The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
19. I.A.No.16 of 2023 is filed under Order 9 Rule 9 CPC. The application seeking permission to grant leave to defend the suit as I.A. No.8 of 2021, was allowed on 10.3.2022 and directed the petitioner to file written statement within 2 weeks. The written statement was not filed in time. Therefore, the petitioner was made ex-parte. The petitioner thereafter, filed O.P.(C) OPC 1409/24 2025:KER:26418 No.1234 of 2022 before this court and entire proceedings were stayed and it was dismissed on 25.7.2023. It is after the dismissal, on 15.9.2023 the present application was filed to set aside exparte order. By that time, there occurred a substantial delay. Therefore, I.A.No.15 of 2023 was filed. The commercial court held that since the written statement was filed after a period of 120 days, the same cannot be accepted and the defendant was set ex-parte.
20. On a perusal of the affidavit in support of the petition to condone the delay in filing the petition to set aside the ex-parte order and the petition to set aside ex-parte order, I am satisfied that the delay in filing the petition to set aside ex-parte can be allowed as sufficient cause is shown. Consequently, I.A.No.16 of 2023 is also allowed. OPC 1409/24 2025:KER:26418
21. While the amendment was brought into the CPC under provisos to Order 5 and Order 8, under section 16 of the C.C. Act, the intention of the legislature was a speedy disposal of commercial suit, and it is keeping the said aspect in mind, it was specifically provided that the defendant shall forfeit the right to file written statement after 120 days from the date of service of summons and the court shall not allow the written statement to be taken on record. On an overall appreciation of the facts and circumstances of the case and taking note of timelines right from the suit till the filing of petitions, which are dismissed as per Ext.P1, I am of the opinion that interference is warranted with Ext.P1 common order dated 16.2.2024, to the extent of dismissing I.A.Nos.15 and 16 and the order in I.A.No.17 of 2023 is upheld. Therefore, the Original Petition stands disposed of, as follows: i. I.A. No.15 of 2023 is allowed OPC 1409/24 2025:KER:26418 ii. I.A.No.16 of 2023 is allowed; and iii. The order in I.A. No.17 of 2023 is sustained. It is also clarified that the defendant shall be permitted to participate in the trial and cross-examine the plaintiff. Sd/BASANT BALAJI dl/ OPC 1409/24 2025:KER:26418 Exhibit P1 TRUE COPY OF THE COMMON ORDER DATED 16.02.2024 IN I.A NO.15, I.A NO 16 AND I.A NO. 17 OF 2023 RENDERED BY THE HON’BLE PRINCIPAL SUBORDINATE JUDGES COURT, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM Exhib…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
OPC 1409/24
2025:KER:26418
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE BASANT BALAJI
WEDNESDAY, THE 26TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 5TH CHAITHRA, 1947
OP(C) NO. 1409 OF 2024
CS NO.73 OF 2021 OF ASSISTANT SESSIONS COURT/PRINCIPAL SUB COURT /
COMMERCIAL COURT, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM
PETITIONER/S:
M/S CAPITAL RETREAT PRIVATE LIMITED, AGED 73 YEARS, TC
31/527 (1), CHAKKAI, PETTAH, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, REPRESENTED
BY ITS CHAIRMAN RAJMOHAN, PIN - 695024
BY ADVS.THEJAN RAJ
E.ADITHYAN
INDRAJITH.I
R.T.PRADEEP
M.BINDUDAS(K/523/2010)
NIRANJAN T. PRADEEP(K/001073/2024)
RESPONDENT/S:
GOPAKUMAR B. NAIR, AGED 57 YEARS, S/O LATE BALAKRISHNAN
NAIR, 5-A, SKYLINE PLAZA APARTMENTS, VELLAYAMBALAM,
SASTHAMANGALAM P.O, THIRUVANATHAPURAM ., PIN - 695010
BY ADVS.C.S.MANU, DILU JOSEPH(D-125)
C.A.ANUPAMAN(A-503), T.B.SIVAPRASAD(K/17/2007)
C.Y.VIJAY KUMAR(K/152/2014)
NEETHU.K.SHAJI(K/148/2012), MANJU E.R.(K/000401/2016)
ANANDHU SATHEESH(K/613/2020)
ALINT JOSEPH(K/505/2020), PAUL JOSE(K/000862/2020)
DAINY DAVIS(K/001135/2024)
THIS OP (CIVIL) HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON 19.02.2025, THE COURT
ON 26.3.2025 DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
OPC 1409/24
2025:KER:26418
C.R.
JUDGMENT
(Dated this the 26th day of March 2025)
The question that arise for consideration in this Original
Petition is whether the defendant can forfeit the right to file a
written statement, if the same is not filed within 120 days from
the date of service of summons.
2. The petitioner is the defendant in C.S.No.73 of 2021
on the files of Principal Sub Court, Thiruvananthapuram. The
respondent filed the suit under Section 26 read with Order 37
Rules 1 and 2 CPC read with Section 6 of the Commercial Courts
Act, 2015
(for short 'the C.C.Act'), for the realisation of an
amount of Rs.5,03,79,000/- from the defendant, together with
future interest at the rate of 18% p.a., from the date of institution
of the suit till realisation. On receipt of summons, the petitioner
entered appearance and sought leave of the court to defend the
OPC 1409/24
2025:KER:26418
suit under Order 37 Rule 3(5) CPC as I.A.No.8 of 2021. By order
dated 10.3.2022, leave was granted to the defendant, who was
directed to file a written statement within 10 days. On 25.3.2022,
the defendant sought time for filing a written statement, which
was refused by the court and the defendant was set ex parte.
3. Meanwhile, the respondent/plaintiff challenged the
order in I.A. No.8 of 2021 before this court, in O.P.(C) No.1234
of 2022 and the entire proceedings were stayed till the O.P. was
dismissed on 25.7.2023. Immediately, a petition was filed by the
petitioner to set aside the ex-parte order, along with a written
statement and a petition to accept the same. An application to
condone the delay in setting aside the ex-parte order, an
application for setting aside the ex-parte order, and to accept the
written statement were filed as I.A.Nos.15, 16 and 17 of 2023,
respectively.
The court below heard all the I.As together and
OPC 1409/24
2025:KER:26418
dismissed as per Ext.P1 common order dated 16.2.2024. The
petitioner has filed this Original Petition to set aside Ext.P1 and
for a direction to the trial court to accept the written statement
filed by the petitioner.
4. The reasoning given by the trial court is that as per the
amended provision of Order 8 Rule 1 CPC, a written statement in
a commercial suit is to be filed within 30 days from the date of
service of summons on him, and if the defendant fails to file the
written statement within the said period of 30 days, he shall be
allowed to file the written statement on such other day, as may be
specified by the court, for reasons to be recorded in writing and
on payment of such cost, as the court deems fit, which shall not
be later than 120 days from the date of service of summons.
5. The court has directed the defendant to file a written
statement within 10 days from 10.3.2022, and since the written
OPC 1409/24
2025:KER:26418
statement was not filed, the defendant was set ex-parte on
25.3.2022 as the 10 days’ time expired on 24.3.2022. It was also
found that under proviso to Order 8 Rule 1, the amendment is
brought into the said Rule under Section 16 of the C.C. Act, the
defendant shall forfeit the right to file the written statement, if it
is not filed within 120 days from the date of service of summons
and the court shall not allow the written statement to be taken on
record.
6. Heard Sri.R T Pradeep, the counsel for the petitioner and
Shri.C.S Manu for the respondent.
7. The counsel for the petitioner argued that the present suit,
C.S. No.73 of 2021, is filed under Order 37 Rule 1 and 2. Order
37 deals with the summary procedure. Under Rule 2(2), once
the suit is filed, the summons of the suit shall be sent to the
defendant in Form No.4 in Appendix B or in such other form, as
OPC 1409/24
2025:KER:26418
may, from time to time, be prescribed. Once the defendant enters
appearance, the notice of appearance is to be given to the
plaintiff’s pleader, and after the defendant enters appearance, the
plaintiff shall thereafter serve on the defendant, a summons for
judgment in Form No.4-A in Appendix B or such other form, as
may be prescribed, from time to time, returnable not less than 10
days from the date of service, supported by an affidavit verifying
the cause of action and the amount claimed and stating that in his
belief, there is no defence to the suit.
8. After the receipt of said summons in Form No.4-A in
Appendix B, within 10 days thereafter, the defendant has to file
an affidavit or otherwise, disclosing that he shall be deemed
sufficient to entitle him to defend, apply for leave to defend the
suit and the court has to grant the leave unconditionally or upon
such terms, as may appear to the court or Judge to be just.
OPC 1409/24
2025:KER:26418
Therefore, he contends that the provisions of either Order 5 or
Order 8 CPC, do not apply to a commercial summary suit.
9. It is also argued that the defendant has no right to file a
written statement unless and until the court grants leave to defend
the suit. The petitioner was served with 2 summons (i) form 4 in
Appendix B and (ii) form 4-A in Appendix B, and therefore, the
time limit of 120 days for filing the written statement from the
date of service of summons as fixed in Order 5 and Order 8 CPC,
cannot hold good as the leave to defend the suit was granted to
the petitioner only after 120 days from service of notice in Form
No.4 Moreover, the respondent himself has challenged the Order
in I.A.No.8 of 2021, allowing leave to defend the suit by the
petitioner in O.P.(C) No.1234 of 2022 and the same was
dismissed. In such circumstances, I.A.Nos.15, 16 and 17 of 2023
were filed, which ended in dismissal by Ext.P1.
OPC 1409/24
2025:KER:26418
10. He relied on an order dated 8.4.2021 passed by the
Bombay High Court in Interim Application (L) No.5323 of 2020
in Commercial Summary Suit No.778 of 2017 (M/s.Sandy Ltd.
v. M/s.Diligent Media Corporation Ltd.), wherein it was held
that the ceiling limit of 120 days fixed for filing a written
statement under proviso to Order 5 Rule 1 and Order 8 Rule 1 and
Rule 10 CPC do not apply to commercial summary suits, after the
coming of operation of the C.C. Act. Reliance was also placed
on the judgment of the Delhi High Court in Bharat Singh v.
Karan Singh and others (2025 SCC Online Delhi 691).
11. The counsel for the respondent, Sri.C.S.Manu, on the
other hand, placed reliance on S.C.G Contracts India Pvt. Ltd.
v. K. S. Chamankar Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. and others
[(2019) 12 SCC 210], and argued that after the period of 120 days
from the service of summons on the defendant under Order 5 Rule
OPC 1409/24
2025:KER:26418
1 and Order 8 Rule 1 CPC, the defendant forfeits the right to file
written statement and no written statement can be taken on record.
According to him, the suit was filed on 15.3.2021 as C.S.No. 73
of 2021, the summons was ordered on 23.3.2021 and served on
the same day. The defendant entered appearance on 9.4.2021.
The 30 days provided for filing a written statement under Order 5
and Order 8 expired on 10.4.2022, taking note of the fact that
summons was served on 10.3.2022. The extended period of 120
days from the date of service of summons expired on 8.7.2022.
12. On receipt of the summons in Form No.4, the defendant
entered appearance, but with a delay. The Commercial Court
condoned the delay in entering appearance on 21.10.2021. The
application for leave to defend on receipt of summons in Form
No.4-A in Appendix B was filed on 29.9.2021, and the court
granted leave on 10.3.2022. While granting leave, the court fixed
OPC 1409/24
2025:KER:26418
a new timeline and directed the defendant to file a written
statement within 2 weeks from 10.3.2022. The said 2 weeks
expired on 24.3.2022, and on the very next day, since no written
statement was filed, the defendant was set ex-parte as there was
no representation, on 25.3.2022. Even if 120 days is taken into
account from the date of granting of leave as per the new timeline,
the time limit expired on 8.7.2022. Even on that day, no written
statement was filed by the defendant.
13. O.P.No.1234 of 2022 challenging the grant of leave to
defend the suit was filed only on 12.7.2022, and the same was
dismissed on 25.7.2023. The present petition filed to accept the
written statement, with a petition to condone delay and to set aside
ex parte order, is only on 15.9.2023. Thus, the court below is fully
justified in dismissing the application as the present I.A s are filed
with inordinate delay.
OPC 1409/24
2025:KER:26418
14.
As mentioned earlier, Order 37 CPC deals with
summary procedure. It is not in dispute that a commercial
dispute filed before the commercial court also can be filed under
the said order. A perusal of Ext.P2 plaint would show that the suit
is filed under Section 26 and Order 37 Rules 1 and 2 CPC read
with Section 6 of the C.C.
Act. A
separate procedure is
prescribed under Order 37 CPC for Institution of Summary Suits
and Procedure for Appearance of Defendant. When a suit is filed
under the said order, Rule 2(2) prescribes that the summons of the
suit shall be in form No.4 in Appendix B or such other form as
may, from time to time, be prescribed. Rule 3(3) directs the
defendant on entering appearance to give notice of appearance to
the plaintiff's pleader or to the plaintiff, if he sues in person either
by notice delivered/sent or by pre paid letter to the plaintiff’
pleader or the plaintiff, as the case may be. Rule 4 directs that if
OPC 1409/24
2025:KER:26418
the defendant enters appearance, the plaintiff shall thereafter
serve on the defendant a summons for judgment in form No.4-A
in appendix B or such other form, as may be prescribed from time
to time, returnable not less than 10 days, from the date of service,
supported by an affidavit verifying the cause of action and the
amount claimed and stating that in his belief, there is no defence
to the suit. According to Rule 5, the defendant may, at any time
within 10 days from the date of service of the judgment, apply on
such summons for leave to defend the suit and the court may grant
leave to defend unconditionally or upon such terms, as it may
appear to the court or Judge to be just.
15. In ordinary suits, if one reads Order 5 Rule 1 CPC, the
time granted for the defendant to file a written statement is 30
days from the date of summons on the defendant, which can be
extended to a period not later than 90 days, from the date of
OPC 1409/24
2025:KER:26418
service of summons for reasons to be recorded in writing. The
same is also stated in Order 8 Rule 1 CPC.
16. But, as mentioned earlier, as far as the commercial suit
is concerned, as per the amendment to the C.C. Act, as provided
under Section 16, by incorporating proviso to Order 5 and Order
8, the period of 30 days can be extended for a period not less than
120 days from the date of service of summons. But the defendant
shall forfeit the right to file a written statement if the written
statement is not filed within 120 days from the date of service of
the summons, and the court shall not accept the written statement
on record.
17. In this case, the present commercial suit is filed under
Order 37 CPC under the summary procedure. As far as the
commercial suit filed under Order 37 is concerned, the
defendant's right to defend the suit arises only on the grant of
OPC 1409/24
2025:KER:26418
leave on receipt of summons under Form 4A Appendix B under
Order 37 Rule 3(5) CPC. As mentioned earlier, on receipt of the
application in Form 4A, the petitioner entered appearance with a
delay, but the said delay was condoned on 21.10.2021, and the
application for leave to defend as I.A. No.8 of 2021 was filed on
29.9.2021, and the leave was granted on 10.3.2022.
The
Commercial Court, while granting leave, fixed a new timeline and
granted 2 weeks from 10.3.2022 for filing written statement. The
defendant did not adhere to the said timeline, and thus, the time
granted expired on 24.3.2022, and the defendant was set ex-parte
on 25.3.2022. As far as the commercial suit filed under Order 37
is concerned, the right of a defendant to defend the suit arises only
on grant of leave, which is admittedly on 10.3.2022. So, going
by proviso to Order 5 Rule 1 and Order 8 Rule 1, the defendant
can file a written statement within 30 days from the date of
OPC 1409/24
2025:KER:26418
granting of leave, which can be extended by the court for reasons
to be recorded in writing, but it shall not be later than 120 days
from the date of grant of leave. So, the 120 days would expire on
8.7.2022 as the leave was granted on 10.3.2022. A proviso is
added to Order 8 Rule 10 CPC by an operation of Section 16 of
the C.C. Act, which provides that no court shall make an order to
extend the time provided under Rule 1 of this Order for filing of
the written statement. Thus, it can be concluded that the 120 days
prescribed for filing the written statement shall run from the date
of grant of leave on 10.3.2022, and it expired on 8.7.2022.
18. The contention raised by the counsel for the petitioner
that the plaintiff filed an O.P.(C) before this court challenging the
grant of leave and the same was dismissed on 25.07.2023 and
therefore, the written statement has to be accepted after
condoning the delay, will not stand, as O.P.(C) No.1234 of 2022
OPC 1409/24
2025:KER:26418
was filed by the plaintiff only on 12.7.2022 i.e, after the expiry of
120 days for filing written statement, which got expired on
8.7.2022. The present applications, I.A.Nos.15, 16 and 17 of
2023, were filed on 15.9.2023, which is 51 days after the
dismissal of O.P.(C) by this court.
Thus, it can be safely
concluded that the trial court is fully justified in dismissing the
application to accept the written statement. No written statement
was filed within 120 days from the grant of leave to defend the
suit, which is admittedly on 10.3.2022.
19. I.A.No.16 of 2023 is filed under Order 9 Rule 9 CPC.
The application seeking permission to grant leave to defend the
suit as I.A. No.8 of 2021, was allowed on 10.3.2022 and directed
the petitioner to file written statement within 2 weeks. The
written statement was not filed in time. Therefore, the petitioner
was made ex-parte.
The petitioner thereafter, filed O.P.(C)
OPC 1409/24
2025:KER:26418
No.1234 of 2022 before this court and entire proceedings were
stayed and it was dismissed on 25.7.2023. It is after the dismissal,
on 15.9.2023 the present application was filed to set aside exparte order. By that time, there occurred a substantial delay.
Therefore, I.A.No.15 of 2023 was filed. The commercial court
held that since the written statement was filed after a period of
120 days, the same cannot be accepted and the defendant was set
ex-parte.
20. On a perusal of the affidavit in support of the petition to
condone the delay in filing the petition to set aside the ex-parte
order and the petition to set aside ex-parte order, I am satisfied
that the delay in filing the petition to set aside ex-parte can be
allowed as sufficient cause is shown. Consequently, I.A.No.16 of
2023 is also allowed.
OPC 1409/24
2025:KER:26418
21. While the amendment was brought into the CPC under
provisos to Order 5 and Order 8, under section 16 of the C.C.
Act, the intention of the legislature was a speedy disposal of
commercial suit, and it is keeping the said aspect in mind, it was
specifically provided that the defendant shall forfeit the right to
file written statement after 120 days from the date of service of
summons and the court shall not allow the written statement to be
taken on record. On an overall appreciation of the facts and
circumstances of the case and taking note of timelines right from
the suit till the filing of petitions, which are dismissed as per
Ext.P1, I am of the opinion that interference is warranted with
Ext.P1 common order dated 16.2.2024, to the extent of dismissing
I.A.Nos.15 and 16 and the order in I.A.No.17 of 2023 is upheld.
Therefore, the Original Petition stands disposed of, as follows:
i. I.A. No.15 of 2023 is allowed
OPC 1409/24
2025:KER:26418
ii. I.A.No.16 of 2023 is allowed; and
iii. The order in I.A. No.17 of 2023 is sustained.
It is also clarified that the defendant shall be permitted to
participate in the trial and cross-examine the plaintiff.
Sd/BASANT BALAJI
JUDGE
dl/
OPC 1409/24
2025:KER:26418
APPENDIX OF OP(C) 1409/2024
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Exhibit P1
TRUE COPY OF THE COMMON ORDER DATED 16.02.2024 IN
I.A NO.15, I.A NO 16 AND I.A NO. 17 OF 2023
RENDERED BY THE HON’BLE PRINCIPAL SUBORDINATE
JUDGES COURT, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM
Exhibit P2
A TRUE COPY OF THE C.S NO. 73 OF 2021 DATED
19/3/2021 OF THE COMMERCIAL
COURT,THIRUVANANTHAPURAM
RESPONDENT EXHIBITS
Exhibit R1(a)
True copy of the Order dated 3-9-2021 in I.A No.4
of 2021 in C.S No.73 of 2021 passed by the
Commercial Court, Thiruvananthapuram
Exhibit R1(b)
True copy of the order dated 10-3-2022 in I.A
No.8 of 2021 in C.S. No.73 of 2021 passed by the
Commercial Court, Thiruvananthapuram
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Exhibit P3
THE TRUE COPY OF THE DELAY PETITION IN CS 73/2021
OF THE PRINCIPAL SUB COURT (COMMERCIAL COURT)
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM
Exhibit P4
THE TRUE COPY OF THE SETASIDE PETITION IN CS
73/2021 OF THE PRINCIPAL SUB COURT (COMMERCIAL
COURT) THIRUVANANTHAPURAM
Exhibit P5
THE TRUE COPY OF THE ACCEPT WRITTEN STATEMENT
PETITION IN CS 73/2021 OF THE PRINCIPAL SUB COURT
(COMMERCIAL COURT) THIRUVANANTHAPURAM
Exhibit P6
THE TRUE COPY OF THE FINAL JUDGMENT IN OPC 1234
OF 2024 DATED 13/6/2024 OF THE HON'BLE COURT
Exhibit P7
THE TRUE COPY OF THE WRITTEN STATEMENT FILED BY
THE DEFENDANT IN CS 73/2021 OF THE PRINCIPAL SUB
COURT (COMMERCIAL COURT) THIRUVANANTHAPURAM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review