Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A
WP(C) No. 872 of 2022
1.
M/s Jaypee Projects Limited, a Company, incorporated under the
Companies Act, 1956, having its registered office at Trinity 5G, 226/1,
A.J.C. Bose Road, Kolkata-700020, represented by its Director, Sri
Dilip Kumar Ghorai, son of late Gobinda Prasad Ghorai, having his
office at Trinity 5G, 226/1, A. J. C. Bose Road, Kolkata-700020.
…..Petitioner
-V E R S U S-
1.
The State of Tripura, represented by the Commissioner & Secretary,
Public Works Department (Roads & Buildings), Government of
Tripura, having his office at New Secretariat Complex, Gorkhabasti,
Agartala, P.O. Kunjaban, P.S. New Capital Complex, Sub-DivisionAgartala, District: West Tripura.
2.
The Commissioner & Secretary, Public Works Department (Roads &
Buildings), Government of Tripura, having his office at New
Secretariat Complex, Gorkhabasti, Agartala, P.O. Kunjaban, P.S. New
Capital Complex, Sub-Division-Agartala, District: West Tripura.
3.
The Chief Engineer, Public Works Department (Roads & Buildings),
Government of Tripura, having his office at New Secretariat Complex,
Gorkhabasti, Agartala, P.O. Kunjaban, P.S. New Capital Complex,
Sub-Division-Agartala, District: West Tripura.
4.
The Superintending Engineer, Public Works Department (Roads &
Buildings), Government of Tripura, having his office at New
Secretariat Complex, Gorkhabasti, Agartala, P.O. Kunjaban, P.S. New
Capital Complex, Sub-Division-Agartala, District: West Tripura.
5.
The Executive Engineer, Public Works Department (Roads &
Buildings), Government of Tripura, having his office at Agartala,
Division No. III, P.O. Kunjaban, P.S. New Capital Complex, SubDivision: Agartala, District: West Tripura.
….. Respondents.
B_E_F_O_R_E
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING)
For Petitioner(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Date of hearing
Date of delivery of
judgment and order
Whether fit for reporting
:
Mr. Somik Deb, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. Abir Baran, Advocate.
Mr. S. S. Dey, Advocate General.
Ms. A. Chakraborty, Advocate.
16.12.2022.
:
:
21.12.2022
NO
JUDGMENT & ORDER
Heard Mr. Somik Deb, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr.
Abir Baran, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. S. S.
Dey, learned Advocate General assisted by Ms. A. Chakraborty, learned
counsel appearing for the respondents.
[2]
This present petition has been filed under Article-226 of the
Constitution of India for enforcement of the Constitutional rights of the
petitioner granted under Articles-14, 19, 21 and 300A of the Constitution of
India also for transmitting the records, relevant to the subject matter of this writ
petition for rendering substantive and conscionable justice to the petitioner.
Further, to direct the respondents to forthwith pay off the outstanding dues to
the petitioner, amounting to Rs.27,46,96,122.55/- along with interest @18%
from the date it fell due.
[3]
The brief fact which falls for considering in this writ petition is
that for execution of the civil work, namely “Construction of the Composite
Tripura Legislative Assembly Building and the new Secretariat of New Capital
Complex, Agartala, Tripura” the Executive Engineer, Capital Complex
Division PWD (R&B) issued a tender notice, pursuant whereto, the petitioner
was selected for execution of the said work and accordingly, the work order
was issued in favour of the petitioner.
[4]
After the successful completion of the work, the project was duly
handed over to the respondents and accordingly, by letters, the Executive
Engineer, Capital Complex Division, PWD (R&B) issued completion
certificates for original work and extra work respectively, in favour of the
petitioner and no dispute arose as to the said work, either during or after
execution of the same. Thereafter, the Executive Engineer, Capital Complex
Division PWD (R&B) issued a letter to the Assistant Engineer, Capital
Complex Sub-Division-I PWD (R&B) as well forwarding a copy of the
petitioner, thereby stating that the petitioner claimed an Escalation Bill, under
up to 19th RA Bill, the amount of Escalation Bill has been scrutinized/modified
by the respondents to Rs.1,85,80,985.52/-.
[5]
Thereafter, the Director of the issued a letter to the Executive
Engineer, PWD (R&B), Government of Tripura, thereby requesting to release
the balance Final Bill, including the Escalation Bill, amounting to
Rs.1,76,40,892.1/-, within a period of one month, to avoid the 18% interest, to
be counted with effect from 31.07.2012. Thereafter, the Director of the
petitioner issue a reminder letter, to the Executive Engineer, PWD (R&B),
Government of Tripura, thereby requesting to release the balance final bill,
including the escalation bill, amounting to Rs.1,76,40,892.1/- along with 18%
interest claimed on to the above amount.
[6]
Thereafter, the Director of the petitioner further issued another
reminder letter to the Executive Engineer, Capital Complex Division, PWD
(R&B) Government of Tripura, thereby requesting to release the balance final
bill, including the escalation bill, amounting to Rs.1,76,40,892.1/- along with
18% interest claimed on to the above amount. Furthermore, the Director of the
petitioner issued another reminder letter to the Executive Engineer, Capital
Complex Division, PWD (R&B), Government of Tripura, thereby requesting
to release the balance final bill, including the escalation bill, amounting to
Rs.1,76,40,892.1/- along with 18% interest claimed on to the above amount.
[7]
Mr. Somik Deb, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. Abir
Baran, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has submitted that Clause31.1 of the agreement inter alia provided for the final completion certificate
which provided that on successful completion of the entire works covered by
the contractor to the full satisfaction of the engineer, the contractor shall ensure
that the works have been completed to the satisfaction of the engineer.
Thereafter, upon the satisfactory fulfillment of the works by the contractor as
stated above, the contractor would be entitled to apply to the engineer for a
final completion certificate in respect of the entire work.
[8]
He has submitted that Clause-34 of the Agreement inter alia
provided for the defect liability period or period of maintenance which
provided that the contractor should maintain the whole of permanent works in
a thoroughly sound, substantial, efficient and perfect condition during the
defects liability period of 365 days after the virtual date of completion of the
whole of the works as was certified by the engineer, which should be remedied
at his own cost and that also to the satisfaction of the engineer which might
have become apparent, prior to or during the maintenance or defect liability
period, which raised out of the materials or workmanship or default of the
contractor.
[9]
He has stressed upon Clause-47 of the Agreement inter alia
provided that if the prices of material or wages of labour required for the
execution of the work increase, the contractor shall be compensated for such
increase and as per the provisions, the amount of the contract shall accordingly
be varied, subject to the condition that such compensation for escalation in
prices shall be available only for the work done during the stipulated period of
the contract including such period, for which the contract is validated, which
was extended under the provisions of Clause-28 of the contract without any
action under Clause-49.
[11]
According to Clause-37.2 of the Agreement all the tendered rates
shall be inclusive of all taxes and levies, payable under respective statutes. It
was further noted that pursuant to the constitution (46th Amendment) Act, 1982
if any further tax of levy was imposed by any statute, the last stipulated date
for receipt of the tender including extensions, if any, and that the contractor
thereupon necessarily and properly pays such taxes, the contractor would be
reimbursed or deducted from the amount so paid and further provided that such
payments, if any, was not in the opinion of the engineer attributable to delay in
execution of the work within the control of the contractor.
[12]
It would evidently be cleared that the petitioner was diligent in
executing the work and that the petitioner was successful in completing the
work in due time. The respondents have admitted that the petitioner has
executed the work to the fullest satisfaction to the said respondent-authority
and hence, the deferment of payment, solely founded on non-grant of fund by
the respondents. It is an established principle in contractual parlance that the
employer owes the responsibility to pay off the amounts, due and payable to
the contractor, within a reasonable time and prolonged non-payment is
unsustainable.
[13]
He has further submitted that the respondents have not disputed
the claim of the petitioner, urging for payment of the outstanding dues. On the
other hand, the respondents have sought to contend that eh payment f the
outstanding dues, to the petitioner would be made, as and when the fund
therefore is sanctioned and paid by the respondent-State. He has further
contended that even though the agreement in question provides for resolution
of any dispute, by way of arbitration, but since, the respondents themselves
have admitted their liability, on to the request of the petitioner for the
appointment of arbitrator, it remains beyond the cavil of any dispute that the
remedy that is available to the petitioner, is either way of institution of a
money suit, or by way of presentation of a writ petition, under Article-226 of
the Constitution of India.
[14]
It is an established principle in commercial transaction, that
prompt payment is the rule, and indefinite non-payment is wholly misplaced.
In view of the above, it is apparently very clear that by not making payment to
the petitioner for such prolonged time, the respondents have invaded the rights
of the petitioner, guaranteed under Article-14, 19 (1) (g), 21 and 300A of the
Constitution of India and the said violates the rights of the petitioner, merit to
be immediately remedied, by directing the respondents to pay off the
outstanding of Rs.27,46,96,122.55/- along with @18% from the date it fell due.
[15]
Per contra, Mr. S. S. Dey, learned Advocate General assisted by
Ms. A. Chakraborty, learned counsel appearing for the respondents has
submitted on the very point of maintainability of the writ petition. He has
submitted that the present petition is full of pleadings raising disputed question
of facts concerning espoused civil rights of the petitioner, none of which have
admitted by the respondents. The petitioners had executed some civil works
and is claiming release of balance payment, the quantum of which, as claimed
by the petitioner has never been admitted and hence, the espoused right of the
petitioner, if any, is under rebuttal. Hence, no writ petition is maintainable to
ascertain the civil rights and liabilities of parties that too on the basis of
disputed facts.
[16]
He has further averred that the petitioner had submitted bill on
26.04.2022 claiming payment at escalated rates. The claim of the petitioner has
since been answered vide letter No.F.25(250)/EE-III/PWD(R&B)/4633-36
dated 18.10.2022 inter alia informing the petitioner that the said price
escalation bill is not maintainable in view of Cluse-47 of the contract between
the parties, thus, the petitioner was requested to resubmit a fresh bill as per
Clause-47 of the Contract. For the purpose of reference, the relevant portion
may be reproduced herein below:
“Not applicable for works for which estimated cost put to tender
is less than Rs.1.00 crore stipulated time form completion is less than or equal
to twenty four months.”The stipulated time for completion of the work in
question being twenty four months, the aforesaid bar applies.”
[17]
The contract between the parties provides for alternative dispute
redressal mechanism in Clause-24, 25 and 26 which the petitioner is free to
exhaust. Although the writ petitioner vide his letter with reference No.C34/NSRCC/JPL/DKG/2021-22/049 dated 27.07.2021 has sought for settlement
of dispute through alternative dispute redressal mechanism and accordingly the
said prayer for appointment of an arbitrator was under consideration,
meanwhile the contractor, the writ petitioner had again filed an escalation bill
which in violation of Clause-47 of the agreement. Hence, in the factum of
existence of the aforesaid alternative dispute redressal mechanism in the
contract itself, the present writ petition with disputed question of facts is not
maintainable in the eye of law.
[18]
Mr. Dey, learned G.A. in regard to the payment to the petitioner
has drawn attention of this Court to Annexure-8. For the purpose of reference,
the letter No. F.25-250/EE-III/12,674-78 may be reproduced herein below:
“To,
The Jypee Projects Limited,
11 Civil Row[Dr.Rajendra Prasad Sarani]
Kolkata-700001
Sub: Request for making different payments.
Reference:- Your letter dated -09January, 2019 8th January, 2019 earlier
different reference in this regard.
Sir,
With reference to subject cited above, I am to state that this office has
examined your request for payment of Rs.1,21,63,33/- outstanding against
GST as claimed by you. In this regard, I am to state that as per clause
no.37.2 of the agreement which clarifies conditions for
reimbursement/rebate of levy/taxes if levied after the receipt of tenders
which inter alia says that such taxes/levies that contractor shall be
reimbursed/deducted that amount so paid, provided such payment, if any, is
not, in the option of the engineer (whose decision shall be final and binding
on the contractor) attributable to the delay in execution of work within the
control of the contractor.
As GST came into force w.e.f. 01/07/2017 after the stipulated date of
completion of said agreement which is 10.01.2013 and time extension
related to the said work is processed by this office to the competent
authority and final decision is yet to be communicated from their end, that
will clearly determine how much proportionate delay of execution of the
said work attributable to Agency and how much to the department.
As this decision is yet to be taken by competent authority and without this,
this office is not in position to ascertain your above said claim for payment
of Rs.1,21,63,338/- reimbursement against GST. It is further stated that
after the finalization of time extension by competent authority, the detailed
matter will be processed to the higher authority for decision/orders and
appropriate action will be taken by this office accordingly, including your
demand for reimbursement of VAT (Tripura WCT) as per clause No.37.2
of the agreement.
In response to your request for release of amount of Rs.20,00,000/- kept in
held on account of interest of mobilization advance has already been
refunded to you and in addition to this, we have also released amount of
Rs.22,83,477/-/ kept in held on account of VAT deduction in the regime of
GST due to non availability of specific instructions in this regard. Now you
liable to pay applicable GST from end for the payments your have received
during the period of 01.07.2017 to 30.09.2018 (in regime of GST when no
deduction of VAT is applicable and no deduction of GST at source was
notified.)
In response to your request for payment of balance amount towards the
final bill of Rs.284.82 lakhs, I am to state that against the bill value of
Rs4288.24 lakhs (up to 24th RA), we have already paid an amount of
Rs.4245.20 lakhs ( as on 28.02.2019) and final bill is yet to received from
respective sub division. The remaining amount will be paid subject to
availability of funds and finalization of time extension/final deviation and
your demand for 18% simple interest on pending bill amount is fully
unwarranted because no such clause exists in the agreement of the said
work.
Yours faithfully,
(Er. Priyabrata Paul)
Executive Engineer,
Agartala Division No.III PWD (R&B)”
[19]
Mr. Dey, learned A.G. in support of his case has placed his
reliance upon a decision of the Hon‟ble Apex Court in Bhaven Construction v.
Esecutive Engineer, Sardar Sarovar Narmada Nigam Limited and Another,
reported in (2022) 1 SCC 75, wherein, the Court held thus:
“18. In any case, the hierarchy in our legal framework mandates that a
legislative enactment cannot curtail a Constitutional right. In Nivedita
Sharma v. Cellular Operators Association of India, (2011) 14 SCC 337, this
Court referred to several judgments and held:
“11. We have considered the respective arguments/submissions. There
cannot be any dispute that the power of the High Courts to issue directions,
orders or writs including writs in the nature of habeas corpus, certiorari,
mandamus, quo warranto and prohibition under Article 226 of the
Constitution is a basic feature of the Constitution and cannot be curtailed
by parliamentary legislation - L. Chandra Kumar v. Union of India, (1997)
3 SCC 261. However, it is one thing to say that in exercise of the power
vested in it under Article 226 of the Constitution, the High Court can
entertain a writ petition against any order passed by or action taken by the
State and/or its agency/ instrumentality or any public authority or order
passed by a quasi- judicial body/authority, and it is an altogether different
thing to say that each and every petition filed under Article 226 of the
Constitution must be entertained by the High Court as a matter of course
ignoring the fact that the aggrieved person has an effective alternative
remedy. Rather, it is settled law that when a statutory forum is created by
law for redressal of grievances, a writ petition should not be entertained
ignoring the statutory dispensation.
[Emphasis supplied]
It is therefore, prudent for a Judge to not exercise discretion to allow
judicial interference beyond the procedure established under the
enactment. This power needs to be exercised in exceptional rarity, wherein
one party is left remediless under the statute or a clear „bad faith‟ shown by
one of the parties. This high standard set by this Court is in terms of the
legislative intention to make the arbitration fair and efficient.”
[20]
Viewed from a different perspective, the arbitral process is
strictly conditioned upon time limitation and modeled on the „principle of
unbreakability‟. This Court in P. Radha Bai v. P. Ashok Kumar, (2019) 13
SCC 445, observed:
36.3. Third, Section 34(3) reflects the principle of unbreakability. Dr Peter
Binder in International Commercial Arbitration and Conciliation in
UNCITRAL Model Law Jurisdictions, 2nd Edn., observed:
“An application for setting aside an award can only be made during the
three months following the date on which the party making the application
has received the award. Only if a party has made a request for correction or
interpretation of the award under Article 33 does the time-limit of three
months begin after the tribunal has disposed of the request. This exception
from the three-month time-limit was subject to criticism in the working
group due to fears that it could be used as a delaying tactics. However,
although “an unbreakable time-limit for applications for setting aside” was
sought as being desirable for the sake of “certainty and expediency” the
prevailing view was that the words ought to be retained “since they
presented the reasonable consequence of Article 33”.
[21]
In view of above observation and on the observation made by the
Apex Court, this Court is of the view that the writ petitioner at one point of
time claimed for Rs.27,46,96,122.55/- and further in the additional affidavit he
has claimed for Rs.16,87,99,319.20/-. When the learned senior counsel is
making his submission and different demand at different point of time, it is not
for this Court to decide these disputed claims.
[22]
It is also seen from Annexure-8 that the respondents have paid
certain amounts and the remaining amount will be paid subject to availability
of funds and finalization of time extensions/final deviation. Learned senior
counsel appearing for the petitioner has submitted that no amount have been
paid and with regard to the other claims in respect to the percentage i.e.
material component as 70% and labour component as 30% and it has been
decided that material component would be 75% and the labour component
would be 25%. All these disputed questions of fact are involved in this writ
petition concerning espoused civil rights of the petitioner, none of which are
admitted by the respondents.
[23]
In any case, the hierarchy in our legal framework mandates that a
legislative enactment cannot curtail a Constitutional right. There cannot be any
dispute that the power of the High Courts to issue directions, orders or writs
including writs in the nature of habeas corpus, certiorari, mandamus, quo
warranto and prohibition under Article-226 of the Constitution of India is a
basic feature of the Constitution and cannot be curtailed by parliamentary
legislation. It is settled law that when a statutory forum is created by law for
redressal of grievances, a writ petition should not be entertained ignoring the
statutory dispensation. Although, the petitioner vide his letter dated 27.07.2021
has sought for settlement of the dispute through alternative dispute redressal
mechanism and the said prayer is under consideration.
[24]
In view of above analysis, this Court is of the considered opinion
that no writ petition is maintainable to ascertain the civil rights and liabilities
of parties that too on the basis of disputed facts. Thus, it is not for this Court to
decide the matter when alternative mechanism are available to the petitioner
and in the factum of existence of the aforesaid alternative dispute redressal
mechanism in the contract itself, the present writ petition with disputed
question of facts, is not maintainable. Accordingly, the same stands dismissed.
As a sequel, miscellaneous applications pending, if any, shall stand
closed.
CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING)
A.Ghosh
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review