Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/15
GAHC040005222025
2026:GAU-AP:447-DB
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WA/32/2025
M/s Sahabuddin Siddique and Anr
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:represented by its proprietor Shri Sahabuddin Siddique
having its office at Kamalabari
Da-Hukuta
PO and PS Duliajan
Dibrugarh District
Assam 786602
2: Sahabuddin Siddique
Age: 46
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Fazur Rahman Siddique
resident of Kamalabari
Da-Hukuta
PO and PS Duliajan
Dibrugarh District
Assam 786602
VERSUS
The Union of India and 4 Ors
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:represented by the Secretary
Govt of India
Ministry of Defence
101A
South Block
New Delhi.
2:The Border Road Organization
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:represented by Director General
Ministry of Defence
Seema Sadak Bahawan
Page No.# 2/15
Ring Road
Naraina
Delhi Cant
New Delhi 110010
3:The Chief Engineer
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:BRO cum Authority Engineer
BRO
Project Brahamank
C/o APO
Pasighat
Arunachal Pradesh 931722
4:The Commander
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:BRO cum Team Leader Cum Senior Highway Engineer
HQ 44
Border Roads Tsk Force
930044
C/o 99 APO
5:The Deputy Commissioner
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:Tato
Shi Yomi District
Arunachal Pradesh.
6:Valecha Engineering Ltd
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:having its registered office at Plot No.B-6
7th Floor
Lokhandwala Complex
Valecha Chambers
New Lind Road
Andheri West-Azad Nagar
Mumbai
Maharashtra 400053
7:Canara Bank
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:Duliajan Branch
Assam
Page No.# 3/15
represented by its Branch Manager
having tis Branch Office at Duliajan
Dibrugarh District
Assam 786602
-----------Advocate for : P J Saikia
Advocate for : Marto Kato appearing for The Union of India and 4 Ors: Advocate ,
,
,
,
,
, appearing for 2,
3,
4,
5,
6,
7, respectively.
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE MRIDUL KUMAR KALITA
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ANJAN MONI KALITA
Date on which judgment was reserved :
03.03.2026
Date of pronouncement of judgment
07.05.2026
:
Whether the pronouncement is of the :
Yes
operative part of the judgment?
Whether the full judgment has been
pronounced?
:
NA
Page No.# 4/15
JUDGMENT AND ORDER(CAV)
Anjan Moni Kalita, J.
Heard Mr. P. J. Saikia, learned Senior Counsel assisted by Ms. M. Nirola,
learned counsel for the appellants. Also heard Mr. M. Kato, learned DSGI
appearing for the Respondent Nos. 1 to 4 and Ms. P. Pangu, learned
Government Advocate appearing for the Respondent No. 5.
2.
The instant intra-court appeal has been filed by the Appellants assailing
the Judgment and Order dated 04.03.2025, passed by the learned Single Judge
in WP(C) No. 186 (AP) of 2024.
3.
The facts leading to the filing of the instant writ appeal are briefly
summarised herein below:
A.
The Appellants and one M/s Velecha Engineering Ltd., had
entered
into
a
Memorandum
of
Understanding
(MoU)
on
15.06.2021, for submitting a tender for “Construction and Upgradation of Tato-Mechuka Road (design chainage from Km 23.800
to Km 33.100 and existing chainage from 24.800 to Km 36.000
(PKG-II) in the State of Arunachal Pradesh” (herein after referred to
as ‘Contract Work’). As per the said MoU, the tender is to be
submitted in the name of the aforesaid M/s Velecha Engineering
Ltd., and if the work is awarded to M/s Velecha Engineering Ltd., the
Appellants will be entitled to execute the entire work, on back to
back basis. In the tender process, M/s Velecha Engineering Ltd.,
came out as a successful bidder and Letter of Acceptance was issued
Page No.# 5/15
in favour of M/s Velecha Engineering Ltd. As per the terms of the
MoU, the Appellants submitted the Bank Guarantee, for the
successful tenderer, i.e., M/s Velecha Engineering Ltd., for a sum of
Rs. 2,41,65,000/- (Rupees Two Crores Fourty One Lakhs and Sixty
Five Thousands) only for the aforesaid Contract Work. However, the
Respondent No. 3, vide it’s letter dated 10.12.2021, approved the
Appellants as the sub-contractor only for 49% of the value of the
Contract Work, amounting Rs.39,46,95,000/- (Rupees Thirty Nine
Crores Fourty Six Lakhs and Ninety Five Thousands) only under the
aforesaid M/s Velecha Engineering Ltd. The Appellants started the
execution of the work and completed 49% of the Contract Work.
However, further progress could not be made due to bad weather
condition, heavy rainfall, various travel restrictions etc. and due to
rejection of the prayer of the aforesaid M/s Velecha Engineering Ltd.,
for extension of time, the Appellants apprehended that the
authorities may impose liquidated damages on the aforesaid bills,
which were yet to be submitted. The Appellants faced with the
aforesaid, submitted a representation to the respondent authorities
on 07.12.2023, praying for releasing the Bank Guarantee as well as
other reliefs and not to impose liquidated damages on the bills.
While
the
aforementioned
representation
was
pending,
the
respondent authorities terminated the Contract with the aforesaid
M/s Velecha Engineering Ltd., vide it’s letter dated 16.12.2023. In
view of the aforesaid termination, the Appellants approached this
High Court by filing the aforesaid writ petition for release of their
dues and other consequential reliefs.
Page No.# 6/15
B.
The respondent authorities by filing their Affidavit-in-opposition
denied the contentions made by the Appellants in the writ petition.
The stand taken by the respondent authorities was that the
respondent authorities had given the Contract Work to M/s Velecha
Engineering Ltd., on 29.06.2021 and on their request for approval of
the Appellants as a sub-contractor, to execute 49% value of the
Contract Work, as per Clause 4.2 of EPC contract, the same was
approved by the authorities, vide it’s letter dated 10.12.2021. The
Respondents contended that as per Article 4 (Obligations of the
Contractor) Clause 4.8 (Unforeseen Difficulties) and 4.11 (Site Data),
the contractor’s reason for failing to carry out the work was not
tenable and none of the reasons assigned by the Appellants come
under Article 21 Clause 21.1 (Force Majeure) and therefore, the
claims of the Appellants could be considered. It was also contended
that the work was in fact abandoned by the Appellants along with
the Contractor. It was contended by the Respondents that only
26.21% work was completed by the Appellants. It was also
contended by the respondent authorities that no further bill(s) had
been submitted by the EPC contractor, i.e. M/s Velecha Engineering
Ltd. regarding any further progress of work on the ground. It was
contended that the contract was terminated on 16.12.2023 due to
the EPC Contractor's default, vide it’s letter dated 16.12.2023, as per
the EPC Contract entered with the EPC Contractor, namely, M/s
Velecha Engineering Ltd. It was contended that as per Article 23.6
(i)(a), upon termination on account of contractor's default under
Clause 23.1, the authority has the right to en-cash and appropriate
Page No.# 7/15
the performance security, additional performance security, if any and
the retention money or in the event the contractor’s failure to
replenish or extend the performance security and additional security,
if any, claim the amount stipulated in clause 7.1 as agreed predetermined compensation to the authority for any losses, delays and
cost of completing the works and maintenance, if any. In terms of
the aforesaid, the respondent authorities en-cashed the Bank
Guarantee and deducted the pre-determined compensation in terms
of the aforesaid EPC Contract. It was contended that the respondent
authorities had full right to en-cash the aforesaid amount on the
default of the EPC Contractor under the terms and conditions of the
Contract and the Appellants’ contention to have completed more
than 49% of the work was baseless as only 26.21% work had been
completed as per the specification.
C.
After hearing the parties, the writ petition was disposed of with
the following direction:
“Under the given facts and circumstances and also in the light
of the submissions advanced by the learned advocates of both
sides, this Court is inclined to dispose of this petition with the
following directions:
i.
In terms of the joint verification regarding the
work executed by the petitioners having already been
carried out by the respondent authorities and a report
thereof being prepared, a work completion certificate to
that extent what the petitioners have executed shall be
issued to them by the respondent numbers 1 to 4;
Page No.# 8/15
ii.
In respect of the issue of liquidated damages,
compensation and releasing of the performance bank
guarantee, etc., the petitioners stand relegated to seek
redress in appropriate Civil Court for recovery of the
amount forfeited by the respondent authorities, if so
advised;
iii.
All pending bills, if not paid in the meantime, shall
be released in favour of the petitioners in terms of the
joint verification report.”
4.
The instant writ appeal has been filed by the Appellants being aggrieved
primarily by the direction given by the learned Single Judge at paragraph 24(ii)
of the impugned Judgment and Order dated 04.03.2025. The Appellants’ main
ground of appeal is that the Contract Work, i.e., “Construction and Up-gradation
of Tato-Mechuka Road (design chainage from Km 23.800 to Km 33.100 and
existing chainage from 24.800 to Km 36.000 (PKG-II) in the State of Arunachal
Pradesh” was awarded to the EPC contractor, namely, M/s Velecha Engineering
Ltd. and there is a contract between the aforesaid M/s Velecha Engineering
Limited and the respondent authorities, however, there is no back-to-back
agreement for the sub-contract between the EPC Contractor and the subcontractor, i.e., the present Appellants. Since there is no privity of contract
between the respondent authorities and the Appellants, none of the conditions
of the EPC Contract dated 29.06.2021 executed between the EPC Contractor,
i.e., M/s Velecha Engineering Ltd. and the respondent authorities shall be
binding on the Appellants. It is the contention of the Appellants that since the
aforesaid Contract is not binding upon the Appellants, the learned Single Judge
ought not to have passed the direction contained in paragraph 24 (ii) of the
Page No.# 9/15
impugned Judgment and Order dated 04.03.2025, thereby relegating the
Appellants to the Civil Court.
5.
The other ground taken by the Appellants is to the effect that since the
Appellants have completed 49% of the work, the action of the respondent
authorities of deducting the liquidated damages to the tune of 10% of the total
contract value is not justifiable. The Appellants contended that in terms of the
aforesaid contract also, since the Appellants had completed their own portion of
49% of the work and the contract had to be terminated due to the default
committed by the EPC Contractor, namely, M/s Velecha Engineering Ltd., by not
performing their remaining 51% of the work, if there is any, then liquidated
damages on the amount of 49% of the contract value should have been
imposed, provided the breach is proved by the respondent authorities as due to
the default of the Appellants. Since there was no finding to that effect, the
respondent authorities ought not to have deducted the whole 10% of the
contract value in the instant case. The Appellants also contended that the Bank
Guarantee was, in fact, submitted by the Appellants for the whole Contract
Work whereas, they were responsible only for 49% of the total work. Therefore,
the invocation of the Bank Guarantee for the total value of the Contract Work by
the respondent authorities is not correct.
6.
In view of the aforesaid, the Appellants have challenged the impugned
order dated 04.03.2025, passed by the learned Single Judge to the effect as
mentioned above.
7.
Mr. P. J. Saikia, learned Senior Counsel for the Appellants submits that the
concerned Bank Guarantee valued at Rs. 2,41,65,000/- (Rupees Two Crores
Fourty One Lakhs and Sixty Five Thousands) was submitted by the Appellants
Page No.# 10/15
in terms of the aforesaid Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) that was
entered into between the Appellants and the EPC contractor, namely, M/s
Velecha Engineering Ltd., dated 15.06.2021, much before the tender process as
well as singing of the aforesaid EPC Contract dated 29.06.2021. He submits that
as per the MoU, after submission of the tender in the name of the EPC
Contractor, M/s Velecha Engineering Ltd., if the contractor is successful then the
whole contract was to be executed by the Appellants and in view of that
understanding, the Bank Guarantee for the whole work was submitted by the
Appellants on behalf of the EPC contractor to the respondent authorities.
However, later on when the respondent authorities, vide their letter dated
10.12.2021, approved only 49% of the Contract Work to be done by the
Appellants, the Appellants though approached the respondent authorities about
the issue, the same remained unanswered. Therefore, he submits that since the
Appellants are responsible only for 49% of the Contract Work which they have
completed, the entire amount of the Bank Guarantee ought not to have been
invoked and en-cashed by the respondent authorities as the termination of the
contract is not due to their default, rather the same is attributable to the EPC
contractor, namely, M/s Velecha Engineering Ltd.
8.
The learned Senior Counsel submits that the Appellants have completed
49% of the work which was given to them but due to the default of the EPC
contractor, namely M/s Velecha Engineering Ltd., who couldnot complete any of
their 51% of the work, the contract was terminated by the respondent
authorities. Therefore, apparently the default is attributable to the EPC
contractor, namely M/s Velecha Engineering Ltd and that being so, the
deduction of liquidated damages of 10% of total value of the Contract is not
correct and the same at best could have been proportionate to the percentage
Page No.# 11/15
of work performed by them. He further submits that since the EPC Contract
dated 29.06.2021 is not binding upon Appellants as they are not a party to the
EPC Contract, the liquidated damages could not have been deducted by the
respondent authorities from the sub-contractor, which does not have any privity
of contract with the respondent authorities. He submits that there has been an
apparent error and illegality committed by the respondent authorities in
deducting the liquidated damages from their legal dues and the same cannot be
sustained under the laws. Therefore, the direction passed by the learned Single
Judge should be interfered with by this court in appeal.
9.
Mr. Saikia, the learned Senior Counsel has relied on certain cases in
support of his case to the effect that since the Appellants are not a party to the
EPC Contract, the same is not binding on them. We have considered the cases
cited by him.
10.
Mr. M. Kato, learned DSGI for the respondent Nos. 1 to 4 in his
submissions contended that there is no privity of contract between the
Appellants and the respondent authorities and the deduction of liquidated
damages has been made from the bill of the EPC Contractor on the whole
amount as the Contract has to be terminated due to default of the EPC
Contractor. Therefore, he submits that there is no wrong in deduction of the
liquidated damages as well as invocation of the Bank Guarantee submitted by
the EPC contractor, namely, M/s Velecha Engineering Ltd. He further submits
that the respondent authorities were unaware that the Bank Guarantee has
been submitted by the Appellants on behalf of M/s Velecha Engineering Ltd., as
same is not on record and not a matter to be looked into by the respondent
authorities.
Page No.# 12/15
11.
We have heard the submissions made by the learned counsel appearing
for the respective parties and have gone through the materials available on
record.
12.
It is seen that the EPC Contract was entered into between the EPC
Contractor, namely, M/s Velecha Engineering Ltd. and the respondent authorities
on 29.06.2021. Subsequent to the aforesaid Contract and on the request of the
EPC Contractor, the respondent authorities, i.e., SE(Civil) OFFG Chief Engineer
Project, Brahmank has approved the sub-contractor, i.e., the Appellants with a
condition that the sub-contractor shall not be allowed to execute work more
than 49% value of the Contract Work. It was also made clear in their approval
letter that the EPC contractor, M/s Velecha Engineering Ltd. shall at all times be
responsible and liable for its obligations under the EPC Contract. It is seen that
after the signing of the aforesaid EPC Contract, there was no back-to-back
contract that was entered into between the EPC Contractor, i.e., M/s Velecha
Engineering Ltd. and the Appellants, though there was a MoU between the two
dated 15.06.2021. During the execution of the Contract Work, it is contended
that 49% part of the Contract Work was executed by the Appellants in the name
of the EPC Contractor, i.e., M/s Velecha Engineering Ltd. It is also seen that an
escrow account was opened jointly by M/s Velecha Engineering Ltd. and the
Appellants for operating and maintaining the payments received for the
execution of the Contract Work as per the terms and conditions of the aforesaid
escrow account. Payments were never released to the sub-contractor, i.e.,
Appellants directly by the respondent authorities.
13.
It is also seen that there is a dispute regarding completion of the work by
the Appellants as though the Appellants contended that they have completed
Page No.# 13/15
their 49% of the Contract Work, the respondent authorities have contended that
only 26.21% of the Contract Work was completed by the Appellants and for the
same, the due money has already been released to the EPC Contractor. They
also contended that no further bills have been submitted by the EPC Contractor
regarding any further work. It is seen that the contract was terminated on
16.12.2023 due to the EPC Contractor's default in terms of the EPC Contract.
14.
The Hon’ble Single Judge, vide its order letter 04.03.2025 has directed for
a joint verification regarding the work executed by the Appellants, a report to be
submitted and thereafter, all the pending bills, if not paid in the meantime, shall
be released in favour of the Appellants in terms of the joint verification.
Therefore, the only issue which has been contended by the Appellants is the
issue regarding liquidity damages, compensation and invocation of the Bank
Guarantee. As far as invocation of Bank Guarantee is concerned, though it has
been claimed by the Appellants that the Bank Guarantee was obtained by them
on behalf of the EPC Contractor, namely, M/s Velecha Engineering Ltd. for the
entire work in the Contract, it is seen from the records that the Bank Guarantee
was submitted in the name of M/s Velecha Engineering Ltd. for the entire
contract work and no separate bank guarantees were submitted for their
respective portion of works, i.e., 49% and 51% respectively by the Appellants
and the EPC Contractor. It is also cannot be made out from the record that the
money for the Bank Guarantee was, in fact, paid by the Appellants, as claimed
by them except a covenant in the aforesaid MoU. Therefore, this being a
disputed question of fact, the writ court has rightly did not go into the
adjudication of the aforesaid issue and the same has been kept open for the
Appellants to raise the same before a competent forum, i.e., the Civil Court.
Page No.# 14/15
15.
As far as liquidated damage is concerned, in the facts of the instant case,
in our opinion, the issue cannot be adjudicated before this Court. It is seen that
there is still a dispute about the percentage of completion of the Contract Work
by the Appellants though the Appellants contended that they have completed
49% of the Contract Work. The respondent authorities contended that only
26.21% of the work has been completed by the Appellants. Further, the settled
law regarding claiming of liquidity damages under Sections 73 and 74 of the
Contract Act has been discussed in a catena of cases by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court. The ratio laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of State
of Karnataka v. Sri Rameshwara Rice Mill reported in (1987)2 SCC 160,
which is followed in the case of J. G. Engineers Private Ltd vs. Union of
India and Another reported in (2011)5 SCC 758, provides that the question
of whether the other party committed breach cannot be decided by the party
alleging breach. A contract cannot provide that one party will be the arbiter to
decide whether he committed breach or the other party committed breach. That
question can only be decided only by an adjudicatory forum, i.e., a Court or an
Arbitral Tribunal. The entitlement to claim compensation against a breach of
contract by opposite party is contained in Sections 73 and 74 of the Indian
Contract Act, 1872. Section 73 of the Contract Act contemplates award of
damages for losses suffered by breach of contract by the opposite party and
Section 74 of the Contract Act stipulates that in a case, a contract is broken and
a sum is named in the contract as the amount to be paid in case of such breach,
whether or not actual damage or loss is proved to have been caused thereby,
the aggrieved party is entitled to receive from the opposite party who has
broken the contract, a reasonable compensation not exceeding the amount so
named. Therefore, under Sections 73 and 74 of the Contract Act, before
Page No.# 15/15
imposing any amount of compensation against a contractor, the primary
responsibility of the employer is to fix the liability against the contractor on the
basis of quotient facts that contractor has breached the contract by delaying
performance beyond stipulated time. Unless such breach is established, the
question of imposition of any amount of compensation does not arise at all.
16.
Therefore, in the instant case, if the appellants have any grievances about
the employer, i.e., the respondent authorities, imposing liquidated damages,
which is not agreeable to the Appellants, the same can be properly adjudicated
in the right forum and such right forum is obviously the civil court or an
Arbitration Tribunal, in case the same is there in the contract. In the instant
case, since the Appellants are raising the issue about wrongful deduction of
liquidated damages in the Contract, wherein they are claiming not to be a party,
in our considered opinion, the learned Single Judge has rightly directed the
Appellants to seek redressal of the same in an appropriate civil court.
17.
In view of the aforesaid discussions, we are of the considered view that
there is no infirmity in passing the direction at paragraph 24 (ii) in the impugned
Judgment and Order dated 04.03.2025. Accordingly, the instant appeal being
devoid of any merit, is dismissed.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review