Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Shampa Dutt (Paul)
WPA 28511 of 2023
M/s. A.R. Engineers
Vs
Deputy Chief Labour Commissioner (Central) & Ors.
with
WPA 28513 of 2023
M/s. Pearson Drums & Barrels Pvt. Ltd.
Vs
Deputy Chief Labour Commissioner (Central) & Ors.
For the Petitioners
: Mr. Ranjay De, ld. Sr. Adv.
Mr. Jaydeb Ghorai,
Mr. Diptesh Ghorai.
For the Respondent/UOI
In WPA 28513 of 2023
: Mr. Souvik Nandy, ld. Sr. Adv.
Mr. Debapriya Samanta.
For the Respondent No. 4
: Mr. Anjan Bhaduri.
Judgment reserved on
: 20.04.2026
Judgment delivered on
: 18.05.2026
Shampa Dutt (Paul), J.:
1. The writ applications have been preferred challenging the
impugned order of reference dated 29.11.2023. The appropriate
authority herein being the Deputy Chief Labour Commissioner
(Central), issued the said order of reference on being satisfied as
follows:“NO. Kol-700020/17/2023-Dy.CLC(C): WHEREAS,
the
undersigned
industrial
is
dispute
of
the
opinion
exists
that
between
an
the
employer in relation to the management of
M/s
Pearson Drums & Barrels Pvt. Ltd. and
M/s. A.R.Engineers, service providers of IOCL,
Haldia Refinery versus their workmen represented
by Bharat Barrel and Drum Mfg. Co. Pvt. Ltd.
Worker's Association (INTTUC) and its workman
in respect of the matter specified in the Schedule
below;
2. The order of reference has been made with the following
schedule/issues:The Schedule
1. “Whether
the
Appropriate
Government
for
the
Management of M/s. Pearson Drums and Barrels Pvt.
Ltd. and M/s. Engineers, service providers of IOCL,
Haldia Refinery is Central Government or State
Government?
2. The action of the managements in denying the reemployment of 90 retrenched workmen are justified?
If not, what relief the concerned workmen are
entitled to?”
3. The principal contention of the petitioner herein which was
recorded by this Court at the interim stage is as follows :
“8. The first question referred for adjudication is
as to whether the appropriate Government for
M/s. Pearson Drums & Barrels Pvt. Ltd. and
A.R. Engineers the service provider to
IOCL, is the Central Government or the State
Government.
9. This appears to be ex facie illegal. If the
Deputy Chief Labour Commissioner (Central)
had any doubt in that regard, he could not have
made any reference to the CGIT.
10. The second limb of the reference is equally
surprising. The second limb is "whether the
actions of the management are justified? and if
not what relief, the concerned workmen are
entitled to?". Neither the ALC nor the workmen
or the Trade Union have even whispered of any
relationship between the employees of M/s.
Bharat Barrel and Drum Mfg. Co. Pvt. Ltd.
Worker's Association and M/s. Pearson Drums
& Barrels Pvt. Ltd. or M/s. A.R. Engineers.
11. In those circumstances, this Court is not able
to appreciate as to what material was available
before the Deputy Chief Labour Commissioner
(Central) to make any reference as contained in
the order dated November 29, 2023.”
4. The facts of the case in short is that the petitioner is a sole
proprietorship concern.
5. The petitioner participated in the tender floated by Indian Oil
Corporation Limited for "fabrication, manufacturing and supply of
empty bitumen drums with BD Lid as per IS: 3575 of 1993 or its
latest
revision"
and
became
successful
as
L-2
bidder.
In
consequence thereof, the petitioner has been awarded with the
contract
by
Indian
Oil
Corporation
vide
"LETTER
OF
ACCEPTANCE" indicating the Tender No. HGNKK22015 and the
Work Order No. 27849589 Dated 24.05.2022.
6. In terms of the said work order, the petitioner has already started
the manufacturing process with its own employees as aforesaid.
It is further stated that the relationship between Indian Oil
Corporation (in short IOC) and the petitioner herein is not that of
principal employer and contractor. Rather the management of IOC
in connection with compliance of the provisions of Contract Labour
(Regulation & Abolition) Act, 1970 and the Rules framed there
under has confirmed that the petitioner is principal employer.
Therefore, the requirement of issuance of FORM-III under Section 7
of the said Act of 1970 read with Rule 18(3) of Contract Labour
(Regulation & Abolition) Central Rules, 1971 was never required.
7. It is the further contention of the petitioner that although there is
no union in the name and style as "Bharat Barrel and Drum Mfg.
Co. Pvt. Ltd. Worker's Association (INTTUC)" (in short the said
union), being respondent No. 4 herein but it has received a
conciliation memo dated 21.12.2022 issued by the respondent No.
2 enclosing therewith a letter dated 15.12.2022 of the respondent
Union.
8. It is further stated that the said conciliation memo dated
21.12.2022 enclosing therewith the letter dated 15.12.2022 of the
respondent No. 4 stating that the said union has made a so called
demand of reinstatement of 90 permanent workers in the
manufacturing unit of the petitioner contending the same to be
IOCL Haldia Refinery Controlled Drum Production Unit.
9. The petitioner further states that a written representation was
placed before the respondent no. 2 being the Assistant Labour
Commissioner (Central), Kolkata-II, on 07.02.2023 stating as
follows :
“In this connection please note that we are no way
connected or associated with the retrenchment of 90workmen of Bharat Barrel and Drum Mfg. Co. Pvt. Ltd.
nor are we working on behalf of the said company at
their place. We are no way connected with the dispute as
termed therein in the letter addressed to us. Ours is
small MSME certified unit and working at Vill-Kastokhali,
Haldia, with the short order received from Indian Oil
Corporation Ltd., Haldia….”
10. The said conciliation ended in a failure report and a reference was
made by the Chief Labour Commissioner (Central). The order of
reference has been challenged by the petitioner on the ground that
the Deputy Chief Labour Commissioner, being the respondent
no.1, in respect of the issue no. 1 as specified in the impugned order
of reference is concerned, the same does not find place in the Second
or Third schedule of the relevant statutory provision. Secondly, in
respect of the petitioner herein the Central Government cannot be an
appropriate government as per the proviso to Section 2(a) of the said
Act of 1947. So far as the petitioner is concerned, State Government
is the appropriate Government in terms of the relevant statutory
provision.
11. It is further submitted that respondent No. 1 and respondent No. 2
have acted, contrary to the provisions of the said Act of 1947 by
illegally assuming jurisdiction being an appropriate Government
when the petitioner is neither a contractor of IOC nor it has got any
employer-employee relationship with the so called 90 workmen for
whom the respondent union sought to espouse the cause.
12. Admittedly, the petitioners in the writ applications are service
providers of IOCL and the issue as to who is the appropriate
Government in respect of the said writ petitioners has been made
part of the reference, without coming to a prima facie finding as to
whether such a reference can at all be made and without being
prima facie satisfied on the basic requirement to make a reference,
that is whether the authority herein at all has the authority to
make such a reference when the authority herein is not certain
who the “appropriate authority is”.
13. It further appears that the authority being the respondent no. 1
herein being prima facie of the opinion that there exists an
employee and employer relationship between the writ petitioners
and the workmen represented by the workers association and on
the said presumption has proceeded to frame the second issue as
to whether the action of the said management in denying the
employment of 90 retrenched workmen was justified or not and as
to what relief the workmen are entitled, even though the
employer employee relationship is denied.
14. In Workmen Employed by Hindustan Lever Ltd. vs Hindustan
Lever Limited (1984) 4 SCC 392, the Supreme Court held:“Only a reference which is legally made by the
appropriate Government can be adjudicated by the
Tribunal on merits.”
15. In Para 4 of Workmen Employed (Supra), the Supreme Court
held as follows:“4. Section 10(1) confers power on the appropriate
Government to refer an existing or apprehended
industrial dispute, amongst others, to the Industrial
Tribunal for adjudication. The dispute therefore, which
can be referred for adjudication of necessity, has to be
an industrial dispute which would clothe the
appropriate Government with power to make the
reference, and the Industrial Tribunal to adjudicate it."
16. In
Mecon
Ltd.
vs
State
of
West
Bengal
and
others
2001(2)L.L.N. 304, the Calcutta High Court in Para 4 and 6 held:“4. First, Mr. Sengupta has contended that there
was no sufficient material before the appropriate
Government to refer the dispute to the Tribunal
under Section 10 of the Act.
6. It is now settled position of law that in
making a reference under Section 10 of the
Act, the appropriate Government does an
administrative act and the fact that it has to
form an opinion as to the factual existence of
an industrial dispute as a preliminary step to
the discharge of its function does not make it
any the less administrative act. The Court
cannot therefore canvass the order of
reference closely to see if there was any
material before the Government to support its
conclusion as if it was a judicial or quasi
judicial determination. See The State of
Madras v. C.P. Sarathy, [A.I.R. 1953 S.C. 53].”
17. Now regarding the 1st issue which is as follows:“Whether the Appropriate Government for the
Management of M/s. Pearson Drums and Barrels
Pvt. Ltd. and M/s. Engineers, service providers of
IOCL, Haldia Refinery is Central Government or
State Government?
18. Section 10(1-A) of the industrial dispute act lays down:“Section 10 (1-A) Where the Central Government is of
opinion that any industrial dispute exists or is
apprehended and the dispute involves any question of
national importance or is of such a nature that
industrial establishments situated in more than one
State are likely to be interested in, or affected by, such
dispute and that the dispute should be adjudicated by
a National Tribunal, then, the Central Government may,
whether or not it is the appropriate Government in
relation to that dispute, at any time, by order in writing,
refer the dispute or any matter appearing to be
connected with, or relevant to, the dispute, whether it
relates to any matter specified in the Second Schedule
or the Third Schedule, to a National Tribunal for
adjudication.”
19. The said provision clearly provides that the central government
may, whether or not it is the appropriate government, may
refer disputes of the nature mentioned in the said section.
20. The power herein is vested only in the central government and in
the present case, the central government has made the reference
and the dispute (issue no. 1) in the present case is also covered
therein. Thus issue no. 1 is a valid reference.
21. Regarding the second issue, Section 10(5) comes into picture
herein.
22. Section 10(5) Industrial Disputes Act, lays down:“Section 10(5) Where a dispute concerning any
establishment or establishments has been, or is to be,
referred to a [Labour Court, Tribunal or National
Tribunal] [under this section and the appropriate
Government is of opinion, whether on an application
made to it in this behalf or otherwise, that the dispute
is of such a nature that any other establishment,
group or class of establishments of a similar nature is
likely to be interested in, or affected by, such dispute,
the appropriate Government may, at the time of
making the reference or at any time thereafter but
before the submission of the award, include in that
reference such establishment, group or class of
establishments, whether or not at the time of such
inclusion any dispute exists or is apprehended in
that
establishment,
group
or
class
of
establishments.]”
23. Thus here again the power has been given to the appropriate
government to make a reference and include establishments
groups etc., whether or not at the time of inclusion any dispute
exists between them or not.
24. But this is after the initial valid reference is made.
25. In the present case, the relationship of employer-employee it self
has been denied and this issue itself should have been framed as
an additional issue, that is “whether there exists an employeremployee relationship between the parties”.
26. So in this case, the government could not have held (presumed)
that there existed an industrial dispute between the parties
without framing another issue, when the petitioner claims
that there is no employer employee relationship between the
parties (Steel Authority of India Ltd. IISCO steel plant vs The
State of West Bengal & Ors., in WPA 20373 of 2008,
24.11.2025).
27. The second issue thus being not in accordance with law is hereby
quashed.
28. But as issue no. 1 is independent of the recital and also the
2nd issue in the reference, the same being valid under Section
10(1A) of Act is to be answered by the tribunal.
29. WPA 28511 of 2023 with WPA 28513 of 2023 are thus
disposed of.
30. Connected application, if any, stands disposed of.
31. Interim order, if any, stands vacated.
32. Urgent Photostat certified copy of this judgment, if applied for, be
supplied to the parties expeditiously after due compliance.
(Shampa Dutt (Paul), J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review