Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 06
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
Pronounced on : 20.02.2026
Uploaded on : 24.02.2026
Arb P. No. 73/2024
M/S Mohan Lal Gupta Sons
…..Petitioner
Through: Mr. Udhay Bhaskar, Advocate
Vs
Union of India & Ors.
.….Respondents
Through: Mr. Sumant Sudan, Advocate vice
Mr. Vishal Sharma, DSGI
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY DHAR, JUDGE
ORDER
01.
Through the medium of the present petition, the
petitioner has invoked the jurisdiction of this Court
under Section 11(6) of the Arbitration and Conciliation
Act, 1996 seeking appointment of an Arbitrator.
02.
As per case of the petitioner, it is a partnership firm duly
registered
with
M.E.S.
Department
as
Class
‘S’
contractor. It has also been submitted that the petitioner
firm is also registered with the Registrar of Firms,
Jammu.
Arb P No. 73/2024
03.
According to the petitioner, contract work bearing
CEUZ/135WE/01/2021-22
for
‘Construction
of
Technical Buildings at Rakhmuthi Under GE(P) Tanda’ as
detailed in the tender inquiry No. 87864-A/11/E8 dated
02.12.2020 and the subsequent amendments issued in
respect thereof, came to be allotted to the petitioner firm
by the Chief Engineer, Udhampur Zone PO Garhi, vide
his
Acceptance
Order
No.
87864-A/54/E8
dated
15.04.2021 and the cost of the work was estimated at Rs.
3,51,55,470/-.
04.
Pursuant
to
issuance
of
acceptance
letter
dated
16.04.2021 issued by the respondent No. 3-HQ, Chief
Engineer, Udhampur Zone, PO Garhi, Udhampur, the
petitioner firm deposited an amount of Rs. 10,54,700/ as
performance security and it also furnished Performance
Bank Guarantee for an amount of Rs. 10,54,700/- issued
by HDFC Bank, Narwal Branch, Jammu on 24.05.2021.
05.
According
to
the
petitioner
despite
submission
of
Performance Bank Guarantee, the Garrison Engineer
(South), Akhnoor vide his letter dated 01.07.2021 again
asked the petitioner to deposit the Performance Bank
Guarantee. The petitioner is stated to have informed
Arb P No. 73/2024
respondent No. 4-GE (South), Akhnoor C/o 56 APO, that
the Performance Bank Guarantee has already been
furnished. The HDFC Bank, Transport Nagar, Narwal,
Jammu vide its letter dated 02.08.2021 also informed
respondent No. 3 and confirmed the issuance of Bank
Guarantee.
06.
The petitioner firm is stated to have marshalled its
resources in anticipation of receiving the work order so as
to complete the execution of the work within the
stipulated period of 22 months but the respondents failed
to issue the work order and to handover the site to the
petitioner firm. It has been submitted that on the
assurance of the respondent No. 4 that work order will be
issued to the petitioner firm, the site identified by the
respondent No. 4 was cleared of the bushes by the
petitioner firm and job of leveling the land was also
undertaken. A temporary shed for storage of material was
also raised on the site identified by respondent No. 4.
However, respondent No. 4 failed to issue the work order
for more than four months and it was only vide letter
dated 04.12.2021 that respondent No. 4 issued the work
order. In the said letter, the date of handing over of the
Arb P No. 73/2024
site has been shown as 13.12.2021 and date of
completion of the work is shown as 17.10.2023.
07.
It has been alleged by the petitioner that despite issuance
of work order on 04.12.2021, hindrance-free site was not
available for execution of the contract work. It has been
further alleged that during the period of eight months
there was steep escalation of the prices of materials like
steel which was required to be consumed in large
quantity for the execution of the contract work as a
consequence whereof, the petitioner vide its letter dated
24.02.2022 requested respondent No. 3 to determine the
contract in terms of the Condition-57 of the General
Conditions of the Contract (IAFW-2249). It was further
requested that accounts of the petitioner firm be settled
and Performance Bank Guarantee be released in its
favour or in alternative complete hindrance-free site be
made available to the petitioner firm and the quoted
prices be treated as enhanced by 20% over and above the
amount of contract to cover up the steep rise in the rates
of materials and labour since March, 2021.
08.
A meeting was held between the representatives of the
petitioner firm and respondent No. 4 on 28.04.2022 and
Arb P No. 73/2024
it was made clear to the said respondent that in the
absence of any clause for escalation in the contract
agreement, the execution of the work at this stage, is not
possible and, as such, a request was made for release of
the Performance Bank Guarantee. Instead of resolving
the issue, respondent No. 3 vide its letter dated
24.06.2022
threatened
to
take
action
against
the
petitioner firm in case the needful is not done. It was
responded to by the petitioner firm.
09.
On 02.08.2022, respondent No. 3 is stated to have issued
a final notice which was responded to by petitioner firm
vide letter dated 01.09.2022. The contentions of the
petitioner firm were ultimately rejected by respondent No.
3 vide his communication dated 16.09.2022. Vide
communication
dated
08.11.2023,
the
respondents
informed the Bank about the cancellation of the contract
and also invoked the Bank Guarantee but no such order
of cancellation or termination of the contract was
received by the petitioner.
10.
It has been contended that an illegal action on the part of
the respondents in invoking the FDR/Bank Guarantee
and cancellation of the contract has led to huge financial
Arb P No. 73/2024
loses to the petitioner firm and it has also brought
disrepute to the petitioner firm. It has been contended
that disputes have arisen between the parties and same
are required to be referred to arbitration.
11.
In the backdrop of the aforesaid facts, the petitioner firm
is stated to have issued a legal notice dated 12.05.2024
invoking the arbitration clause by making a request that
a conciliator be appointed in terms of the Clause 71 of
the General Conditions of the Contract (IAFW-2249) and
if the same is not done within a period of 30 days then
the letter may be deemed to be one for invocation of
arbitration clause in terms of Clause 70 of the General
Conditions of the Contract. It is alleged that the
respondents have not responded to the said notice of the
petitioner firm, hence the present petition.
12.
Notice of this petition was issued to the respondents on
09.08.2024 and the learned counsel for the respondents
after accepting the notice had sought time to file the
objections. However, no objections have been filed by the
respondents till date. On the last date of hearing viz. on
06.02.2026, it was directed that in the event objections
are not filed, the right to file the same shall stand closed.
Arb P No. 73/2024
13.
Heard and considered.
14.
So far as the existence of Arbitration agreement vide
Clause 70 of the General Conditions of the Contract is
concerned, the same is not in dispute. As per this Clause,
all disputes between the parties to the contract excepting
those for which decision of the C.W.E. or any other
person is by the contract expressed to be final and
binding, have to be referred to sole arbitration after
written notice by either party to the contract. The
arbitrator so appointed has to be a Serving Officer having
degree in Engineering or equivalent or having passed
final/direct final Examination of Sub-Division II of
Institution
of
Surveyor
(India)
recognized
by
the
Government of India, to be appointed by the authority
mentioned in the tender documents.
15.
The invocation of arbitration clause by the petitioner is
not in dispute. It is also an admitted fact that disputes
have arisen between the parties during the execution of
the contract work. Therefore, in order to determine these
disputes, an arbitrator is required to be appointed,
particularly, when the appointing authority has failed to
Arb P No. 73/2024
appoint the arbitrator in terms of the covenants of the
Arbitration Clause.
16.
In view of the above, the petition is allowed and with the
consent of the learned counsel for the parties, Mr. Satish
Chandra, Additional Director General (Retd.), R/o H.
No. 89, Lane No. 4, Greater Kailash, Jammu-180011,
is appointed as the sole arbitrator to adjudicate upon
the disputes and differences between the parties arising
out of and in connection with the agreement referred to
above.
17.
A copy of this order shall be communicated to the learned
Sole Arbitrator by the Registry of this Court within a
period of ten (10) days from today and the learned
Arbitrator
is
requested
to
forward
the
‘Statutory
Statement of Disclosures’ under Section 11(8) read with
Section 12(1) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act,
1996, to the parties within a period of two weeks from
the date of receipt of this order.
18.
The
parties
shall
appear
before
the
learned
Sole
Arbitrator on the date and place, to be fixed by the
learned Sole Arbitrator. It is further directed that all the
Arb P No. 73/2024
arbitration costs and fees of the Arbitral Tribunal shall be
borne by the parties equally and shall be subject to the
final award that may be passed by the learned Arbitrator
in relation to the costs.
19.
Disposed of.
(SANJAY DHAR)
JUDGE
JAMMU
20.02.2026
SUNIL
Whether the order is speaking ?
Whether the order is reportable ?
:
:
Yes
No
Arb P No. 73/2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review