Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Shampa Dutt (Paul)
WPA 22987 of 2025
M/s. Medicare Environmental Management
Private Limited
Versus
The State of West Bengal & Anr.
With
WPA 26230 of 2025
with
CAN 1 of 2025
CAN 2 of 2026
M/s. Medicare Environmental Management
Private Limited
Versus
The State of West Bengal & Anr.
With
WPA 28006 of 2025
with
CAN 1 of 2025
CAN 2 of 2026
M/s. Medicare Environmental Management
Private Limited
Versus
The State of West Bengal & Anr.
with
WPA 28011 of 2025
with
CAN 1 of 2025
CAN 2 of 2026
M/s. Medicare Environmental Management
Private Limited
Versus
The State of West Bengal & Anr.
with
WPA 29815 of 2025
with
IA No.: CAN 1 of 2026
CAN 2 of 2026
M/s. Medicare Environmental Management
Private Limited
Versus
The State of West Bengal & Anr.
For the Petitioner
:
Mr. Soumya Majumder, ld. Sr. Adv.
Mr. Ritesh Kr. Ganguly,
Ms. Sanjukta Dutta,
Ms. Utsa Podder,
Ms. Debasmita Chakraborty.
For the Private Respondents :
Mr. Nayan Rakshit,
Mr. Nilay Rakshit.
For the State in
WPA 22987 of 2025
:
Mr. Ajit Kr. Chaubey,
Mr. Vinayak Chaubey.
For the State in
WPA 26230 of 2025
:
Mr. Abhishek Kabir.
For the State in
WPA 28006 of 2025
:
Ms. Madhusudhan Saha Roy.
For the State in
WPA 28011 of 2025 and
WPA 29815 of 2025
:
Mr. Siddhartha Goswami,
Ms. Paramita Mondal.
Judgment reserved on
:
24.08.2026
Judgment delivered on
:
28.09.2026
Shampa Dutt (Paul), J.:
1.
Affidavit-of-service filed be kept with the record.
2.
Leave to file supplementary affidavit annexing the copy of the
enquiry report is granted.
3.
The writ application in WPA 22987 of 2025 has been preferred
challenging an award dated 18th March, 2025 passed by the
learned Second Labour Court, West Bengal in Case No. 05 of
2015 under Section 2A(2) of the Industrial Disputes Act,1947
and published on 21st April, 2025 by the Government of West
Bengal.
4.
The writ application in WPA 26230 of 2025 has been preferred
challenging an award dated 18th March, 2025 passed by the
learned Second Labour Court, West Bengal in Case No. 11 of
2014 under Section 2A(2) of the Industrial Disputes Act,1947
and published on 11th April, 2025 by the Government of West
Bengal.
5.
The writ application in WPA 28006 of 2025 has been preferred
challenging an award dated 18th March, 2025 passed by the
learned Second Labour Court, West Bengal in Case No. 09 of
2014 under Section 2A(2) of the Industrial Disputes Act,1947
and published on 9th April, 2025 by the Government of West
Bengal.
6.
The writ application in WPA 28011 of 2025 has been preferred
challenging an award dated 18th March, 2025 passed by the
learned Second Labour Court, West Bengal in Case No. 10 of
2014 under Section 2A(2) of the Industrial Disputes Act,1947
and published on 9th April, 2025 by the Government of West
Bengal.
7.
The writ application in WPA 29815 of 2025 has been preferred
challenging an award dated 18th March, 2025 passed by the
learned Second Labour Court, West Bengal in Case No. 12 of
2014 under Section 2A(2) of the Industrial Disputes Act,1947
and published on 11th April, 2025 by the Government of West
Bengal.
8.
It is the case of the petitioner that the Second Labour Court,
West Bengal under the provisions of Section 2A(2) of the
Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 and registered as Case No.
05/2015 under Section 2A(2) has held that there was refusal of
employment in this case as the service was not terminated by
any letter. The Labour Court granted re-instatement and 50%
back wages and costs along with all consequential benefits.
9.
It is the case of the petitioner that respondent no. 2/workman
who has not entered appearance in spite of service was engaged
in certain disputes and differences while raising certain charter
of demands. The workers went on a flash strike, completely
jeopardizing public safety and health care services in the
locality, in complete disregard to the responsibilities of the
workers engaged in essential services and stopped attending
work. The Conciliation meeting resulted in a bipartite
settlement.
10.
It is also alleged that few of the workers including the petitioner
had assaulted the representatives of the Management and, as
such, a charge-sheet-cum-suspension order had been issued on
6th August, 2013. On completion of departmental proceedings,
the enquiry officer found the charges to be proved.
11.
The Management without terminating his services, issued a
transfer order dated 27th January, 2014, transferring the
respondent no. 2 to Gaziabad unit of the company. But the
respondent/workman refused to resume his duties.
12.
It is further the case of the petitioner that though a bipartite
agreement was signed on 6th September, 2013, it is alleged by
the respondent/workman that he was not allowed to join his
duties on and from 1st January, 2014.
13.
It is the contention of the petitioner that the fact of transfer was
on record, in the written statement before the Labour Court and
a copy of the transfer order has been placed before this Court.
14.
It appears that the transfer order dated 27.01.2014 was issued,
on
the
enquiry
officer’s
report
finding
that
the
respondent/workman was guilty, but the Management wanted to
give one opportunity to the respondent and, as such, he was
transferred to Gaziabad.
15.
Vide a letter dated 01.11.2022, the respondent no. 2 was
dismissed
from
service
on
the
ground
that
the
respondent/workman did not attend the enquiry nor did he deny
the charge in the charge-sheet and also failed to join his place of
transfer. So finally he was dismissed on and from 31.10.2022.
16.
Petitioner
is
an
“Operator”
under
Bio-Medical
Waste
Management Rules, 2016. It has one of its plants at Howrah.
17.
Respondent no. 2 was engaged as a “picker” with a transfer
clause
contained
in
his
appointment
letter.
Conciliation
proceedings were initiated over the demand but the management
bilaterally settled such disputes. Two of the workers tendered
apology and resumed duties; others did not.
18.
No dispute was raised with regard to suspension and transfer
issues. The management paid subsistence allowance from the
date of suspension (i.e. 06.08.2013) till the date of transfer (i.e.
27.01.2014).
19.
Clause (d) in the appointment letter provides for transfer which
reads as follows:“d) Your present place of posting will be at M/s
SEMBRAMKY ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT PVT.
LTD., Howrah. You will be reporting to the DEPUTY
MANAGER
-
OPERATIONS
or
any
other
person
assigned. The company reserves the right to
transfer
you
to
any
of
sites/subsidiaries/associates/offices/factories
its
at
any place existing at present or which may be
established in future.”
20.
The petitioner relies upon the judgment of this Court in the case
of the Collector of Customs, Calcutta & Ors. vs. Biswanath
Mukherjee reported in 1971 SCC OnLine Cal 35, wherein the
Court held as follows:“8. Besides, if principles of natural justice are said to be
violated by the use of the two expressions abovenamed,
then there are also the other questions of principles of
natural justice on which the learned Judge has not come to
a finding namely, (1) no evidence, and (2) documents
considered by the Enquiring Officer behind the back
of the petitioner. It is difficult therefore to judge
piecemeal even this question of the principles of natural
justice in the present context of facts………………”
21.
The respondent no. 2 relies upon the judgment of the Supreme
Court in Sayed Yakoob vs. K.S. Radhakrishnan & Ors.
reported in AIR 1964 (SC) 477, (para 7 & 8)
wherein the
Court held:“this Limitation necessarily means that findings of fact
reached by the inferior court or Tribunal as a result of
the appreciation of evidence cannot be re-opened or
questioned in the writ proceedings. An error of law
which is apparent on the face of the record can be
corrected by a writ, but not an error of fact.”
22.
In conclusion it is submitted that the workmen, who have
obtained an Award in their favour after more than 11 years, the
same cannot be set aside by the Hon’ble writ Court without
considering valid reason. Therefore the prayer for dismissal of
the writ petition with cost.
23.
The respondent also relies upon the judgment of Nicks (India)
Tools vs. Ram Surat & Anr. reported in (2004) 8 SCC 222.
24.
The respondent/workman herein was not dismissed from service
but transferred for the serious offences committed by him in
spite of being found guilty.
25.
The learned tribunal held as follows:“Given the present facts, it is difficult to show and
suggest refusal by direct evidence. It is because there is
not a single document in the record, on the point of such
refusal. Hence it is to be inferred from the circumstance.
Exhibits 10 to 15 of the case no. 09/14 relating to similar
workmen under similar circumstances (of which this court
takes a Judicial notice) depicts a discord between the
employees and the management, which is an inference of
a motive of strained relationship which in general
experience prompts the management to takes stern action
against employees. This is followed by alleged act of
assault upon the member of employer and criminal cases
against applicant. In absence of direct evidence, these
are the circumstances of the case, which cannot be
overlooked to suggest a motive for refusal of employment.
A charge sheet in sessions trial case was filed against
the applicant. The charges appear to be assault by the
group of employees of one Victor Dasgupta, in a meeting
of
conciliation
summoned
by
Deputy
Labour
Commissioner. It has also appeared from the documents
on record that they were acquitted from the case.
There is no charge sheet preceding a domestic
enquiry by the company apart from a chargesheet before
the sessions Judge. No alleged order of transfer of
the applicant is on record. These facts suggest that
there was neither any domestic enquiry nor any alleged
transfer has been subject of discord.
Weighed in the balance of the probabilities, it seems that
the alleged protest activities undertaken by the
applicant’s and his associates has been a cause of
discomfort
which
goes
without
much
barren
contradictions that such alleged act of alleged assault
upon a representative of the employer side is not
supposed to be attended with comfort by the employer.”
26.
The said findings of the Tribunal seems to be erroneous
considering
that
copy
of
charge-sheet/show
cause
cum
suspension order dated 6th August, 2013 was before the
Tribunal as the document filed bears the Courts (tribunal’s) seal.
(Herein Annexure P-6 at page 35 to the writ application).
27.
It is unfortunate that the Tribunal also held that there was thus
neither any domestic enquiry nor an order of transfer, which
again is erroneous, as the transfer order is also on record
(Annexure P-7).
28.
The transfer order is part of a letter dated 27.01.2014,
(Annexure P-7), where in it is noted that though the enquiry
report finds the employees guilty. Instead of dismissal the
authorities gave an opportunity to work but transferred him.
29.
From such erroneous findings, the Tribunal came to the
conclusion that there was refusal of service and granted 50%
back wages. It appears that there was no proper consideration of
the documents/evidence on record, and thus non application of
mind.
30.
It appears from the record that admittedly the respondent did
not join his place of transfer and has taken the stand of “refusal
of service”.
31.
Admittedly, there is a criminal case (Sessions Case) against the
respondent for assaulting a management personnel.
32.
In spite of being found guilty in a lawfully conducted disciplinary
proceedings, the management did not dismiss him. Transfer is a
service condition accepted by the employee at the time of
appointment.
33.
Admittedly, he did not join his place of transfer (in 2014) and
thus he was dismissed from service (2022).
34.
Finally, on perusal of the materials on record and considering
the facts and circumstances, the documents which decide the
issue in the present case are:a) The transfer order dated 17.02.2014.
This order is as follows:-
“We have received the enquiry report which
was held against you consequent to the
charge sheet dated 06.08.1013. After going
through the proceedings of enquiry, we find
that the Enquiry Officer has found you guilty
and
further
you
have
not
denied
the
allegations mentioned in your charge sheet.
Since, the charges/offences committed
by you are of serious and grave nature, the
appropriate punishment is dismissal from
service. However in view of the your constant
persuasion,
verbal
apologies,
personal
request / assurances given by you and other
workers on your behalf, the management has
decided to take a lenient view and give you
one
more
opportunity
to
work
in
the
company.
As such, the Management has decided
to give you one more opportunity to continue
working in the Company and has decided to
transfer you to the Ghaziabad Unit of the
Company.
You
are
directed
to
report
to
Ghaziabad unit on or before 17.02.2014.”
b) The dismissal order dated 01.11.2022, wherein the
workman was dismissed from the said company with effect
from 31.10.2022. Full and final settlement was being
made from 06.08.2013.
35.
The order of reference in this case is dated 2nd February,
2012 in partial modification of Dept. Notification dated
25.07.1997.
36.
The impugned award was passed on 18.03.2025.
37.
The application before the 2nd Labour Court, Kolkata is no.
05/2015 under Section 2A(2) of the Industrial Dispute Act.
38.
Section 2A(2) of the Act, lays down:“Section 2A(2) Notwithstanding anything contained in
section 10, any such workman as is specified in subsection (1) may, make an application direct to the
Labour Court or Tribunal for adjudication of the dispute
referred to therein after the expiry of forty-five days
from the date he has made the application to the
Conciliation Officer of the appropriate Government for
conciliation of the dispute, and in receipt of such
application the Labour Court or Tribunal shall have
powers and jurisdiction to adjudicate upon the dispute,
as if it were a dispute referred to it by the appropriate
Government in accordance with the provisions of this
Act and all the provisions of this Act shall apply in
relation to such adjudication as they apply in relation
to an industrial dispute referred to it by the appropriate
Government.”
39.
To maintain an reference/application under the said provision,
there has to be prima facie, a case under Section 2A(1) of the
Industrial Dispute Act.
40.
In the present case, the transfer order (2014) and the order of
dismissal
(2022),
proves
that
the
workman
was
neither
discharge, dismissed, retrenched and or otherwise terminated,
when the reference was made in 1997 and modified in 2012 and
also when an application being no. 15/2015 was made under
Section 2A(2) of the Act.
41.
The order of dismissal dated 01.11.2022 is not under
challenge.
42.
The issues decided in the impugned award are as follows:a) That the termination of workman from service in
the form of refusal was illegal,
b) Reinstatement of the workman in consequence
thereof along with backwages,
c) Declaration of illegal retrenchment and awarding
compensation
in
consequence,
as
consequential
benefits.
43.
Admittedly there is a transfer order dated 17.02.2014, where the
workman was asked to join his place of transfer.
44.
There was never any “refusal to join” by the company.
45.
As the workman refused to join his place of transfer even till
2022, an order of dismissal was issued, which is not under
challenge in this case.
46.
Refusal to join a place of transfer from 2014 to 2022 is thus
a clear case of abandonment of service.
47.
The judgment of the Supreme Court in Life Insurance
Corporation of India & Ors. vs Om Prakash, in Civil Appeal
No. 4393/2010 dated 13.11.2024 is relied upon.
48.
Thus the award dated 18th March, 2025 passed by the learned
Second Labour Court, West Bengal in Case No. 05 of 2015 under
Section 2A(2) of the Industrial Disputes Act,1947 and published
on 21st April, 2025 by the Government of West Bengal, being not
in accordance with law is perverse and would amount to an
abuse of the process of law if not set aside.
49.
The impugned orders as noted in paragraph nos. 3 to 7 herein
are quashed and set aside.
50.
WPA 22987 of 2025, WPA 26230 of 2025, WPA 28006 of
2025, WPA 28011 of 2025 and WPA 29815 of 2025 are
accordingly allowed.
51.
Applications, if any, connected thereto stand disposed of
consequently.
52.
Interim order, if any, stands vacated.
53.
Photostat certified copy of this Judgment, if applied for, be given
to the parties on priority basis upon compliance of all
formalities.
(Shampa Dutt (Paul), J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review