Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
SINGLE BENCH: BHASKAR RAJ PRADHAN, JUDGE.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
F.A.O No. 01 of 2017
M/s JAL Power Corporation Ltd.
Through Shri H.B Thapa
Deputy Manager (H.R.)
Near San Francis School,
South Sikkim
.… Appellant.
Versus
1. M/s R.S.M Infra Project,
Through Sunil Kumar Agarwal,
Opposite State Bank of India
2. Erung Tenzing Lepcha
S/o Late Kinchok Tashi Tshering Lepcha
R/o Rinchenpong (P.S. Kaluk), West Sikkim.
3. The Principal Secretary-cum-PCCF,
Department of Forest Environment & Wildlife Management,
Government of Sikkim, Gangtok, East Sikkim.
4. The District Collectorate,
Office of the Collectorate, Gyalshing, West Sikkim.
5. The Sub Divisional magistrate,
Soreng Sub Division, Soreng, West Sikkim.
6. The Sub Divisional Magistrate-1
West Sikkim, Gyalshing, West Sikkim.
.... Respondents.
Appeal under Order XLIII Rule 1 of the
Code of civil Procedure, 1908.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Mr. Jorgay Namka, Ms. Panila Theengh and Ms. Tashi D. Sherpa
Advocates for the Appellant.
Mr. Sudesh Joshi, Advocate for the Respondent No. 1 and 2.
Mr. S.K Chettri and Ms. Pollin Rai, Asst. Govt. Advocates for the
Respondent No. 3, 4, 5 and 6.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
F.A.O No. 01 of 2017
M/s Jal Power Corporation Ltd. v. M/s R.S.M. Infra Project & Ors.
ORALJUDGMENT
(05.10.2017)
Bhaskar Raj Pradhan, J.
Amicable
settlement
of
dispute
perhaps
is
the
highest
benchmark to gauge the evolution of any civilized society involved in
adversarial litigation.
2.
On the request made by the learned counsel for the parties on
19.06.2017 before this Court, the matter was referred for Mediation.
3.
A report has been submitted by the Sikkim State Legal Services
Authority
vide
a
communication
bearing
Reference
no.
1032/SLSA/02/MC dated 25.09.2017 stating that the case was
amicably settled before the Mediation Centre, East Sikkim at Gangtok
and also forwarding the case records along with the Deed of
Agreement dated 20.09.2017 entered between the parties to the FAO
no. 01/2017 pending before this Court. The Deed of Agreement has
been signed by all the parties to the litigation and in the presence of
two witnesses who have also put their signatures in attestation
thereof.
4. The Deed of Agreement so executed is reproduced herein below:“DEED OF AGREEMENT
This DEED OF AGREEMENT is made on this the 20th Day of
September, 2017 between M/s Jal Power Corporation Ltd., through its Deputy
Manager (HR), Shri H.B Thapa, S/O Shri P. Thapa, R/O Jorethang, South
Sikkim (the plaintiff, hereinafter referred to as the FIRST Party [which term
and expression shall unless repugnant to the content be deemed, mean and
include its successors, representative, assigns, administrators and executors]
of the FIRST PART.
AND
F.A.O No. 01 of 2017
M/s Jal Power Corporation Ltd. v. M/s R.S.M. Infra Project & Ors.
1. M/s RSM Infra Project, through Sunil Kumar Agarwal having its office
opposite SBI, Jorethang Bazar, South Sikkim, (Second Party),
2. Shri Erung Tenzing Lepcha, S/o Late Kinchok Tshering Lepcha, R/o
Rinchenpong (P.S Kaluk), West Sikkim, (Third Party),
3. The Principal Secretary-cum-PCCF, Department of Forests, Env. & Wildlife
Management, Government of Sikkim, Gangtok, (Fourth Party),
4. The District Collectorate, Office of the District Collectorate, Gyalshing, West
Sikkim, (fifth Party),
5. The Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Soreng Sub-Division, Soreng, West Sikkim
(Sixth Party),
6. The Sub Divisional Magistrate-1, West District, Gyalshing, West Sikkim
(Seventh Party).
AND
WHEREAS, the suit land bearing Plot No. 229 and 231 as per the cadastral
survey record of 1950-52 and corresponding plot no. 323 and 326 as per the
cadastral survey record of 1978-80 is situated at Zeel Revenue Block,
Rinchenpong, West Sikkim.
AND
WHEREAS, the First Party has instituted the Title Suit bearing T.S No. 01 of
2017 against the Second Party and Others before the Court of Ld. District
Judge, West Sikkim at Gyalshing for Declaration, Recovery of Possession,
Mandatory Injunction and other consequential reliefs under Order VII Rule 1 &
3 of the CPC, 1908
AND
WHEREAS, the First Party being aggrieved by the Order rejecting its
injunction application filed an Appeal/FAO before the Hon‟ble High Court of
Sikkim at Gangtok and the same is pending.
AND
WHEREAS, during the pendency of the aforesaid case, a joint Inspection of
the suit land situated at Zeel Revenue Block, West Sikkim was conducted on
21.06.2017 in presence of the following persons/Officers.
(a) Revenue Inspector, Sub Division Office, Soreng, West Sikkim.
(b) ACF, Block Officer and Assistant Surveyor, Survey and Demarcation
Division, Forest, Env. & Wildlife Management Department.
(c) V.L.O, Rinchenpong Circle, Soreng Sub Division.
(d) Incharge, RSM Infra Project.
(e) The Deputy Manager, (HR), M/s Jal Power Corporation Ltd.
(f) Shri Erung Tenzing Lepcha, S/o Late Kinchok Tashi Tshering Lepcha
R/o Rinchenpong, West Sikkim.
(g) B.O (T) Legship, Forest, Env. & Wildlife Management Department.
F.A.O No. 01 of 2017
M/s Jal Power Corporation Ltd. v. M/s R.S.M. Infra Project & Ors.
That during the said joint inspection the following facts were observed which
are as follows;
1. As per the land records of 1950-52 the crusher plant constructed by the
M/s RSM Infra Project falls within the part of plot no. 229 which is „Sarkar
Khasmal‟ and part of plot no. 231 which is „Khasmal Vir‟.
2. As per the land records of 1950-52 the crusher plant constructed by JPCL
falls within the part of plot no. 229 which is „Sarkar Khasmal‟ and part of the
plant falls within „River Reserve‟.
3. Further, the joint Inspection Report which was conducted on 14.06.2017
remains same which was based on the land records of 1978-80.
WHEREAS, during the course of hearing of the FAO, as suggestion for the
matter to be referred to a Mediator came out from the parties and with the
general consensus of the parties the Hon‟ble High Court was pleased to
forward the same to the Mediation Centre, East Sikkim at Gangtok for
amicable settlement.
AND
WHEREAS, the amicable talk and deliberations took place in the Mediation
Centre at Gangtok and gradual progress towards the amciable settlement of
the matter was made.
AND
WHEREAS, the parties as well as their counsel including the Forest
Department officials made efforts and endeavor to settle the matter amicably.
Private caucused and long and through deliberation were made with both the
parties. Ultimately, the parties agreed to settle the matter amicably in the
terms and conditions as mentioned herein below.
NOW IT IS HEREBY AGREED BY AND BETWEEN THE PARTIES HERETO:1. That Third Party shall allow all the parties, free ingress and egress to reach
their respective crusher plants and access to the forest land at any time.
2. That the First Party and the Second Party shall take necessary permissions
from the Fourth Party for execution of their respective project works even
for temporary use, as required under the relevant Legislations.
3. That the Third Party, Erung Tenzing Lepcha have agreed to lease out
whatever portion of his ancestral land required by the First Party and the
Second Party at the existing rate.
4. That the First Party and the Second Party shall not disturb and harass each
other during the execution of their respective project works.
F.A.O No. 01 of 2017
M/s Jal Power Corporation Ltd. v. M/s R.S.M. Infra Project & Ors.
5. That after the execution of this Deed of Agreement the First Party
undertakes all necessary steps for disposal of the matter before the
Hon‟ble High Court and the Ld. Trial Court.
6. All disagreements and disputes arise with respect to the interpretation of
the agreement or the agreements which cannot be mutually decided upon,
shall be referred to and decided by the appropriate Court of law (both Civil
& Criminal) having jurisdiction within the State of Sikkim.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have set and subscribed their
respective hands and seals on the day, months and year first herein above
written.
Witnesses;
Sd/1. Rinzing Bhutia.
Rincenpong
First Party.
Sd/2. Naren Pradhan.
Gangtok
Second Party. Sd/-
Sd/-
Third Party. Sd/Fourth Party. Sd/Fifth Party. Sd/Sixth Party. Sd/Seventh Party. Sd/-”
5.
The Deed of Agreement dated 20.09.2017 is accordingly made a
part of present judgment and the present appeal disposed of in terms
thereof.
6.
The learned Counsel for the parties submits that in view of the
compromise and settlement deed nothing survives in the Title Suit no.
01/2017 pending before the Court of learned District Judge, West
Sikkim. The said Title Suit is also therefore, settled in terms of the
Deed of Agreement and disposed of.
7.
A copy of this judgment may be transmitted to the Court of
learned District Judge, West Sikkim for necessary compliance. A
F.A.O No. 01 of 2017
M/s Jal Power Corporation Ltd. v. M/s R.S.M. Infra Project & Ors.
compromise decree in terms of above settlement may be drawn
accordingly.
8.
It is indeed heartening to note that the adversarial parties with
the active involvement of their learned counsels have arrived at an
amicable settlement of their disputes.
9.
This Court records its appreciation of the positiveness of the
parties hereto to settle the matter amicably, the efforts of the learned
Counsels for the respective parties to assist in the settlement arrived
at and of the Mediator, Ms. Yangchen D. Gyatso, Advocate who has
successfully facilitated the parties to reach a common agreement for
the resolution of their disputes.
10.
The parties to bear their own costs.
Sd/(Bhaskar Raj Pradhan)
Judge
05-10-2017
Avi/
Approved for reporting: yes.
Internet: yes.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review