Judgments
LegalFirms.in Judgments · legalfirms.in/judgments/m-s-kismat-spices-industry-vs-the-state-of-tripura-and-ors-20230821/ · Printed 19 Nov 2026
Constitutional

M/S Kismat Spices Industry vs The State of Tripura and ors

Add to a compilation

Keep judgments in folders, mark the paragraphs you rely on, and print a compilation with an index. It comes with the Research and Advocate Pro judgment plans and with a campus licence. Sign in · See the plans

Court
Tripura High Court
Date
21 August 2023
Case No.
WP(C) 455/2023
Result
Disposed
Bench
Justice Justice, Justice T. Amarnath Goud
Cite this judgment
Citation
Link for your website or blog
Cite the court's own record or the law report in court filings.

The court's order

The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.

4. The DDF, Dharmanagar/Udaipur,O/C, Central Stores, A.D. Nagar for information. Sd/ Addl. Secretary & Director Food CS&CA, Tripura" [10] Clause 27 of the terms and conditionsof the NIT are also extracted hereunder which stipulates furnishing of mandatory 7 (seven) days notice before the agreementis terminatedat the behest of the employer. "27. Penalty on default /Extension of time: The successful Bidder shallhave to supply the monthly ordered quantity of lodised Salt as per specitications prescribed in the NIT and supply shall have to be completed in a spanof 30 (hirty) days from the date of issuance of the supply order. However, the successful Bidder shall be given a one-time preparatory period of 30 (thirty)days from the date of issuance of the Letter of Appointment(LoA) for the Work. In case of non-supply/delayedsupply as per the above schedule, liquidated damage for delay in supply shall be i. recovered to be computing @2% of the work order value for 1 week, @3% of the work order value for 2nd week, of the quantity of delayed supply from the approved supplier. In case the supplier still fails to supply even after 2nd week, the Department shall have the right to cancel the supply order and make arrangements for the supply of lodised Salt from other sources at the risk & cost of the defaulted supplier/Bidderand the incidental charges incurred thereon on this account shall be de…

22. The High Court has simply stated that the purpose of show cause notice is primarily to enable the noticee to meet the grounds on which the action is proposed against him. No doubt, the High Court is justifiedto this extent. However, is equally importantto mention as to what would be the consequenceif the noticee does not satisfactorily meet the grounds on which an action is proposed.To put it otherwise,we are of the opinion that in order to fulfil the requirementsof principlesof natural justice, a show-causenotice should meet the following two requirements viz: (i) The material/groundsto be stated which accordingto the Departmentnecessitatesan action; (ii) Particular penaltylactionwhich is proposed to be taken. It is this second requirement which the High Court has failed to omit. We may hasten to add that even if it is not specificallymentioned in the show-cause notice but it can clearly and safely be discerned from the reading thereof, that would be sufficient to meet this requirement." |12) Reliance is also placed on the decision of the Apex Court in the case of Kulja Indstries Limited (Supra) (paragraphs17,18,20,27,28,28.1& Z8.2)_ The Apex Court has laid down that not only the order of blacklisting should precede a show-cause containingthe charges but it should also indicate the propOsed quantum of penalty in vjew of the doctrine of proportionalityso that the noticee is in …

Full Judgment Text

Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs, CC BY 4.0). The court's own copy is the authoritative text.

HIGHCOURT OF TRIPURA AGARTALA WP(C) No.455 of 2023 M/S Kismat Spices Industry, Math Chowmohani, A.A. Road, Agartala, P.O Agartala, P.S-East Agartala, Tripura West, PIN-799006, Having its Head ofice at Math Chowmuhani, Factory at Badharghat, Industrial Estate, P.0 AD. Nagar, Agartala, West Tripura,Representedby its partnersShri Gautam Paul & SmtiSubhra Paul. Petitioner(s) VERSUS 1. The State of Tripura, Represented by the Secretary to the Government of Tripura, Food,Civil Supplies &Consumer Affairs, Civil Secretariat,P.O 2. Agartala Secretariat,PIN-799010. The Additional Secretary & Director, Food, Civil Supplies & Consumer Affairs, Government of Tripura, P.N. Complex, Gurkhabasti, Agartala 799010. 3. The Director Food, Civil Supplies & Consumer Affairs, Government of Tripura, P.N Complex, Gurkhabasti,Agartala-799010. 5. The Union of India, Represented by the Secretary to the Government of India, Ministry of Commerce & Industry, Udyog Bhawan, New Delhi 110107,India. The Salt Commissioner, the Government of India, 2-A Lavan Marg, Post Box No.139, Jaipur Respondent(s) For Petitioner(s) Mr. S.M.Chakraborty,Sr. Advocate. Mrs. P. Chakraborty,Advocate. For Respondent(s) Date of hearing & Mr. D. Sarma, Addl. G.A. 21" August, 2023. Judgment Whether fit for reporting YES HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMARSINGH HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD JUDGMENT &ORDER (ORAL) Heard Mr. S.M. Chakraborty,learned senior counsel appearing for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. D. Sarma, learned Additional Government Advocate appearing for the State respondents. (21 By the impugned orders dated 25.04.2024 (sic.2023 ; wrongly written as 2024) (Annexure-18)and (Annexure-19), respondent No.2 has cancelled the Work Order and Agreementexecuted between the Departmentand the petitionerdated 14.12.2022invoking Clause 27 & 28 of theGeneral Terms & Conditions of the NIT. Petitioner has also been blacklisted for a period of 05 (five) years from the date of issuance of the order from participatingin any e Tender/Expression of Interests (EolyRequest for Proposal (RFP) of the Department. It is also indicated that penalty will be deducted from his bill due and PerformanceGuarantee deposit as per NIT against the work order No.F.5 11(1)-PP(PD)-DF/2022-23(Tender)/16620dated 16.12.2022. [3] From the pleadings on record and documents adduced, it is evident that the agreement was for procurementof 'Super Fine Crashed White Iodised Salt (as per FSSAI Standard) in one Kg Poly-packet during the period November, 2022 to October, 2023. [4) Petitioner has taken a plea that the termination of the contract has been made without following the prescriptionof mandatory 7 (seven) days notice under Clause 27 of the General Terms & Conditionsof the NIT. In fact,no notice was issued on the petitionerbefore terminationof the agreement and cancellation of the work order. No notice has either been issued before blacklisting the petitioner. Learned counsel for the petitionerhas relied upon the decisionof the Apex Court in Gorkha Security Services Vs. Government (NCT of Delhi) and others reported in (2014) 9 SCC 105 and Kulja Industries Limited Vs. Chief General Manager, Western Telecom Project Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited and others reported in (2014) 14 SCC 731in support of his submission. [6| Petitioner has made reply on 27.04.2023 against the impugned order of cancellationof contract and blacklistingand requested them to review the matter with a holistic approach. [7] Learned counsel for the petitionersubmits that since the impugned orders suffers from violation of principles of natural justice and the terms and conditions of the agreement and entails adverse consequencesas he has been debarred from participatingin any tender for the next 5 (five) years affecting the prospects of the petitioner company in participating in tenders with other State or its instrumentalities,the impugned orders may be the matter may be remanded to the respondent any set aside and authorities to take a fresh decision in accordance with law. [8] Mr. D. Sarma, learned Additional Government Advocate submits that the matter has been taken up for the first time, therefore, instructions are awaited. However, since a perusal of the impugned letter indicates that order of cancellation of contract and the blacklistinghas not been preceded with anyshow-cause notice, this Court if it may deem so fit, remand the matter to the respondent authorities to take a decision in accordance with law on the subjectafter giving due show-causenotice and opportunityto the petitioner. We have considered the submissions of learned counsel for the parties. The impugned letters bearing No.F.5-11(1)-PP (PD)-DF/2022-23 (Tender)5766-70 (Annexure-18) and No.F.5-1 1(1)-PP (PD)-DF/2022-23 (Tender)/5771-75 (Annexure-19) both dated 25.04.2024 (should be read as 25.04.2023) are extracted hereunder: "No.F.S-11(1)-PP(PD)-DF/2022-23(Tender)/5766-70 Government of Tripura, Directorate of Food, Civil Supplies & CA P.N. Complex,Gurkhabasti,Agartala Agartala, the 25th April, 2024. To M/S. Kismat Spices Industry, Math Chowmuhani, A.A. Road, Agartala, Tripura (West). Subject: Cancellationof Work Orders for supply of lodised Salt. Sir, As per provisions of the 'Clause 27° and 'Clause 28' of the General Terms & Condition' Section of the NIT No.F.5 11(1)-PP (PD)-DF/2022-23 (Tender/12446 dated 12.09.2022, penal provisions have been invoked by the Department against your Company and the following Work Orders for supply of lodised Salt are hereby cancelled. SI W.0. No. & Date Quantity Last date of supply i) F.5-11(1)-PP(PD)-DF/2022-23 (Tender)/1325dated 20.01.2023. F.5-11(1)-PP(PD)-DF/2022-23 (Tender)/3012dated 04.03.2023. 2520.00 15.03.2023 MT 2520.00 28.04.2023 ii) MT Sd/ (Nirmal Adhikari) Addl.Secretary& Director Food CS&CA, Tripura Copy to: 1. PS to the Hon'ble Minister, Food CS&CA for kind informationof the Hon'ble Minister. 2. PS to the Special Secretary, Food CS&CA for kind informationof the Special Secretary. 3. All Sub-DivisionalMagistratesof the State for information. 4. The DDE, Dharmanagar/Udaipur,O/C, Central Stores, A.D. Nagar for information. Sd/ Addl. Secretary& Director Food CS&CA,Tripura" "No.F.5-11(1)-PP(PD-DF/2022-23(Tender)/5771-75 Governmentof Tripura, Directorateof Food, Civil Supplies& CA P.N.Complex, Gurkhabasti,Agartala Agartala,the 25h April, 2024. Subject: Procurementof Super Fine Crashed White lodised Salt (as per FSSAIStandard)in one Kg Poly-packetduring the period from November,2022 to October, 2023-Cancellationof Deed of Agreement' and Blacklistingof MIS. Kismat Spices Industry, Agartala, Tripura from participatingin any e-Tender, Eol and RFP of the Food CS&CADepartmentfor 05 years. References: a) NIT No.F.5-11(1)-PP (PD)-DF/2022-23 (Tender)/12446 dated 12.09.2022. b) Deed of Agreement F.5-11(1)-PP (PD)-DFI2022-23 (Tender)/12446dated 14.12.2022. C) Work Order No. F.5-11(1)-PP (PD)-DF/2022-23 (Tender)/16620 dated 16.12.2022, Work Order No.F.5 11(1)-PP (PD)-DF/2022-23(Tender)/1325dated 20.01.2023 and Work Order No. F.5-11(1)-PP (PD)-DF/2022-23 d) (Tender)/3012dated 04.03.2023. e-Mail communications of the Food CS&CA Department dated 05.03.2023, 06.03.2023, 05.04.2023, 09.04.2023 & 10.04.2023. M/S. Kismat Spices Industry, Math Chowmuhani, A.A. Road, Agartala (herein under referred as the Supplier) participated in the e-Tender invited by the Food CS&CA Department, Govt. of Tripura (herein under referred as the Department) vide NIT No.F.5-11(1)-PP(PD)-DF/2022-23 (Tender)y12446 dated 12.09.2022 and offered lowest rate for supply of 'Super Fine Crashed White lodised Salt (as per FSSAI Standard) in one Kg Poly-packet' during the period from November, 2022 to October, 2023. The Supplier quoted the lowest rate (L) for the supply and recognized by the Department as successful Bidder against the referred e-Tender. Thereafter, in response to Letter of Intent (Lol) dated |1.11.2022 of the Department, the Supplier executed Deed of Agreement' on 14.12.2022 for supply of 22384.00 MT (tentative) of lodised Salt with the Food CS&CA Department, Govt,of Tripura as per terms &conditionsstipulatedin the NIT Document, Deed of Agreenment & Work Orders etc. of the Food CS&CA Department. Subsequently, the Department issued 03(three) Work Orders vide No. F.5-11()-PP(PD)-DF/2022-23(Tender)/16620 dated 16.12.2022: Work Order No.F.5-1I()-PP(PD)-DF/2022 23 (Tendery/1325 dated 20.01.2023 and Work Order No. F.5 11()-PP (PD)-DF/2022-23(Tender)/3012dated 04.03.2023 for supply of total 7560 MT (@2520 MT per Work Order) within the last date of supply stipulatedin the respectiveWork Orders. However, it has been observed that due to delay in supply and total non-responsive approach of the Supplier, regular monthly distribution of lodised Salt through PDS has been hampered badly during last few months and thus, the 9.60 lakh ration cardholdersof the State deprived of getting their monthly entitlement of lodised Salt in time. Upon review of the supply position, it is observed that the following defaults have been committed by the Supplier which are breach of the contractual obligations and contrary to the interestof the Departmentand ration cardholdersof the State. a) Last date for supply of lodised Salt at 55 (fifty five) nos. State Food Godowns against the Word Order No. F.5 11(1)-PP (PD)-DF/2022-23 (Tender)/16620 dated 16.12.2022 was 30.01.2023. However, the Supplier initiated supply at State Food Godown level on 13.02.2023 i.e. after 02(two) weeks from the date of supply. b) Last date for supply of lodised Salt at 55 (fifty five)nos. State Food Godowns against the Work Order No.F.5 11(1)-PP (PD)-DFI2022-23 (Tender)/1325 dated 20.01.2023 was 15.03.2023. However, the Supplier has not yet supplied any quantity of lodised Salt at State Food Godowns till date. c) In the meantime, the Department sent several e-mail communicationsto the Supplier periodically, requesting to inform regarding the status of supply. Unfortunately the Department hardly received any reasonable reply from the Supplier. In view of the delaults detailed at para-5 above, the Competent Authority in the Departmentis of the view that the Supplier has failed to comply the contractualobligations,execute the Work Orders of supply and hampered the interests of the Departmentand 9.60lakh ration cardholdersof the State as well. 7. Now therefore, with approval of the Competent Authority, Ihereby invoking penal provisions under Clause 27 & 28 of the 'General Terms & Conditions' Section NIT document under referenceand passing the followingorders. executed between the The Dced of Agreement M/S. Kismat Spices Industry, Math Department and is Chowmuhani, A.A. Road, Agartala dated 14.12.2022 hereby cancelled. Chowmuhani, A.A. MIS. Kismat Spices Industry, Math period of 05 Road, Agartala is hereby blacklisted for a Order for b) (five) yecars from the date of issuance of this participating any e-Tender/Expression of Interests (Eol)/Requestfor Proposal (RFP) of the Department. the Bill Appropriate penalamount willbe deducted from due/PerformanceGuarantee deposit of the Supplier as per c) provisions of the NIT document under reference for delayed supply against Work Order No. F.5-11(|-PP (PD)-DFI2022-23(Tender)/16620dated 16.12.2022. Sd/ (Nirmal Adhikari) Addl. Secretary & Director Food CS&CA, Tripura To MIS. Kismat Spices Industry,Math Chowmuhani, A.A. Road, Agartala Copy to: 1. PS to the Hon'ble Minister, Food CS&CA for kind information of the Hon'ble Minister. 2. PS to the Special Secretary, Food CS&CA for kind informationof the Special Secretary. 3. All Sub-DivisionalMagistratesof the State for information. 4. The DDF, Dharmanagar/Udaipur,O/C, Central Stores, A.D. Nagar for information. Sd/ Addl. Secretary & Director Food CS&CA, Tripura" [10] Clause 27 of the terms and conditionsof the NIT are also extracted hereunder which stipulates furnishing of mandatory 7 (seven) days notice before the agreementis terminatedat the behest of the employer. "27. Penalty on default /Extension of time: The successful Bidder shallhave to supply the monthly ordered quantity of lodised Salt as per specitications prescribed in the NIT and supply shall have to be completed in a spanof 30 (hirty) days from the date of issuance of the supply order. However, the successful Bidder shall be given a one-time preparatory period of 30 (thirty)days from the date of issuance of the Letter of Appointment(LoA) for the Work. In case of non-supply/delayedsupply as per the above schedule, liquidated damage for delay in supply shall be i. recovered to be computing @2% of the work order value for 1 week, @3% of the work order value for 2nd week, of the quantity of delayed supply from the approved supplier. In case the supplier still fails to supply even after 2nd week, the Department shall have the right to cancel the supply order and make arrangements for the supply of lodised Salt from other sources at the risk & cost of the defaulted supplier/Bidderand the incidental charges incurred thereon on this account shall be deducted from the due payments of the supplieras wellas from the performance guarantee amount deposits. In addition to this, the Departmentshall also have the right to forfeit the Performance Guarantee Deposit of the supplier/Bidderbesides black-listingthe firm. The Department reserves the right to terminate awarded iv. contract at any time by giving 07 days prior notice, if the service of the Bidder is found un-satisfactory. Penalty provision as mentioned above for delayed supply V. will be applicable,but in exceptionalcircumstancesand if it is sufficientlyproved that the delay in supply is due to the circumstances beyond the control of the suppliers, extension of timne will be granted at the discretion of Director, Food, CS&CA. In the event of failure by the successful Bidder (L) the Food, CS&CA Department is at liberty and also reserves the right to purchase the ordered quantity to ensure uninterrupted supplies. In such circumstances the differentialcost, transport charges, incidentalcharges and vi. other excess expenditure, if any, will be recovered from the successful Bidder (L1).If the new rate is cheaper the benefit willnot accrue to the unsuccessfulsupplier. vii. Food, CS&&CA Department reserves the right to charge penalty provision as mentioned above or withhold payment against any unsatisfactorystocks supplied by the supplier without prejudices to other rights. The decision of the Director, Food, CS&CA Department is final and cannot be called into question. The supplier is liable to reimburselcompensatethe Food, CS&CA Department or to third party for any loss, damage, injury, etc. caused or arising out of the negligence in supply of low or inferior viii. quality of stocks or any breach of contract. Notwithstanding anything contained in the terms and conditions of this tender, The Director, Food, CS&CA Department is the authority in deciding the recovery of penalty from the supplier taking into account the stock position and future requirement of supply in the larger interestof the uninterruptedPDS supply." |11] A perusal of the impugned letters itself show that there is no reference to any show-cause notice issued upon the petitioner before the precipitate action of termination of the agreement and blacklisting has been taken against him. The law in this regard in quite well settled. Reference is made to the decision of the Apex Court in the case of Gorkha SecurityServices (Supra) (paragraphs 21and 22) which are quoted hereunder: *21. The central issue, however, pertains to the requirement of stating the action which is proposed to be taken. The fundamental purpose behind the serving of show-cause notice is to make the noticee understand the precise case set up against him which he has to meet. This would require the statement of imputationsdetailingout the alleged breaches and defaults he has committed, so that he gets an opportunity to rebut the same. Another requirement, according to us, is the nature of action which is proposed to be taken for such a breach. That should also be stated so that the noticee is able to point out that proposed action is not warranted in the given case, even if the defaults/ breaches complained of are not satisfactorilyexplained. When it comes to blacklisting, this requirement becomes all the more imperative, having regard to the fact that it is harshest possible action. 22. The High Court has simply stated that the purpose of show cause notice is primarily to enable the noticee to meet the grounds on which the action is proposed against him. No doubt, the High Court is justifiedto this extent. However, is equally importantto mention as to what would be the consequenceif the noticee does not satisfactorily meet the grounds on which an action is proposed.To put it otherwise,we are of the opinion that in order to fulfil the requirementsof principlesof natural justice, a show-causenotice should meet the following two requirements viz: (i) The material/groundsto be stated which accordingto the Departmentnecessitatesan action; (ii) Particular penaltylactionwhich is proposed to be taken. It is this second requirement which the High Court has failed to omit. We may hasten to add that even if it is not specificallymentioned in the show-cause notice but it can clearly and safely be discerned from the reading thereof, that would be sufficient to meet this requirement." |12) Reliance is also placed on the decision of the Apex Court in the case of Kulja Indstries Limited (Supra) (paragraphs17,18,20,27,28,28.1& Z8.2)_ The Apex Court has laid down that not only the order of blacklisting should precede a show-cause containingthe charges but it should also indicate the propOsed quantum of penalty in vjew of the doctrine of proportionalityso that the noticee is in a position to offer his reply to the charges and also the proposed penalty since the order of blacklisting has serious adverse consequences as it affects the right to carry on business guaranteed under Article 19(1X(g) of the Constitutionof India. [13] It further appears that the impugned orders suffers from non applicationof mind as even the date mentioned in the orders are of 25.04.2024 which the concerned respondent has not even cared to correct before signing it. [14] Having regard to the position in law referredto above and the facts and circumstancesof this case, since the impugned orders of cancellationof work order, termination of agreement/contractand blacklistingare apparently in violation of principlesof natural justice and not preceded by any show-cause notice, in order to give an opportunityto the petitionerto submit his defence, at this stage without observinganything on the merits of the charges referred to in the impugned orders, the impugned letters bearing No.F.5-11(1)-PP (PD) DF/2022-23(Tender)/5766-70 and No.F.5-1 1(1)-PP(PD)-DF/2022-23 (Tender)/S771-75both dated 25.04.2024are quashed. |15] The matter is remitted to the competent authorities/respondent No.2 1o take a fresh decision in accordance with law on the issue of cancellation of work order., termination of contract and the blacklisting by giving adequate opportunity to the petitioner to show-cause and upon considerationof his reply, if any. Needless to say, such decision be taken preferablywithin 4 (four) weeks as the issue not only affects the petitionerbut the interest of the employer also whose work may continue to suffer. The writ petition is accordinglydisposed of. Pending application(s),if any, also stands disposed of. (T.AMARNATH GOUD), J Rudradeep RUDRADEEP BANERJEE BANERJEE Date: 2023.08.23 16:22:43 +05'30' Apasesh keman Son (APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ

This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.

Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong? Request a review

All Tripura HC judgments →
LegalFirms.in Directory
Find an advocate for this matter
Dealing with a similar case? Find an advocate who handles this kind of matter on LegalFirms.in.
Find an advocate →