The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
8. -l aking into consideration the lleculiar f-acts and circumstances of Lhc case. and principle laid clorvn by the Hon,ble Apex Ciourt in Yogendrt pratop Singh (supra), this Court is of the considr.rccl vie\\ rhar the present complaint, vide S.T.C.N.l.No.22 of 2013. on the llle of the principal Junior Civil Judge_curn_ Judicial Magistr.are o1' First Class. Nagarkurnool, belbre the expin. ol. the staturor.r, periocl ol_ J5 was filed e,en days, as requirecl -6 under Clause (c) of the proviso to Section 1 3 8 of the NI Act, and the same is liable to be quashed. Accordingly, the same is hereby quashed on the above said ground only. However, respondent No.2 is granted liberty to file a fresh complaint within a period of 30 days from today. In case respondent No.2 files a fresh complaint within the aforesaid period, the leamed trial Court is directed to treat the complaint as having been filed within the stipulated time and dispose of the case in accordance with law
9. Accordingly, the Criminal Petition is disposed ol Miscellaneous applications, pending if any, shall stand closed. SD/. A.JAYASREE //TRUE COPY// To, l.ThePrincipa|JuniorCivilJudgecumJudicialMagistrateofFirstClass' Nagarkurnool
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3303 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
MONDAY, THE THIRTY FIRST DAY OF AUGUST
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE J SREENIVAS RAO
CRIMINAL PETITION NO: 12176 OF 2026
Between:
M. Rama Swamy Goud, S/o.Balaiah Goud, Clo. M.
srilatha,age.40years,Occ. Business R/o. Sy. No. 366, Ace Olive Garden,
Phase - 1, Tummkunta Village, Shamirpet Mandal. Medchal - Malkajgiri
District, 500078
...PETITIONER/ACCUSED
AND
1. The State of Telangana, Rep by its Public Prosecutor, High Court of
Telangana, Hyderabad.
2. Badepally Mohan Goud, S /o. Raman Goud, age. 40 years Occ. Business,
R/o. Uyyalavada Village, Nagarkurnool Mandal and District
.,.RESPONDENTS/COMPLAINANTS
Petition under Section 528 of BNSS praying that in the circumstances stated in
the Memorandum of Grounds of Criminal Petition, the High Court may be pleased to
quash the proceedings in S.T.C. No. 22 ol 2023 On The File of the Principal Junior
Civil Judge cum Judicial Magistrate of First Class, Nagarkurnool, for the offences
alleged under Sections 138 read with 142 of the Negotiable lnstruments Act. 1881 in
the interest of justice.
l.A. NO: 1OF 2026
Petition under Section 528 of BNSS praying that in the circumstances stated in
the Memorandum of Grounds of Criminal Petition, the High Court may be pleased to
grant stay of all further proceedings in S.T.C No. 22 of 2023 On The File of the
Principal Junior Civil Judge cum Judicial Magistrate of First Class, Nagarkurnool, for
-138
read with 142 of the Negotiable lnstruments
the offences alleged under Sections
Act, 1BB'1, pending disposal of the present criminal petition, and pass .
This Petition coming on for hearing, upon perusing the Memorandtrm cf
Grounds of Criminal Petition and upon hearing the arguments of t<Vk
ASSOCIATES, Advocate for the Petitioner and Sri Jithender Rao Veeranraiia. il ,Addl. Public Prosecutor on behalf of the Respondent No.1 and Sri K.Pradeep Reddy
appeared on behalf of the Respondent No.2.
The Court made the following: ORDER
IN THE HI(;H COI] RT FOR THE STATE OF T ELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
-THE
HO}.OL:RABLE SRI JUSTICE J.SREENIVAS RAo
CRIMINAL PETT TION No.12176 of2026
Date;31.08.2026
Betrveen:
N,l.Rama Sn'amv Goud
.Petitioner
AND
The State of 1'elangana and anothet.
.Respondents
ORDER
This Cr.iminrrl petition "has been filed by the
petitioner/accLts!'d seeking 10 quash the proceedings in
S.T.C'.NI.No.ll ol 2023 on the flle of the principal Junior Civil
Judge-curn-Judicial Nlagistrate of F irst Class. Nagarkumool.
2.
Heard \{s.Muskan Joshi, Iearned counsel representing RVR
Associates. Iearned ccunscl fbr the petitioner and Mr.K.pradeep
Reddr. learned coLrnscl for respondent No.2.
3.
Learned counscl fbr the petitioner submitted that respondent
No.l tlled a complainr br invoking the provisions of Section
of Lhe Cr.p.C belbre, the Judicial Magistrate of First
.
Class
f,-
(Special-Mobile) at Nagarkurnool against the
petitioner for the
offence punishabte under Sections 138 r/w 142
ofthe Negotiable
InstrumentsAct,1881(forshort,'NIAct')'evenbeforetheexpiry
of the statutory period as envisaged under Clause
(c) ol proviso of
Section 138 of the NI Act' She lurther submitted
notice sent by him
No.2 has not filed any proof that the statutory
was delivered or served on the petitioner' In
effective service of notice, respondent No'2
maintain the complaint under Section 138 of
that respondent
the absence of
is not entitled to
the NI Act' Hence' the
continuation of the proceedings against the
petitioner is a clear
abuse of the Process of law
4.
Learned counsel 1br respondent No 2 submitted
respondent No.2 filed the complaint belore
statutory period of 15 days However' as
that
the expiry of the
per the principle laid
down by the Full Bench of the Hon'ble Apex
Court inYogendra
Pralap Singh v. Savitri Pandey and anothert'
respondent No'2 is
entitled to file a fresh complaint within a
period of one month' He
iurthersubmittedthat,byvirtueoftheprinciplelaiddown
in Yogendra Pratap Singft (supra)' the
' (2014) lo scc 713
complaint filed by
respondent No.l befbre the expiry of
the statutory period of l5
davs is not rnainrainable. pursuant to the
lJ<rn'ble Aper ('oun in Crl,A.No.605
pe.r1l11s6 the c.nr,rainant to
of 20 12 on 16.10.2014,
fre a fresh complaint within one
month. and if rhe fic,sh complaint is
filed within the said period, the
learned Magisrrate shall entertain and
deal w,ith the same as if it
had been filecl ri ith in the stipulated
accordance rvith lar and the benellt
be e rtended in lhvttLrr rtf respondent
)
said principle, the
tirne, on merits ancl in
granted in the said case may
No.2.
Learned counsc-l fbr petitioner has
not disputed the above
said subu-rission
6.
Har.ing consiclered the rir al submissions
respective partic.s ancl after perusal
record. it rer.eals rhat respondent
that rt-spondent \o.l cren before
da_r s
fhe lcarned Hon.blt,
under Sections I3g r/w 142
specific case olthe petitioner is
expiry of statutory period of l5
ri,e as reqrrrrecl Lrnder Clause (c)
the NI Ac1 t'iled conrpliant
of the material available on
No.2 filed compliant against
petiti()ner ror rhc .r'rcnccs purishable
of thc NI Act on 05.07.2022. The
rnade by the
ofpro'iso of.section l3g
and saure is not
maintainable under
Apex Court in yogendra
of
law.
praktp
-4
Sizgft (supra) held that no complaint can be
maintained against the
drawerofthe cheque beforethe expiry of t5
days from the date of
receipt of notice because the drawer/accused
cannot be said to have
committed any offence until then ln the
case on hand' though
leamed counsel for the petitioner raised
respondent No.2 has not placed any
another contention that
material to establish that the
statutory notice sent by him was delivered
same is a disputed question ol lact
to the petitioner' the
and cannot be adjudicated or
decided while exercising the powers conferred
of the BNSS. The petitioner is entitled to
under Section 528
put forth the said ground
during the course ol trial' Howeier' respondent
present complaint even before the expiry
No'2 filed the
of the statutory period of
15 days, and the same is not maintainable
in law' The Hon'ble
ApexCourtinYogendraPrlrapSingh(supra),atparagraph4l,
held as follows:
" section 1 12 of the NI Act prescribes the mode and so also
under Section
,i^r"*iini, *ihirh o complaint lbr an offence*nd:
complaint
I 38 of the NI Act can be filed' 'l
.yno',:-:::",o"
due course of the cheque nas
in
138 Ly the payee or the holder
month 'from
i" u"'i, ,ririi"g and needs to be made u'ithin oneunder
clause
action has arise.n
the date on riirh th, cause ol
'ii-"t,n,
one month
proviso to Section 138 The period of
the-cause
which
'unii, inriion 112ft) begins from the date on
to Section
f,,i]r,,im n^ arisen under c:lau'\? tc) of thc proriso
he
i""l ,ru il rhe 'ompl'tinttnt satislies the Courr.t.hut the
7:i"
'n""a
,ift;r,rr:,, c'ctuse ./or not making Lt complaint ,\t'ithin bv
'iiii',i;iifi-prr,rd
o.l ttne month tt ciomptuinr mav be taken
the
J
tlk (ourt tlt(,r tlk pre\(ribed period. lott. sirtce otr unsv,er to
questton ti) i.; lt the negutive. v,e observe that the pa.vee or the
holcler in Llut crttu.:ie o/ the cheque may Jile a
fre.sh ,:ttmplaint
v ithin ont, month lrom tht date ofdetision in the crininal csse
unl. ttt rhtt arvttt. clekn in liling the complaint will be treated
us huting ht,t'n tont tnetl uncler lhe prot,iso to clause (b) of
St'ttion I ll ol tlrc .\'l .1c1. T his direction shall be cleemed to be
up1tlitabL to tll .such pending cases y,here lhe compiaint doe.s
nt)l pro(e('Ll /trrtlret irt tiev of our on.\v:er to
Etestion li). As we
h,n e r:t.lreud.l ltcirl rhat cr tompLaint.filed be.lbre the expiy of t 5
dtry,5 1n. thc t rre of'retcipt o/ notice is.suecl ttnder ,.lausi (c)
ol the proviso to .settion 138 is not mainrairuble, rhe
tttntpluinttnt tunnt)t hc ptr.nilted lo present lhe vt,rl, same
c'ontpluint dt dtl\ lLttct .stugt lli.: remtJl, is unll to te a
f
fresh
totrtltluittt trnrl t/ rht, \(rntt, LouLd rutt be /ilecl trtthin thi tme
prc.:Lribect utkfut .\ection ll)tb) his reL.oLrsc is lo seek the
he nr:lit rtl tfu pt ott.so :ati.sf.,ing the (.'olfft o.l suffic.ient
cause.
OtrsliLlt (.;i) i.t unsyered ttct'ordmglt.. '
'[he Hon'blc Apex
Court, in the above said judgment and
order. spccif.icaill held that the complainant is entirled to file a
fiesh complaint on the basis of the notice already issued by him
\! ithin a period o1'3(t 6121 . lrom the date of the order passed
tn
Crl A.No.605 of l0l:. i.e.. 16 10.2014
8.
-l
aking into consideration the lleculiar f-acts and
circumstances of Lhc case. and principle laid clorvn by the
Hon,ble
Apex Ciourt in Yogendrt pratop Singh (supra), this Court is of the
considr.rccl vie\\ rhar the present complaint, vide S.T.C.N.l.No.22
of 2013. on the llle of the principal Junior Civil Judge_curn_
Judicial Magistr.are o1' First Class. Nagarkurnool,
belbre the expin. ol. the
staturor.r, periocl ol_ J5
was filed e,en
days, as requirecl
-6
under Clause (c) of the proviso to Section 1 3 8 of the NI Act, and
the same is liable to be quashed. Accordingly, the same is hereby
quashed on the above said ground only. However, respondent No.2
is granted liberty to file a fresh complaint within a period of 30
days from today. In case respondent No.2 files a fresh complaint
within the aforesaid period, the leamed trial Court is directed to
treat the complaint as having been filed within the stipulated time
and dispose of the case in accordance with law
9.
Accordingly, the Criminal Petition is disposed ol
Miscellaneous applications, pending if any, shall stand
closed.
SD/. A.JAYASREE
ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER
To,
l.ThePrincipa|JuniorCivilJudgecumJudicialMagistrateofFirstClass'
Nagarkurnool
2. The Station House Officer, Police Station Nagarkurnool'
3. One CC to SRl. RVR ASSOCIATES Advocate [OPUC]
4. Two CCs to PUBLIC PROSECUTOR High Court for the State of Telangana'
at Hyderabad [OUT]
5. Two CD CoPies
TPK/GNK
q*'
HIGH COURT
DATED: 3110812026
,/ l
/--
,^t,
ST/U € o
it:
I_.
,o
l)
o 2 sEP
.<
ORDER
,/,
CRLP.No.12176 o12026
\:
CRIMINAL PETITION IS DISPOSED OF
t'
ts6
1/
t
--
<)
ti
k,//
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review