Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
OPC 1986/24
2025:KER:28355
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE BASANT BALAJI
TUESDAY, THE 18TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 27TH PHALGUNA, 1946
OP(C) NO. 1986 OF 2024
CMA(Arb) NO.1355 OF 2023 OF DISTRICT COURT & SESSIONS COURT, ERNAKULAM
PETITIONER/S:
M/S. HEDGE FINANCE LIMITED,HEDGE HOUSE, MAMANGALAM, PALARIVATTOM,
ERNAKULAM, KOCHI- 682 025, REPRESENTED BY ITS AUTHORIZED SIGNATORY
MR. MADHU E, S/O KELAPPAN, AGED 42, VENKALLULLATHIL HOUSE,
MEPPAYUR, CALICUT DISTRICT., PIN - 673524
BY ADV C.S.MANILAL
RESPONDENT/S:
JACOB MATHEW,S/O LATE V C MATHEW, VADAKKAYIL HOUSE, VADAKODU P O,
KANGARAPADY, KOCHI, PIN - 682021
ALLAMAH GOLD INDIA PRIVATE LIMITED,
RODRICKS OPTICIANS, FOURTH FLOOR, CAPITAL TOWERS, GENERAL HOSPITAL
ROAD, MANJALIKULAM, THIRUVANANTHUPURAM DISTRICT, REPRESENTED BY
ITS DIRECTOR RAJAN M, THONGAL VILA VEEDU, NELLIMOODU P.O.,
THIRUVANANTHUPURAM, PIN - 695524
RAJAN M,S/O M MADHAVAN NADAR, THONGAL VILA VEEDU, NELLIMOODU P.O.,
THIRUVANANTHUPURAM DISTRICT,, PIN - 695524
RASHID AZHIKKODANTEKATH,
S/O ABDUL LATHEEF MUKKOTH, AZHIKKODANTEKATH HOUSE, CHALIL,
PAPPINISSERY, KANNUR DISTRICT,, PIN - 670561
BY ADV K.P.ARAVINDAKSHAN
OTHER PRESENT:
ADV JACOB MATHEW
THIS OP (CIVIL) HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON 18.03.2025, THE COURT ON
THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
OPC 1986/24
2025:KER:28355
JUDGMENT
(Dated this the 18th day of March 2025)
Petitioner is a public limited company, having its
registered office at Ernakulam. Respondents 2 to 4 entered into
a loan agreement on 09.01.2023, with the petitioner for the
purchase of a Power Generator. The loan agreement included
an arbitration clause stipulating that all disputes will be resolved
through arbitration under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act
1996, and an advocate was designated as the sole arbitrator.
2.
Respondents 1 to 3 received Rs.5,90,000 from the
petitioner to be paid in instalments, but defaulted on repayment.
Therefore, the petitioner filed CMA (Arb.) No. 920/2023 in the
2nd Additional District Court, Ernakulam, seeking the
appointment of an Advocate Commissioner to seize the
hypothecated generator and due to a mistake, that occurred in
the asset's location, the court-ordered seizure could not be
OPC 1986/24
2025:KER:28355
executed by the Commissioner.
3.
In the meantime, the 1st respondent, a non-party,
filed an application to get impleaded himself in the proceedings.
The petitioner, thereafter, filed a not press memo on 21.10.2023,
withdrawing CMA (Arb.) No. 920/2023. Later, the petitioner
filed CMA (Arb.) No. 1355/2023 before the VII Additional
District
Court,
Ernakulam,
to
appoint
an
Advocate
commissioner to take possession of the hypothecated assets,
which was allowed and an Advocate Commissioner was
deputed for the same. The Commissioner filed an interim report
requesting police assistance since she was subjected to physical
assault by the first respondent and the court granted the same
and the Advocate Commissioner successfully seized the asset
and handed it over to the petitioner.
4.
As per Ext P1, the petitioner issued a notice dated
10.11.2023, under Section 21 of the Arbitration Act, to
OPC 1986/24
2025:KER:28355
Respondents 2 to 4. Subsequently, the petitioner submitted a
Claim Statement to the designated Arbitrator and issued notice
dated 16.04.2024, to the parties to appear before him in Arb.
Ref. No. 613/2023. However, respondents 1 to 3 did not appear
and therefore, the petitioner filed IA No.1/2024, seeking
permission to sell the repossessed asset. This was allowed by
the tribunal, by order dated 31.07.2024.
5.
The 4th respondent, who was not initially a party
to the proceedings, filed Ext.P10 as I.A. No.07/2024 to be
impleaded himself in the party array, without serving a copy on
the petitioner. The court, without notice to the petitioner,
granted the impleadment by order dated 06.03.2024. The
petitioner then filed I.A.No. 09/2024, to set aside the
impleadment order and while the said I.A was pending, the 4th
respondent filed I.A.No. 10/2024, seeking permission to
examine the repossessed asset, to which the petitioner filed a
OPC 1986/24
2025:KER:28355
th
Counter. the 4 respondent filed a reply affidavit to the counter.
The court, after hearing the parties, allowed I.A. No.10/2024,
by Ext P15 order dated 14.08.2024, directing the petitioner to
release the asset to the 4th respondent. Challenging Ext P15,
present O.P.(C) stands filed.
6.
The counsel for the petitioner contends that the
petitioner in I.A. No 10/2024, the 1st respondent, being a
stranger to the proceedings, has no locus to get impleaded in the
proceedings and does not have vested title over the secured
asset. Further, he contended that the trial court, on a wrong
perspective, ordered the release of the secured asset to the 1st
respondent, and hence, Ext P15 order is perverse and illegal,
and is liable to be set aside, since a third party to the agreement
is not entitled to the relief under section 9 of the Arbitration Act.
7.
The counsel for the 1st respondent filed a counter
denying the averments in the petition. In the affidavit along with
OPC 1986/24
2025:KER:28355
the impleadment application, it is stated that the petitioner
herein was never in possession of the equipment in order to seek
possession of the same, whereas, it was in the possession of the
1st respondent who seeks for impleadment, which confers locus
standi upon him. Further, he contends the petition to be not
maintainable challenging the validity of the hypothecation
agreement so produced. Moreover, since CMA (Arb.) No.
920/2023 was dismissed as not pressed and without getting
leave of the court, the petitioner herein is not entitled to file a
second petition on the very same cause of action as provided
under Order 23 Rule 1(3)(b) CPC. Thus, the petitioner has come
up with the present CMA(Arb.), suppressing the fact regarding
the earlier petition filed. Thus, prayed for dismissal of this
O.P.(C).
8.
Heard counsels appearing on either sides.
OPC 1986/24
2025:KER:28355
st
9. Ext.P12 was filed by the 1 respondent herein,
seeking return of the goods hypothecated to the petitioner on
the premise that he wants to proceed against the asset referred
to in the present CMA (Arb.). It is found that the CMA (Arb.)
which was filed earlier by the petitioner herein, was dismissed
as not pressed due to the omission to mention the place where
the asset is stationed. This was the reason to not press the
erstwhile CMA and to file the present one, after curing the
mistake thus occurred. Thus, the present CMA (Arb) cannot be
said to be not maintainable.
10.
It is pertinent to note that the next question arose
in this O.P.(C) is that whether the 1st respondent, who is the
petitioner in I.A. No.10/2024, has locus standi to get impleaded
in the above proceedings, which is to be decided at a later stage,
after having an adjudication on I.A.No.9 of 2024, which is
pending. It is apposite in this context to read section 9 of the
OPC 1986/24
2025:KER:28355
Act, which is as follows;
“9. Interim measures, etc., by Court.-[(1)] A party may, before or
during arbitral proceedings or at any time after the making of the arbitral
award but before it is enforced in accordance with section 36, apply to a
Court:(i)
for the appointment of a guardian for a minor
or a person of unsound mind for the purposes of arbitral
proceedings; or
(ii)
for an interim measure of protection in respect
of any of the following matters, namely:(a) the preservation, interim custody or sale of any
goods which are the subject-matter of the arbitration
agreement;
(b) securing the amount in dispute in the arbitration;
(c) the detention, preservation or inspection of any
property or thing which is the subject-matter of the dispute
in arbitration, or as to which any question may arise
therein and authorising for any of the aforesaid purposes
any person to enter upon any land or building in the
possession of any party, or authorising any samples to be
taken or any observation to be made, or experiment to be
tried, which may be necessary or expedient for the purpose
of obtaining full information or evidence;
(d) interim injunction or the appointment of a
receiver;
(e) such other interim measure of protection as may
appear to the Court to be just and convenient,
and the Court shall have the same power for making orders
as it has for the purpose of, and in relation to, any
proceedings before it.
xxx xxx xxx ”
OPC 1986/24
2025:KER:28355
On going through the provision, a third party has no right to
invoke section 9 of the Arbitration Act. Reliance has been
placed on a decision rendered by the apex Court in Firm Ashok
Traders v. Gurumukh Das Saluja & Ors. (2004 (3) SCC
155), wherein it was held that the qualification a person should
possess while invoking the said section is of being a ‘party’ to
the arbitration agreement and a person not party to an
arbitration agreement, cannot enter the court for protection
under the said section.
11. This court in Shoney Sanil v. Coastal Foundations
(P) Ltd; reported in (2006 (1) KLT 915) held that the intention
of the legislature is explicit from the opening words of sec 9 of
the Arbitration Act itself that it confine to the matters relating
to the arbitration agreement between the parties only and this
can only as against the party to an agreement, or, at best, against
any person claiming under him.
OPC 1986/24
2025:KER:28355
12.
In Vijay Arvind Jariwala v. Umang Jatin
Gandhi; (2022 KHC 4539), it was held that interim measures
under Section 9 of the Arbitration Act are intended to operate
between the parties who are bound by the arbitration agreement
and including a non-party in Sec 9 of the Arbitration Act
proceedings would create complications, as the arbitrator's
jurisdiction is limited to disputes between the parties to the
arbitration agreement.
13. Going through the counter filed by the petitioner
herein to I.A. No.10 of 2024, the very locus standi of the 1st
respondent is challenged, relying on the dictum in Firm Ashok
Traders (supra), as held by the apex court. It is pertinent to
note that the prayer in I.A.No.10 of 2024 was to produce the
assets before the court for examination, while the relief granted
was to handover the movables to the 1st respondent, that too,
when an application as I.A. No.9 of 2024, filed by the petitioner
OPC 1986/24
2025:KER:28355
st
herein, to set aside the order of impleadment of the 1
respondent, is pending consideration. So, it is discernible that
I.A.No.9 of 2024 was to be considered first by the court below,
before passing a judgment in I.A.No.10 of 2024. Therefore, I
deem it appropriate to dispose of this O.P.(C) directing the
District Court, Ernakulam, to consider I.A.No.9 of 2024, which
is filed to set aside the order in I.A.No.7 of 2024, and then
resort to I.A.No.10 of 2024. It is also made clear that this court
has not gone into the merits of the case and it is left open for the
parties to take contentions before the court below.
Sd/-
BASANT BALAJI
JUDGE
dl/
OPC 1986/24
2025:KER:28355
APPENDIX OF OP(C) 1986/2024
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Exhibit P1
A COPY OF THE AGREEMENT DATED 09.01.2023 BETWEEN
PETITIONER AND RESPONDENTS 2 TO 4
Exhibit P2
A COPY OF THE CMA (ARB.) NO.920/2023 DATED
08.09.2023 BEFORE THE DISTRICT COURT, ERNAKULAM
Exhibit P3
A COPY OF THE NOT PRESS MEMO DATED 21.10.2023 IN
C M A (ARB) NO. 920/2023 BEFORE THE DISTRICT
COURT ERANAKULAM
Exhibit P4
A COPY OF THE APPLICATION FILED IN CMA (ARB.)
NO.1355/2023 DATED 07.12.2023 BEFORE THE DISTRICT
COURT ERANAKULAM
Exhibit P5
A COPY OF THE COMMISSION APPLICATION DATED
07.12.2023 AS IA NO.03/2023 FILED IN CMA (ARB.)
NO.1355/2023 BEFORE THE DISTRICT COURT ERANAKULAM
Exhibit P6
A COPY OF THE INTERIM REPORT OF THE ADVOCATE
COMMISSIONER DATED 26.02.2024 IN IA NO.03/2023 IN
CMA (ARB.) NO.1355/2023 BEFORE THE DISTRICT COURT
ERANAKULAM
Exhibit P7
A COPY OF 2ND COMMISSION REPORT FIELD BY THE
ADVOCATE COMMISSIONER 2024 IN IA NO.03/2023 IN
CMA (ARB.) NO.1355/2023 BEFORE THE DISTRICT COURT
ERANAKULAM
Exhibit P8
A COPY OF THE NOTICE DATED 10.11.2023 UNDER
SECTION 21 OF THE ARBITRATION AND CONCILIATION
ACT
Exhibit P9
A COPY OF THE ORDER IN IA NO.1/2024 DATED
31.07.2024 IN ARB. REF. NO.613/2023 BEFORE THE
ARBITRAL TRIBUNAL KOCHI
Exhibit P10
A COPY OF THE APPLICATION TO IMPLEAD THE 4TH
RESPONDENT AS IA NO.7/2024 DATED 04.03.2024 IN
CMA (ARB.) NO.1355/2023 BEFORE THE DISTRICT COURT
ERANAKULAM
Exhibit P11
A COPY OF IA NO.09/2024 IN IA NO.7/2024 IN DATED
25.03.2024 IN CMA (ARB.) NO.1355/2023 BEFORE THE
DISTRICT COURT ERANAKULAM
OPC 1986/24
2025:KER:28355
Exhibit P12
A COPY OF THE IA NO.10/2024 DATED 18.05.2024 IN
CMA (ARB.) NO.1355/2023 BEFORE THE DISTRICT COURT
ERANAKULAM
Exhibit P13
A COPY OF THE COUNTER AFFIDAVIT IN IA NO.10/2024
IN CMA (ARB.) NO.1355/2023 DATED 29.06.2024
BEFORE THE DISTRICT COURT ERANAKULAM
Exhibit P14
A COPY OF THE REPLY AFFIDAVIT IN IA NO.10/2024 IN
CMA (ARB.) NO.1355/2023 DATED 5.7.2024 BEFORE THE
DISTRICT COURT ERANAKULAM
Exhibit P15
A COPY OF THE ORDER DATED 14.8.2024 IN IA
NO.10/2024 IN CMA (ARB.) NO.1355/2023 OF THE
DISTRICT COURT ERANAKULAM
Exhibit P16
A COPY OF THE IA NO.11/2024 DATED 14.08.2024 IN
CMA (ARB.) NO.1355/2023 BEFORE THE DISTRICT COURT
ERANAKULAM
RESPONDENT EXHIBITS
Exhibit R1(b)
True copy of the certified copy of the CMA
(Arb)No. 920/2023 (Exhibit P4) dated 08.09.2023
Exhibit R1(c)
True copy of the certified copy of invoice dated
07.12.2023
Exhibit R1(a)
True copy of the certified copy of the CMA
(Arb)No. 1355/2023 (Exhibit P4) dated 07.12.2023
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review