Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
Case: LPA No.167/2026 in
WP(C) No.2388/2026
CM Nos.5687/2026 &
5688/2026
Reserved on: 01.09.2026
Pronounced on:17.09.2026
Uploaded on:17.09.2026
Whether the operative part or
Full judgment is pronounced
M/S Jai Sukrala Trading Co.,
Through its Prop. Sh. Ishan Gupta, 38 years,
S/o Sh. Pawan Gupta,
R/o H.No.75/76, Sarwal Colony, Jammu
…..Appellant
Mr. Vikram Sharma, Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Sachin Dev Singh, Advocate.
1. Union of India through the
Secretary, Ministry of Defence,
South Block, New Delhi.
2. The Commanding Officer,
59 Engineer Regiment,
PIN-914059,
C/o 56 APO, Rajouri (J&K).
3. General Officer Commanding
(GOC), 25 Infantry Division/Chief
Engineer, Headquarter 25
Infantry Division, C/o 56 APO.
4. Engineer Planning Officer for CO,
59 Engineer Regiment,
PIN 914059, C/o 56 APO.
.…. Respondents
Mr. Vishal Sharma, DSGI with
Mr. Karan Sharma, CGSC and
Capt. Varun Bajiya OIC, Legal Cell HQ16
Corps.
LPA No. 167/2026
CORAM:
HON’BLE MRS.JUSTICE SINDHU SHARMA, JUDGE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SHAHZAD AZEEM, JUDGE
(JUDGMENT)
PER-SHAHZAD AZEEM, J
1.
This intra-court appeal is directed against the order dated
13 August 2026 passed by the learned Single Judge [the writ
Court] in WP(C) No.2388/2026 titled “Jai Sukrala Trading Co.
Vs. Union of India and others”, whereby the interim order dated
3 August 2026 was modified and respondents were left at liberty to
proceed with and finalise the bidding process and all further action
OFHIGH
JAMMU COURT
& KASHMIR
including finalisation, was
keptLADAKH
subject to the final outcome of the
AND
writ petition, with a further direction that the successful bidder
shall not claim equity by reason of action taken pursuant to that
order.
FACTS
2.
The
proprietorship
facts
in
concern
brief
are
that
the
appellant
engaged
in
supply
of
is
a
fencing,
electrification, solar and allied structural stores/works to defence
Army Units functioning under 25-Infantry Division/16 Corps. It
claims to have executed similar works of substantial value with the
respondents.
LPA No.167/2026
3.
On 17 June 2026, respondent No.2- the Commanding
Officer, 59 Engineer Regiment, issued a Request For Proposal
(RFP) No.6690/RFP/26-27/04/OPW and floated nine (9) parallel
open tender enquiries on the defence e-procurement portal for
“Realignment of IAIOS/AOIS at multiple stretches including
Naushera, Jhangar, Shiv Shakti to Cheetah; and eight (8)
connected tenders. Accordingly, twelve (12) bidders including the
appellant, participated.
4.
The original bid submission and bid opening date was 8
HIGH COURT
JAMMU
& KASHMIR
July 2026. On OF
7 July
2026, a corrigendum
dated 6 July 2026 was
AND LADAKH
uploaded. It altered original conditions and, inter-alia, mandated
physical submission of sample of the “Solar Cube Generator-cumInvertor” at the Technical Evaluation Committee (TEC) stage,
failing which the bid was liable to rejection. The last date was
thereafter extended.
5.
The appellant’s case is that it cured the short falls within
the extended period, reported on the scheduled date of sample
evaluation/demonstration with representations of the OEM; that
no TEC was present that day; that no other bidder produced a
sample in its presence; and that the Commanding Officer
examined its sample.
LPA No.167/2026
6.
On 29 July 2026 the appellant was declared as “rejected-
technical” in all nine (9) tenders, on grounds of non-submission of
BIS/ISO certificates, non- submission of the sample in time, nonconformity of the sample, and failure to establish that the offered
product did not infringe a patent of a similar product.
7.
On 30 July 2026 the appellant made a representation
alleging absence of the TEC on 23 July 2026; formulaic clearance
of eight (8) competing bidders; and that one cleared bidder, M/s
Ace
Engineering
Infratech
India,
faced
an
FIR/chargesheet
HIGH COURT
JAMMU
& supply
KASHMIR
concerning an OF
alleged
forged army
order qua 107 Engineer
Regiment.
8.
Aggrieved,
AND LADAKH
the
appellant
filed
WP(C) No.2388/2026
seeking quashing of the rejection order dated 29 July 2026 and
the corrigendum dated 6 July 2026 and also the appellant sought
direction for re-evaluation before a duly constituted TEC, opening
of
its
financial
bid,
and
an
interim
restraint
against
opening/finalising the financial bids.
9.
By order dated 3 August 2026 the writ Court directed
that opening of the financial bid be deferred till the next date of
hearing.
LPA No.167/2026
10.
The respondents filed objections and inter alia, informed
the writ Court that the financial bids had already been opened on
29 July 2026; that rate analysis was underway; and that in the FY
2024-25 the appellant had emerged as L-1 but had withdrawn its
offer unilaterally, causing operational delay and administrative
difficulty.
11.
By the order dated 13 August 2026 the writ Court
modified the interim order dated 3 August 2026 permitted the
respondents to proceed with and finalise the bidding process
HIGH COURT
JAMMU
& KASHMIR
subject to the OF
outcome
of the writ
petition and directed that the
AND LADAKH
successful bidder shall not claim equity.
SUBMISSIONS
12.
The appellant has challenged the ad-interim order dated
13 August 2026, inter alia on the ground that he was duly
qualified; that its documents and averments remained unrebutted;
and that the writ Court returned no prima facie finding on
eligibility and yet permitted finalisation. It was further submitted
that no finding was returned on the alleged arbitrariness in
clearing the other eight (8) bidders, though it was specifically
pleaded that they resorted to a pooled sample in breach of the
Defence Procurement Manual (DPM)-2025; that those eight (8)
LPA No.167/2026
bidders did not independently possess BIS certification; that two
cleared bidders are husband and wife; and that one cleared bidder
faces a charge-sheet. The corrigendum issued two days before the
original last date, altering specifications, was described as tailoredmade and vitiated by malafides. On that footing, it was contended
that the order dated 13 August 2026 takes away the protection
granted on 03 August 2026, as a result it affects the valuable right
to compete, therefore, said order is a “Judgment” under Clause 12,
and is, therefore, appealable.
13.
HIGH COURT
OF JAMMU
KASHMIR
Ex-adverso,
Mr. Vishal &
Sharma,
learned DSGI submits
AND LADAKH
that the financial bids had already been opened on 29 July 2026
and that the appellant, though was declared L-1 in 2024-25, but
had withdrawn unilaterally, delaying operational works. Learned
DSGI has also produced the record and canvassed that the
technical bid was evaluated and found not to conform to the
tender conditions; that clause 5.12 of chapter 5 of DPM-2025
permits sample-evaluation criteria in justified cases with approval
of the Competent Financial Authority (CFA) and that same was
observed; that the sample was not submitted within the time fixed
as 0900 hours on 23 July 2026; and that mandatory parameters
LPA No.167/2026
and sample standards were not met, for which reason the bid was
declared technically non-responsive.
ANALYSIS
14.
We have heard learned counsels for the parties and
perused the record.
15.
The writ Court noticed that the appellant disputed the
opening of financial bids before 3 August 2026 and relied on the
portal status “under process”, and that the issues required
HIGH COURT
consideration OF
after JAMMU
completion &
of KASHMIR
pleadings. The challenge to
AND LADAKH
technical evaluation was held to be serious, but strongly
controverted, and incapable of conclusive determination at the
interlocutory stage. The writ Court further held that the work
pertain to re-alignment of IAIOS(S&C) on the Naushera-Jhanger
border, pursuant to directions for operational readiness after “OP
Sindoor”, in a sensitive sector in the Area of Responsibility (AOR)
of 25 Infantry Division. The writ Court also observed that 22.15
km had been executed in the preceding year and a further 6.20 km
in the Naushera sector along the LOC was planned for the current
year. The defence procurement for active operational requirements,
the writ Court held, cannot be stalled merely to accommodate a
LPA No.167/2026
vendor’s commercial interest, particularly where interference may
compromise proscribed technical or operational requirements.
16.
On the question of opportunity, the writ Court recorded
that technical opening was on 8 July 2026, the period was
extended to 15 July 2026, and the appellant participated in
sample production/evaluation. The respondents’ case that the
sample was late and non-compliant was noticed. Lateness was
held to be a disputed question to be decided on completion of the
pleadings and the record. The appellant, as on date, stands
HIGH COURT
OF JAMMU
& KASHMIR
technically dis-qualified
and whether
that disqualification is the
AND LADAKH
product of an unfair process was expressly left open.
17.
The observation which weighed with the writ Court is
that whether the appellant met the technical threshold is a matter
for the writ petition on merits; that, at the interlocutory stage, the
material indicated that opening of financial bids had already
commenced and, according to the respondents, stood completed
before 3 August 2026; and that portal status “under process” was
not sufficient to hold that the bids had not been opened. Stalling
the entire tender merely because issues warranting further
consideration had been raised, it was held, may seriously
prejudice public interest and impede operationally urgent works.
LPA No.167/2026
The principal issue, whether disqualification accorded with the
tender and the law, or whether the process was arbitrary, nontransparent or mala fide, requires adjudication after completion of
pleadings and production of the record. At the interlocutory stage,
the competing equities were held to yield to the larger public and
operational interest in timely execution.
18.
It is not in dispute that the writ petition remains pending.
The writ Court has neither upheld nor quashed the rejection order
dated 29 July 2026 or the corrigendum dated 6 July 2026. It has
not
finally
HIGH COURT
OF JAMMU
& KASHMIR
declared
the appellant
technically
qualified
or
AND LADAKH
disqualified. It has not determined cartelisation, tailored made
specification, absence of the TEC, or alleged discrimination. On the
contrary, it has expressly held that those allegations cannot be
conclusively determined at the interlocutory stage, that technical
eligibility is an issue in the writ petition, and that the legality of
the process remains open. All that has been done is modification of
the earlier deferment order dated 3 August 2026, with finalisation
kept subject to the writ and with a further express rider that the
successful bidder shall not claim any equity.
19.
What is discernible, therefore, is that the writ Court order
under challenge is a classic example of balancing of equities and is
LPA No.167/2026
not a disposal of the application for interim relief in the sense of a
final determination of rights.
20.
The contention of the appellant that modification of the
order dated 3 August 2026 amounts in substance and effect, to a
final and irreversible disposal of the interim application cannot be
accepted.
being
An interim order merges in, and remains capable of
moulded
by,
later
orders
in
the
same
proceeding.
Modification of an interim restraint is an ordinary incident of
interlocutory jurisdiction. If every such modification were a
HIGH COURT
OF JAMMU
KASHMIR
“judgement” under
clause 12 of&
the
Letters Patent, the Division
AND LADAKH
Bench would become a court of first appeal against every
interlocutory direction of the writ Court. The writ Court has shut
out the argument of fait accompli. Finalization of the tender is
expressly kept subject to the outcome of the writ petition. The
successful bidder is restrained from claiming equity. Those twin
conditions are the conventional device by which the Courts refuse
to stall public works without extinguishing the petition.
21.
An order that keeps the petition alive, keeps every
substantial issue open, and only refuses to halt an ongoing tender,
does not determine vital rights with finality. An order which
recognizes that the stage sought to be frozen has already been
LPA No.167/2026
crossed, and therefore declines to keep the process in suspended
animation,
does
not
decide
the
merits
of
the
technical
qualification. It, therefore, decides only that the public work will
not be stalled. The impugned order cannot be fitted into the
category of an intermediary judgment.
22.
In any event, appellate interference with grant, refusal or
modification of interim relief is confined to perversity, disregard of
settled
principles,
reliance
on
irrelevant
considerations,
or
omission of considerations that were legally mandatory. Another
HIGH COURT
JAMMU
KASHMIR
possible view OF
is, by
itself, no&ground
for interference. That
AND LADAKH
proposition is well settled, and this judgment need not to be
burdened with a plethora of authorities on the subject. The prayer
is not for preservation of the lis, in substance, it is the final relief
sought in the writ petition to treat the appellant as technically
qualified. Grant of that relief in a Letters Patent Appeal would preempt the writ petition, usurp the TEC, and rest on the conjecture
that the appellant would emerge as L-1. The writ Court rightly
declined to act on that conjecture.
23.
Clause 12 of the Letters Patent permits an Intra-Court
appeal against a “judgment” of a Single Judge. The expression
“Judgment” carries a concept of finality. The judgment may be
LPA No.167/2026
final, preliminary or intermediary, but it must determine some
right or issue between the parties. Routine or purely interlocutory
orders which do not determine any such right or issue are not
judgments. The law is settled in ‘Shah Babulal Khimji vs.
Jayaben D. Kania and anr;’ (1981) 4 Supreme Court Cases 8,
and Midnapore Peoples’ Coop Bank Ltd. Vs. Chunilal Nanda
and ors; (2006) 5 Supreme Court Cases 399.
24.
Tested on that principle, the grievance that the writ Court
did not return point-wise findings on each certificate and each
competing
HIGH COURT
OF JAMMU
KASHMIR
bidders’
document &mistakes
the nature
of
an
AND LADAKH
interlocutory order. It is to be kept in mind that the writ Court was
not deciding the writ petition finally, rather it was deciding
whether to keep a defence tender frozen. Having held that the
issues were debatable, controverted and reserved for the main
petition, it was not required to write a trial judgment on the
applications, CM No.5301/2026 and 5514/2026. Absence of
issue-wise findings at that stage is not a vitiating infirmity.
25.
Even otherwise, the judicial review of tenders is a review
of the decision making process, not a re-trial of the TEC. That
principle admits of no dilution in a Letters Patent Appeal. The
Court examines the process, not the soundness of technical
LPA No.167/2026
choice. The author of the tender is the best interpreter of its terms.
If two views are possible, the owners’ view prevails. Therefore,
technical
evaluation
and
comparison
by
the
Court
is
impermissible. The Court does not sit in appeal over the Technical
Evaluation Committee. In contracts involving technical issues,
restraint is greater.
26.
Private commercial interest of a bidder must yield to the
public interest. The RFP is not a routine civil store purchase. It is
“realignment of IAIOS/AIOS on stretches in the Naushera-Jhanger
OFHIGH
JAMMU COURT
& KASHMIR
sector, in the Area of Responsibility of 25 Infantry Division,
AND LADAKH
pursuant to directions issued for operational readiness after “OP
Sindoor”. Defence procurement of operational works on the LOC is
not to be halted on a vendor’s claim that it would have been L-1, if
admitted to the financial bid.
27.
Without
prejudice
to
the
conclusion
of
the
maintainability, the learned Single Judge applied the correct
principles of interlocutory restraint in tender matters, gave due
weight
to
the
operational
character
of
the
IAIOS/AIOS
“Realignment on the LOC” and preserved the appellant’s remedies
in the writ petition, therefore, no interference on merits is called
for.
LPA No.167/2026
CONCLUSION
28.
As a necessary corollary to the above discussion, it is
held that the order dated 13 August 2026 is not a “judgment”
within the meaning of clause 12 of the Letters Patent. It is a
discretionary modification of an interim direction in a pending writ
petition, with the lis kept alive and equity expressly balanced. The
Letters Patent Appeal is, therefore, not maintainable and is
dismissed.
29.
It is made clear that this Court expressed no opinion on
OFHIGH
JAMMU COURT
& KASHMIR
the merits of the writ petition.
contentions of the parties therein
AND All
LADAKH
are kept open.
30.
The record produced by the learned DSGI be returned
forthwith.
31.
All the connected applications also stand disposed of.
(SHAHZAD AZEEM)
JUDGE
(SINDHU SHARMA)
JUDGE
JAMMU
17.09.2026
Surinder
Whether order is speaking:
Whether order is reportable:
Surinder Kumar
2026.09.17 17:58
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
LPA No.167/2026
Yes/No
Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review