Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
RFA No. 03 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. M/s Dreambox Marketing (A) Pvt. Ltd. & Anr.
RFA No. 06 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 128 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
RFA No. 07 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 156 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
RFA No.3 of 2017
M/s. Himalaya Distilleries Ltd.,
Majitar, Rangpo,
Sikkim.
...
APPELLANT
...
RESPONDENTS
...
APPELLANT
...
RESPONDENTS
versus
1.
M/s. Dreambox Marketing(A) Pvt. Ltd.,
Techno Plaza Commercial Complex,
Motilal Nehru Road, Panbazar,
Guwahati-781001
Assam.
2.
Mr. Bonoraj Choudhary,
Managing Director,
M/s. Dreambox Marketing(A) Pvt. Ltd.,
Techno Plaza Commercial Complex,
Motilal Nehru Road, Panbazar,
Guwahati-781001
Assam.
Also at:
Mr. Bonoraj Choudhary,
Latika Bhawan,
Buddha Mandir,
Abhoy Nagar,
Agartala-799005
Tripura.
RFA No.6 of 2017
M/s. Himalaya Distilleries Ltd.,
Majitar, Rangpo,
Sikkim.
versus
1.
The Commandant,
128 Bn. C.R.P.F.,
Spun Silk Mill, Jagiroad,
Morigaon, Assam.
2.
M/s. Dreambox Marketing(A) Pvt. Ltd.,
Through its Managing Director,
Shri Bonoraj Choudhary,
9, Techno Plaza, Motilal Nehru Road,
Panbazar,
Guwahati-781001, Assam.
RFA No. 03 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. M/s Dreambox Marketing (A) Pvt. Ltd. & Anr.
RFA No. 06 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 128 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
RFA No. 07 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 156 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
RFA No.7 of 2017
M/s. Himalaya Distilleries Ltd.,
Majitar, Rangpo,
Sikkim.
versus
1.
The Commandant,
156 Bn., C.R.P.F.,
Kukumare, Dhaligaon,
Bongaigaon, Assam.
2.
M/s. Dreambox Marketing(A) Pvt. Ltd.,
Through its Managing Director,
Shri Bonoraj Choudhary,
9, Techno Plaza, Motilal Nehru Road,
Panbazar,
Guwahati-781001, Assam.
...
APPELLANT
...
RESPONDENTS
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARUP KUMAR GOSWAMI, C.J.
For Appellant
: Mr. Udai P. Sharma, Advocate.
For Respondents
: Mr. A. Moulik, Senior Advocate with Ms. K. D. Bhutia,
Advocate.
Date of Hearing
: 21.11.2020 and 23.11.2020
Date of Judgment : 30.11.2020
JUDGMENT
RFA No.3 of 2017, RFA No.6 of 2017 and RFA No.7 of 2017, on being
listed together, were heard and are being disposed of by this judgment. The
appellants are same in all the appeals. In RFA No.3 of 2017, defendants are
M/s. Dreambox Marketing(A) Pvt. Ltd. and Bonoraj Choudhury, who is the
Managing Director of the defendant no.1. In RFA No.6 of 2017 and RFA No.7
of 2017, the defendant no.1 is the Commandant, 128 Bn., C.R.P.F. and the
Commandant, 156 Bn., C.R.P.F., respectively. Defendant no.2 in both the
aforesaid appeals is M/s. Dreambox Marketing(A) Pvt. Ltd., represented by
its Managing Director.
RFA No. 03 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. M/s Dreambox Marketing (A) Pvt. Ltd. & Anr.
RFA No. 06 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 128 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
RFA No. 07 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 156 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
2.
Mr. Udai P. Sharma, learned Counsel appears for the appellant in all
the three appeals while Mr. A. Moulik, learned Senior Counsel appears for
defendants in RFA No.3 of 2017 and for defendant no.2 in RFA No.6 of 2017
and RFA No.7 of 2017. Mr. Karma Thinlay, learned Central Government
Counsel appears for defendant no.1 in RFA No.6 of 2017 and RFA No.7 of
2017.
3.
RFA No. 03 of 2017 is preferred against the judgment and decree
dated 30.05.2017 passed by the learned District Judge, East Sikkim at
Gangtok in Money Suit No. 810 of 2013. RFA No. 06 of 2017 is preferred
against a judgment and decree dated 31.05.2017 passed by the learned
District Judge, Special Division-II, Sikkim at Gangtok, in Money Suit No. 18
of 2015. RFA No. 07 of 2017 is preferred against a judgment and decree
dated 31.05.2017 passed by the learned District Judge, Special Division-II,
Sikkim at Gangtok, in Money Suit No. 19 of 2015. The appellant is the
plaintiff in respect of the three suits out of which the present appeals arise.
4.
Learned Counsel for the parties are ad idem that decision in RFA No.3
of 2017 will have substantial bearing in the outcome of RFA No.6 of 2017
and RFA No.7 of 2017. Mr. Sharma has submitted that IA No.4of 2019 for
amendment of Memorandum of Appeal to add additional grounds is pending.
Mr.Moulik submits that it being a first appeal, the appellant may urge the
grounds mentioned in the Memorandum of Appeal without there being any
amendment of the Memorandum of Appeal.
5.
Noting the above preliminary submissions, I will presently advert to
the case of the plaintiff/appellant in RFA No.3 of 2017.
RFA No. 03 of 2017
6.
The plaintiff is a private limited company registered under the
Registration of Company Act, Sikkim, 1961 and is engaged in the business of
RFA No. 03 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. M/s Dreambox Marketing (A) Pvt. Ltd. & Anr.
RFA No. 06 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 128 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
RFA No. 07 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 156 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
manufacturing and distribution of Indian Made Foreign Liquor (IMFL).
Defendant No.1 is a company registered under the Companies Act, 1956.
The defendants on 03.03.2007 had entered into a Memorandum of
Understanding (MoU) with the plaintiff for marketing of IMFL products of the
plaintiff to para-military forces in North-East India and civil-bonded
warehouses. The MoU was initially for two years with an option to renew the
same for a further period of two years. The MoU, though renewed and
validated till 31.03.2010, was not fully acted upon. Though Clause 2 of the
MoU stipulated that payment is to be made by defendant no.1 to the plaintiff
through Letter of Credit (L/C) after 70 days from the date of dispatch of
goods on a consignment to consignment basis, however, as the defendants
expressed difficulty, a different arrangement was worked out for smooth
operation of the business whereby it was decided that defendants would
deposit an ad hoc minimum amount by way of 60 days’ post-dated cheques
drawn in favour of the plaintiff. The defendants, after procuring supply
orders from the para-military forces, place supply orders to the plaintiff and
thereafter, the plaintiff directly supplies the goods to the para-military forces
along with the invoice which contains terms and conditions on its overleaf.
7.
It is the case of the plaintiff that during Financial Year 2008-2009,
plaintiff supplied goods valued at Rs.1,70,42,754/- to the para-military
forces as per supply orders placed by the defendants and the amount was
collected by the defendants. However, defendants made payment of only
Rs.96,19,169/- in favour of the plaintiff. Similarly, for the Financial Year
2009-2010,
total
Rs.2,51,85,763/-,out
supply
of
made
which
by
the
defendants
plaintiff
paid
was
only
a
valued
at
sum
of
Rs.1,38,20,953/. For the Financial Year 2010-2011, out of total goods
valued
at
Rs.1,68,73,496/-,
defendants
made
payment
of
only
Rs.86,68,166/-. Thus, for the above three financial years, while the total
RFA No. 03 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. M/s Dreambox Marketing (A) Pvt. Ltd. & Anr.
RFA No. 06 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 128 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
RFA No. 07 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 156 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
goods supplied was valued at Rs.5,91,01,952/-, the defendants made
payment of only Rs.3,21,08,288/- in favour of the plaintiff, thus, withholding
a sum of Rs.2,69,98,834/-. The defendants, after depositing 60 days’ postdated cheques for a minimum agreed amount for each invoice, was required
to render account for the difference between the quoted price and the postdated cheque and to raise Debit Note against actual expenses and if the
same was found to be satisfactory, the plaintiff was required to issue Credit
Note. However, the defendants, after collecting payment from the paramilitary forces, went on postponing rendering of account and raising Debit
Note for actual expenses incurred, and had failed to remit the balance
amount to the plaintiff and to honor the post-dated cheques issued by it.
8.
MoU.
For such failure, the plaintiff had no other option but to terminate the
However,
in
order
to
maintain
continuity,
before
a
fresh
MoU/Agreement was signed, they had verbally agreed to continue the
business on new terms which included payment to be made directly to the
plaintiff by the para-military units. After repeated requests, the defendants
finally sent the Statement of Account, invoice by invoice. However,
Statement of Account was not furnished for the Financial Year 2008-2009,
which means that defendants owe a sum of Rs.73,23,594/- to the plaintiff.
9.
The Debit Notes submitted by the defendants consisted of expenses
incurred by the defendants under the heads of (i) transportation charges, (ii)
breakages & shortages charges, (iii) marketing & selling expenses, (iv)
travelling & boarding expenses, (v) interest of money involvement on credit
basis, (vi) margin of Dreambox Marketing, (vii) expenses for processing of
import permit and (viii) expenses for processing tender. It is stated that out
of the same, as per mutual agreement, the defendants were entitled to only
margin money appearing at Sl. No.(vi). It is stated that Sl. No. (iii), Sl. No.
(iv) ,Sl. No. (vii) and Sl. No. (viii ) are to be borne by the defendants from
RFA No. 03 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. M/s Dreambox Marketing (A) Pvt. Ltd. & Anr.
RFA No. 06 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 128 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
RFA No. 07 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 156 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
their margin money. In connection with Sl.No.(i) and Sl. No. (ii), Books of
Account along with Money Receipts and Vouchers were demanded. With
regard to Sl.No.(v), it is stated that the plaintiff realized its payment only
after the defendants had collected money from para-military forces. It is
further pleaded that the defendants failed to furnish the Money Receipts
despite requests made by the plaintiff.
10.
The plaintiff had agreed to an amount of Rs.11,76,040/- for the
Financial Year 2009-2010 and Rs.5,69,400/- for the Financial Year 20102011 towards “Margin of Dreambox Marketing” as well as the claim made by
the defendants for Rs.50,72,740/- towards transportation charges, breakage
& shortage charges, import permit processing charges and tender processing
charges for which Money Receipts were sent. Pending rendering of accounts,
the defendants had agreed to increase initial payments by Rs.30/- per case
containing 12 bottles and the defendants had started paying on the agreed
increased rate since January, 2011, but had not made payment of additional
Rs.30/- per case for shipments prior to January, 2011.
11.
It must be noted at this stage that collection of payment from
defendant no.1, as stated in paragraphs 5 and 13 of the plaint, did not arise
as defendant no.1 is the entity with whom the MoU was executed. It appears
that plaintiff was actually referring to collection of payment from the paramilitary forces.
12.
In an attempt to make an amicable settlement, a meeting was
arranged in Delhi on 31.03.2011 where defendants were represented by
Somraj Choudhury. In the meeting, it was mutually agreed upon and
decided that the plaintiff would instruct the para-military forces to make
payment of goods directly to the plaintiff. Defendants, however, failed to
adhere to the agreement and had also failed to honor four post-dated
RFA No. 03 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. M/s Dreambox Marketing (A) Pvt. Ltd. & Anr.
RFA No. 06 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 128 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
RFA No. 07 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 156 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
cheques that it had drawn in favour of the plaintiff for a total sum of
Rs.22,41,372/-. It is stated that even accepting all the Debit Notes sent by
the defendants on their face value and allowing the expenses under various
heads as sent by the defendants, for the three financial years, the
defendants owed a minimum amount of Rs.1,51,67,244/-.
13.
Following prayers were made in the suit:“(i)
direct the defendants to furnish all the actual money receipts for
verification for the financial years 2009-2010 and 2010-2011 and also
furnish debit notes with supporting money receipts for the financial
year 2008-2009 for verification to be carried out by this Hon’ble Court;
(ii)
to determine the amount due and payable by the Defendant in
favour of the plaintiff;
(iii)
pass a decree in favour of the plaintiff and against the
defendants for the amount to be determined by this Hon’ble Court
along with interest @ 12% from the date of invoice till the same are
realized;
(iv)
pass a decree for recovery of the above said sum along with
interest;
(v)
award the cost of suit to the plaintiff and against the defendants;
(vi)
pass a decree for such other relief or reliefs to which the plaintiff
may be entitled to under the law and this Hon’ble Court may deem fit
and necessary.”
14.
The defendants filed a written statement along with a counter-claim. It
is stated that the MoU was a business tie-up with the plaintiff. As the
defendants were already engaged in the business of supplying IMFL to
various para-military forces and civil-bonded warehouses, the plaintiff had
approached the defendants with a request to deal with its products so that
business of the plaintiff increases. It is denied that defendants were
RFA No. 03 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. M/s Dreambox Marketing (A) Pvt. Ltd. & Anr.
RFA No. 06 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 128 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
RFA No. 07 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 156 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
authorized/ appointed to procure orders for the products of the plaintiff and
it is stated that they were engaged by the plaintiff by giving full authority to
submit tender in the name of defendant no.1, which is evidenced under the
MoU and further confirmed by two letters dated 26.04.2007, by which, terms
of the MoU dated 03.03.2007 were further clarified. The MoU dated
03.03.2007 was renewed up to 31.03.2010. A fresh MoU was entered into
between the plaintiff and the defendants on 19.03.2010 for a period of two
years commencing from 01.04.2010 up to 31.03.2012, but the plaintiff with
ulterior motive had not even whispered about the same and had suppressed
the existence of the said MoU dated 19.03.2010. It is denied that the
defendants were appointed as an agent of the plaintiff and that MoU was not
actually acted upon though validated till 31.03.2010. It is pleaded that in
terms of MoU dated 03.03.2007 and MoU dated 19.03.2010, the defendants
are entitled to collect payment from the para-military forces against supply
orders procured from para-military forces by participating in the tender
process in its own name and at their quoted rates. The defendants procured
import permit from the Excise Department of the Government of Assam and
dispatched the same to the plaintiff for onward dispatch of goods to various
para-military units and civil-bonded warehouses because it is the convention
that the manufacturer dispatches goods to the consignee directly.
15.
It is pleaded that the plaintiff had received entire dues for the goods
supplied for the Financial Years 2008-2009, 2009-2010 and 2010-2011. It is
also stated that during the relevant financial years, the plaintiff had supplied
goods amounting to Rs.5,88,00,584/- and not Rs.5,91,01,922/- and the plea
taken by the plaintiff that the defendants had withheld a sum of
Rs.2,69,98,834/- is a false statement. It is stated that the defendants had to
resort to stop payment of post-dated cheques as the plaintiff, by violating
the MoU dated 19.03.2010, sought to receive payment directly from the
RFA No. 03 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. M/s Dreambox Marketing (A) Pvt. Ltd. & Anr.
RFA No. 06 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 128 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
RFA No. 07 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 156 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
para-military units. It is pleaded that the balance amount remaining after
adjusting the ex-distillery price (for short, EDP)/ex-factory price (for short,
EFP) of the plaintiff is the margin of the defendant company. The defendants
being marketing associate of the plaintiff as per the MoU, there is no
question of rendering accounts to the plaintiff. It is specifically stated that
the defendants never sent any Statement of Account to the plaintiff, invoice
by invoice, or otherwise and that only Debit Notes were issued by the
defendants showing the difference between EFP/EDP + Export Fee + Central
Sales Tax and the billing amount to the para-military forces for the purpose
of maintaining the accounts. Defendants bear transportation charges and the
defendants pay to the plaintiff by cheque the EFP/EDP + Export Fee +
Central Sales Tax, to which amount only, the plaintiff is entitled to. In terms
of the minutes of the meeting dated 13.12.2010, the defendants agreed to
increase the rate of EDP by Rs.30/- per case containing 12 bottles with
effect from 01.01.2011. Defendants denied exchange of any e-mail as well
as any understanding with the plaintiff regarding payment to be received by
the plaintiff from the para-military forces directly. It is pleaded that though
the suit of the plaintiff seems to be a suit for accounts but the plaintiff had
neither furnished any account regarding its claim nor any copy of accounts
to the defendants and therefore, the suit ought to be dismissed at the
threshold.
16.
By raising a counter-claim, it is pleaded that the plaintiff had invited
the defendants to a meeting on 13.12.2010 at New Delhi for increasing EDP
by Rs.30/- per case and had agreed to pay all the expenses of the
representative of the defendant no.1 and accordingly, the defendants had
raised a Debit Note for a sum of Rs.30,502/- dated 06.01.2011 but the same
had not been paid by the plaintiff. Accordingly, defendants claim a sum of
RFA No. 03 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. M/s Dreambox Marketing (A) Pvt. Ltd. & Anr.
RFA No. 06 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 128 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
RFA No. 07 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 156 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
Rs.30,502/- from the plaintiff with up to date interest @18% per annum
from 06.01.2011 till final payment.
17.
By filing written objection to the counter-claim, the plaintiff pleaded
that the plaintiff had not agreed to pay any expenses of the representative
of the defendant no.1 and therefore, question of making payment of the
aforesaid amount does not arise.
18.
Initially, two issues were framed. Subsequently, two additional issues
were framed. The issues finally settled are as follows:“(i)
Whether
Rs.1,51,67,244/
the
defendants
(Rupees
One
are
liable
to
pay
a
sum
of
crore
Fifty-One
lakh
Sixty-Seven
thousand Two hundred & Forty-Four) only for the goods supplied to
the para-military forces based in North-East India? (onus of plaintiff)
(ii)
Whether the claim of the plaintiff amounting to Rs.74,23,594/-
(Rupees Seventy-Four lakh Twenty-Three thousand Five hundred &
Ninety-Four) was barred by the law of limitation? (onus of defendants)
(iii)
Whether the defendants are entitled to a sum of Rs.30,502/-
(Rupees Thirty thousand Five hundred & Two) only from the plaintiff?
(onus of defendants)
(iv)
19.
Whether the plaintiff is entitled to any reliefs? (onus of plaintiff)
In support of its case, the plaintiff examined its constituent attorney,
Shri K. B. Biswakarma, as PW-1 and one Shri H. K. Dey, as PW-2. The
defendants examined Shri Bonoraj Choudhury, the defendant no.2, as DW-1
and Shri Somraj Choudhury, as DW-2.
20.
Mr. Udai P. Sharma, learned Counsel for the appellant submits that
learned Trial Court erred in law in holding that Debit Notes exhibited by the
appellant were manufactured documents instead of holding the Debit Notes
exhibited by the defendants as manufactured documents. It is also
RFA No. 03 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. M/s Dreambox Marketing (A) Pvt. Ltd. & Anr.
RFA No. 06 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 128 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
RFA No. 07 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 156 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
submitted that learned Trial Court committed error of law in not sending the
Debit Notes exhibited by both the plaintiff and the defendants for scientific
and forensic examination. That apart, out of 120 Debit Notes submitted by
the defendants, only 10 invoices had been submitted in support of the Debit
Notes. In this connection, he has drawn the attention of the Court to
Exhibits-D/P to Exhibit-D/W and submits that none of them tallied with the
Debit Notes. He submits that the learned Trial Court failed to examine the
evidence on record in its correct perspective while dismissing the suit of the
plaintiff and in holding that claim for the sum of Rs.74,23,594/- is barred by
limitation. With reference to paragraphs 25 and 52 of the written statement,
it is submitted that the defendants had admitted payment of only Rs.
3,21,08,288/-
out
of
total
amount
of
Rs.
5,88,00,583/-,and
thus,
acknowledged that a sum of Rs. 2,69,98,834/- is due to the plaintiff but this
aspect was overlooked by the learned Trial Court. It is submitted that the
learned Trial Court committed error in law as well as of facts in decreeing
the counter-claim of the defendants without there being any acceptable
evidence on record.
21.
Mr. A. Moulik, learned Senior Counsel for the respondents submits that
the plaintiff miserably failed to prove its case and the case of the plaintiff is
based on falsehood. There is no admission by the defendants that any
amount was due to be paid by the defendants to the plaintiff. While the
plaintiff had suppressed the MoU dated 19.03.2010, in cross-examination of
the witnesses of the plaintiff, it has become manifestly clear that the parties
had executed MoU dated 19.03.2010 and the same was also acted upon and
the business of the parties were conducted accordingly. It is submitted that
invoices as enclosed in Exhibits-D/P to Exhibit-D/W, reference to which is
made in IA No.4 of 2019, were samples/proforma of the invoice to enable
the appellant to prepare the invoice to be submitted to the para-military
RFA No. 03 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. M/s Dreambox Marketing (A) Pvt. Ltd. & Anr.
RFA No. 06 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 128 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
RFA No. 07 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 156 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
forces and being sample, obviously, invoices are not signed. He has
submitted that the learned Trial Court rightly did not place any reliance on
the Debit Notes exhibited by the plaintiff. He has drawn the attention of the
Court to the cross-examination of PW-1 to submit that the same would
demonstrate that the Debit Notes exhibited by the plaintiff are manufactured
documents. He, however, submits that having regard to the MoUs entered
into by and between the parties, nothing hinges on the Debit Notes.
22.
It is submitted by him that EDP is an agreed upon price between the
plaintiff and the defendants and based on that, the defendants used to make
payment to the plaintiff. The plaintiff had received its due price for the
supplies made and evidence of PW-1 and PW-2 itself demolishes the claim of
the plaintiff. With regard to the claim of Rs.74,23,594/- for the Financial
Year 2008-2009, he submits that there is no basis for such a claim and
besides, the claim is rightly held by the learned Trial Court to be barred by
limitation. He submits that Exhibit-D-AA and Exhibit-D-AE go to show that
no amount was due to be paid by the defendants to the plaintiff.
23.
The MoU dated 03.03.2007 is exhibited by DW-1 as Exhibit-D/B.
Exhibit-D/B goes to show that the second party, i.e. defendant no.1, was
appointed as a marketing associate to market IMFL to para-military forces
and civil-bonded warehouses in Eastern and Northern India for a period of
two years with effect from 03.03.2007, renewable for a further period of two
years at mutual option on the terms and conditions indicated therein. Clause
2 provides for payment term which is to the effect that defendant no.1 will
make payment to the plaintiff through L/C after 70 days from the date of
dispatch of goods (consignment to consignment). Clause 4 provides that
Himalayan Distilleries Limited (HDL), i.e. the appellant, will raise the bill in
the name of BSF/ITBP etc. with the instruction that the payment should be
made by the BSF/ITBP in favour of Dreambox Marketing(A) Pvt. Ltd.,
RFA No. 03 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. M/s Dreambox Marketing (A) Pvt. Ltd. & Anr.
RFA No. 06 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 128 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
RFA No. 07 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 156 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
Guwahati, i.e. the defendant no.1. Clause 5 provides that for the release of
L/C, HDL will make an invoice or bill in the name of consignee M/s.
Dreambox Marketing(A) Pvt. Ltd., Pan Bazar, Guwahati-701001, which will
be produced before Canara Bank. Clause 6 provides that for the difference
amount between the quoted price and EDP, Dreambox Marketing will give a
Debit Note to HDL against expenses incurred for sales promotion, selling
expenses, etc. and thereafter, HDL will issue a Credit Note. Clause 7
provides that payment shall be made by third party (i.e. para-military
forces) in favour of M/s. Dreambox Marketing(A) Pvt. Ltd., Guwahati, i.e.
defendant no.1,
at the quoted rate of second party (i.e. M/s. Dreambox
Marketing(A) Pvt. Ltd.). The first party (M/s. Himalaya Distilleries Ltd.) shall
not collect payment from the third party. In case the third party remits
payment directly to the first party by mistake against the invoice value, the
first party shall remit the payment back to the second party immediately.
Clause 8 provides that the payment shall be adjusted by the second party
after deduction of ex-factory price as mentioned in Annexures-1 from the
quoted rate (as mentioned in the invoice) to the third party for the margin of
the second party (i.e. royalties and sales promotional expenses). Clause 12
provides that the first party is selling the goods at Ex-Distillery, Majitar,
Sikkim. Though there was no whisper in the plaint with regard to MoU dated
19.03.2010, in cross-examination, PW-1 admitted execution of MoU dated
19.03.2010, Exhibit-D/A. MoU dated 19.03.2010, Exhibit-D/A, is identical to
the MoU dated 03.03.2007, Exhibit-D/B.
24.
A combined reading of paragraphs 5 and 11 of the plaint goes to show
that though in terms of Clause 2 of MoU dated 03.03.2007, the defendants
were required to make payment to plaintiff through L/C, as the defendants
verbally expressed their difficulties, an arrangement was worked out to the
effect that the defendant would deposit an ad hoc minimum amount by way
RFA No. 03 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. M/s Dreambox Marketing (A) Pvt. Ltd. & Anr.
RFA No. 06 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 128 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
RFA No. 07 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 156 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
of 60 days’ post-dated cheques drawn by the defendants in favour of the
plaintiff. PW-1, in his cross-examination, however, admitted that defendants
never expressed any difficulty in opening L/C and that system of opening
L/C was stopped at the instance of the plaintiff. There is no pleading and
naturally, no evidence as to how the minimum amount was worked out. PW1 stated that the cheques issued to the plaintiff by the defendants were for
the amount of the EDP of IMFL goods and the government levies and that
Annexure-1 in Clause 8 of both the MoUs shows the EDP/basic price of IMFL
at which the goods are to be sold to the defendants. It appears that though
it was recited in the MoU that no amendment or other modification of the
agreement shall be valid or binding on either party unless reduced to writing
and executed by the parties, the system of deposit of post-dated cheques
continued till the present suit was filed and therefore, notwithstanding the
recital, because of the course of conduct of the parties over a prolonged
period of time, it has to be accepted that Clause 2 of the MoU was given a
complete go-bye.
25.
Immediately after execution of MoU, Exhibit-D/B, a letter dated
26.04.2007, Exhibit-D/E, but noted as Exhibit-D/F (there is another ExhibitD/F, which is a letter dated 30.05.2008) was issued stating that the plaintiff
company could offer margin to the defendant no.1 after deduction of EDP
from quoted price as indicated in the invoice issued to para-military units
and civil-bonded warehouses. It is also stated therein that the plaintiff
company would issue Credit Note against invoice value for the margin
money or the defendant no.1 may adjust the balance amount as its margin
after deduction of EDP + Export Fees + Insurance + CST + transportation
charges from the invoice value. This letter goes to show that plaintiff
permitted the defendants to adjust the balance amount remaining from the
invoice amount after deductions as indicated as their margin money. PW-1
RFA No. 03 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. M/s Dreambox Marketing (A) Pvt. Ltd. & Anr.
RFA No. 06 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 128 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
RFA No. 07 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 156 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
admitted in his cross-examination that the plaintiff had never issued any
Credit Note.
Another letter dated 26.04.2007, Exhibit-D/D, was issued by
the authorized signatory of the plaintiff stating, amongst others, that
defendant no.1 is authorized to submit tenders, negotiate prices and collect
supply orders on behalf of plaintiff company and that they will not collect
any payment against the invoice value from para-military units.
26.
Three different copies of Annexure-1, referred to in the MoUs, were
exhibited as Exhibit-D/G. Exhibit-D/G gives rates of basic price, i.e. EDP of
IMFL products for different years. Letter dated 05.03.2007, Exhibit-D/J, is a
letter issued by the plaintiff to the defendants quoting “most competitive
rate/basic price” of the products mentioned therein for making supplies to
para-military units in Assam, Meghalaya and Tripura. The rates were
reiterated by letter dated 24.04.2007, Exhibit-D/K. Exhibit-D/F, as noticed
earlier, is a letter dated 30.05.2008 confirming revised EDP with effect from
01.04.2008. Exhibit-D/H, a letter dated 20.01.2009, is another letter
wherein EDP of various products are indicated.
27.
PW-2 stated that the defendants, while participating in the tender,
quote their own rate, which includes EDP, Export fees, Central Sales Tax,
transportation, insurance, own margin money, etc. and if the bid submitted
by the defendants is accepted, the para-military forces place supply orders
to the defendants and not to the plaintiff. The defendants, in turn, issue
their own supply orders to the plaintiff requesting to supply different
quantities of various items to the para-military forces. Defendants then
make payment to the plaintiff towards its entitlement and purchase the
goods from the plaintiff. In cross-examination, PW-2 was shown various
supply orders which he had received from the defendants. I will refer to only
one exhibit, Exhibit-D/O. With reference to the aforesaid exhibit, PW-2
stated that he had received of a cheque for Rs.2,79,828/- dated 22.11.2008
RFA No. 03 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. M/s Dreambox Marketing (A) Pvt. Ltd. & Anr.
RFA No. 06 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 128 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
RFA No. 07 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 156 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
from the defendant company towards price of goods which included EDP,
CST @ 2% and Export Fees. With reference to all the exhibits pertaining to
supply orders received by him, he stated that the he had received different
cheques for different amounts which included EDP of the goods supplied,
Central Sales Tax and Export Fees paid to the plaintiff by the defendant
company towards entitlement of the plaintiff company for purchase of the
goods and the plaintiff, upon receipt of the amount, dispatches the goods to
the para-military forces directly and the para-military forces release the
payment to the defendants and not to the plaintiff. He also stated that such
payments do not suggest that the same were by way of any part-payment to
the plaintiff. PW-2 also admitted that that defendant no.1 had been
appointed as a marketing associate and not as an agent. He further stated
that the profit margin of the defendants is the difference of quoted price,
which is reflected in the invoice price, and the EDP.
28.
How the transactions were carried out can be seen, by way of
illustration, from Exhibit-4 and Exhibit-9. Exhibit-4 is a letter dated
19.03.2011 addressed to the plaintiff by the defendant company placing a
supply order for Commandant, 68 Bn., C.R.P.F., Veneer Mills, Monkholi, for
600 cases of 750 ml. of Himalayan Pride XXX Rum. Quoted rate is shown as
Rs.785/- per case and the total amount including CST is Rs.4,80,420/-.
Based
on
the
aforesaid
supply
order,
plaintiff
raised
invoice
dated
08.04.2011, Exhibit-9, upon the consignee, i.e. the Commandant, for
Rs.4,80,420/-. An endorsement is there in Exhibit-9 that post-dated Cheque
No.020577 dated 08.06.2011 for Rs.2,72,310/- was received. Exhibit-D/P to
Exhibit-D/W are letters, with which, amongst others, supply order and
cheque are enclosed. The supply orders are similar to Exhibit-4. The
unsigned invoices, which are also enclosed with Exhibit-D/P to Exhibit-D/W,
carry no value and as rightly submitted by Mr.Moulik, they are enclosed as
RFA No. 03 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. M/s Dreambox Marketing (A) Pvt. Ltd. & Anr.
RFA No. 06 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 128 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
RFA No. 07 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 156 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
sample for guidance to the appellant for preparing the invoice to be
submitted by the appellant to the para-military forces. Having regard to the
evidence of PW-2, it is evident that the cheque amounts represent EDP,
which is already fixed in terms of Annexure-1,+CST+Export Fees. It is
relevant to note that PW-1, in his cross-examination, stated that the plaintiff
sells its IMFL products to other organizations, wholesalers, etc. at the EDP
rate only. PW-2 had stated that out of the cheque amount, CST and Export
Fees being Government levies, EDP is the entitlement of the plaintiff.
29.
Both PW-1 and PW-2, in their cross-examination, had stated that the
two MoUs did not visualize that the defendants have to submit any accounts
to the plaintiff. PW-1 also admitted that in the MoUs, there is no stipulation
that the defendant company, after collecting invoice amount from paramilitary forces, shall pay back the sum to the plaintiff company.
30.
From MoUs and the cross-examination of witnesses of the plaintiff it is
seen that the para-military forces make payment to defendant no.1 at the
quoted rate of the defendant no.1 and that plaintiff does not collect
payments from para-military forces. In case by mistake the payment is
remitted by the para-military forces to the plaintiff, the plaintiff is required
to remit the payment to the defendant no.1 immediately. There is no
requirement that after receipt of payment from the para-military forces, the
defendant no.1 has to remit the amount to the plaintiff. What is visualized is
that the payment shall be adjusted by the defendants after deduction of
EDP/EFP as stated in Annexure-1 from the quoted rate as mentioned in the
invoice to the para-military forces for the margin of the defendants. There is
also no requirement of furnishing of any account to the plaintiff by the
defendants.
RFA No. 03 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. M/s Dreambox Marketing (A) Pvt. Ltd. & Anr.
RFA No. 06 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 128 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
RFA No. 07 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 156 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
31.
Submission of Mr. Sharma that in paragraphs 25 and 52, the
defendants admitted that a sum of Rs.2,69,98,834/- is due to the plaintiff is
misconceived. There is no such admission in the aforesaid paragraphs. In
paragraph 25, amount paid to the plaintiff is shown as Rs.3,21,08,288/-,
whereas in paragraph 52, after giving the break-up for relevant financial
years, the amount is reflected as Rs.3,21,07,688/-. There is a difference of
Rs.600/-. Be that as it may. What the defendants have essentially stated in
the aforesaid paragraphs is that the amount paid by them to the plaintiff is
the entitlement of the plaintiff.
32.
There is a dispute with regard to the Debit Notes furnished by the
plaintiff being Exhibits-17(1) to 17(42) and the set of Debit Notes furnished
by the defendants being Exhibits-D/C (collectively). It was deposed on
behalf of the plaintiff that the Debit Notes, Exhibit-17(1) to Exhibit-17(42)
were sent by the defendants by putting the same in an envelope, Exhibit-18
and was received in the month of March, 2011. In Exhibit-18, address is
shown as Managing Director…….. SBL… Pvt. ……….. The address seen in the
Exhibit-18 is not complete but it appears that the same was addressed to
Managing Director of one SBL Pvt. Ltd., Delhi. PW-1 admitted that none of
the Debit Notes, Exhibit-17(1) to Exhibit-17(42), received in the envelope,
Exhibit-18, are in the letter head of the defendant no.1 company. PW-1 also
admitted that all the Debit Notes marked as Exhibit-17(1) to Exhibit-17(42)
could not have been put inside Exhibit-18 at a time. Besides, though all the
Debit Notes, which were put inside Exhibit-18, were stated to have been
received in the month of March, 2011, it is seen that Exhibit-17(39), Exhibit17(40), Exhibit-17(41) and Exhibit-17(42) are Debit Notes of post-March,
2011. It is in that context, the learned Trial Court had opined that the
submission of the learned Counsel for the defendants that documents
RFA No. 03 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. M/s Dreambox Marketing (A) Pvt. Ltd. & Anr.
RFA No. 06 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 128 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
RFA No. 07 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 156 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
marked as Exhibit-17(1) to Exhibit-17(42) are manufactured documents for
the purpose of the case could not be ruled out.
33.
In paragraph 14 of the plaint, it is pleaded that Debit Notes submitted
by the defendants consisted of 8 heads. Exhibits-17(1) to 17(42) also
contain 8 heads. The Debit Notes exhibited by the defendants as ExhibitsD/C (collectively), on the other hand, only show margin of Dreambox
Marketing(A) Pvt. Ltd., being the difference in amount between the quoted
price and the EDP. There is no stipulation in the MoUs that the defendants
have to justify their expenses and along with Debit Notes, they would have
to furnish Money Receipts as pleaded in the plaint. Therefore, plea taken by
the plaintiff that the defendants did not furnish Money Receipts for
transportation charges and breakages & shortages charges has no basis.
Nowhere it is pleaded by the plaintiff, what according to it, constitutes
margin money of the defendants. PW-2, as noticed earlier, stated that the
profit margin of the defendants is the difference of quoted price, which is
reflected in the invoice price, and the EDP. In the above scenario, plea set
up in the plaint that the defendants must adjust marketing & selling
expenses, travelling & boarding expenses, expenses for processing of import
permit and expenses for processing tender from their profit margin has no
legs to stand. It is also not understood what the plaintiff intended to say
with regard to interest of money involvement on credit basis, which was
stated to be another head of the Debit Notes of the defendants, that it
realized payment from the defendants after the defendants had collected
payment from the para-military forces. Apart from the fact that there is no
evidence regarding when the defendants had collected payments from the
para-military forces, the MoUs did not provide that the plaintiff would be
entitled to any amount from the invoice amount. Even if it is assumed that
the Debit Notes, Exhibit-17(1) to Exhibit-17(42), are the Debit Notes sent by
RFA No. 03 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. M/s Dreambox Marketing (A) Pvt. Ltd. & Anr.
RFA No. 06 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 128 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
RFA No. 07 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 156 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
the defendants, then also, the same do not, in any way, improve the case of
the plaintiff. In view of the evidence on record and the MoUs, the Debit
Notes will not have any role to play and therefore, submission of Mr. Sharma
that the learned Trial Court committed error of law in not sending the Debit
Notes for forensic examination has no merit.
34.
The plaintiff had alleged withholding of amounts by the plaintiff for
three Financial Years, namely, 2008-2009 to 2010-2011, i.e. up to
31.03.2011. The suit was filed on 09.11.2011. The learned Trial Court was
not justified in holding that the claim for Rs.74,23,594/- is barred by
limitation inasmuch as the learned Trial Court had taken starting point of
limitation from 01.04.2008, which is the beginning of the Financial Year
2008-2009. However, the same will not have any material difference as on
an appreciation of evidence on record and in view of the discussion, I find
that the plaintiff has failed to prove that any amount was due to it from the
defendants for the three Financial Years, namely, 2008-2009 to 2010-2011.
35.
Exhibit-D/AA is a letter dated 26.05.2010 issued by the authorized
signatory of the plaintiff to defendant no.1 certifying that the defendant no.1
has no dues for the Financial Years 2007-2008 and 2008-2009. Exhibit-D/AE
is a letter dated 01.03.2011 issued by the plaintiff to Somraj Choudhury of
defendant no.1, stating, amongst others, that defendant no.1 has no dues
till that day. The aforesaid exhibits had been admitted by PW-1. This
admission also goes to show that no dues were payable by the defendants to
the plaintiff for the Financial Years 2008-2009, 2009-2010 and for the
Financial Year 2010-2011 up to 01.03.2011.
36.
In view of the above discussion, issue nos. 1 and 2 are decided against
the plaintiff.
RFA No. 03 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. M/s Dreambox Marketing (A) Pvt. Ltd. & Anr.
RFA No. 06 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 128 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
RFA No. 07 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 156 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
37.
Learned Trial Court in issue no. 3 held that the defendants are entitled
to a sum of Rs.30,502/-. While coming to the aforesaid conclusion, learned
Trial Court observed that the plaintiff had not filed written statement to the
counter-claim of the defendants. It was held that DW-2, Bonoraj Choudhury,
was also not cross-examined on the issue of counter-claim as well as on the
contents of Exhibit-D/N (collectively). The observation of the learned Trial
Court that the plaintiff did not file written statement is not correct. A written
objection to the counter-claim was filed by the plaintiff praying for
dismissing the counter-claim. It was denied that the plaintiff had agreed to
pay all the expenses of the representative of the defendant Company while
going for the meeting at Delhi. Learned Trial Court also referred to the
evidence on affidavit of PW-2 at paragraphs 26, 27 and 28. Exhibit-D/N
(collectively) is a letter dated 06.01.2011 issued by DW-2 to the appellant
with reference to the discussions he had with the Managing Director of the
plaintiff towards his expenses for travelling, food and lodging at Delhi for
attending the meeting dated 13.10.2010, wherein Debit Notes and plane
tickets, etc. were enclosed. However, there is no evidence establishing that
the appellant had agreed to bear the expenses of the representative of the
defendant Company for the meeting that was held in Delhi.
38.
In that view of the matter, the finding of the learned Trial Court that
the defendants are entitled to a sum of Rs.30,502/-, as claimed in the
counter-claim, cannot be sustained. Issue no.3 is, accordingly, decided
against the defendants.
39.
In view of the above discussions, the appeal is partly allowed. Decision
of the learned Trial Court dismissing the suit of the plaintiff is upheld.
Decision of the learned Trial Court allowing the counter-claim of the
defendants is set aside and the counter-claim is dismissed.
RFA No. 03 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. M/s Dreambox Marketing (A) Pvt. Ltd. & Anr.
RFA No. 06 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 128 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
RFA No. 07 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 156 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
RFA No.06 of 2017 and RFA No. 07 of 2017
40.
In the plaint of Money Suit No.810 of 2013, out of which RFA No. 3 of
2017 had arisen, reference was made to Money Suit No.13 of 2012 and
Money Suit No.14 of 2012. Subsequently, Money Suit No.13 of 2012 and
Money Suit No.14 of 2012 were registered as Money Suit No.19 of 2015 and
Money Suit No.18 of 2015, respectively. It was stated in Money Suit No.810
of 2013 that the aforesaid two Money Suits were instituted for an amount of
Rs.5,26,320/- each as despite clear instruction given on the invoices to
make payment directly to the plaintiff, M/s. Dreambox Marketing(A) Pvt. Ltd.
had illegally collected payment from the C.R.P.F. battalions and the C.R.P.F.
battalions had also committed illegality in making payment to M/s.
Dreambox Marketing(A) Pvt. Ltd.
41.
Learned Counsel for the parties had submitted that the decision in RFA
No.03 of 2017 would substantially cover the present two appeals. The plea
set up in Money Suit No.18 of 2015 and Money Suit No.19 of 2015 that the
plaintiff had instructed defendant no.1 to make payment for the supply of
IMFL to it directly is the distinctive feature of these two suits as this plea was
not raised in Money Suit No. 810 of 2013. At this stage, it will be appropriate
to briefly notice the case set up by the plaintiff in the aforesaid two suits as
well as to take note of the case of the defendants.
42.
The plaint in Money Suit No. 18 of 2015 and in Money Suit No.19/2015
is almost identical. Reference is made to the MoU dated 03.03.2007 and
averments are made with regard to business transactions in between the
plaintiff and the defendant company, which are already noticed while
discussing RFA No.03 of 2017. It is pleaded that after a meeting was held by
the Managing Director of the plaintiff with the defendant no.2, wherein
defendant no.2 was represented by one Shri Somraj Choudhury, it was
RFA No. 03 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. M/s Dreambox Marketing (A) Pvt. Ltd. & Anr.
RFA No. 06 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 128 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
RFA No. 07 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 156 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
mutually agreed upon and decided that the plaintiff thenceforth was to
instruct the defendant no.1 to make payments to it directly in respect of the
goods manufactured and supplied by the plaintiff. It is stated that an e-mail
was sent with the entire transcript of the meeting and its outcome and the
same was followed by a letter dated 06.04.2011, stating that the old
arrangement
between
the
plaintiff
and
the
defendant
no.2
was
to
immediately cease and that request was made to defendant no.2 to come to
Sikkim to draw up a new agreement. In these two suits, reference is made
to the MoU executed on 19.03.2010, but with a rider that the same was
neither assented by the plaintiff nor acted upon by the parties.
43.
In Money Suit No. 810 of 2013, as noticed supra, no mention was
made about MoU dated 19.03.2010.
44.
In the usual course of business, the plaintiff had received two letters,
both dated 23.05.2011, for supply of 500 cases of Himalayan Pride XXX Rum
(750 ml.) and 100 cases of Royal Orchid Whisky (750 ml.) to be supplied to
the Commandant, 156 Bn., C.R.P.F., Dhaligaon, (Money Suit No.19/2012)
and to the Commandant, 128 Bn., C.R.P.F., Spun Silk Mill, Jagiroad, (Money
Suit No.18 of 2015). Accordingly, plaintiff raised invoice dated 28.05.2011 in
respect of Commandant, 156 Bn., C.R.P.F. and invoice dated 27.05.2011 in
respect of Commandant, 128 Bn., C.R.P.F. The invoice amount in both the
cases was Rs.5,26,320/-.
45.
It is the case of the plaintiff that there was a specific instruction in
Clause 6 in the overleaf of the invoice that payment shall be remitted by
Demand Draft drawn in favour of Himalaya Distilleries Ltd., payable at
Gangtok, Sikkim. Despite issuance of legal notice, as no amount was paid,
suits came to be filed. It is also stated that the Commandant, 128 Bn.,
RFA No. 03 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. M/s Dreambox Marketing (A) Pvt. Ltd. & Anr.
RFA No. 06 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 128 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
RFA No. 07 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 156 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
C.R.P.F. had written a letter dated 21.08.2011 stating that the payment
would be made in favour of defendant no.2.
46.
The written statement filed by the defendant no.1 in both the cases is
more or less identical save and except the dates and particulars applicable in
the respective cases. It is pleaded that 68 Bn., C.R.P.F. had floated a tender
for purchase of IMFL from various suppliers/marketing agents. The rate
quoted by the defendant no.2 was found to be most favourable and
accordingly, defendant no.2 was engaged as supplier of defendant no.1. It is
pleaded that the defendant no.1 had no direct contact with plaintiff and IMFL
was purchased through its authorized distributor and therefore, there is no
obligation of the defendant no.1 to make payment to the plaintiff. It is
stated that defendant no.1 had made payment to defendant no.2 in
accordance with the terms and conditions of the comparative statement
which was agreed upon by and between defendant nos. 1 and 2.
47.
The written statement filed by defendant no.2 in both the suits is also
more or less identical. It is specifically pleaded that MoU dated 19.03.2010
was given effect to and was acted upon by both the plaintiff and defendant
no.2 and based on the said MoU dated 19.03.2010, the defendant no.2 was
making supply of liquor to various para-military forces of the North-Eastern
Region and payment instructions in all the invoices were made in favour of
defendant no.2. It is denied that there was any e-mail exchange between
plaintiff and defendant no.2 or that there was any understanding that the
plaintiff would receive payment directly from the para-military forces. The
defendant no.2 also denied to have received any letter dated 06.04.2011. It
is further pleaded that while forwarding the import permit to make supplies
to the aforesaid battalions, two undated cheques for Rs.2,81,760/-, each,
being the entitled amount of the plaintiff against the IMFL to be dispatched,
were sent and the same were duly received by the plaintiff. However, the
RFA No. 03 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. M/s Dreambox Marketing (A) Pvt. Ltd. & Anr.
RFA No. 06 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 128 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
RFA No. 07 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 156 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
plaintiff tried to receive the entire amount of the invoices from the defendant
no.1.
48.
In both the cases, identical issues were framed, which are:
(1)
Whether the defendant no.1 had floated a tender through
the
Bn.,
C.R.P.F.
for
supply
of
IMFL
from
various
suppliers/marketing agents? (onus of defendant no.1)
(2)
Whether defendant no.1 had paid to defendant no.2 a sum
of Rs.5,26,320/- as price of 500 cases of Himalayan Pride XXX
Rum (750 ml.) and 100 cases of Royal Orchid whisky (750 ml.)
as per the supply order of defendant no.1? (onus of the plaintiff)
(3)
Whether the plaintiff is entitled to any other reliefs? (onus
of plaintiff)
49.
In both the suits, plaintiff’s constituent attorney, K. B. Biswakarma,
who also deposed as PW-1 in the Money Suit No.810 of 2013, was examined
as PW-1 and another employee, M. B. Majhi was examined as PW-2.
In
Money Suit No.18 of 2015, defendant no.1 examined the Second-inCommand, Arvind P. Anand as D1W1 and in Money Suit No.19/2015, the
defendant no.1 examined the Deputy Commandant, Gyachho Tshering
Lepcha as D1W1. The Managing Director of defendant no.2, Mr. Bonoraj
Choudhury was examined as D2W1 in both the suits.
50.
The learned Trial Court had taken up issue nos.1 and 2 together in
both the suits and it was held that it is more or less an admitted position
that 68 Bn., C.R.P.F. had floated a tender for supply of IMFL pursuant to
which the defendant no.2 was engaged as a supplier of IMFL. In Money Suit
No.18 of 2015, it was recorded that defendant no.1 had made payment of
Rs.4,23,470/- and the amount of Rs.1,02,850/- was not paid as the matter
is sub judice. In Money Suit No.19 of 2015, it was recorded that defendant
RFA No. 03 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. M/s Dreambox Marketing (A) Pvt. Ltd. & Anr.
RFA No. 06 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 128 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
RFA No. 07 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 156 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
no.1 had paid a sum of Rs.5,22,413/- against the total invoice amount of
Rs.5,26,320/- to the defendant no.2. Issue no.3 was decided against the
plaintiff having regard to the evidence on record.
51.
The plaintiff had exhibited, as Exhibit-7, the invoice dated 27.05.2011
for the amount of Rs.5,26,320/- in Money Suit No.18 of 2015. In Money Suit
No.19 of 2015, the plaintiff had exhibited as Exhibit-7, the invoice dated
28.05.2011 for the amount of Rs.5,26,320/-. In Clause 6, printed on the
reverse side of the invoices, it is written as follows: “Payment shall be
remitted by Demand Draft drawn in favour of Himalaya Distilleries Ltd.,
payable at Gangtok, Sikkim.” D1W1, in Money Suit No.18 of 2015, had
exhibited an invoice dated 27.05.2011 for the amount of Rs.5,26,320/-, as
Exhibit-D1-C, and in Clause 6, printed on the reverse side of the invoice, it is
written as follows: “Payment shall be remitted by crossed Demand Draft
drawn in favour of Dreambox Marketing(A) Pvt. Ltd. payable at Kahilipara,
Guwahati (SBI Code No. 04420)/ or deposit on cash payment directly online
to our SBI account No.30389786188. Dreambox Marketing(A) Pvt. Ltd. has
sole
authority
to
receive
all
kinds
of
payments
from
you.”
Similarly, in Money Suit No.19/2015, D1W1 exhibited an invoice dated
28.05.2011 for the amount of Rs.5,26,320/-, as Exhibit-D1-A, wherein
Clause 6 was identical with Exhibit-D1-C. Thus, the invoices exhibited by the
plaintiff and by the para-military forces, i.e. defendant no.1 in both the suits,
were different as far as Clause-6 is concerned.
52.
The learned Trial Court had observed that once the parties are held to
be governed by the MoU, it is of no significance what was written on the
reverse side of Exhibit-7 as the MoU prohibited the plaintiff from directly
seeking payment from para-military forces.
RFA No. 03 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. M/s Dreambox Marketing (A) Pvt. Ltd. & Anr.
RFA No. 06 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 128 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
RFA No. 07 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 156 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
53.
In both the suits, a Deed of Compromise dated 15.04.2014 (Exhibit-
13), which was entered into between the plaintiff and the defendant no.2 of
the respective suits, were exhibited. The Deeds of Compromise were in
respect of compromise effected in two complaint cases, which were filed
alleging dishonour of cheques for Rs.2,81,760/- each, issued by the
defendant no.2. In the written statement of defendant no.2, it is mentioned
that two cheques for Rs.2,81,760/- each were issued while forwarding the
import permit to make supply to the Commandant of 128 Bn., C.R.P.F. and
the Commandant of 156 Bn., C.R.P.F. It is recorded in Exhibit-13 that the
plaintiff had acknowledged the payment of amount of Rs.2,81,760/- as full
and final settlement of its claim and that it will have no claim in any form for
the cheques that were dishonoured and that the dispute involved in the
matter had been fully and finally settled.
54.
Cross-examination of PW-1 had taken place at the first instance in
Money Suit No.18 of 2015. While he was cross-examined in Money Suit
No.19 of 2015, he was confronted with his cross-examination in Money Suit
No.18 of 2015. In cross-examination of PW-1 by defendant no.2, it is
admitted by PW-1 that business, in question, between the parties was
guided by various clauses of the MoU, which were duly acted upon by the
parties and that as per Clause 7 of the MoU, payment against the goods
supplied by the plaintiff to the para-military forces is required to be made by
the para-military forces directly to the defendant no.2 at the quoted rate of
the defendant no.2 and that the plaintiff cannot collect payment from the
para-military forces. Plaintiff could not prove that there was any other
agreement with the defendant no.2 enabling it to demand payment from
defendant no.1. Therefore, there is no basis for the claim of the plaintiff that
it is entitled to receive the payment of the invoice amount from the
defendant no.1 during the subsistence of the MoU dated 19.03.2010.
RFA No. 03 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. M/s Dreambox Marketing (A) Pvt. Ltd. & Anr.
RFA No. 06 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 128 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
RFA No. 07 of 2017 : M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. vs. The Commandant 156 Bn. C.R.P.F. & Anr.
55.
In view of the above discussion, there is no merit in these two appeals
and, accordingly, the same are dismissed. IA No.4 of 2019 stands disposed
of in the light of the observations made in paragraph 4.
Chief Justice
jk
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review