The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
18. In view of the legal position adumbrated herein above, I find merit in the preliminary objection to the maintainability of this application raised by Mr. Mohinder Singh, learned counsel appearing for the respondents. That apart, Mr. Mohinder Singh has also brought to my notice an order dated 02.02.2024 passed by the then Chief Justice of this Court while hearing a similar application. The arbitration Clause
15. 4 of the work order/agreement executed between the parties in the said case also contained a similar arbitration clause fixing the venue of arbitration at Mumbai and restricting jurisdiction of the Mumbai Courts only. The learned Chief Justice did not entertain the application and dismissed the same for want of jurisdiction.
19. In view of the aforesaid discussion, I am convinced that this Court lacks jurisdiction to entertain this application and appoint an arbitrator. This application is, accordingly, dismissed. The petitioner shall, however, be at liberty to approach the Court of competent jurisdiction. Regarding delay, it is appropriate to observe that competent Court shall certainly consider the time taken by the petitioner in pursuing the present case before this Court, if it is so urged before it. (Sanjeev Kumar) Judge
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
Arb P No.21/2021
Reserved on: 06.02.2026
Pronounced on:13.02.2026
Uploaded on: 13.02.2026
M/s S.D.Bhat Through Proprietor
Shamusdin Bhat alias S.d.Bhat, Age 55 years,
S/o Ghulam Mohammad Bhat R/o Basholi, Hut (J&K)
A/p VPO Khairi, The: Dalhouse,
District Chamba, Himachal Pradesh-176325
....Petitioner(s)
Through:- Mr. Pranav Sharma, Advocate
Versus
1.
Hindustan Construction Company Ltd (HCC Ltd)
Through its chairman and Managing Director,
Hincon House, Lal Bhadur Shastri Marg,
Vikhroli West Mumbai-400083, India
2.
Chairman and Managing Director,
Hindustan Construction Company Ltd (HCC Ltd)
Hincon House, Lal Bhadur Shastri Marg,
Vikhroli West Mumbai-400083, India
...Respondent(s)
Through: Mr. Mohinder Singh Advocate with
Mr. Moti Sharma, Advocate
Coram: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV KUMAR, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1.
This is a petition by the petitioner under Section 11 of the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 [“the Act”] for
appointment of an independent arbitrator.
Arb P No.21/2021
2.
The petitioner is a Class-A Govt. Contractor having more than
twenty years‟ experience in the field. He claims to have been
engaged as Sub-contractor by the respondent-corporation for
architectural work of Chutuk Power Station, Kargil (J&K) in the
year 2011. The work was governed by an agreement dated
5.07.2011, executed between the parties. This was in the shape of
a Work Order along with Bill of Quantity and Standard
conditions
of
sub-contract.
Clause
of
the
Work
Order/agreement contained an arbitration clause.
3.
In view of the dispute having arisen between the petitioner and
the respondents, the petitioner claims to have invoked the
arbitration clause and approached the respondents for settlement.
The respondent did not accede to the request of the petitioner,
thereby giving him a cause of action of action to approach this
court for appointment of an arbitrator in terms of Section 11(6) of
the Act.
4.
The petition is opposed by the respondents, who have, in their
objections, raised inter alia the issue of maintainability of this
petition before this Court on the ground of want of jurisdiction. It
is the contention of the respondent that it is clearly provided in
the arbitration clause, the seat of arbitration is at Mumbai and the
Sub-contract is governed as per the laws of India and the
jurisdiction of only Mumbai Courts shall apply. It is, thus, argued
Arb P No.21/2021
that in the face of aforesaid clear stipulation in the arbitration
clause, the Courts in Jammu shall have no jurisdiction to deal
with any matter relating to the arbitration in terms of Arbitration
Clause contained in the Sub-contract entered into between the
parties.
5.
Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner would
argue that the arbitration clause only fixes the venue of
arbitration and not the seat of arbitration and, therefore, the
application under Section 11 of the Act is maintainable before
this Court, for, the work has been executed and the cause of
action has accrued within the territorial jurisdiction of this Court.
6.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
material on record, the only question that begs determination in
this case is, “whether this Court lacks jurisdiction to entertain an
application under Section 11 of the Act and refer the parties to
arbitration by appointment of an independent arbitrator?”
7.
Before proceeding to determine the aforesaid question, it would
be appropriate to set out Clause 32 of the Sub-contract
hereunder:“32. Settlement of Disputes:
If a dispute of any kind whatsoever arises between the contractor
and the subcontractor or the execution of the subcontract works,
whether during the execution of th subcontract works or after their
completion and whether before or after repudiation or other
termination of the subcontract, then the contractor or the
subcontractor may give a notice of such dispute to the other party,
Arb P No.21/2021
in which case the parties shall attempt for the next fifty six days to
settle such dispute amicably through offices of project
manager/project controller/GM-subcontractor of HCC before the
commencement of arbitration. Such notice shall state that it is
made pursuant to this clause. Any dispute which has not been
amicably settles within fifty six days after the day on which such
notice is given shall be finally settled in accordance with the
Arbitration & Conciliation Act 1996 by sole Arbitrator to be
nominated by the Chairman & Managing Director of HCC,
Mumbai. The Arbitration may be commenced prior or after
completion of the subcontractor works, provided that the obligation
of the contractor and the subcontractor has not been altered by
reason of the arbitration being conducted during the progress of the
subcontract works. The venue shall be at Mumbai. This
subcontract is governed as per the Laws of India and the
jurisdiction of only Mumbai court shall apply.”
8.
From a plain reading of the arbitration clause reproduced herein
above, it transpires that the parties have agreed that the venue of
arbitration shall be at Mumbai. They have also agreed that the
subcontract would be governed as per the laws of India and
Mumbai Courts alone shall have the jurisdiction.
9.
Although, the arbitration clause makes mention of ‘venue of
arbitration’ and does not refer to ‘seat of arbitration’, yet when
this clause “venue shall be at Mumbai” is read with the next
clause in the arbitration agreement i.e. “jurisdiction of only
Mumbai Courts shall apply”, the intention of the parties is
clearly manifested that they intended Mumbai to be the „seat of
arbitration’. Had the word “venue” been used distinctively from
the seat of arbitration in the arbitration clause, we could have
given different meaning to the „venue‟ and the „seat of
arbitration‟.
Arb P No.21/2021
10. In these circumstances, the word “venue” used in the arbitration
clause must be read to mean „seat of arbitration‟. Once it is
conceded that the seat of arbitration agreed to by the parties is at
Mumbai and the parties have also agreed to restrict the
jurisdiction for arbitration only to the Courts at Mumbai, this
Court would lack jurisdiction to entertain an application under
Section 11(6) of the Act and appoint an arbitrator to adjudicate
the dispute between the parties.
11. The issue, which is raised before this Court, by the parties is no
longer res integra. Hon‟ble the Supreme Court in paragraph
No.82 of the judgment in BGS SGS SOMA JV v. NHPC Ltd.,
(2020) 4 SCC 234 held thus:“82.On a conspectus of the aforesaid judgments, it
may be concluded that whenever there is the
designation of a place of arbitration in an arbitration
clause as being the “venue” of the arbitration
proceedings, the expression “arbitration proceedings”
would make it clear that the “venue” is really the
“seat” of the arbitral proceedings, as the aforesaid
expression does not include just one or more individual
or particular hearing, but the arbitration proceedings
as a whole, including the making of an award at that
place. This language has to be contrasted with
language such as “tribunals are to meet or have
witnesses, experts or the parties” where only hearings
are to take place in the “venue”, which may lead to the
conclusion, other things being equal, that the venue so
stated is not the “seat” of arbitral proceedings, but only
a convenient place of meeting. Further, the fact that the
arbitral proceedings “shall be held” at a particular
venue would also indicate that the parties intended to
anchor arbitral proceedings to a particular place,
signifying thereby, that that place is the seat of the
arbitral proceedings. This, coupled with there being no
other significant contrary indicia that the stated venue is
merely a “venue” and not the “seat” of the arbitral
proceedings, would then conclusively show that such a
clause designates a “seat” of the arbitral proceedings.
Arb P No.21/2021
In an international context, if a supranational body of
rules is to govern the arbitration, this would further be
an indicia that “the venue”, so stated, would be the seat
of the arbitral proceedings. In a national context, this
would be replaced by the Arbitration Act, 1996 as
applying to the “stated venue”, which then becomes the
“seat” for the purposes of arbitration.”
12. It is, thus settled that whenever there is mention of place of
arbitration in an arbitration clause as being the venue of
arbitration proceedings, it would really mean the seat of arbitral
proceedings. This is so because the expression “arbitration/
arbitral proceedings” does not refer to individual hearing but
conveys that entire arbitration process including making of the
award shall be conducted at the place referred to as „venue‟. It is
also well settled that where the parties have anchored the arbitral
proceedings to one fixed location or places, it would clearly
indicate that the parties have intended such place to be the seat of
arbitration. This is more so when there is no other significant
contrary indicia that such place is merely a „venue‟ and not the
„seat of arbitration‟.
13. In BGS SGS SOMA (supra), the Supreme Court laid down a
three condition test to determine as to whether the term “venue”
used in arbitration clause can be construed as
„seat‟ of
arbitration. These three conditions read as under:
“i)
The arbitration agreement or clause in question should
designate or mention only one place;
Arb P No.21/2021
ii)
Such place must have anchored the arbitral proceedings i.e.,
the arbitral proceedings must have been fixed to that place
alone without any scope of change;
iii)
There must be no other significant contrary indicia to show
that the place designated is merely the venue and not the
seat.”
14. If these three conditions are fulfilled then the place that has been
designated in the arbitration clause as „venue‟ would be
considered the „seat‟ of arbitration. When we apply these three
conditions test to the arbitration clause in question, we find that it
fulfills all the three conditions.
15. The arbitration clause designates only Mumbai as the venue of
arbitration and no other place and, therefore, condition No.(i) is
fully met.
16. The arbitration clause fixes Mumbai as the only venue for
arbitration proceedings without making any scope for change. In
short, the venue of arbitration proceedings at Mumbai is fixed
one and all arbitration proceedings culminating into passing of
the arbitral award are agreed to be held at Mumbai. The
expression “venue shall be at Mumbai” has been used in the
context of arbitration proceedings only and, therefore, leaves no
manner of doubt that as per the arbitration clause in question, the
venue for conducting the arbitration proceedings is at Mumbai
Arb P No.21/2021
and at no other place. Condition No.(ii) is also fully met in the
instant case.
17. From a reading of the arbitration clause and the other clauses of
the subcontract in question, this Court could not find any
significant contrary indicia which would indicate that the place
designated i.e. Mumbai is merely a venue and not the seat.
Rather, the last lines of the arbitration clause make the things
abundantly clear when these lines unequivocally provide that the
arbitration would be governed by the laws of India and the
jurisdiction shall be restricted to the Mumbai Courts only. This
way condition No.(iii) of the test laid down in BGS SGS SOMA
(supra), too, is fulfilled.
18. In view of the legal position adumbrated herein above, I find
merit in the preliminary objection to the maintainability of this
application raised by Mr. Mohinder Singh, learned counsel
appearing for the respondents. That apart, Mr. Mohinder Singh
has also brought to my notice an order dated 02.02.2024 passed
by the then Chief Justice of this Court while hearing a similar
application.
The
arbitration
Clause
15.4
of
the
work
order/agreement executed between the parties in the said case
also contained a similar arbitration clause fixing the venue of
arbitration at Mumbai and restricting jurisdiction of the Mumbai
Arb P No.21/2021
Courts only. The learned Chief Justice did not entertain the
application and dismissed the same for want of jurisdiction.
19. In view of the aforesaid discussion, I am convinced that this
Court lacks jurisdiction to entertain this application and appoint
an arbitrator. This application is, accordingly, dismissed. The
petitioner shall, however, be at liberty to approach the Court of
competent jurisdiction. Regarding delay, it is appropriate to
observe that competent Court shall certainly consider the time
taken by the petitioner in pursuing the present case before this
Court, if it is so urged before it.
(Sanjeev Kumar)
Judge
JAMMU
13.02.2026
Vinod, Secy
Vinod Kumar
2026.02.13 12:01
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Whether the order is speaking : Yes
Whether the order is reportable: Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review