Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Miscellaneous Appeal No.2240/2020 & 2231/2020
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH, BENCH AT INDORE
-1Miscellaneous Appeal No.2240/2020
M/s. Suman Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd.
Vs.
State of M. P. and Others
Miscellaneous Appeal No.2231/2020
M/s. Suman Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd.
Vs.
State of M. P. and Others
Indore, dated 09/10/2020
Mr. Shekhar Sharma, learned counsel for the appellant(s).
Ms.
Kirti
Patwardhan,
learned
Panel
Lawyer
for
the
respondent / State.
Regard being had to the similitude in the controversy involved
in the present cases, the miscellaneous appeals were analogously
heard and by a common order, they are being disposed of by this
Court. Facts of Miscellaneous Appeal No.2240/2020 are narrated
hereunder.
02-
The present appeal has been filed by the appellant / plaintiff
being aggrieved by order dated 06/03/2020 passed in RCSA/410/2017 by IX Additional District Judge, Ujjain by which the
application preferred under Order XXXIX Rule 1 and 2 of the Code of
Civil Procedure, 1908 has been dismissed.
03-
The facts of the case reveal that Public Works Department, a
Department of State of Madhya Pradesh invited tender for
Miscellaneous Appeal No.2240/2020 & 2231/2020
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH, BENCH AT INDORE
-2construction of Kiloli – Lakhesra Road and the appellant was found to
be eligible being “L1”. An agreement was executed between the State
of Madhya Pradesh and the appellant followed by work order dated
10/05/2010. The appellant has stated that he has deployed resources
including manpower and machinery for completion of work as it was
required to be completed within 12 month including rainy season.
04-
It has been further stated that the State Government has not
made available funds as per the terms and conditions of the
agreement and a Letter of Request was sent to respondent No.5 –
Executive Engineer (B/R) on 28/02/2011. The appellant has stated
that various obstacles and hindrance were in existence. Land was not
made available, mining clearances were not granted and in those
circumstances, various requests were made to the respondent No.5
for extension of time. A request was made on 06/05/2011 for
extension of time up to 06/06/2012 and the time was extended only up
to 31/03/2012.
05-
Up to 31/12/2012, the appellant has completed the work of
about Rs.160 Lakhs and he again applied for extension of time,
however, no order was passed in respect of extension of time and no
payment was made in respect of executed work. The appellant made
a request to the Department for releasing the payment vide letter
dated 30/05/2011, 23/08/2011 and 17/09/2011, however, nothing was
done in the matter. Letters were written to remove encroachments and
Miscellaneous Appeal No.2240/2020 & 2231/2020
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH, BENCH AT INDORE
-3again nothing was done and finally a notice was issued on 06/12/2012
under Clause 3(c) for terminating the contract.
06-
The appellant did submit a reply to the show cause notice,
however, vide order dated 14/02/2013 the contract was terminated in
exercise of power conferred under Clause 3(a) and 3(c) of the
contract.
07-
The appellant vide letter dated 03/04/2013 requested the
Superintending Engineer, Ujjain Division, Ujjain for revival of the
agreement, however, it was not revived. On 21/04/2014 a similar
request was made. The appellant kept on writing to the respondents
and without making funds available the contract was terminated. The
appellant submitted an appeal on 21/07/2014 against termination,
however, in spite of repeated requests, the appeal was not decided by
respondent No.4 and the appellant was informed by letter dated
31/05/2016 that hearing of the appeal will take place on 05/06/2016
but nothing was informed to the appellant thereafter.
08-
A letter was also issued by respondent No.3 – Chief Engineer,
Public Works Department, Ujjain Zone on 10/03/2016 to adjust the
earnest money and security deposits and to recover the remaining
amount the other ongoing contracts. The respondent No.5 has issued
a letter on 19/05/2016 for recovery of the money by issuing the RRC
and the appellant finally came before this Court by filing a writ petition
i.e. Writ Petition No.1032/2017 and an interim order was passed on
Miscellaneous Appeal No.2240/2020 & 2231/2020
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH, BENCH AT INDORE
-420/02/2017. This Court by an order dated 22/02/2017 has directed the
respondent No.4 to decide the appeal within a period of 60 days and
the appeal was finally decided by an order dated 05/08/2017.
09-
The present appellant thereafter preferred another writ petition
i.e. Writ Petition No.6105/2017 before this Court, however, this Court
by an order dated 13/10/2017 has directed the appellant to file a civil
suit or to take recourse of arbitration proceeding.
10-
A civil suit was preferred by the appellant along with an
application under Order XXXIX Rule 1 and 2 of the Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908. Reliance was placed upon a judgment delivered by
this Court in the case of B. B. Verma and Ors. Vs. State of Madhya
Pradesh and Ors. reported in (2007) 4 MPLJ 610, however, the
Court below has dismissed the application preferred under Order
XXXIX Rule 1 and 2 by an order dated 06/03/2020. The present
appeal is arising out of order dated 06/03/2020.
11-
Learned Government Advocate appearing in the matter has
vehemently opposed the contentions and grounds raised by the
present appellant. His contention is that the amount which is
outstanding and due has to be recovered from the appellant without
waiting for the final decision in the civil suit. It has been argued that
the appellant has abandoned the work, he did not complete the work
in time and therefore, the State Government is justified in rejecting the
appeal preferred by the appellant and the trial Court was also justified
Miscellaneous Appeal No.2240/2020 & 2231/2020
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH, BENCH AT INDORE
-5in dismissed the application under Order XXXIX Rule 1 and 2 of the
CPC.
12-
In the present case, the issue involved is whether at this stage
recovery can be done or not in the peculiar facts and circumstance of
the case. This is the third visit of the petitioner before this Court. The
petitioner did avail the remedy available as per the terms and
conditions of the contract, however, as his appeal was not being
decided, this Court by an order dated 16/08/2017 passed in Writ
Petition No.1032/2017 has passed the following order:“Shri Yatish Laad, learned counsel for the petitioner.
Shri Pushyamitra Bhargav, learned Public Prosecutor for
the respondents/State.
Heard.
This writ petition has been filed against the order dated
30/01/2017.
It is not in dispute that an appeal against the impugned
order of termination of agreement is pending before the learned
appellate authority, therefore, we grant one month time to the
respondents to decide the appeal pending before respondent
No.4 and submit its compliance report supported with the affidavit
of respondent No.4.
In the meanwhile, the liberty granted vide the interim order
passed on 20/02/2017 shall continue for a period of one month or
till the disposal of the appeal, which ever is earlier.
With the aforesaid, this petition stands disposed of.”
The respondent No.4 therein the Superintending Engineer was
directed to decide the appeal and an interim order was passed
restraining the recovery.
13-
After dismissal of the appeal a second writ petition was
preferred i.e. Writ Petition No.6105/2017 and the Division Bench of
Miscellaneous Appeal No.2240/2020 & 2231/2020
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH, BENCH AT INDORE
-6this Court in the aforesaid case in paragraphs No.12, 13 and 14 has
held as under:“12. In the present case, the petitioner is not seeking to enforce
any statutory right of theirs nor he is seeking to enforce any
statutory obligation cast upon the respondents. Indeed, the very
resort to Article 226 of the Constitution of India is misconceived.
13.
However, it is open to the petitioner, if it so chooses to
either raise a dispute by filing an application under the provisions
of Madhya Pradesh Madhyastham Adhikaran Adhiniyam, 1983, if
the same is in time, or to approach Civil Court, according to law,
as the case may be. In the circumstances of the case, no order
as to costs.
14.
For the above mentioned reasons, Writ Petition
No.6105/2017 filed by the petitioner is not maintainable and is
accordingly dismissed. No costs.”
The petitioner has thereafter, preferred a civil suit along with an
application under Order XXXIX Rule 1 and 2 of the CPC and the
same has been dismissed.
14-
The Full Bench of this Court in the case of B. B. Verma (Supra)
has held as under:“3.29.2.
Except where otherwise specified in the contract,
for claim valued at Rs. 50,000/- or more the decisions of the S.E.
of the Circle for the time being in respect of all questions and
disputes relating to the meaning of the specification, designs,
drawings, and instructions hereto before mentioned and as to the
quality of workmanship or materials used on the work or as to any
other question, claim, right, matter or thing whatsoever, in any
way arising out of, or relating to the contract, designs, drawings,
specifications, estimates, instructions, orders or those conditions
or otherwise concerning the work of execution or failure to
execute the same whether arising during the progress of the work
or after the completion or abandonment thereof shall be final
provided that the S.E. shall before giving his decision in writing in
the matter give an opportunity of being heard, to the parties to the
contract.
If any party to the contract is dissatisfied with the final
decision of the S.E. in respect of any matter, he may within 28
days after receiving notice of such decision may refer such
dispute to the Arbitration Tribunal constituted under the Madhya
Pradesh Madhyastham Adhikaran Adhiniyam, 1982 (No. 2 of
Miscellaneous Appeal No.2240/2020 & 2231/2020
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH, BENCH AT INDORE
-71983).
3.38.1. Recovery of dues from the contractor.Whenever any claim against the contractor for the
payment of a sum or money arises out of or under the
contract, Government shall be entitled to recover such
sum by appropriating, in part or whole, the security
deposit of the contractor and to sell any Govt.
promissory notes etc. forming the whole or part of
such security. In the event of the security being
insufficient or if no security has been taken from the
contractor, then the balance or the total sum
recoverable, as the case may be, shall be deducted
from any sum then due or which at any time thereafter
may become due to the contractor under this or any
other contract with Govt. Should this sum be not
sufficient to cover the full amount recoverable from the
contractor then it shall be recovered from him as
arrears of land revenue.
A perusal of Clause 4.3.29.2 of the conditions of contract
quoted above would show that the decision of the S.E. of the
Circle for the time being in respect of questions and disputes
mentioned therein 'or as to any other question, claim, right, matter
or thing whatsoever in any way arising out of, or relating to the
contract...or otherwise concerning the work of execution or failure
to execute the same whether arising during the progress of the
work or after the completion or abandonment thereof shall be
final'. Hence, the decision of the Divisional Officer of the
Executive Engineer under Clause 4.3.3.3 of the conditions of
contract quoted above to have the unexecuted work completed
by another contractor and claim the expenses which may have
been incurred in excess of the sum which would have been paid
to the original contractor is subject to the final decision of the S.E
if the contractor raises a dispute on such claim made by the
Divisional Officer or the Executive Engineer. The second para of
Clause 4.3.29.2 further stipulates that if any party to the contract
is dissatisfied with the final decision of the S.E. in respect of any
matter, he may within 28 days after receiving notice of such
decision refer such dispute to the Arbitration Tribunal constituted
under the Adhiniyam. Hence, any decision taken and any amount
claimed by the Executive Engineer or the Divisional Officer under
Clause 4.3.3.3 of the conditions of contract is not final but subject
to the decision of the S.E. and any decision of the S.E. on these
aspects is also subject to the decision of the Tribunal under the
Adhiniyam, if referred to the Tribunal by any party to the contract.
The result is that the amount claimed by the Executive Engineer
or the Divisional Officer under Clause 4.3.3.3 will not become a
sum due from the contractor until the dispute is decided by the
S.E. on an appeal made before him from the decision of the
Executive Engineer or the Divisional Officer, or until the dispute is
adjudicated by the Tribunal under the Adhiniyam where the
Miscellaneous Appeal No.2240/2020 & 2231/2020
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH, BENCH AT INDORE
-8decision of the S.E. is challenged by way of reference.
Further, the Proviso to Section 7-B of the Adhiniyam states
that if the Final Authority, namely S.E. fails to decide a dispute
within the period stipulated therein, a petition to the Tribunal
under Section 7 can be made by a party. Thus, when an appeal
against the decision of the Executive Engineer or the Divisional
Officer under Clause 4.3.3.3 of the conditions of contract is not
decided by the S.E. and a party files a reference under Section 7
of the Adhiniyam before the Tribunal, the amount claimed by the
Executive Engineer or the Divisional Officer under Clause 4.3.3.3
will not be due and therefore not recoverable from the contractor
as arrears of land revenue under Clause 4.3.38.1 of the
conditions of contract until the Tribunal adjudicates the dispute
raised by the contractor.
In the two decisions in Ch. Chandra Shekhar v. State of
M.P. and Ors. and Seth Mohanlal Hiralal v. State of M.P. and Anr.
(supra), the Division Bench lost sight of the fact that the decision
of the Executive Engineer or the Divisional Officer under Clause
4.3.3.3 and other Clauses of the conditions of contract is subject
to the final decision of the S.E. and the decision of the S.E. is
subject to the award of the Tribunal where a reference is made to
the Tribunal against the decision of the S.E. or where the S.E.
fails to decide the dispute. In fact, in the two decisions of the
Division Bench, there is no reference whatsoever to the Clause
providing for decision by the S.E. or by the Tribunal under the
Adhiniyam.
In the two decisions of the Division Bench in Ch. Chandra
Shekhar v. State of M.P. and Anr. and Seth Mohanlal Hiralal v.
State of M.P. and Anr. (supra), there is also no reference to the
decision of the Supreme Court in Union of India v. Raman Iron
Foundry (supra). As we have seen, in Union of India v. Raman
Iron Foundry (supra), Clause 18 of the general conditions of the
contract which was titled 'Recovery of Sums Due' provided inter
alia that whenever any claim for payment of a sum or money
arises against the contractor, the purchaser shall be entitled to
recover such sum by appropriating in whole or in part the security
if any deposited by the contractor and in the event of security
being insufficient and if no security has been taken from the
contractor, the entire sum recoverable shall be recovered by
appropriating any sum then due or which at any time thereafter
may become due to the contractor under the contract or any
other contract with the purchaser. The Supreme Court,
interpreting Clause 18 of the General Conditions of Contract, held
that under Clause 18, the purchaser cannot recover the amount
as claimed without resorting to arbitration by appropriating sums
due to the contractor under the same contract or under other
contracts and if the claim of the purchaser is not well founded and
the appropriate made by him is therefore not justified, the
contractor can always resort to civil suit or arbitration and it is
only when the adjudication is made by the Civil Court or the
Miscellaneous Appeal No.2240/2020 & 2231/2020
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH, BENCH AT INDORE
-9arbitrator and the breach of the contract is established and the
amount of damages decreed that the amount becomes due and
recoverable from the contractor.
In the two decisions of the Division Bench in Ch. Chandra
Shekhar v. State of M.P. and Ors. and Seth Mohanlal Hiralal v.
State of M.P. and Anr. (supra), there is also no reference to the
decision of the Supreme Court in State of Karnataka v.
Rameshwar Rice Mills Thirthahalli (supra), in which Clause 12 of
the agreement with the State of Mysore and a private person for
purchase of paddy under the Paddy Procurement Scheme, 1959
inter alia provided that any amount that may become due or
payable by the first party to the second party under any part of
the agreement shall be deemed to be and will be recovered from
the first party as if they are arrears of land revenue and the
Supreme Court held that the terms of Clause 12 of the agreement
do not have scope for liberal construction being made so as to
confer power on the Deputy Commissioner to adjudicate upon
disputed questions of breach as well as to assess the damages
arising from the breach. The Supreme Court further held that the
officers of the State Government which is a party to the
agreement, cannot be an arbiter in his own cause and interest of
justice and equity require that where a party to a contract
disputes the committing of any breach of conditions, the
adjudication should be by an independent person or body and not
by the other party to the contract.
After considering the aforesaid decisions of the Supreme
Court in Union of India v. Raman Iron Foundry and State of
Karnataka v. Rameshwar Rice Mills Thirthahalli (supra), we have
no doubt in our mind that Clause 4.3.38.1 does not confer any
power on the State Government or its officers to recover any
amount that is disputed by the contractor as payable under the
contract to the State Government prior to the decision of the S.E.
or of the Tribunal under the Adhiniyam.
In the decision of the Division Bench in Ch. Chandra
Shekhar v. State of M.P. and Ors. (supra), a reference has been
made to Sections 146 and 147 of the M.P. Land Revenue Code,
1959 (for short 'the Code') to show that the procedure has been
prescribed for recovery of amount as arrears of land revenue.
Section 146 of the Code provides that Tehsildar or Naib-Tehsildar
may cause a notice of demand to be served on any defaulter
before the issue of any process under Section 147 for the
recovery of an arrear and Section 147 of the Code mentions the
different processes by which arrear of land revenue payable to
the Government may be recovered by the Tehsildar. These two
provisions, provide the procedure for recovery of arrear of land
revenue but does not provide whether any amount under any
contract between the State Government and a private person can
be recovered as arrear of land revenue. Section 155(b) of the
Code provides that 'all moneys falling due to the State
Government under any grant, lease or contract which provides
Miscellaneous Appeal No.2240/2020 & 2231/2020
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH, BENCH AT INDORE
- 10 that they shall be recoverable in the same manner as an arrear of
land revenue' may be recovered in the same manner as an arrear
of land revenue if the contract provides as such. Obviously, where
the contractor disputes an amount claimed by the State
Government or any officer on its behalf as payable by the
contractor to the State Government, such an amount cannot be
said to be due to the State under the contract and cannot be
recovered as arrear of land revenue in accordance with the terms
of the contract and Section 155(b) of the Code.
We may now deal with the contention of Mr. Shukla that
under Clause 4.3.3.3 of the conditions of contract, the Executive
Engineer or the Divisional Officer does not assess and recover
any damages but expenses which may be incurred in excess of
the sum which would have been paid to the original contractor in
case the unexecuted part of the work is completed by another
contractor. This contention of Mr. Shukla over-looks the fact that
the additional expenses incurred by the State Government for
getting the unexecuted part of the work completed by another
contractor which are sought to be recovered under Clause 4.3.3.3
are really in the nature of damages. Section 73 of the Indian
Contract Act, 1872 provides that when a contract is broken, the
party who suffers by such breach is entitled to receive from the
party who has broken the contract compensation for any loss or
damage caused to him thereby which naturally arose in the usual
course of things from such breach, or which the parties knew,
when they made the contract, to be likely to result from the
breach of it but such compensation will not be given for any
remote and indirect loss or damage sustained by reason of the
breach. Where therefore a contractor does not complete the work
entrusted to him under the contract and the unexecuted part of
the work is entrusted to another contractor for completion and the
Government incurs additional expenses for having the work
completed by another contractor over and above the expenses
which have been paid to the original contractor, the additional
expenses sought to be recovered by the Government are nothing
but damages within the meaning of Section 73 of the Indian
Contract Act, 1872. The contention of Mr. Shukla that the
additional expenses sought to be recovered under Clause 4.3.3.3
of the conditions of contract are not really damages is therefore
misconceived.
We, therefore, hold that the view taken by the Division
Bench in the two decisions in Ch. Chandra Shekhar v. State of
M.P. and Ors. and Seth Mohanlal Hiralal (supra), that under
Clause 4.3.38.1 or any other similar Clause in the conditions of
contract, a claim against the contractor for payment of sum or
money under the contract can be recovered by the Government
from the contractor as arrears of land revenue in accordance with
the M.P. Land Revenue Code, 1959 without a decision of the S.E.
or the Tribunal under the Adhiniyam where the contractor
disputes the amount before the S.E. or the Tribunal under the
Adhiniyam is not correct in law and the two decisions of the
Miscellaneous Appeal No.2240/2020 & 2231/2020
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH, BENCH AT INDORE
- 11 Division Bench on this point are over-ruled.
The writ appeals will now be placed before the appropriate
Division Bench for hearing on merits.”
Keeping in view the judgment delivered in the aforesaid case,
as there is no adjudication so far in respect of the amount to be
recovered and the civil suit is still pending, the prayer made by the
appellant appears to be a genuine prayer.
15-
In a similar case i.e. Writ Petition No.4205/2017 (M/s. Sanee
Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. Vs. The State of Madhya Pradesh) a writ
petition was preferred challenging recovery and the recovery was
being made from other contract of the Contractor therein / by issuing
recovery certificate. The Division Bench of this Court on 21/06/2017 in
Writ Petition No.4205/2017 has passed the following order:“Shri Brian D'Silva, Senior Advocate with Shri Abhijeet
Awasthy, Advocate for the petitioner.
Shri Deepak Awasthy, Govt. Advocate for the respondentsState.
Learned counsel for the respondents-State seeks some
time to file return. He may do so within three weeks. Learned
counsel for the petitioner relies upon an order dated 20.4.2015
passed by this Court in W.P. No.5025/2015 whereby an interim
order was passed that no coercive steps for recovery of the
amount in pursuance to the Revenue Recovery Certificate be
taken. The claim of the petitioner is that such interim order,
pending hearing of the matter, in the matters raising similar
question, should be granted in favour of the petitioner.
The question: as to whether the State is competent to
recover the amount either by adjustment from the other contracts
being executed by the contractor or by issuance of recovery
certificate, requires consideration, which is pending before this
Court in number of writ petitions.
Pending consideration of the said question, we find that
the interest of the State is required to be equally protected, as in
the event the writ petition is dismissed, the State will have to start
the process of recovery afresh, the petitioners may dispose of
Miscellaneous Appeal No.2240/2020 & 2231/2020
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH, BENCH AT INDORE
- 12 their property or other contingency may render the recovery
process redundant.
Consequently, we order that the adjustments from the
other contracts and/or recovery proceedings shall remain stayed
provided the petitioner submits the Bank Guarantee to the
competent Authority and keeps the Bank Guarantee effective and
valid during the pendency of the writ petition and for a period of
three months after the decision of the writ petition.
List for final hearing immediately after three weeks.”
The Division Bench has directed the Contractor therein to
furnish a bank guarantee.
16-
The matter thereafter, has gone before the apex Court and the
apex Court vide order dated 18/08/2017 in Special Leave to Appeal
(C) No.18058/2017 has passed the following order:“Heard the learned counsel for the petitioner and perused
the relevant material.
Application for exemption from filing official translation is
allowed.
Issue notice.
Until further orders, there shall be stay of the interim order
dated 21.06.2017 passed by the High Court of Madhya Pradesh
at Jabalpur in Writ Petition No.4205 of 2017 and also of the
proceedings initiated for recovery of amount vide Demand Notice
dated 06.02.2017 by the Tehsildar, Najool Capital Project, T. T.
Nagar, Bhopal).”
The apex Court has stayed the recovery as well as the order of
the High Court by which the Contractor therein was directed to furnish
bank guarantee.
17-
In the considered opinion of this Court, the recovery ordered by
the respondent, as there has been no adjudication so far in respect of
quantum of the amount to be recovered from the appellant, deserves
to be kept in abeyance till the civil suit is decided by the trial Court.
Miscellaneous Appeal No.2240/2020 & 2231/2020
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH, BENCH AT INDORE
- 13 Resultantly, it is directed that the recovery against the appellant shall
remain in abeyance till the civil suit is decided by the trial Court. The
trial Court is directed to decide the civil suit as expeditiously as
possible preferably within a period of 03 months from the date of
receipt of certified copy of this order.
18-
In the another connected matter also i.e. Miscellaneous Appeal
No.2221/2020 recovery shall remain in abeyance and the application
preferred under Order XXXIX Rule 1 and 2 is allowed. The trial Court
shall decide the civil suit within a period of 03 months from the date of
receipt of certified copy of this order. With the aforesaid, both the
appeals stand allowed.
Certified copy as per rules.
(S.C. SHARMA)
JUDGE
Tej
Tej Prakash Vyas
Date: 2020.10.13
13:14:36 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review