Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
DATED : 4th MAY, 2023
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
RFA No.03 of 2022
Appellants
:
M/s. Himal Match Co. Pvt. Ltd. and Another
versus
Respondent
:
Smt. Kiran Agarwal
Appeal under Order XLI Rules 1 and 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. Passang Tshering Bhutia, Advocate for the Appellants.
Mr. Sajal Sharma and Ms. Shreya Sharma, Advocates for the
Respondent.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
The Respondent/Plaintiff filed an Eviction Suit before
the Court of the District Judge, East Sikkim, at Gangtok, seeking
eviction of the Appellants/Defendants from the suit premises,
recovery of arrears in rent and mesne profits.
The grounds
enumerated for such eviction were illegal occupation of the suit
premises by the Appellants despite due receipt of Notice of
Eviction.
That, the premises were required for the Respondent‘s
personal use and occupation and that the suit premises being in a
dilapidated condition were required to be overhauled.
2.
The facts relevant for the present purposes are that the
suit premises comprising of a four storied RCC building, measuring
30 ft. x 92 ft., situated at Rangpo Bazar, was rented out by M/s.
Balchand Udairam, the owner, to the Appellant, M/s. Himal Match
Co. Pvt. Ltd., at a monthly rent of ₹ 250/- (Rupees two hundred
RFA No.03 of 2022
M/s. Himal Match Co. Pvt. Ltd. and Another
vs. Smt. Kiran Agarwal
and fifty) only. The year of tenancy has not been mentioned in the
plaint.
On 14-08-1991, M/s. Balchand Udairam sold the suit
property to the Respondent.
Upon such sale, the Respondent
informed the Appellant Company about it and requested that
monthly rent be deposited to her. The Appellant Company failed to
comply with the request.
(i)
The suit premises being in a dilapidated condition the
Assistant Town Planner II, Urban Development and Housing
Department (UD&HD), sent a Notice dated 01-10-2008 to the
Respondent requiring her to ensure structural stability with
retrofitting works, but the required repairs could not be carried out
as the premises were not vacated by the Appellants. An Eviction
Notice dated 30-12-2008 was served upon the Appellants by the
Respondent, which was also not complied with and the Appellants
continue to remain in unlawful occupation of the suit premises from
01-02-2009. That, on this ground, the Respondent was entitled to
mesne profit calculated @ ₹ 200/- (Rupees two hundred) only, per
day, on and from 01-02-2009, till the date of obtaining vacant
possession of the suit premises.
The further case of the
Respondent is that during the pendency of the suit (Eviction Suit
No.01 of 2010), permission was granted to withdraw it with liberty
to file afresh. On such liberty, the Respondent on 29-01-2018 sent
a fresh Notice for Eviction to the Appellant, through Registered AD,
requesting the Appellant to vacate the suit premises by 01-032018. The Appellants again failed to oblige. That, the Appellants
are defaulters in payment of rent from 14-08-1991, when the suit
premises was registered in the name of the Respondent.
The
Respondent claims arrears of rent from 14-08-1991 till 01-02-2009
RFA No.03 of 2022
M/s. Himal Match Co. Pvt. Ltd. and Another
vs. Smt. Kiran Agarwal
and mesne profits after 01-02-2009. Accordingly, the Respondent
sought for a decree for recovery of possession of the suit premises,
recovery of arrears of rent of ₹ 54,000/- (Rupees fifty four
thousand) only, decree declaring that the Respondent is entitled to
mesne profits from 01-02-2009 till the date of filing of the suit.
(ii)
The Appellants contested the claims and averred that
the suit is barred by limitation under the provision of Article 52 of
the Schedule of the Limitation Act, 1963, which stipulates that the
period of limitation for recovery of arrears in rent is three years
from the date when the arrears become due. Admittedly, the rent
became due from 01-09-1991 as per the Respondent.
It was
claimed that the Appellants have been regularly paying the rent to
M/s. Balchand Udairam, till the month of January, 2009, after
which M/s. Balchand Udairam refused to accept the rent.
The
Appellants have then been depositing the rent in the postal savings
account of K. B. Biswakarma, C/o Himal Match Company.
The
electricity bill is being deposited in the name of M/s. Balchand
Udairam, as he is the owner of the suit property.
The grounds of
dilapidated
requirement
condition
of
the
suit
premises,
of
overhauling and personal occupation were denied. That, after the
receipt of Notice of Eviction dated 30-12-2008, the Appellants vide
a communication dated 09-04-2009, addressed to Jeevan Agarwal,
authorised representative of M/s. Balchand Udairam, enquired
about the reason for refusal to accept rent from February, 2009,
but the letter was returned with the remarks ―Refused by
Addressee hence return to sender‖.
The Appellants are therefore
not liable to pay mesne profit of ₹ 200/- (Rupees two hundred)
RFA No.03 of 2022
M/s. Himal Match Co. Pvt. Ltd. and Another
vs. Smt. Kiran Agarwal
only, per day, from 01-02-2009. Hence, the suit be dismissed as
not being maintainable.
The
3.
Learned Trial Court settled eight
issues for
determination;
1.
Whether the Defendants have defaulted in payment of rent
of the suit premises? (onus on Plaintiff)
2.
Whether the Plaintiff requires the suit premises for bona fide
requirement? (onus on Plaintiff)
3.
Whether the premises is in a dilapidated condition? (onus on
Plaintiff)
4.
Whether the plaintiff is entitled for recovery of arrears of
rent and mesne profit? (onus on Plaintiff)
5.
Whether the recovery of arrears of rent mesne profit are
barred by law of limitation? (onus on Defendants)
6.
Whether the Plaintiff is the absolute owner of the suit
property who is entitled under the law to file the present
suit? (onus on Plaintiff)
7.
To what relief or reliefs the Plaintiffs are entitled to?
8.
Whether the suit is bad for non-joinder and mis-joinder of
parties?
4.
In issue no.1, the Learned Trial Court concluded that
the Appellants defaulted in payment of rent to the Respondent, as
the Appellants were unable to prove payment of rent by a single
document filed by them. The only witness who deposed on behalf
of the Appellants, Tanka Bahadur Chettri, had categorically denied
having any idea about any of the documents filed by the Appellants
except Exhibit D2.
He admitted under cross-examination that till
date not a single rupee had been paid as rent to the Respondent,
by the Appellants, with respect to the suit premises.
That,
Appellants neither pleaded nor proved that the alleged deposit of
rent in the name of K. B. Biswakarma was for and on behalf of the
Respondent.
RFA No.03 of 2022
M/s. Himal Match Co. Pvt. Ltd. and Another
(i)
vs. Smt. Kiran Agarwal
Issue no.2 was decided in favour of the Respondent
having concluded that the Respondent required the premises for
her personal use, to set up her business and to supervise her
business
in
Gangtok, Siliguri and
Darjeeling, Rangpo
being
equidistant from the above places of her business.
(ii)
Issue no.3 stood decided in favour of the Respondent,
as Exhibit P2, the Notice issued by the Assistant Town Planner -II,
UD&HD revealed that the suit premises required retrofitting works,
hence the suit premises was in a dilapidated condition, fortified by
the evidence of the Appellants‘ witness, Tanka Bahadur Chettri,
who admitted that the building on which the suit premises is
located is very old and in a dilapidated condition.
(iii)
Issues no. 4 and 5 were taken up together being co-
related. The Respondent had claimed arrears of rent from 14-081991, that as per Article 52 of the Schedule of the Limitation Act,
1963, the period of limitation for setting up of claim for arrears of
rent was three years from the date when the arrears become due.
Hence, the claims from August, 1991 till the date three years prior
to the filing of the suit would be barred by limitation.
The
Respondent was found to be entitled to arrears of rent from
September, 2015, till the date of receipt of the amount from the
Appellants @ ₹ 250/- (Rupees two hundred and fifty) only, per
month.
(iv)
Issue
no.6
was
also
decided
in
favour
of
the
Respondent in view of Exhibit 1, the Sale Deed document, dated
14-08-1991.
The Learned Trial Court found that the Respondent
had sufficiently proved that she is the absolute owner of the suit
property.
RFA No.03 of 2022
M/s. Himal Match Co. Pvt. Ltd. and Another
vs. Smt. Kiran Agarwal
While deciding issue no.7, the Court held that the
(v)
Appellants are liable to be vacated from the suit premises and
liable to pay rent arrears @ rent of ₹ 250/- (Rupees two hundred
and fifty) only, from September, 2015, till the date of receipt of the
amount from the Appellants.
The suit was found to be not bad for non-joinder and
(vi)
mis-joinder of parties in issue no.8. M/s. Balchand Udairam a third
party to the suit could not be impleaded in the suit as no reliefs
has been claimed from him, and the matter could be adjudicated
without his involvement.
Eviction Suit No.02 of 2018 in the Court of District Judge,
Special Division – I, Sikkim at Gangtok, was accordingly decreed.
5.
The submissions of learned Counsel for the parties
before this Court have been heard and anxiously considered. The
evidence and documents on record, the impugned Judgment and
the citations placed in the written synopsis have been carefully
perused.
6.
This Court is to determine; (i) Whether the Respondent
proved her requirement of the suit premises and for personal
occupation and thorough overhauling on account of failure of the
Appellants to pay rent for four months, in terms of the Government
of Sikkim, Health and Works Department, Notification No.6326—
600-H&W—B, dated 14-04-1949 (in short ―Notification of 1949‖)?
and (ii) Whether the Appellants are liable to be evicted from the
suit premises?
7.
Notification No.6326—600-H&W—B, dated 14-04-1949,
provides as follows;
‖GOVERNMENT OF SIKKIM
Health and Works Department
Notification No.6326—600-H&W—B.
RFA No.03 of 2022
M/s. Himal Match Co. Pvt. Ltd. and Another
vs. Smt. Kiran Agarwal
Under powers conferred in para 2 of Notification
No.1366-G, dated the 28th July 1947, the following Rules
have been framed to regulate letting and sub-letting of
premises controlling rents thereof and unreasonable
eviction of tenants as the scarcity of housing
accommodation still exists in Sikkim.
I The landlords can charge rent for premises either
for residential or business purposes on the basis of the
rents prevailing in locality in year 1939, plus an increase
upto 50 per cent so long as the scarcity of housing
accommodation lasts.
2. The landlords cannot eject the tenants so long as the
scarcity of housing accommodation lasts, but when the whole or
part of the premises are required for their personal occupation or
for thorough overhauling the premises or on failure by the
tenants to pay rent for four months the landlords may be
permitted to evict the tenant on due application to the Chief
Court.
3- Any tenant may apply to this Department for
fixing his rent. On receipt of such application the
Department will enquire about the rent prevailing in the
locality in 1939, and fix rent as per Rule (I) above.
4- Any person acting in contravention of this
Notification will be liable to prosecution under para. 4. of
notification No.I366-066-G, dated the 28th July, 1947.
5. The tenant means those person in actual
occupation. Landlord means owners of the premises.
These rules will come into force with immediate
effect.
By order of his Highness the Maharaja of Sikkim.
R.B. Singh
Gangtok,
The 14th, April, 1949.
Secretary,
Health and Works Department;
Government of Sikkim.
[emphasis supplied]”
In terms of the above extracted Notification, in order to evict
tenants, the landlord is to establish that he requires the whole or
part of the premises for his personal occupation or for thorough
overhauling or the tenants have failed to pay rent for four months.
8.
That, the property belongs to the Appellants is no more
res integra in view of Exhibit P1, the Sale Deed document,
executed between M/s. Balchand Udairam and the Respondent
herein. In any event, it is settled law that in a suit for eviction the
Court is only required to determine whether a relationship of
landlord and tenant exists between the parties and not the
question of title to the properties, which may be considered
tangentially but cannot be decided finally.
In Keshar Bai v.
RFA No.03 of 2022
M/s. Himal Match Co. Pvt. Ltd. and Another
Chhunulal
vs. Smt. Kiran Agarwal
the Hon‘ble Supreme Court observed that even the
denial of a landlord‘s title in the written statement can provide a
ground for eviction of a tenant. That, it is not necessary that the
denial of title by the tenant should be anterior to the institution of
eviction proceedings. That, in eviction proceedings the question of
title to the properties may be incidentally gone into, but cannot be
decided finally.
(i)
The Appellants have proved that Exhibit P3 is the
Eviction Notice, dated 30-12-2008, addressed to the Appellants,
M/s. Himal Match Co. (P) Ltd. and B. K. Shresta, Chairman and
Managing Director of the Appellant Company.
The Notice states
that the premises into which the Appellant Company was inducted
at a monthly rate of ₹ 250/- (Rupees two hundred and fifty) only,
has been purchased by the Respondent and hence the Appellant
Company was required to vacate the suit premises having sub-let it
to a third party, without the consent of the Respondent, apart from
which the building was to be retrofitted to ensure structural
stability being in a dilapidated condition.
(ii)
The letter addressed to Jeevan Agarwal of M/s.
Balchand Udairam, by one K. B. Biswakarma, Constituted Attorney
of the Managing Director of the Appellant Company, Exhibit D6,
informed inter alia that, he was in receipt of Notice dated 30-122009 (sic, 30-12-2008) sent through the Respondent‘s lawyer.
The sender requested Jeevan Agarwal therein to inform him
‗urgently‘ as to why he was not receiving the rent or whether he
had sold the tenanted premises to a third party. That, if in spite of
the receipt of the letter, Jeevan Agarwal failed to reply or explain
the reason for refusal of the monthly rent, then it would be
(2014) 11 SCC 438
RFA No.03 of 2022
M/s. Himal Match Co. Pvt. Ltd. and Another
vs. Smt. Kiran Agarwal
presumed that M/s. Balchand Agarwal was no longer the owner
and as such, rent would be sent to M/s. Mona Jyoti Investment
Company from whom he had received the above, Notice Exhibit P3.
The witness of the Appellant Company, Tanka Bahadur Chettri,
identified Exhibit D6 as the letter dated 09-04-2009, sent to
Jeevan Agarwal of M/s. Balchand Udairam by K. B. Biswakarma.
The witness asserted that Exhibit D6 is not a false and fabricated
document. The foregoing circumstances establish that the Eviction
Notice supra made the Appellants aware of the sale of the suit
premises to the Respondent and her ownership of it, thereby
despite lack of any specific communication informing the Appellants
of the sale and purchase, the Appellants were seized of the
situation and Exhibit P3 the Legal Notice suffices to establish that
the property had changed hands. In other words, sale of the suit
premises and the consequent transfer of property was in the
knowledge of the Appellant Company.
(iii)
Coming to the question of dilapidated condition of the
premises, Exhibit P2 is a letter dated 01-10-2008 issued to Kiran
Agarwal (Respondent) by the Assistant Town Planner II, UD&HD,
mentioning that the four storied building of the Respondent,
situated at Rangpo Bazar, had been inspected jointly by the
officers of the Town Planning Cell and Engineering Cell of UD&HD.
The inspection found that the building required to be retrofitted to
avoid any disaster due to structural failure of the building.
The
retrofitting works were to be completed within six months as
detailed in the letter supra at sl. no.1 to sl. no.6 therein. In this
context, apart from the evidence of the Respondent who identified
Exhibit P2, which stood the test of cross-examination, the witness
RFA No.03 of 2022
M/s. Himal Match Co. Pvt. Ltd. and Another
vs. Smt. Kiran Agarwal
of the Appellants testified that the building was in a poor condition.
Under cross-examination the fact that the building in which the suit
premises is located is very old and in a dilapidated condition was
extracted from the Appellants‘ witness.
The witness further
testified that on looking at the building, major retrofitting and
repair works are required to be done as it in a dilapidated
condition.
Thus, the evidence discussed above and Exhibit P2
establish that the property required retrofitting and strengthening.
(iv)
Coming to the question of requirement of the premises
for the personal use and occupation of the Respondent, in her
evidence she stated that she requires the suit premises for her
personal use and occupation as well as that of her husband as both
of them had decided to open an Office at Rangpo which is located
centrally between Darjeeling, Siliguri and Gangtok.
That, she
intended to open an office to expand their business. That, she and
her husband also intend to reside in the suit premises in their old
age, to oversee their business in Darjeeling, Siliguri and Gangtok.
These facts have not been demolished under cross-examination.
To support the evidence of the Plaintiff with regard to the
dilapidated condition of the suit premises and the requirement for
their personal occupation, the Respondent‘s husband Mahabir
Prasad Agarwal adduced evidence and supported the Respondent‘s
evidence on both counts. It concludes that the suit premises are
required for the personal use and occupation of the Respondent.
Relevant reference is made to the observation in Sidhharth Viyas
and Another
vs. Ravi Nath Misra and Others2 wherein the Hon‘ble
Supreme Court while referring to the decisions of Joginder Pal vs.
Naval Kishore Behal [(2002) 5 SCC 397] and Malpe Vishwanath
(2015) 2 SCC 701
RFA No.03 of 2022
M/s. Himal Match Co. Pvt. Ltd. and Another
vs. Smt. Kiran Agarwal
Acharya and Others vs. State of Maharashtra and Another [(1998) 2
SCC 1]
held that the object of the Rent Law is to balance the
competing claims of the landlord to recover possession and the
tenant to be protected from arbitrary eviction when there is acute
shortage of accommodation.
(v)
Coming to the question of rent arrears, the Respondent
as per the Appellants was not eligible to get rent arrears from 0102-2009 in view of the Article 52 of the Limitation Act.
This
provision provides for arrears of rent and the period of limitation is
three years, for which the time begins to run when the arrears
become due. The Respondent‘s case is that after the property was
purchased by her on 14-08-1991, the monthly rent has not been
paid to her by the Appellants. The evidence of the Appellants‘
witness is that Exhibit D2 (collectively) are the money orders
receipts, postal slips and deposit slips of the Post Office Savings
Bank, from February, 2009 to September, 2011 in respect of
monthly rent remitted by the Appellant Company, to M/s. Balchand
Udairam in respect of the rented premises. Perusal of Exhibit D2
(collectively) reveals that this pertains to the Post Office Savings
Bank Account of one K. B. Biswakarma and Money Order
Acknowledgement Cards. A sum of ₹ 250/- (Rupees two hundred
and fifty) only, has been deposited in the Post Office Savings Bank
A/c of K. B. Biswakarma in various months. It is unfathomable as
to how the Court is to presume that the amount deposited in the
account of K. B. Biswakarma was for the purpose of payment of
house rent to M/s. Balchand Udairam or the Respondent.
As
correctly noticed by the Learned Trial Court in its impugned
Judgment, K. B. Biswakarma who was the Constituted Attorney of
RFA No.03 of 2022
M/s. Himal Match Co. Pvt. Ltd. and Another
vs. Smt. Kiran Agarwal
the Appellants-Defendants No.1 and 2 and claimed to be a wellacquainted with the facts of the case having verified the written
statement on oath, failed to enter the witness box to substantiate
his averments, instead one Tanka Bahadur Chettri deposed for the
Appellants and he was unaware of matters pertaining to the suit.
The Learned Trial Court has held that the Respondent is entitled to
arrears of rent from September, 2015. No arguments have been
advanced as to why there should be no such payment. The finding
is accordingly upheld.
9.
While
addressing
the
question
of
mesne
profits,
Learned Counsel for the Respondent submitted that the mesne
profits had not been allowed by the Learned Trial Court. That, this
decision was not being assailed by the Respondent.
In view of the
submission of Learned Counsel for the Respondent with regard to
mesne profit no further discussions need ensue.
10.
In conclusion, questions no.(i) and (ii) framed above
are decided in favour of the Respondent. All conditions for eviction
and not only one, as required under Notification No.6326—600H&W—B, dated 14-04-1949 are fulfilled, viz., the Respondent has
established her personal requirement of the suit premises, that the
suit premises were in a dilapidated condition and that rent was not
paid to her by the Appellants.
The decision of the Learned Trial
Court on the issues settled by it for determination call for no
interference by this Court.
11.
Appeal dismissed.
12.
The Appellants shall vacate the suit premises within
three months from today and hand over vacant possession to the
Respondent.
RFA No.03 of 2022
M/s. Himal Match Co. Pvt. Ltd. and Another
13.
vs. Smt. Kiran Agarwal
The Appellants shall pay arrears of house rent from
September, 2015, till handing over of possession of the suit
premises to the Respondent.
14.
No order as to costs.
15.
Copy of this Judgment be forwarded to the Learned Trial
Court for information along with its records.
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
04-05-2023
Approved for reporting : Yes
ds
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review