Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page 1 of10
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.405 of 2022
M/sJaypee Projects Limited, a Company, incorporated under the Companies
Act, 1956, having its registered office at Trinity 5G, 226/1, A.J.C Bose Road,
Kolkata-700020,Representedby its Director, Sri Dilip Kumar Ghorai, son of
Late Gobinda Prasad Ghorai, having his office at Trinity 5G, 226/1, A.J.C
Bose Road,Kolkata-700020.
Petitioner(s)
VERSUS
1.
The State of Tripura, represented by the Commissioner& Secretary, Public
Works Department(Roads &Buildings),Governmentof Tripura, having his
office at New Secretariat Complex, Gorkhabasti,Agartala, PO- Kunjaban.
2.
PS-New Capital Complex, Sub-Division-Agartala,District-WestTripura.
The Commissioner & Secretary, Public Works Department (Roads &
Buildings), Govemment of Tripura, having his office at New Secretariat
Complex, Gorkhabasti,Agartala, PO- Kunjaban, PS-New Capital Complex.
Sub-Division-Agartala,
District-WestTripura.
3.
The Chief Engineer, Public Works Department (Roads & Buildings),
Government of Tripura, having his office at New Secretariat Complex,
Gorkhabasti, Agartala, PO- Kunjaban, PS-New Capital Complex, Sub
Division-Agartala,District-WestTripura.
The Superintending Engineer, Public Works Department (Roads &
Buildings), Government of Tripura, having his office at New Secretariat
Complex, Gorkhabasti,Agartala, PO- Kunjaban, PS-New Capital Complex,
Sub-Division-Agartala,District-WestTripura.
The Executive Engineer, Public Works Department (Roads & Buildings),
Government of Tripura, having his office at Capital Complex Division,
Kunjaban,Agartala,PO- Kunjaban,PS-New Capital Complex, Sub-Division
Agartala, District-WestTripura
Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
Mr. Somik Deb, Senior Advocate.
Mr. Pranabindu Chakraborty,Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
Mr. S.S. Dey, Advocate General.
Ms. Ayantika Chakraborty,Advocate.
16th August, 2023.
Date of hearing &
Judgment
Whether fit for
reporting
YES
HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESHKUMAR SINGH
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Mr. Somik Deb, learned senior counsel appearing for the
petitioner. Also heard Mr. S.S. Dey, learned Advocate General appearing for
the State respondents.
|2]
The instant writ petition is primarily for payment of contractualdues
totaling Rs.5,02,92,681.10/-along with interest @ 18% from the date it fell due
i.e. 31.07.2012. Though the petitioner had prayed for quashing of a
letter dated
28.07.2021 (Annexure-9) but it appears that it does not correspond to the
pleading of the writ petition and in fact, there is no such letter. Therefore, learned
senior counsel for the petitionerdoes not press that prayer.
[3]
Brief facts, as are necessary for consideration of the issue at hand
are that the petitioner was awarded the work under the Agreement No.
T/01/CE/EE(CCD)y2007-08 for an amount of Rs.15,16,76,040.00/-, The
stipulated date of completion was January, 2009. The said nature of work is
reproduced hereunder:
"Construction of New capital Complex, Agartala (Project
cost Rs. 177.00 crores)/Composite Tripura Legislative
Assembly Building and the New Secretariat of New Capital
Complex, Agartala/Construction of Tripura Legislative
Assembly Building/BalanceWork."
The original work was completed on 19.11.2011and the additional
work was also completed by 18.04.2015.The Executive Engineer, Public Works
Department (Roads & Buildings), Government of Tripura, Capital Complex
Division, respondent No.5 issued completion certificates dated 19.11.2011 and
18.04.2015 (Annexure-2) for original work and additional work respectively in
favour of the petitioner.Petitionerraised 14(fourteen) numbers of escalation bill
on 19.05.2018.The respondent No.5 vide letter dated 07.09.2018 directed the
AssistantEngineerto take on record summary of the billappended with the letter
for an amount of Rs. 1,85,80,985.52/-as Annexure-A with the observation that
the escalation bill has been prepared as per provision of the agreement under
Clause-10 up to 19th running account bill. Thereafter, an exchange of
correspondencestarted between the petitioner and respondent No.5 and also the
petitioner and respondent No. 4, the Superintending Engineer, Public Works
Department (Roads & Buildings), Government of Tripura on the subject of
revision of the escalation billsubmitted by the petitioner. Annexure- 12 dated
22.03.2021l was issued by respondent No.5 upon petitioner asking him to
withdraw his request for arbitrationmade through letter dated 15.02.2021 so that
the matter can be placed before the Chief Engineer, PWD(Buildings). It also
made an observation that the payment for the final escalation bill will be made to
the petitioneron receipt of the approval of the competent authority. The security
deposit as claimed by him willalso be paid in due course. Petitionerreplied vide
Annexure-13 dated 06.04.2021 that he cannot seek to withdraw his letter dated
15.02.2021since his claims are yet to be settled/finalized.He was again asked by
respondent No.5 vide letter dated 18.l10.2021 (Annexure-1S)to re-submit his bills
dated 10.03.202 I indicating that the escalation bils were to be processed to
respondent No,3 for according approval. As desired by respondent No.3,
petitioner was requested to re-submit the quarter wise escalation bill for the total
period considering the first quarter from April, 2007 to June, 2007 in place of
July, 2007 to September,2007. Petitionerwas served with a reminderletter dated
20.11.2021(Annexure-16) by respondent No.5. Thereafter, vide letter dated
24.11.2021 (Annexure-17),the respondent No.4 also directed the petitioner to
attend discussion on letter of the petitioner dated 08.09.2021 on 30.11.2021.
Respondent No.4 again asked the petitioner vide letter dated 27.01.2022
(Annexure-22)to attend the meeting and discuss the issue relating to the letters
dated 22.12.2021 and 22.01.2022 on the claim for outstandingdues. The matter
remained unresolved. Finally,by Annexure-23 dated 11.02.2022,the petitioner
was informed by respondentNo.5 in the followingmanner:
"To
The Director,
JAYPEE PROJECTS LTD
11, Clive Row (Dr. Rajendra Prasad Sarani)
Kolkata-700001
Mob-6290749647
Email:info@jaypee.co.in
Subject: "Construction of New Capital Complex at Agartala composite
Tripura LegislativeAssembly Buildingsand the New Secretariatof Capital
Complex, Agartala/Construction of Tripura Legislative Assembly
Buildings/BalanceWork"-regarding.
Agreement No. T/01/CE/EE/CCD/07-08
Date of completion:-21/07/2012
Project Cost: Rs.177.00 Crore
Ref:- Your letter (i)No.F.C-024/DKG/061/21-22dated 22-12-2021
(ii) No.F.C-024/DKG/21-22/057dated 08.09.2021
Sir,
Please refer to your letter No. referred under SI. No.(ii) wherein you
have requested this office to resolve your "revised schedule of
claims/disputes"under the above agreement within 15(fifteen) days and
stated that if no positive action was taken from this end within the given
time, you would have no other option but to take legal action as per law.
In this connection, a meeting was held in the office of the
SuperintendingEngineer, Project Unit, PWD(Buildings)when the issue of
your schedule of claims was discussed in detail in presence of your
representativeSmt. SomdattaDas.
In this regard, it is to inform you that the revised schedule of
claims/disputesas raised by you in your above letter is not correct as up-to
date payment already made against your final bill in March 2021 and
provisionalpayment of Rs.l.89 crore made as per your bills received till
March, 202 1. Final Escalationbill as submitted by you is not based on scope
& provision of the Agreement clause, hence could not be processed to
Authority for approval.
Escalationbills so far submitted in differenttimes were not based on
provisionsof scope of Agreement clause though out of total final projected
Escalation bill submitted by you of Rs.2.46 crore, an amount of Rs.1.89
crore already paid to you provisionally,which is above 77% of total bill.
Your Final Escalation bills submitted under reference under Sl. No.1
is found not prepared in accordance with the escalation clause of the
agreement and it is to be re-submitted fresh for taking further course of
action from this end.
From the above break-up of payment made, it is concluded that you
have no outstanding dues to claim to us.
However, you are requested to please submit the Final Escalation
bills in correct shape this office for obtainingapproval of the same from the
competentauthorityat an early.
After getting approval of Escalation bill, your all outstanding
payment will be made on availabilityof fund as soon as possible.
Hence your request to consider the appointmentof arbitratoras per
provision of clause 25 of the agreement for settlement of disputes/claims
and taking legal action against the department as per law is not at all
justifiedand acceded to.
Yours faithfully
Sd/
(Er. Manik Debnath)
Executive Engineer,
Capital Complex Division, PWD (R&B)
Kunjaban Extension,Agartala.
Copy to:
1)
The Chief Engineer, PWD(Buildings) New Secretariat Complex,
Agartala for kind informationplease.
2)
The Superintending Engineer, Project unit PWD(Buildings) New
SecretariatComplex, Agartala for kind informationplease.
Executive Engineer
Capital Complex
Division, PWD(R&B)
Kunjaban Extension, Agartala."
Petitioner has thereafter submitted his reply which is dated
28.02.2022(Annexure-24)addressedto the respondentNo.5.
|6]
Learned senior counsel for the petitioner submits that the
outstandingclaim of the petitioner is contained in a tabular chart at Annexure
24 and it also corresponds to the request made by the petitioner at paragraph
3.9 of the writ petition. Petitioner's revised claim has not been finally
consideredand disposed of as yet.
I7]
Respondents No.1 to 5 have filed a counter affidavit which in
substance refers to Clause 25 of the contract containing the mechanism for
settlementof disputes. Learned AdvocateGeneral submits that the claim being
raised by the petitioneris amenable to the mechanism provided for settlement
of disputes under Clause 25 which the petitioner should have invoked. The
quantum of the claim raised by the petitioner has never been admitted.
Therefore,the writ petitionis not maintainableon the basis of disputed facts.
[8]
Rival submissionshave been made on the question of arbitrability
of the claim raised by the petitioner. On the one hand, learned senior counsel
for the petitioner has taken objection to the stand of the respondents for
reference of the dispute for arbitration on the ground that if part of the claim
such as at item (ii) and (iii) relatingto escalationbills cannot be bifurcatedfrom
the whole claim the matter could not be referred for arbitration in terms of
Section 8 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 as amended. It is also
submitted that the respondents have all along engaged in correspondenceand
discussion on the question of escalationbills raised by the petitionerat item (ii)
and (iii) in particular. The claim does not stand denied by the competent
authority even till date. As such, petitioner has rightfully invoked the writ
jurisdiction for appropriate directions/mandamus upon the respondents to
considerand decide the claim of the petitionerin accordancewith law. It is also
submitted that the issuance of completioncertificateboth for original work and
additional work is in itself a proof of due execution of the work by the
petitioner.Whether the outstandingclaims relating to escalation bills as per the
terms and conditions of the agreement are admissible or not and whether the
remaining claims relating to return of security deposit and interest are
admissible or not has to be decided by the competent authority of the
Department.In case, the part of the claim or whole of it is allowed or some part
of it is disputed then only the question of invoking an alternative dispute
resolution mechanism or the forum of the competent Civil Court for
adjudicationon the disputed amount can be raised.
[91
Therefore,a suitable directionmay be passed upon the respondent
authorities to consider and take a decision on the claim of the petitioner in
accordancewith law within a stipulatedtime period as the petitionercontinues
to suffer on account of non-paymentof the outstandingdues being a running
business concern.
|10]
Learned Advocate General has at the outset taken objection to the
maintainability of the writ petition in view of the availability of adispute
redressal mechanism under Clause 25 of the agreement. He also submits that
none of the dues are admitted by the respondents. Noneof the correspondences
placed on record do show a final admission of the claim of the petitionerby the
competentauthority. If the claims are not finally resolved, no writ of mandamus
or appropriatedirection can be issued for pavment thereof as the petitioner
has
prayed for in the writ petition.
|11]
However, learned Advocate General does not dispute that after the
series of correspondencesbetween the petitionerand the respondent authorities
and the discussionmade on the claims raised by the petitioner,no final decision
has been taken by the competent authority either rejecting the claim or
admitting part or whole of it. Learned Advocate General is, therefore, not
averse to the propositionthat the competent authority can be directed to
take a
decision on the outstandingclaim of the petitioneras at Annexure-24.
|12]
I have considered the submissions of learned counsel for the
parties and taken note of the relevant pleadings and also the documents placed
from the record referred to hereinabove. The chronology of dates and
correspondencesreferred to in the narrative hereinabovecreates the impression
that tilldate no decision on the claim of the petitioner has been taken by the
competent authority under the respondents. It is also evident that his claims
have not been outrightly rejected. The series of correspondences up to
Annexure-23 dated 11.02.2022 indicates that the respondents have once again
requested the petitionerto submit the final escalation bill in correct shape for
obtaining approvalfrom the competent authority at an early date. It also
indicates that after getting approval of the escalation bill, his outstanding
payment will be made on availabilityof fund as soon as possible. In fact, the
letter dated 11.02.2022 also indicates that the request for arbitration under
Clause 25 of the agreement for settlement of disputes/claimsand taking legal
action against the department is not at all justified and acceded. In such
circumstances, the obvious inference is that the decisions on the outstanding
claims of the petitioner are yet to be taken. Whether the dues are
admissible or
not cannot be determined in the present writ petition since they
relate to
admissibility of the claims as per the terms and conditions agreed between the
parties as per the measurements and the records relating to
the execution of the
work maintained by the respondent authorities.
|13]
Court is of the
In the aforesaid circumstances, therefore, this
considered opinion that the competent authority under the respondents
take a decision on the claims of the petitioner, as referable in
should
letter dated
the
28.02.2022 (Annexure-24 to the writ petition). Learned counsel for
petitioner and learned Advocate General both have agreed to confine the claims
as are borne out from the letter dated 28.02.2022 submitted by the petitioner in
response to the request of respondentNo.S vide letter dated 11.02.2022
which
has been extracted hereinabove. Such exercise would necessarily require
scrutiny of the records relating to execution of the work by the petitioner and
also the terms and conditions of the agreement entered into between the parties.
The exercise may entail considerable time. Therefore, this Court without
expressing anything on the merits of the claim of the petitioner is inclined to
dispose of the writ petition with a direction to the competentauthority under the
respondentsto take a decision on the claim of the petitioneras are contained in
Annexure-24 dated 28.02.2022 to the writ petition within a reasonable time
preferablywithin a period of 12(twelve)weeks from the date of receiptof copy
of this order. Needless to say, the competent authority would take a decision
and pass areasonedorder on the claim of the petitioner within the aforesaid
time.In case, theclaim of the petitioneror part of it is found to be admissible,
the respondent authoritieswould ensure that the admissibledues are released in
favour of the petitioner within a reasonable period preferably within 8(eight)
weeks thereafter.In case the petitioneris aggrievedby the decision taken by the
respondent authorities,he may have hisremedy in an appropriate proceeding
before the appropriate forum in accordance with law. The writ petition stands
disposed of in the aforesaidmanner.
Pending application(s),if any, also stands disposed of.
Apanesh eumae Sigh
(APARESHKUMAR SINGH), CJ
Rudradeep
RUDRADEEP
BANERJEE
BANERJEE
Date: 2023.08.21 16:27:08 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review