Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT RAWAL
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE K. V. JAYAKUMAR
WEDNESDAY, THE 12TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025 / 23RD MAGHA, 1946
OP (CAT) NO. 81 OF 2023
AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 03.04.2023 IN OA NO.907 OF 2017 OF
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL, ERNAKULAM BENCH
PETITIONER/APPLICANT:
M.PARIYANI
AGED 65 YEARS
S/O. THE LATE KUNJAN, AGED 65 YEARS,
MULTI TASKING STAFF (RETIRED),
MANNARKKAD MUKHYA DAK GHAR, RESIDING AT KUNJAN NIVAS,
KANJIRAPPUZHA POST PALAKKAD., PIN - 678591
BY ADVS.
SRI.H.VISHNUDAS
SRI.O.V.RADHAKRISHNAN (SR.)
SRI.GEORGE VARGHESE
RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS:
SUPERINTENDENT OF POST OFFICES
OTTAPPALAM DIVISION, OTTAPPALAM, PIN - 679101
POSTMASTER GENERAL,
NORTHERN REGION, KOZHIKODE, PIN - 673006
CHIEF POSTMASTER GENERAL
KERALA CIRCLE, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695001
DIRECTOR GENERAL OF POSTS
DAK BHAVAN, NEW DELHI, PIN – 110001
OP (CAT) NO. 81 OF 2023
-22025:KER:20359
UNION OF INDIA
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY,
MINISTRY OF COMMUNICATIONS NEW DELHI,
PIN - 110001
BY ADV.
SRI.K.S.PRENJITH KUMAR, CGC
THIS
12.02.2025,
FOLLOWING:
OP
THE
(CAT)
COURT
HAVING
BEEN
FINALLY
ON
SAME
DAY
THE
HEARD
ON
DELIVERED
THE
OP (CAT) NO. 81 OF 2023
-32025:KER:20359
JUDGMENT
AMIT RAWAL, J.
The present O.P.(CAT) is directed against the
judgment dated 03.04.2023 in O.A.No.907 of 2017,
whereby the claim of the petitioner - applicant for
treating his period of officiating/adhoc service in the post
of postman with effect from 01.10.2002 to 08.08.2007
and thereafter till 17.07.2010, for consideration for the
purpose of pension, has been rejected.
2.
Succinctly
the
facts
in
brief
for
adjudication of the lis are as follows:
While
working
as
a
Gramin
Dak
Sevak
(hereinafter called ‘GDS’, for short) the applicant –
petitioner was ordered to officiate as postman at
Kanhirapuzha Branch against the regular vacancy during
the
period
from
30.09.2002
to
17.07.2010
and
thereafter, at different post offices. This fact is evident
OP (CAT) NO. 81 OF 2023
-42025:KER:20359
from the information received under the RTI Annexure
A2 as well as from the first and second additional reply
statements, which we will be extracting in the later part
of the judgment. However, vide order Annexure A6 on
22.07.2010 was appointed as Group D against the post of
postman
with
effect
from
09.08.2007
with
the
clarification that the period of notional service shall
count only for the purpose of pension. A representation
Annexure A7 was submitted by the petitioner for
counting of Ad-hoc arrangement rendered as officating
postman in the vacant post for the purpose of pension,
which was rejected vide Annexure A8 dated 24.11.2016.
The relevant portion of the order is extracted herein
below:
“Sub: Counting of Ad-hoc arrangement
rendered
as
officiating
Postman
for
consideration of pension – reg.
Ref: Your representation dated 02.08.2016.
This
has
reference
to
your
OP (CAT) NO. 81 OF 2023
-52025:KER:20359
representation dated 02.08.2016 requesting to
count the ad-hoc service rendered as Postman
in different spells for the purpose of pension.
This is to inform you that the engagement as
postman
against
leave
vacancies
and
/or
otherwise will not be counted for pension and
other terminal benefits.
As per records, you
were appointed as MTS against the vacancy
arisen after the introduction of New Pension
scheme.
Therefore, you are not eligible for
pension
an
other
benefits
under
Statutory
Pension Scheme 1972.”
3.
The aforementioned order was assailed
before the Tribunal. Respondents in the first additional
reply statement did not disclose the fact that the
applicant -petitioner had worked from 30.09.2002 to
17.07.2010 but only gave the particulars of employment
of 2010 i.e., from 12.04.2010 to 29.04.2010, 16.06.2010
to 19.06.2010, 24.06.2010 to 30.06.2010 and 01.07.2010
to 17.07.2010. However, in paragraph No.5 of the said
statement, it has been stated that he had served against
the vacant post of post man, Mannarkad from 01.10.2002
OP (CAT) NO. 81 OF 2023
-62025:KER:20359
to 31.03.2010. Similar was the contention in the second
additional reply in paragraph No.4 thereof.
4.
Learned
tribunal
though
noticed
the
aforementioned contentions/averments recorded in the
additional reply, in paragraph No.11 of the judgment
under challenge, but, while giving the findings in the
penultimate paragraph and in between found that the
service of the applicant – petitioner as postman, while
working as GDS, was only intermittent and rejected the
case.
It is in this contention this O.P.(CAT) has been
filed.
5.
Learned
Senior
counsel
Sri.O.V.Radhakrishnan assisted by Mr.Vishnudas H.,
learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner applicant submitted that the relevant point of time the
applicant-petitioner officiated as postman in Mannarkad
area was from 30.09.2002 to 17.07.2010.
III
Rule
of
the
Chapter
Central Civil Service (Pension)
OP (CAT) NO. 81 OF 2023
-72025:KER:20359
Rules, 1972 (hereinafter referred to as ‘1972 Rules’, for
short), dealing with qualifying services were applicable,
which came to be repealed only in 2004 and as per Rule
13 the ‘qualifying service’ would mean the service
rendered by an applicant in official temporary capacity
without any interruption by substantive appointment.
The aforementioned contention has also been rejected
only on the premise that the material available on record
shows that the applicant – petitioner had not satisfying
the requirement of qualifying service as contemplated
under Rule 13 of 1972 Rules, thus, the findings of the
tribunal are wholly erroneous.
6.
On the other hand, Mr.Prenjith Kumar,
learned Central
Government Counsel appearing on
behalf of the respondents reiterated the submissions
recorded by the tribunal as culled out from the first and
second additional reply statements, found that the
intermittent
services
rendered
by
the
applicant-
OP (CAT) NO. 81 OF 2023
-82025:KER:20359
petitioner will not be construed to be a qualifying service
as it was not uninterrupted.
Even otherwise, the
aforementioned 1972 Rules had undergone a sea change
by introduction of a new pension scheme into force and
thus urged this Court for upholding the findings under
challenge.
7.
We have heard learned counsel for the
parties and appraised the paper book.
8.
Before dealing with the rival findings it
would be axiomatic to extract the contents of paragraph
No.5 of the first additional reply and the chart contained
in paragraph No.4 of the second additional reply.
9. Paragraph No.5 in the first additional reply
reads as follows:
“5. It is submitted that as per the contentions
raised in Para 5 of the Original Petition it is
admitted that the Applicant was engaged as
Gramin Dak Sevak Mail Deliverer(GDSMD for
Short),
Kanhirapuzha
PO
with
effect
from
22.08.1977. It is further submitted that the
OP (CAT) NO. 81 OF 2023
-92025:KER:20359
applicant worked as a substitute in the vacant
post
of
Postman
Mannarkkad
MDG
from
01.10.2002 to 31.03.2010 in the vacancy arose
subsequent to the retirement of the regular
departmental incumbent, availing LWA [Leave
without allowance] from his original post of
EDDA
Kanhirapuzha.
When
a
regular
departmental postman joined at Mannarkkad
MDG on 01.04.2010, the applicant had to return
to his original post and continued to work there
as EDDA Kanhirappuzha. Later he worked as
substitute
for
Postman
vacancies
at
Mannarkkad MDG on different spells of period
12.04.10 to 29.04.2010, 16.06.10 to 19.06.2010,
24.06.2010 to 30.06.2010 and 01.07.2010 to
17.07.2010 when any of the regular postmen at
Mannarkkad MDG proceeded on leave. There
after
the
Applicant
was
posted
as
Group
DPattambi as per Annexure A-5 memo dated
17.07.2010. Later the applicant was transferred
to Mannarkkad MDG and retired from service
on attaining the age of Superannuation on
30.06.2016.It may be pertinent to point out here
that the post of postman and MTS are entirely
different carrying different Grade Pay/Levels.”
Chart contained in paragraph No.4 of the second
additional reply
OP (CAT) NO. 81 OF 2023
-102025:KER:20359
“4. It is humbly submitted that Gramin
DakSevaks are holders of Civil posts but they
are outside the purview of regular Civil Service
and are employed for a maximum of five hours
in different post offices, for performing various
types of duties. Their engagement is governed
by GDS Conduct Rules [now GDS (Conduct &
Engagement) Rules as amended from time to
time. The selection of a Grameen Dak Sevak to
the cadre of Multi Tasking Staff or Postman is
considered
as
direct
recruitment.
GrameenDakSevaks are engaged to work in the
posts of Postman/ Multi Tasking Staff in short
term leave vacancies or long term vacancies as
working arrangement. Such arrangements are
purely temporary. A Grameen Dak Sevak is not
eligible for officiating in any Departmental posts
of Postman, Multi tasking Staff. It is admitted
that the applicant was engaged in the vacant
posts of Postman in various spells purely on a
working arrangement as detailed below.
The
applicant
has
not
worked
continuously from 01.10.2002 to 17.07.2010 as
stated below.
Period
Post
22.08.1977- GDSMD
30.09.2002 Kanjirapuzha
Remarks
Regular post
the applicant
of
OP (CAT) NO. 81 OF 2023
-112025:KER:20359
01.10.2002- Postman
31.03.2010 Mannarkkad
MDG
Engaged
to
manage the post
due to vacancy
01.04.2010- GDSMD
11.04.2010 Kanjirapuzha
Regular post
the applicant
12.04.2010- Postman
29.04.2010 Mannarkkad
MDG
Engaged
to
manage the post
due to vacancy
30.04.2010- GDSMD
15.06.2010 Kanjirapuzha
Regular post
the applicant
16.06.2010- Postman
19.06.2010 Mannarkkad
MDG
Engaged
to
manage the post
due to vacancy
20.06.2010- GDSMD
23.06.2010 Kanjirapuzha
Regular post
the applicant
24.06.2010- Postman
30.06.2010 Mannarkkad
MDG
Engaged
to
manage the post
due to vacancy
01.07.2010- Postman
17.07.2010 Mannarkkad
MDG
Engaged
to
manage the post
due to vacancy
18.07.2010
GDSMD
Kanjirapuzha
Regular post
the applicant
19.07.2010
Group D
Pattambi
Promotion
of
of
of
of
”
10.
The aforementioned two aspects were
noticed by the tribunal in paragraph No.11 of the
judgment, which is extracted hereinbelow:
“11.
The
details
of
service
of
the
applicant in O.A 907/2017 is available
OP (CAT) NO. 81 OF 2023
-122025:KER:20359
from
the
additional
reply
statement
dated 3.3.2022. It shows that during the
period from 01.10.2002 to 17.07.2010,
he has officiated on different spells, as
Postman, Mannarkad in short term leave
vacancy/long term vacancy. After each
spell, he continued to hold the regular
post of GDS. The last spell as GDS was
on 18.07.2010. Thereafter on 19.07.2020
he got appointed as Group D employee,
at Pattambi.”
11.
paragraph
But
while
Nos.21
and
rendering
failed
the
findings
in
to
notice
the
aforementioned service to bring the case within the
parameters of Rule 13 of 1972 Rules. It would be also
pertinent to extract Rule 13 as they were in vogue and
operative when the applicant-petitioner was ordered to
officiate the post of postman from 2002. The said rule is
extracted herein below:
“13. Commencement of qualifying service
Subject to the provisions of these
OP (CAT) NO. 81 OF 2023
-132025:KER:20359
rules,
qualifying
service
of
a
Government
servant shall commence from the date he takes
charge of the post to which he is first appointed
either substantively or in an officiating or
temporary capacity:
Provided that officiating or temporary
service is followed without interruption by
substantive appointment in the same or another
service or post:
Provided further that(a) in the case of a Government
servant in a Group 'D' service or post
who held a lien or a suspended lien on
a permanent pensionable post prior to
the 17th April, 1950, service rendered
before attaining the age of sixteen
years shall not count for any purpose,
and
(b) in the case of a Government
servant not covered by Clause (a),
service rendered before attaining the
age of eighteen years shall not count,
except for compensation gratuity.
[(c) the provisions of Clause (b) shall
not be applicable in the cases of
counting of military service for civil
OP (CAT) NO. 81 OF 2023
-142025:KER:20359
pension under Rule 19.”
12. We are of the view that respondents had
been remiss in not explaining the continuous service of
30.09.2002 to 17.07.2010 as officiating/discharging the
duties of postman at Mannarkkad post office. This was
the clincher for, in our considered view, allowing the
application of the applicant-petitioner to be strictly in
tandem with the Rule 13 of 1972 Rules ibid. Similar view
has also been expressed by the Division Bench of this
Court in support of the judgment of this Court in
Reghukumar C.P. Vs. Union of India and Others
[2021 (3) KHC 400). Paragraph No.7 of the judgment
is extracted herein below:
“7. A reading of the above Rules would make it
clear that the operative portion of Rule 13
would mandate that, subject to the provisions of
the
CCS
Rules,
qualifying
service
of
a
Government servant shall commence from the
date he takes charge of the post to which he is
first appointed either substantively or in an
officiating or temporary capacity. The first
OP (CAT) NO. 81 OF 2023
-152025:KER:20359
proviso to the said Rule would stipulate that this
is so provided that officiating or temporary
service is followed without interruption by
substantive appointment in the same or another
service or post. The second proviso thereto
consists of three clauses as per clauses (a), (b)
and (c) thereof. Clause (a) to the second proviso
is not applicable in the instant case inasmuch as
it deals with cases which have occurred prior to
17th April, 1950. Clause (b) would stipulate that
in a case of a Government servant not covered
by clause (a), service rendered before attaining
the age of 18 years shall not count, except for
compensation gratuity. A reading of internal
page No.2 of Annexure R1 would show that date
of birth of the petitioner herein (shown as
Sl.No.2 thereof) is 24.03.1955. So, obviously the
petitioner’s case will not be affected by the
condition in clause (b) of the second proviso to
Rule 13 inasmuch as the service rendered by
the petitioner is much after the cut of age of 18
years. Clause (c) of the second proviso would
further stipulate that the provisions of clause (b)
of the second proviso shall not be applicable in
cases of counting of military service for civil
pension under Rule 19 of the CCS (Pension)
Rules. Clause (c) of the second proviso would
also in any manner detrimentally affect the case
OP (CAT) NO. 81 OF 2023
-162025:KER:20359
of the petitioner inasmuch as clause (b) itself is
not applicable to his case. Thus it can be seen
that if an incumbent like the petitioner can
satisfy the requirements the operative portion of
Rule 13 of CCS (Pension) Rules as well as its
first proviso, then such an incumbent is entitled
to count his initial adhoc/officiating service, for
the
purpose
of
reckoning
the
same
as
pensionable service in the post, to which he is
substantively/regularly
provided
that
the
appointed
officiating
or
later,
temporary
service is followed without interruption by
substantive appointment in the same post or
another service or post as envisaged in the first
proviso to Rule 13.”
13. As an upshot of findings, we are of the view
that the reasoning assigned by the tribunal is wholly
perverse, opaque, fallacious and not sustainable in the
eyes of law.
aside.
Accordingly, impugned judgment is set
O.A. is, therefore, allowed.
(CAT) is also allowed.
Consequently O.P.
Respondents are directed to
consider the officiating service of applicant-petitioner
from 30.09.2002 to 17.07.2010 strictly as per the
OP (CAT) NO. 81 OF 2023
-172025:KER:20359
provisions of Rule 13 of the 1972 Rules and grant the
benefit of the pension which was though a condition at
the time when the applicant-petitioner was actually
appointed with effect from 09.08.2007 within a period of
two months from the date of receipt of the certified copy
of the judgment.
Sd/-
AMIT RAWAL
JUDGE
Sd/K. V. JAYAKUMAR
JUDGE
vv
OP (CAT) NO. 81 OF 2023
-182025:KER:20359
APPENDIX OF OP (CAT) 81/2023
PETITIONER ANNEXURES
Annexure A 1
PHOTOCOPY OF THE CHARGE REPORT DATED
17-08-1977
ANNEXURE A 2
PHOTOCOPY OF THE REPLY DATED 02-082016 FURNISHED UNDER THE RIGHT TO
INFORMATION ACT OF THE IST RESPONDENT.
ANNEXURE A 3
PHOTO COPY OF THE MEMO DATED 16-072010 OF THE IST RESPONDENT.
ANNEXURE A 4
PHOTO COPY OF THE MEMO DATED 17-072010 OF THE IST RESPONDENT.
ANNEXURE A 5
PHOTOCOPY OF THE MEMO DATED 17-07-2010
OF THE POSTMASTER, PATTAMBI M.D.G.
ANNEXURE A 6
PHOTOCOPY OF THE MEMO DATED 22-07-2010
OF THE POSTMASTER, PATTAMBI MDG.
ANNEXURE A 7
PHOTOCOPY OF THE REPRESENTATION DATED
02-08-2016 OF THE APPLICANT TO THE IST
RESPONDENT.
ANNEXURE A 8
PHOTOCOPY OF THE MEMO DATED 24-11-2016
OF THE IST RESPONDENT.
ANNEXURE A 9
PHOTOCOPY OF THE ORDER DATED 17-112016 IN O.A NO. 749 OF 2015 AND
CONNECTED CASES (EXCLUDING PAGES 2 TO
320 WHICH CONTAINS THE NAME AND
ADDRESS OF APPLICANTS 4 TO 106)
ANNEXURE R1
TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT IN CIVIL
APPEAL 90/2015 OF THE SUPREME COURT OF
INDIA IN Y.NAJITHAMOLAND OTHERS CASE
OP (CAT) NO. 81 OF 2023
-192025:KER:20359
ANNEXURE R2
TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGEMENT IN OP(CAT)
327/2016 BY HON’BLE HIGH COURT OF
KERALA INDUKALA & OTHERS CASE.
ANNEXURE R3
TRUE COPY OF THE RULE 13 OF SWAMY’S
PENSION COMPILATION INCORPORATING CCS
PENSION RULES.
ANNEXURE A 10
TRUE COPY OF THE EXTRACT-RELEVANT
PAGES INCLUDING PARA 64 OPERATIVE
PORTION OF THE COMMON ORDER IN O.A.NO.
312/2008 AND O.A.NO.422 OF 2008 OF
THIS HON’BLE TRIBUNAL.
Annexure A 11
TRUE COPY OF THE D.G., POSTS, LETTER
NO. 18-34/92-ED & TRG., DATED THE 25TH
NOVEMBER, 1993.
ANNEXURE A 12
TRUE COPY OF THE RELEVANT PAGES OF THE
DEPARTMENT OF POSTS (GROUP-D POSTS)
RECRUITMENT RULES, 2002
ANNEXURE A 13
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED 16-092009 IN O.A.NO.462 OF 2008 OF THIS
HON’BLE TRIBUNAL.
ANNEXURE A 14
TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGEMENT DATED 1002-2010 IN WP(C) NO.18 OF 2010 OF THE
HON’BLE HIGH COURT OF KERALA.
ANNEXURE R 4
TRUE EXTRACT OF RULE 127 A OF POSTAL
MANUAL VOLUME II.
ANNEXURE R5
JUDGEMENT DATED 31-05-2016 ON OA NO.
135/2013 FILED BY SRI.P.S.PADMAKUMAR
AND OTHERS.
EXHIBIT P 1
TRUE COPY OF THE ORIGINAL APPLICATION
NO.907/2017 FILED BY THE
PETITIONER/APPLICANT.
OP (CAT) NO. 81 OF 2023
-202025:KER:20359
EXHIBIT P2
TRUE COPY OF THE REPLY STATEMENT FILED
ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENTS DATED 1705-2018.
EXHIBIT P3
PHOTOCOPY OF THE COMMON ORDER DATED
30-10-2019 IN OA NO.180/000907/2017 OF
THE CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
ERNAKULAM BENCH.
EXHIBIT P4
TRUE COPY OF THE COMMON JUDGEMENT
DATED 22ND DAY OF OCTOBER, 2021IN
OP(CAT)NOS. 55&56 OF 2021 OF THIS
HON’BLE COURT.
EXHIBIT P5
TRUE COPY OF THE ADDITIONAL REPLY
STATEMENT FILED BY THE RESPONDENTS 1
TO 5 DATED 31-12-2021.
EXHIBIT P6
TRUE COPY OF THE REJOINDER STATEMENT
FILED BY THE APPLICANT/PETITIONER.
EXHIBIT P7
TRUE COPY OF THE 2ND ADDITIONAL REPLY
STATEMENT FILED ON BEHALF OF THE
RESPONDENTS 1 TO 5 DATED 03-03-2022.
EXHIBIT P8
TRUE COPY OF THE ADDITIONAL REJOINDER
STATEMENT OF THE APPLICANT DATED 0404-2022.
EXHIBIT P9
TRUE COPY OF THE 3RD ADDITIONAL REPLY
STATEMENT FILED BY THE RESPONDENTS
DATED 27-05-2022.
EXHIBIT P 10
TRUE COPY OF THE IIND ADDITIONAL
REJOINDER TO THE IIIRD ADDITIONAL
REPLY STATEMENT OF THE
APPLICANT/PETITIONER DATED 22-09-2022.
EXHIBIT P 11
PHOTOCOPY OF THE COMMON ORDER DATED
03-04-2023 IN OA NO.180/000907/2017 OF
THE CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
OP (CAT) NO. 81 OF 2023
-212025:KER:20359
ERNAKULAM BENCH.
Exhibit P-12
TRUE COPY OF THE GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
(AUTHORIZATION OF OFFICERS FOR
VERIFICATION OF PLEADINGS AND OTHER
DOCUMENTS TO BE FILED IN THE CENTRAL
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL) RULES, 1993
AS PER G.I., DEPT. PER AND TRG.,
NOTIFICATION NO., A-11019/105/87- AT,
DATED 28-09-1993 PUBLISHED AS PER GSR
630(E) IN THE GAZETTE OF INDIA.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review