Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
SHAMURAILATPAM SUSHIL Digitally signed by SHAMURAILATPAM
SUSHIL SHARMA
SHARMA
Date: 2023.09.13 11:56:04 +05'30'
Page |1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022
Shri M. Pheijao Singh, aged about 54 years, S/o late M.
Amu Singh of Awang Sekmai Bazar, P.O. & P.S. Sekmai of
Imphal West District, Manipur, Pin – 795136 functioning as
Deputy Director, TA & Hills, Babupara near Kuki InnImphal- 795001.
… … PETITIONER.
-versus1.
The State of Manipur, represented by the Additional
Chief Secretary/ Principal Secretary/ Commissioner/
Secretary, Tribal Affairs & Hills, Government of
Manipur, Secretariat Complex- 795001.
2.
The Director, Tribal Affairs & Hills and Schedule
Castes
Department,
Government
of
Manipur,
Babupara near Kuki Inn – 795001.
… … RESPONDENTS.
WP(C) No. 913 of 2021
Shri M. Pheijao Singh, aged about 54 years, S/o late M.
Amu Singh of Awang Sekmai Bazar, P.O. & P.S. Sekmai of
Imphal West District, Manipur, Pin – 795136 functioning as
Deputy Director, TA & Hills, Babupara near Kuki InnImphal- 795001.
… … PETITIONER.
-versus-
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022 and WP(C) No.913 of 2021
Page |2
1.
The State of Manipur, represented by the Additional
Chief Secretary/ Principal Secretary/ Commissioner/
Secretary, Tribal Affairs & Hills, Government of
Manipur, Secretariat Complex- 795001.
2.
The Director, Tribal Affairs & Hills and Schedule
Castes
Department,
Government
of
Manipur,
Babupara near Kuki Inn – 795001.
… … RESPONDENTS.
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE M.V. MURALIDARAN
For the Petitioners
::
Mr. A. Romenkumar, Sr. Adv.
For the Respondents
::
Mrs. Ch. Sundari, GA
Date of Hearing and
reserving Judgment & Order ::
28.08.2023
Date of Judgment & Order
12.09.2023
::
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
(CAV)
W.P.(C) No.37 of 2022 has been filed by the
petitioner to quash the impugned order dated 18.12.2021,
communicated to the petitioner on 11.1.2022, initiating second
departmental proceedings by framing article of charges on
selfsame charges as the earlier charges which are under
challenge in W.P.(C) No.913 of 2021.
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022 and WP(C) No.913 of 2021
Page |3
2.
W.P.(C) No.913 of 2021 has been filed by the very
same petitioner to quash the impugned order dated 25.2.2020
thereby initiating departmental proceedings and framing of article
of charges vide order dated 10.6.2020 and to direct the
respondents to provide the consequential service benefits as if
no departmental proceedings were initiated against the
petitioner.
3.
Since the prayers in the writ petitions are interlinked
with each other, both the writ petitions were heard together and
disposed of by this common order.
4.
Brief facts which led to the filing of the writ petitions
are as follows:
The petitioner, after serving in the Department of TA
& Hills, was promoted to the rank of Deputy Director, TA & Hills
and was functioning as Drawing and Disbursing Officer in the
said Department from 24.4.2014 to 31.8.2016. Thereafter, he
was removed from functioning as Drawing and Disbursing
Officer.
On 25.2.2020, the petitioner was placed under
suspension on the ground that disciplinary proceedings were
contemplated against him and, accordingly, charges were
framed against him vide order dated 10.6.2020.
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022 and WP(C) No.913 of 2021
Since the
Page |4
suspension order was extended violating the provisions of Rule
10(6) and (7) of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965, the petitioner has
filed W.P.(C) No.688 of 2021 and, this Court, by the order dated
15.11.2021 in W.P.(C) No.688 of 2021, quashed the suspension
order and directed the respondents to treat the petitioner to have
been reinstated in service with effect from 20.11.2020 with all
consequential benefits. According to the petitioner, under Rule
14(24)(a) of the CCS (CCA) Rules, the Inquiring Authority shall
conclude the inquiry and submit his report within six months from
the date of receipt of the appointment.
4.1.
On 22.8.2020, Shri R.K.Dinesh, IAS, was appointed
as Inquiring Authority.
Again on 17.9.2020, one Shri Gyan
Prakash, IAS, Commissioner-cum-Secretary was appointed as
Inquiring Authority. Again on 28.9.2021, another officer namely
Shri DeveshDeval, IAS was appointed as the Inquiring Authority.
Though the first Inquiring Authoritywas appointed on 22.6.2020,
the said authority could not conclude the inquiry within six
months.
4.2.
The petitioner requested the State authorities to
furnish the required documents relied upon by the disciplinary
authority to enable him to prepare effective written statement of
defence. The respondent authority had constituted a special
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022 and WP(C) No.913 of 2021
Page |5
audit through the Director, Local and Fund Audit, Manipur to
conduct the audit inspection in the Department of TA & Hills. On
24.6.2021, the audit report was submitted to the effect that the
petitioner has cleared the amount, except Rs.45,881/- and the
said amount was ordered to be recovered immediately. In the
said report, it has been stated that the petitioner may be allowed
to revoke his suspension order. However, the authority has not
put the report into action.
4.3.
Challenging the initiation of the departmental
proceedings, vide order dated 25.2.2020 and framing of charges
dated 10.6.2020, the petitioner has filed W.P.(C) No.913 of 2021
and during the pendency of the said writ petition, the respondent
authorities issued the impugned order dated 18.12.2021 which
was communicated to the petitioner on 11.1.2022 initiating the
second departmental proceedings by framing of charges after
withdrawing the earlier article of charges on the same set of facts,
for which the earlier departmental proceedings could not be
proved which is under challenge in W.P.(C) No.913 of 2021.
Aggrieved by the issuance of the second departmental
proceedings, the petitioner has filed W.P.(C) No.37 of 2022.
5.
Resisting the writ petitions, the respondents 1 and
2 filed affidavit-in-oppositions stating that the petitioner has
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022 and WP(C) No.913 of 2021
Page |6
already filed W.P.(C) No.688 of 2021 challenging the suspension
order dated 25.2.2020 and this Court allowed the said writ
petition vide order dated 15.11.2021.
In compliance of this
Court’s order, the authorities have issued an order dated
21.12.2021 thereby reinstating the petitioner with effect from
20.11.2020.
5.1.
It is stated that on 10.6.2020, the respondent
authorities issued a Memorandum along with article of charges
and statement of imputations of misconduct etc. for holding
inquiry against the petitioner. However, the same was withdrawn
vide order dated 7.12.2021. It is stated that subsequently, vide
order dated 21.1.2022 the respondent authorities cancelled the
order dated 11.1.2022 on the ground that there was some
inadvertent mistake in it.
5.2.
It is stated in the affidavit-in-oppositions that the
inability of the respondent authorities to supply documents to the
petitioner expeditiously may not be viewed as victimization of the
petitioner. The impugned order dated 18.12.2021 communicated
on 11.1.2022 has not been cancelled vide order dated 21.1.2022.
Hence, the allegations of mala fide, illegalities etc. are denied.
Since the impugned orders have already been cancelled, no
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022 and WP(C) No.913 of 2021
Page |7
cause of action survives and, therefore, the writ petitions are
liable to be dismissed.
6.
Assailing
the
impugned
orders,
Mr.
A.
Romenkumar, the learned senior counsel for the petitioner
submitted that the petitioner was functioning as Drawing and
Disbursing Officer in the Department of TA & Hills from 24.4.2014
to 31.8.2016 and subsequently he was removed from functioning
as Drawing and Disbursing Officer. On 25.2.2020, the petitioner
was placed under suspension on the ground that disciplinary
proceedings are initiated against him and article of charges were
framed against the petitioner vide order dated 10.6.2020.
Challenging the suspension, the petitioner has filed W.P.(C)
No.688 of 2021 and, this Court, by the order dated 15.11.2021,
allowed the said writ petition and directed the respondents to
treat that the petitioner have been reinstated in service with effect
from 20.11.2020 with all consequential benefits and the said
exercise was directed to be completed within four weeks from the
date of receipt of a copy of the said order.
7.
Mr. A. Romenkumar, the learned senior counsel for
the petitioner submitted that under Rule 14(24)(a) of the CCS
(CCA) Rules, 1965, the Inquiring Authority has to conclude the
inquiry and submit his report within a period of six months from
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022 and WP(C) No.913 of 2021
Page |8
the date of appointment. Though the Inquiring Authority was
appointed and the Inquiring Authority was changed thrice, the
first Inquiring Authorityhas not concluded the enquiry within six
months as contemplated under Rule 14(24)(a) of the CCS (CCA)
Rules, 1965.
8.
The learned senior counsel for the petitioner urged
that the departmental proceeding against the petitioner was
initiated with cool calculation and deliberate design to humiliate,
harass and victimize the petitioner. When the Director of Local
and Fund Audit conducted a special audit in the Department of
Tribal Affairs and Hills, the said authority submitted his report to
the effect that (a) almost the issue is cleared, except an amount
of Rs.45,881/-, which is to be recovered immediately; (b) the
petitioner may be allowed to revoke his suspension order
immediately. However, the respondent authorities have not acted
on the report of the Director of Local and Fund Audit.
9.
The learned senior counsel further submitted that
challenging the suspension order dated 25.2.2020 and the
initiation of departmental proceedings and framing of article of
charges dated 10.6.2020, the petitioner has filed W.P.(C) No.913
of 2021.
During the pendency of the said writ petition, the
respondent authorities issued the impugned order dated
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022 and WP(C) No.913 of 2021
Page |9
18.12.2021, communicated to the petitioner on 11.1.2022,
initiating second departmental proceedings by the framing of
article after withdrawing the earlier article of charges on the same
set of facts, for which the earlier departmental proceedings could
not be proved which is under challenge in W.P.(C) No.913 of
2021.
10.
According to the learned senior counsel for the
petitioner, the initiation of second departmental proceedings
without the leave of the Court is illegal, mala fide and unjust and
also interfering with the administration of justice. In support of
his submission, the learned senior counsel for the petitioner has
placed reliance upon the decision in the case of Athokpam
Sukhendrajit Singh v. State of Manipur and others, 2021 (1) MLJ
93.
11.
The learned senior counsel for the petitioner, by
placing on record the decision in the case of Ziauddin v. State of
Manipur, (2016) 4 NEJ 323 (MN), submitted that there is no
denial in the affidavit-in-opposition filed by the respondents 1 and
2 that the second departmental proceedings on the same set of
facts is not permissible.
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022 and WP(C) No.913 of 2021
P a g e | 10
12.
According to the learned senior counsel for the
petitioner, if an averment is not specifically denied, such
averment is deemed to have to been admitted and judgment can
be delivered under Order 12, Rule 6 CPC.
In support, the
learned counsel for the petitioner placed reliance upon the
decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Indian Bank
v. S.N.Engineers and Suppliers, (2018) 4 SCC 606. Thus, a
prayer has been made to quash the impugned orders.
13.
Per
contra,
Mrs.
Ch.
Sundari,
the
learned
Government Advocate for the respondents submitted that the
petitioner has filed W.P.(C) No.37 of 2022 to quash the order
dated 18.12.2021 initiating the second departmental proceedings
along with framing of charges on selfsame charges of the earlier
charges which are under challenge in W.P.(C) No.913 of 2021;
that the petitioner has already filed W.P.(C) No.688 of 2021
challenging the suspension order dated 25.2.2020 andthis Court
allowed the said writ petition on 15.11.2021. In compliance of
the order passed in the said writ petition, the respondent
authorities have issued an order dated 21.12.2021reinstating the
petitioner with effect from 20.11.2020; that the respondent
authorities have issued Memorandum dated 10.6.2020 for
holding enquiry against the petitioner and the article of charges
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022 and WP(C) No.913 of 2021
P a g e | 11
and statement of imputations of misconduct/misbehavior etc.
was furnished.
But the said Memorandum dated 10.6.2020,
whereby charges framed against the petitioner, was withdrawn
vide order dated 7.12.2021; that the Government issued an order
dated 21.1.2022 thereby cancelling the earlier order dated
11.1.2022 on the ground that there has been some inadvertent
mistake.
14.
The
learned
Government
Advocate
further
submitted that the inability of the respondents to supply
documents to the petitioner expeditiously may not be viewed as
victimization of the petitioner. Since the impugned order dated
11.1.2022 has already been cancelled, no cause of action exists
in maintaining the writ petition.
15.
Adding further, the learned Government Advocate
submitted that during the preliminary hearing, the Inquiring
Authority was apprised by the Presenting Officer that the
authority desires to issue a modified charge sheet and that the
Commissioner, Departmental Enquiry also agreed the proposal
of the Inquiring Authority for serving revised charge sheet to the
petitioner. As such, vide order dated 18.12.2021, article of
charges against the petitioner were framed after the withdrawal
of the order dated 10.6.2020.
The impugned order dated
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022 and WP(C) No.913 of 2021
P a g e | 12
18.12.2021 framing article of charges against the petitioner has
not been cancelled.
Arguing so, the learned Government
Advocate prayed for dismissal of the writ petitions.
16.
This Court considered the rival submissions and
also perused the materials available on record.
17.
The petitioner was functioning as Drawing and
Disbursing Officer in the Department of TA & Hills from 24.4.2014
to 31.8.2016 and thereafter, he was removed from functioning as
Drawing and Disbursing Officer. On 25.2.2020, the petitioner
was placed under suspension on the ground that the disciplinary
proceedings are contemplated against him. The charges were
framed against the petitioner and the gist of charges dated
10.6.2020 are quoted hereunder for ready reference:
“ARTICLE-I
That, while Shri M.Pheijao Singh, Deputy
Director (under suspension), Department of
Tribal Affairs and Hills, Government of
Manipur was functioning as Head of Office
and Drawing &Disbursing Officer of the said
Department during the period from 24-042014 to 31-08-2016 have misappropriated a
sum of Rs.3,96,46,031.00 (Rupees Three
crores, ninety six lakhs, forty six thousand
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022 and WP(C) No.913 of 2021
P a g e | 13
and thirty one only) of the Government
money.
ARTICLE-II
That during the aforesaid period the said Shri
M. Pheijao Singh, Deputy Director (under
suspension), Department of Tribal Affairs &
Hills,
Government
of
Manipur
while
functioning as Drawing & Disbursing Officer
in the Directorate of Tribal Affairs & Hills,
Manipur the programme/scheme namely (a)
Post Matric Scholarship for ST Students, (b)
Post
Matric/Pre-Matric
Scholarship
to
Scheduled Castes students (c) All Schemes
related to Scheduled Castes (d) District
Officer, Senapati and € CCD Plan (Maram
Primitive Tribe) were allocated to him vide
orders
No.
1/64/99-TD(B)(Pt)
dated
6/10/2015 and 1/5/201-TAHSC(Pt) dated
15/10/2016 respectively, he mismanaged the
programme/scheme and misappropriated a
large chunk of programme/scheme money.
ARTICLE-III
That, during the aforesaid period and while
functioning in the aforesaid Office as an
Officer
in
charge
of
various
programme/schemes of the Department in
addition to the work of Head of Office and
Drawing & Disbursing Officer Shri M. Pheijao
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022 and WP(C) No.913 of 2021
P a g e | 14
Singh have transacted fund/money of the
programmes/schemes
by
operating
Account/funds of the Directorate in utter
violation of the Financial Rules, regulations
and instruction issued by the Government of
Manipur from time to time and utilized the
money as if the funds are his private money
thereby leading to misappropriation of money
to the tune of Rs.3,96,46,031.00 (Rupees
three crores ninety six lakh forty six thousand
and thirty one only) which is illegal.
ARTICLE-IV
That during the aforesaid period and while
functioning in the above said capacity in the
aforesaid Office Shri M. Pheijao Singh did not
manage properly as per the Scheme
Guidelines
of
the
programme/schemes
allocated to him, and also did not maintain
the papers, documents, information as
expected from an officer who functioned as
Head of Office and Drawing & Disbursing
Officer of the Directorate of Tribal Affairs &
Hills, Government of Manipur.
Shri M. Pheijao Singh during the aforesaid
period and while functioning in the aforesaid
office failed to maintain absolute integrity and
devotion to duty and thus unbecoming of a
Government Servant leading to violation of
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022 and WP(C) No.913 of 2021
P a g e | 15
the provisions of the Central Civil Services
(Conduct) Rules, 1964.”
19.
By the order dated 22.8.2020, the Additional Chief
Secretary (TA & Hills), appointed Shri R K Dinesh Singh (IAS),
Commissioner, Departmental Enquiry, as the Inquiring Authority
to inquire into the charges framed against the petitioner. In the
said order, the suspension period was extended for another three
months or till their revocation whichever is earlier. Again by the
order
dated
17.9.2020,
Shri
H.Gyan
Prakash,
IAS,
Commissioner-cum-Secretary (Social Welfare/Veterinary) &
Special Secretary (Home) & Commissioner Departmental
Enquiry (DE), Government of Manipur, was appointed as
Inquiring Authority to inquire into the charges framed against the
petitioner and one Shri N.Kaikho Mao, Joint Director. Again on
28.9.2021, Shri Devesh Deval, IAS, Commissioner Departmental
Enquiry (DE), Government of Manipur was appointed as the
Inquiring Authority to inquire into the charges framed against the
petitioner.
20.
On a perusal of the appointment orders of the
Inquiring Authority, it is seen that there is no whisper about the
cancellation of the first Inquiring Authority in the appointment
order of second Inquiring Authority and similarly, there is no
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022 and WP(C) No.913 of 2021
P a g e | 16
reference about the cancellation of the second Inquiring Authority
in the appointment order of third Inquiring Authority.
21.
The petitioner has challenged the suspension order
dated 25.2.2020 in W.P.(C) No.688 of 2021 and, this Court, by
the order dated 15.11.2021, allowed the said writ petition. The
operative portion of the order reads thus:
“(a) The writ petition is allowed.
(b) The Impugned suspension Order dated
25.02.2020 is set aside.
(c) The Respondents Authorities shall treat
that the Petitioner (M. Pheijao Singh) have
been instated in service with effect from
20.11.2020 with all consequential benefits.
(d) The said exercise shall be done within a
period of 4 (four) Weeks from the date of
receipt of a copy of this order. No cost.”
22.
On 21.12.2021, the Additional Chief Secretary (TA
& Hills) issued an order reinstating the petitioner into service with
effect from 20.11.2020 with all consequential benefits.
23.
At this juncture, the learned counsel for the
petitioner submitted that the Inquiring Authority appointed on
22.8.2020 could not conclude the enquiry within six months,
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022 and WP(C) No.913 of 2021
P a g e | 17
which is violative of Rule 14(24)(a) of the CCS (CCA) Rules,
1965.
24.
Rule 14(24)(a) of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965 reads
thus:
“14. Procedure for imposing major penalties.
…..
(24)(a)
The
Inquiring
Authority
should
conclude the inquiry and submit his report
within a period of six months from the date of
receipt of order of his appointment as
Inquiring Authority.”
25.
On a perusal of Rule 14(24)(a), it is seen that the
Inquiring Authority should conclude the inquiry and submit his
report within a period of six months from the date of receipt of
order of his appointment as Inquiring Authority.
26.
In the present, the first appointment of Inquiring
Authority was made on 22.8.2020 and after about 25 days, again
another Inquiring Authority was appointed and, thereafter, about
a lapse of one year, another Inquiring Authority was appointed.
27.
With regard to the appointment of Inquiring
Authority, it is the say of the learned Government Advocate that
consequent upon the transfer of the first Inquiring Authority, the
second Inquiring Authority was appointed and thereafter, the
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022 and WP(C) No.913 of 2021
P a g e | 18
second Inquiring Authority was transferred, which necessitated
the authority to appoint Shri Devesh Deval, IAS as Inquiring
Authority. However, the same is not reflected in the order of
appointment of the Inquiring Authority for the second and third
time.
28.
The
learned
Government
Advocate
further
submitted that the preliminary hearing of the departmental
enquiry against the petitioner was held on 26.10.2021 and during
the course of the preliminary hearing the Inquiring Authority was
apprised by the Presenting Officer that the authority intends to
issue a modified charge sheet.
29.
On a perusal of the order dated 7.12.2021 produced
by the learned Government Advocate, it is seen that the charges
framed against the petitioner dated 10.6.2020 were withdrawn
and the proceedings initiated against the petitioner by appointing
Shri Devesh Deval, IAS dated 28.9.2021 was also cancelled. In
this regard, the affidavit-in-opposition filed by the respondents 1
and 2 in W.P.(C) No.913 of 2021 reads thus:
“2 (iii) The authorities issued Memorandum
dated 10.6.2020 for holding enquiry against
the petitioner and Article of Charges and
statement
of
imputations
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022 and WP(C) No.913 of 2021
of
P a g e | 19
misconduct/misbehavior, etc. was furnished.
But the said Memorandum dated 10.6.2020
whereby charges framed against Shri M.
Pheijao
Singh
but
remained
without
adjudication was withdrawn vide order dated
7.12.2021.”
30.
The respondents themselves admitted that the
departmental proceedings dated 10.6.2020 was withdrawn
without adjudication. While so, on 18.12.2021, the Additional
Chief Secretary (TA & Hills) initiated second departmental
proceedings against the petitioner by framing article of charges
and the same was communicated to the petitioner under letter
dated 11.1.2022 of the Under Secretary (TA & H) calling upon
the petitioner to submit his written statement of defence within 7
working days i.e. on order before 21.1.2022, with a condition that
if the petitioner fails to submit the written statement of defence,
the enquiry will be held ex- parte.
31.
The gist of article of charges framed against the
petitioner dated 18.12.2021 read thus:
“ARTICLE-I
That, M. Pheijao Singh, Deputy Director
(under suspension) Department of Tribal
Affairs and Hills, Government of Manipur,
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022 and WP(C) No.913 of 2021
P a g e | 20
Imphal while functioning of Drawing and
Disbursing Officer and Head of Office,
Directorate of Tribal Affairs and Hills,
Manipur during the period from 24.004.2014
to 31.08.2016 have caused a heavy loss to
the tune of Rs.34,86,761/- (Rupees thirty four
lakh eighty thousand seven hundred sixty
one) only of Government of money.
ARTICLE-II
That, M. Pheijao Singh, Deputy Director
(under suspension) Department of Tribal
Affairs and Hills, Government of Manipur,
Imphal while functioning as the Head of
Office and Drawing and Disbursing Officer,
Directorate of Tribal Affairs and Hills,
Manipur during 24.04.2014 to 31.08.2016
have committed an act thereby causing
wrongful and heavy loss of Government
money to the tune of Rs.1,02,47,367/(Rupees one crore two lakh forty seven
thousand three hundred sixty seven)only.
ARTICLE-III
That, M. Pheijao Singh, Deputy Director
(under suspension) Department of Tribal
Affairs and Hills, Government of Manipur,
Imphal while functioning as Drawing and
Disbursing Officer of the Directorate of Tribal
Affairs and Hills, Manipur from 24.04.2014 to
31.08.2016 have failed to recover a sum of
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022 and WP(C) No.913 of 2021
P a g e | 21
Rs.4,28,599/- (Rupees four lakh twenty eight
thousand five hundred ninety nine) only from
SAIL,
Guwahati,
Assam
which
was
recoverable from SAIL for the unsupplied
item (GCI Sheets).
ARTICLE-IV
That, M. Pheijao Singh, Deputy Director
(under suspension) Department of Tribal
Affairs and Hills, Government of Manipur,
Imphal was functioning as Drawing and
Disbursing Officer of the Directorate of Tribal
Affairs and Hills, Manipur.
The said M.
Pheijao Singh did not make any attempt to
recover
an
amount
of
Rs.79,90,500/-
(Rupees seventy nine lakh ninety thousand
five hundred) only from M/s.Kamal Polymers
Industries, Thangal Bazar, Imphal for the
unsupplied item (Water Storage Tank) during
his DDO ship of the aforesaid Directorate.
ARTICLE-V
That, M. Pheijao Singh, Deputy Director
(under suspension) Department of Tribal
Affairs and Hills, was the Head of Office and
Drawing and Disbursing Officer of the
Directorate of Tribal Affairs and Hills,
Manipur from 24.04.2014 to 31.08.2016 in
pursuance of the Government of Manipur,
Secretariat:
Tribal
Affairs
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022 and WP(C) No.913 of 2021
and
Hills
P a g e | 22
Department
order
No.26/38/2013-
TA&H(Misc) dated 28.03.2014. As Head of
Office and Drawing and Disbursing Officer of
the Directorate aforesaid M. Pheijao Singh
was making transactions of Government
fund relating to the Directorate.
While
transacting fund M. Pheijao Singh have
utilized
Government
money
or
made
payments without observing Financial Rules,
instructions of the Government leading to
misappropriation
of
fund
amounting
to
Rs.16,82,109/- (Rupees sixteen lakhs eighty
two thousand one hundred and nine) only out
of the fund provided for Infrastructure
Development under the Department of Tribal
Affairs and Hills, Manipur.
ARTICLE-VI
That, during the period from 24.04.2014 to
31.08.2016
M.
Pheijao
Singh,
Deputy
Director (under suspension) Directorate of
Tribal Affairs and Hills Department, Manipur
was functioning as the Head of Office and
Drawing
&
Disbursing
Officer
of
the
Directorate of Tribal Affairs and Hills,
Manipur. While functioning as the Head of
Office and Drawing & Disbursing Officer of
the Directorate aforesaid M. Pheijao Singh
utilized the Government money as if the
Government money was his private money
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022 and WP(C) No.913 of 2021
P a g e | 23
leading
to
misappropriation
of
Rs.3,10,98,184/- (Rupees three crore ten
lakh ninety eight thousand one hundred
eighty four) only.
ARTICLE-VII
That, M. Pheijao Singh, Deputy Director
(under suspension), Tribal Affairs, Hills and
Scheduled
Castes
Development
Department, Manipur 9nowTribal Affairs &
Hills) was functioning as Head of Office and
Drawing and Disbursing Officer of the
Directorate of Tribal Affairs and Hills,
Manipur during the period from 24.04.2014 to
31.08.2016. The said M. Pheijao Singh was
operating the Account of the Directorate
being
No.31391304922
(Savings)
maintained in the State Bank of India, Imphal
Secretariat Branch, Secretariat Complex,
Babupara, Imphal West, Manipur.
As Drawing and Disbursing officer and Head
of Office of the Directorate of Tribal Affairs
and Hills, Government of Manipur, the said
M. Pheijao Singh during the aforesaid period
encashed funds through many A.C. Bills. A
sum of Rs.65,66,78,414/- (Rupees sixty five
crore sixty six lakh seventy eight thousand
four hundred fourteen) only was encashed
through many AC Bills.
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022 and WP(C) No.913 of 2021
P a g e | 24
ARTICLE-VIII
That, M. Pheijao Singh, Deputy Director
(under suspension), Tribal Affairs and Hills,
Department of Tribal Affairs and Hills,
Government of Manipur was the Head of
Office and Drawing & Disbursing Officer of
the Directorate of Tribal Affairs and Hills,
Manipur during the period from 24.04.2014 to
31.08.2016 on the issuance of the Order
No.26/38/2013-TA&H
(Misc)
dated
01.04.2014 by the Government of Manipur
Secretariat: Tribal Affairs & Hills Department,
M. Pheijao Singh as the Head of Office and
Drawing and Disbursing officer of the
Directorate of Tribal Affairs and Hills,
Manipur
was
operating
the
Account
No.31391304922 (Saving) maintained in the
State Bank of India, Manipur Secretariat
Branch, Imphal and transacted Government
money during the period aforesaid. In the
course of such transaction during the
aforesaid period the said M. Pheijao Singh as
DDO and HoD of the Directorate of Tribal
Affairs and Hills, Manipur made payments
through cheques and in cash on many
occasions
in
violation
of
orders
and
instructions issued by the Government of
Manipur and misappropriated a sum of
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022 and WP(C) No.913 of 2021
P a g e | 25
Rs.72,78,32,968/- (Rupees seventy two
crore seventy eight lakh thirty two thousand
nine hundred sixty eight) only.
ARTICLE-IX
That, M. Pheijao Singh, Deputy Director
(under suspension), Tribal Affairs and Hills
Department was functioning as Head of
Office and Drawing and Disbursing Officer of
the Directorate of Tribal Affairs and Hills,
Government of Manipur from 24.04.2014 to
31.08.2016, Mr. N. Kaikho Mao, Joint
Director/Tribal Affairs and Hills, on issuance
of the Order No.1/5/2014-TAH&SC dated
23.08.2016 whereby declaring the said N.
Kaikho Mao as Head of Office and Drawing
& Disbursing
officer and took over the
charges of HoD and DDO from M. Pheijao
Singh on 31.08.2016.
On this day of
31.08.2016 there was a difference of
Rs.13,87,46,829/- (Rupees thirteen crore
eighty seven lakh forty six thousand eight
hundred twenty nine) only between the Cash
Book Balance and Bank Balance.
ARTICLE-X
That, M. Pheijao Singh, Deputy Director
(under suspension), Tribal Affairs and Hills
Department was functioning as Head of
Office and Drawing and Disbursing Officer of
the Directorate of Tribal Affairs and Hills,
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022 and WP(C) No.913 of 2021
P a g e | 26
Government of Manipur from 24.04.2014 to
31.08.2016.
The said M. Pheijao Singh
allowed Smt. A. Binodhini Devi, Joint
Director, Tribal Affairs and Hills Department,
Manipur to retire from the post on 02.08.2014
without bringing to the notice of the higher
Authority the liabilities standing against Smt.
A. Binodini Devi and the overdrawal of
remuneration by Smt. A. Binodini Devi as
OSD. Shri M. Pheijao Singh, Deputy Director
(under suspension) Department of Tribal
Affairs and Hills and Drawing and Disbursing
Officer and Head of Office of the Directorate
of Tribal Affairs and Hills, Manipur violated
Rule 3 of the Central Civil Services (Conduct)
Rules, 1964.”
32.
The learned senior counsel for the petitioner has
made three-fold submissions. Firstly, the second departmental
enquiry without arriving at a finding qua the earlier enquiry on the
same set of facts is not permissible in law.
Secondly, the
authority had constituted special audit by the Director, Local and
Fund Audit, Manipur and after conducting the audit, the Director
has submitted a report to the effect that the amount recoverable
from the petitioner is only Rs.45,881/-. Thirdly, pending W.P.(C)
No.913 of 2021 and that too without leave of the Court, the
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022 and WP(C) No.913 of 2021
P a g e | 27
second departmental proceedings was initiated, which is unjust
and unreasonable.
33.
It is pertinent to note that with regard to the
averments set out in paragraphs 13 to 15 of the writ petition in
W.P.(C) No.37 of 2022, the respondents 1 and 2 have filed
affidavit-in-opposition in the following manner:
“6. That with reference to para Nos.13, 14
and 15 of the writ petition, it is humbly
submitted
that
the
impugned
Order
No.1/64/2020-TA & H (Pt-4) communicated
on 11.1.2022 (Annexure-A/9 to the writ
petition) has now been cancelled vide order
dated 21.1.2022. Hence, the allegations of
mala fide, illegalities, etc. are denied.”
34.
In paragraph 7 of the affidavit-in-opposition filed by
the respondents 1 and 2, it has been stated as under:
“7. That with reference to para Nos.16 to 19
of the writ petition, it is humbly submitted that
since the impugned order has already been
cancelled no cause of action survives (sic)
and this writ petition is liable to be closed.”
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022 and WP(C) No.913 of 2021
P a g e | 28
35.
The petitioner has filed a rejoinder to the affidavit-
in-opposition filed by the respondents 1 and 2. In paragraphs 4
and 5 of the rejoinder, it is has been stated as under:
“4. That at Para 7 of the Affidavit-inOpposition of W.P.(C) No.37 of 2022 the
Respondents have admitted that since the
impugned order has already been cancelled
no cause of action survives and this Writ
Petition is liable to be closed.
5. That the impugned order is order of
11.1.2022 and 18.12.2021 but cancellation
order mentions only order of 11.1.2022
(Annexure X-3 Page 10 and 11) but it is
mentioned at Para 7 that no cause of action
survives.
In view of the position stated above, it is
therefore prayed that the order of 18.12.2021
of framing of Article of charges of 2nd
Department Proceeding may kindly be
quashed, Annexure A/9 of the Writ Petition
No.37 of 2022 by allowing the present Writ
Petition (C) No.37 of 2022 for the ends of
justice so that the case can be closed as
contended by the Respondents.”
36.
The stand taken by the respondents 1 and 2 in the
affidavit-in-opposition and the reply to the rejoinder filed in
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022 and WP(C) No.913 of 2021
P a g e | 29
W.P.(C) No.37 of 2022 is admittedly contradictory to each other.
The respondents 1 and 2 firmly averred in the affidavit-inopposition that since the impugned order has already been
cancelled no cause of action survives and the writ petition
(W.P.(C) No.37 of 2022) may be closed.
37.
A litigant can take different stands at different times,
but cannot take contradictory stands in the same case.
38.
In Suzuki Parasrampuria Suitings Private Limited v.
Official Liquidator of Mahendra Petrochemicals Limited (In
Liquidation) and others, (2018) 10 SCC 707, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court held:
“12. A litigant can take different stands at
different times but cannot take contradictory
stands in the same case. A party cannot be
permitted to approbate and reprobate on the
same facts and take inconsistent shifting
stands. The untenability of an inconsistent
stand in the same case was considered in
Amar Singh v. Union of India, (2011) 7 SCC
69, observing as follows:
“50.This Court wants to make it clear
that an action at law is not a game of
chess. A litigant who comes to court
and invokes its writ jurisdiction must
come with clean hands. He cannot
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022 and WP(C) No.913 of 2021
P a g e | 30
prevaricate and take inconsistent
positions.””
39.
When the respondents 1 and 2 contended that the
impugned order No.1/64/2020-TA & H (Pt-4) communicated on
11.1.2022 (Annexure-A9 to the writ petition) has now been
cancelled vide order dated 21.1.2022, it is unfair on the part of
the respondents 1 and 2 in saying that the Government, vide
order dated 21.1.2022, cancelled only the letter dated 11.1.2022
issued against the petitioner and the order dated 18.12.2021
framing article of charges against the petitioner has not been
cancelled.
At the risk of repetition, this Court reiterates
paragraph 7 of the affidavit-in-opposition filed in W.P.(C) No.37
of 2022 that since the impugned order has already been
cancelled no cause of action survives and this Writ Petition is
liable to be closed.
40.
At this juncture, it is worthwhile to extract the
communication letter dated 11.1.2022 hereunder:
“No.1/642020-TA&H(Pt.4)
GOVERNMENT OF MANIPUR
SECRETARIAT: TRIBAL AFFAIRS & HILLS
DEPARTMENT
*****
Imphal, the 11th January, 2022
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022 and WP(C) No.913 of 2021
P a g e | 31
To
Shri M Pheijao Singh
Deputy Director, TA&H
Manipur
Subject: Submission of fresh Article of
Charge.
Sir,
I am directed to refer to the subject
mentioned above regarding submission of
fresh Article of Charge and request you
kindly to submit written statement of defence
within 7 (seven) working days i.e. on or
before 21st January, 2022 failing which the
enquiry will hold ex-parte.
Encl: As stated above.
Yours faithfully,
Sd/-xxx
(Dr. RA Ransing)
Under Secretary (TA&H)
Govt. of Manipur”
41.
It is also necessary to extract the contents in the
order dated 21.1.2022, referred to by the respondents 1 and 2
and the same reads thus:
“Whereas
in
pursuance
of
Office
Memorandum being No.1/64/2020-TA&H(Pt3) dated 7.12.2021 an Office Memorandum
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022 and WP(C) No.913 of 2021
P a g e | 32
being
No.1/64/2020-TA&H(Pt.4)
dated
18.12.2021 proposing to hold an enquiry
against Shri M. Pheijao Singh, Deputy
Director/TA&H, Manipur who was under
suspension by then but reinstated vide Order
No.1/5/2021-TAH(H) dated 21.12.2021 was
served upon the said Shri M.Pheijao Singh,
Deputy Director/TA&H, Manipur with a
direction to submit his written statement of
defence on the charges set out in the Article
of Charges (Annexure-I & II) enclosed with
the Memorandum dated 18.12.2021 within
15 (fifteen days) of the receipt of the above
said Memorandum dated 18.12.2021.
Whereas,
Orders
being
Nos.
being
No.1/64/2020-TA&H(Pt.3) dated 07.12.2-22
and
No.1/64/2020-TA&H
(Pt.3)
dated
07.12.2022 have been issued appointing
Shri Devesh Deval, IAS, Commissioner,
Departmental
Enquiry,
Government
of
Manipur as the Inquiring Authority to inquire
into the charges framed against the said Shri
M. Pheijao Singh and Shri Th. Chandrabir
Singh, Retired Deputy Director (Admn),
RIMS, Imphal as the Presenting Officer of the
case respectively.
Whereas
through
some
inadvertent
mistakes,
the
Affairs
and
Tribal
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022 and WP(C) No.913 of 2021
Hills
P a g e | 33
Department, Government of Manipur, have
issued a letter No.1/64/2020-TA&H (Pt.-4)
dated 11.01.2022 to Shri M. Pheijao Singh,
Deputy Director/TA&H, Manipur asking him
to submit written statement of defence within
7 (seven) working days, i.e. on or before
21.01.2022, failing which the enquiry will hold
ex-parte which is nothing but redundant.
Now, therefore it is to order that the letter
No.1/64/2020-TA&H (Pt.4) dated 11.01.2022
is hereby cancelled with immediate effect.”
42.
The respondents 1 and 2 filed reply to the rejoinder
stating that the Memorandum/Order dated 18.12.2021 framing
article of charges against the petitioner has not been cancelled.
Admittedly, the said stand taken by respondents 1 and 2 is totally
inconsistent with the statement made in paragraph 7 of the
affidavit-in-opposition filed in W.P.(C) No.37 of 2022.
The
respondent authorities should not blow hot and cold by taking
inconsistent stands and protract the proceedings unnecessarily.
43.
Since
the
letter
dated
11.1.2022
is
the
communication of fresh charges thereby calling upon the
petitioner to submit his written submission of defence, the
cancellation includes the Memorandum/Order dated 18.12.2021.
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022 and WP(C) No.913 of 2021
P a g e | 34
The order dated 22.1.2022, nowhere states retaining of the
Memorandum/Order dated 18.12.2021. If the intention of the
concerned authority is not to cancel the Memorandum/Order
dated 18.12.2021, the said authority ought to have stated
accordingly in the order dated 22.1.2022. The aforesaid mistake
committed by the authority cannot be legalised by saying that
only the letter dated 11.1.2022 is cancelled. The cancellation of
the communication letter dated 11.1.2022 alone cannot be made,
as the said letter accompanied the Memorandum/Order dated
18.12.2021. That is why the respondents 1 and 2 have filed their
affidavit-in-opposition dated 28.9.2022 in W.P.(C) No.37 of 2022
that since the impugned order has already been cancelled no
cause of action survives and the writ petition is liable to be
closed. If the authority concerned has really not cancelled the
proceedings, it ought not to have filed such an affidavit praying
to close the writ petition.
Now taking a volte-face, the
respondents 1 and 2 cannot contend that the letter dated
11.1.2022 is alone cancelled and the Memorandum/Order dated
18.12.2021 remained as such.
44.
Assuming
arguendo,
the
Memorandum/Order
dated 18.12.2021 remains as such, as rightly argued by the
learned counsel for the petitioner, initiating the second
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022 and WP(C) No.913 of 2021
P a g e | 35
departmental proceedings by framing of article of charges after
withdrawing the earlier article of charges on the same set of facts
is not permissible.
Admittedly, there is no denial by the
respondents 1 and 2 in the affidavit-in-opposition that the second
departmental proceedings on the same set of facts is not
permissible.
45.
The
impugned
Memorandum/Order
18.12.2021 is quoted hereunder for ready reference:
“No.1/64/2020-TA&H(Pt-4): It is proposed to
hold an inquiry against Shri M.Pheijao Singh,
Deputy
Director
(under
suspension),
Department of Tribal Affairs and Hills,
Government of Manipur, Imphal under Rule
of
the
Central
Civil
Services
(Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules,
1965. The substance of the imputations of
misconduct or misbehavior in respect of
which the inquiry is proposed to be held is set
out in the enclosed statement of articles of
charge (Annexure-I).
A statement of the
imputations of misconduct or misbehavior in
support of each article of charge is enclosed
(Annexure-II). A list of documents by which,
and a list of witness by whom, the articles of
charge are proposed to be sustained are also
enclosed (Annexure-III and IV).
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022 and WP(C) No.913 of 2021
dated
P a g e | 36
2. Shri M. Pheijao Singh, Deputy Director
(under suspension), Department of Tribal
Affairs and Hills, Government of Manipur is
directed to submit within 15 (fifteen) days of
the receipt of this Memorandum a written
statement of his defence and also to state
whether he desires to be heard in person.
3. He is informed that an inquiry will be held
only in respect of those articles of charge as
are not admitted.
He would, therefore,
specifically admit or deny each article of
charge.
4. Shri M. Pheijao Singh, Deputy Director
(under suspension), Department of Tribal
Affairs and Hills, Government of Manipur
Imphal is further informed that if he does not
submit his written statement of defence on or
before the date specified in para 2 above or
does not appear in person before the
inquiring authority or otherwise fails or
refuses to comply with the provisions of the
Central Civil Services (Classification, Control
and
Appeal)
Rules,
1965,
or
the
Order/directions issued in pursuance of the
said rule, the Inquiring Authority may hold
inquiry against him ex-parte.
5. Attention of Shri M. Pheijao Singh, Deputy
Director (under suspension), Department of
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022 and WP(C) No.913 of 2021
P a g e | 37
Tribal Affairs and Hills, Government of
Manipur, Imphal is invited to Rule 20 of the
Central Civil Services (Conduct) Rules,
1964, under which no Government servant
shall bring or attempt to bring any political or
outside influence to bear upon any superior
authority to further his interest in respect of
matters pertaining to his service under the
Government,
if
any
representation
is
received on his behalf from another person in
respect of any matter dealt with in these
proceedings, it will be presumed that Shri M.
Pheijao
Singh,
Deputy
Director (under
suspension), Department of Tribal Affairs
and Hills, Government of Manipur, Imphal is
aware of such a representation and that it
has been made at his instance and action will
be taken against him for violation of Rule 20
of the Central Civil Services (Conduct) Rules,
1964.”
46.
While
withdrawing
the
first
departmental
proceedings under order dated 7.12.2021, the first respondent
has stated that the authority intends to issue a modified charge
sheet.
47.
It is pertinent to note that under Rule 14 of the CCS
(CCA) Rules, 1965, under which the disciplinary authority is
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022 and WP(C) No.913 of 2021
P a g e | 38
initiating the departmental proceedings, there is no provision
enabling and empowering the authority to alter, amend, modify
the article of charges already issued.
48.
The explanation to Rule 14(23) of the CCS (CCA)
Rules, 1965 empowers the Inquiring Authority to give a finding
different from the original article of charges and it may record its
findings on such article of charges. Qua modifying, altering,
amending the article of charges, finding can be recorded other
than original article of charges. As held by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court, the disciplinary authority cannot read any expressions into
the provisions of Rule 14 of the CCS (CCA) Rules to modify, alter
and amend the original article of charges.
49.
On a reading of the article of charges framed during
the first departmental proceedings (challenged in W.P.(C)
No.913 of 2021) and the second departmental proceedings
(challenged in W.P.(C) No.37 of 2022), it is clear that both are
similar.
As stated supra, there is no specific denial in the
affidavit-in-opposition that second departmental enquiry on the
same set of facts without logical conclusion of the earlier
departmental enquiry is not permissible, being violative of Rule
15 of the CCS (CCA) Rules, and it also amounts to admission by
the respondents 1 and 2.
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022 and WP(C) No.913 of 2021
P a g e | 39
50.
In Kanailal Bera v. Union of India and others, (2007)
11 SCC 517, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held:
“6. … Once a disciplinary proceeding has
been initiated, the same must be brought to
its logical end meaning thereby a finding is
required to be arrived at as to whether the
delinquent officer is guilty of charges levelled
against him or not. In a given situation further
evidences may be directed to be adduced but
the same would not mean that despite
holding a delinquent officer to be partially
guilty of the charges levelled against him
another inquiry would be directed to be
initiated on the selfsame charges which could
not be proved in the first inquiry.”
51.
An averment made in the petition is expected to be
specifically denied by the replying party and if there is no specific
denial, such averments is deemed to have been admitted by the
respondent.
52.
In T.P.Gopalakrishnan v. State of Kerala, 2023 (1)
SCALE 1, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held:
“38. …… Thus, it can be said that the present
cases pertain to the same set of facts and are
in respect of same offences, for the same
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022 and WP(C) No.913 of 2021
P a g e | 40
period, committed in the same capacity as
the previous three cases wherein the
appellant herein was already prosecuted in
the year 1999.
The core allegation in all
these five cases pertains to misappropriation
by making false entries in the cash book.
The allegation of the prosecution that twothirds of the auction amount was not remitted
to the treasury would be covered under the
allegations of misappropriation of funds, that
the appellant has already been prosecuted
for in the year 1999. The appellant is right in
contending that the charge in the first three
cases were framed on 17.08.1999 which is
much after the audit and the prosecution
would
have
been
well
aware
of
the
misappropriation in respect of the present
cases on 17.08.1999.”
53.
In the light of the decision in T.P. Gopalakrishnan,
supra, when we examine the present case, it is clear that the
second departmental proceedings pertains to the same set of
facts and in respect of the same allegation of the first
departmental proceeding and allegedly committed in the capacity
as in the previous departmental proceedings, which was
cancelled by the respondent authorities.
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022 and WP(C) No.913 of 2021
P a g e | 41
54.
As righty argued by the learned counsel for the
petitioner, the initiation of second departmental proceedings
thereby framing of article of charges on the selfsame charges as
the earlier charges without the leave of the Court is illegal, mala
fide and also interfering with the administration of justice.
In
other words, W.P.(C) No.913 of 2021 was filed on 13.12.2021 to
quash the first departmental proceeding. During the pendency
of the said writ petition, the respondent authorities issued the
impugned order initiating second departmental proceedings by
framing charges on 18.12.2021, which was communicated to the
petitioner on 11.1.2022 without the leave of the Court.
The
argument of the learned senior counsel for the petitioner is that
the action of the respondent authorities is not only mala fide, but
also an abuse of process of the Court to render W.P.(C) No.913
of 2021 otiose and infructuous. This Court finds some force in
the submission made by the learned counsel for the petitioner.
Admittedly, the aforesaid plea of the petitioner has not been
controverted by the respondents.
On the other hand, the
respondents have stated in the affidavit-in-opposition filed in
W.P.(C) No.913 of 2021 that “no cause of action survives and the
writ petition is not maintainable”. Similarly, the stand taken in the
affidavit-in-opposition filed by the respondents 1 and 2 in W.P.(C)
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022 and WP(C) No.913 of 2021
P a g e | 42
No.37 of 2022 is that “since the impugned order has already been
cancelled no cause of action survives and this writ petition is
liable to be closed”. The impugned order assailed in W.P.(C)
No.37 of 2022 is the order dated 18.12.2021, which was
communicated on 11.1.2022. This Court in the earlier paragraph
held that the second departmental proceedings initiated against
the petitioner for the same set of selfsame charges is not legally
sustainable.
55.
The learned senior counsel for the petitioner argued
that the authority had constituted a special audit done by the
Director, Local and Fund Audit, Manipur, and, after conducting
the audit, the Director has submitted a report to the effect that the
amount recoverable from the petitioner is only Rs.45,881/-. In
support, the learned counsel drew the attention of this Court to
the report of the Director, Local Fund Audit, Manipur (AnnexureA/8). On a perusal of the audit report, this Court finds that the
audit was conducted for the period from 2011-2012 to 2019-20.
Upon auditing, the authority submitted the report in respect of the
petitioner as follows:
“C) Shri M. Pheijao Singh, Deputy Director
w.e.f. 25/04/2014 to 30.08.2016
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022 and WP(C) No.913 of 2021
P a g e | 43
An amount of Rs.87,68,631/- standing as
outstanding advance against Shri M. Pheijao
Singh, Deputy Director/former HOO/DDO
(TA & Hills) now under suspension w.e.f.
25/02/2020.
During the test check of the
documents submitted by the office of the TA
& Hills and Shri M. Pheijao Singh, Dy.
Director/TA & Hills, former HOO/DDO (under
suspension) submitted documents to the
Director, TA & Hills.
It is found that the
amount of Rs.87,22,650/- charged to him as
liability stands Rs.45,881/- only as an
advance as per documents enclosed.
In
view
of
examination/auditing
of
expenditures incurred by Shri M. Pheijao
Singh, almost the issue is cleared excepting
the amount of Rs.45,881/-. The amount be
recovered immediately.
It is pertinent to mention that Shri M. Pheijao
Singh may be allowed to revoke his
suspension immediately as per his statement
of Accounts occurred during his tenure.”
56.
While issuing the first departmental proceedings,
the respondents stated that during the period from 24.4.2014 to
31.8.2016, the petitioner had misappropriated a sum of
Rs.3,96,46,031.00 of the Government money. In the second
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022 and WP(C) No.913 of 2021
P a g e | 44
departmental proceedings, the respondent stated that during the
period from 24.4.2014 to 31.8.2016, the petitioner had caused
loss to the tune of Rs.34,86,761/-, Rs.1,02,47,367/-, 4,28,599/-,
16,82,109/-
and
Rs.3,10,98,184/-
respectively
of
the
Government money and he has failed to make any attempt to
recover a sum of Rs.79,90,500/- from M/s. Kamal Polymers
Industries. When the auditing authority audited the accounts for
the period from 2011-2012 to 2019-2020 and came to the
conclusion that the liability stands on the petitioner is only
Rs.45,881/-, the misappropriation of the Government money
alleged by the respondent authorities in the charge memo is
highly doubtful. That apart, the report of the auditor is prior to the
initiation of the second departmental proceedings.
57.
It is not the case of the respondents that the audit
report is not reliable. In paragraph 12 of the writ petition, the
petitioner averred that since the audit report is in favor of the
petitioner, the authority has not put the report into action, which
clearly and abundantly proved the mala fide and bias of the
authority. With regard to the averments made paragraph 12 of
the writ petition, the respondents 1 and 2 filed affidavit-inopposition as under:
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022 and WP(C) No.913 of 2021
P a g e | 45
“5. That with reference to para No.12 of the
writ petition, it is denied that there has been
any mala fide and bias on the point of
authority.”
58.
Except the above, no particulars have been
mentioned by the respondents in the affidavit-in-opposition that
the audit report dated 24.6.2021 cannot be used by the petitioner.
As rightly argued by the learned counsel for the petitioner, since
the audit report is in favour of the petitioner and Rs.45,881/- is
shown as liability of the petitioner out of the charged amount of
Rs.87,22,650/-, the respondent authorities are bound to put the
report into action.
Further, the auditing authority has
recommended for revocation of suspension of the petitioner. If
the petitioner has committed huge loss to the Government, the
auditing
authority
would
not
recommend
revocation
of
suspension order.
59.
The initiation of departmental proceedings by
issuance of article of charges against the petitioner and its
subsequent cancellation by the respondent authorities for one
reason or the other would definitely prove the cool calculation
and malevolent design to harass, humiliate and victimize the
petitioner.
As stated supra, under Rule 14(24)(a) of the CCS
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022 and WP(C) No.913 of 2021
P a g e | 46
(CCA) Rules, 1965, the Inquiring Authority has to conclude the
inquiry and submit his report within six months from the date of
receipt of the order of appointment.
60.
Though
the
respondent
authorities
initiated
departmental proceedings against the petitioner way back in the
year 2020, they have not taken keen interest in proceeding
further to reach a logical conclusion in the departmental
proceedings. In other words, the first enquiry could not be
brought to its logical end and the same charges were withdrawn
and second enquiry has been initiated on the same set of facts
which are split up facts by splitting the article of charges which is
admittedly not permissible in law.
61.
The role model of governance and decision making
thereof should manifest justice, fair play, equity and free from
illegalities, arbitrariness. The cardinal principle of governance in
a civilized society based on rule of law must create an impression
that the decision making is motivated on the consideration of
probity, strictly adhering to rule of law, law declared by the Court
and the principles of service jurisprudence.
This Court is
highlighting the above only to show the intention and action of
the respondent authorities to victimize the petitioner. Admittedly,
in the case on hand, the respondent authorities have taken
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022 and WP(C) No.913 of 2021
P a g e | 47
inconsistent pleas. Taking the inconsistent pleas by a party
makes a conduct far from satisfactory. As rightly argued by the
learned counsel for the petitioner, the action of respondent
authorities is not only mala fide, but also an abuse of process of
the Court. On the whole, this Court is of the considered view that
there are merits in the writ petitions. Exercising the arbitrary
power, the first respondent has issued the impugned orders,
which are not sustainable in the eyes of law and, therefore, the
same are liable to be quashed.
62.
In the result,
(i)
W.P.(C) Nos. 37 of 2022 and 913 of
2021 are allowed.
(ii)
The impugned order No. 1/64/2020TA
&
HILLS
dated
25.2.2020
initiating Departmental Proceedings
and framing Memorandum with
Articles of charges vide order No.
1/64/2020/TA
&
HILLS
dated
10.6.2020 and order No. 1/64/2020TA & H(Pt-4) dated 18.12.2021
communicated on 11.1.2022 (A/9)
initiating
Second
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022 and WP(C) No.913 of 2021
Departmental
P a g e | 48
Proceedings with framing of Articles
of charges are set aside.
(iii)
There will be no order as to costs.
ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
FR/NFR
Sushil
WP(C) No. 37 of 2022 and WP(C) No.913 of 2021
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review