Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:27807-DB
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
W.P.(C) No. 7558 of 2025
M/s Narayan Horticultural Nursery, Dahutoli, Kanke Road, Hatma,
Ranchi through its Proprietor Pradip Maity, aged about 58 years, son
of late Naren Maity, resident of Dahu Toil, Hatma, Kanke Road, P.O.
Ranchi University, P.S. Gonda, District Ranchi.
...
Petitioner
Versus
1. The State of Jharkhand.
2. Director, Directorate of Horticulture, Govt. of Jharkhand,
Department of Agriculture, Animal Husbandry & Cooperative,
Jharkhand having its office at Krishi Bhawan, Kanke Road, P.O.
Ranchi University, P.S. Gonda, District Ranchi.
3. Joint Director, Directorate of Horticulture, Govt. of Jharkhand,
Department of Agriculture, Animal Husbandry & Cooperative,
Jharkhand having its office at Krishi Bhawan, Kanke Road, Ρ.Ο.
Ranchi University, P.S. Gonda, District Ranchi.
4. Deputy Director, Directorate Horticulture, Govt. of Jharkhand,
Department of Agriculture, Animal Husbandry & Cooperative,
Jharkhand having its office at Krishi Bhawan, Kanke Road, P.O.
Ranchi University, P.S. Gonda, District Ranchi.
...
Respondents
--------CORAM:
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH SHANKAR
--------For the Petitioner:
Mr Dilip Kumar Chakravarty, Advocate
For the Respondents: Ms Neeharika Mazumdar, A.C. to A.G.
--------07/Dated: 15.09.2026
1.
Heard Mr Dilip Kumar Chakravarty, learned counsel for the
petitioner, and Ms Neeharika Mazumdar, learned A.C. to A.G.,
for the respondents.
2.
Rule. The Rule is made returnable immediately, at the request
of and with the consent of the learned counsel for the parties.
3.
The petitioner challenges the rejection of his tender application
in pursuance of notice inviting tender bearing No. Horti03/2025-26 dated 03.12.2025, inter alia on the ground that the
2026:JHHC:27807-DB
petitioner had not fulfilled clause 3.0 of the Jharkhand
Procurement Policy, 2014 (as amended vide memo No. 1342
dated 16.07.2019) [in short “said Policy”].
4.
Mr Chakravarty, the learned counsel for the petitioner, by
relying upon the UDYAM Registration Certificate bearing
No. UDYAM-WB-18-0055699, submitted that the petitioner
fulfilled the applicability criteria prescribed in clause 3.0 of the
said Policy and therefore, the Bid Evaluation Committee was
not justified in rejecting the petitioner’s bid. He also referred to
the DIC certificate dated 01.11.2025 and the Under Secretary’s
letter dated 12.12.2025, submitting that the rejection of the
petitioner’s bid on the ground of non-fulfilment of the
requirements under clause 3.0 of the said Policy was patently
erroneous. Accordingly, he submitted that the Court should
interfere with the rejection of the petitioner’s bid and direct the
respondents to consider the petitioner’s bid and proceed in
accordance with law.
5.
Ms Neeharika Mazumdar, learned A.C. to A.G., submitted that
the petitioner did not fulfil the eligibility criteria prescribed under
clause 3.0 of the said Policy, which was admittedly binding
upon all the bidders. She submitted that the Bid Evaluation
Committee, comprising almost 10 technical experts, after
examining the documents submitted by the petitioner, including
the UDYAM certificate and the DIC certificate, held that the
petitioner did not fulfil the criteria under clause 3.0 of the said
Policy.
2026:JHHC:27807-DB
6.
Ms Mazumdar submitted that the Under Secretary’s letter, apart
from being without jurisdiction, at best represented the Under
Secretary’s ex post facto opinion. She pointed out that the Bid
Evaluation Committee met and rejected the petitioner’s bid on
03.12.2025, and the Under Secretary’s letter was issued on
12.12.2025. Accordingly, she submitted that there was no error
in rejecting the petitioner’s technical bid.
7.
Ms Mazumdar submitted that, in such matters, the Courts'
interference should be minimal. She submitted that the Bid
Evaluation Committee, comprising experts, examined the
matter in substantial detail, and that its interpretation of the
tender terms and the documents submitted by the parties was
correct. In any event, she submitted that their interpretation was
reasonable and, in terms of the decisions of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court, this Court should defer to it.
8.
For the above reasons, Ms Mazumdar submitted that this
petition may be dismissed.
9.
The rival contentions now fall for our determination.
10.
In this case, the petitioner has not disputed the applicability of
clause 3.0 of the Policy which specifies the eligibility criteria for
consideration of bids. Though the applicability is not disputed,
its interpretation is.
11.
Accordingly, we transcribe clause 3.0 of the said Policy below
for the convenience of reference: “3.0 Applicability
Jharkhand Procurement Policy 2014 shall be applicable to
such Micro and Small Units (MSEs-as defined under
MSME Act 2006 of Govt of India and JIP-2012) of the
2026:JHHC:27807-DB
State and other units/enterprises of the state which fulfill
all the following criteria:
(i)
The manufacturing or Service unit is located within
the State of Jharkhand.
(ii)
The Head Office or Corporate Office of such
registered unit/company/enterprise is within the
territorial jurisdiction of Jharkhand.
(iii)
"MSE
is
registered
with
the
Directorate
of
Industries/District Industries Centre, Khadi and
Village Industries Board, Directorate of Handloom,
Sericulture and Handicraft of Jharkhand Govt,
Industrial
Area
Development
Authorities
and
National Small Industries Corporation Ltd or any
other body specified by Directorate of Industries,
Jharkhand Govt from time to time and other
industrial units/enterprises which have submitted
IBM and been issued Date of Production (DOP)
certificate
by
GM,
DIC/MD,
Industrial
Area
Development Authorities/Director, Industries, GoJ
or MSEs having Udyog Aadhar Number issued by
Ministry of Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises,
GoJ
to
be
duly
verified,
whether
unit
is
existing/functional and doing regular production at
what capacity by GM, DIC/MD, Industrial Area
Development Authorities/Director, Industries, GoJ".
(iv)
The MSEs/other Enterprises and units must be
registered under Jharkhand Goods and Services
Tax (JGST) Act-2017 or The Central Goods &
Services Tax (CGST) Act 2017.
(v)
The MSE/other enterprise and unit must have
encouraged local people in employment.
(vi)
The MSE/other enterprise and unit must have
complied with all statutory and legal formalities of
concerned regulators/Act.
(vii)
The MSE Unit availing preferential treatment will
give an undertaking with respect to (i) to (vi) above
including
a
categorical
statement
that
the
product/services being supplied to Govt. Deptt. or
2026:JHHC:27807-DB
its agencies has been manufactured/created by the
unit located in Jharkhand only, giving details of
batch no./date or any other identifiable tag (GSI
etc) as per prevalent established practice and will
have to submit compulsorily duly signed copy of
Form GSTR-9C (For units having aggregate yearly
turnover of more than 2 crores) as prescribed
under JGST Act-2017". However, in case of VAT
products/services,
Form
JVAT-409
(For
units
having of gross yearly turnover more than 60 lacs)
issued by deptt. of Commercial taxes, Govt. of
Jharkhand.”
12.
From the perusal of the aforesaid, it is quite clear, and it was
not even seriously disputed, that a bidder, in order to be
adjudged eligible, must fulfil all the conditions/criteria set out in
sub-clauses (i) to (vii) of clause 3.0 of the said Policy.
13.
The petitioner submitted, along with his bid, two documents to
support
his
case
that
he
fulfilled
the
above-referred
conditions/criteria. They are as follows: (i)
UDYAM Registration Certificate (Annexure B to the
supplementary affidavit filed by the petitioner on
20.08.2026)
(ii)
Certificate dated 01.11.2025 issued by the District
Industry Centre (DIC), Ranchi (Annexure-C at page
16 to the supplementary affidavit filed by the
petitioner on 20.08.2026).
14.
Upon analysis of the UDYAM Certificate, we find nothing to
indicate that the head office or corporate office of the petitioner
is situated within the territorial jurisdiction of Jharkhand. On the
contrary, the certificate shows that the head office or corporate
2026:JHHC:27807-DB
office of the petitioner is situated at Sukdebpur, P.S. Bishnupur,
District South 24 Parganas, State of West Bengal, PIN 743503, which is admittedly not within the territorial jurisdiction
of Jharkhand.
15.
The UDYAM certificate no doubt indicates that the petitioner
has two units. The first such unit is situated in the State of West
Bengal, and the second at Dahutoli, Hatma, Kanke, Ranchi.
Thus, even on a very liberal construction of the UDYAM
certificate, it could be said that one of the manufacturing or
service units of the petitioner is located within the State of
Jharkhand and the petitioner fulfils the condition prescribed in
clause 3(i). However, based on the UDYAM certificate, there is
no scope to hold that the petitioner's head office or corporate
office is within the territorial jurisdiction of Jharkhand as
required by Clause 3(ii).
16.
By filing counter affidavits and supplementary affidavits, the
respondents have disputed that the petitioner’s unit situated at
Ranchi is a manufacturing unit or a service unit. The
respondents have also contended that the petitioner’s bid was
rejected for several other non-compliances as well. However,
we do not propose to enter into those controversies because we
are satisfied that the petitioner did not fulfil the condition under
clause 3(ii).
17.
Now coming to the certificate issued by the District Industry
Centre, Ranchi, we note that it only states that the petitioner’s
unit office and nursery were at Kanke, Ranchi. This certificate
2026:JHHC:27807-DB
does not state that the head office or the corporate office of the
petitioner was within the territorial jurisdiction of Jharkhand.
18.
The Bid Evaluation Committee has correctly interpreted clause
3.0 of the Policy by holding that all the conditions/criteria
prescribed under sub-clauses (i) to (vii) had to be fulfilled by the
bidder and further, based upon the documents produced by the
petitioner, the petitioner did not fulfil the conditions/criterial
prescribed under clause 3(ii) of the said Policy.
19.
Neither the UDYAM certificate relied upon by the petitioner and
considered by the Bid Evaluation Committee nor the certificate
issued by the District Industry Centre, Ranchi, shows that the
petitioner’s head office or corporate office was situated within
the territorial limits of Jharkhand. Accordingly, we are satisfied
that the petitioner did not fulfil the criteria prescribed under
clause 3(ii) of the said Policy, and that the Bid Evaluation
Committee’s view on this issue was correct and, in any event,
neither unreasonable nor patently illegal.
20.
In the case of Afcons Infrastructure Ltd. v. Nagpur Metro
Rail Corpn. Ltd., (2016) 16 SCC 818, the Hon’ble Supreme
Court held that even when interpreting tender conditions,
interference is permissible if the decision is arbitrary or
irrational, or if no responsible authority acting reasonably and in
accordance with law could have reached it. Further, perversity
of the decision-making process or the decision, not merely a
faulty or erroneous decision, is a ground for interference by the
courts. Constitutional Courts are expected to exercise restraint
2026:JHHC:27807-DB
in interfering with administrative decisions and ought not to
substitute their view for that of the administrative authority.
21.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court has further held that a mere
disagreement with the decision-making process or the decision
of the administrative authority is no reason for a Constitutional
Court to interfere. The Constitutional Courts must defer to the
authority’s understanding and appreciation of the tender
documents, unless there is mala fide intent or perversity in the
understanding or appreciation, or in the application of the terms
of the tender conditions. A different interpretation given by the
authority, which is not acceptable to the court, is no ground for a
Constitutional
Court
to
interfere
with
the
authority’s
interpretation unless it is proved to be perverse or mala fide or
intended to favour a particular bidder.
22.
In the present case, there are hardly any pleadings of mala
fides or favouritism. In any event, no mala fides, favouritism, or
nepotism has been established based on the material on
record. The plea of mala fide or nepotism was, quite correctly,
not even argued before us. Therefore, following the principle
laid down in Afcons Infrastructure Ltd (supra), we find no
ground to interfere with the decision of the Bid Evaluation
Committee, which, in this case, comprised 10 members,
including experts.
23.
The Under Secretary’s letter dated 12.12.2025 was issued after
the Bid Evaluation Committee met on 03.12.2025 and rejected
the petitioner’s bid. That letter was not before the Bid Evaluation
Committee when it decided to reject the petitioner’s bid. In any
2026:JHHC:27807-DB
event, under the notice inviting tenders, we fail to understand
the
authority
under
which
the
Under
Secretary,
while
disagreeing with the views of the 10-member Bid Evaluation
Committee, observed that the petitioner was incorrectly
disqualified.
24.
If the Hon’ble Supreme Court has advised even the
constitutional courts to exercise restraint, we fail to understand
how an Under Secretary, who, under the scheme of the notice
inviting tenders, has no role to play, can proceed to disagree
with the decision of the 10-member Bid Evaluation Committee
and hold that the petitioner was wrongly disqualified.
25.
In any event, the Under Secretary’s opinion certainly does not
bind this Court. It rests on a misreading of clause 3.0 of the said
Policy and of the two main documents furnished by the
petitioner with his bid. The Under Secretary’s letter does not
even refer to the requirement under clause 3(ii) of the said
Policy, which requires the corporate or head office of a bidder to
be within the territorial jurisdiction of Jharkhand.
26.
The Under Secretary, perhaps, seems to be under the
impression that if even one of the conditions/criteria prescribed
under sub-clauses (i) to (vii) or at least (i) to (iii) is satisfied, then
the bidder can be adjudged as eligible. This is a gross
misreading of clause 3.0 of the said Policy, which is admitted to
be the clause prescribing the eligibility criteria for a bidder.
27.
Therefore, based on the Under Secretary’s post facto
communication dated 12.12.2025, we cannot be persuaded to
2026:JHHC:27807-DB
hold that the petitioner was in fact qualified and the rejection of
his bid suffered from any perversity.
28.
For the above reasons, we dismiss this petition without any
order for costs. The rule is discharged. Pending Interlocutory
Applications, if any, will not survive and are hereby disposed of.
(M. S. Sonak, C.J.)
(Rajesh Shankar, J.)
September 15, 2026
N.A.F.R.
APK/VK
Uploaded on 18.09.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review