Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
WP(C) No. 2490/2021
Reserved on: 21.05.2026
Pronounced on: 06.06.2026
Uploaded on: 06.06.2026
Operative part or full Judgement: Full
M/S Alpine Agro Services,
Through authorized partner,
Abdul Majid Mattoo (79 Yrs.)
S/O Mubarik Shah Mattoo
R/O Bul Bul Bagh, Barzulla,
Srinagar.
…Petitioner(s)
Through:
Mr. Salih Pirzada, Advocate
Mr. Ahmad Basuad, Advocate
Vs.
1. Union of India through,
Ministry of Consumer Affairs,
Food & Public Distribution Deptt.,
New Delhi.
2. Food Corporation of India through,
General Manager, FCI,
Regional Office, Jammu,
Jammu & Kashmir.
3. Assistant General Manager (PEG),
Food Corporation of India,
Jammu.
4. Manager Store,
Divisional Officer,
Food Corporation of India,
Srinagar.
...Respondent(s)
Through:
Mr. T. M. Shamsi, DSGI with
Ms. Yasmeen Jan, Advocate for R-1
Mr. Jahangir Ahmad Ganai, Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Omais Kawoos, Advocate for R-2 to R-4
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR JUSTICE M. A. CHOWDHARY, JUDGE
JUDGEMENT
01.
The petitioner has invoked the writ jurisdiction of this Court
seeking quashment of communications/orders dated 03.09.2021
and 15.11.2021 issued by the respondent-Food Corporation of
India (FCI), whereby recoveries have been ordered to be effected
from the monthly rentals payable to the petitioner-firm on
account of the alleged delay in completion of black-topping of the
internal roads of the godown established by the petitioner under
the Private Entrepreneur Guarantee (PEG) Scheme.
02.
The petitioner-firm, a registered partnership concern, claims to be
aggrieved of the action of the respondents in effecting recoveries
by way of penalty from the rentals payable under the Lease and
Service Agreement executed between the parties, on the grounds
that the construction of the godown was completed in conformity
with the prescribed norms and specifications and that the same
was taken over by the respondents after being found suitable and
operationally fit for storage purposes; that the only work which
remained to be completed was the black-topping of the internal
roads. It is submitted that, under the applicable guidelines, the
said work was required to be completed within one year from the
commissioning of the facility. The petitioner asserts that the work
could not be completed within the stipulated period due to
circumstances beyond his control, including the demise of a
partner and the extraordinary law and order situation which
prevailed in the Kashmir Valley during the year 2016.
03.
The case set up by the petitioner, in brief, is that the respondentFCI invited tenders for construction of godowns for storage of
food grains in the Union Territory of Jammu & Kashmir under
the PEG Scheme. The petitioner-firm participated in the tendering
process and was awarded the work of construction of a godown
having a storage capacity of 17,500 MT at Srinagar on “Build,
Own and Operate” basis vide Letter of Memorandum dated
21.05.2013 for a guaranteed period of ten years.
04.
It is pleaded that though a Lease and Service Agreement was
initially executed between the parties, the same could not be
registered owing to the demise of one of the partners, namely
Irfan Mattoo. Consequently, a fresh Lease and Service
Agreement came to be executed on 17.06.2016, which was
deemed to have commenced with effect from 26.02.2015. Under
the terms of the agreement, the godown was taken over on
Guaranteed Hiring Basis (GHB) for the period commencing from
27.02.2015 upto 20.05.2024 at the approved rate of Rs.10.20 per
quintal per month, subject to annual escalation in accordance with
the Wholesale Price Index (WPI).
05.
The petitioner avers that despite the godown having remained
continuously operational since February, 2015, the respondents
issued a communication dated 21.10.2016 proposing imposition
of penalty on account of non-completion of the black-topping
work. It is asserted that the said communication was never served
upon the petitioner and that knowledge thereof was acquired only
in November, 2017.
06.
Upon coming to know of the aforesaid communication, the
petitioner submitted a representation seeking reconsideration of
the proposed action. However, the said representation came to be
rejected vide communication dated 07.11.2017. The petitioner
further places reliance upon a communication dated 02.01.2018
issued by the District Development Commissioner, Bandipora,
wherein it was stated that no macadamization work had been
undertaken in the district during the year 2016, owing to the
prevailing law and order disturbances. According to the
petitioner, the said communication substantiates the plea that the
delay in completion of the black-topping work was attributable to
circumstances beyond its control.
07.
It is the specific case of the petitioner that the black-topping work
was
ultimately
completed
during
May–June,
2017.
Notwithstanding the same, the respondents imposed a penalty
amounting to Rs.1,58,002/-, which was recovered from the
rentals payable by the respondent-FCI, to the petitioner, alleging
that despite having already recovered the aforesaid amount, the
respondents proceeded to impose further recoveries through the
impugned communications dated 03.09.2021 and 15.11.2021.
08.
The respondents have contested the writ petition by filing
reply/objections and have, at the outset, raised a preliminary
objection with regard to the maintainability of the writ petition,
asserting further that the impugned communications merely
implement the decisions taken by the High Level Committee
(HLC) in its meetings held on 09.11.2016, 28.03.2017 and
16.11.2017. It is contended that the petitioner has challenged only
the consequential communications and not the decisions of the
High Level Committee, which constitute the very foundation of
the impugned action.
09.
The respondents submit next that at the time of inspection prior to
takeover of the godown, it was noticed that the drainage work as
well as black-topping of the internal roads had not been
completed; that the petitioner furnished an affidavit dated
24.02.2015, undertaking to complete the drainage work by
March, 2015 and the black-topping work by September, 2015,
however, the petitioner failed to adhere to the undertaking so
furnished, the respondents granted additional relaxation and
extended the period for completion of the black-topping work
upto one year from the date of takeover, i.e., upto 26.02.2016.
10.
The respondents further maintain that black-topping of the
internal roads constitutes an essential component of the
infrastructure envisaged under the Model Tender Form (MTF)
and that non-completion thereof amounts to breach of contractual
obligations. Reliance is placed upon Clause 5 of the Lease and
Service Agreement which, according to the respondents,
empowers the lessee to terminate the contract in the event of
failure, on the part of the lessor to fulfil its contractual
obligations, nevertheless, instead of terminating the agreement, a
lenient view was adopted and recoveries were ordered, in terms
of the decisions taken by the High Level Committee.
11.
It is further submitted that the explanation furnished by the
petitioner regarding the law and order situation in the Valley is
untenable, inasmuch as the extended deadline for completion of
the black-topping work expired on 26.02.2016, whereas the
disturbances referred to by the petitioner commenced only in
July, 2016; that the issue relating to non-completion of blacktopping by PEG investors, across the country, was examined by
the High Level Committee, which observed that black-topping
constituted an essential requirement and that non-compliance,
therewith, could not be treated as a minor deviation.
12.
The respondents state that the High Level Committee initially
considered withdrawal of the guarantee and conversion of the
hiring arrangement to Actual Utilization Basis (AUB). However,
upon reconsideration, it was decided that in cases where blacktopping was completed beyond one year, recoveries would be
effected by reducing the rentals on Actual Utilization Basis, along
with deduction equivalent to twice the Cost Saving Amount
(CSA).
13.
It is submitted that the impugned recoveries have been effected in
pursuance of the aforesaid policy decisions taken uniformly
throughout the country and are not confined to the petitioner
alone.
14.
It is further submitted that during the pendency of the
proceedings, the respondents were permitted to place on record
an additional affidavit explaining the methodology adopted for
calculating the recoverable amount. In the said affidavit, it has
been stated that the recovery of Rs.1,58,002/- was initiated in
compliance with audit objections raised by the Comptroller and
Auditor General (CAG) of India, which had noticed that certain
PEG godowns, including that of the petitioner, had not completed
black-topping work, despite receiving rentals on Guaranteed
Hiring Basis.
15.
The respondents explain that the Guaranteed Hiring Basis ensures
payment of assured rentals irrespective of the actual utilization of
the storage capacity. According to them, the petitioner, having
failed to provide complete infrastructure in terms of the Model
Tender Form, was not entitled to avail such benefit.
16.
It is further stated that the amount recoverable was calculated on
the basis of the estimated cost saved by the petitioner by not
undertaking the black-topping work and the corresponding time
value of money. As per the calculation furnished, the cost of
black-topping was assessed at Rs.123.22 per square metre.
Considering the area of the godown premises measuring 7,693.68
square metres, the annual cost saving was computed at
Rs.9,48,015/-, translating into a monthly figure of Rs.79,001/-.
The recovery of Rs.1,58,002/- represented twice the monthly
cost-saving amount.
17.
The respondents reiterate that the impugned recoveries are
traceable to the decisions of the High Level Committee, which
had directed that in cases where black-topping was completed
beyond the permissible period, rentals from the commencement
of hiring till completion of the black-topping work would be
regulated on Actual Utilization Basis with deduction of twice the
Cost Saving Amount.
18.
It is lastly pleaded that since the petitioner completed the black-
topping work only during the year 2017, recoveries were initiated
for the period commencing from February, 2015 till completion
of the work, strictly in accordance with the formula approved by
the High Level Committee.
19.
Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner submits that the
impugned action of the respondents is arbitrary, violative of the
principles of natural justice and dehors the terms and conditions
governing the contract between the parties. It is argued that
neither the Lease and Service Agreement nor any other
contractual stipulation authorizes unilateral imposition of penalty
or recovery from the rentals, in the manner sought to be effected
by the respondents. It is further contended that no opportunity of
hearing was afforded to the petitioner prior to issuance of the
impugned communications and that the respondents, having
continuously utilized the godown without any interruption and
having suffered no demonstrable loss, cannot impose punitive
recoveries upon the petitioner.
20.
Learned counsel for the petitioner, referred and relied upon the
law laid down by the Apex Court in the cases reported as (2015)
4 SCC 136, (2006) 10 SCC 236 and (2023) 2 SCC 703, in
support of his submissions.
21.
The Supreme Court in the judgement in Noble Resources Ltd. v.
State of Orissa, (2006) 10 SCC 236, held that merely because a
dispute arises out of a contractual relationship, the jurisdiction of
this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution is not completely
ousted, where the action of the State or its instrumentalities is
alleged to be arbitrary, unreasonable or violative of Article 14 of
the Constitution of India. It is argued that since the respondentFCI is a State within the meaning of Article 12 of the
Constitution, its actions are required to satisfy the test of fairness
and non-arbitrariness even in contractual matters, and therefore
the impugned recoveries are amenable to judicial review.
22.
Learned counsel for the petitioners has also placed reliance upon
the judgment rendered in M.P. Power Management Co. Ltd. v.
Sky Power Southeast Solar India (P) Ltd., (2023) 2 SCC 703, to
submit that contractual powers vested in a State instrumentality
cannot be exercised in a manner that is manifestly arbitrary,
unreasonable or disproportionate and that the doctrine of fairness
continues to apply even within the contractual sphere. It is
contended that the respondents, despite having accepted the
infrastructure, operationalized the godown and continued to
derive benefit therefrom, could not subsequently alter the
financial arrangement by effecting unilateral recoveries allegedly
on the basis of subsequent policy decisions of the High Level
Committee, particularly when such recoveries were neither
expressly contemplated under the Lease and Service Agreement
nor preceded by any adjudicatory determination of breach.
23.
Placing reliance on the judgement of the Hon’ble Supreme Court
in Kailash Nath Associates v. Delhi Development Authority,
(2015) 4 SCC 136, he contended that even where a contract
provides for levy of liquidated damages or penalty, compensation
can be awarded only when actual loss or damage is suffered, and
a party cannot recover penal amounts in the absence of proof of
loss unless the case falls within the narrow category of contracts
where damage is impossible to quantify. It is submitted that the
respondents, having continued to utilize the godown without
interruption and having failed to demonstrate any actual financial
loss occasioned due to delayed black-topping, could not have
imposed recoveries of a punitive character upon the petitioners.
24.
Learned counsel appearing for the respondents has placed
reliance upon the judgment rendered by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in State of Punjab and Others v. Dhanjit Singh Sandhum
(2014) 15 SCC 144, to contend that a party having accepted the
terms and conditions of a contract and derived benefits thereunder
cannot subsequently approbate and reprobate by disputing
liabilities flowing from the same contractual arrangement. It is
submitted that the doctrine of election and estoppel precludes a
contracting party from accepting benefits under an agreement
while simultaneously seeking to avoid obligations arising
therefrom. Learned counsel contends that the petitioners, having
furnished undertakings regarding completion of black-topping
work within the stipulated period and having continued under the
contractual
arrangement,
are
estopped
from
challenging
consequential recoveries effected by the respondents pursuant to
the contractual terms and policy decisions taken under the PEG
Scheme.
25.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties at length and perused
the material available on record.
26.
The controversy in the present petition essentially revolves
around the legality and validity of the recoveries sought to be
effected by the respondent-Corporation on account of the delayed
completion of black-topping of the internal roads of the godown
established by the petitioner under the PEG Scheme.
27.
The factual matrix is largely undisputed. It is not in dispute that
the petitioner was awarded the project for construction of a
17,500 MT capacity godown at Srinagar under the PEG Scheme
and that the facility was taken over by the respondent-FCI on
Guaranteed Hiring Basis with effect from 27.02.2015. It is
equally not disputed that, at the time of takeover, the blacktopping of the internal roads had not been completed and that the
petitioner had furnished an undertaking to complete the said work
within the stipulated period.
28.
It also emerges from the record that despite the undertaking
furnished by the petitioner, the black-topping work was not
completed within the period initially contemplated. The
respondents have placed considerable emphasis on the fact that an
extension of time upto 26.02.2016 had already been granted and
that the petitioner failed to complete the work even within the
extended period.
29.
On the other hand, the petitioner seeks to justify the delay by
referring to circumstances which, according to him, were beyond
his control, including the demise of one of the partners and the
extraordinary law and order situation which prevailed in the
Kashmir Valley during the year 2016. Reliance has also been
placed upon the communication issued by the District
Development Commissioner, Bandipora, indicating that no
macadamization work had been undertaken in the district during
the relevant period.
30.
A significant aspect which requires consideration is the fact that
the godown admittedly remained operational and continued to be
utilized by the respondent-Corporation during the entire period in
question. The petitioner has emphasized this circumstance to
contend that no prejudice was caused to the respondents and that
the continued utilization of the facility militates against the
subsequent imposition of punitive recoveries.
31.
Equally, the respondents have sought to justify the impugned
action by asserting that black-topping constituted an essential
component of the infrastructure envisaged under the Model
Tender Form and that failure to provide the same amounted to a
breach of contractual obligations. According to the respondents,
the issue was not confined to the petitioner's case alone but
formed part of a larger policy decision applicable to similarly
situated PEG investors throughout the country.
32.
The pleadings further indicate that the impugned recoveries have
their genesis in the decisions taken by the High Level Committee.
The
respondents
have
consistently
maintained
that
the
communications impugned in the present petition are merely
consequential in nature and flow from decisions taken by the
High Level Committee in its meetings held from time to time.
The extent to which such decisions constitute the source of
authority for the recoveries and their interplay with the
contractual stipulations governing the parties assumes relevance
in the present proceedings.
33.
Another aspect which merits examination pertains to the nature of
the recovery itself. The petitioner asserts that the respondents
have, in effect, imposed a penalty without any express contractual
authorization and without adherence to the principles of natural
justice. The respondents, however, characterize the impugned
action not as a conventional penalty but as a recovery based upon
the Cost Saving Amount and the Actual Utilization Basis formula
approved by the High Level Committee.
34.
The additional affidavit filed by the respondents discloses the
methodology adopted for computing the recoverable amount.
According to the respondents, the amount represents the financial
advantage allegedly derived by the petitioner on account of nonexecution of the black-topping work within the prescribed period,
coupled with the time value of money. Whether such
methodology can be treated as compensatory in nature or assumes
the character of a penal consequence is one of the issues arising
for consideration.
35.
The Court also notices that the petitioner has raised a specific
grievance that an amount of Rs.1,58,002/- had already been
recovered earlier and that the subsequent communications have
resulted in further recoveries in respect of the same default. The
respondents, however, dispute the said characterization and
maintain that the earlier recovery and the impugned recoveries
operate in distinct fields and originate from different decisions
and audit observations. The true nature and effect of the
recoveries, therefore, require careful scrutiny in the context of the
material placed on record.
36.
The maintainability of the writ petition has also been questioned
by the respondents on the ground that the dispute arises out of
contractual obligations and involves disputed questions of fact. At
the same time, the petitioner has invoked the well-settled
principle that where the action of a State instrumentality is
alleged to be arbitrary, unreasonable or violative of constitutional
guarantees, the existence of a contractual relationship does not,
by itself, operate as an absolute bar to the exercise of writ
jurisdiction.
37.
The rival submissions advanced on behalf of the parties,
therefore, give rise to questions touching upon the scope of
judicial
review
in
contractual
matters
involving
State
instrumentalities, the source and extent of the authority claimed
by the respondents to effect the impugned recoveries, the legal
effect of the decisions of the High Level Committee, the
relevance of the circumstances relied upon by the petitioner to
explain the delay, and the nature and character of the recoveries
sought to be effected.
38.
The respondent-Food Corporation of India invited tenders under
Private
Entrepreneur
Guarantee
(PEG)
Scheme
for
the
construction of godown for storage of foodgrains in the Union
Territory of Jammu & Kashmir and the petitioner-firm
participated in the tendering process and was awarded the work
of construction of the godown having a storage capacity of
17,500 MT at Shilvat on Build, Own and Operate basis vide
Letter of Memorandum dated 21.05.2013 for a guaranteed period
of ten years and, consequently, a Lease and Service Agreement
came to be executed between the parties on 17.06.2016, which
was deemed to have commenced w.e.f. 26.02.2015 in terms of
which the godown was taken over on Guaranteed Hiring Basis for
the period commencing from 27.02.2015 to 20.05.2024 at the
approved rate of Rs. 10.20 per quintal per month, subject to
annual escalation in accordance with the Wholesale Price Index
(WPI). The godown, thus, was made operational since February,
2015.
39.
As per the agreement, the petitioner was to be paid monthly
rentals on completion of the entire infrastructure, including
drainage and black-topping of internal roads, however, the
respondents pointed out that the petitioner had failed to complete
the drainage and black-topping of internal works within the
stipulated period, on which the petitioner-firm filed an
undertaking on 24.02.2015 to complete the drainage work by
March, 2015 and black-topping of internal roads by September,
2015. The petitioner was alleged to have failed to complete the
work and, on its request, the period was further extended upto one
year, i.e., 26.02.2016, however, the petitioner-firm even then
failed to complete the black-topping of the internal roads.
40.
The dispute essentially in this petition is with regard to penalty
imposed by the respondent-Corporation for not completing the
black-topping of the internal roads, despite receiving rentals on
Guaranteed Hiring Basis. The respondent-Corporation, on the
basis of the estimated costs saved by the petitioner by not
undertaking the blacktopping of the work and the corresponding
time value of money, calculated the recoverable amount and, as
per this calculation, the cost of black-topping was assessed at Rs.
123.22 per square metre considering the area of the godown
premises measuring 7,693.68 square metres, as such, the annual
cost saving was computed at Rs. 9,48,015/-, translating into a
monthly figure of Rs. 79,001/-, as such, the recovery of Rs.
1,58,002/- was worked out representing twice the monthly cost
saving amount. These recoveries are traceable to the decisions of
the High Level Committee which had directed that in cases where
the black-topping was completed beyond the permissible period,
rentals from the commencement of hiring till completion of the
black-topping work would be regulated on Actual Utilization
Basis with deduction of twice the Cost Saving Amount. The
petitioner-firm has taken a stand that the respondents’ impugned
action was arbitrary and violative of the principles of natural
justice and dehors the terms and conditions governing the
contract between the parties.
41.
Black-topping of the internal roads of the godown premises
constituted an essential component of the infrastructure envisaged
under the Model Tender Form and the failure to provide the same
amounted to breach of contractual obligations. The impugned
recoveries ordered by the respondent-Corporation, in view of the
national phenomenon, have their genesis in the decision taken by
the High Level Committee and the impugned action taken by the
respondent-Corporation was consequential in nature and flows
from the decision taken by the High Level Committee in its
meetings. The petitioner had not challenged the decision taken in
the High Level Committee and has challenged only the
consequential orders/ actions passed/ taken by the respondentCorporation.
42.
Admittedly, the petitioner-firm, despite the terms and conditions
of the agreement, had failed to provide the required infrastructure
in full as it failed to complete the drainage as well as the blacktopping of the internal roads within the stipulated period and the
black-topping of the internal roads even within the extended
period after filing of undertaking by the petitioner-firm to
complete the same despite its extension as well. The respondents
have justified their calculations of the penalty sought to be
recovered from the petitioner-firm which is recoverable in view
of Clause 5 of the Lease and Service Agreement, which
empowered the lessee to even terminate the contract in the event
of failure on the part of the lessor to fulfil its contractual
obligations. Nevertheless, instead of terminating the agreement,
the respondent-Corporation had taken a lenient view and
recoveries were ordered in terms of the decisions taken by the
High Level Committee.
43.
The contention of the learned counsel for the petitioner that the
writ petition is maintainable as even in cases of contractual
relationship, the disputes can be adjudicated under writ
jurisdiction of the Court as laid down by the Apex Court in the
Noble Resources Ltd. judgment (supra) and that the
respondents,
despite
having
accepted
the
infrastructure,
operationalized the godown and continued to derive benefit
therefrom could not subsequently alter the financial arrangement
by effecting recoveries allegedly on the basis of subsequent
policy decisions of the High Level Committee, when such
recoveries were neither expressly contemplated under the Lease
and Service Agreement nor preceded by any adjudicatory
determination of breach, seems to be untenable in view of the fact
that the petitioner-firm had not only admitted that the drainage
and the black-topping of the internal roads was not complete
when the agreement was executed between the parties and that
despite filing an undertaking by the petitioner-firm, the needful of
black-topping of the internal roads was not carried out even
within the extended period of time.
44.
The other contention of the learned counsel for the petitioner-firm
that the petitioner could not carry out the work in view of the law
and order disturbances in the Valley in the year 2016 also seems
to be misplaced, as the petitioner was under an obligation to
complete the work within the extended period of time before
26.02.2016, whereas, the disturbances in the Valley started in the
month of July, 2016. The petitioner-firm, on filing of the
undertaking, is estopped now from raising the plea that the
respondent-Corporation had taken over and utilized the premises,
as a lenient view was stated to have been taken by the
respondent-Corporation instead of terminating the contract as per
contractual condition, to allow the petitioner-firm to complete the
work which was not complete, though the same was an essential
component of the required infrastructure to set up a godown
under the PEG Scheme. The petitioner-firm, having accepted the
terms and conditions of a contract and deriving benefits
therefrom, cannot subsequently approbate and reprobate by
disputing
liabilities
flowing
from
the
same
contractual
arrangement in view of the doctrine of election and estoppel
which precludes a contracting party from accepting benefits
under an agreement, while simultaneously seeking to avoid
obligations arising therefrom, as has been held by the Apex Court
in State of Punjab and Ors. judgment (supra). In such a
situation and keeping in view the facts and circumstances of the
case, this Court is of the considered opinion that there is no merit
and substance in this petition, which is liable to be rejected.
45.
Viewed thus, the present petition is dismissed, along with
connected CM(s). Interim direction(s), if any, shall stand vacated.
(M. A. CHOWDHARY)
JUDGE
SRINAGAR
06.06.2026
Manzoor
Whether the Judgement is approved for reporting?
Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review