The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
7. In view of the above, I find that this Arbitration Request is fit to be allowed and that a retired District Judge from the panel of Arbitrators maintained by this Court can be appointed as the Arbitrator.
8. Accordingly, this Arbitration Request stands allowed and it is ordered as follows : (i) Smt.K.P.Indira, Retired District Judge, B-10IJ, Chakolas Orange Park, Edachira P.O., Thengode, Kochi-682 030, is nominated as the sole Arbitrator to resolve the disputes that have arisen between the applicant and the respondents under the Annexure-1 agreement. (ii) The learned Arbitrator may entertain all disputes/ issues between the parties in connection with the said agreement, including questions of jurisdiction, maintainability, arbitrability and limitation, if any, raised by the parties. (iii) The Registry shall communicate a copy of this order to the learned Arbitrator within ten days from today and obtain a AR NO. 219 OF 2024 2025:KER:15441 Statement of Disclosure from the learned Arbitrator as stipulated under Section 11(8) read with Section 12(1) of the Act. (iv) Upon receipt of the Disclosure Statement, the Registry shall issue to the learned Arbitrator a certified copy of this order with a copy of the Disclosure Statement appended. The Original of the Disclosure Statement shall be retained in Court. (v) The fees of the learned Arbitrator shall be governed by the Fourth Schedule of the Act. Sd/- csl AR NO. 219 OF 2024 2025:KER:15441 PETITIONER'S ANNEXURES Annexure 1 MR.K.C.ABRAHAM & APPLICANT DATED
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
AR NO. 219 OF 2024
2025:KER:15441
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SYAM KUMAR V.M.
THURSDAY, THE 20TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025/1ST PHALGUNA, 1946
AR NO.219 OF 2024
PETITIONER:
M/S EDASSERY AGENCIES REPRESENTED BY ITS
PROPRIETOR
SAJU E.S., AGED 52, S/O.SEBASTIAN, 9/9C,
PUTHIYEDOM, SOUTH BAZAR, KANJOOR P.O.,
ERNAKULAM, PIN - 683575
BY ADVS.
SABU FRANCIS
C.T.APPACHEN
RESPONDENTS:
M/S.KUNNATH PHARMACEUTICALS ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICE
AT OS-15, 3RD FLOOR, G.C.D.A. COMPLEX,
MARINE DRIVE, COCHIN-682031
NOW RESIDING AT KUNNATH HOUSE, JANSAKTHI ROAD,
MUDAVOOR P.O., MUVTTUPUZHA, REPRESENTED BY
SMT.LISSA ABRAHAM, AGED 63, W/O.LATE KC. ABRAHAM,
KUNNATH HOUSE, JANSAKTHI ROAD, MUDAVOOR P.O.,
MUVTTUPUZHA, PIN - 686669
SMT.LISSA ABRAHAM
AGED 63 YEARS
W/O LATE K.C.ABRAHAM, KUNNATH HOUSE,
JANSAKTHI ROAD, MUDAVOOR P.O.,
MUVTTUPUZHA, PIN - 686669
SMT.LIDIYA ABRAHAM
AGED 35 YEARS
D/O LATE K.C. ABRAHAM, KUNNATH HOUSE,
JANSAKTHI ROAD, MUDAVOOR P.O.,
AR NO. 219 OF 2024
2025:KER:15441
MUVTTUPUZHA, PIN - 686669
SMT.LIDA ABRAHAM
AGED 33 YEARS
D/O LATE K.C.ABRAHAM,
KUNNATH HOUSE, JANSAKTHI ROAD,
MUDAVOOR P.O., MUVTTUPUZHA, PIN - 686669
SMT.DR.LIYA ABRAHAM
AGED 28 YEARS
D/O LATE K.C.ABRAHAM, KUNNATH HOUSE,
JANSAKTHI ROAD, MUDAVOOR P.O.,
MUVTTUPUZHA, PIN - 686669
BY ADVS.
M.GOPIKRISHNAN NAMBIAR, R1, R2 & R4
K.JOHN MATHAI(K/413/1984)
JOSON MANAVALAN(J-526)
KURYAN THOMAS(K/131/2003)
PAULOSE C. ABRAHAM(MAH/58/2006)
RAJA KANNAN(K/356/2008)
IZHAR MOHAMMED(K/2855/2022)
THIS ARBITRATION REQUEST HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON
20.02.2025,
FOLLOWING:
THE
COURT
ON
THE
SAME
DAY
DELIVERED
THE
AR NO. 219 OF 2024
2025:KER:15441
ORDER
Dated this the 20th day of February, 2025
This Arbitration Request is filed invoking Section 11 of the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (hereinafter referred to as “the
Act”) to appoint an Arbitrator to resolve the disputes that have arisen
between the applicant and the respondents under Annexure 1
agreement.
2. Applicant is a proprietary concern. It had entered into an
agreement for distribution dated 10.03.2017 with the 1 st respondent
whereby the applicant was appointed as the super stockist for the
entire state for the purpose of distributing and selling the products
manufactured and marketed by the 1 st respondent. The said
agreement contained an arbitration clause. It is stated that the
proprietor of the 1st respondent passed away on 19.11.2020 and
respondents 2 to 5 are his legal heirs. Annexure 2 and Annexure 3
are produced to corroborate the same.
After the demise of the
proprietor, the 3rd respondent, one of the legal heirs, had purportedly
issued Annexure 4 letter dated nil acknowledging a debt of
Rs.61,75,500/- from the 1st respondent to the applicant. Since the
AR NO. 219 OF 2024
2025:KER:15441
amount remained outstanding, Annexure 5 notice was issued to the
respondents by the applicant demanding payments of the amounts
due. Service of the said notice upon respondent Nos.1 and 2 are
revealed from Annexures 6 and 7. Since the amounts due were not
paid in spite of the demand, the applicant proceeded to invoke the
arbitration as envisaged in the Annexure 1 agreement. Annexure 12
notice dated 09.02.2024 was accordingly issued by the applicant to
the respondents invoking the arbitration clause and nominating an
Arbitrator. The nominated Arbitrator thereafter issued Annexure 13
notice which respondents 1, 2 and 4 accepted. Respondents 3 and
5 had refused the said notice. A reply notice produced as Annexure
14 has been caused to be issued by respondents 1, 2 and 4 inter
alia stating that the nominated Arbitrator has been unilaterally
appointed and that they do not wish to move forward with the
arbitration proceedings. It is at such juncture that the applicant has
preferred this Arbitration Request invoking Section 11 of the Act.
3. A counter affidavit has been filed by respondent 1,2 and 4
in the Arbitration Request inter alia stating that the applicant is not
entitled to any amounts as claimed and that the document relied on
AR NO. 219 OF 2024
2025:KER:15441
to claim the amount of Rs.61,75,000/- is a fabricated one. It is further
stated that no notice of invocation as claimed had been issued and
that appointment was brought to the notice of the said respondents
only when the unilaterally nominated Arbitrator issued the statutory
disclosure letter. The counter affidavit thus sought a dismissal of the
Arbitration Request. Subsequent thereto, the applicant has filed
Annexures 15 to 21 along with I.A.No.1 of 2025 filed in the
Arbitration Request, so as to substantiate the contention that
invocation notice had been issued to all the respondents.
4. Heard Sri.Sabu Francis, Advocate, for the applicant and
Sri.M.Gopikrishnan Nambiar, Advocate, for respondents 1, 2 and 4.
Though service was complete as against respondents 2, 3 and 5
there was no appearance on their behalf.
5. The arbitration clause in Annexure 1 agreement reads as
follows:
“It is agreed between the parties that all disputes arising
out of or in connection with the matters relating to this
agreement shall be decided only by way of arbitration as
provided under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1986
and the venue of arbitration shall be only at Ernakulam. It
is further agreed between the parties that either party may
nominate one Arbitrator and such appointment may be
concurred by other party or in case of any failure to
concur on such appointment of Arbitrator, further action
can be initiated for arbitration as provided under law. It is
further unambiguously agreed among the parties that in
AR NO. 219 OF 2024
2025:KER:15441
case of any dispute whatsoever arising out of or in
connection with this contract and/or the arbitration
proceedings the same shall be subject to the jurisdiction
of courts at Ernakulam only.”
The said clause unequivocally stipulates arbitration as the means of
dispute resolution between the parties with respect to disputes and
differences under Annexure 1. The 1 st respondent is a proprietary
concern and respondents 1 to 5 are the legal heirs of the deceased
proprietor of the 1st respondent. The 3rd
respondent had vide
Annexure 4 acknowledged the debt on behalf of the 1 st respondent,
however, the same has been alleged to be a fabricated document by
respondents 1, 2 and 4. Issuance of Annexures 5 and Annexure 8
lawyer notices and its receipt stands acknowledged vide Annexures
6, 7, 9, 10 and 11. The invocation of the arbitration clause vide
Annexure 12 letter is evidenced by Annexures 15 to 21, though its
receipt is denied by respondents 1, 2 and 4. Issuance of Annexure
13 notice by the nominated Arbitrator is not denied by respondents
1, 2 and 4. Their objection to the same is that the Arbitrator has
been unilaterally appointed. It is trite law that it is not open to either
of the parties to unilaterally appoint an Arbitrator for the resolution of
the disputes. [See Trf Ltd. v. Energo Engineering Projects (2017
AR NO. 219 OF 2024
2025:KER:15441
KHC 4463), Perkins Eastman Architects DPC and another v.
HSCC (India) Ltd. (2019 KHC 7173) and Central Organisation for
Railway Electrification v. M/s.ECI SPIC SMO MCML (JV) (2024
KHC OnLine 6620)]. Hence the objection regarding the unilateral
appointment of Arbitrator is valid.
6. I note that all the essential elements to constitute an
arbitration agreement viz., (1) The presence of a present or a future
difference in connection with some contemplated affair. (2) Intention
of the parties to settle such differences by a private Tribunal. (3)
Agreement in writing to be bound by the decision of such Tribunal,
and (4) the parties being in ad idem regarding same, are found
satisfied. [See Babanrao Rajaram Pund v. Samarth Builders &
Developers and another (2022) 9 SCC 691]. The invocation of the
arbitration clause is evidenced by Annexures 12 and 15 to 21. It is
trite that the Arbitrator can decide on questions regarding
jurisdiction/arbitrability/maintainability and limitation, if any, in the
arbitration proceedings. All legal contentions, including objections
available to the respondents, can be kept open to be taken up
before the learned Arbitrator as mandated in SBI General
AR NO. 219 OF 2024
2025:KER:15441
Insurance Co. Ltd v. Krish Spinning
[(2024) SCC OnLine SC
1754].
7.
In view of the above, I find that this Arbitration Request is
fit to be allowed and that a retired District Judge from the panel of
Arbitrators maintained by this Court can be appointed as the
Arbitrator.
8. Accordingly, this Arbitration Request stands allowed and it
is ordered as follows :
(i) Smt.K.P.Indira, Retired District Judge, B-10IJ, Chakolas
Orange Park, Edachira P.O., Thengode, Kochi-682 030, is
nominated as the sole Arbitrator to resolve the disputes that
have arisen between the applicant and the respondents under
the Annexure-1 agreement.
(ii) The learned Arbitrator may entertain all disputes/ issues
between the parties in connection with the said agreement,
including questions of jurisdiction, maintainability, arbitrability
and limitation, if any, raised by the parties.
(iii) The Registry shall communicate a copy of this order to the
learned Arbitrator within ten days from today and obtain a
AR NO. 219 OF 2024
2025:KER:15441
Statement of Disclosure from the learned Arbitrator as
stipulated under Section 11(8) read with Section 12(1) of the
Act.
(iv) Upon receipt of the Disclosure Statement, the Registry
shall issue to the learned Arbitrator a certified copy of this
order with a copy of the Disclosure Statement appended. The
Original of the Disclosure Statement shall be retained in Court.
(v) The fees of the learned Arbitrator shall be governed by the
Fourth Schedule of the Act.
Sd/-
SYAM KUMAR V. M.
JUDGE
csl
AR NO. 219 OF 2024
2025:KER:15441
APPENDIX OF AR 219/2024
PETITIONER'S ANNEXURES
Annexure 1
TRUE COPY OF AGREEMENT EXECUTED BETWEEN
MR.K.C.ABRAHAM & APPLICANT DATED
10.03.2017
Annexure 2
TRUE COPY OF DEATH CERTIFICATE OF M. KC.
ABRAHAM DATED 06.12.2020
Annexure 3
TRUE COPY OF LEGAL HEIRSHIP CERTIFICATE OF
LATE KC. ABRAHAM DATED 27.02.2021
Annexure 4
TRUE COPY OF ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF DEBT ISSUED
BY THE 3RD RESPONDENT DATED MAY 2023
Annexure 5
TRUE COPY OF LAWYER NOTICE ISSUED TO ALL
RESPONDENTS BUT ACCEPTED BY 1ST AND 2ND
RESPONDENTS ONLY DATED 21.10.2023
Annexure 6
TRUE COPY OF ACKNOWLEDGMENT CARD SIGNED
FOR THE 1ST RESPONDENT DATED NIL
Annexure 7
TRUE COPY OF ACKNOWLEDGMENT CARD SIGNED BY
THE 2ND RESPONDENT DATED NIL
Annexure 8
TRUE COPY OF LAWYER NOTICE ISSUED TO 3RD,
4TH, AND 5TH RESPONDENTS DATED 11.12.2023
Annexure 9
TRUE COPY OF LAWYER NOTICE REFUSED BY 3RD
RESPONDENT DATED NIL
Annexure 10
TRUE COPY OF LAWYER NOTICE REFUSED BY THE
4TH RESPONDENT DATED NIL
Annexure 11
TRUE COPY OF LAWYER NOTICE REFUSED BY THE
5TH RESPONDENT DATED NIL
Annexure 12
TRUE COPY OF NOTICE ISSUED BY THE
APPLICANT TO ALL RESPONDENTS APPOINTING
SRI.NISHIN GEORGE VIJAYABABU ADVOCATE, AS
AR NO. 219 OF 2024
2025:KER:15441
THE SOLE ARBITRATOR DATED 09.02.2024
Annexure 13
TRUE COPY OF STATUTORY DISCLOSURE NOTICE
ISSUED BY ADV.NISHIN GEORGE VIJAYABABU TO
ALL RESPONDENTS AND APPLICANT DATED
05.05.2024
Annexure 14
TRUE COPY OF REPLY LAWYER NOTICE ISSUED
FOR AND ON BEHALF OF RESPONDENTS 1,2, AND
4 DATED 08.06.2024
Annexure 15
PRINT OUT PHOTO OF ANNEXURE-12 BEARING THE
STICKER NUMBER OF POSTAL AUTHORITY SENT BY
THE PETITIONER TO THE 1ST RESPONDENT
Annexure 16
PRINT OUT PHOTO OF ANNEXURE-12 BEARING THE
STICKER NUMBER OF POSTAL AUTHORITY SENT BY
THE PETITIONER TO THE 2ND RESPONDENT
Annexure 17
PRINT OUT PHOTO OF ANNEXURE-12 BEARING THE
STICKER NUMBER OF POSTAL AUTHORITY SENT BY
THE PETITIONER TO THE 3RD RESPONDENT
Annexure 18
PRINT OUT PHOTO OF ANNEXURE-12 BEARING THE
STICKER NUMBER OF POSTAL AUTHORITY SENT BY
THE PETITIONER TO THE 4TH RESPONDENT
Annexure 19
PRINT OUT PHOTO OF ANNEXURE-12 BEARING THE
STICKER NUMBER OF POSTAL AUTHORITY SENT BY
THE PETITIONER TO THE 5TH RESPONDENT
Annexure 20
TRUE COPY OF APPLICATION SUBMITTED BY THE
PETITIONER BEFORE THE SUPERINTENDENT OF
POS. ALUVA DIVISION TO ISSUE CERTAIN
DOCUMENT SHOWING REGISTRATION OF
ADDITIONAL ANNEXURE 15 TO 19, DATED
24/01/2025
Annexure 21
TRUE COPY OF REPLY TO ADDITIONAL ANNEXURE
20 ISSUED BY THE SUPERINTENDENT, ALUVA TO
THE PETITIONER DATED 27/1/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review