Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.472 of 2023
M/s K.L.D. Creation Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. through its Authorized
Representative Mr. Awadhesh Kumar Roy, S/O: Rajeshwar Roy, having its
registered office at F-134, Flat No.A-9 Jawahar Park Debli Road, Khanpur,
New Delhi-110062.
......... Petitioner(s)
VERSUS
1.
Executive Director (Technical) National Highways and Infrastructure
Development Corporation Ltd., Ministry of Road Transport and Highways,
Government of India, 3rd Floor, PTI Building, 4 Parliament Street, New
Delhi-110001.
2.
NHIDCL through its Deputy General Manager (Project), having its Regional
Office at 3rd Floor UD Bhawan, near Ravindra Bhawan, Shakuntala Road,
Agartala, Tripura 799001.
3.
Lion Engineering Consultants Pvt. Ltd. through its Team Leader, having
office at near Tripura Gramin Bank, P.O. Resham Bagan, Agartala Tripura799008.
4.
The Union of India, Represented by: Secretary, (RT & H), Ministry of Road
Transport & Highways, Transport Bhawan, 1, Parliament Street, New Delhi,
110001.
...... Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Devansh Mishra, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Bidyut Majumder, Dy. SGI.
Mr. S. Ghosh, Advocate.
Mr. Kohinoor N. Bhattacharjee, Advocate
Date of hearing &
Judgment
:
7th August, 2023.
:
YES
Whether fit for
reporting
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Mr. Devansh Mishra, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner. Also heard Mr. S. Ghosh, learned counsel appearing for respondents
No.1 and 2 as well as Mr. Kohinoor N Bhattacharjee, learned counsel
appearing for respondent No.3 and Mr. Bidyut Majumder, learned Dy. SGI
appearing for respondent No.4.
[2]
Writ petitioner, being the successful tenderer, entered into
agreement dated 24.05.2021 (Annexure-3) with the National Highways and
Infrastructure Development Corporation Ltd. for execution of the following
work:
“Rehabilitation and up-gradation of road from design km 19.300 to km
31.300 (Total length:12.000 km) of Agartala-Khowai section on NH 108
B to two lane with paved shoulder in the state of Tripura on EPC basis
(Package-II).”
[3]
As per the terms of the agreement, the date of commencement of
work was 08.06.2021 and date of its scheduled completion was 06.12.2022. As
per the case of the writ petitioner, the execution of the work encountered certain
impediments which led to delay in its timely completion. Petitioner took a plea
that the Right of Way had not been provided free from encumbrance;
mobilization of men and machinery by the agency could not take place in time
due to the adverse weather conditions such as excessive rains and outbreak of a
pandemic during execution of the project. Petitioner has referred to Annexure-4
series, which are correspondences written by the petitioner indicating the delay
not attributable to the contractor. The Regional Officer, Agartala, NHIDCL had
issued a letter on 24.02.2022 indicating the intention to terminate the petitioner
EPC contractor for his defaults under articles 23.1.(i)(c), 23.1.i(e) and 23.1.i(p) of
the contract agreement. The EPC contractor had submitted its representation on
09.03.2022 which is Annexure-6 to the writ petition indicating that there were
some serious health issues with the Managing Director of the company which
badly affected the progress of the project. They had tried to achieve the financial
progress of the work programme according to article 10.1(iii) of the contract
agreement but could not be achieved. As per them, the physical progress of work
up to 28.02.2022 was 5.4% of the contract amount but it could not be converted
in financial progress because stage payment statement had not been submitted
and approved by the Authority Engineer till date.
[4]
The petitioner further stated that they had reviewed their project site
properly and planned for all manpower, equipments and material procurement to
speed up the progress of work according to requirement of contract agreement
and had committed to achieve the financial progress in accordance with scheduleJ and revised work programme. They had also submitted a tabular chart
containing the strength of manpower, equipments which are mobilized to work in
a schedule timeframe. They had also taken a plea that after elapse of 50% of time
of contract period, the complete length of Right of Way (ROW) has not been
handed over. In view of these facts and the reference of review meeting of
Managing Director, NHIDCL, they had set their target for the month of March as
10% and for April-10% to be achieved. Total financial progress up to 30.04.2022
of 20% was committed to be achieved. This letter was considered by the
respondent authorities. The General Manager (P) by letter dated 26.04.2022
(Annexure-5) had conveyed its intention to grant opportunity to the contractor to
achieve the commitment made for minimum 20% physical progress up to
30.04.2022 as per the representation of the contractor and the review meeting
held on 03.03.2022. The Assistant Engineer was asked to review the work
progress of the contractor on 01.05.2022 and provide recommendation for further
action of declaring the contractor „non-performer‟ in case the progress of the
work is not achieved as committed by the contractor. Therefore, it was
recommended by the AE that the competent authority may provide an
opportunity to contractor to achieve the progress as per commitment made
instead of issuing termination notice. It was further indicated that the action for
declaration of the contractor as „non-performer‟ shall be initiated by the AE in
case the contractor fails to achieve the committed progress.
[5]
It seems that desired progress had not been achieved thereafter and
despite total 19 extensions of time granted during course of the contract,
petitioner made a request for extension of time up to 31.07.2023 vide letter dated
14.02.2023 (Annexure-7). In this background, the letter dated 14.03.2023
(Annexure-8) which accepted the request of the petitioner for extension of time
for completion of the work up to 31.07.2023 assumes significance. The letter
dated 14.03.2023 (Annexure-8) is quoted hereunder:
“NHIDCL/PMU-Tel/A-K/(Pkg-II)/25(1)/2021-22/Voll-II/2069
Date:14.03.2023
To,
The Team Leader
Lion Engineering Consultants Pvt. Ltd.
C/O-Mr. Milan Ch. Das, 1st Floor,
Near Tripura Gramin Bank,
Reshambagan, Agartala
email ID: lecagartala-khowai@liongroup.in
Sub:- Rehabilitation and up-gradation of road from Km 19.300 Km to Km
31.300 (Total length=12.000 Km) of Agartala-Khowai (Pkg-II) section of
NH-108B to two lanes with paved shoulders in the state of Tripura on EPC
mode-Extension of Time-Reg.
Ref: i) HQ, NHIDCL Letter No-NHIDCL/Tripura/NH-108B/AgtKhowai/P(2)/2019/986 dated 07.03.2023.
ii) RO Office Letter No-NHIDCL/RO-Agt/W/T/Agt-Khowai (Pkg-II) (NH108B)/315/850 dated 11.03.2023.
Sir,
Please refer to the above-mentioned letter vide which approval of
shifting of milestone has been conveyed with Revised completion Date as
31.07.2023 (101 days up to 17.03.2023 without LD and balance 136 days up
to 31.07.2023 with LD).
2.
In this regard, it is requested to take further necessary action as per the
provisions of the Contract Agreement.
Yours Sincerely
Sd/R K Tindwal
General Manager (P)”
[6]
Petitioner is aggrieved as by the impugned notice dated
18.07.2023 (Annexure-9), the agreement has been terminated invoking clause
23.1 of the contract agreement. Petitioner has been asked to vacate the site
within 15 days and handover all related documents and records to the Authority
in accordance to clause 23.4 of the contract agreement. Steps have also been
initiated for encashment of bank guarantee submitted against performance
security by the petitioner vide letter dated 26.07.2023 (Annexure-10) issued by
the respondent-NHIDCL to the HDFC Bank Ltd.
[7]
In the aforesaid chronology of dates and events, Mr. Devansh
Mishra, learned counsel for the writ petitioner has in particular invited the
attention of this Court to clause 23.1. The relevant clauses of which are
extracted hereunder:
“23.1 Termination for Contractor Default
(i) Save as otherwise provided in this Agreement, in the event that any
of the defaults specified below shall have occurred, and the Contractor
fails to cure the default within the Cure Period set forth below, or where
no Cure Period is specified, then within a Cure Period of 60 (sixty)
days, the Contractor shall be deemed to be in default of this Agreement
(the “Contractor Default”), unless the default has occurred solely as a
result of any breach of this Agreement by the Authority or due to Force
Majeure. The defaults referred to herein shall include:
xxxx
xxxx
xxxx
xxxx
(c) the Contractor does not achieve the latest outstanding Project
Milestone due in accordance with the provisions of Schedule-J, subject
to any Time Extension, and continues to be in default for 45 (forty five)
days;
xxxx
xxxx
xxxx
xxxx
(e) the Contractor fails to proceed with the Works in accordance with
the provisions of Clause 10.1 or stops Works and/or the Maintenance
for 30 (thirty) days without reflecting the same in the current
programme and such stoppage has not been authorised by the
Authority‟s Engineer;
(f) the Project Completion Date does not occur within the period
specified in Schedule-J for the Scheduled Completion Date, or any
extension thereof;
xxxx
xxxx
xxxx
xxxx
(p) the Contractor has failed to fulfil any obligation, for which failure
Termination has been specified in this Agreement; or
(q) the Contractor commits a default in complying with any other
provision of this Agreement if such a default causes a Material Adverse
Effect on the Project or on the Authority.
xxxx
xxxx
xxxx
xxxx
(ii) Without prejudice to any other rights or remedies which the
Authority may have under this Agreement, upon occurrence of a
Contractor Default, the Authority shall be entitled to terminate this
Agreement by issuing a Termination Notice to the Contractor; provided
that before issuing the Termination Notice, the Authority shall by a
notice inform the Contractor of its intention to issue such Termination
Notice and grant 15 (fifteen) days to the Contractor to make a
representation, and may after the expiry of such 15 (fifteen) days,
whether or not it is in receipt of such representation, issue the
Termination Notice.
(iii) The following shall apply in respect of cure of any of the defaults
and/ or breaches of the Agreement:
(a) The Cure Period shall commence from the date of the
notice by the Authority to the Contractor asking the latter to
cure the breach or default specified in such notice;
(b) The Cure Period provided in the Agreement shall not
relieve the Contractor from liability for Damages caused by its
breach or default;
(c) The Cure Period shall not in any way be extended by any
period of suspension under the Agreement;
(d) If the cure of any breach by the Contractor requires any
reasonable action by the Contractor that must be approved by
the Authority hereunder the applicable Cure Period (and any
liability of the Contractor for damages incurred) shall be
extended by the period taken by the Authority to accord its
required approval.
(iv) After termination of this Agreement for Contractor Default, the
Authority may complete the Works and/or arrange for any other entities
to do so. The Authority and these entities may then use any Materials,
Plant and equipment, Contractor‟s documents and other design
documents made by or on behalf of the Contractor.”
[8]
Learned counsel for the petitioner has assailed the impugned
termination notice primarily on the ground of violation of principles of natural
justice and non compliance of the terms of the agreement as contained in clause
23.1. It is submitted that the petitioner‟s request for extension of time to
complete the scheduled work was granted vide letter dated 14.03.2023
(Annexure-8) with the scheduled date of completion as 31.07.2023. During this
cure period, the impugned termination order has been issued which is in teeth
of clause 23.1.(i). As such, the requirement of prior notice before termination
has not been met and petitioner has been denied opportunity to submit his
representation as to the alleged causes of non completion of the work within the
extended time limit. It is submitted that if the impugned termination notice is
set aside and the matter is remitted to the respondent-NHIDCL to consider the
representation of the petitioner afresh, he would be in a position to explain the
reasons for delay and also indicate the time schedule within which the work is
to be completed. Learned counsel for the writ petitioner also submits that the
petitioner not only to be blamed for the delay as the Right of Way was not
granted free from encumbrance for a very long time.
[9]
Learned counsel for the respondents No.1 and 2 has strongly
opposed the prayer. Learned counsel for the respondents No.3 and 4 also have
opposed the prayer. They have sought to take us to the chronology of the facts
and events as are borne from the records of the writ petition itself to show that
petitioner despite having granted sufficient opportunity has not been able to
adhere to its own projected timeline for completion of the scheduled project
which is a prestigious public project of road under the NHIDCL.
[10]
We have considered the submissions of learned counsel for the
parties and taken note of the relevant documents placed on record and also the
terms of the agreement. Relevant clauses of Clause 23.1 have been quoted
hereinabove. From a perusal of the letter dated 26.04.2022 (Annexure-5), it
appears that the respondent-NHIDCL undertook a review of the physical
progress of the work and the representation of the contractor for extension of
time to complete the work at least 20% up to 30.04.2022. This was preceded by
the notice dated 24.02.2022 (not annexed) which was an intention to
termination notice invoking clause 23.1.i(c), 23.1.i(e) and 23.1.i(p) of the
contract agreement. In substance therefore, it is apparent from perusal of the
instant letter itself that on account of delay in execution of the work which had
a schedule completion period of 18 months from 08.06.2021 till 06.12.2022,
petitioner was served with a notice of an intention to termination notice as way
back as 24.02.2022. In fact, on the request of the petitioner, he was granted
suitable time to cure the defects in terms of clause 23.1. However, it further
appears from perusal of the subsequent letter dated 14.03.2023 (Annexure-8)
that though the petitioner had not been able to execute the work as per the
commitment made but taking into consideration its representation for extension
of time vide letter dated 14.02.2023, it was granted further extension with a
revised completion date up to 31.07.2023 (101 days up to 17.03.2023 without
LD and balance 136 days up to 31.07.2023 with LD). The letter dated
14.03.2023 indicated that the team leader i.e. respondent No.3 was requested to
take further necessary action as per the provisions of the contract agreement.
The impugned termination letter dated 18.07.2023 is comprehensive in nature
and contains the narration of the entire sequence of dates and events right from
the stage of execution of the work agreement on 24.05.2021 till the issuance of
the impugned termination letter. A mere perusal of some of the paragraphs of
this letter would show as to how the progress of the work has been affected
despite sufficient extension of time. Para 23 with its tabular chart, Para 26, Para
29, Para 36 and Para 39 to Para 42 are also extracted hereunder to give a bird‟s
eye view of the tardy progress of the execution of the work and also the
compliance of the intention to termination notice on the part of the respondentNHIDCL before proceeding to terminate the agreement in question.
“23. WHEREAS, the issue of slow progress of work has been discussed
in several meetings. Despite close monitoring of the physical progress of
work by PMU/AE, there is no endearment of contractor to the work,
resulting in merely 0.4% progress of the work during the last four
months. The month wise progress of the work since appointed date till
date is tabulated below:
S.N.
Month
Progress
in Physical
Particular
Progress
Month
Financial
Progress
1.
June-2021
2.
July-2021
0.09%
0.09%
0.00%
3.
Aug-2021
0.03%
0.12%
0.00%
4.
Sept-2021
0.10%
0.22%
0.00%
5.
Oct-2021
0.28%
0.50%
0.00%
6.
Nov-2021
0.46%
0.96%
0.00%
7.
Dec-2021
0.46%
1.42%
0.00%
8.
Jan-2022
0.46%
1.88%
0.00%
9.
Feb-2022
1.13%
3.01%
0.00%
10.
March-2022
0.99%
4.00%
1.80%
11.
April-2022
0.93%
4.93%
1.80%
12.
May-2022
0.37%
5.30%
2.44%
13.
June-2022
0.00%
5.30%
2.44%
14.
July-2022
0.00%
5.30%
2.44%
15.
Aug-2022
0.24%
5.54%
2.44%
16.
Sep-2022
0.21%
5.75%
2.44%
17.
Oct-2022
0.05%
5.80%
2.44%
18.
Nov-2022
0.25%
6.05%
2.44%
19.
Dec-2022
1.25%
7.30%
3.94%
20.
Jan-2023
0.80%
8.10%
3.94%
21.
Feb-2023
0.00%
8.10%
5.90%
22.
Mar-2023
0.00%
8.10%
5.90%
23.
April-2023
0.00%
8.10%
5.90%
24.
May-2023
0.40%
8.50%
5.90%
26. WHEREAS, total physical progress achieved by EPC contractor till
date is only 8.10% although 100% ROW was handed over to the EPC
contractor on Appointed Date of the project.
29. WHEREAS, NHIDCL vide letter at ref. (ii) issued a CURE
PERIOD Notice to the EPC contractor in pursuance of clause 23.1.(i) of
article 23 of the Contract Agreement to cure the defaults mentioned
within cure period of 60 (sixty) days from date of issuance of the notice
but no positive action in this regard has been taken by the EPC
contractor.
36. WHEREAS, after the lapse 60 days CURE PERIOD, notice for
intention to termination of the contract as per 23.1 (ii) of the Contract
Agreement was issued to the EPC contractor on 24.02.2022 vide letter
ref. (xvi) due to poor progress of work, poor mobilization of men,
materials, machinery & non-achievement of milestones.
39. WHEREAS, Extension of Time was also granted to the contractor
for completing the project till 31.07.2023, but contractor showed no
interest in completion of the project and could achieve merely 5.90%
progress till date.
40. WHEREAS, as on date, the EPC contractor has even failed to
achieve milestone-I even after granting extension of time.
41. WHEREAS, after passing of about more than 23 months since the
date of commencement of work, the EPC contractor could achieve only
8.50% physical progress and 5.90% financial progress as on date. Now,
the present pace of progress seems that it is not possible by the
contractor, to complete the project even after granting extension of time.
Clearly, in absence of satisfactory performance of the EPC contractor
and lack of proper construction planning, deployment of machinery &
manpower and reluctant behavior of EPC Contractor, all the Project
Milestones are not achieved even within the extended dates.
42. WHEREAS, in the light of aforesaid facts and circumstances, nonexhaustive fundamental breach, in view of the contractor‟s persistent &
sustained gross default in fulfilling contractual obligations, leading to a
material adverse effect on the project, the Authority has now after
giving sufficient time to cure the defaults and extending all possible
support to the contractor and after observing no improvement in the
non-professional attitude of the contractor, the Authority has left with no
other option but to terminate the contract with M/s KLD Creation
Infrastructure Private Limited forthwith in accordance with clause 23.1
of the contract agreement with immediate effect. The contract is hereby
terminated with immediate effect.”
[11]
A consideration of the aforesaid chronology of facts and events
and the documents and as an upshot of the aforesaid discussions, therefore,
negates the plea taken by the writ petitioner that the respondent-NHIDCL had
failed to comply with the mandatory pre-termination notice under clause 23.1
before terminating the agreement in question. The first intention to termination
notice in fact dates back to 24.02.2022. Thereafter, the petitioner has got
repeated extension to show physical progress of the work and finally the last
extension was granted by letter dated 14.03.2023 for scheduled completion of
the work by 31.07.2023. After review of the progress of the work which was
only 8.10%, the respondent-NHIDCL has chosen to terminate the contract. As
such, the plea raised the petitioner regarding non compliance of the terms of the
Agreement i.e. clause 23.1 and violation of Principles of Natural Justice is not
tenable in law or on facts.
[12]
Let it be made clear that we are not examining the merits of the
grounds of termination. The challenge is primarily confined to the compliance
of intention to termination notice under clause 23.1 and alleged violation of
principles of natural justice. It has been brought to our notice that clause 26
contains a dispute redressal mechanism which also provides for conciliation
and clause 26.3 contains the arbitration clause. As such, the parties have an
alternate dispute resolution mechanism which the petitioner is free to invoke.
Let it be also made clear that no observations made hereinabove shall be treated
as comments on the merits of the termination of the agreement in any such
proceedings that the parties may invoke.
[13]
On consideration of the entire facts and circumstances and for the
reasons discussed hereinabove, we do not find that the plea is substantiated
from the materials on record. As such, the writ petition fails and is accordingly
dismissed.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
(T. AMARNATH GOUD), J
Rudradeep
RUDRADEEP
BANERJEE
BANERJEE
Date: 2023.08.10 13:30:40 +05'30'
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review