Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extraordinary Jurisdiction)
WP (C) No. 18 of 2018
1.
M/s Bluefern Ventures (P) Ltd.,
Registered Office: Ethenpa Villa,
Damthang Road, Namchi-737126,
South Sikkim.
2.
Shri Tshering Pintso Bhutia,
Aged about 70 years,
Son of Late Namgay Bhutia,
Ethenpa Villa,
Damthang Road, Namchi-737126
South Sikkim.
3.
Smt. Ongmu Bhutia,
Aged about 60 years,
Wife of Shri Tshering Pintso Bhutia,
Ethenpa Villa,
Damthang Road, Namchi-737126
South Sikkim.
…
Petitioners
Versus
1.
Union of India,
Represented by the Secretary to the
Government of India,
Ministry of Finance,
Department of Financial Services,
Jeevan Deep Building,
10, Sansad Marg, New Delhi.
2.
State of Sikkim,
Through the Secretary-cum-State Relief Commissioner,
Land Revenue & Disaster Management Department,
Government of Sikkim, Gangtok, Sikkim.
3.
The Branch Manager,
Dena Bank, Gangtok Branch,
Nam Nang Road, Below Assembly House,
Gangtok-737101, Sikkim.
4.
The Authorised Officer/Chief Manager,
Dena Bank, Zonal Office, Kolkata,
“Avani Heights”, 1st Floor,
59 A, Chowringhee Road,
Kolkata-700020.
…
Respondents
WP (C) No. 18 of 2018
M/s Bluefern Ventures (P) Ltd. & Ors. vs. Union of India & Ors.
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARUP KUMAR GOSWAMI, CJ.
For the Petitioners
Mr. Jorgay Namka and Mr. Simeon Subba,
:
Advocates.
For the Respondent No. 1 :
None.
For the Respondent No. 2 :
Mr. Santosh Kumar Chettri, Assistant Government
Advocate Sikkim.
For the Respondent Nos.
3 & 4.
:
Mr. Sudesh Joshi, Advocate.
Date of hearing
:
27.11.2019
Date of judgment
:
27.11.2019
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
(Arup Kumar Goswami, CJ)
Heard Mr. Jorgay Namka, learned counsel appearing for the petitioners.
Also heard Mr. Sudesh Joshi, learned counsel appearing for respondent nos.3
and 4 as well as Mr. S.K. Chettri, learned Assistant Government Advocate,
Sikkim appearing for respondent no.2.
None appears for Union of India,
respondent no.1.
2.
By filing this petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, the
petitioners pray for setting aside a notice dated 18.01.2017 issued under
Section 13(2) of the Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and
Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002 (hereinafter referred to as
“SARFAESI Act”), a notice dated 19.12.2017 issued under Section 13(4) of
SARFAESI Act and a possession notice dated 16.01.2018 issued by the
Authorised Officer under Section 13(12) of SARFAESI Act read with Rule 9 of
Security Interest (Enforcement) Rules, 2002, for short, the Rules. Prayers are
also made for a direction to respondent no.1 to set up a Debt Recovery Tribunal
(DRT) at Gangtok, Sikkim and in the interim, to assign the DRT, Siliguri to deal
with the cases pertaining to the State of Sikkim as well as for a probe against
WP (C) No. 18 of 2018
M/s Bluefern Ventures (P) Ltd. & Ors. vs. Union of India & Ors.
the Branch Manager, respondent no.3, for making the loan accounts of the
petitioners as Non Performing Assets (NPA).
3.
It is averred in the petition that notice under Section 13 (2) was not
served upon the petitioners and they came to learn about the aforesaid notice in
the month of December 2017 when petitioner no.2 was served with the notice
under Section 13(4) of the SARFAESI Act.
4.
Perusal of the averments made in the writ petition goes to show that
symbolic possession of land and building, as indicated in the possession notice,
had been taken over.
5.
It is contended by Mr. Namka that issuance of notice dated 18.01.2017
under Section 13(2) is not maintainable in view of Section 31(j) of the
SARFAESI Act, as the amount due from the petitioners is less than 20% of the
principal amount and the interest thereon. Therefore, availability of alternative
remedy under Section 17 of the SARFAESI Act against the notice under Section
13(4) shall not come in the way of entertaining this petition under Article 226 of
the Constitution of India. It is submitted by Mr. Namka that provision of Rule
8(1) of the Rules was also not followed.
6.
By relying upon the judgments of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the cases
of (i) United Bank of India vs. Satyawati Tondon and Ors., reported in
(2010) 8 SCC 110, (ii) Authorised Officer, State Bank of Travancore &
Anr. Vs. Mathew K.C., reported in (2018) 3 SCC 85 and (iii) Agarwal
Tracom Private Ltd. vs. Punjab National Bank & Ors., reported in (2018)
1 SCC 626, Mr. Joshi has submitted that in view of alternative statutory remedy
available to the petitioners, this Court may not exercise its jurisdiction under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India. It is submitted by him that the account
of the petitioners was rightly declared to be NPA. He contends that the
argument of Mr. Namka that the notice under Section 13(2) is not maintainable
WP (C) No. 18 of 2018
M/s Bluefern Ventures (P) Ltd. & Ors. vs. Union of India & Ors.
in view of Section 31(j) is wholly fallacious as the Statement of
Account
demonstrates that amount due from the petitioners is far in excess of 20% of
principal amount and interest thereon. In any view of the matter, if petitioners
have any grievance with the same or any action taken by the Bank under the
SARFAESI Act, they may avail remedy in accordance with law under Section 17
of the SARFAESI Act, he submits.
7.
Mr. Joshi also submits that the DRT set up at Siliguri has jurisdiction to
entertain applications under Section 17 of the SARFAESI Act pertaining to the
State of Sikkim. This submission is disputed by Mr. Namka.
8.
The notice under Section 13(2) was issued by respondent no.4 in respect
of two loans taken by M/s Bluefern Ventures (P) Ltd., petitioner no. 1, which are
indicated as TL-1 and TL-2. Sanctioned amount in respect of TL-1 was
Rs.1033.00 lakhs (Rupees Ten crores thirty three lakhs) and sanctioned amount
in respect of TL-2 was Rs.1861.00 lakhs (Rupees eighteen crores sixty one
lakhs).Outstanding in respect of TL-1 and TL-2 was shown as Rs.9,02,56,238.00
and Rs.19,02,96,114.31, respectively, totaling Rs.28,05,52,352.31.
9.
In Satyawati Tondon (supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court at paragraphs
28, 43 and 55 observed as follows:
“28. This Court in Mardia case [(2004) 4 SCC 311] then held that
the borrower can challenge the action taken under Section 13(4) by
filing an application under Section 17 of the SARFAESI Act and a
civil suit can be filed within the narrow scope and on the limited
grounds on which they are permissible in the matters relating to an
English mortgage enforceable without intervention of the court. In
para 81 of the judgment, the Court observed as under: (SCC p.
362)
WP (C) No. 18 of 2018
M/s Bluefern Ventures (P) Ltd. & Ors. vs. Union of India & Ors.
“81. In view of the discussion held in the judgment and
the
findings
paragraphs,
and
we
directions
hold
that
contained
the
in
borrowers
the
preceding
would
get
a
reasonably fair deal and opportunity to get the matter
adjudicated upon before the Debts Recovery Tribunal. The
effect of some of the provisions may be a bit harsh for some
of the borrowers but on that ground the impugned provisions
of the Act cannot be said to be unconstitutional in view of the
fact that the object of the Act is to achieve speedier recovery
of the dues declared as NPAs and better availability of capital
liquidity and resources to help in growth of the economy of the
country and welfare of the people in general which would
subserve the public interest.”
(emphasis supplied)
x
x
x
43. Unfortunately, the High Court overlooked the settled law that
the High Court will ordinarily not entertain a petition under Article
226 of the Constitution if an effective remedy is available to the
aggrieved person and that this rule applies with greater rigour in
matters involving recovery of taxes, cess, fees, other types of public
money and the dues of banks and other financial institutions. In our
view, while dealing with the petitions involving challenge to the
action taken for recovery of the public dues, etc. the High Court
must keep in mind that the legislations enacted by Parliament and
State Legislatures for recovery of such dues are a code unto
themselves inasmuch as they not only contain comprehensive
procedure for recovery of the dues but also envisage constitution of
quasi-judicial bodies for redressal of the grievance of any aggrieved
person. Therefore, in all such cases, the High Court must insist that
WP (C) No. 18 of 2018
M/s Bluefern Ventures (P) Ltd. & Ors. vs. Union of India & Ors.
before availing remedy under Article 226 of the Constitution, a
person must exhaust the remedies available under the relevant
statute.
x
x
x
55. It is a matter of serious concern that despite repeated
pronouncement of this Court, the High Courts continue to ignore the
availability
of
statutory
remedies
under
the
DRT
Act
and
the SARFAESI Act and exercise jurisdiction under Article 226 for
passing orders which have serious adverse impact on the right of
banks and other financial institutions to recover their dues. We hope
and trust that in future the High Courts will exercise their discretion
in such matters with greater caution, care and circumspection.”
10.
A perusal of above judgment goes to show that an effective remedy is
available to an aggrieved person before the DRT and that the SARFAESI Act is a
code unto itself. The Hon’ble Supreme Court also sounded a note of caution that
High Courts should exercise their discretion to exercise jurisdiction under Article
226 of the Constitution of India in matters relating to right of banks and other
financial institutions to recover their dues with greater caution, care and
circumspection.
11.
In Authorized Officer, State Bank of Travancore (supra), the Hon’ble
Supreme Court reiterated the judgment of Satyawati Tondon (supra) and had
disapproved the approach of the High Court in entertaining the writ petition. The
Hon’ble Supreme Court further held that normal rule is that a writ petition under
Article 226 of the Constitution ought not to be entertained if alternate statutory
remedies are available, except in cases falling within the well-defined exceptions
as observed in Commissioner of Income Tax and Ors. vs. Chhabil Dass
Agarwal, reported in (2014) 1 SCC 603.
WP (C) No. 18 of 2018
M/s Bluefern Ventures (P) Ltd. & Ors. vs. Union of India & Ors.
12.
In paragraph 15 of the Chhabil Dass Agarwal (supra), the Hon’ble
Supreme Court observed as follows:
“15. Thus, while it can be said that this Court has recognised some
exceptions to the rule of alternative remedy i.e. where the statutory
authority has not acted in accordance with the provisions of the
enactment in question, or in defiance of the fundamental principles
of judicial procedure, or has resorted to invoke the provisions which
are repealed, or when an order has been passed in total violation of
the
principles
of
natural
justice,
the
proposition
laid
down
in Thansingh Nathmal case [AIR 1964 SC 1419] , Titaghur Paper
Mills case [Titaghur Paper Mills Co. Ltd. v. State of Orissa, (1983) 2
SCC 433 : 1983 SCC (Tax) 131] and other similar judgments that
the High Court will not entertain a petition under Article 226 of the
Constitution if an effective alternative remedy is available to the
aggrieved person or the statute under which the action complained
of has been taken itself contains a mechanism for redressal of
grievance still holds the field. Therefore, when a statutory forum is
created by law for redressal of grievances, a writ petition should not
be entertained ignoring the statutory dispensation.”
13.
In Agarwal Tracom (supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that
Section 17(2) empowers the Tribunal to examine all the issues arising out of the
measures taken under Section 13(4) including the measures taken by the
secured creditor under Rules 8 and 9 for disposal of the secured assets of the
borrower.
14.
On due consideration, I find that no case is made out for exercise of
power under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, as the case presented by
the petitioners do not come within the exceptions curved out which alone
WP (C) No. 18 of 2018
M/s Bluefern Ventures (P) Ltd. & Ors. vs. Union of India & Ors.
enable the Court to exercise discretionary power under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India despite availability of statutory alternative remedy.
15.
Accordingly, this writ petition is disposed of, granting liberty to the
petitioners to approach the jurisdictional DRT for redressal of their grievances, if
so advised. If any such approach is made by the petitioners within a period of
45 days from today, the jurisdictional DRT will decide the same on its merit
without raising the question of limitation. It is made clear that this Court has
expressed no opinion on merits and all contentions are left open to be decided
by the DRT.
16.
Before parting with the records, this Court further observes that this Court
has not gone into the question as to whether a direction is to be given to the
authorities for setting up of a DRT at Gangtok, Sikkim, inasmuch as such a
prayer is made collaterally to the challenges made to the notices under Section
13(2), 13(4) of the SARFAESI Act and the possession notice dated 16.01.2018,
which are the fundamental assailments in this petition.
17.
No costs.
Chief Justice
Approved for reporting : Yes
Internet: Yes
jk/
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review