Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
Reserved on: 13.02.2026
Pronounced on 27.02.2026
Uploaded on
27.02.2026
Whether the operative part or full
judgment is pronounced: Full judgment.
Arb P No. 10/2023
M/s Sharma Construction Company, …Petitioner(s)/Appellant(s)
Engineers and Contractors Jourian Road,
Near Church Akhnoor-1812201 (J&K)
through its Partner Sh. Mangu Ram
Sharma, aged 76 years S/o late Sh. Ram
Chand.
Through:
Mr. R. K. Gupta, Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Udhay Bhaskar, Advocate
v/s
…. Respondent(s)
1. Union of India through Ministry of
Defence, Govt. of India, New Delhi.
2. Engineer-in-Chief, E-in C’s Branch,
Directorate of Contract Management,
Integrated HQ of Ministry of defence
Army, Kashmir House, Rajaji Marg,
New Delhi.
3. Chief Engineer, Northern Command,
Pin 914698 C/o 56 APO
4. Chief Engineer, Udhampur Zone,
Udhampur P.O Garhi Pin 182121, C/o
56 APO.
5. Garrison Engineer (N), Akhnoor, Pin
181201.
Through:
Mr. Vishal Sharma, DSGI with
Mr. Eishaan Dadhichi, GA
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJNESH OSWAL, JUDGE.
Arb P No. 10/2023
JUDGMENT
1.
The petitioner-firm was allotted contract work for construction of “10 X
above ground bunkers (50 Mt) each 01 X open WP AMN Shed and Allied
infrastructure at 102 AP 10 INF DOU at Sunderbani” by respondent No.
4 vide acceptance letter No. 87360-A/74/E8 dated 30.10.2006.
2.
It is stated by the petitioner-firm that despite certain breaches on the part
of the respondent-department, it successfully executed the contract work
on 23.05.2009, well within the stipulated contract period and respondent
No. 5 issued the completion certificate dated 29.05.2009. The petitionerfirm further claims to have requested the respondent-department to take
the joint measurements of the executed work and supply the abstract of
measurable works, DO’s, statement of recoveries, consolidated statement
of credit and debits, statement of all paid RARs, to enable the petitionerfirm to prepare and submit the final bill but the aforesaid documents were
not provided to the petitioner-firm for years together, therefore, the final
bill could not be prepared. It is stated that while the final bill was still
awaited, one of the walls (VIFT wall) constructed by the petitioner-firm in
the aforesaid work collapsed in the year, 2010. A Court of inquiry was
initiated by the department. The petitioner-firm participated in the Court
of enquiry and submitted its reply to the department stating therein that
the wall in question had fallen due to the defective design supplied by the
department. It is also stated that all the stages of the work carried out by
the petitioner-firm were duly checked and approved by the Engineer-inCharge and G.E. at every stage of the work. While the Court of enquiry
Arb P No. 10/2023
was being conducted by the department, the petitioner-firm kept on
requesting the department to prepare the final bill and make the balance
payment of the executed work. The petitioner-firm claims to have
subsequently gained the knowledge that nothing adverse was found in the
Court of inquiry against the petitioner-firm, therefore, the petitioner-firm
again requested the department to finalize the final bill and make the
payment of the work executed by the petitioner-firm, but there was no
response from the department.
3.
The petitioner-firm vide its letter dated 26.10.2018 requested the
department to furnish the desired documents for preparation of the final
bill. It is averred that the department, being not satisfied with the result of
the court of enquiry, initiated yet another departmental enquiry against the
petitioner-firm and issued a fresh show-cause notice dated 31.12.2018.
The petitioner firm vide its letter dated 14.01.2019 submitted its reply to
the aforesaid show-cause notice and denied any omission or lapse on its
part in execution of the contract work. Again, in the departmental enquiry,
nothing was found adverse against the petitioner-firm. It is stated that
during the Court of enquiry as well as departmental enquiry, the
petitioner-firm had been regularly requesting the department for release of
the payment of final bill and the FDR, but in vain. After its exoneration,
the petitioner-firm vide its letter dated 26.07.2019, again requested the
department to release the payment of the executed contract work within
30 days of the receipt of the letter, failing which the petitioner-firm shall
be left with no option but to invoke condition 70 of IAFW-2249 for
Arb P No. 10/2023
reference of the claim to the Arbitrator. When the said letter evoked no
response, the petitioner-firm vide its communication dated 19.02.2020,
addressed to respondent No. 4, invoked Clause 70 of IAFW-2249 and
requested for reference of the disputes/claims to the Sole Arbitrator for its
adjudication. When respondent No. 4 failed to refer the claim of the
petitioner-firm to the sole Arbitrator, the petitioner-firm, vide its letter
dated 20.03.2020, requested respondent No. 2 for reference of the
claims/disputes to the sole Arbitrator.
4.
It is contended that after more than one year of receipt of the letters for
appointment of the Arbitrator submitted by the petitioner-firm to the
respondent Nos. 2 & 4, the Commandant HQ 135 Works Engineer vide
his letter dated 06.05.2021 issued a convening order for the constitution of
Board of Offers to ascertain the de-valuation statement in respect of the
contract work executed by the petitioner firm. The petitioner-firm in terms
of communication dated 01.06.2021, addressed to respondent No. 2,
pointed out the harassment being meted out to the petitioner-firm at the
behest of officers of the department as the convening order was passed
pursuant to the letter dated 10.12.2019 issued by respondent No. 4 after 16
months of the said letter. The petitioner-firm claims to have objected to
the constitution of the Board of Officer for ascertaining de-valuation
statement. Thereafter, respondent No. 4 vide letter dated 01.06.2022,
rejected the request of the petitioner-firm for appointment of independent
Arbitrator made vide letters dated 19.02.2020 and 20.03.2020 on the
Arb P No. 10/2023
grounds that request for appointment of Arbitrator is time barred and that
the petitioner-firm had signed the final bill without any protest.
5.
It is urged that rejection of the request of the petitioner-firm for referring
its claim to the Arbitrator is totally illegal and bad in the eyes of law
because in the convening order dated 06.05.2021, Commander HQ 135
Works Engineer has clearly observed that final bill has been prepared but
not yet paid. It is contended that in view of the pendency of the court of
enquiry and department enquiry, the department did not take any decision
with regard to the release of balance payment of the executed work and
FDRs, therefore, the observations that the request for appointment of sole
Arbitrator is time barred, is wholly incorrect and illegal and the conduct of
the department itself goes to show that it was adopting all illegal means to
deprive the petitioner-firm of its genuine claim.
6.
The respondents have filed the response, stating therein that the petitioner
firm’s claim got crystallized on the date of completion of work and hence
the first cause of action for appointment of arbitrator arose on 23.05.2009
and thereafter on 19.10.2010, when the final bill ought to have been paid.
Further, third cause of action for appointment of Arbitrator arose on
26.07.2019, when the petitioner-firm served notice for reference of
disputes to the arbitration under condition 70 of IAFW-2249.
Accordingly, it is contended that the present petition for appointment of
arbitrator has been filed on 03.04.2023 i.e. after 14 years of completion of
work and more than 12 years after the due date of payment of final bill
and more 3½ years after the notice for appointment of arbitrator was
Arb P No. 10/2023
served by the petitioner on the respondents and as such, the petition is not
maintainable being time barred. It is also urged that as the petitioner-firm
has signed the final bill and no claim certificate forming part of the final
bill without any reservation and submitted undertaking letter dated
07.05.2019, wherein it is stated that it would not claim any interest on the
delayed payment of final bill amount and there are no subsisting claims of
the petitioner which are required to be referred to arbitration. It is also
contended that retaining wall had collapsed due to the bad workmanship
and use of spurious/substandard material by the petitioner and the
petitioner was squarely held responsible for the lapse as is evident from
the proceedings of the court of inquiry, which recommended to take
action against the petitioner-firm by way of recovery of amount towards
cost of defect attributable to firm and by reviewing its Class of Enlistment
owing to the default attributable to it as mentioned in the court of inquiry.
The petitioner’s request for finalization of the bill and balance payment
for the work executed, was not acceded to as huge recovery was likely to
be affected from petitioner-firm owing to defective work executed by it.
As the court of inquiry had not quantified the extent of recovery for
defective work, a BOO was ordered on 06.05.2021 to prepare a devaluation statement and work out the amount of recovery due from the
petitioner. Since at the given time, the recoveries from the petitioner were
not crystallized, the final amount could not be determined. The said BOO
submitted report working out the recovery, on account of devaluation for
the work to the tune of Rs. 41,51,823.48/- which is under examination by
Arb P No. 10/2023
the Accepting Officer. As regards final bill, it was already signed by the
petitioner, but its processing was withheld as huge recoveries were likely
to be affected from the petitioner. It is further stated that Enlisting
Authority did not take disciplinary action against the petitioner-firm and
only warned the petitioner to be more careful in executing the work as per
the contract provisions in future, but it did not imply that the recovery of
defective work was not to be made from his final bill by the department.
7.
Mr. R. K. Gupta, learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner, has submitted
that when the findings of the Board of officers and court of inquiry
proceedings were not submitted till 2021, this petition cannot be said to be
barred by limitation. He particularly referred to convening order dated
06.05.2021 to assert that there is admission on the part of respondents that
final bill could not be processed pending preparation of devaluation
statement.
8.
Mr. Vishal Sharma, learned DSGI, has submitted that the petitioner-firm
invoked the Clause-70 of IAFW/2249 for referring the disputes/claims
initially vide notice dated 26.07.2019, as such, the petition is time barred
and even if the cause of action to file this petition is to be reckoned with
reference to notice dated 19.02.2020, still the instant petition would be
time barred, as the same was filed only on 03.04.2023.
9.
In rebuttal, Mr. R. K. Gupta, learned Senior Counsel has submitted that
assuming for the sake of arguments that cause of action to file the petition
is to be reckoned from 30 days from the expiry of notice dated
19.02.2020, still the petition would be within time as due to Covid-19
Arb P No. 10/2023
pandemic, the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India vide its order dated
10.01.2022, passed in Misc. Application No. 21/2022, had directed that
the period from 15.03.2020 till 28.02.2022 shall stand excluded for the
purpose of limitation. As such, this petition cannot be said to be barred by
limitation.
10.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
11.
The petitioner-firm invoked Condition 70 of IAFW-2249 (General
Conditions of Contract) for the referral of disputes vide notice dated
19.02.2020. The respondents contend that both the underlying claims and
the present petition for the appointment of an arbitrator are barred by
limitation. Regarding the learned DSGI’s contention that arbitration was
invoked earlier on 26.07.2019, a perusal of that communication reveals it
was merely a demand for payment. It stipulated that if dues were not
released within 30 days, the petitioner would 'be left with no option' but to
invoke Condition 70 of IAFW-2249. Crucially, vide letter dated
26.07.2019, no actual request was made for referral of the claims to an
arbitrator; it was only through the communication dated 19.02.2020 that
the petitioner formally invoked the arbitration clause.
12.
Mr. Vishal Sharma, learned DSGI has argued that the petition, filed on
03.04.2023, is time-barred since the notice of invocation was issued on
19.02.2020. Notably, the respondents admit the contents of paragraphs 20
and 21 of the petition, but fail to specify when the notice dated 19.02.2020
was actually served upon them. This omission is significant, as the
limitation for filing a petition under Section 11(6) of the Arbitration and
Arb P No. 10/2023
Conciliation Act, 1996 was triggered only upon the expiry of 30 days
from the receipt of the invocation notice.
13.
Be that as it may, even if assuming the period of limitation is to be
reckoned when the notice dated 19.02.2020 was served, the limitation
period to file petition under section 11(6) of the Act for appointment of
arbitrator commenced during the period Covid-19 Pandemic and in view
of the order passed by Hon’ble the Supreme Court of India order dated
10.01.2022, in Misc. Application No. 21/2022, the period of limitation
from 15.03.2020 till 28.03.2022 shall stand excluded for the purpose of
calculating the period of limitation. As such, the present petition cannot be
dismissed on account of it being time-barred.
14.
Regarding the respondents' contention that the petitioner’s claims are
time-barred, is left open to be adjudicated by the Arbitrator. As limitation
is a mixed question of facts and law, it shall be considered on its merits
alongside the rival claims and counter-claims of the parties during the
arbitral proceedings.
15.
In view of the above, this Court is of the considered view that, given the
existence of a valid arbitration agreement and the respondents' failure to
appoint an arbitrator despite due notice, the jurisdictional requirements
under Section 11(6) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, stand
fully satisfied. The serious disputes raised by the parties regarding their
respective claims and counter-claims are matters, that must be referred to
the chosen forum for adjudication. The disputes raised by the petitionerfirm arise out of the execution of the contract and are arbitrable in nature.
Arb P No. 10/2023
Accordingly, Mr. Satish Chandra, Additional Director General (Rtd)
MES, R/o lane No. 04, Greater Kailash, Jammu 180011, is hereby
appointed as the Sole Arbitrator to adjudicate the disputes between the
parties arising out of “construction work of 10 X above ground bunkers
(50 Mt) each 01 X open WP AMN Shed and Allied infrastructure at 102
AP 10 INF DOU at Sunderbani”. The learned Arbitrator shall enter upon
the reference after furnishing the disclosure as required under Section
12(1) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 and shall conduct the
arbitral proceedings in accordance with the provisions of the Act.
16.
The Registry shall send a copy of this order to the learned Arbitrator
forthwith.
17.
Disposed of.
18.
(RAJNESH OSWAL)
JUDGE
JAMMU:
27.02.2026
Karam Chand
Whether the order is speaking: Yes/No
Whether the order is reportable: Yes/No
KARAM CHAND
2026.02.27 16:40
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review