Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
Record of Proceedings
COURT NO.1
WA No. 03/2021
M/S LINKWELL TELESYSTEMS PVT. LTD.
APPELLANT (S)
VERSUS
STATE OF SIKKIM & ORS.
For Appellant
:
RESPONDENT (S)
Mr. Sajal Sharma, Advocate.
For Respondents No.1 :
&2
Mr. Sudesh Joshi, Addl. Advocate General.
Mr. Yadev Sharma, Government Advocate.
Mr.Sujan Sunwar, Asst. Government Advocate
For Respondent No.3
Mr. Sangay Gyurmay Bhutia, Advocate.
:
Date: 10/12/2021
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWANATH SOMADDER, CHIEF JUSTICE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BHASKAR RAJ PRADHAN, JUDGE
…
JUDGMENT: (per the Hon’ble, the Chief Justice)
Let a photocopy of the receipt issued by the bank indicating
payment of costs of Rs.5,000/- in terms of our order dated 03rd
December, 2021, be taken on record.
2.
This appeal, preferred by the writ petitioner, arises in respect of
a judgment and order dated 09th June, 2021, passed by a learned
Single Judge in W.P.(C) No.23 of 2021 (M/s Linkwell Telesystems Pvt.
Ltd. vs. The State of Sikkim & Ors.). By the impugned judgment and
order, the learned Single Judge was pleased to dismiss the writ
petition for reasons stated therein.
3.
Briefly stated, the facts of the case, culled out from the
impugned judgment and order, are as follows: “3.(i)
Briefly, the case of the petitioner is that vide Agreement
dated 04.05.2017, the Petitioner was awarded the Contract for the
purpose of supply and maintenance of POS Devices, POS application,
its installation, maintenance, integration with the TPDS Software and
Automation of Fair Price Shops of the 1421 Fair Price Shops in Sikkim.
COURT NO.1
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
Record of Proceedings
(ii)
As per Clause 2 of the said Agreement, the Petitioner was
to adhere to the Request for Proposal (RFP) Guidelines and the Service
Level Agreement also formed a part of the Agreement.
(iii)
Clauses 2 and 8 of the Agreement were to be read
together to determine the rights and liabilities of the parties.
(iv)
Clause
7.9
of
the
RFP
contained
the
Arbitration
Agreement as defined under Section 7 of the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996. The relevant portion of Clause of 7.9 of the RFP
inter alia reads as under;
“7.9. Resolution of Disputes.
FCS&CA Department and the successful bidders shall
make every effort to resolve amicably by direct informal
negotiation, any disagreement or dispute, arising between
them under or in connection with the contract.
Any dispute or difference whatsoever arising between
the parties to this Contract out of or relating to the meaning,
scope, operation or effect of this Contract or the validity of the
breach thereof, which cannot be resolved, shall be referred to a
sole Arbitrator to be appointed by mutual consent of both the
parties herein. If the parties cannot agree on the appointment
of the Arbitrator within a period of one month from the
notification by one party to the other of existene of such
dispute, then the Arbitrator shall be nominated by the
Secretary, Law Department, Government of Sikkim (“Law
secretary”). The provisions of the Arbitration and Conciliation
Act, 1996 will be applicable and the award made thereunder
shall be final and binding upon the parties hereto, subject to
legal remedies available under the law. Such differences shall
be deemed to be a submission to arbitration under the Indian
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, or of any modifications,
rules or re-enactments thereof. The arbitration proceedings will
be held at Gangtok, Sikkim, India.”
(v)
The work was to be taken up by the Petitioner in a
phased manner as per the terms and conditions specified in Order
No.1804/FCS&CA, dated 29.03.2017. The Petitioner commenced the
works accordingly.
(vi)
By a Letter, dated 25.05.2020 (Annexure-12), addressed
to the State-Respondent No.2 by the Petitioner, the Petitioner raised a
Bill of Rs.3,65,01,842.00 (Rupees three crores, sixty five lakhs, one
thousand, eight hundred and forty two) only, and requested the StateRespondent No.2 to release the pending payment within seven days to
enable them to run the project, besides informing them that the
COURT NO.1
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
Record of Proceedings
Petitioner may not be able to manage operations beyond 01.06.2020
unless the payments were made over to them for the Bills raised.
(vii)
From the month of June, 2020, the Petitioner stopped all
works granted to them vide the Contract mentioned supra.
(viii)
That, the State-Respondent No.2 issued Show Cause
(Annexure-10) bearing No.753/F&CSD, dated 11.01.2021, reminding
the Petitioner that the State-Respondent No.2 had released a sum of
Rs.1,44,87,880.00 (Rupees one crore, forty four lakhs, eighty seven
thousand, eight hundred and eighty) only, in March, 2017, in favour of
the Petitioner as mobilization advance.
(ix)
The Show Cause also stated that from the month of June,
2020, without informing the State-Respondents No.1 and 2, the
Petitioner stopped providing their services resulting in a complete halt
in the Public Distribution System through EPOS Machine at Fair Price
Shops. That, further the unilateral suspension of services is ultra vires
the Service Level Agreement. That, the discontinuance of services by
the Petitioner caused a set back to the State-Respondents No.1 and 2
for timely implementation of the One Nation One Ration Card Scheme,
hence they were to explain as to why the Agreement entered on
04.05.2017 should not be terminated.
(x)
By a Letter also of the same date i.e. 11.01.2021
(Annexure-11),
the
State-Respondent
No.2
agreed
to
release
payments which were due to the Petitioner in a phased manner.
(xi)
It is the Petitioner’s case that on 16.01.2021, the
response to the Show Cause was given by them.
(xii)
the
Despite the response to the Show Cause, the services of
Petitioner
were
terminated
vide
Letter
bearing
No.801/F&CSD/2021, dated 22.01.2021.
(xiii)
Having thus terminated the services of the Petitioner, the
Respondent No.2 on 02.02.2021, issued “Notice Inviting E-Tender”
from eligible Bidders for the same works that had earlier been awarded
to the Petitioner i.e. Automation of Fair Price Shops in Sikkim.
(xiv)
Pursuant to the E-Tender, the Respondent No.3 was
awarded the Contract and Work Order issued on 09.03.2021.
(xv)
On 24.04.2021, the Petitioner was before the Learned
Commercial Court, East Sikkim at Gangtok, seeking reliefs under
Section 9 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, the prayers
being;
“i. Kindly issue an ad interim ex-parte injunction order to
restrain the Respondent from accepting any bid in relation to
the Notice Inviting E-Tender dated 02.02.2021.
ii. Kindly issue an order of injunction to restrain the Respondent
from accepting any bid in relation to the Notice Inviting E-
COURT NO.1
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
Record of Proceedings
Tender
dated
02.02.2021
until
the
conclusion
of
the
determination of the controversy between the parties by an
Arbitrator.
iii. Kindly pass an order quashing the Show Cause Notice
bearing No.753/F&CSD dated 11.01.2021.
iv. Kindly pass an order quashing Notice of Termination of
Service issued by the Secretary, Food and Civil Supplies
Department bearing No.801/F&CSD/2021 dated 22.01.2021.
v. Any other order/orders that this Hon’ble Court deems fit to
pass in the interests of justice.”
The reliefs so claimed supra are similar to the prayers made before
this Court
(xvi)
Vide an ex-parte ad interim Order, dated 27.04.2021, the
Learned Commercial Court restrained the State Respondent No.2
herein, the Secretary, Food and Civil Supplies Department, who was
the Respondent therein, from accepting any Bid in connection with the
E-Tender floated by them on 02.02.2021.
(xvii)
Later, after hearing both parties, by a subsequent Order,
dated 27.05.2021, the Learned Commercial Court vacated its earlier
ex-parte ad interim Order, dated 27.04.2021.
(xviii) Learned Counsel for the Petitioner submits that subsequent to
the Order dated 27.05.2021, the Petitioner invoked the Arbitration
Clause
of
the
Agreement,
dated
04.05.2017
and
sought
for
appointment of an Arbitrator. The suggested Arbitrator was not
agreeable to the State-Respondent No.2 and hence further steps in
this context are being taken and the process is underway.”
4.
The learned Single Judge after considering the respective
submissions advanced by the parties came to the following conclusion:
“5.
It may relevantly be stated here that this Court is aware
that the existence of an Arbitration Clause would not divest the High
Court of its jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution, neither is
the exercise of Writ jurisdiction under Article 226 in a contractual
matter ruled out. However, this jurisdiction is invoked when there is no
efficacious alternative remedy for the Petitioner.
6.
The
Hon’ble
Supreme
Court,
recently
in
Bhaven
Construction through Authorised Signatory Premjibhai K. Shah vs.
Executive Engineer Sardar Sarovar Narmada Nigam Ltd. and Another1
referred to the ratio in Nivedita Sharma v. Cellular Operators
Association of India2 and inter alia observed as follows;
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
Record of Proceedings
COURT NO.1
“17. In any case, the hierarchy in our legal framework,
mandates that a legislative enactment cannot curtail a
Constitutional right. In Nivedita Sharma v. Cellular Operators
Association of India, (2011) 14 SCC 337, this Court referred to
several judgments and held:
“11.
We
have
considered
the
respective
arguments/submissions. There cannot be any dispute that
the power of the High Courts to issue directions, orders or
writs including writs in the nature of habeas corpus,
certiorari, mandamus, quo warranto and prohibition under
Article 226 of the Constitution is a basic feature of the
Constitution and cannot be curtailed by parliamentary
legislation - L. Chandra Kumar v. Union of India, (1997) 3
SCC 261. However, it is one thing to say that in
exercise of the power vested in it under Article 226
of the Constitution, the High Court can entertain a
writ petition against any order passed by or action
taken
by
the
State
and/or
its
agency/instrumentality or any public authority or
order passed by a quasi-judicial body/authority,
and it is an altogether different thing to say that
each and every petition filed under Article 226 of
the Constitution must be entertained by the High
Court as a matter of course ignoring the fact that
the aggrieved person has an effective alternative
remedy. Rather, it is settled law that when a statutory
forum is created by law for redressal of grievances, a writ
petition should not be entertained ignoring the statutory
dispensation.”
(emphasis supplied)
18. It is therefore, prudent for a Judge to not exercise
discretion to allow judicial interference beyond the procedure
established under the enactment. This power needs to be
exercised in exceptional rarity, wherein one party is left
remediless under the statute or a clear ‘bad faith’ shown by one
of the parties. This high standard set by this Court is in terms of
the legislative intention to make the arbitration fair and
efficient.”
7.
In light of the detailed discussions that have emanated
supra, and in view of the obtaining facts and circumstances in the instant
matter as reflected hereinabove, I am of the considered opinion that the
Petitioner has failed to put forth any exceptional circumstances for invoking
the Writ jurisdiction of this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution.
of.”
5.
8.
The Writ Petition is accordingly dismissed and disposed
In an Intra-Court Mandamus appeal, interference is usually
warranted only when palpable infirmities or perversities are noticed on
a plain reading of the judgment and order. In the facts of the instant
case, on a plain reading of the impugned judgment and order, we do
not notice any such palpable infirmity or perversity. That apart and in
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
Record of Proceedings
COURT NO.1
any event, the impugned judgment and order is supported with cogent
and justifiable reasons. It is patently evident that the learned Single
Judge has dismissed the writ petition while choosing not to exercise
the writ Court’s discretion to entertain the petition upon considering
the facts of the case.
6.
As stated hereinbefore, it would be evident from the relevant
facts of the case that the contract between the appellant/writ
petitioner and the State-respondent no.2 stood terminated on 22nd
January, 2021. If this termination is wrongful, it is always open to the
appellant/writ petitioner to invoke the arbitration clause, which
admittedly is in existence in so far as the contract in question is
concerned. At this juncture, the learned Additional Advocate General
representing the State-respondent no.2, informs this Court that the
appellant/writ petitioner has already invoked the arbitration clause.
7.
So far as the subsequent award of contract to the private
respondent no.3 is concerned, in the facts of this case, that cannot be
the subject matter to be decided by the writ Court. Clearly, in the facts
of the instant case, the appellant/writ petitioner’s remedies are
elsewhere.
8.
For reasons stated above, we do not find any merit in the instant
appeal, which is liable to be dismissed and stands accordingly
dismissed along with all connected applications.
jk/avi/bp
(Bhaskar Raj Pradhan)
Judge
(Biswanath Somadder)
Chief Justice
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review