold that
unreasonable tender conditions are arbitrary:
a. Mahesh Varma and anr. Vs State of Maharashtra and others, 2008
SCC OnLine Bom 327, Refer Paragraphs 24 to 29
b. Balajee Electrosteels Company (P) Ltd. v. Bokaro Steel Plant,
2009 SCC OnLine Jhar 666, Refer Paragraphs 22 to 23, 27 to 30
c. Jagruti Welfare Organization v. State of Odisha, 2017 SCC
OnLine Ori 485, Refer Paragraph 40
d. Icomm Tele Limited Vs. Punjab State Water Supply and Sewerage
Boad and anr., (2019) 4 SCC 401, Refer Paragraphs 20-28
e. Gwalior Distilleries (P) Ltd. v. State of M.P., (2020) 12 SCC 690,
Refer Paragraphs 8 to 9
f. Rosmerta Technologies Ltd. v. State of Odisha, 2024 SCC OnLine
Ori 1593, Refer Paragraphs 48 to 56
g. Vinishma Technologies Pvt. Ltd. V. State of Chattisgarh and anr.,
2025 SCC OnLine SC 2119, Refer Paragraphs 18 to 20
h. M/s. Watergate Products Vs. Nashik Municipal Corporation &
Ors., Writ Petition No. 701 of 2025, Refer Paragraphs 19 to 20
__________
Page11 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
i. M/S Vishal Pharmaceutical Laboratories Vs. The State Of Madhya
Pradesh & ors., Writ Petition No. 612 of 2025, Refer Paragraphs
23 b to 24
3.2. Petitioner would submit that state actions which are an absolute
restriction must be tested against Article 19(1)(g) of the Constitution of India,
and that restriction, while cannot be absolute, would also need to pass the test of
proportionality. In this regard, the following judgments was relied on by the
Petitioner:
j. Chintamanrao v. State of M.P., 1950 SCC 695, Refer Paragraphs
10 to 13
k. Mohd. Yasin v. Town Area Committee, (1952) 1 SCC 205, Refer
Paragraph s 20 to 21
l. Akshay N. Patel v. RBI, (2022) 3 SCC 694, Refer Paragraph 21 &
3.3. Petitioner, also relied on the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court
in the following judgment with regard to manner of
interpretation of
contractual obligations.
m. Nabha Power Ltd. v. Punjab SPCL, (2018) 11 SCC 508, Refer
Paragraph 49
4.Case of Respondent:
4.1.
That Regulation 3 of 2023 Regulations provides that Domestic
Scheduled Airline Operators and Scheduled Helicopter Operators are permitted
to carry out Ground Handling Activities “solely”, for the purpose of “selfhandling” at all airports including civil enclaves.
__________
Page12 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
4.2 That in airports with annual passenger throughput of 10 (ten) million
passengers or above, airport operator shall ensure that there are 3 (three) ground
handling agencies including those appointed through a transparent bidding
process. That petitioner being a flight operator, it cannot attempt to wear two
hats of being a Ground Handling Agency and Flight/Air Line Operator.
Petitioner is disqualified under Clause 2.2.1(f) inasmuch as AISATS is a 50:50
joint venture between Air India Limited and SATS Limited.
4.3. That post disinvestment of Air India, 2023 amendment regulations
were notified, "to ensure competitiveness", "to facilitate a level playing field",
"to avoid conflict of interest", "to prevent cartelisation", "to prevent
compromise in standard operating procedures", and "to avoid potential breaches
in Service Level Agreements".
4.4.
That Clause 2.2.1(f) of Tender has been included to prevent
conflict of interest between user airlines and appointed ground handling
agencies. That if a ground handling agency provides ground handling to an
airline which holds "any interest" in such ground handling agency (or is its
associate), it may lead to conflict of interest and may adversely affect the
revenue share due to AAI, including by provision of services at a discounted
rate.
4.5. That if a bidder associated /having interest in an airline which has a
substantial traffic share at the airport, it could potentially leverage such
__________
Page13 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
relationship to secure a portion of the ground handling market. Impugned
Clause 2.2.1(f) prevents potential conflicts of interest associated with an airline
having an equity interest in an upstream airline supply chain service provider.
4.6. AAI has awarded Ground Handling Services concessions at 87
airports since 2021 with a uniform conflict of interest clause, and that Petitioner
did not raise objections to this clause in earlier tenders (2019–2022).
Respondents would submit that above conduct establishes a precedent of
acceptance.
4.7. Following are some of the previous tenders relied on by the
Respondents, tabulated for reference, which shows that similar clause being
employed even prior to the 2023, Airport Authority of India (hereinafter "AAI")
had issued several tenders since 2020 including those are mentioned hereunder:
Details of Previous tender
Sl. Group
No.
Airport
Tender ID
Kolkata
2023_AAI_151634_1 13.04.2023 NIL bid
received
even after
02(two)
auto
extensions
by CPP
Portal
A
Published
Date
Remarks
__________
Page14 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
A
Kolkata
A
Goa
10 Group
D
Airports
Gaggal
(Kangra),
Porbandar,
Cuddapah,
Rajahmundry,
Deoghar,
Jharsuguda,
Keshod,
Diu,
Gondia, &
Kandla.
Bareilly,
Bathinda &
Pathankot
03 Group
D
Airports
(Civil
Enclaves)
C
Dehradun
C
Bhopal
2023_AAI_177470_1 12.12.2023 NIL bid
received
even after
02 (two)
auto
extensions
by CPP
Portal
2023_AAI_151640_1 13.04.2023 NIL Bid
received
even after
02 (two)
auto
extensions
by CPP
Portal
2024_AAI_189588_1 06.03.2024 LOIAS
issued
2024_AAI_189587_1 06.03.2024 LOIAS
issued
2024_AAI_204181_1 08.08.2024 LOIAS
issued
2024_AAI_207093_1 01.10.2024 LOIAS
issued
__________
Page15 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
C
Ranchi
C
Vijayawada
B
Srinagar
B
Indore
C
Vadodara
D
Jodhpur
2024_AAI_212157_1 22.10.2024 LOIAS
issued
2024_AAI_212075_1 23.10.2024 Under
process
2024_AAI_214975_1 20.11.2024 LOIAS
issued
2024_AAI_217735_1 06.12.2024 LOIAS
issued
2025_AAI_225632_1 06.02.2025 Under
process
2025_AAI_234131_1 30.04.2025 Under
process
4.8. That tender inviting authority, may prescribe its own conditions for
appointment of ground handling agencies. There are no guidelines or
instructions in the AAI Act or the 2023 Regulations for fixation of criteria in
RFPs for appointment of ground handling agencies.
4.9. Respondents would clarify that no "oral undertaking" was given that
Clause 2.2.1(f) would not be applied in W.P. No. 27390 of 2025 nor any finding
rendered on the scope and ambit of Clause 2.2.1(f) of the Tender.
4.10. Petitioner has written to the Respondent vide letter dated
30.06.2025 seeking amendment of the clause, which would show that petitioner
was conscious and understood that in terms of impugned clause, they stand
disqualified.
4.11. That scope of judicial review with regard to challenge to tender
clauses is narrow and limited inasmuch invitation to tender is in the realm of a
__________
Page16 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
contract. Government must have freedom of contract. Government and its
undertakings must have a free hand, in setting terms of the tender. Interference
is limited only if it is shown that clause impugned is arbitrary, discriminatory,
mala fide, actuated by bias. It is necessary to bear in mind that courts do not
have the expertise to substitute terms of tender for it will be substitution of
terms by courts without necessary expertise which itself might be fallible nor
would courts interfere because in the view of the court it feels some other terms
in the tender would have been fair, wiser or logical. In support of the above
proposition relied on several decisions inter alia including the following:Sl.
No.
Citation
2005 (1) SCC 679 - Association of Registration
Plates v. Union of India & Others
2005 (4) SCC 435 - Global Energy Ltd v. Adani
Exports
2008 (16) SCC 215 - Siemens Public
Communication Network v. Union of India
2012 (8) SCC 216 - Michigan Rubber (India) Ltd v.
State of Karnataka
2016 (15) SCC 272-Monte Carlo Ltd v. National
Thermal Power Corporation Ltd.
2017 (4) SCC 318 TANGEDCO v. CSEPDI-Trishe
Consortium
2020 (16) SCC 489 Silppi Constructions Contractors
v. Union of India
2022 (1) SCC 165 Uflex Ltd v. Government of Tamil
Nadu
2022 (13) SCC 256 State of Uttarakhand v. Sudhir
Budakoti
__________
Page17 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
2022 (16) SCC 633 State of Madhya Pradesh v. Uttar
Pradesh State Bridge Corporation
2023 SCC Online Bom 2238-Minakshi Traders v.
State of Maharashtra
5. Heard both sides. Perused materials on record.
6. Discussion:
Before proceeding further it may be relevant to note that the controversy
is fairly narrow and limited to the scope of restriction imposed vide impugned
clause, giving rise to following questions of law:
(I) Whether Ground Handling Agency is a class by itself, if so, any subclassification of Ground Handling Agency would offend Article 14 of
Constitution of India.
(II) Whether petitioner’s disqualification vide 2023 Regulation in the
absence of such disqualification under 2018 Regulation is permissible.
(III) Whether 2023 Regulation can be understood as imposing a fetter on
contractual freedom of government by sub-classifying Ground Handling
Agency, if so, permissible.
(IV) Whether impugned clause is introduced without any basis/irrational.
6.1. Before proceeding to deal with the above questions it may be
relevant to note that thrust of the petitioner’s arguments is that judicial review is
permissible even with reference to challenge to the clause in a tender if it is
__________
Page18 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
shown to be manifestly arbitrary, actuated by malice and unreasonable. In
support of the above contention petitioner relied upon number of decisions. 1
There can be no two views about the said proposition. However, question arises
as to whether the impugned clause suffers from any of the above vice
warranting interference.
6.2. Before I proceed to deal with the above questions, it may be relevant
to note the following aspects:
7. Undisputed facts:
a. Petitioner is a 50-50 Joint Venture between Air India Limited, and
SATS Limited. Petitioner is the largest “Ground Handling Service Provider”,
in India, having valid contracts with various airlines, across multiple airports in
India. Petitioner is not an "Airline Operator" but a “Ground Handling Services
Agency”.
a. Mahesh Varma and anr. Vs State of Maharashtra and others, 2008 SCC OnLine Bom
327, Refer Paragraphs 24 to 29
b. Balajee Electrosteels Company (P) Ltd. v. Bokaro Steel Plant, 2009 SCC OnLine
Jhar 666, Refer Paragraphs 22 to 23, 27 to 30
c. Jagruti Welfare Organization v. State of Odisha, 2017 SCC OnLine Ori 485, Refer
Paragraph 40
d. Icomm Tele Limited Vs. Punjab State Water Supply and Sewerage Boad and anr.,
(2019) 4 SCC 401, Refer Paragraphs 20-28
e. Gwalior Distilleries (P) Ltd. v. State of M.P., (2020) 12 SCC 690, Refer Paragraphs 8
to 9
f.
Rosmerta Technologies Ltd. v. State of Odisha, 2024 SCC OnLine Ori 1593, Refer
Paragraphs 48 to 56
g. Vinishma Technologies Pvt. Ltd. V. State of Chattisgarh and anr., 2025 SCC OnLine
SC 2119, Refer Paragraphs 18 to 20
h. M/s. Watergate Products Vs. Nashik Municipal Corporation & Ors., Writ Petition
No. 701 of 2025, Refer Paragraphs 19 to 20
i.
M/S Vishal Pharmaceutical Laboratories Vs. The State Of Madhya Pradesh & ors.,
Writ Petition No. 612 of 2025, Refer Paragraphs 23 b to 24
__________
Page19 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
b. After its disinvestment in 2022, petitioner's shareholding continues to
be held equally by Air India Limited, now part of TATA Group of Companies,
along with Joint Venture Partner, SATS Limited.
c. Petitioner falls within the disqualification clause in terms of Clause
2.2.1.(f) of tender inasmuch as petitioner is 50:50 Joint Venture between Air
India Limited and SATS Limited. Thus, stands disqualified being an entity in
which a scheduled or non-scheduled air carrier, or its promoter(s), directly or
indirectly holding interest.
8. Preliminary objection:
A preliminary objection was raised questioning the locus of petitioner to
challenge impugned clause on the premise that though similar clause was
contained in earlier tenders, however no challenge was made, petitioner must
thus be understood to have waived its right to challenge. The above submission
only needs to be noticed to be rejected for more than one reason viz;
a. The case of petitioner is that by virtue of the impugned clause
petitioners Fundamental Right guaranteed under Article 19(1)(g) of the
Constitution is offended, that being the case the above objection cannot
be sustained inasmuch as there can be no waiver of Fundamental right.2
b. Secondly, each tender gives rise to a fresh cause of action.
See Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Basher Nath Vs The Commissioner of Income Tax, AIR
1959 SC 149 wherein it wsas held that waiver has no application in the case of Fundamental Rights.
__________
Page20 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
c. Thirdly, whether earlier tenders contained similar clause is itself a
matter of dispute.
Preliminary objections lack merit and thus stands rejected.
9. I shall now proceed to examine the scope of impugned clause. It may
be relevant rather necessary to extract the impugned clause which reads as
under:
"(f) No Bidder shall be a Scheduled or/and non-scheduled air
carrier or any entity in which a scheduled air carrier or nonscheduled carrier or its promoter(s) directly or indirectly holds any
interest or is otherwise an Associate of a scheduled air carrier."
10. From a reading of impugned clause it would be clear that three
categories of bidders stands disqualified viz;
a. Scheduled or/and non-scheduled air carrier.
b. Any entity in which a scheduled air carrier or non-scheduled carrier or
its promoter(s) directly or indirectly holds any interest.
c. Any entity which is otherwise an Associate of a scheduled air carrier.
11. Petitioner is not a Scheduled or non-scheduled air carrier thus would
not fall under (a);
__________
Page21 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
Petitioner is an entity in which a scheduled air carrier or non-scheduled
carrier or its promoter(s) directly or indirectly holds “any interest” thus falling
under (b);
Share holding of Air India being only 50% in petitioner may not qualify
as an Associate for the purposes of this Request For Proposal (RFP).
12. Though expression “any interest” is not defined however it is not in
dispute that 50% of share in the Petitioner company is held by Air India and
would thus qualify as having “substantial interest” even in terms of Section
294AA of Companies Act, 2013.
13. Against this background, I shall proceed to address the questions
raised supra:
(I) Ground Handling Agency – Whether a class by itself – If so subclassification would offend Article 14 of Constitution of India:
To answer the question as to whether Ground Handling Agency governed
under 2023 Regulations forms a class by itself and any sub-classification would
offend Article 14 of the Constitution, it may be necessary to understand the
overall statutory scheme governing Ground Handling Service.
__________
Page22 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
STATUTORY FRAMEWORK- AIRPORTS AUTHORITY OF
ACT, 1994 AND GROUND HANDLING SERVICES REGULATIONS,
2018 AND THE 2023 AMENDMENT:
(1) Section 42 of the AAI Act, 1994 is extracted hereunder:
"42. Power to make regulations.(1) The Authority may make regulations not inconsistent with this
Act and the rules made thereunder to provide for all matters for
which provision is necessary or expedient for the purpose of giving
effect to the provisions of this Act.
(2) Without prejudice to the generality of the foregoing power,
such regulations may provide for(a) the time and places of the meetings of the Authority and the
procedure to be followed for the transaction of business including
the quorum at such meetings under sub-section (1) of section 8;
(b) the conditions of service and the remuneration of officers and
other employees to be appointed by the Authority under sub-section
(2) of section 10;
(c) the construction of residential accommodation for the officers
and other employees appointed by the Authority under clause (e) of
sub-section (3) of section 12;
(d) the storage or processing of goods in any warehouse
established by the Authority under clause (g) of sub-section (3) of
section 12 and the charging of fees for such storage or processing;
(e) the contracts or class of contracts which are to be sealed with
the common seal of the Authority and the form and manner in
__________
Page23 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
which a contract may be made by the Authority under sub-section
(1) of section 21;
(f) the custody and restoration of lost property and the terms and
conditions under which lost property may be restored to the
persons entitled thereto under section 34;
(g) the disposal of any lost property in cases where such property
is not restored;
(h) securing the safety of aircraft, vehicles and persons using the
airport or civil enclave and preventing danger to the public arising
from the use and operation of aircraft in the airport or civil
enclave;
(i) preventing obstruction within the airport or civil enclave for its
normal functioning;
(j) prohibiting the parking or waiting of any vehicle of carriage
within the airport or civil enclave except at places specified by the
Authority;
(k) prohibiting or restricting access to any part of the airport or
civil enclave;
(1) preserving order within the airport or civil enclave and
preventing damage to property therein;
(m) regulating or restricting advertising within the airport or civil
enclave;
(n) requiring any person, if so directed by an officer appointed by
the Authority in this behalf, to leave the airport or civil enclave or
any particular part of the airport or civil enclave; and
__________
Page24 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
(o) generally for the efficient and proper management of the
airport or civil enclave.
(3) Any regulation made under any of the clauses (h) to (o) (both
inclusive) of sub-section (2) may provide that a contravention
thereof shall be punishable with fine which may extend to five
hundred rupees and in the case of a continuing contravention with
an additional fine which may extend to twenty rupees for every day
during which such contravention continues after conviction for the
first such contravention.
(4) No regulation made by the Authority under this section shall
have effect until it has been approved by the Central Government
and published in the Official Gazette.
(5) Notwithstanding anything contained in this section, the first
regulations under this Act shall be made by the Central
Government and shall have effect on being published in the
Official Gazette.
(6) The first regulations framed under sub-section (5) shall remain
in force until such time the Authority has made regulations and
they are published in the Official Gazette."
14. AAI has notified the Airports Authority of India (Ground Handling
Services) Regulations, 2018, framed in exercise of power conferred under
Section 42 of Airport Authority of India Act, 1994.
__________
Page25 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
15. Section 3(1) of the Ground Handling Service Regulations, 2018 is
extracted hereunder:
"3. Ground Handling Services at Airports.(1) All domestic scheduled airline operators and scheduled
helicopter operators will be free to carry out self-handling at all
airports including civil enclaves;
(2) A foreign airline may undertake self-handling in respect of
passenger and baggage handling activities excluding security
functions listed in paragraph 1 of AVSEC Order No. 03/2009 dated
the 21st August, 2009 [enclosed as Annexure-I at the airport
terminals restricted to the passenger check-in at pre security hold
area, at all the airports except civil enclaves;
(3) At the cargo terminal except civil enclave, all cargo aircraft
operator may undertake self-handling excluding security functions
listed in paragraph 1 of AVSEC Order No. 03/2009 referred to in
sub regulation (2);
(4) At the airport having annual passenger throughput of ten
million passengers per annum or above, the airport operator shall
ensure that there will be three ground handling agencies including
that of, - (a) the airport operator or its joint venture or its hundred
percent owned subsidiary; (b) a joint venture or a subsidiary of the
Air India; and (c) any other ground handling agencies appointed
by the airport operator through a transparent bidding process.
(5) At the airport having annual passenger throughput of less than
ten million passengers per annum, based on the traffic output and
airside and terminal building capacity, the airport operator may
decide on the number of ground handling agencies, not exceeding
three, including that of,- (a) the airport operator or its joint
__________
Page26 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
venture or its hundred percent owned subsidiary; (b) a Joint
Venture or a subsidiary of Air India; and (c) any other ground
handling agency appointed by the airport operator through a
transparent bidding process.
(6) A ground handling agency, with foreign ownership of fifty
percent or more of its paid-up capital shall not be allowed to
undertake ground handling activities at the civil enclave;
(7) At all airports, the joint venture or the subsidiary of Air India
shall match the lowest royalty paid by the other ground handling
agencies, as long as majority share in such entity is with the
Government;
(8) The provisions of sub-regulations (4), (5) and (7) relating to
subsidiary or joint venture of the Air India shall apply so long as
such ground handling agency remains a subsidiary or a fifty-fifty
joint venture of a public sector undertaking and in case such
ground handling agency ceases to be subsidiary or a fifty-fifty joint
venture of a public sector undertaking, the provisions of sub
regulations (4), (5) and (7) shall continue to apply to such ground
handling agency all such airports where it is operating as a ground
handling agency, for a period of thirty-six months from the date
such ground handling agency ceased to be a subsidiary or a joint
venture of a public sector undertaking; (9) No royalty is payable in
case of self-handling; and (10) All airlines, joint ventures,
subsidiaries, ground handling agencies shall enter into an
agreement with the airport operator for the satisfactory
observance of performance of standards as may be mutually
acceptable."
16. This provision was subsequently amended in 2023 as follows:
"3. Ground Handling Services at Airports. (1) All domestic scheduled airline operators and domestic
scheduled helicopter operators may carry out ground handling
__________
Page27 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
activities solely for the purpose of self-handling at all airports
including civil enclaves."
(2) A foreign airline may undertake self-handling in respect of
passenger and baggage handling activities excluding security
functions listed in paragraph 1 of A VSEC Order No. 03/2009,
dated the 21st August, 2009, [enclosed as Annexure-1] at the
airport terminals restricted to the passenger'. check-in at pre
security hold area, at all the airports except [civil enclaves:]
(3) Provided that, the full self-handling, including security
functions, shall be allowed to be undertaken by the designated
airline of a country having a bilateral Air Transport Agreement or
Air Services Agreement with India containing a clause permitting
self-handling by the designated airlines, at any airport in India
available to such airline(s) as a point of call under the bilateral
Agreement, except at civil enclaves of defence airports, subject to
the condition of compliance with additional security measures as
may be made by the Ministry of Civil Aviation from time to time
and implemented under oversight of Bureau of Civil Aviation
Security;]
(3) At the cargo terminal except civil enclave, all cargo aircraft
operator may undertake self-handling excluding security functions
listed in paragraph 1 of AVSEC Order No. 03/2009 referred to in 2
subregulation (2):)
3[Provided that, the security functions may also be undertaken by
the designated cargo airline(s) of a country having a bilateral Air
Transport Agreement or Air Services Agreement with India
containing a clause permitting self-handling by the designated
airlines, subject to the condition of compliance with additional
security measures, as may be made by the Ministry of Civil
Aviation from time to time and implemented under oversight of
Bureau of Civil Aviation Security.]
(4) At the airport having annual passenger through put of ten
million passengers per annum or above, the airport operator shall
__________
Page28 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
ensure that there will be three ground handling agencies including
that of,(a) the airport operator or its joint venture or its hundred percent
owned subsidiary, provided that this mode is used only when the
airport operator has invited bids as under clause (c) and no bidder
is found suitable or selected;
(b) subject to sub-regulations (8) and (8A), a subsidiary or joint
venture of a public sector undertaking. In case there is no
subsidiary or joint venture of a public sector undertaking, a ground
handling agency shall be selected through a bidding process as
under clause (c); and
(c) any other ground handling agency appointed by the airport
operator through a transparent bidding process.
[(5) At the airport having annual passenger throughput of less than
ten million passengers per annum, based on the traffic output and
airside and terminal building capacity, the airport operator may
decide on the number of ground handling agencies, not exceeding
three, including that of,- (a) the airport operator or its joint
venture or its hundred percent owned subsidiary, provided that this
is used only when the airport operator has invited bids as under
clause (c) and no bidder is found suitable or selected; (b) subject
to sub-regulations (8) and (8-A), a subsidiary or joint venture of a
public sector undertaking. In case there is no subsidiary or joint
venture of a public sector undertaking, a ground handling agency
shall be selected through a bidding process as under clause (c);
and (c) any other ground handling agency appointed by the airport
operator through a transparent bidding process;]
(6) A ground handling agency, with foreign ownership of fifty
percent or more of its paid-up capital shall not be allowed to
__________
Page29 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
undertake ground handling activities at the civil enclave;.
1((7) Subject to sub-regulations (8) and (8-A), at all airports, the
subsidiary or joint venture of a public sector undertaking shall
match the lowest royalty or revenue share, as applicable, paid by
the other ground, handling agency at such airport;]
1/(8) The provisions of sub-regulations (4), (5) and (7) relating to
subsidiary or joint venture of a public sector undertaking shall:- (i)
continue to apply so long as such ground handling agency remains
a subsidiary or joint venture of a public sector undertaking (ii)
continue to apply to such ground handling agency at all such
Airports where it is operating as a ground handling agency, from
the date such ground handling agency ceases to be a subsidiary or
a joint venture of a public sector undertaking till the earlier of:- (a)
eighty four months, or (b) change in more than fifty percent
shareholding of such ground handling agency save and except
where such change in shareholding is after the expiry of the lock-in
period agreed to at the time of acquisition of such ground handling
agency by a private sector entity; (iii) continue to be applicable to
a successor entity, being a special purpose vehicle, which acquires
the ground handling agency at a civil enclave subject to: - (a)
compliance with sub-regulation (6), and (b) there being no change
in more than fifty percent shareholding of such successor entity for
the period of eighty-four months from the date of its acquisition,
save and except where such change in shareholding is after the
expiry of the lock-in period agreed to at the time of acquisition of
such ground handling agency by a private sector entity;]
1/(8-A) No ground handling agency or any person(s) controlling
such ground handling agency shall have significant influence in
any other ground handling agency operating on the same airport.
In case a ground handling agency or the person(s) controlling the
ground handling agency has significant influence in another
ground handling agency operating on the same airport or acquires
significant influence in another ground handling agency operating
on the same airport pursuant to an acquisition from a public sector
__________
Page30 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
enterprise: - (a) the two ground agencies operating at the same
airport shall be deemed to be a single ground handling agency at
the relevant airport; (b) airport operator for such airport shall
promptly appoint another ground handling agency through a
transparent bidding process; and (c)(A) within twenty four months
of such acquisition, such ground handling agency/person(s)
controlling the ground handling agency shall reorganize or
restructure the business of the ground handling agencies to ensure
that on completion of such twenty four month period, only one of
the two ground agencies operates at the relevant airport; or (B) on
expiry of twenty four months of such acquisition, of the two ground
handling agencies, the ground handling agency with the shorter
outstanding concession period, shall be deemed to have
surrendered its concession at the relevant airport.
Explanation. For the purposes of this sub-regulation, the terms
"significant influence" and "control" shall have the meanings as
respectively assigned to them in the Companies Act, 2013 (18 of
2013).)
(9) No royalty is payable in case of self-handling; and
(10) All airlines, joint ventures, subsidiaries, ground handling
agencies shall enter into an agreement with the airport operator
for the satisfactory observance of performance of standards as may
be mutually acceptable.
[Emphasis Supplied]
17. As seen supra, the above regulations governing Ground Handling
Services derives its authority from Section 42 of the Airport Authority of India
Act, 1994.
__________
Page31 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
18. Under Regulation 3(1) of Ground Handling Service Regulations,
2018, Domestic Scheduled Airline Operators and Scheduled Helicopter
Operators were "free to carry out self-handling at all airports including civil
enclaves." However, under 2023 Amendment, Regulation 3(1) provides that
domestic scheduled airline operators and domestic scheduled helicopter
operators may carry out ground handling activities “solely” for the purpose of
self-handling at all airports including civil enclaves."
19. Expression “solely” is inserted under 2023 Regulation, with an intent
to narrow the scope of activities that may be carried by Domestic Schedule
Airline/helicopter operators. Domestic airlines are restricted rather permitted to
undertake ground handling activities solely for their own operations (selfhandling), and not for third parties. Thus, 2023 amendment bars an airline
operator from directly or indirectly offering ground-handling services to other
airlines, while permitting only self-handling. Thus, a Domestic Airlines though
may qualify a Ground Handling Service is subject to differential treatment visa-vis other Ground Handling Service in restricting its operations to act as
Ground Handling Service solely for self- handling.
Thus, assumption that all Ground Handling Service is extended uniform
treatment overlooks sub-classification even in terms of Regulation.
__________
Page32 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
20. Classification amongst Ground Handling Agencies is also made on
the basis of share holding pattern both under 2018 and 2023 Regulation, in other
words, there is sub-classification amongst “Ground Handling Agency” in terms
of the said regulations as could be seen from the following:
i. 2018 Regulation:
On a reading of Rule 3 of 2018 Regulations it would appear that an
airport operator or its joint venture or its hundred percent owned subsidiary; or a
joint venture or a subsidiary of Air India are assured of a place as a Ground
Handling Service.
A ground handling agency, with foreign ownership of fifty percent or
more of its paid-up capital was not allowed to undertake ground handling
activities at civil enclave.
ii. 2023 Regulations:
On a reading of Rule 3 of 2023 Regulations it would appear that an
airport operator or its joint venture or its hundred per cent owned subsidiary or a
joint venture or a subsidiary of Public Sector Undertaking, are extended
priority/ preferential treatment.
A ground handling agency, with foreign ownership of fifty percent or
more of its paid-up capital is not be allowed to undertake ground handling
activities at Civil Enclave.
__________
Page33 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
21. The above analysis is not exhaustive but illustrative, and made only to
show that even in terms of 2018 and 2023 Regulations, Ground Handling
Agencies has been subject to different treatment depending on the basis of
entities origin, its shareholding pattern or ownership. It is thus clear that
submission by respondent that Ground Handling Agency is a class by itself
under 2023 Regulation and any sub-classification would fall foul of Article 14
of Constitution on the ground of being discriminatory is made on a
misconception of the scheme of the 2018 Regulations.
(II) Whether 2023 Regulation makes a departure from 2018 Regulation insofar
as petitioner – Disqualification in impugned clause – Whether government has
contractual freedom to insert impugned clause – Prescribing criteria for
disqualification:
22. If we contrast 2018 with 2023 Regulation, we would find that under
2018 Regulation any joint venture or its hundred percent owned subsidiary or a
joint venture or a subsidiary of Air India was assured of a place as ground
handling agency in any airport by virtue of its share holding pattern more
particularly beneficial treatment was extended to Air India which was a Public
Sector Undertaking thus qualifies as a State for the purposes of Article 12 of
the Constitution. It is trite that State/Public Sector Undertaking constitutes a
class by itself and a differential treatment extended thereto may not offend
__________
Page34 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
Article 14 of Constitution of India, 1950. In this regard it may be relevant to
refer to the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Hindustan Paper
Corporation Limited Vs Government of Kerala & Ors., 1986 SCC OnLine SC
130.
23. Thus, intent of the 2018 Regulation was to extend beneficial treatment
to Air India by providing for an assured position as a “Ground Handling
Agency” in any airport. This was in view of the fact that it was a Public Sector
Undertaking. However, pursuant to its disinvestment in 2022 and take over by
TATA Group, the above benefit was not extended under 2023 Regulation
apparently in view of the fact that there was a change in the share holding
pattern and it was no longer a Public Sector Undertaking.
(III) 2023 Regulation - Not a Fetter on contractual freedom :
24. Question then arises whether government has the authority to
introduce impugned clause by virtue of which any entity in which a scheduled
air carrier or non-scheduled carrier or its promoter(s) directly or indirectly holds
any interest stands disqualified – Though such a disqualification is not
founded/traceable from the 2023 Regulation.
24.1 Assuming “Ground Handling Agency” is treated as a class by itself
for the purpose of 2018/2023 Regulation, that would not in any view impose
any fetter on the government freedom to contract by sub-classifying “Ground
__________
Page35 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
Handling Agencies” for the purpose of tender. This would be clear if we bear in
mind
that
2018/2023
Regulations
are
meant
to
regulate
the
operation/functioning of “Ground Handling Agency” and does not nor can be
understood to impose any fetter on the freedom of the government to impose
clauses in tender creating sub-classification amongst “Ground Handling
Agencies”, while issuing Tender. Any attempt to suggest that power of
government in issuing tender would be controlled by regulations whereby all
Ground Handling Services, are to be treated as a single class uniformly would
have to fail, inasmuch as such construction would result in imposing fetter on
the government freedom to impose conditions by creating sub – classification
amongst Ground Handling Service, while calling for tender which may render
2023 Regulation itself vulnerable to challenge as being arbitrary, such
construction thus ought to be avoided. In this regard, it is relevant to refer to the
decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court, wherein various facets governing contracts
entered by Government was explained as under:
Municipal Corpn., Ujjain v. BVG India Ltd., reported in (2018) 5 SCC 462
13. Whenever the State or public body or the agency of the
State enters into such contract, an element of public law or public
interest may be involved even in such a commercial transaction.
In that very judgment i.e. Raunaq International Ltd. [Raunaq
International Ltd. v. I.V.R. Construction Ltd., (1999) 1 SCC 492] ,
the elements of public interest are also noted. It is held thus: (SCC
pp. 500-01, paras 10 & 11)
__________
Page36 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
“10. What are these elements of public interest? (1) Public money
would be expended for the purposes of the contract. (2) The goods
or services which are being commissioned could be for a public
purpose, such as, construction of roads, public buildings, power
plants or other public utilities. (3) The public would be directly
interested in the timely fulfilment of the contract so that the
services become available to the public expeditiously. (4) The
public would also be interested in the quality of the work
undertaken or goods supplied by the tenderer. Poor quality of
work or goods can lead to tremendous public hardship and
substantial financial outlay either in correcting mistakes or in
rectifying defects or even at times in redoing the entire work—thus
involving larger outlays of public money and delaying the
availability of services, facilities or goods e.g. a delay in
commissioning a power project, as in the present case, could lead
to power shortages, retardation of industrial development,
hardship to the general public and substantial cost escalation.
15. It is well settled that the award of contract, whether it is by a
private party or by a public body or by the State, is essentially a
commercial transaction. In arriving at a commercial decision, the
considerations
which
are
of
paramount
importance
are
commercial considerations. These would include, inter alia, the
price at which the party is willing to work; whether the goods or
services offered are of the requisite specifications; and whether
the person tendering the bid has the ability to deliver the goods or
services as per the specifications. It is also by now well settled
that the authorities/State can choose its own method to arrive at a
__________
Page37 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
decision and it is free to grant any relaxation for bona fide
reasons, if the tender conditions permit such a relaxation.
(IV) Whether disqualification is without basis/irrational :
25. The next submission of petitioner that there is no basis for insertion of
impugned clause it is thus arbitrary is also liable to be rejected. It may be
necessary to note that tender issuing authority has explained the reasons behind
the impugned clause as under:
(i). Post disinvestment of Air India, 2023 amendment regulations were
notified, "to ensure competitiveness", "to facilitate a level playing field", "to
avoid conflict of interest", "to prevent cartelisation", "to prevent compromise in
standard operating procedures", and "to avoid potential breaches in Service
Level Agreements".
(ii). Impugned Clause in subject Tender has been included to prevent
conflict of interest between user airlines and appointed ground handling
agencies. That if a ground handling agency provides ground handling to an
airline which holds "any interest" in such ground handling agency (or is its
associate), it may lead to conflict of interest and may adversely affect the
revenue share due to AAI, including by provision of services at a discounted
rate.
__________
Page38 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
26. With this in view it may do well to remind that power of Courts to
interfere in matters relating to tender is very narrow and limited, if we bear in
mind that tender conditions are in the realm of contract and courts must show
deference to the commercial wisdom of tender inviting authority. Let us proceed
to examine approach adopted by courts in exercising the power of judicial
review while examining challenge to clauses in tender. It may be relevant to
refer to the following decisions:
(a). Global Energy Ltd. v. Adani Exports Ltd., reported in (2005) 4 SCC
435 after referring to Tata Cellular held as under:
9. ...the terms of the invitation to tender cannot be open to
judicial scrutiny because the invitation to tender is in the
realm of contract. In Air India Ltd. v. Cochin International
Airport Ltd. [(2000) 2 SCC 617] the same view was
reiterated that the State can fix its own terms of invitation of
tender and that it is not open to judicial scrutiny...
Government must have a free hand in settling the terms
of the tender. The courts would not interfere with the terms
of the tender notice unless it was shown to be either
arbitrary or discriminatory or actuated by malice...
__________
Page39 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
(b). Siemens Public Communication Networks (P) Ltd. v. Union of India,
reported in (2008) 16 SCC 215;
40. ……. A contract is a commercial transaction 3 and
evaluating tenders and awarding contracts are essentially
commercial functions. In such cases principles of equity and
natural justice stay at a distance. If the decision relating to
award of contracts is bona fide and is in public interest,
courts will not exercise the power of judicial review and
interfere even if it is accepted for the sake of argument that
there is a procedural lacuna.
(c). Michigan Rubber (India) Ltd. v. State of Karnataka, reported in
(2012) 8 SCC 216
23. From the above decisions, the following principles emerge:
(e) … no person can claim a fundamental right to carry on
business with the Government.
(d) Montecarlo Ltd. v. NTPC Ltd., reported in (2016) 15 SCC 272
After referring to,
19. In Sterling Computers Ltd. v. M&N Publications Ltd.
[Sterling Computers Ltd. v. M&N Publications Ltd., (1993) 1
SCC 445]… It was observed as under:
State of M.P. v. U.P. State Bridge Corpn. Ltd., reported in (2022) 16 SCC 633
__________
Page40 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
… Court cannot examine the details of the terms of the
contract which have been entered into by the public bodies or
the State. Courts have inherent limitations on the scope of
any such enquiry.
(e) Silppi Constructions Contractors v. Union of India, reported in (2020)
16 SCC 489 :
19. This Court being the guardian of fundamental rights is
duty-bound to interfere when there is arbitrariness,
irrationality, mala fides and bias. However, this Court in all
the aforesaid decisions has cautioned time and again that
courts should exercise a lot of restraint while exercising their
powers of judicial review in contractual or commercial
matters. This Court is normally loathe to interfere in
contractual matters unless a clear-cut case of arbitrariness
or mala fides or bias or irrationality is made out. One must
remember that today many public sector undertakings
compete with the private industry. The contracts entered into
between private parties are not subject to scrutiny under writ
jurisdiction. No doubt, the bodies which are State within the
meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution are bound to act
fairly and are amenable to the writ jurisdiction of superior
courts but this discretionary power must be exercised with a
great deal of restraint and caution. The courts must realise
their limitations and the havoc which needless interference in
commercial matters can cause. In contracts involving
__________
Page41 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
technical issues the courts should be even more reluctant
because most of us in Judges' robes do not have the
necessary expertise to adjudicate upon technical issues
beyond our domain. As laid down in the judgments cited
above the courts should not use a magnifying glass while
scanning the tenders and make every small mistake appear
like a big blunder. In fact, the courts must give “fair play in
the joints” to the government and public sector undertakings
in matters of contract.
20. ………. court must realise that the authority floating the
tender is the best judge of its requirements and, therefore, the
court's interference should be minimal. The authority which
floats the contract or tender, and has authored the tender
documents is the best judge as to how the documents have to
be interpreted. If two interpretations are possible then the
interpretation of the author must be accepted. The courts will
only interfere to prevent arbitrariness, irrationality, bias,
mala fides or perversity. With this approach in mind we shall
deal with the present case.
(f) Uflex Ltd. v. State of T.N., reported in (2022) 1 SCC 165;
2. … The purpose is to check whether the choice of decision
is made lawfully and not to check whether the choice of
decision is sound.4 In evaluating tenders and awarding
contracts, the parties are to be governed by principles of
Central Coalfields Ltd. v. SLL-SML (Joint Venture Consortium), (2016) 8 SCC 622
__________
Page42 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
commercial prudence. To that extent, principles of equity and
natural justice have to stay at a distance.
3. We cannot lose sight of the fact that a tenderer or
contractor with a grievance can always seek damages in a
civil court and thus, “attempts by unsuccessful tenderers with
imaginary grievances, wounded pride and business rivalry, to
make
mountains
out
of
molehills
of
some
technical/procedural violation or some prejudice to self, and
persuade courts to interfere by exercising power of judicial
review, should be resisted”.
Conclusion
42. … The question is should the judicial process be resorted
to for downplaying the freedom which a tendering party has,
merely because it is a State or a public authority, making the
said process even more cumbersome…
...The objective is not to make the Court an appellate
authority for scrutinising as to whom the tender should be
awarded.
(g) State of M.P. v. U.P. State Bridge Corpn. Ltd., reported in (2022) 16
SCC 633 :
K. Afcons Infrastructure Ltd. v. Nagpur Metro Rail Corpn.
Ltd. [Afcons Infrastructure Ltd. v. Nagpur Metro Rail Corpn.
__________
Page43 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
Ltd., (2016) 16 SCC 818] puts the proposition extremely well
when it states : (SCC p. 825, paras 14-15)
“15. We may add that the owner or the employer of a project,
having authored the tender documents, is the best person to
understand and appreciate its requirements and interpret its
documents. The constitutional courts must defer to this
understanding and appreciation of the tender documents,
unless there is mala fide or perversity in the understanding or
appreciation or in the application of the terms of the tender
conditions. It is possible that the owner or employer of a
project may give an interpretation to the tender documents
that is not acceptable to the constitutional courts but that by
itself is not a reason for interfering with the interpretation
given.”
27. Applying the law laid down in the above decisions the following
position appears to emerge:
a. Terms of the invitation to tender is normally not open to
judicial scrutiny because invitation to tender is in the realm of
contract.
b. State can fix its own terms of invitation of tender.
Government must have a free hand in settling the terms of the
tender.
c. No person can claim a fundamental right to carry on
business with the Government.
__________
Page44 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
d. A contract is a commercial transaction and evaluating
tenders and awarding contracts are essentially commercial
functions. In such cases principles of equity and natural
justice stay at a distance. If the decision relating to award of
contracts is bona fide and is in public interest, courts will not
exercise the power of judicial review and interfere even if it
is accepted for the sake of argument that there is a procedural
lacuna.
e. In the matter of formulating conditions of a tender
document and awarding a contract, greater latitude is required
to be conceded to the State authorities unless the action of the
tendering authority is found to be malicious and a misuse of
its statutory powers, interference by courts is not warranted;
f. If the State or its instrumentalities act reasonably, fairly
and in public interest in awarding contract, here again,
interference by court is very restrictive.
g. Authority floating the tender is the best judge of its
requirements and, therefore, the court's interference should be
minimal. The authority which floats the contract or tender,
and has authored the tender documents is the best judge as to
how the documents have to be interpreted.
h. Scope of judicial review is to check whether the choice of
decision is made lawfully and not to check whether the
choice of decision is sound. In evaluating tenders and
awarding contracts, the parties are to be governed by
__________
Page45 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
principles of commercial prudence. To that extent, principles
of equity and natural justice have to stay at a distance.
i. Judicial review in not intended to downplay the freedom
which a tendering party has, merely because it is a State or a
public authority, making the said process even more
cumbersome. Court are not to act as an appellate authority for
scrutinising as to whom the tender should be awarded.
j. If the decision relating to award of contract is bona fide and
is in public interest, courts will not, in exercise of power of
judicial review, interfere even if a procedural aberration or
error in assessment or prejudice to a tenderer, is made out.
The power of judicial review will not be permitted to be
invoked to protect private interest at the cost of public
interest, or to decide contractual disputes. Soundness of the
decision taken by the employer ought not to be questioned
except of being irrational or mala fide or intended to favour
someone or a decision ‘that no responsible authority acting
reasonably and in accordance with relevant law could have
reached’ .
28. The above rule of restraint to be exercised by courts is not absolute
but subject to exceptions inter-alia including the following:
(a) Where terms of the tender shown to be either arbitrary or
discriminatory or actuated by malice.
(b) Where action of tendering authority found to be malicious and misuse
of its statutory powers.
__________
Page46 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
29. Applying the above principles to the facts of the present writ petition
this court finds no reason warranting interference for the following reasons:
a. That contention of petitioner that “Ground Handling
Services” are a class and any sub-classification would fall
foul of Article 14 is devoid of merit inasmuch as seen from
the discussion supra Regulations itself provide for differential
treatment of certain categories of “Ground Handling
Agencies”.
b. The submission that there is no reason for differential
treatment to the petitioner only on the basis of share holding
pattern, loses sight of the fact that even under 2018
regulation, beneficial treatment was extended to Air India and
its joint venture apparently keeping in view that it was 100%
held by government. The disinvestment in 2022 and TATA
Group stepping in, the above benefit was withdrawn since it
was no longer a government/public sector undertaking. The
above contention is thus without merit.
c. The contention that there is no basis for disqualifying any
entity in which a scheduled air carrier or non-scheduled
carrier or its promoter(s) directly or indirectly holds any
interest is again without merit inasmuch as it has been
explained by the respondent that reason for inserting the
clause was "to ensure competitiveness", "to facilitate a level
playing field", "to avoid conflict of interest", "to prevent
cartelisation", "to prevent compromise in standard operating
procedures", and "to avoid potential breaches in Service
__________
Page47 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
Level Agreements". This court should show deference to the
commercial wisdom of the tender inviting authority in
framing the tender clauses. The above reasoning which
necessitated the imposition of the restriction cannot be stated
to be extraneous or even remotely malicious. Importantly,
there is no allegation of malafides in imposing the
disqualification.
d. Tenders are in the realm of contract, it is for the authority
issuing tender to decide the terms thereof. No entity can
claim to right to do business with government.
30.
In view of the above, this Court finds that challenge to Clause
2.2.1(f) of Tender ID.2025_AAI_256733_1 dated 12th December, 2025, lacking
merit thus stand rejected. This writ petition stands disposed of with above
observations. No costs. Consequently, connected miscellaneous petitions are
closed.
21-09-2026
Index: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
jv/sdk
To:
1.Union of India
Through Ministry of Civil Aviation,
Represented by its Secretary,
Rajiv Gandhi Bhawan, Block-B, Jor Bagh, Safdarjung Airport Area, New
Delhi- 110 003.
__________
Page48 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
2.Airports Authority of India
Having its Principal Office at
Rajiv Gandhi Bhawan, Safdarjung Airport,
New Delhi-110 003.
3.Airport Authority of India
Through Regional Executive Director, Southern Region, Having
Regional Headquarters at Anna International Airport, Chennai- 600 027.
4. Chennai International Airport
Through its Airport Director, Great Southern Trunk Road,
Meenambakkam, Chennai,
Tamil Nadu – 600 027, India.
__________
Page49 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No.123 of 2026
MOHAMMED SHAFFIQ J.
jv/sdk
WP No.123 of 2026
21-09-2026
__________
Page50 of 50
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review