Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Form No. J(2)
Sl. No. 18
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Before:
THE HON’BLE JUSTICE RAJA BASU CHOWDHURY
WPA 29647 of 2025
M/s. Haji Munna Miah and
Company Private Limited & Ors.
Vs.
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
For the Petitioners
:
Mr. Rudranil De, Adv.
Mr. Nemai Chandra Betal, Adv.
For the KMC
:
Mr. Biswajit Mukherjee, Adv.
Ms. Debangana De, Adv.
For the State
:
Mr. Sukanta Ghosh, Adv.
Mr. Arghya Chatterjee, Adv.
For KMDA/respondent no. 4 :
Mr. Satyjit Talukder, Adv.
Mr. Arindam Chatterjee, Adv.
Hearing Concluded on
:
1st July, 2026.
Judgment on
:
1st July, 2026.
RAJA BASU CHOWDHURY, J.:
1.
Considering the objection raised by Mr. Talukder, learned advocate
representing the KMDA, leave is granted to the learned advocate for the
WPA 29647 of 2025
petitioners to correct the cause title insofar as respondent no. 4 is
concerned in course of the day.
2.
The petitioners being aggrieved by change and alteration of municipal
records whereby the names of the petitioners stood deleted and the name
of Kolkata Improvement Trust (KIT) having registered office at P-16 India
Exchange Place (Extension), 6th Floor, Kolkata – 700073 stood inserted in
respect of premises no. 22, Uday Sankar Sarani, Kolkata - 700033
pertaining to assessee no. 210940301002, the instant writ petition has
been filed.
3.
According to the petitioners, the aforesaid alteration has been made
without notice and/or affording opportunity of hearing to the petitioners.
When the matter was taken up for consideration on 20 th January, 2026
this Court having regard to the case made out by the petitioners had
directed that the status quo in respect of the assessing property shall be
maintained.
Such
interim
order
is
subsisting.
The
municipality
subsequently filed a report duly countersigned by the Assessor Collector
AC (T Tax) Department, KMC wherein it was observed that change of
ownership was done as per the order of the Municipal Commissioner
dated 11th March, 2011, as per IB records with effect from 3 rd quarter of
2005-2006.
4.
Mr. Talukder, learned advocate representing the KMDA had, however,
submitted before this Court that the entire premise being premise no. 22,
WPA 29647 of 2025
Golf Club Road, (Now Uday Sankar Sarani Road), Kolkata which forms
subject matter of the writ petition had been acquired following which this
Court directed the respondent no. 4 to produce the KIT Scheme 118
showing the extent of acquisition of premise no. 22, Golf Club Road,
Kolkata. Later, by an order dated 17th June, 2026 this Court had directed
the respondent no. 5 being the First Land Acquisition Collector to be
personally present in Court along with records when the matter is taken
up next. In pursuance of such direction, Mr. Biswajit Roy Chowdhury,
Assistant Director, WBLRS is personally present in Court with the records,
as such the presence of the respondent no. 5 is excused.
5.
Mr. Ghosh, learned advocate representing the State has by placing before
this Court the notification dated 31st May, 1968 issued under sub-section
(1) of Section 49 of the Kolkata Improvement Act, 1911 (hereinafter as the
“said Act”) would submit that a scheme had been notified for general
information that in exercise of powers conferred under Section 48 of the
said Act and the Governor had been pleased to sanction the General
Improvement Scheme known as Scheme 118 (Tollygunge Area, Prince
Gulam Md. Shah Road – Golf Club Road) ward no. 95/96 of the
Corporation of Calcutta (now Kolkata) which had seen been submitted by
the Board of Trustees for the improvement of Kolkata under Section 47 of
the said Act. The boundaries of the scheme area have duly been indicated
in such notification and the list of premises which were proposed to be
acquired and the list of premises which were scheduled for levy of
WPA 29647 of 2025
betterment fees in terms of the said Act which were not proposed to be
acquired have also been indicated. As would appear therefrom, the
premises no. 22, Golf Club Road in its entirety was sought to be acquired.
He submits by placing before this Court the copy of the award passed
under Section 11 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 that the entirety of the
premises being 22, Golf Club Road, Kolkata comprising of area of 6 bighas
18 kathas 12 chittaks and 35 sqaure feet have been acquired. Not only the
compensation
therefor
but
also
the
enhanced
compensation
was
disbursed in favour of the claimants. The endorsement made on the copy
of the award showing disbursement of payment of compensation in favour
of the claimants would also corroborate therefrom.
6.
Having regard to the same, it is submitted, since, entirety of the premises
no. 22, Golf Club Road, Kolkata was acquired, there is no irregularity on
the part of the municipality in recording the same in the name of the
KMDA (erstwhile Calcutta Improvement Trust) for whom the acquisition
was made.
7.
Mr. Talukder, learned advocate supports such cause and would submit
that the petitioners at all material point of time was aware with regard to
the aforesaid. He has also placed before this Court the copy of the KIT
Scheme no. 118 and the original plan thereof has also been produced.
Upon perusal of the original plan, the same is returned to the respondents
by retaining the copy of the scheme on the file.
WPA 29647 of 2025
8.
Mr. De, learned advocate representing the petitioner has, however, drawn
the attention of this Court to the title deed in vernacular, executed by Sk.
Md. Fazel in favour of Sk. Munno, S/O Sk. Rhmatulla, the predecessor of
the petitioners. By placing reliance on the schedule of the aforesaid title
deed he would submit that what was conveyed in favour of the petitioners’
predecessor vide the title deed was 6 acres of raytee sthitiban land. The
acquisition was only for 6 bighas, the same does not take away the title of
the petitioners who are the successor in interest of the aforesaid Sk.
Munnoo, in respect of the entirety of the property. He has also drawn the
attention of this Court to the document appearing at page 41 of the writ
petition being a letter issued by the Kolkata Improvement Trust and the
order passed by the Co-ordinate Bench dated 28 th November, 2013
directing consideration of the petitioners’ representation by the Land
Acquisition Authorities.
9.
Independent of the aforesaid he would submit that the petitioners’ name
should be recorded in the records of the KMC and without giving
opportunity of hearing the name ought not to have been removed. He
further submits that despite directions passed by this Court, the orders
based on which the aforesaid deletion of the petitioners’ name was made,
could not be produced by the respondents. As such, in the fitness of
things, the petitioners’ name should be restored in the file and at least, an
opportunity should be given to the petitioners to make appropriate
representation.
WPA 29647 of 2025
10. Having heard the learned advocates appearing for the respective parties
and having considered the materials on record, I find that in the instant
case a notification was published in terms of Section 49(1) of the said Act
whereby the State Government had sanctioned the scheme. To more fully
appreciate the scope of Section 49(1) of the said Act, the same is extracted
hereinbelow:“49. Notification of sanction to improvement scheme. (1) Whenever the [State Government] [Words substituted by the Adaptation
of Laws Order, 1950.] sanctions an improvement scheme, it shall
announce the fact by notification, and the Board shall forthwith proceed to
execute the scheme.”
11. The said scheme as produced, as also the above notification, not only
identifies boundaries of the area which is comprised in the scheme but the
same also identifies the premises proposed to be acquired. Incidentally,
the premises no. 22 Golf Club Road (now renamed as Uday Sankar Sarani)
Kolkata forms part of the acquisition. The said notification also deals with
the list of premises which were scheduled for levy of betterment fee in
respect whereof the acquisition was not proceeded with. I do not find from
the aforesaid document that premises no. 22, Golf Club Road now Uday
Sankar Sarani was acquired in part. Although, Mr. De has tried to make
out a case by relying on the title deed that the petitioners’ interest in the
premises in question was far greater and the entirety of the premises was
not acquired, however, having regard to the publication of the scheme
effected on 31st May, 1968, I find that it is too late for the petitioners to
WPA 29647 of 2025
raise such issue and for this Court to accept such contention that too in
exercise of the writ jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India.
12. This apart there is another aspect of the matter. Though, Mr. De would
submit that the petitioners are in possession of the property, I am of the
view, once, an award is passed and the possession thereof is taken over
under Section 16 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, the subsequent entry
into such property cannot be considered to be a legal possession by the
owner who has lost its right, as once possession is taken under Section 16
thereof, the right of the owner in the said property extinguishes and the
possession itself is deemed to be free from all encumbrances.
13. Independent of the above, it has also been pointed out by Mr. De that the
petitioners’ name continued in the records of the municipal authorities,
and that the municipal authorities all of a sudden had removed the name
of the petitioners from the records. On this score, I find that the
petitioners were not given opportunity of hearing. Though, the petitioners
would insist that in their case an opportunity of hearing should be
granted, I am of the view ,in the given facts, when the petitioners are
unable to establish any right over the property, no fruitful purpose will be
served by directing the municipality to consider the issue of deletion of the
petitioners’ name, especially when the municipality is not competent to
adjudicate on the title.
WPA 29647 of 2025
14. This order shall, however, not interfere with the rights of the petitioners to
establish its cause in appropriate proceedings before appropriate forum, if
so advised.
15. Since, no affidavits have been called for from the respondents, the
allegations made in the writ petition are deemed not to have been
admitted by the respondents.
16. With the aforesaid directions, the writ petition stands disposed of.
17. There shall be no order as to costs.
18. Let urgent Photostat certified copy of this judgment, if applied for, be
supplied to the parties on usual undertaking.
(Raja Basu Chowdhury, J.)
SG. A.R (Ct.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review