Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
( 2026:THC:602 )
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
_A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A_
WP(C) No.108 of 2026
1.
M/s Devi Engineering and Constructions Pvt. Ltd., a company, incorporated
under the Companies Act, 2013, having its head office at flat No.G-1,
Ground floor, Plot No.20, IVY GRAND, Narsanna Nagar, Suryaraopeta,
Kakinada, East Godavari, Andhra Pradesh, PIN-533003, represented by its
General Managar (Projects), namely, S. Venkata Rameshchandra, son of
Pulla Rao, having his office at Kamadhenu Para, South Badharghat,
Agartala, District: West Tripura.
…..Petitioner
_V_E_R_S_U_S_
1.
The Union of India, represented by the Secretary, Ministry of Petroleum &
Natural Gas, Government of India, Kartavya Bhawan-03, Janpath Road,
New Delhi, Pin-110001.
2.
Oil India Limited, having its Office at Duliajan, Dibrugarh, Assam-786602,
represented by its Chairman and Managing Director.
3.
The Executive Director (ΝΕΡ, DSF, OALP Projects), Oil India Limited,
Tripura E&P Office, "Neelakash", Dhaleshwar Road No. 1, Shibnagar,
Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799003.
4.
The Resident Chief Executive, Oil India Limited, Duliajan, DistrictDibrugarh, Assam, Pin-786602.
5.
The Chief General Manager (Frontier Basin), Oil India Limited, Duliajan,
District- Dibrugarh, Assam, Pin-786602.
6.
The Chief General Manager (Contracts) (Head of Department-Contracts),
Oil India Limited, Duliajan, District-Dibrugarh, Assam, Pin-786602.
7.
The Chief General Manager (Geophysics) (Head of Geophysics), Oil India
Limited, Duliajan, District- Dibrugarh, Assam, Pin-786602.
8.
The Block Manager, Oil India 8. Limited, Tripura E&P Operations,
Langtarai & Khubal, District- Dhalai Tripura.
…..Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE JUSTICE DR. T. AMARNATH GOUD
For Petitioner(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Date of hearing
Date of judgment
Whether fit for reporting
:
:
:
Mr. B. N. Majumder, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, Advocate.
Mr. K. Chakraborty, Advocate.
Mr. S. M. Chakraborty, AG
Mr. B. Majumder, Deputy SGI
Mr. A. Sarma, Advocate.
Mr. R. Nath, Advocate
20.04.2026
11.05.2026
YES
( 2026:THC:602 )
_F_I_N_A_L_O_ R_ D_ E_ R_
Heard.
[2]
The present petition has been filed under Article-226 of the
Constitution of India directing the respondents for quashing/setting aside the
impugned termination notice dated 04.02.2026 and further to permit the petitioner
to execute the works in terms of the LOA dated 29.09.2025 issued in connection
with the work, namely, Hiring of services for Acquisition of 100 LKM each of 2D
Seismic Data in Khubal (AA-OHNP-2020/1) and Langtarai (AA-ONHP-2020/3)
Blocks of OALP-VI Round in Tripura, under tender No.CDG9342P26. Further,
restraining the respondents from acting in any manner in furtherance of the
impugned termination notice dated 04.02.2026.
[3]
The petitioner has prayed for the following reliefs:
“(i) Issue Rule, calling upon the Respondents and each one of them, to show
cause as to why a Writ of Certiorari and/or in the nature thereof, shall not be
issued, for rendering substantive and conscionable justice to the Petitioner, and
for quashing/setting aside the impugned Termination Notice dated 04.02.2026
(Annexure-11 supra);
(ii) Issue Rule, calling upon the Respondents and each one of them, to show
cause as to why a Writ of Mandamus and/or in the nature thereof, shall not be
issued, mandating/directing them to permit the Petitioner to execute the works
in terms of the LOA dated 29.09.2025 (Annexure-2 supra), issued in
connection with the work, namely, 'Hiring of services for Acquisition of 100
LKM each of 2D Seismic Data in Khubal (AA-OHNP-2020/1) and Langtarai
(AA-OHNP-2020/3) Blocks of OALP-VI Round in Tripura', under Tender No.
CDG9342P26;
(iii) Issue Rule, calling upon the Respondents and each one of them, to show
cause as to why a Writ of Prohibition and/or in the nature thereof, shall not be
issued, restraining/prohibiting them, from acting in any manner, in furtherance
of the impugned Termination Notice dated 04.02.2026 (Annexure-11 supra);
(iv) In the Ad-interim, and thereafter, on hearing the parties, in the Interim, an
order in terms of (iii) above;
(v) Call for the records, appertaining to this writ petition;
(vi) After hearing the parties, be pleased to make the Rule absolute in terms of
(i) to (iv) above;
(vii) Costs of and incidental to this proceeding.”
[4]
At the outset, it is seen that at the stage of admission, having heard
the learned counsel appearing for the parties, this Court granted interim order
considering the fate of 500 unemployed workers balance of convenience and the
( 2026:THC:602 )
huge investments made by the petitioner and deploying heavy machinery, in I.A.
No.01 of 2026 arising out of WP(C) No.108 of 2026 dated 16.02.2026, granted
interim orders wherein, it has been observed as under:
“Heard Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel for the applicant. Also heard Mr.
B. Majumder, learned Deputy SGI appearing for the respondent No.1.
By means of this application the applicant has sought for an ad-interim relief in
the following manner:
“In the premises whereof, it is most humbly and respectfully prayed that Your
Lordships would be graciously pleased to pass an Order, in the Ad-interim, and
thereafter, on hearing the parties, in the Interim, prohibiting/restraining the
Respondent-OPs, from acting in any manner, in furtherance of the impugned
Termination Order dated 04.02.2026 (Annexure-2 to the connected Writ
Petition), till the final disposal of the connected Writ Petition, and consequently
direct the Respondents to permit the Petitioner to proceed with completion of
mobilization and seismic data acquisition forthwith in Contract No. 6121691
(GEMC5116877509648561
awarded
against
GeM
Tender
No.
GEM/2025IB/6471633 for 'Hiring of services for Acquisition of 100 LKM
each of 2D Seismic Data in Khrubal (AA-ONHP-2020/1) and Langatarai (AAONHP-2020/3) Blocks of OALP-VI Round in Tripura' pending disposal of the
connected Writ petition”
Learned counsel for the petitioner has urged this court for passing an interim
direction upon the respondents for suspension of the impugned proceeding in
furtherance with the consequential directions, as quoted here-in-above.
Learned counsel for the respondent No.1 has not raised any objection.
I have gone through the contentions made in the instant application and also
have gone through the grounds taken in the writ petition. This matter needs a
detailed hearing.
The reasons stated in the application are found to be satisfactory including a
huge works in the State of Tripura as well involving livelihood of around 500
workers. Accordingly, all further proceeding, relating to the impugned
Termination Notice dated 04.02.2026, stands suspended, consequently
directing the respondents to permit the petitioner to proceed with completion of
mobilization and seismic data acquisition forthwith in Contract No. 6121691
(GEMC-5116877509648561
awarded
against
GeM
Tender
No.
GEM/2025IB/6471633 for 'Hiring of services for Acquisition of 100 LKM
each of 2D Seismic Data in Khrubal (AA-ONHP-2020/1) and Langatarai (AAONHP-2020/3) Blocks of OALP-VI Round in Tripura'
The petitioner shall take steps for service of notice upon the remaining
respondents as per procedure with the Registry at the earliest.”
[5]
Thereafter, Mr. S. M. Chakraborty, learned senior counsel appearing
for the respondent Nos.2 to 8 filed I.A. No.02 of 2026 for the following reliefs:
“In the premises aforesaid your Lordships would be pleased to admit this
application and after hearing the parties be pleased to vacate/modify and/or
( 2026:THC:602 )
cancel the impugned ex-parte interim order dated 16.02.2026 passed by this
Hon’ble Court in the accompanying I.A. No.01 of 2026 arising out of WP(C)
No.108/2026 and/or pass such other order/orders as your Lordships may deem
fit and proper under the facts and circumstances of the case.”
[6]
During the course of argument, it was noticed that the documents
filed in I.A. No.02 of 2026 by the respondents, certain relevant pages are not
legible and at the request, the matter was adjourned for placing the relevant legible
documents and accordingly, the matter was adjourned. Thereafter, the matter was
listed on 20.04.2026. The respondents once again came up with another
interlocutory application i.e. I.A. No.03 of 2026 with the following prayers:
“a) Take on record the subsequent developments arising from expiry of the
petroleum exploration Licences on 12.04.2026.
b) Hold and declare that in view of the said statutory development,
continuation of the contract and related operations has become legally
impermissible and void.
c) Vacate and/or suitably modify the interim order dated 16.02.2026, as the
same has become infructuous and incapable of implementation and/or pass
such other order/orders as your Lordships may deem fit and proper under the
facts and circumstances of the case.”
[7]
Both sides represented that in view of the urgency, the matter be
finally heard and decided.
[8]
The facts in brief are that the petitioner, is a private limited Company,
incorporated under the Companies Act, 2013, engaged in the field of Construction
and Engineering and is executing EPC work contracts and Oil field service
contracts and have been serving several public sector undertakings of both the
central and state governments like Oil India Limited, Gujarat State Petroleum
Corporation Limited, Engineers India Limited, Nuclear Fuel Complex, National
Geophysical Research Institute, Gas Authority of India Limited, etc. After the
petitioner emerged out successful in the connected tender process, the respondents
issued LOA dated 29.09.2025, in favour of the petitioner. On the same date,
mobilization notice was also issued to the petitioner. On 13.11.2025, the petitioner
deposited the requisite Bank Guarantee of Rs.1,04,38,000/-. On 02.02.2026, the
petitioner sought for essentiality certificate.
[9]
Only on 10.02.2026, the respondents issued the essentiality
certificate. Thereafter, most illegally and arbitrarily, in flagrant violation of the
general conditions of the contract, the respondent issued the impugned termination
( 2026:THC:602 )
order dated 04.02.2026, informing the petitioner that the contract would be
terminated on 19.02.2026. On 08.02.2026, the petitioner served a reply thereto,
vehemently objecting thereto, inter alia contending that due to non-fulfillment of
the reciprocal obligations of the respondents, the mobilization process could not be
completed. The petitioner served a further letter dated 12.02.2026, reiterating its
earlier letter, but the same neither fetched any response, nor any opportunity was
given to the petitioner for placing the matter, thereby resulting to utter violation of
the cardinal principles of natural justice.
[10]
Hence, the present petition has been preferred before this Court by
the petitioner.
[11]
Mr. B. N. Majumder, learned senior counsel and Mr. S.
Bhattacharjee, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner in the writ petition has
submitted that the impugned termination notice dated 04.02.2026 is arbitrary,
unreasonable and violative of Article-14 of the Constitution of India. The
respondents being a State instrumentality are bound to act fairly, transparently and
in a non-discriminatory manner even in contractual dealings. The impugned action
has been taken mechanically without due consideration of relevant facts and
circumstances and therefore suffers from manifest arbitrariness.
[12]
The respondents have failed to discharge their reciprocal contractual
obligations. Issuance of the essentiality certificate was a mandatory statutory
prerequisite for customs clearance and mobilization of critical equipment. Without
issuance of the said certificate, the petitioner was legally disabled and substantially
restrained from performing its contractual obligations. Having themselves
prevented performance; the respondents cannot attribute delay or default to the
petitioner. It is a settled legal principle that no party can take advantage of its own
wrong. The respondents having failed to facilitate statutory clearances and
permissions cannot invoke alleged non-performance arising out from their own
omissions. The impugned termination is therefore vitiated by the doctrine of
prevention and employer's default.
[13]
It has been further contended that that invocation of GCC Clause 44.5
is wholly misconceived. The said clause contemplates termination only after
specifying deficiencies and granting a reasonable and effective opportunity to
rectify the same. In the present case, no meaningful opportunity was granted after
( 2026:THC:602 )
removal of statutory impediments. Rectification was impossible in the absence of
Essentiality Certificate and pending permissions. Invocation of GCC Clause-44.8 is
equally unsustainable. The said clause presupposes that the contractor is free and
capable of mobilization but has failed to do so. Where mobilization is prevented by
statutory and administrative barriers within the control of the employer, such clause
cannot be invoked.
[14]
It is submitted that the impugned termination violates the cardinal
principles of natural justice. The respondents failed to consider the detailed
explanation and documents submitted by the petitioner on 02.02.2026. No personal
hearing was granted. Relevant materials were ignored. The drastic consequence of
termination was imposed without fair procedure. The respondents have acted in
breach of the doctrine of proportionality. Termination is an extreme contractual
action entailing serious civil and commercial consequences. When the petitioner
had already achieved substantial mobilization, established base camps, deployed
manpower, undertaken field level works, and demonstrated readiness to commence
operations upon statutory clearance, the respondents ought to have adopted lesser
corrective measures. Premature termination is grossly disproportionate and
excessive.
[15]
The impugned action is vitiated by non-application of mind. The
respondents failed to examine whether substantial contract period still remained
and whether the project could be completed within time. The petitioner had
demonstrated capacity and readiness to complete the work well within the
contractual period. These material considerations were ignored. The respondents
ignored the past performance record of the petitioner. The petitioner had
successfully executed earlier projects for the respondents without levy of damages.
Such past conduct is a relevant factor in assessing intent and capability. Failure to
consider the same renders the decision arbitrary.
[16]
The respondents failed to act in public interest. Premature termination
of a viable contract leads to delay in project execution fresh tendering escalation of
costs and avoidable litigation. Such action defeats public interest and defeats the
very object of the project. The impugned termination amounts to colourable
exercise of power. Contractual clauses have been invoked as a mere formality
without satisfying their substantive preconditions. The real cause of delay being
( 2026:THC:602 )
administrative and statutory impediments attributable to the Respondents has been
deliberately ignored.
[17]
It is submitted that the respondents failed to adhere to settled PSU
contracting norms and administrative fairness. Public Sector Undertakings are
expected to resolve performance issues through facilitation and corrective
mechanisms rather than resorting to punitive measures at the first instance when
continuation of the contract remains feasible. The respondents violated the doctrine
of legitimate expectation. Having accepted technical documents, facilitated field
activities, permitted establishment of base camps, and encouraged continued
mobilization, the respondents created a legitimate expectation that reasonable
opportunity would be granted after statutory clearances and that the contract would
be allowed to be performed. Abrupt termination defeats such expectation and is
arbitrary and unjust.
[18]
The respondents failed to consider that time was not the essence of
the contract in the strict sense. The overall completion period extended up to
11.05.2026 and substantial time remained available. In such circumstances
termination on alleged mobilization delay is legally untenable. The impugned
termination constitutes arbitrary exercise of contractual power by a State
instrumentality and is violative of Article-14 of the Constitution of India. It defeats
public interest and exposes both parties to avoidable disputes and losses.
[19]
The petitioner has always acted bona fide diligently and in good faith.
All delays were transparently communicated. All documents were promptly
submitted. Field level works were continuously undertaken. There is no allegation
of fraud misrepresentation or willful default. The impugned action exposes the
petitioner to severe civil consequences including stigma, loss of reputation, loss of
goodwill and loss of future business opportunities without due process of law. The
respondents failed to consider that upon issuance of Essentiality Certificate the
petitioner could immediately commence operations and recover mobilization time.
Denial of such opportunity renders the termination unjust.
[20]
The impugned notice for termination affects not merely the private
contractual rights of the petitioner but directly impacts execution of a public sector
seismic survey project forming part of national energy infrastructure and resource
development. Arbitrary disruption of such projects leads to delay fresh tendering
( 2026:THC:602 )
escalation of costs and wastage of public funds thereby causing prejudice to public
interest. It is trite law that when State instrumentalities exercise contractual powers
in matters involving public projects and public resources such powers must be
exercised fairly reasonably and in furtherance of public interest. The respondents
by resorting to premature termination despite availability of viable alternatives
have acted in breach of these principles.
[21]
Where arbitrary State action in contractual matters affects public
interest and public projects writ jurisdiction is clearly maintainable. The impugned
termination undermines continuity of a vital public project exposes the public
exchequer to avoidable financial loss and reflects abdication of administrative
responsibility. It is submitted that for execution of the work in execution, the
petitioner has employed around 500 skilled and semi-skilled workers, who are
presently working in the worksite. Out of them, 450 are permanent residents of
Tripura. Hence, if such illegal termination is sustained, said 500 workers would be
without bread and butter.
[22]
Even though, it was the obligation of the respondents to obtain NOC
from TTAADC and the State Forest Department, for facilitating the petitioner to
execute the work, but, the respondents utterly failed to do so. On one hand, the
respondents did not discharge their liabilities, and on the other hand, the
respondents illegally terminated the contract. The present writ petition is
maintainable notwithstanding the existence of an arbitration clause in the contract.
The challenge raised herein is directed against arbitrary and unconstitutional
exercise of power by a State instrumentality in violation of Articles-14 and 19(1)(g)
of the Constitution. The availability of an arbitral remedy does not bar exercise of
writ jurisdiction where State action is manifestly arbitrary violative of natural
justice and contrary to public interest.
[23]
Being the aggrieved party, the petitioner has the right to enforce the
contractual obligation of the State and its instrumentality, since; the same had acted
in an arbitrary manner. The impugned Termination Notice dated 04.02.2026,
deciding termination of the contract in question with 15 days from the date of
issuance thereof, had resulted in gross violation of the Constitutional rights of the
petitioner, guaranteed under Articles-14, 19, 21 & 300A of the Constitution of
India, and hence, deserve kind interference of this Court and also prayed to
evaluate the experimental work carried on line No.6(KL.00), along with all
( 2026:THC:602 )
supporting data, reports, and communications submitted by DECPL keeping in
view the contractual stipulations, including Clauses 8.3 & 8.5.
[24]
Mr. S. M. Chakraborty, learned senior counsel appearing for the
respondent referred I.A. No.2 and prayed to dismiss the same filed on behalf the
respondent No.2 to 8 as two interlocutory applications i.e. I.A. No.02 of 2026 and
I.A. No.03 of 2026 are not maintainable seeking two common reliefs. Therefore,
I.A. No.02 of 2026 is dismissed as not pressed. Later, in I.A. No.03 of 2026 as
multiple reliefs were sought under Section-151 of CPC and only one prayer is
maintainable, prayer Nos. (a) & (b) are dismissed as not pressed. Only prayer No.
(c) i.e. vacating/modification pressed and argued. Since Pleadings are completed,
the matter is heard finally as desired by both sides.
[25]
Mr. S. M. Chakraborty, learned senior counsel appearing for the
respondent Nos.2 to 8 firstly in support of his case has contended that Section-3 of
the Oilfields (Regulation and Development) Act, 1948, inter alia, defines “ Mining
Lease” to include an exploring or prospecting licence, thereby bringing such
licences within statutory framework governing mineral oil operations. Further,
Section-4 of the said Act mandates that no Petroleum Lease shall be valid unless
granted in accordance with the rules framed thereunder, while Section-4A
expressly provides that no person shall undertake any operation for the purpose of
prospecting, exploration or production of mineral oils except under a valid lease
granted under the Act and the rules made thereunder.
[26]
This legal requirement is further strengthened by Rule-4 of the
Petroleum and Natural Gas Rules, 1959, which categorically stipulates that no
person shall prospect for petroleum except in pursuance of a petroleum exploration
licence granted under the said Rules, and Rule-10 thereof which provides that the
term of such licence shall, in the first instance, be valid for a period of four (4)
years, extendable in accordance with the Rules. Thus, the entire Contract Work
depends on the continued validity of the licence, and if the licence is absent,
expired, or not renewed, no exploration or field work can be legally carried out,
making performance of the contract legally impossible.
[27]
Pursuant to the award of the Contract Areas, the Government of
Tripura, Department of Industries and Commerce, vide Letter bearing F. No.I2(74)/GEO/DI/2021/PART-I(A)/3014-15 dated 28.02.2022, granted Petroleum
( 2026:THC:602 )
Exploration Licence (PEL) in favour of Oil India Limited in respect of Block AAONHP-2020/1 admeasuring 557.33 sq. km. under Rule 5(1)(ii) of the Petroleum
and Natural Gas Rules, 1959. The said licence was expressly granted "initially for a
period of four years" from the date of issuance of the letter and was made subject to
the terms and conditions of the Revenue Sharing Contract and the Deed Agreement
to be executed between the Government of Tripura and the Operator. Thus, the
licence itself was time-bound and incapable of continuing beyond the stipulated
period except by specific extension granted in accordance with law.
[28]
Accordingly, the Directorate General of Hydrocarbons, Ministry of
Petroleum & Natural Gas, Government of India, vide communications dated
11.03.2025 and 17.03.2025, has granted extension of the exploration period in
respect of Block AA-ONHP-2020/1 and Block AA-ONHP-2020/3 on account of
force majeure conditions arising in the Tribunal Tribal Areas Autonomous District
Council (TTAADC) region, in terms of Article-29 of the Revenue Sharing
Contract. By the said communication, the competent authority approved grant of
351 days extension and accordingly, the exploration period of the said Blocks stood
extended up to 12.04.2026.
[29]
It has been further contended that similarly, the government of
Tripura, through its Directorate of Industries & Commerce, vice communication
dated 09.10.2025 has granted extension of the Petroleum exploration licence in
respect of Block AA-ONHP-2020/3, having an area of 219.37sq. km., up to
12.04.2026, on account of force majeure conditions arising in the Tripura Tribal
Areas Autonomous District Council region, based on prior approval of the Ministry
of Petroleum and Natural Gas, Government of India, as communicated through the
Directorate General of Hydrocarbons.
[30]
The petitioner was fully aware of the necessity and statutory
requirement of a valid Petroleum Exploration Licence for execution of the
contractual work, as is evident from the email correspondence exchanged between
the parties. It is pertinent to mention herein that by email dated 31.10.2025, the
petitioner itself specifically requested details of the PEL for the concerned blocks,
expressly acknowledging that possession of such licence is essential for compliance
with statutory and regulatory requirements, to which the applicant company
responded vide email dated 01.11.2025 confirming that it held valid PELs for the
said blocks with validity up to 12.04.2026.
( 2026:THC:602 )
[31]
In the meantime, Oil India Limited, vide its communication dated
03.01.2025 addressed to the Directorate General of Hydrocarbons, specifically
sought guidance for availing paid extension of the block validity under the relevant
clauses of the Revenue Sharing Contract, in order to complete additional 2D
seismic data acquisition in Blocks AA-ONHP-2020/1 and AA-ONHP-2020/3. In
the said communication, it has been expressly acknowledged that the initial
exploration period stood extended only up to 12.04.2026 on account of force
majeure, and that additional time may be required for completion of the remaining
work. This clearly demonstrates that continuation of operations was contingent
upon further statutory extension and not otherwise permissible in law.
[32]
The Oil India Ltd. has, in continuation of its earlier request, again
approached the Directorate General of Hydrocarbons, vide communication dated
20.02.2026, seeking approval for availing paid extension of the block validity in
respect of Blocks AA-ONHP-2020/1 and AA-ONHP-2020/3, in terms of the
relevant clauses of the Revenue Sharing Contract. In the said communication, the
respondent has unequivocally reiterated that the exploration period of the said
blocks stood extended only up to 12.04.2026 and that additional time beyond the
said date would be required to complete the remaining seismic work, thereby
necessitating formal extension upon payment as per contractual provisions. It has
been further stated that in the absence of such extension, continuation of work
beyond the said date would not be feasible. This subsequent communication clearly
establishes that the subsistence of the contract operations was entirely contingent
upon statutory/contractual extension f the licence period and not otherwise
permissible in law.
[33]
The petitioner vide its letter dated 11.04.2026, has expressly
acknowledged that the Petroleum Exploration Licence for the subject blocks was
valid only up to 12.04.2026 and that cessation of activities has occurred due to its
expiry, and has further admitted that it had sought and was informed of each
validity prior to commencement of work and had undertaken mobilization and
execution accordingly, thereby clearly establishing its full knowledge that
continuation of the contract was dependent upon a valid PEL. However, despite
such admission, the petitioner has raised claims seeking payment for work
executed, compensation for idling of resources and manpower and other
( 2026:THC:602 )
contractual reliefs, while also requesting extension of the PEL and continuation of
the project.
[34]
The contract depends entirely on the validity of the PELs, and once
they expire, the basis of the contract ends. As a result, continuing the contract
becomes not only impractical but also legally not allowed, making it a case of
impossibility due to a change in law. In such circumstances, the doctrine of
frustration as embodied under Section-56 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 squarely
applies, inasmuch as the contract has become void by reason of performance
having become unlawful due to a statutory prohibition arising subsequent to its
formation. It is a settled principle of law that an act of State or statutory embargo
overrides all contractual obligations, including those protected by interim orders of
a Court, and no party can be compelled, directly or indirectly, to act in
contravention of binding statutory provisions.
[35]
The Ministry of Petroleum and Natural Gas, in exercise of powers
conferred under Sections-5, 6, 9 and 9A of the Oilfields (Regulation and
Development) Act, 1948, has framed the applicable statutory rules regulating
petroleum operations, which categorically prohibit undertaking of any exploration
or related activity without a valid and subsisting licence or lease. Under Section-9
of the Oilfields (Regulation and Development) Act, 1948, any person undertaking
petroleum operations in violation of the statutory regime, including without a valid
licence, is liable to penal consequences.
[36]
Upon expiry of the Petroleum Exploration Licences, no exploration
activity can be carried out in law, the contract being entirely dependent on the
subsistence of such licence; consequently, the present case squarely attracts
Section-56 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, inasmuch as the contract has become
void on account of supervening impossibility, the performance thereof having
become unlawful by operation of statute. This is not a case of mere commercial
hardship or inconvenience, but one of complete statutory prohibition, and it is a
settled principle that an act of State or statutory embargo overrides even a courtprotected contractual continuation. Under the statutory regime framed pursuant to
the Oilfields (Regulation and Development) Act, 1948, undertaking operations
without a valid licence is expressly prohibited, and any such continuation would
attract penal consequences Section-9 of the said Act.
( 2026:THC:602 )
[37]
Having scrupulous discussion and heard the learned counsel
appearing for the parties, this Court is of the view that the case of the petitioner is
that there are only two successful tenderers i.e. the L-1 and L-2. The petitioner
being the L-1 has been awarded the work and he has invested huge money and
procured the machineries and deployed the same at site and further engaged around
500 workmen and because of the non-cooperation of the respondents, the petitioner
was unable to proceed with the works and provide the work to his labours. In the
process, the petitioner has also drawn attention of this Court that there were no
laches on the part of the petitioner. The duration for performing the works contract
as per the agreement was 6 months 45 days that would come to an end in June,
2026. Even without waiting for the same and without giving an opportunity, the
respondents have proceeded in initiating adverse actions against the petitioner and
with an ill motive and more particularly, to encourage the L-2 who happens to be
their closed one and initiated proceeding dated 04.02.2026 which is impugned in
this petition.
[38]
Though the very notice indicates that the petitioner should submit his
explanations within a period of 15 days but, the manner in which the contentions
are placed in the notice, are explicitly gross and inference can be drawn that the
respondents are predetermined to cancel the works contract awarded to the
petitioner through a letter of award and handover the same to the next tenderer.
Considering the submissions made at the stage of admission since, it is a livelihood
of 500 people was involved and the balance of convenience that the petitioner has
deployed plant and the machineries at the work site and has incurred huge amount,
this Court granted the interim directions.
[39]
The respondents came up with a vacate stay petition and since the
same was not in a proper form, sought for an adjournment and the same was
granted and again the respondents filed I.A. No.03 of 2026. During the course of
arguments, when this Court has pointed out how both the interlocutory applications
i.e. I.A. No.02 & 03 of 2026 seeking common relief of stay vacate/modification of
the orders are maintainable, Mr. S. M. Chakraborty, learned senior counsel prayed
to dismiss the I.A. No.02 of 2026 as un-pressed and accordingly, the I.A. No.02 of
2026 stands dismissed as un-pressed.
[40]
Insofar as the examination of I.A. No.03 of 2026 is concerned, the
reliefs are already stated (supra). When this Court has verified with the senior
( 2026:THC:602 )
counsel with regard to the maintainability of three reliefs in one interlocutory
application i.e. I.A. No.03 of 2026 reliefs in one interlocutory application filed
under Section-151 of CPC, the learned senior counsel in all fairness has submitted
that the prayers (a) i.e. Take on record the subsequent developments arising from
expiry of the Petroleum Exploration Licences on 12.04.2026 & (b) i.e. Hold and
declare that in view of the said statutory development, continuation of the contract
and related operations has become legally impermissible and void, may be
dismissed as un-pressed and only application is made to be confined to decide
prayer (c) i.e. “vacate and/or suitable modify the interim order dated 16.02.2026,
as the same has become infructuous and incapable of implementation and/or pass
such other order/orders as Your Lordships may deem fit and proper under the facts
and circumstances of the case” to the extent of vacating or modifying and the
orders passed in I.A. No.001 if 2026 dated 16.02.2026.
[41]
In the counter affidavit filed along with interlocutory applications, it
is categorically stated that the respondents are duly satisfied and convinced that the
orders passed by this Court as lawful and for the ready reference the observations
made in the I.A. No.01 of 2026 has already been extracted (supra). In view of the
change in circumstances they do not have any objection to hand over the work to
the petitioner in the event if they get the extension. It is seen from the Petroleum
and Gas Rules that the original licence is for a period of four years and thereafter
the same may be extended by another one year and one year in all it becomes six
years period. For the purpose of reference, the same may be extracted hereunder:
“10. Area and term of license: The area covered by a license shall be specified
therein and the term of a license shall in the first instance be valid for a period
of four years which may be extended for two further periods of one year each.”
[42]
Mr. S. M. Chakraborty, learned senior counsel further contended that
Section-56 of the Indian Contract Act applies as the principle of Force majeure, the
contract gets frustrated as the licence period came to an end and they awaiting for
renewal/extension of the licence from the concerned respondents and further stated
that this petition becomes infructuous as the impugned notice by efflux of time
becomes inoperative and the respondents cannot take any action against the
petitioner for cancellation of the said tender.
[43]
In this regard, learned counsel appearing for the respondents has
submitted before this Court that there were certain change in circumstances and the
( 2026:THC:602 )
respondents have no grievance to permit the petitioner to proceed with the works.
He further contended that in view of the licence i.e. granting Oil India Limited [for
short, OIL], the respondent in the writ petition have addressed a letter requesting
the Union of India seeking for renewal of the licence that was already granted to
them and stood expired on 12.04.2026. The letters were made even before the
licence got expired; reminders were also addressed by the respondents to the OIL.
While denying the contentions and allegations made by the petitioner that OIL is
not in favour of granting to L-2 but presently, they are in a helpless condition to
allow the petitioner L-1, to proceed with the work.
[44]
It is seen day in and day out that for the various considerations, the
higher officials at public sectors take out a way to eliminate the successful
tenderers and to place said works to the persons interested of their choice by
making the conditions of the tenders tailor made. Such kind of practices cannot be
appreciated by the Court of law and it becomes immense necessary that such
conduct of the responsible officials of the institutions need to be exposed by
conducting an inquiry by the CBI.
[45]
However, for the present it is not for this Court to enter into such
issue for causing any investigation into this tender matter by the CBI nor to express
any opinion in this regard. Mr. S. M. Chakraborty, learned senior counsel in all
fairness has submitted that since the licence of the respondent, got expired by
efflux of time they do not have any renewal of licence and awaiting for such
renewal and once the renewal is received, they would proceed with the works
assigned to the petitioner.
[46]
This Court in many occasions having concerned for the development
of the State of Tripura and felt that where there is no scope for providing private
employment and other sources for earning livelihood for unemployed youth and it
is practical experience where a B.Com(Hon.) passed unemployed youths in the
State of Tripura are working on contractual basis and getting around Rs.6,500/- per
month and if the people of Tripura who are finding their employment through
certain contractual works for more wages, this Court expresses its concern for
around 500 workers who are facing hardship without any employment and if the
tenderer is put to hardship due to any technical reasons, it becomes difficult for any
person to come to State like Tripura and perform his obligatory duties and to
extend his hands for the development and uplifting of the State of Tripura. The
( 2026:THC:602 )
official-respondents or any other authority who are directly or indirectly involved
for the benefit of State of Tripura must have a magnanimous view and have
pragmatic approach in exercising the powers for the betterment of the State of
Tripura and its people. Insofar as the argument on force majure is concerned, the
same is negatived. The application seeking renewal made by OIL to concerned
authority is pending.
[47]
In view of the above observations and discussions, it falls for
consideration in view of the works i.e. for digging of oil wells and the ancillary
works that has to be taken up by the OIL and more particularly, in view of the
future days to come because of the Iran vs. Israel/America war the shortage of oil is
uncertain and on technical reasons rejecting any tenders and cancelling the works
or discouraging tenderers may not sound plausible. For a moment, if it is
considered that he petitioner needs to be eliminated by the respondents and the
fresh tenders have to be called for as per tender procedure obviously it would take
pretty long time and till then any employee/workmen of Tripura would suffer and
the progress in Tripura will be delayed.
[48]
Even the Hon’ble Apex Court to minimize the litigation in its true
letter and spirit to maintain the harmony amongst the litigants has formulated
“Samadhan Samaroha” (Lok Adalat) and making all attempts to settle and reduce
the pending matters. It is not proper if the institution like respondent corporation in
the course of litigation, dealing with such type of matters technically attracting
trivial issue is unsound.
[49]
In view of the same, this Court feels that the vacate stay application
fails and the same is dismissed. Insofar as the writ petition is concerned, for the
reasons stated and for the discussion made, the impugned notice dated 04.02.2026
under challenge is unsustainable and is liable to be set aside and accordingly, the
same is set aside. However in view of the facts and subsequent developments, this
Court feels that ends of justice would be met if a direction is given to the
respondents and D.G. Oil India Ltd. Therefore, the respondent Nos.1 to 8 and D.G.
OIL are directed to take a decision at the earliest upon the issue for renewal of the
licence of OIL which got expired on 12.04.2026 in the light of the representations
made by the Oil India Corporation dated 08.02.2026 and the reminder dated
12.02.2026 forthwith, if not already decided.
( 2026:THC:602 )
[50]
There shall also be a direction to the Oil India Corporation to permit
the petitioner forth with to continue with the work in terms of the contract for the
balance period once the Oil India Limited obtained the renewal of the licence. It is
not open for the respondents to say the licence period is over, when the work is in
progress. It is there bona fide bounded duty to see that licence is renewed and
ensure hassle free access to the petitioner to complete the work. In the process of
any laches on the part of the respondents causing any hindrances or damages, it is
always open to the petitioner to avail remedies under law. The respondents shall
consider and evaluate the experimental work carried out on line No.6(KL.00) along
with all supporting data, repots and communications submitted by DECPL keeping
in view the contractual obligations, including Clauses 8.3 & 8.5.
[51]
With the above observation and direction, the present petition stands
allowed and disposed of.
[52]
As a sequel, miscellaneous application, pending if any, shall stand
closed.
DR.T. AMARNATH GOUD, J
A. Ghosh
signed by ANJAN GHOSH
ANJAN GHOSH Digitally
Date: 2026.05.13 16:24:47 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review