Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
signed by
CHONGNUNKI Digitally
CHONGNUNKIM GANGTE
Date: 2023.01.10 14:37:21
M GANGTE
+05'30'
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No. 333 of 2022 with WP(C) No. 334 of 2022 with
WP(C) No. 335 of 2022 with WP(C) No. 336 of 2022 with
WP(C) No. 337 of 2022 with WP(C) No. 338 of 2022 with
WP(C) No. 339 of 2022 with WP(C) No. 340 of 2022 with
WP(C) No. 341of 2022 with WP(C) No. 342 of 2022
Ema Ebema Langol Lairembi Construction, represented
by its Proprietor, Shri Khomdram Surendra Kumar Singh,
aged about 43 years, s/o Shir Khomdram Tombi Singh,
Naoremthong Khulem Leikail, P.O & P.S Lamphelpat,
Imphal West District, Manipur - 795004
....Petitioner
-Versus1. The State of Manipur, represented through the Addl.
Chief Secretary (Tribal Affairs & Hills), Government of
Manipur, Old Secretariat, Babupara, P.O & P.S. Imphal,
Imphal West District, Manipur – 795001
2. The Director (Tribal Affairs & Hills), Government of
Manipur, Old Secretariat, Babupara, P.O & P.S.Imphal,
Imphal West District, Manipur-795001
3. The
Executive
Engineer
(Tribal
Affairs
&
Hills),
Government of Manipur, Babupara, P.O & P.S.Imphal,
Imphal West District, Manipur-795001
.. Respondents
WP(C)No. 333 of 2022 & Ors
Page 1
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE AHANTHEM BIMOL SINGH
For the Petitioner ::
Dr. R.K Deepak, Advocate
For the Respondents::
Mr. A. Vashum, Govt. Advocate
Dates of hearing
::
10-10-2022
Date of judgment/ ::
Order
10-01-2023
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
(C A V)
Heard Dr. R.K Deepak, learned counsel appearing
for the petitioner and Mr. A. Vashum, learned GA appearing for
the respondents.
[2]
The present ten writ petitions had been filed with
the prayer, inter alia, for quashing and setting aside the
impugned orders dated 26-04-2022, which cancelled the work
orders dated 12-06-2020 issued in favor of the petitioner, as
well as for quashing and setting aside the fresh NITs dated 1105-2022 and also for directing the respondents to allow the
petitioner to commence the contract work by re-scheduling the
date of commencement of the work.
As the facts and issues involved in the ten writ
petitions are the same, all the writ petitions were heard jointly
and being disposed of by this common judgment and order.
WP(C)No. 333 of 2022 & Ors
Page 2
[3]
The petitioner is a registered special
class
contractor in the department of Tribal Affairs & Hills,
Government of Manipur. The case of the petitioner is that with a
view to enhance infrastructure development in the hills district of
Manipur, the State Cabinet took a decision in its meeting held
on 12-10-2019 to adopt restricted tender for the contract work
of infrastructure development of 3 (three) Eklavya Model
Residential School (EMRS) at Moreh, Tamenglong & Gamnom,
Sapermaina. Pursuant to the said Cabinet decision, the Under
Secretary (Tribal Affairs & Hills), Government of Manipur sent a
proposal to the Director, Tribal Affairs & Hills, Govt. of Manipur
to adopt restricted tender in respect of the contract works for
infrastructure development for the said three EMRS where
estimated cost of each work is less than 1.5 crore, vide letter
dated 25-10-2019. After obtaining the approval
of the
Government, the Executive Engineer, Tribal Affairs & Hills,
Government of Manipur issued three separate notices bearing
numbers 2, 3 & 4, all dated 10-02-2020 inviting restricted sealed
tender
from
intending
approved
and
eligible
registered
contractors of the department for execution of the works
mentioned in the said NITs.
[4]
The petitioner submitted bids in respect of 10 (ten)
works and having found to be the lowest bidder and having
fulfilled all the terms and conditions of the tender, the petitioner
was awarded the following works by issuing ten separate work
orders all dated 12-06-2020 issued by the Executive EngineerII, Tribal Affairs & Hills, Manipur :(a) Eklavya Model Residential School, Tamenglong :
WP(C)No. 333 of 2022 & Ors
Page 3
(i)
Renovation of school building;
(ii)
Renovation of hostel building Block – A and
construction of toilet block and septic tank;
Renovation of hostel building Block – B and
(iii)
construction of toilet block and septic tank;
and
(iv)
Construction and Science Block i/c internal
electrification
(b) Eklavya Model Residential School, Moreh, Tengnoupal:
(i)
Construction of Science Block;
(ii)
Construction
of
four
numbers
of
Staff
numbers
of
Staff
School,
Gamnom,
quarters Block – A; and
(iii)
Construction
of
four
quarters Block - B
(c) Eklavya
Model
Residential
Sapermaina:
(i)
Construction of Science Block;
(ii)
Construction of hostel building Block – A; and
(iii)
Construction of hostel building Block – B.
As per the said work orders, the time allowed for
executing the work was given as 12 (twelve) months and the
following terms and conditions were also given:Terms and Condition
1. You are requested to attend the office of the
undersigned to complete the Agreement and
other formalities within 7 days from the issue of
the letter.
WP(C)No. 333 of 2022 & Ors
Page 4
2. The date of start of the work is reckoned from
18.06.2020 i.e, seven days from the date of
issue work order to commence the work shown
in the scheduled.
3. Your attention is drawn to clause 1 of the
contract hereby time allowed for carrying out the
work as entered in the tender shall be strictly
observed by you. The progress work be
mentioned corresponding to the time given time
of completion. If 50% of the work is not executed
within the given time of completion of the work, it
is the sufficient ground of cancellation of the
work.
4. The undersigned is not liable for any payment
for work (s) done/executed completed after the
stipulated time.
5. The work should be carried out as per the
specification and estimates enclosed herewith
and failure of which this office is not responsible
for payment.
6. You are to contact the Assistant Engineer incharge of the work immediately and obtain the
necessary technical guidance and selection of
works site etc.
before the commencement of
the work.
7. No materials shall be issued by the department.
WP(C)No. 333 of 2022 & Ors
Page 5
8. Constructions should be strictly based to the
speculation as per Design & Drawing of the
Department.
[5]
After the issuance of the NIT dated 10-02-2020 and
before issuing the work orders dated 12-06-2020, the
Government of India imposed total lockdown in the whole
country due to the pandemic of Covid-19 from the later part of
March, 2020. Even after partial lifting of the total lockdown
imposed by the Government of India, the State Government
continued to impose total lockdown in the whole state to contain
the pandemic of Covid-19 and to safeguard the health and lives
of the citizens. It is also the case of the petitioner that the
premises of all the three EMRSs’ at Tamenglong, Sapermaina
and Moreh were utilized as quarantine centers from the month
of May, 2020 as per the orders of the concerned District
Magistrate and only after the issuance of the order dated 02-112021, the Government stopped utilizing the said three school
premises as quarantine centers for covid patients. According to
the petitioner, during the period from the month of May, 2020 till
the month of November, 2020, the premises of the said three
schools were utilized by the Government as quarantine
centers/containment zone and because of the strict restriction
imposed by the Government, movement in and around the
premises of the said three schools were strictly prohibited. Due
to the aforesaid situation prevailing in the state of Manipur, the
petitioner could not start execution of the work within the period
WP(C)No. 333 of 2022 & Ors
Page 6
stipulated under the terms and conditions No. 2 of the work
order dated 12-06-2020.
[6]
On
30-11-2020,
the
petitioner
submitted
a
representation to the Executive Engineer – II, Tribal Affairs &
Hills, Government of Manipur requesting for giving necessary
technical guidance and selection of work site so as to enable
him to start the work and complete the same on time. Instead of
providing necessary technical guidance and selection of work
site as requested by the petitioner, the Executive Engineer – II,
Tribal Affairs & Hills, Government of Manipur, issued an order
dated 01-12-2020 cancelling the 10 (ten) work orders issued in
favor of the petitioner on the ground that the petitioner failed to
start executing the work within the time stipulated under clause
(2) of the terms and conditions of the work orders.
[7]
After issuance of the cancellation order dated 01-
12-2020, the Executive Engineer – II, Tribal Affairs & Hills,
Government of Manipur, issued an NIT dated 07-12-2020 in
respect of the same works earlier awarded to the petitioner.
Having been aggrieved, the petitioner assailed the cancellation
order dated 01-12-2020 and NIT dated 07-12-2020 by filing a
writ petition being WP(C) No. 648 of 2020 before this Court. In
the said writ petition, this Court passed an interim order on 1512-2020 to the effect that fresh tender process in respect of the
contract work involved in the writ petition should not be finalized
without the leave of the Court. During the pendency of the said
writ petition, the Executive Engineer – II, Tribal Affairs & Hills,
Government of Manipur issued an order dated 13-01-2021
cancelling the earlier cancellation order dated 01-12-2020
WP(C)No. 333 of 2022 & Ors
Page 7
impugned in the above mentioned writ petition. After issuance of
the
subsequent
order
dated
31-01-2021,
the
petitioner
submitted a representation dated 14-01-2021 to the Executive
Engineer – II, Tribal Affairs & Hills, Government of Manipur
requesting to provide technical support, laying/measurement of
the work site, to furnish drawing schedule of quantity and site
identification of the said work so as to enable the petitioner to
start the work as soon as possible and for timely execution of
the work. On the same day of submitting the said representation
by the petitioner, the Executive Engineer – II, Tribal Affairs &
Hills, Government of Manipur issued a show cause notice dated
14-01-2021 directing the petitioner to submit in writing within 7
(seven) days as to why he could not execute the works awarded
to him within the period stipulated under clause (2) of the terms
and conditions of the work order. In response to the said show
cause notice, the petitioner submitted his reply in writing on 1901-2021 explaining in detail the reasons for the inability to
commence the works.
[8]
The petitioner challenged the said show cause
notice dated 14-01-2021 by filing a writ petition being WP(C)
No. 233of 2021 before this Court and during the pendency of
the said writ petition, the Executive Engineer – II, Tribal Affairs &
Hills, Government of Manipur issued an order dated 17-03-2021
cancelling the earlier NITs dated 10-02-2020 as well as the
subsequent NIT dated 07-12-2020. Having been aggrieved, the
petitioner challenged the said cancellation order dated 17-032021 by filing WP(C) No. 868 of 2021 before this Court to
redress his grievances. During the pendency of the aforesaid
WP(C)No. 333 of 2022 & Ors
Page 8
writ petitions, the Executive Engineer – II, Tribal Affairs & Hills,
Government of Manipur, issued another order dated 01-12-2021
thereby restoring the earlier NITs dated 10-02-2020. In view of
the restoration of the earlier NITs dated 10-02-2020, this Court
disposed of all the pending writ petitions by passing common
orders dated 06-12-2021 and 08-12-2021. In the said common
orders, this Court directed the State respondents to re-schedule
the time period that has been prescribed in the work order dated
12-06-2020. The petitioner communicated the orders passed by
this Court to the Executive Engineer – II, Tribal Affairs & Hills,
Government of Manipur, by submitting a representation dated
27-12-2021 and also requested to allow the petitioner to
commence the works and to extend the time period for
completion of the work.
[9]
Instead of allowing the petitioner to commence
work by re-scheduling the time period prescribed in the work
order, the Executive Engineer – II, Tribal Affairs & Hills,
Government of Manipur issued an order dated 29-12-2021
cancelling, for the second time all the earlier work orders issued
in favor of the petitioner. Thereafter, the Executive Engineer – II,
Tribal Affairs & Hills, Government of Manipur issued another
three NITs all dated 13-01-2022 in respect of the same work
awarded earlier to the petitioner and without cancelling the first
NITs dated 10-02-2020. Having been aggrieved, the petitioner
challenge the said cancellation order dated 29-12-2021 as well
as the new NITs dated 13-01-2022 by filing WP(C) No. 50 of
2022 and other analogous case before this Court. In the said
writ petitions, this Court passed an interim order on 25-01-2022
WP(C)No. 333 of 2022 & Ors
Page 9
directing that the impugned NITs shall remain suspended.
Subsequently, the Executive Engineer – II, Tribal Affairs & Hills,
Government of Manipur, issued two orders dated 04-03-2022
and 09-03-2022 cancelling the impugned NITs as well as the
impugned cancellation order dated 29-12-2021. In view of the
said two orders, all the writ petitions filed by the writ petitioner
challenging the said NITs and the impugned cancellation order
were closed as infructuous.
[10]
The State Government filed a batch of writ appeals
challenging the common orders dated 06-12-2021, 08-12-2021
and 10-12-2021 passed by the learned Single Judge in the
batch of writ petitions directing the state authorities to reschedule the time period that was prescribed in the work order
issued in favor of the petitioner. All the writ appeals were
disposed of by a common order dated 28-03-2022 passed in
Writ Appeal No. 6 of 2022 and other analogous writ appeals by
setting aside the direction given by the learned Single Judge to
re-schedule the time period for execution of the work pursuant
to the work order issued in June, 2020. The Appellate Court
further directed the authorities to consider the reply submitted
by the petitioner in response to the show cause notice dated 1401-2021 by giving an opportunity of personal hearing and
thereafter, to decide each case as to whether there was any
willful delay or negligence on the part of the contractor
concerned warranting punitive action. The Appellate Court
further observed that in the event, no such lapse is found to be
attributable to the contractor concerned, the authorities shall reschedule the time period for the execution of works.
WP(C)No. 333 of 2022 & Ors
Page 10
[11]
In compliance with the directions given by the
Division Bench of this Court in its common order dated 28-032022, the Additional Chief Secretary (TA & Hills), Government
of Manipur, issued an order dated 26-04-2022 cancelling all the
work orders dated 12-06-2022 awarded to the petitioner and
also directing to issue fresh tenders and fresh work orders.
Having been aggrieved, the petitioner filed the present writ
petitions assailing the said order dated 26-04-2022 for
redressing his grievances.
In the present writ petitions, this Court passed
interim order dated 13-05-2022 suspending the operation of the
impugned cancellation order dated 26-04-2022 and directing the
authorities not to take up any action for issuing a fresh NIT in
respect of the contract work involved in the writ petitions with
leave of this Court.
[12]
During the pendency of the present writ petitions,
the Executive Engineer – II, Tribal Affairs & Hills, Government of
Manipur issue three fresh NITs all dated 11-05-2022 in respect
of the works earlier awarded to the petitioner. The said NITs
were challenged by the petitioner by filing miscellaneous
applications being MC(WP(C)) No. 163 of 2022 and other
analogous applications. In the said applications, this Court
passed an interim order on 23-05-2022 suspending the
impugned NITs dated 11-05-2022.
[13]
Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner
submitted that before issuance of impugned order dated 26-042022, the work orders awarded to the petitioner were cancelled
by the authorities on two earlier occasions. At the first instance
WP(C)No. 333 of 2022 & Ors
Page 11
of cancellation, the reason given by the authorities was for noncommencement of the execution of work as per clause (2) of the
terms and conditions of the work order. Subsequently, the
authorities revoked the cancellation order suo moto by issuing
another order, which clearly indicated that the reason for
cancellation of the work order was unjustified. At the time of
issuing the second cancellation order, no reason whatsoever
was given by the authorities for cancelling the said work orders.
Later on, the second cancellation order was again revoked by
the authorities suo moto, thereby clearly indicating that there
was no justifiable reason for cancelling the work orders awarded
to the petitioner. For the third time, the authorities again
cancelled the work orders awarded to the petitioner by issuing
the impugned orders dated 26-04-2022. The only reason given
by the authorities for such cancellation is for breach of clause
(2) of the terms and conditions of the work orders dated 12-062020.
[14]
Learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that
under clause (2) of the terms and conditions of the work order,
there is no term and condition for cancellation of the work orders
if the contractor breach any of the conditions mentioned therein.
Only under clause (3) of the said terms and conditions, it is
provided that if 50% of the work is not executed within the given
time of completion of the work, it will be sufficient ground for
cancellation of the work. Learned counsel further submitted that
as the authorities cancelled the work orders dated 12-06-2020
awarded to the petitioner on -1-12-2020 well before the expiry of
the given period for execution of the work, there was no reason
WP(C)No. 333 of 2022 & Ors
Page 12
whatsoever for cancelling the work orders awarded to the
petitioner. Learned counsel accordingly submitted that the
authorities have acted arbitrarily and unreasonably in issuing
the impugned order and such action deserved interference from
this Court by quashing and setting aside the impugned order
dated 26-04-2022.
[15]
Learned counsel also submitted that as there was
no justifiable reason for cancellation of the work orders awarded
to the petitioner and as the authorities have not yet cancelled
the earlier NIT dated 10-02-2020, there was no reason for
issuing the impugned NITs dated 11-05-2022 and that the
authorities have issued the impugned NIT without application of
mind and accordingly, the impugned NITs are also liable to be
quashed and set aside.
[16]
It is also submitted that in spite of the best intention
and effort on the part of the petitioner, work at the allotted sites
could not be started because of the prevailing situation in the
State due to the pandemic of Covid-19. After the award of the
work order, the petitioner was unable to commence the work
because of several restrictions in entering the work site as the
premises of the three EMRS were declared as containment
zone. It is submitted that during the said period, procuring
construction materials like cement and steel was almost
impossible and as the prices of whatever little materials
available in the market have skyrocketed, it was not feasible to
execute the work under the sanction amount. It has also been
submitted that there was also acute shortage of labour as the
labour force was unwilling to work under the prevailing Covid-19
WP(C)No. 333 of 2022 & Ors
Page 13
situation and that the Government SOP issued in connection
with the Covid-19 pandemic prohibits labour force to work in
groups. It has also been submitted that if the authorities gave a
little co-operation, the petitioner could have completed the work
within the stipulated time.
[17]
Learned counsel also submitted that, the authorities
ignored the request of the petitioner to provide technical
guidance and selection of work site etc., which are required to
be followed as per the terms and conditions of the work order
before commencing the work and that without specifically
identifying the work site, without providing the specific task to be
done and without providing the technical guidance as to how the
task are to be performed, it was not feasible and practicable for
the petitioner to execute the work. It is also submitted that the
work orders awarded to the petitioner have been cancelled
without giving any valid and justifiable reason and by ignoring
the reply to the show cause notice as well as the
reasons/explanations given therein. Accordingly, the action of
the authorities in cancelling the work orders are arbitrary, bias,
unlawful and illegal. Learned counsel also submitted that the
authorities made an unreasonable allegation against the
petitioner in the impugned order that the petitioner failed to start
execution of the work despite lapse of more than 18 (eighteen)
months. In this regard, learned counsel for the petitioner
submitted that the reason for non-commencement of the
execution of work was due to non- cooperation of the on the
part of the officials of the department in giving technical
guidance and selection of work site as well as the impossibility
WP(C)No. 333 of 2022 & Ors
Page 14
of commencing the work during the pandemic of Covid-19 and
that the authorities never consider this valid reason at the time
of issuing the impugned order.
[18]
In the impugned order, the authorities observed
that the petitioner executed the work for upgradation/renovation
of “Museum and Amp: Internal Electricity Installation of Tribal
Research Institute (TRI)” under the same department whereas
the petitioner failed to execute the present works. In that regard,
it has been submitted that the execution of work at TRI and
execution of work at the three EMRS are not comparable for the
following reasons:
i. Unlike the work site at EMRS Tamenglong, the
work site at the TRI was not a Covid-19 quarantine
center and as such there was no restriction in
visiting the work site.
ii. There was no restriction in movement around the
work site at the TRI.
iii. The work at TRI was executed after the Covid
restriction were slightly relaxed.
iv. Unlike in the case of the work at EMRS
Tamenglong, selection of work site and technical
guidance were given in the case of the work at the
TRI.
v. The work site at the TRI is located at the heart of
Imphal city, making it easier for the Petitioner to
mobilize labour, raw material and prices of goods.
WP(C)No. 333 of 2022 & Ors
Page 15
[19]
Mr. A. Vashum, learned G.A. appearing for the
respondents, submitted that the petitioner was awarded the
contract works for infrastructure development of EMRS at
Tamenglong, Gamnom, Sapermeina and Moreh by issuing work
the orders dated 12.06.2020. As per the terms and conditions of
the contract work, the petitioner was to attend the office of the
respondents to complete the agreement and other formalities
within 7 (seven) days from the date of the issue of the work
order. Secondly, the petitioner was to start execution of the work
from 18.06.2020, i.e., 7 (seven) days after the date of issue of
the work order. Thirdly, if the petitioner does not execute 50
percent of the work within the time allocated for completion of
the work, it is sufficient ground for cancellation of the work
order. Fourthly, as soon as the work order was issued, the
petitioner was to contact the Assistant Engineer In-charge of the
work immediately and obtain a necessary technical guidance
and selection of work site etc. before the commencement of the
work.
[20]
The learned G.A. further submitted that in spite of
obtaining the work order dated 12.06.2020, the petitioner never
contacted the Assistant Engineer In-charge of the work and also
did not complete the agreement and other formalities as
stipulated in the terms and conditions of the contract work. It
has also been stated that since the petitioner did not contact the
Assistant Engineer In-charge of the work and since the
petitioner did not commence the work within the stipulated time,
the authorities cancelled the work order on 01.12.2020 in terms
WP(C)No. 333 of 2022 & Ors
Page 16
and conditions under clause (1), (2), (3) & (6) of the terms and
conditions of the work order.
[21]
The learned G.A. submitted that the Division Bench
of this Court disposed of the batch of writ appeals filed by the
State Government by common order dated 28.03.2022 by
setting aside the direction given by the learned Single Judge to
re-schedule the time period for execution of the work. While
disposing of the said batch of writ appeals, the Division Bench
also directed the authorities to consider the reply submitted by
the petitioner in response to the show cause notice dated
14.01.2021 by giving an opportunity of personal hearing and
thereafter to decide each individual case as to whether there
was any willful delay or negligence on the part of the contractor
warranting punitive action. It has been submitted that in
compliance with the order passed by the learned Division
Bench, the authorities heard the petitioner in person and also
considered the reply submitted by him in response to the show
cause notice dated 14.01.2021 and passed the impugned order
dated 26.04.2022 thereby cancelling the work orders awarded
to the petitioner.
[22]
The learned G.A. also submitted that the authorities
issued similar work orders to different contractors for executing
the work of water harvesting and solar pumps installation in the
same 3 (three) schools, i.e., EMRS at Tamenglong, Gamnom,
Sapermeina and Moreh, Tengnoupal during the same period of
Covid pandemic. It has also been submitted that the other
contractors successfully executed the said works within the
prescribed period for completion of the works, whereas the
WP(C)No. 333 of 2022 & Ors
Page 17
petitioner failed to execute the works awarded to him. It has also
been submitted that if the other contractors can execute the
work during the period of Covid Pandemic, the petitioner cannot
take the plea that he cannot execute the work awarded to him
because of the pandemic of Covid – 19, which shows that the
petitioner does not want to execute the work.
[23]
The learned G.A. vehemently submitted that the
claim of the petitioner that the authorities did not provide
necessary technical guidance and selection of work site etc.
despite his request is unacceptable because the petitioner
requested the concerned Executive Engineer for providing such
technical support and selection of work site only on 30.11.2020
after a gap of more than 5 (five) months and accordingly, the
authorities cannot accede to the request made by the petitioner.
It has lastly been submitted by the learned G.A. that the
authorities have not committed any illegality or irregularity in
issuing the impugned orders and accordingly, the present writ
petitions are liable to be dismissed as being devoid of merit.
[24]
I have heard the submissions of the learned
counsel appearing for the parties at length and also carefully
examined the materials available on record.
It is an undisputed fact that the 10 (ten) work orders
dated 12.06.2020 issued in favour of the petitioner were earlier
cancelled twice by the authorities. The first cancelation order
was issued on 01.12.21020, just hardly after about 6 (six)
months from the date of issue of the work order only on the
ground that the petitioner failed to start execution of the work
within the period stipulated under clause (2) of the terms and
WP(C)No. 333 of 2022 & Ors
Page 18
conditions of the work order. The second cancellation order was
issued on 29.12.2021 without assigning any reason whatsoever.
The authorities subsequently revoked both the cancellation
orders suo moto, thereby indicating that the authorities did not
find any justifiable reasons for cancelling the said work orders.
For the third time, the authorities again cancelled the work
orders issued in favour of the petitioner by issuing the impugned
order dated 26.04.2022. The reason for the cancellation was
that the petitioner failed to start execution of the works despite
the lapse of more than 18 months and the petitioner had
breached the conditions under Clause (2) of the terms and
conditions of the work orders. The authorities were also of the
viewed that the reasons given by the petitioner in his written
reply to the show cause for not starting the work has no
relevancy inasmuch as the petitioner executed the work for
upgradation/renovation of Museum & Amp: Internal Electric
Installation of Tribal Research Institute (TRI) under the
department during the Covid pandemic and that the petitioner
deliberately delayed and neglected in executing the work.
[25]
On careful examination of the terms and conditions
provided under the work orders, this Court is of the considered
view that Clause (2) does not provide that the starting date of
the work is the essence of the contract and that failure to strict
adherence thereto would attract cancellation of the contract. It is
only under Clause (3) where there is condition for cancellation
of the work, if 50 percent of the work is not executed within the
allotted time of 12 months. In the present case, the cancellation
of the work orders was not for breach of the condition under
WP(C)No. 333 of 2022 & Ors
Page 19
Clause (3) of the terms and conditions of the work orders.
Accordingly, this Court is of the considered view that the
grounds given by the authorities for cancellation of the works
are unreasonable, arbitrary and ultra vires the terms and
conditions provided under the work orders.
[26]
With regard to the observations made by the
authorities
that
the
petitioner
executed
the
work
for
upgradation/renovation of Museum & Amp: Internal Electric
Installation at Tribal Research Institute during the pandemic of
Covid – 19 whereas the petitioner failed to execute the work
involved in the present writ petitions, it has been elaborately
explained by the petitioner that the execution of the work at the
Tribal Research Institute and the execution of the work at the 3
(three) EMRS are not comparable for the following reasons:i.
Unlike the work site at EMRS Tamenglong,
the work site at the TRI was not a Covid-19
quarantine center and as such there was no
restriction in visiting the work site.
ii.
There was no restriction in movement around
the work site at the TRI.
iii.
The work at TRI was executed after the
Covid restriction were slightly relaxed.
iv.
Unlike in the case of the work at EMRS
Tamenglong, selection of work site and
technical guidance were given in the case of
the work at the TRI.
WP(C)No. 333 of 2022 & Ors
Page 20
v.
The work site at the TRI is located at the
heart of Imphal city, making it easier for the
Petitioner to mobilize labour, raw material
and prices of goods.
[27]
In the present case before issuance of the first
cancellation order dated 01.12.2020, the petitioner submitted a
representation dated 30.11.2020 to the concerned authorities of
the government for providing necessary technical guidance and
selection of work site for starting the contract works, however,
instead of providing the necessary technical guidance and
selection of work site, the authorities, in a most arbitrary manner
issued the first cancellation order. In fact till today, the
authorities have not provided the necessary technical guidance
and selection of work site to enable the petitioner to start
execution of works despite the repeated request made by the
petitioner. In view of this factual aspects, this Court is
constrained to hold that the authorities have acted unreasonably
and arbitrarily in accusing the petitioner that he failed to start
execution of the work despite lapses of more than 18 months,
when the fault lies with the authorities.
[28]
The sequence of events starting from issuance of
the first cancellation order leading to the cancellation of the work
orders for the third time on the same invalid and unreasonable
ground and subsequent issuance of the fresh NIT indicates that
the authorities do not want the petitioner to execute the work at
any cost. The work orders which have been lawfully awarded to
the petitioner after fulfilling all the legal norms and requirements
WP(C)No. 333 of 2022 & Ors
Page 21
cannot be cancelled at the whims and fancies of the authorities.
There should be a reasonable justification for the cancellation
and absence of any reasonable justification will render the
official action unlawful and illegal.
[29]
Only
in
the
counter
affidavit
filed
by
the
respondents, a new ground had been introduced by the
respondents for cancelling the work orders awarded to the
petitioner. It had been stated by the respondents in their counter
affidavit that the authorities issued similar work orders to other
contractors for executing the work of Water Harvesting and
Solar Pumps Installation in the same 3 (three) EMRS at
Tamenglong, Sapermeina and Tengnoupal during the same
period of pandemic of Covid – 19 and that the other contractors
successfully executed the said works within the prescribed
period for completion of the works, whereas the petitioner failed
to execute the work awarded to him. It has also been stated that
if the other contractors can execute the work during the period
of Covid pandemic, the petitioner cannot take the plea that he
could not execute the work awarded to him because of the
pandemic of Covid – 19, which shows that the petitioner does
not want to execute the works. These new grounds were never
mentioned by the authorities in the impugned order dated
26.04.2022.
In my considered view, the validity of the impugned
order must be judged on the basis of the reasons mentioned
therein and the new grounds introduced by the respondents in
their counter affidavit cannot be entertained while judging the
validity of the impugned order. In this regard, we can gainfully
WP(C)No. 333 of 2022 & Ors
Page 22
rely to the principle of law laid down by a constitution bench of 5
(five) Judges of the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Mohinder
Singh Gill & Anr. Vs. The Chief Election Commissioner,
New Delhi & Ors. reported in (1978) 1 SCC 405 wherein it is
laid down as under:“8. The second equally relevant matter is that when a
statutory functionary makes an order based on certain
grounds, its validity must be judged by the reasons so
mentioned and cannot be supplemented by fresh reasons in
the shape of affidavit or otherwise. Otherwise, an order bad in
the beginning may, by the time it comes to Court on account of
a challenge, get validated by additional grounds later brought
out. We may here draw attention to the observations of Bose,
J. In Gordhandas Bhanji:
Public orders, publicly made, in exercise of a statutory
authority cannot be construed in the light of explanations
subsequently given by the officer making the order of what he
meant, or of what was in his mind, or what he intended to do.
Public orders made by public authorities are meant to have
public effect and are intended to affect the actings and conduct
of those to whom they are addressed and must be construed
objectively with reference to the language used in the order
itself.
Orders are not like old wine becoming better as they
grow older.”
[30]
For the findings and reasons given hereinabove,
the present writ petitions are allowed by quashing the impugned
order dated 26.04.2022 and the impugned NITs dated
11.05.2022. The respondents are further directed to allow the
petitioner to execute the works awarded to him under the work
WP(C)No. 333 of 2022 & Ors
Page 23
orders dated 12.06.2020 by rescheduling the time period for
execution of such works as expeditiously as possible.
With the aforesaid directions, the present writ
petitions are disposed of. Parties are to bear their own cost.
JUDGE
Kim/joshua
WP(C)No. 333 of 2022 & Ors
Page 24
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review