Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT G WA L I O R
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE ANAND PATHAK
ON THE 11th OF JANUARY, 2024
ARBITRATION CASE No. 78 of 2023
BETWEEN:M/S SGP INDANE GAS DISTRIBUTOR
MUNGAOLI
DISTRICT
ASHOKNAGAR
THROUGH ITS PROPRIETOR MOHAMMAD
IMRAN KHAN S/O SHRI A.M. SUNNI, AGED
ABOUT 41 YEARS, R/O MUNGAOLI DISTRICT
ASHOKNAGAR (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI AJAY MISHRA WITH SHRI SOMYADEEP DWIVEDI- ADVOCATES)
AND
INDIAN
OIL
CORPORATION
LTD.
THROUGH ITS GENERAL MANAGER (LPG)
M.P. STATE OFFICE INDIAN OIL BHAWAN
16 ARERA HILLS JAIL ROAD BHOPAL PIN
462011 (MADHYA PRADESH)
DEPUTY GENERAL MANAGER (LPG-S)
2.
INDIAN
OIL
CORPORATION
LTD.
BAHADURA RESIDENCY, II FLOOR CITY
CENTER, GWALIOR PIN- 474011 (MADHYA
PRADESH)
1.
.....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI SANKALP SHARMA- ADVOCATE FOR RESPONDENT NO.1)
AND
ARBITRATION CASE No. 88 of 2023
BETWEEN:M/S SGP INDANE GAS DISTRIBUTOR
MUNGAOLI
DISTRICT
ASHOKNAGAR
THROUGH ITS PROPRIETOR MOHAMMAD
IMRAN KHAN S/O SHRI A.M. SUNNI, AGED
ABOUT 41 YEARS, MUNGAOLI DISTRICT
ASHOKNAGAR (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI AJAY MISHRA WITH SHRI SOMYADEEP DWIVEDI- ADVOCATES)
AND
1. INDIAN OIL CORPORATION LIMITED
THROUGH ITS GENERAL MANAGER (LPG)
M.P. STATE OFFICE INDIAN OIL BHAWAN
16 ARERA HILLS JAIL ROAD BHOPAL PIN
462011 (MADHYA PRADESH)
DEPUTY GENERAL MANAGER (LPG-S)
2.
INDIAN
OIL
CORPORATION
LTD
BAHADURA RESIDENCY, II FLOOR CITY
CENTER, GWALIOR PIN- 474011 (MADHYA
PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI SANKALP SHARMA- ADVOCATE FOR RESPONDENT NO.1)
This petition coming on for hearing this day, the court passed the
following:
ORDER
1.
Regard being had to the similitude of the factual and legal
distpute involved in the cases, these cases are heard simultaneously
and decided by this common order. For convenience's sake, facts as
narrated in AC No. 78 of 2023 are taken into consideration.
2.
The instant application is preferred under Section 11 of the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (hereinafter referred as Act of
1996) through which the applicant, who happens to be a LPG distrubutor
of Indian Oil Corportion seeking appointment of arbitrator to resolve the
dispute errupted between the two.
3.
Precisely stated facts of the case is that applicant was appointed as
LPG distributor by the respondents in the year 2012 and Indane (LPG)
distributorship (Domestic and Commercial) agreement was executed
between the parties on 30.08.2012 for sale of Liquefied Petroleum Gas as
Indane in cylinders for household consumer and commercial consumers
into the territory of Mungaoli an area falling within 15 kms. radius of
Mungaoli.
5.
As per clause 37 of the said agreement all disputes/differences, if
any crept between the two, had to be decided as per the procedure
prescribed into it. In sum and substance, an arbitrator has to be appointed
for resolution of the disputes.
6.
Vide order dated 30.01.2020, certain fine and penalty was imposed.
Taking exception to the said order, a writ petition vide W.P.
No.4145/2020 was preferred in which respondents referred the question
of alternative remedy available to the petitioner by way of appointment of
arbitrator. Considering the said submissions and concession of petitioner,
writ petition was disposed of to avail alternative remedy. A writ appeal
was preferred by way of W.A. 307/2021 on 15.03.2021 for clarification
so that parties may resort to arbitration proceedings. Said writ appeal was
disposed of vide order dated 26.03.2021 whereby learned Division Bench
of this Court clarified the position that parties are always at liberty to
resort to alternative remedy.
7.
Meanwhile, it appears that on 02.03.2020, in pursuance to the
impugned order dated 30.01.2020, Gas Agency of applicant got
terminated and this further precipitated the cause of action for applicant
to agitate. It appears that on 10.07.2022, plea for appointment of
arbitrator was raised by applicant before the respondents which was
declined. Therefore, applicant is before this Court for appointment of
arbitrator.
8.
It is the submission of learned counsel for applicant that due to
wrath of COVID-29 Pandemic situation when all proceedings, even life,
came to a halt, applicant did not have any opportunity to press for
arbitration proceedings and, considering the peculiar fact situation as
crept into overall lives of people, Hon'ble Apex Court suo moto took the
cognizance and extended the period of limitation in legal proceedings
time and again. Learned counsel for applicant referred the judgment
passed by Apex Court in the case of IN RE: COGNIZANCE FOR
EXTENSION OF LIMITATION 2022 (1) MPLJ 250 (equivalent 2022
(3) SCC 117). According to him, limitation between the period of
15.03.2020 to 28.02.2022 stood excluded for the purposes of limitation as
may be prescribed under any general and special laws in respect of all
judicial or quasi judicial proceedings. Therefore, that period has to be
excluded from the period of limitation prescribed. In other words,
applicant had to resort to arbitration proceedings within three years from
the date of cause of action and if the period as referred above which
comes to almost two years, if excluded from the three years applicant
having for initiation of proceedings, then it comes around five years and
that exclusion puts the applicant in a position where, he can assert his
rights to be decided on merit by way of appointment of arbitrator.
9.
According to learned senior counsel, period of limitation even
otherwise has to be seen on the anvil of sufficiency of cause and once in a
century phenomenon haunted the whole life of the country, then, in that
peculiar fact situation, dispute is to be seen from that vantage point.
10.
Learned counsel for respondent opposed the prayer and prayed for
dismissal of application on the ground of limitation as according to him,
after cause of action accrued to the applicant from 30.01.2020, he had to
resort to alternative remedy of appointment of arbitrator within three
years. Since, applicant failed in its endeavors to resort to arbitration, then
as per the dictum of the Apex Court in the case of B and T AG Vs.
Ministry of Defence 2023 SCC Online SC 657, the instant application
be dismissed. Another ground raised by the learned counsel for
respondent is the manner in which legal notice was sent. According to
him, the legal notice ought to have been duly approved by the litigating
parties and legal notice sent by its counsel does not stand to definition of
legal notice. Therefore, there is no notice for appointment of arbitrator
per se.
11.
Heard the counsel for the rival parties and perused the documents
appended thereto.
12.
In the case in hand, primary objection of respondents is in respect
of limitation. Case in hand further delineates the factual details by which
it appears that applicant after getting cause of action on 30.01.2020 tried
to pursue its other remedies before learned writ court and thereafter
learned writ appellate court. Besides that, due to wrath of COVID-19
Pandemic, when the lives and legal procedures came to a grinding halt,
then the Apex Court given guidance regarding computation of limitation
so that the litigating parties may not suffer because of unavoidable
situation created by the COVID-19 Pandemic. Therefore, Judgment
referred above by counsel for applicant, while computing the limitation
appears to further the cause of applicant. When period from 15.03.2020 to
28.02.2022 was excluded for the purposes of limitation by the Apex
Court, then it appears that applicant had sufficient limitation to its credit
to agitate the issue. Considering the dispute from such angle, it appears
that applicant had limitation to agitate. Relevant paragraph of the
judgment
of
the
Apex
Court
in
the
case
of
COGNIZANCE(supra) is reiterated for ready reference:5. Taking into consideration the arguments
advanced by learned counsel and the impact of the
surge of the virus on public health and adversities
faced by litigants in the prevailing conditions, we
deem it appropriate to dispose of the M.A. No. 21 of
2022 with the following directions:
I.
The order dated 23.03.2020 is restored
and in continuation of the subsequent orders
dated
08.03.2021,
27.04.2021
and
23.09.2021, it is directed that the period
from 15.03.2020 till 28.02.2022 shall stand
excluded for the purposes of limitation as
may be prescribed under any general or
special laws in respect of all judicial or
quashi juridical proceedings.
IN
RE:
II.
Consequently, the balance period of
limitation remaining as on 03.10.2021, if
any, shall become available with effect from
01.03.2022.
III. In cases where the limitation would
have expired during the period between
5.03.2020 till 28.02.2022, notwithstanding
the actual balance period of limitation
remaining, all persons shall have a
limitation period of 90 days from 01.03.2022.
In the event the actual balance period of
limitation remaining, with effect from
01.03.2022 is greater than 90 days,that
longer period shall apply.
IV.
It is further clarified that the period
from 15.03.2020 till 28.02.2022 shall also
stand excluded in computing the periods
prescribed under Sections 23(4) and 29A of
the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996,
Section 12A of the Commercial Courts Act,
2015 and provisos (b) and (c) of Section 138
of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 and
any other laws, which prescribe period(s) of
limitation for instituting proceedings, outer
limits (within which the court or tribunal
can condone delay) and termination of
proceedings.
13.
Legal notice sent by applicant was under the information and
instructions received from the client,therefore, it cannot be assumed, out
rightly at this juncture that notice was bereft of any prior approval. Even
otherwise, learned counsel for applicant made statement at Bar that they
are relying upon the notice and once the reliance by the litigant itself
reflects consent, then such argument has to pale into oblivion.
14.
Even otherwise, arbitration can take care of all objections as raised
by the respondents in accordance with law. Therefore, application
preferred by applicant for appointment of arbitrator is hereby allowed and
matter is referred for arbitration at Madhya Pradesh Domestic and
International Arbitration Centre, Jabalpur to undertake appointment of
arbitrator and for arbitration proceedings to be proceeded in accordance
with law. Appointment of arbitrator be made in both the cases.
15.
Needful be done at an expeditious note.
16.
Application stands disposed of with the aforesaid.
Certified copy as per rules.
(ANAND PATHAK)
JUDGE
vishal
VISHAL
UPAD
HYAY
UPADHYAY
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF
MADHYA PRADESH BENCH
GWALIOR, ou=HIGH COURT OF
MADHYA PRADESH BENCH
GWALIOR,
2.5.4.20=5d5050008f4c040023a64cb
030d9c80d25cbf5f3eb4f56fa864a20d
b4fbe3d3e, postalCode=474001,
st=Madhya Pradesh,
serialNumber=637E939E833627AE8C
C13D85E5F2383A287E83C6CDFA634
7A00E482772314FE9, cn=VISHAL
UPADHYAY
Date: 2024.01.11 18:04:27 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review