Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH: THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BHASKAR RAJ PRADHAN, JUDGE
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
R.F.A. No. 06 of 2020
*Mr. Karma Pintso Bhutia,
S/o Late Ong Tshering Bhutia,
R/o Upper M.G. Marg Municipal Ward,
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
….. Appellant
*Substituted vide order dated: 21.09.2021.
versus
1.
Shri Naresh Subba,
S/o Shri A.P. Subba,
R/o House No. T 63(A) & P 87 (B),
Sichey,
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok,
East Sikkim – 737101.
2.
Master Subham Subba,
S/o Shri Naresh Subba,
R/o House No. T 63(A) & P 87 (B),
Sichey,
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok,
East Sikkim – 737101.
3.
Shri Thinlay Karma Peter Topden,
S/o Late Karma Topden @Karma Tenzing Topden,
R/o Martam House, Bhanupath,
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok,
East Sikkim – 737101.
….. Respondents
Appeal under Order XLI rule 1 and 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Mr. Sudipto Majumdar, Senior Advocate with Mr. Basant Kharka, Advocate for
the appellant.
Mr. A. Moulik, Senior Advocate with Mr. Simeon Subba and Ms Adeshna
Subba, Advocate for the respondents no. 1 and 2.
None for respondent no.3.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
and
R.F.A. No. 06 of 2020 (Karma Pintso Bhutia vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
R.F.A. No. 07 of 2020 (M/s Balchand Udairam vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
R.F.A. No. 08 of 2020 (M/s Ramjilal Tarachand vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
R.F.A. No. 07 of 2020
M/s Balchand Udairam,
Shri Jiwan Agarwal,
S/o Late Udairam Agarwal,
R/o Upper M.G. Marg,
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
….. Appellant
versus
1.
Shri Naresh Subba,
S/o Shri A.P. Subba,
R/o House No. T 63(A) & P 87 (B),
Sichey,
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok,
East Sikkim – 737101.
2.
Master Subham Subba,
S/o Shri Naresh Subba,
R/o House No. T 63(A) & P 87 (B),
Sichey,
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok,
East Sikkim – 737101.
3.
Shri Thinlay Karma Peter Topden,
S/o Late Karma Topden @Karma Tenzing Topden,
R/o Martam House, Bhanupath,
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok,
East Sikkim – 737101.
….. Respondents
Appeal under Order XLI rule 1 and 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Mr. Sudipto Majumdar, Senior Advocate with Mr. Basant Kharka, Advocate for
the appellant.
Mr. A. Moulik, Senior Advocate with Mr. Simeon Subba and Ms Adeshna
Subba, Advocate for the respondents no. 1 and 2.
None for respondent no.3.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
and
R.F.A. No. 08 of 2020
M/s Ramjilal Tarachand,
Shri Brahamand Agarwal,
S/o Late Tarachand Agarwal,
R/o Upper M.G. Marg,
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
versus
….. Appellant
R.F.A. No. 06 of 2020 (Karma Pintso Bhutia vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
R.F.A. No. 07 of 2020 (M/s Balchand Udairam vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
R.F.A. No. 08 of 2020 (M/s Ramjilal Tarachand vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
1.
Shri Naresh Subba,
S/o Shri A.P. Subba,
R/o House No. T 63(A) & P 87 (B),
Sichey,
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok,
East Sikkim – 737101.
2.
Master Subham Subba,
S/o Shri Naresh Subba,
R/o House No. T 63(A) & P 87 (B),
Sichey,
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok,
East Sikkim – 737101.
3.
Shri Thinlay Karma Peter Topden,
S/o Late Karma Topden @Karma Tenzing Topden,
R/o Martam House, Bhanupath,
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok,
East Sikkim – 737101.
….. Respondents
Appeal under Order XLI rule 1 and 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Mr. Sudipto Majumdar, Senior Advocate with Mr. Basant Kharka, Advocate for
the appellant.
Mr. A. Moulik, Senior Advocate with Mr. Simeon Subba and Ms Adeshna
Subba, Advocate for the respondents no. 1 and 2.
None for respondent no. 3.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Date of hearing
:
Date of judgment :
21.09.2022, 26.09.2022, 28.09.2022 & 22.11.2022
20.12.2022
JUDGMENT
Bhaskar Raj Pradhan, J.
1.
This judgment shall dispose three identical appeals
preferred by three tenants (the appellants/defendant no.1)
against the judgments and decrees, all dated 30.06.2020, in
Eviction Suits No. 08 of 2015, 09 of 2015 and 10 of 2015. The
impugned judgments and decrees directed the eviction of the
R.F.A. No. 06 of 2020 (Karma Pintso Bhutia vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
R.F.A. No. 07 of 2020 (M/s Balchand Udairam vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
R.F.A. No. 08 of 2020 (M/s Ramjilal Tarachand vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
appellants from the suit property and to vacate the same within
three months of the judgment. Additionally, a decree for recovery
of arrears of rent from the appellants from November 2014 was
directed till the time the appellants handed over vacant
possession of the suit property to the plaintiffs (respondents no.1
and 2).
2.
The eviction suits were filed by the plaintiffs on
28.12.2015 for eviction, recovery of khas possession of the suit
property and arrears of rent. The plaintiffs sought eviction, inter
alia, on the ground of non-payment of rents by the appellants
since November 2014; for bona fide requirement; and for
thorough overhauling.
3.
The appellants filed their written statements on
10.5.2016. The appellants pleaded that the suit was not
maintainable; that there was no landlord tenant relationship; that
the plaintiffs had no locus standi; that the suit was filed for mala
fide purpose and illegal gain; that it was a collusive suit and the
plaintiffs were proxies for late Karma Topden (the original
defendant no.2 and father of present respondent no.3). The
appellants stated that late Martam Topden, father of late Karma
Topden, constructed the suit property in the early 1930s on a plot
of land gifted to him by the then Maharaja of Sikkim. According to
the appellants, the words that fell from the mouth of the then
R.F.A. No. 06 of 2020 (Karma Pintso Bhutia vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
R.F.A. No. 07 of 2020 (M/s Balchand Udairam vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
R.F.A. No. 08 of 2020 (M/s Ramjilal Tarachand vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
Maharaja of Sikkim who was the sovereign ruler became law
during those days; the gift became absolute and late Martam
Topden became the absolute owner of the suit property. After
construction, a portion on the southern side measuring 30’ x 30’
consisting of a shop space at the road level, first basement and
the second basement of the same size below the shop space
were let out to M/s Balchand Udairam (appellant in R.F.A. No. 07
of 2020) on monthly rental by late Martam Topden. The middle
portion of the suit property measuring 10’ x 30’ consisting of a
shop space at the road level, first basement and the second
basement of the same size below the shop space were let out on
a monthly rent to the father of the original defendant no.1 (now
replaced by appellant in R.F.A. No. 06 of 2020). The northern side
measuring 20’ x 30’ consisting of a shop space at the road level,
first basement and the second basement of the same size below
the shop space were let out to Ramjilal Kashiram which was later
changed to M/s Ramjilal Tarachand (the appellant in R.F.A. No. 08
of 2020) in the year 1956 on monthly rentals by late Martam
Topden. According to the appellants, sometime in 1978 late
Karma Topden informed them that his father late Martam Topden
had gifted the suit property to him and thereafter late Karma
Topden started collecting monthly rents for the suit property from
the appellants.
R.F.A. No. 06 of 2020 (Karma Pintso Bhutia vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
R.F.A. No. 07 of 2020 (M/s Balchand Udairam vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
R.F.A. No. 08 of 2020 (M/s Ramjilal Tarachand vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
4.
Late Karma Topden filed his written statement on
10.5.2016 supporting the case of the plaintiffs. He stated that he
had entered into a sale agreement on 6.8.2012 (exhibit-3)(Sale
Agreement) to sell the suit property to the plaintiff at a
consideration value of Rs.4,00,00,000/- and after having received
an
advance
applied
to
Urban
Development
&
Housing
Department (UD&HD), Government of Sikkim, for transfer of suit
property in favour of the plaintiffs. According to Late Karma
Topden, the suit property was then transferred to the plaintiffs vide
lease deed dated 25.11.2013 (exhibit-7) (lease deed) which was
subsequently registered in the name of the plaintiffs on 5.4.2014
after he had received full and final amount of Rs.4,00,00,000/-. He
then informed the appellants about the transfer as they had
agreed to vacate the suit property immediately on its transfer.
Late Karma Topden averred that, however, he had thereafter
received the rent through Demand Drafts/Pay Orders from the
appellants with a covering letter dated 23.2.2015 to which he
replied vide his letter dated 27.2.2015 (exhibit-14), returned the
Demand Drafts/Pay Orders and informed them about the new
house owners, i.e., the plaintiffs. The appellants thereafter sent the
rent through their lawyer Mr Sudesh Joshi along with legal notice
on 4.5.2015 (exhibit –D1/5). Late Karma Topden averred that he
returned the said rent again. He further averred that inspite of the
filing of the eviction suits the appellants sent their rents to him
R.F.A. No. 06 of 2020 (Karma Pintso Bhutia vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
R.F.A. No. 07 of 2020 (M/s Balchand Udairam vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
R.F.A. No. 08 of 2020 (M/s Ramjilal Tarachand vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
through their lawyer Mr Sudesh Joshi by his notice dated 1.4.2016
(exhibit – D1/6 Collectively) which was returned through his
Advocate’s letter dated 13.4.2016 (exhibit – D2/13).
5.
The order dated 30.10.2018 of the District Judge
records the filing of an application for substitution of the legal heirs
of late Karma Topden as he expired on 4.8.2018. The application
was allowed and late Karma Topden was substituted by his son
Thinlay Karma Peter Topden as defendant no.2 in the suit
(respondent no.3 herein). Thinlay Karma Peter Topden then filed
his written statement reiterating what his father late Karma
Topden had stated in his written statement.
6.
The learned District Judge framed eleven identical
issues for consideration in all the three eviction suits. The plaintiff
no.1 examined himself, Bijay Mondal (PW-2), Ashim Basnet (PW-3),
A. B. Karki (PW-4) and Siddharth Rasaily (PW-5) in support of his
case. Late Ong Tshering Bhutia (original defendant no.1 in Eviction
Suit No. 08 of 2020), Jiwan Agarwal (represented the defendant
no.1 in Eviction Suit No. 09 of 2015) and Brahmanand Agarwal
(represented the defendant no.1 in Eviction Suit No. 10 of 2015),
deposed for themselves as defendant no.1 as well as for each
other as witnesses in the three Eviction Suits. Tsewang Rinzing
Dorjee deposed on behalf of Thinlay Karma Peter Topden who
substituted his father late Karma Topden and reiterated what both
R.F.A. No. 06 of 2020 (Karma Pintso Bhutia vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
R.F.A. No. 07 of 2020 (M/s Balchand Udairam vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
R.F.A. No. 08 of 2020 (M/s Ramjilal Tarachand vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
late Karma Topden as well as Thinlay Karma Peter Topden stated
in their written statements. Tsewang Rinzing Dorjee verified and
confirmed the contents of his evidence on affidavit. During his
cross-examination, he stated that although the appellants had
been tendering the rent to the defendant no.2, he did not
accept the rents.
7.
The learned District Judge while examining issues no.1,
2 and 3, concluded that the plaintiffs are the owners of the suit
property through the lease deed and so they had the locus standi
to file the eviction suits which was thus maintainable. The learned
District Judge also held that the lease deed was valid and the
schedule of the lease deed to be correct on examining Issues No.
4 and 5. It was further held that late Karma Topden had let out all
the three floors to the appellants on monthly rent while deciding
Issue No. 6. Issue No. 10 was also decided in favour of the plaintiffs
and it was held that the appellants had made alterations and
additions to the suit property. While deciding issue no.11, the
learned District Judge concluded that on the valid execution of
the lease deed, the plaintiffs became the owner of the suit
premises. The learned District Judge held that the appellants had
defaulted in payments of rents of more than four months; that the
plaintiffs required the suit property for their bona fide need and
occupation; and that the suit property was in a dilapidated
R.F.A. No. 06 of 2020 (Karma Pintso Bhutia vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
R.F.A. No. 07 of 2020 (M/s Balchand Udairam vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
R.F.A. No. 08 of 2020 (M/s Ramjilal Tarachand vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
condition requiring thorough overhauling while deciding Issues No.
7, 8 and 9.
8.
Mr. Sudipto Mazumdar, the learned Senior Advocate
for the appellants, assailed the impugned judgment on the
grounds set out in the appeal. It was his case that the suit property
was constructed not on leasehold land but on the land gifted by
the Maharaja of Sikkim to late Martam Topden and as such the
lease deed by which the plaintiffs sought title is non-est. It was
argued that there was no jural relationship of landlord and tenant
between the plaintiffs and the appellant. He submitted that the
claim of the plaintiffs of having purchased the suit property is false
since there was no registered sale deed. It was also submitted
that there was no default of payment of rent as the appellants
continued to tender rent to late Karma Topden and thereafter to
his son Karma Peter Thinlay Topden. The plaintiffs did not have any
locus standi to file the suits which was thus not maintainable. The
Eviction Suits were filed by the plaintiffs on proxy for late Karma
Topden and therefore it was collusive suit. He relied upon the
judgment of the Supreme Court in Apollo Zipper India Limited vs. W.
Newman and Company Limited1 to submit that though by virtue of
section 116 of the Evidence Act, the tenant is estopped from
challenging the title of his landlord, yet the tenant is entitled to
(2018) 6 SCC 744
R.F.A. No. 06 of 2020 (Karma Pintso Bhutia vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
R.F.A. No. 07 of 2020 (M/s Balchand Udairam vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
R.F.A. No. 08 of 2020 (M/s Ramjilal Tarachand vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
challenge the derivative title of an assignee of the original
landlord of the demised property in an action brought by the
assignee against the tenant for his eviction under the rent laws.
9.
Mr. A. Moulik, learned Senior Advocate for the plaintiffs
vehemently defended the impugned judgment and submitted
that the prayers for eviction were correctly granted as they had
been able to prove non-payment of rent for more than four
months; bona fide need; as well as the fact that the suit property
was in dilapidated condition requiring thorough overhauling. He
relied upon various judgment of the Supreme Court as well as this
Court. Relying upon Apollo Zipper India Limited (supra), he submitted
that in eviction suits when issue of title is raised, landlord is not
expected to prove his title like what he is required to prove in a
title suit. He relied upon Ambica Prasad vs. Mohd. Alam and Another2 to
submit that under section 109 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882
a transferee of a landlord’s right enters into the shoe of the
landlord in respect of the subsisting tenancy and attornment by
tenant is not required. He relied upon Shamim Akhtar vs. Iqbal Ahmad
and Another3 and submitted that a tenant by merely denying title
cannot avoid eviction. He relied upon Swadesh Ranjan Sinha vs.
Haradeb Banerjee4 to submit that even a sub-lessee could be the
owner/landlord and entitled to file eviction suit. The judgment of
(2015) 13 SCC 13
(2000) 8 SCC 123
4 (1991) 4 SCC 572
R.F.A. No. 06 of 2020 (Karma Pintso Bhutia vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
R.F.A. No. 07 of 2020 (M/s Balchand Udairam vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
R.F.A. No. 08 of 2020 (M/s Ramjilal Tarachand vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
this court in Tika Khawas vs. Pashupati Nath5 was cited to submit that
the landlord under the Gangtok Rent Control and Eviction Act,
1956 need not be the owner.
10.
On examination of the plaints, it is seen that the suits
were filed essentially for eviction of the appellants by the plaintiffs.
As the suit property is situated in Gangtok, under section 4 of the
Gangtok Rent Control and Eviction Act, 1956 a tenant can be
evicted essentially on three grounds, i.e., when whole or part of
the premises are required for the bona fide occupation of the
landlord or his dependents; for thorough overhauling (excluding
additions and alteration); and when the rent in arrears amount to
four month rent or more. In the case of thorough overhauling, the
tenant so evicted shall, have the first right to reoccupy the
premises on such enhanced rate as may be fixed by the Sikkim
Durbar [now the State Government vide the Adaptation of Sikkim
Law (1) Order, 1975 which came into force on 27th April, 1975].
Thus, out of the eleven issues framed, issues no. 7, 8 and 9 would
determine the fate of the suit.
11.
The Gangtok Rent Control and Eviction Act, 1956
which is applicable to Gangtok does not define the word
‘landlord’ used therein, unlike Notification No.6326-600-H&W-B
dated 14.04.1949, which is the existing rent law for the rest of
5AIR 1986 Sikkim 6
R.F.A. No. 06 of 2020 (Karma Pintso Bhutia vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
R.F.A. No. 07 of 2020 (M/s Balchand Udairam vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
R.F.A. No. 08 of 2020 (M/s Ramjilal Tarachand vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
Sikkim. However, it is settled that under the Gangtok Rent Control
and Eviction Act, 1956 it is not necessary that the landlord should
also be the owner of the property. This Court in Tika Khawas (supra)
held that the expression ‘landlord’ as used in the Gangtok Rent
Control and Eviction Act, 1956 is to be construed in its ordinary
sense and there is no warrant for the contention that ‘landlord’
means ‘owner’. This Court, therefore, affirmed the finding of the
learned Trial Court that the plaintiff had locus standi to bring the
suit repelling the contention that as the plaintiff was not the owner
of the suit premises he had no locus standi as he was not the
landlord. Resultantly, it is settled that to file an eviction suit under
the Gangtok Rent Control and Eviction Act, 1956 it is not
necessary to establish that the plaintiff is the owner of the suit
property and it would be enough if he established that he was the
landlord.
12.
The appellants do not dispute that they are tenants.
They also do not dispute that late Martam Topden and thereafter,
late Karma Topden, were the owners of the suit property as well as
their landlords. Infact, the appellants had attorned to late Karma
Topden after he started collecting rents from them on the demise
of late Martam Topden. The appellants disputed that the plaintiff
had purchased the suit property since the plaintiffs had failed to
annex any registered sale deed or registered conveyance deed
executed by late Karma Topden in their favour. The appellants
R.F.A. No. 06 of 2020 (Karma Pintso Bhutia vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
R.F.A. No. 07 of 2020 (M/s Balchand Udairam vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
R.F.A. No. 08 of 2020 (M/s Ramjilal Tarachand vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
contended that the suit was collusive one with an ulterior motive
to make out the grounds for eviction.
13.
What therefore falls for consideration is to what extent
could the appellants, who were admittedly tenants of late Karma
Topden in the suit property, dispute the assertion made by late
Karma Topden that he had sold the property to the plaintiffs? In
Apollo Zipper India Limited (supra), the Supreme Court held that it is
settled principle of law laid down by it that in an eviction suit filed
by the landlord against the tenant under the rent laws, when the
issue of title over the tenanted premises is raised, the landlord is
not expected to prove his title like what he is required to prove in
a title suit. In other words, the burden of proving the ownership in
an eviction suit is not the same like a title suit. The Supreme Court
further held that by virtue of section 116 of the Indian Evidence
Act, the tenant is estopped from challenging the title of his
landlord yet the tenant is entitled to challenge derivative title of
an assignee of the original landlord of the demised property in an
action brought by the assignee against the tenant for his eviction
under the rent laws.
14.
Admittedly, the appellants had been informed by late
Karma Topden about the transfer of the suit property to the
plaintiffs vide his letter dated 27.2.2015 (exhibit-14). In fact, the
appellants by their Advocate’s letter 4.5.2015 (exhibit-D-1/5) to
R.F.A. No. 06 of 2020 (Karma Pintso Bhutia vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
R.F.A. No. 07 of 2020 (M/s Balchand Udairam vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
R.F.A. No. 08 of 2020 (M/s Ramjilal Tarachand vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
late Karma Topden disputed that the suit property had been sold
to the plaintiffs inspite of a clear assertion to that effect in the
letter dated 27.2.2015. In cross-examination, late Ong Tshering
Bhutia admitted that if the plaintiff would have furnished copies of
registered sale deed to them justifying the fact that they had
purchased the suit property then they would have paid the
plaintiffs’ rent. He admitted that since the plaintiffs produced the
registered lease deed, they declined to give him rent on the
presumption that he did not become the owner of the suit
property by virtue of such lease deed. He admitted that although
late Karma Topden told him and other tenants that the plaintiffs
had become the owners of the suit property and they were now
required to pay rent to them still they kept sending the rent to late
Karma Topden. He further admitted that the plaintiff no.1 had
informed them that they had purchased the suit property for
Rs.4,00,00,000/- and the UD&HD had transferred the land on lease
basis and as such they had become owners of the suit property.
However, they did not believe the plaintiffs statement and
continued sending rent to late Karma Topden. He also admitted
that they did not give reply to the plaintiffs legal notice dated
15.9.2015 (exhibit-21). Jiwan Agarwal too admitted that vide letter
dated 27.2.2015 (exhibit-14), late Karma Topden informed them
that plaintiff no.1 had become the owner of the suit property. He
further admitted that by letter dated 6.8.2015 (exhibit-15 and
R.F.A. No. 06 of 2020 (Karma Pintso Bhutia vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
R.F.A. No. 07 of 2020 (M/s Balchand Udairam vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
R.F.A. No. 08 of 2020 (M/s Ramjilal Tarachand vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
exhibit-D1/2), late Karma Topden informed the appellant’s lawyer
that the plaintiff no.1 was the owner of the suit property while
returning the Demand Draft/Pay Order. He admitted that by the
plaintiffs letter dated 21.8.2015 (exhibit-16) addressed to him and
other appellants they informed that they were the new owners of
the suit property and that the appellants had not paid rent to
them. Inspite of receipt of the same, the appellants did not pay
the rent to the plaintiffs or made any inquiry before the Registrar
or UD&HD to know whether it was true. He admitted that by the
plaintiffs’ lawyers letter dated 15.9.2015 (exhibit-21) to the
appellants, he informed them that the plaintiffs were the lessees
of the land in which the suit property was located by way of a
lease deed registered on 5.8.2014. He admitted that the
appellants had been informed of the change in ownership of the
suit property but inspite of the receipt they did not offer rent to the
plaintiffs. He further admitted that there was in fact a meeting at
Hotel Tashi Delek between the plaintiff no.1 and the appellants.
Brahmanand Agarwal also admitted having received the notice
from the plaintiffs’ advocate informing him that they had become
the owners of the suit property through lease deed, however, he
had not replied to the notice. He admitted that even after receipt
of the notice none of the appellants paid rent and instead sent
the same to late Karma Topden who did not accept it but
returned it to them. He admitted that late Karma Topden had sent
R.F.A. No. 06 of 2020 (Karma Pintso Bhutia vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
R.F.A. No. 07 of 2020 (M/s Balchand Udairam vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
R.F.A. No. 08 of 2020 (M/s Ramjilal Tarachand vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
several letters to the appellants duly informing all of them that
plaintiff no.1 was the owner of the suit property which was very
much in their knowledge as all of them had met plaintiff no.1 at
Hotel Tashi Delek.
15.
In an eviction suit under the Gangtok Rent Control and
Eviction Act, 1956, it would not be necessary to go into the
question of title as it would suffice if the plaintiffs established they
were the landlords in view of what has been settled by this Court
in Tika Khawas (supra). The Apellants’ bona fide seeking to ascertain
the fact to protect themselves without disowning that he is a
tenant of the suit property would be legitimate. However, the
appellants not acknowledging or attorning to the plaintiffs, inspite
of being told in writing by late Karma Topden, the admitted owner
and landlord of the suit property, that he had sold the suit
property to the plaintiffs and returning the rents forwarded would
be dogged insistence only. The records reveal that the appellants
were informed in writing as well as orally in more than one
occasion that the suit property had since been sold to the
plaintiffs. Late Karma Topden had informed the appellants in
writing about it vide his letter dated 27.2.2015 (exhibit-14). By this
time, late Karma Topden had already entered and executed sale
agreement dated 6.8.2012 and thereafter the plaintiffs had
entered upon a lease deed with UD&HD on 25.11.2013. The lease
deed also granted the plaintiffs the right to transfer the suit
R.F.A. No. 06 of 2020 (Karma Pintso Bhutia vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
R.F.A. No. 07 of 2020 (M/s Balchand Udairam vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
R.F.A. No. 08 of 2020 (M/s Ramjilal Tarachand vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
property with the previous written consent of the UD&HD.
According to the plaintiffs, pursuant to the sale agreement dated
6.8.2012, they paid Rs.4,00,00,000/- to late Karma Topden.
Tsewang Rinzing Dorjee who deposed on behalf of Thinlay Karma
Peter Topden, son of late Karma Topden, also confirmed the
payment. Thereafter, late Karma Topden also executed sale
deed document and approached the office of the Sub-Registrar,
Gangtok for transfer of the suit property in favour of the plaintiffs.
However, the Sub-Registrar found that the land in which the suit
property stood was recorded in the name of Sarkar and therefore,
directed them to approach the UD&HD for execution of lease. A.
B. Karki, the Sub-Registrar then, also verified this fact in his
deposition before the learned District Judge. Quite evidently, the
plaintiffs had purchased the suit property from late Karma
Topden, became landlord and had the locus standi to seek
eviction of the appellants for their defaults. The plaintiffs had
proved that they had a better title over the suit property than the
appellants. It is inconceivable that late Karma Topden, the
original owner of the suit property would sign the sale agreement,
the sale deed and also inform the appellants in writing that he
had sold the suit property to the plaintiff and give away all his
rights to the suit property in favour of the plaintiffs only to collude
with them to evict the appellants. However, the appellants
declined to acknowledge these facts and resorted to legalese to
R.F.A. No. 06 of 2020 (Karma Pintso Bhutia vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
R.F.A. No. 07 of 2020 (M/s Balchand Udairam vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
R.F.A. No. 08 of 2020 (M/s Ramjilal Tarachand vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
dispute the claim of late Karma Topden as well as the plaintiffs.
Therefore, till the receipt of the letter dated 27.2.2015 (exhibit-14)
of late Karma Topden, the appellants’ non-payment of rent to the
plaintiffs may be excused but their failure to do so thereafter
would definitely be default. A little effort on the part of the
appellant may have yielded better information to convince
themselves that they were required to accept the plaintiffs as their
landlords but they decided to remain adamant on their initial
insistence and not reason their own unreasonableness. The
appellant ought to have known that they would continue to be
the tenants and not get better title on the suit property by refusing
to acknowledge the plaintiffs as the new landlords. Admittedly,
the appellants had not paid rents of the suit property from
November 2014. The suit was filed in December 2015. Nonpayment of rent to the plaintiffs after receipt of letter dated
27.2.2015 of late Karma Topden till December 2015 would
necessarily have to be considered as their default. As the period
would be for more than four months, the default would squarely
fall within the period when the rent in arrears amount to four
month rent or more which would permit the plaintiffs to seek their
eviction for non-payment of rent under the Gangtok Rent Control
and Eviction Act, 1956.
16.
Resultantly, it is held that the appellants were in arrears
of rent for four months and more and on this ground alone the
R.F.A. No. 06 of 2020 (Karma Pintso Bhutia vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
R.F.A. No. 07 of 2020 (M/s Balchand Udairam vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
R.F.A. No. 08 of 2020 (M/s Ramjilal Tarachand vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
appellants were liable to be evicted. The finding of the learned
District Judge on this aspect is upheld and Issue No.7 is held in
favour of the plaintiffs.
17.
The learned District Judge also held that the plaintiffs
required the suit premises for their bona fide and personal
occupation. The plaintiffs had pleaded that when late Karma
Topden approached them with the offer of sale of suit property
they were on the lookout for a suitable property to build their own
residential house along with a hotel as they did not own a house
of their own and were living in a rented accommodation
belonging to Ashim Basnett. The plaintiffs also asserted that they
required the suit property for commercial purpose. The learned
District Judge on examination of the evidence concluded that
the plaintiffs did not have their own residential house in Gangtok
whereas the appellants admittedly had their own residential
houses situated at Tibet Road and New Market Road in Gangtok.
The plaintiff no.1 has deposed that the plaintiffs did not own any
residential properties in Gangtok. Ashim Basnett deposed that the
plaintiffs were his tenants. Their cross-examination did not bring
out anything contrary to their depositions in chief. The appellants
admitted having their own residential houses in Tibet Road and
New Market Road in Gangtok. The assertions of the plaintiffs that
the suit property was required for their bona fide occupation has
been proved. The need projected is genuine and a reasonable
R.F.A. No. 06 of 2020 (Karma Pintso Bhutia vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
R.F.A. No. 07 of 2020 (M/s Balchand Udairam vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
R.F.A. No. 08 of 2020 (M/s Ramjilal Tarachand vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
one and not just devised to evict the appellants. The finding of the
learned District Judge on Issue No.8 is also upheld.
18.
The learned District Judge further concluded that the
suit premises were in dilapidated condition and required thorough
overhauling and that the appellants were required to be evicted
on this ground as well. The learned counsel for the appellants
submitted that since the appellants had been evicted on this
ground, as required under section 4 of the Gangtok Rent Control
and Eviction Act, 1956 the plaintiffs should be directed to offer the
first right of pre-occupation to the appellants on the suit property
after being thoroughly overhauled. The submission of the learned
counsel for the appellants would hold good if the appellants had
been evicted solely on this ground of thorough overhauling.
However, as the eviction of the appellants has been upheld on
the ground of non-payment of rents as well as for bona fide
requirement, even if this court upholds the findings of the learned
District Judge that the appellants were liable to be evicted on the
ground of thorough overhauling, the appellants would not get the
benefit of the right of pre-occupation after it is over-hauled.
19.
It is the case of the plaintiffs that the suit property was
constructed several decades ago and since become old and
dilapidated requiring complete reconstruction and overhauling.
The appellants themselves assert that the suit property, i.e., a
R.F.A. No. 06 of 2020 (Karma Pintso Bhutia vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
R.F.A. No. 07 of 2020 (M/s Balchand Udairam vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
R.F.A. No. 08 of 2020 (M/s Ramjilal Tarachand vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
three storied wooden house was constructed by late Martam
Topden sometime in early 1930 after which the appellants have
been in occupation of various portions of the suit property. They,
however, deny that it is in dilapidated condition. According to the
appellants,
the
three
storied
wooden
house
undergoes
maintenance periodically and the expenses are borne by the
appellants. No evidence was, however, placed before the court
to establish what they asserted. Late Ong Tshering Bhutia and
Jiwan Agarwal admitted that the suit property was 89 years old.
Bijoy Mondal, the plaintiffs’ witness, also asserted that the suit
property was an old dilapidated wooden house as personally
informed by late Karma Topden to him. Bijoy Mondal also stated
that on his query and personal inspection the house was
constructed several decades ago and since had become old
and
dilapidated
requiring
complete
reconstruction
and
overhauling. Siddarth Rasaily, Town Planner of Gangtok Municipal
Corporation,
deposed
about
various
notices
(exhibit-5A
collectively) issued to late Karma Topden informing him that the
suit property occupied by the appellants were found to be in
dilapidated condition and not fit for habitation upon its technical
verification.
Exhibit-5A
760/UD&HD
dated
collectively
19.6.1992,
consists
761/UD&HD
of
notice
dated
nos.
19.6.1992,
762/UD&HD dated 19.6.1992 and 763/UD&HD dated 19.6.1992
issued to late Karma Topden by the Assistant Town Planner stating
R.F.A. No. 06 of 2020 (Karma Pintso Bhutia vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
R.F.A. No. 07 of 2020 (M/s Balchand Udairam vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
R.F.A. No. 08 of 2020 (M/s Ramjilal Tarachand vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
that on technical verification, it is found that the wooden house
structure housing Ramjilal Tarachand, Ong Tshering Bhutia and
Balchand Udairam, is in a dilapidated condition and found unsafe
for habitation. Exhibit-5A collectively also includes final notice
no.1406(77)/UDHD/2240 dated 21.9.1992 addressed to late Karma
Topden calling upon him to submit a Blue Print Plan for new RCC
building to be constructed in place of the old wooden structure
which is required to be demolished within the given time. The last
notice in exhibit-5A collectively is notice no. 320/TP-1/UD&HD
dated 26.3.2012 issued by the Town Planner to late Karma Topden
stating that all owners of old wooden houses are directed to
submit Blue Print Plan for a new structure that has been designed
according to the Bureau of Indian Standards norms for seismic
zones IV and V. The notice dated 26.3.2012 was a notice signed
by Siddarth Rasaily. Exhibit-5A collectively reflects that the UD&HD
had been pursuing late Karma Topden to demolish the old
wooden structure much prior to the transfer of the suit property by
him to the plaintiffs. This fact belies the allegation of the
appellants that the plaintiffs were making a false claim in collusion
with late Karma Topden to make out a ground for eviction.
According to the plaintiff no.1, before the lease deed dated
25.11.2013 was executed, the UD&HD vide letter dated 5.12.2013
(exhibit-5) put a condition to him that it would transfer the allotted
site only if an undertaking was given by the plaintiffs that they
R.F.A. No. 06 of 2020 (Karma Pintso Bhutia vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
R.F.A. No. 07 of 2020 (M/s Balchand Udairam vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
R.F.A. No. 08 of 2020 (M/s Ramjilal Tarachand vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
would submit a Blue Print Plan for approval and start construction
within six months. The plaintiffs submitted an undertaking dated
7.12.2013 (exhibit-6) pursuant to which the lease deed was
executed. The plaintiffs, thereafter, also submitted the Blue Print
Plan (exhibit-8) which was duly approved by the UD&HD and
pursuant to which the UD&HD issued the Construction Order
dated 22.9.2014 (exhibit-9). These facts have been substantially
proved by the plaintiffs and inspite of lengthy and detailed crossexamination of the plaintiff no.1 and the plaintiffs’ other witnesses
nothing substantial to destroy the case made out by the plaintiffs
has been brought forth. Consequently, Issue No. 9 is also held in
favour of the plaintiffs and against the appellants.
20.
The plaintiffs had claimed that the appellants had not
paid rents since November 2014. It is the appellants’ case that
they had tendered the rents to late Karma Topden and not to the
plaintiffs as they refused to accept that the plaintiffs had
purchased the suit property. Admittedly, late Karma Topden
declined to accept the rents so tendered and returned it to the
appellants. The eviction suits were filed in December 2015. The
records do not reveal that the appellants deposited the rents
before the learned District Judge. It is only at the stage of the
appeals on the direction of this Court that rents from November
2014 have been deposited by the appellants. Special equities are
not in favour of the appellants. The learned District Judge had
R.F.A. No. 06 of 2020 (Karma Pintso Bhutia vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
R.F.A. No. 07 of 2020 (M/s Balchand Udairam vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
R.F.A. No. 08 of 2020 (M/s Ramjilal Tarachand vs. Naresh Subba & Others)
directed the appellants to vacate and hand over the suit
premises within three months from the date of the impugned
judgment. The eviction decree passed by the learned District
Judge is confirmed. The appellants shall vacate the suit premises
within three months from the date of this judgment. The plaintiffs
are entitled to the arrears of rent from November 2014 till the
appellants hand over the suit property to them.
21.
The amount of rent deposited by the appellants with
effect from November 2014, in terms of the order of this Court
dated 12.10.2020, in State Bank of India maintained in the name
of the Registrar General, High Court of Sikkim, be released to the
plaintiffs along with the interest accrued on the deposit, if any.
22.
Appeals dismissed.
23.
Consequently, the stay granted in all the appeals vide
order dated 12.10.2020 stand vacated.
24.
Copy of this Judgment shall be sent to the learned Trial
Court for information.
25.
Trial Court records be remitted forthwith.
( Bhaskar Raj Pradhan )
Judge
Approved for reporting : Yes/No
Internet
: Yes/No
bp
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review