Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
S.A.No.725 of 2005
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED : 26.02.2026
CORAM :
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE V.LAKSHMINARAYANAN
S.A.No.725 of 2005
1.M.Kasthuri
2.G.Ramesh
3.Philomina (Died)
[A3 died, A1 & A2 already on record are
LR’s of the deceased A3 vide Court
Order dated 24.04.2023 made in
C.M.P.No.9521 of 2023 in
S.A.No.725 of 2005(RHJ)]
Vs.
1.R.Kasthuri
2.G.Rajkumar
3.G.Tamilselvan
4.G.Jhansi, Minor
[R4 declared as Major and
R1 discharged from the guardianship of R4
vide Court Order dated 24.04.2023
made in C.M.P.Nos.9517 & 9476 of 2023
in S.A.No.725 of 2005 (RHJ)]
... Appellants
... Respondents
5.Tamil Nadu Civil Supplies Corporation,
Rep.by its Manager,
Chennai Division,
having Office at
No.7, Conronsmith Road,
Chennai-600 086.
Prayer: This Second Appeal is filed under Section 100 of CPC against the
Judgment and Decree dated 31.01.2005 passed in A.S.No.164 of 2004 on the
file of the learned Additional District & Sessions Judge, Fast Track Court IV,
1/14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.725 of 2005
Chennai confirming the Judgment and Decree dated 07.01.2004 passed in
O.S.No.222 of 1998 on the file of the learned XV Assistant Judge, City Civil
Court, Chennai.
For Appellants : Mr.J.R.K.Bhavanantham
For Respondents: No Appearance
JUDGMENT
This Second Appeal is before this Court on account of the Order of
Remand passed by the Supreme Court in Civil Appeal No.432 of 2018 dated
16.01.2018.
2. I heard Mr.J.R.K.Bhavanantham for the appellants. Despite a couple
of opportunities granted, there has been no representation for the respondents.
3. For the sake of convenience, the parties are referred to as per their
ranks before the trial Court.
4. The case of the plaintiffs is as follows:The 1st plaintiff, R.Kasthuri claims to be the wife of one Gunaseelan,
S/o.V.M.Aalai. She pleaded that, Gunaseelan passed away on 13.09.1996.
From the wedlock between the 1st plaintiff and Gunaseelan, the plaintiffs 2 to
4 were born. She impleaded the defendants, who, according to her were
unlawfully claiming to be the legal heirs of the very same Gunaseelan. She
2/14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.725 of 2005
also impleaded her mother-in-law (mother of Gunaseelan), as the 3 rd
defendant.
5. The plaintiffs had secured a legal heirship Certificate from the
Tahsildar on 11.10.1996. Similarly, the defendants 1 and 2 had also secured
a legal heirship certificate stating that they are the legal heirs of Gunaseelan.
As there where two conflicting legal heirship certificates, the plaintiffs
approached the District Collector, Chennai District, for rectification of the
records and to set aside the Certificate obtained by the defendants 1 and 2.
6. The District Collector, vide order dated 28.06.1997, cancelled both
the certificates i.e., certificates issued to the plaintiffs, as well as, that issued
to the defendants, and directed the parties to approach the jurisdictional Civil
Court and get a declaration as to who the legal heirs of the deceased
Gunaseelan are. Hence, the plaintiffs presented the suit seeking a declaration
that the 1st plaintiff is the legally wedded wife of Gunaseelan and plaintiffs 2
to 4 are the legal heirs of the said Gunaseelan. Since there was a dispute, they
impleaded the defendants 1 and 2, who claimed to be the legal heirs of the
deceased Gunaseelan, and the mother of Gunaseelan as the 3 rd defendant.
This suit was numbered as O.S.No.222 of 1998.
7. Summons were served on the defendants.
3/14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.725 of 2005
8. The stand of the defendants is that the 1 st defendant is the legally
wedded wife of Gunaseelan. She claimed that she married Gunaseelan two
years prior to the alleged marriage between the 1 st plaintiff and Gunaseelan.
She stated her marriage was solemnised on 30.04.1979. The defendants
further pleaded that, from the wedlock between Gunaseelan and the 1 st
plaintiff (R.Kasthuri), two children were born; one Ramesh, who is the 2 nd
defendant, and another daughter by name Gunasundari. They claimed that
there was no dispute on the date of death of Gunaseelan. They stated that
Gunaseelan was residing with the defendants. Soon after his death, they
claimed that the plaintiffs, along with certain unlawful elements, entered the
property of the defendants and claimed the body of Gunaseelan. However,
they denied the averments made by the plaintiffs that the last rites were
performed by them. On the contrary, they contended that the last rites were
performed only by the 2nd defendant, Ramesh. Apart from pleading that the
1st defendant had married Gunaseelan earlier than the 1 st plaintiff, the
defendants also projected that the 1st plaintiff had married one Munusamy.
Munusamy, it was claimed, was an employee of Corporation of Chennai.
They further pleaded that Munusamy passed away on 13.08.1992 and that the
children, namely, plaintiffs 2 to 4, were the children born to Munusamy and
M.Kasthuri, rather than to the deceased Gunaseelan.
4/14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.725 of 2005
9. Since Kasthuri was already married to Munusamy, the defendants
contended that the plaintiffs’ case as if the 1 st plaintiff is the wife of the
deceased Gunaseelan, is absolutely without any basis. They also projected
that on the death of Munusamy, one of the sons of Munusamy, namely, one
Sivarajan, had secured employment on compassionate grounds with the
Corporation of Chennai.
10. On the basis of these pleadings, the trial Court framed the
following issues:“1/ thjpfs; nfhhpa[s;sthW tpsk;g[if ghpfhuk; bgw chpatu;fsh >
2/ ntW vd;d ghpfhuk; >
11. On the side of the plaintiffs, they have examined PW1 to PW3. The
1st plaintiff, R.Kasthuri, entered into witness box as PW1. One Sivaraj was
examined as PW2, while one Vijayakumar was examined as PW3. The
plaintiffs marked Exs.A1 to A19. On the side of the defendants, the 1 st
defendant examined herself as DW1 and the father of Gunaseelan, one Aalai,
was examined as DW2, and one Ranganathan was examined as DW3. On the
side of the defendants, they marked Exs.B1 to B9.
5/14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.725 of 2005
12. After considering the oral and documentary evidence, the learned
trial Judge decreed the suit as prayed for. Aggrieved by the same, the
defendants 1 to 3 preferred A.S.No.164 of 2004 to the file of learned
Principal Judge, City Civil Court, Chennai. The matter was made over to the
IV Additional Fast Track Court, Chennai. The learned Judge took up the
appeal for hearing on 31.01.2005 and dismissed the same. Before him, the
defendants urged that a suit for declaration before a Civil Court is not
maintainable and that, even if it were maintainable, the grant of decree by the
learned trial Judge is erroneous and contrary to the evidence on record.
13. The learned District Judge held that a Civil Court has jurisdiction
to grant the declaration as claimed. However, he did not discuss the merits of
the case at all. Holding the decree and reasoning of the trial Court is correct,
dismissed the regular appeal. Aggrieved by the same, the defendants
preferred the present Second Appeal.
14. This Second Appeal was admitted on the following Substantial
Questions of Law:(i) Whether Civil Court has jurisdiction to try a suit for
declaration as to the validity of a marriage or as to the
marital status of any person under Sec.7(1) explanation?
(ii) Whether the finding of the Trial Court is perverse
6/14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.725 of 2005
since no oral and documentary evidence adduced on either
side was considered and finding given in respect of all the
issues framed by the Trial Court?
(iii) Whether the first appellate Court, being the last
Court of facts, failed to advert its mind into the facts of the
case, both oral and documentary evidence?
(iv) Whether the Appellate Court was right by not
probing into the correctness of the finding arrived at by the
Trial Court, while exercising the power under Or.41 r/w.
Sec.96 of CPC?
(v) Whether mere declaratory suit is maintainable
under Sec.34 of the Specific Relief Act?
15. The Second Appeal was originally taken up for hearing before this
Court on 08.06.2015. A learned Single Judge held that the finding of the First
Appellate Court, regarding the Civil Court having jurisdiction, is erroneous.
She further held that it is only the Family Court, which has the jurisdiction to
decide whether the plaintiffs are the legal heirs of Gunaseelan or not.
Consequently, the Second Appeal was allowed. The judgments and decrees of
the Court below were set aside and the case was directed to be forwarded to
the Principal Family Court at Chennai for disposal. Aggrieved by the same,
the plaintiffs had preferred a Special Leave Petition to the Supreme Court in
7/14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.725 of 2005
S.L.P.(Civil) No.12985 of 2016.
16. The Supreme Court granted leave and allowed the Civil Appeal. It
held that Civil Courts have jurisdiction to grant declaratory decrees, as sought
in the present suit. It remitted the matter back to this Court, as stated supra.
The Supreme Court held that when the issue is whether the plaintiffs or the
defendants are the legal heirs of Gunaseelan, can be gone into only by the
Civil Court and not by the Family Court. As this Court has not gone into the
merits of the case, the matter was remitted for fresh disposal.
17. After a perusal of the records, I am of the view that questions of
law, (i) & (v) having been settled by the Supreme Court in this very case, do
not arise for consideration. Hence, I am taking up questions of law (iii) & (iv)
together.
18. The relevant paragraph of the lower Appellate Court is extracted
hereunder to show how the First Appellate Court has given a short shrift to
the entire appellate proceedings. It reads:“The Apex Court has clearly held that legitimacy of
any person and claim of marital relationship are not directly
entertainable by family Courts. Therefore, the Jurisdiction
issue also would not help the appellants. Hence the appellants
have no case and the lower Court’s judgment was based on
8/14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.725 of 2005
clinching oral and documentary evidence. The legal position
is also against the appellants. Hence this Court find nothing
to interfere with the lower Court Judgment and accordingly
decide the appeal.”
19. The reason for dismissal of the appeal on merits, as seen above, is
that the First Appellate Court held that the appellants have no case and that
the trial Court’s judgment is based on “clinching oral and documentary
evidence”. Consequently, the legal position is against the appellants. The
learned First Appellate Judge has not considered either the evidence let in by
the plaintiffs or the evidence adduced by the defendants before coming to a
conclusion that the evidence are clinching.
20. First appeal is a very valuable right. The First Appellate Court is a
last Court of facts. It is the duty of the First Appellate Court to consider the
pleadings, the evidence, and the arguments of both sides, weigh them and
finally come to a conclusion as to whether the plaintiffs have proved their
case or whether the defendants have a better case than that of the plaintiffs.
Such an exercise is necessary because the test required to be applied by the
First Appellate Court in civil proceedings is on the basis of preponderance of
probabilities.
9/14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.725 of 2005
21. This assumes greater significance in this case, on account of the
involvement of serious repercussions relating to the legitimacy of the
plaintiffs 2 to 4 and the 2nd defendant. If the manner of disposal of the First
Appellate Court were to be acceded to, then, the parties would be seriously
prejudiced, even without an analysis as to how the Court came to the said
conclusion.
22. The position of law on how the First Appellate Court should deal
with an appeal is settled by the Supreme Court in Santhosh Hazari v.
Purushottam Tiwari (Deceased) by L.Rs., (2001) 3 SCC 179. The relevant
portion of the judgment is extracted hereunder:“15. ..... The appellate Court has jurisdiction to reverse or
affirm the findings of the trial Court. First appeal is a valuable
right of the parties and unless restricted by law, the whole case is
therein open for rehearing both on questions of fact and law. The
judgment of the appellate Court must, therefore, reflect its conscious
application of mind, and record findings supported by reasons, on
all the issues arising along with the contentions put forth, and
pressed by the parties for decision of the appellate Court. The task
of an appellate Court affirming the findings of the trial Court is an
easier one. The appellate Court agreeing with the view of the trial
Court need not restate the effect of the evidence or reiterate the
reasons given by the trial Court; expression of general agreement
with reasons given by the Court, decision of which is under appeal,
would ordinarily suffice (See Girijanandini Devi & Ors. Vs.
Bijendra Narain Choudhary, AIR 1967 SC 1124). We would,
however, like to sound a note of caution. Expression of general
10/14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.725 of 2005
agreement with the findings recorded in the judgment under appeal
should not be a device or camouflage adopted by the appellate
Court for shirking the duty cast on it....”
23. If the test laid down by the Supreme Court is applied to the present
judgment under appeal, then, certainly the First Appellate Court’s judgment
cannot pass legal muster. It does not reflect any application of mind or
consideration of oral and documentary evidence let in before the trial Court.
Though Mr.J.R.K.Bhavanantham has filed the evidence and would invite this
Court to look into the same, I am not inclined to do so on account of the fact
that the cryptic judgment of the lower Appellate Court does not give any
indication to me as to how the evidence were analysed. In fact, owing to the
judgment being laconic, the Second Appeal was admitted only on the basis of
question of law Nos.3 & 4.
24. It is represented by Mr.J.R.K.Bhavanantham that the 1 st
respondent / R.Kasthuri is no more. This Court has already recorded that the
legal heirs of R.Kasthuri, namely, plaintiffs 2 to 4 are already on record.
Hence, plaintiffs 2 to 4 are recognised as the legal representatives of the
deceased 1st respondent. As such, recognition has taken place, suffice for the
appellants to file a memo before the First Appellate Court to the effect that
the legal heirs of the deceased 1st Respondent / R.Kasthuri are already on
record. On filing of such Memo, the First Appellate Court shall order the
11/14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.725 of 2005
same and carry out the necessary corrections in the cause title.
25. In the light of this discussion, this Second Appeal is allowed. The
judgment and decree of the First Appellate Court in A.S.No.164 of 2004
dated 31.01.2005 is set aside. The matter is remitted back to the file of the
First Appellate Court. The First Appellate Court shall issue notice to the
appellants, as well as the respondents, and thereafter, take up the matter for
disposal. At the time of disposal, the learned First Appellate Judge will keep
in mind the principles laid down by the Supreme Court referred to above.
26. The parties are directed to appear before the First Appellate Court
on 23.03.2026. In the event of the respondents not appearing, the First
Appellate Court shall direct the appellants to take notice on the plaintiffs, and
once service is complete, take up the appeal for disposal.
26.02.2026
Index
Internet
NCC
ssn
12/14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
:Yes/No
:Yes
: Yes / No
S.A.No.725 of 2005
To
1. The Additional District & Sessions Judge,
Fast Track Court IV,
Chennai.
2. XV Assistant Judge,
City Civil Court, Chennai.
13/14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.725 of 2005
V.LAKSHMINARAYANAN, J.,
ssn
S.A.No.725 of 2005
26.02.2026
14/14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review