Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CNR No. SKHC01-000119-2023
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM: GANGTOK
(Civil Extraordinary Jurisdiction)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. MUHAMED MUSTAQUE,
CHIEF JUSTICE
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------WP(C) No.38 of 2023
Cipla Limited
Through the Director (Indirect Tax Finance),
A company incorporated under
the erstwhile Companies Act, 1956,
Unit-II, Taza Block,
Amba Thareythang Illaka,
Rorathang Bazaar, Sikkim.
... Petitioner
versus
1.
Union of India
Through the Secretary,
Ministry of Commerce and Industry,
Vanijya Bhawan, New Delhi.
2.
State of Sikkim
Through the Secretary,
Finance, Revenue and Expenditure Department,
Secretariat, Gangtok, Sikkim.
3.
Department for Promotion of Industry and Internal Trade
(Erstwhile Department for Industrial Policy and
Promotion) under the Ministry of Commerce,
and Industry, through the Secretary,
Udyog Bhawan, New Delhi.
4.
Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs,
Department of Revenue
Through the Secretary,
Ministry of Finance,
North Block, New Delhi.
5.
The Commissioner,
Central Goods and Services Tax,
Gangtok Division, Near District Court,
Near Bypass Road, Sichey, Gangtok, Sikkim.
6.
Deputy/Assistant Commissioner,
Central Goods and Services Tax,
Gangtok Division, Near District Court,
Near Bypass Road, Sichey, Gangtok, Sikkim.
... Respondents
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India
WP(C) No.38 of 2023
Cipla Limited
vs. Union of India and Others
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Mr. Gopal Mundra, Advocate with Ms. Ashwini Shantharam (through VC)
and Mr. Sangay Gyurmay Bhutia, Advocates for the Petitioner.
Ms. Sangita Pradhan, Deputy Solicitor General of India with Ms. Sittal
Balmiki and Mr. Amit Kumar Sharma, Advocates for the Respondents
No.1, 3 to 6.
Mr. Thinlay Dorjee Bhutia, Government Advocate for Respondent No.2.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------Judgment Pronounced on
: 21.08.2026
Judgment Uploaded on
: 24.08.2026
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
(A. Muhamed Mustaque, C.J.)
1.
The Petitioner, a pharmaceutical company having industrial units
in the State of Sikkim has filed this instant Writ Petition. The matter
arises from a claim for budgetary support under the budgetary support
notification under the Goods and Services Tax (GST) regime to the units
located in the States of Jammu & Kashmir, Uttarakhand, Himachal
Pradesh and North Eastern States including Sikkim issued by the
Ministry of Commerce and Industry, Union of India (Respondent No.1)
on 05.10.2017 to promote industrial growth.
2.
The
Petitioner
had
submitted
a
declaration/application
on
19.09.2019, claiming budgetary support for its unit in Sikkim. In that
declaration/application, the Petitioner claimed Input Tax Credit (ITC) for
an eligible unit amounting to ₹15,28,80,613/- (Rupees fifteen crores,
twenty-eight lakhs, eighty thousand, six hundred and thirteen only). To
substantiate this claim, Respondent No. 6 directed the Petitioner to
provide a Chartered Accountant (CA) certificate. The resulting certificate
explicitly stated that the ITC actually availed by the Petitioner was
₹10,01,57,759/- (Rupees ten crores, one lakh, fifty-seven thousand,
seven hundred and fifty-nine only). However, the proceedings were
concluded via an order dated 19.01.2023 without consideration of the
WP(C) No.38 of 2023
Cipla Limited
vs. Union of India and Others
CA certificate or affording an opportunity for the Petitioner to explain the
discrepancy. The impugned order accepted the initial declaration of
₹15,28,80,613/-, even though the CA certificate confirmed that the ITC
utilized for eligible goods was only ₹10,01,57,759/-.
3.
The Petitioner contends that the higher figure in the declaration
was a mistake and that the actual ITC was the lower amount reflected in
the CA certificate. Consequently, the Petitioner argues that the balance
of ₹5,27,22,856/- (Rupees five crores, twenty-seven lakhs, twenty-two
thousand, eight hundred and fifty-six only) was wrongly deducted from
their entitlement. This writ petition challenges the impugned order
regarding that deduction.
4.
This Court while hearing this matter on 19.09.2025, passed the
following order:“The matter is fixed today for clarification. During the
process of clarification it is noticed that one of the grievances of
the Petitioner is that an opportunity of personal hearing was not
given to the Petitioner by the Respondent No.6 to enable the
Petitioner to clarify the errors made in the claim.
Learned Deputy Solicitor General submits that the
documentary evidence submitted by the Petitioner was the basis
of the computation in the impugned Order.
Considered submissions.
In the wake of foregoing circumstance, it is hereby
ordered that the Respondent No.6 shall afford a personal hearing
to the Petitioner to verify the claims of the Petitioner regarding
the entitlement and errors if any made in such claims in terms of
the dispute detailed in the instant Writ Petition within 45 days’
from today.
Consequent upon consideration by the Respondent No.6,
the matter shall be reverted to this Court. List on 24-11-2025.”
5.
Thereafter, an order was passed by the Respondent No.6 after
hearing the parties on 24.04.2026. As is evident from that order, the
Respondent
refused
to
consider
the
Petitioner’s
objection.
The
Petitioner has pointed out that in terms of the certificate issued by the
CA, the actual figures were reflected therein and due to an error in the
declaration, the Petitioner would be disentitled to the credit to which
the Petitioner would otherwise be entitled.
In the order passed on
WP(C) No.38 of 2023
Cipla Limited
vs. Union of India and Others
24.04.2026, the Respondent observed that there was no provision under
the scheme permitting post facto revision or substitution of figures after
filing, particularly where such revision would alter the quantum of
benefit.
6.
This Court is unable to agree with the finding in the impugned
order, particularly when such finding is contrary to the earlier direction
issued by this Court to consider the claim of the petitioner. The question,
therefore, is whether the petitioner is entitled to seek rectification or,
alternatively, whether the petitioner is entitled to challenge the
impugned order. There may not be any specific statutory provision
governing such a situation. However, on the face of the record, there is
admittedly a discrepancy between the declaration submitted by the
petitioner and the certificate issued by the Chartered Accountant.
7.
In such circumstances, before concluding the proceedings, the
respondent ought to have sought an explanation from the petitioner
regarding the discrepancy apparent from the declaration and the CA
certificate. It is significant that the CA certificate was produced pursuant
to the direction of the respondents themselves. Despite this, the
proceedings
were
concluded
without
affording
the
petitioner
an
opportunity to explain the discrepancy. In such circumstances, the
proceedings could not have been validly concluded without due
consideration of the discrepancy and without affording an opportunity to
the Petitioner to explain the same.
8.
This is not a case in which the question of rectification, in the
ordinary sense in which that expression is understood in assessment
proceedings, arises. The issue is anterior to that. The proceedings
themselves
were
concluded
without
affording
the
petitioner
an
opportunity to explain the discrepancy between the declaration and the
WP(C) No.38 of 2023
Cipla Limited
vs. Union of India and Others
CA certificate. It is true that ordinarily the petitioner would have to
stand by the declaration submitted by the Petitioner. That, however,
cannot be treated as an invariable or inflexible rule. If the petitioner
contends that the declaration contains an error or mistake, the
Petitioner must necessarily be afforded an opportunity to explain how
such mistake occurred and, if necessary, to substantiate the explanation
by supporting documents.
9.
Indeed, the position becomes apparent if the situation is reversed.
If the declaration had disclosed a lesser value while the CA certificate
disclosed a higher value, would the respondents have accepted the
declaration without seeking any explanation? This Court has little doubt
that, in such a situation, the respondents would themselves have called
upon the petitioner to explain the discrepancy. A mere human error in a
declaration cannot, by itself, be capitalised upon to the prejudice of the
claimant without affording an opportunity to explain the same.
10.
This Court is not, at this stage, expressing any opinion as to
whether the discrepancy was in fact the result of an error or whether
the explanation of the petitioner is ultimately acceptable. The limited
question is whether, when the discrepancy was apparent from the
record, the petitioner ought to have been afforded an opportunity to
explain it before the proceedings were concluded. In the considered
view of this Court, the answer must necessarily be in the affirmative.
11.
The Respondents were required to act fairly. When a discrepancy
is apparent on the face of the record, the officer ought to call upon the
applicant to explain the same. If the explanation is found unsatisfactory,
the officer would be at liberty to proceed to a conclusion on the merits.
But the proceedings cannot be concluded without giving the affected
WP(C) No.38 of 2023
Cipla Limited
vs. Union of India and Others
party a reasonable opportunity to explain a discrepancy which forms the
basis of the decision.
12.
Fairness is the hallmark of such proceedings. Therefore, this Court
is of the view that the present case cannot properly be characterised as
one involving rectification in the ordinary course after the conclusion of
proceedings. The defect goes to the proceedings itself, since it was
concluded without affording the petitioner an opportunity to explain the
discrepancy. The proceedings, therefore, could not have been concluded
merely by relying upon the declaration, particularly when the CA
certificate had been produced pursuant to the direction of the
respondents themselves.
13.
This Court is of the view that the proceedings so concluded, have
to be set aside to the extent challenged before this Court, and the
Petitioner is required to be given an opportunity to explain the mistake,
if any, that occurred.
14.
Accordingly, the impugned Order is set aside to the extent of the
challenge before this Court.
15.
The Petitioner is given the liberty to produce all the documents to
substantiate the claim that the mistake occurred in the Declaration.
16.
The Order has to be complied by the Respondents No.5 and 6. The
needful shall be done within eight weeks.
17.
The Petitioner is free to produce any documents in the meanwhile
before the hearing is concluded before the Respondents No. 5 and 6 to
substantiate the contention that there occurred a mistake in the
Declaration.
WP(C) No.38 of 2023
Cipla Limited
18.
vs. Union of India and Others
With the liberty as above, WP(C) No.38 of 2023 is allowed and the
impugned order is set aside to the extent as above.
Chief Justice
Approved for reporting: Yes/No
ds/ami/arc
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review