Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE M.A.ABDUL HAKHIM
FRIDAY, THE 26TH DAY OF JULY 2024 / 4TH SRAVANA, 1946
MSA NO. 17 OF 2024
AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 24.05.2024 IN REFA NO.36 OF 2023 OF
KERALA REAL ESTATE APPELLATE TRIBUNAL, ERNAKULAM ARISING OUT
OF THE ORDER DATED 20.02.2023 IN COMPLAINT NO.98 OF 2022 OF
KERALA REAL ESTATE REGULATORY AUTHORITY, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM
APPELLANT(S)/APPELLANTS/RESPONDENTS:
M/S. PTC BUILDERS,
REPRESENTED BY MANAGING PARTNER
BIJU JACOB
AGED 48 YEARS
M/S. PTC BUILDERS,
REGISTERED FIRM,
OFFICE AT PTC TOWERS,
S.S KOVIL ROAD,
THAMPANOOR,
THIRUVANTHAPURAM,
PIN - 695001
MR. BIJU JACOB
AGED 48 YEARS
S/O LATE P.T CHACKO,
MANAGING PARTNER,
M/S P.T.C BUILDERS,
A REGISTERED PARTNERSHIP FIRM,
HAVING ITS OFFICE AT PTC TOWERS,
S.S KOVIL ROAD,
THAMPANOOR,
THIRUVANATHAPURAM,
PIN - 695001
BY ADVS.
SIDHARTH A.MENON
V.AJAKUMAR
SANDRA MARIYA
VINITHA S.T.
MSA NO. 17 OF 2024
RESPONDENT/RESPONDENT/COMPLAINANT:
MARIAMMA STEPHAN
AGED 50 YEARS
MARIAMMA STEPHAN,
P.O BOX NO. 2424,
DUBAI, UAE
AND NOW RESIDING AT HOUSE NO.481 D,
ATTUPURATHU,
PUTHAVILAYIL,
RAINBOW GARDEN,
UNICHIRA,
THRIKKAKARA NORTH,
CHENGAMPUZHA,
ERNAKULAM,
PIN - 682033
BY ADV ARUN CHANDY
THIS MISC. SECOND APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION
ON
26.07.2024,
FOLLOWING:
THE
COURT
ON
THE
SAME
DAY
DELIVERED
THE
MSA NO. 17 OF 2024
JUDGMENT
1. The appellant is the respondent in complaint No.98/2022
before the Real Estate Regulatory Authority (RERA) filed
by the respondent. The parties are referred according to
their status before the Authority.
2. The complainant filed the complaint claiming refund of an
amount of Rs.27,44,000/- with interest which was paid by
him on the basis of Ext.A1 agreement dated 23/11/2013 by
which the complainant agreed to purchase and the
respondents agreed to sell a residential Apartment No.4F
including car park on the basement/ground and 1.48
percent of undivided interest in the multi storied residential
complex
named
“PTC
WESTERN
GHATS”
to
be
constructed by the respondents for a consideration of
Rs.49,00,000/-. As per the terms of Ext.A1 agreement, the
apartment had to be completed before July 2015. A grace
MSA NO. 17 OF 2024
period of six months is also provided in Ext.A1 Agreement,
which expired in January 2016.
3. According to the complainant, she had been making
payments as per the payment schedule to the respondents
till 12/08/2015. There after the installment amounts were
not paid since she came to know that the respondents are
not proceeding with the construction as per the time
schedule provided in Ext.A1 agreement.
4. According to the complainant, the 1 st respondent issued a
Ext.A5 Legal Notice dated 04/05/2018 to the complainant
demanding to pay the balance amount threatening to
cancel the allotment. The said legal notice was followed by
Ext.A6 letter dated 04/06/2018 by which the respondent
intimated the complainant that her allotment is cancelled
and that refund of the amount paid by the complainant
after deducting the damages and cost incurred to the
MSA NO. 17 OF 2024
respondent owing to the willful latches and defaults on the
part of the complainant and that the balance amount due
after the said deductions without any interest will be paid
after the resale of the Apartment No.4F in favour of new
purchaser.
5. According to the complainant, she was fully justified in
withholding the payments since the respondent had been
delaying the construction of the building and the
respondents did not even replied to Ext.A3 Emails sent by
her requesting to inform the status of the construction to
enable her to make the payments.
6. The respondent 1 and 2 opposed the prayers in the
complaint on the ground that it is the complainant who has
violated the obligations under Ext.A1 Agreement and as
also provided under Section 9 of the Kerala Real Estate
(Regulation and Development) Act. She did not make the
MSA NO. 17 OF 2024
payment in accordance with the Payment Schedule. They
also contended that they are only builders of the apartment
and it is for land owner to answer the claims of the
allottees. According to them, there is no obligation on their
part to complete the construction before July 2015 with a
grace period of six months as claimed by the complainant.
The time limit provided in the agreement is subject to
payment
by the allottee and it is also subject to the
unforeseen circumstances such as natural calamities,
court orders, prohibitory orders of the Government and
other Authorities and under all circumstances where the
builder is prevented from completing the project. It is
stated in the written statement that the construction could
not be progressed as expected as the soil of the land on
excavation for construction of foundation was found to be
rocky and about 19 months were taken to remove the
MSA NO. 17 OF 2024
same for construction of foundation. It is also stated that as
there is a school nearby, only controlled blasting after
school hours is permitted and there was substantial delay
on the part of the Authorities to issue permits for blasting
removal of the rocks. They also contented that they
completed the construction in 27/07/2017 leaving only
minor finishing works and the Pathanamthitta Municipality
issued Occupancy Certificate on 30/07/2020. According to
them though an option was given to the complainant to
cancel the agreement as per Legal Notice dated
04/06/2018, the same was not availed by the complainant
and hence without cancellation of the agreement, the
complainant cannot claim refund of the amount paid by
her.
7. The
Authority
ordered
refund
of
the
amount
of
Rs.27,44,000/- with simple interest at the rate of 16.15 %
MSA NO. 17 OF 2024
per annum on the payments made as the Payment
Schedule from the date of each payment till the date of
realization.
8. Though the respondents filed appeal before the Real
Estate Appellate Tribunal, the same was dismissed
confirming the order passed by the Authority. The
Miscellaneous Second Appeal is filed against the order of
the Tribunal.
9. I heard the learned counsel for the appellants and also the
learned counsel for the respondent.
10.
The learned counsel for the appellant argued that there
was clear default on the part of the complainant who was
the allottee of the project in making payment of the amount
as per the payment schedule. The Agreement terms and
S. 19 (6) of the RERA Act mandates timely payment by the
allottee to the builder. Here admittedly the payments were
MSA NO. 17 OF 2024
not made in accordance with the Payment schedule. There
was no cancellation from the side of the complainant to
claim refund of the amount as required under Section 18 of
the Act. He also pointed out that in one of the emails in
Ext.A3, the complainant has expressed her inability to pay
the balance amount.
11.
On the other hand the learned counsel for the
respondent submitted that admittedly the respondent did
not complete the project within the time stipulated in Ext.
A1 agreement. Ext.A5 would show that they have
cancelled the allotment and they do not intend to give the
apartment to the complainant. In such case, the only
remedy of the complainant is to seek refund of the amount.
Since the complainant is not in anyway responsible for the
delay in completing the construction, the complainant is
entitled to get full refund of the amount with interest
MSA NO. 17 OF 2024
thereon.
12.
Admittedly, going by the pleadings from the part of the
respondents, they could not complete the construction
within the time stipulated in Ext.A1 agreement. It is
admitted that the stipulated period for construction is July,
2015 with a grace period of six months which expired in
January 2016. Of course it is stated in the agreement that
it is subject to several unforeseen circumstances. The
respondent
have
pleaded
several
unforeseen
circumstances as the causes for the delay in completing
the construction. But no material was produced before the
authority
justifying
the
delay
for
completing
the
construction. Even according to the version of the
respondents, the 1st respondent could complete the
construction only on 27/07/2017 that also leaving minor
finishing works.
MSA NO. 17 OF 2024
13.
The Ext. B5 Occupancy Certificate would show that the
construction was completed only on 30/07/2020. Since
there was no material produced before the Authority for
justifying the delay on the part of the respondent, I find that
the respondents alone are responsible for the delay in
completing the construction.
14.
The contention of the learned counsel for the appellant
that the complainant could not maintain the complaint
without making the full payment of the amount as per the
schedule. It is seen that the complainant has made
payments upto 12/08/2015. Thereafter, she did not make
further payments since she understood that there is delay
in proceeding with the construction as per the time
schedule. Though she sent Ext.A3 emails, none of them
were replied by the respondents. So in those emails the
complainant has specifically sought for the status of the
MSA NO. 17 OF 2024
project, but the respondents did not send any reply. Even
in Ext.A5 Legal Notice dated 04/05/2018, the statement of
the respondent is that the project is nearing completion,
without reference to the actual status of the completion. In
such circumstances a complainant is fully justified for
holding further payments as per the payment schedule.
This is not a case where the builder had been proceeding
with the construction in accordance with the time schedule
in Ext.A1 agreement and the complainant withheld the
payments as per the payment schedule. This is not a case
where the builder cancelled the allotment before the
agreed date of completion on the ground of delay in
making payments by the allottee.
15.
With respect to the cancellation of allotment it is seen
from Ext.A5 that the allotment is cancelled at the instance
of the respondent and they do not intent to give
MSA NO. 17 OF 2024
possession of the apartment to the complainant. In such
case, going by Section 18 of the RERA Act, the
complainant is fully justified to claim the refund of the
amount. There is no need for any further cancellation from
the part of the complainant.
16.
The learned counsel for the appellant relied on
Paragraph 80 of the decision in New tech promoters and
Developers Pvt. Ltd. v. State U.P. & Others [2021 SCC
ONLINE SC 1044] and contented that if the allottee has
defaulted payment of the amount as per the terms of the
agreement, the allottee cannot claim refund of the amount
paid by him. The said decision is clearly distinguishable on
facts of the present case as the complainant herein had
justification for withholding the payment on account of the
delay on the part of the builder to complete the project.
17.
In the very same decision in Paragraph No.25, the
MSA NO. 17 OF 2024
Hon'ble Supreme Court stated about the unqualified right
of the allottee to seek for refund in the following words.
The unqualified right of the allottee to seek refund
referred under S.18(1)(a) and S.19(4) of the Act is not
dependent on any contingencies or stipulations thereof.
It appears that the legislature has consciously provided
this right of refund on demand as an unconditional
absolute right to the allottee, if the promoter fails to
give possession of the apartment, plot or building
within the time stipulated under the terms of the
agreement regardless of unforeseen events or stay
orders of the Court/Tribunal, which is in either way not
attributable to the allottee/home buyer, the promoter is
under an obligation to refund the amount on demand
with interest at the rate prescribed by the State
Government including compensation in the manner
provided under the Act with the proviso that if the
allottee does not wish to withdraw from the project, he
shall be entitled for interest for the period of delay till
MSA NO. 17 OF 2024
handing over possession at the rate prescribed.
18.
Here also, whatever be the reasons for delay, the
complainant is not in anyway responsible for the same.
Since the allotment is already cancelled by Annexure A6,
the complainant is fully justified to claim refund of the
amount paid by her.
19.
Under the circumstances, I do not find any illegality in
the order passed by the Authority which is confirmed by
the Tribunal and the Regular Second Appeal fails and the
same is dismissed accordingly.
Sd/-
sms
M.A.ABDUL HAKHIM
JUDGE
MSA NO. 17 OF 2024
APPENDIX OF MSA 17/2024
PETITIONER ANNEXURES
Annexure 1
TRUE COPY OF ORDER DATED 20/02/2023 IN
COMPLAINT NO. 98/2022 OF THE KERALA REAL
ESTATE
REGULATORY
AUTHORITY,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM
Annexure 2
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED 24/05/2024
IN REFA 36 OPF 2023 OF THE KERALA REAL
ESTATE APPELLATE TRIBUNAL, ERNAKULAM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review