Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:MHC:1892
A.S. NO.731 OF 2018
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
JUDGMENT RESERVED ON : 26 / 02 / 2026
JUDGMENT PRONOUNCED ON : 03 / 06 / 2026
CORAM :
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE N.SATHISH KUMAR
AND
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE R.SAKTHIVEL
A.S. NO.731 OF 2018
AND
C.M.P. NOS.16630 AND 15359 OF 2023
AND
C.M.P. NO.25998 OF 2025
A.S.NO.731 OF 2018
M.Balasundaram
S/o. M.Mani
No.10-A/9, Negareeswarar Koil Street,
Kancheepuram Town.
… Appellant /
1st defendant
Versus
1.A/M Vaikunda Perumal Temple
Kancheepuram,
Rep. By its Executive Officer
Having Office at A/M Katchabeswarar Temple
Nellukara Street, Kancheepuram.
… 1st Respondent /
plaintiff
2.Kanchipuram Municipality
Rep. By its Commissioner
Nellukara Street,
Kancheepuram.
Page No.1 of 34
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1892
A.S. NO.731 OF 2018
3.Superintending Engineer
Tamilnadu Electricity Board
Anna Maligai,
Olimohamedpet, Kanchipuram.
… Respondents 2&3 /
defendants 2&3
PRAYER: First Appeal filed under Section 96 and Order XLI Rule 1 of
the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, praying to set aside the Judgment and
Decree dated December 22, 2017 passed in O.S. No.208 of 2010 by the
learned District Judge, District Court - II, Kancheepuram.
For Appellant
:
Mr.T.M.Hariharan
For Respondent-1 :
Mr.K.Hariharan
For Respondent-2 :
Mr.RA. Gopinath
Standing Counsel
For Respondent-3 :
No appearance
CMP NO.15359 OF 2023
A/M Vaikunda Perumal Temple
Kancheepuram,
Rep. By its Executive Officer
Having Office at A/M Katchabeswarar Temple
Nellukara Street, Kancheepuram.
…
Petitioner /
1st Respondent
1.M.Balasundaram
S/o. M.Mani
No.10-A/9, Negareeswarar Koil Street,
Kancheepuram Town.
…
1st Respondent /
Appellant
2.Kanchipuram Municipality
Rep. By its Commissioner
Nellukara Street, Kancheepuram.
…
2nd Respondent /
2nd Respondent
Versus
Page No.2 of 34
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1892
A.S. NO.731 OF 2018
3.Superintending Engineer
Tamilnadu Electricity Board
Anna Maligai,
Olimohamedpet, Kanchipuram.
…
3rd Respondents /
3rd Respondent
PRAYER: Civil Miscellaneous Petition filed under Order XLI Rule 27
and Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, praying to receive
the documents filed with the list as additional evidence on the side of the
first respondent in the appeal and mark the same on the side of the
plaintiff/first respondent as Exhibits A11, A12 and A13 in the appeal.
List of documents annexed in CMP No.15359 of 2023
S.No.
Date
Description of Documents
29.06.2022 Photostat copy of the order passed by the Settlement Officer in
Appeal e.f.<.1/8553/2010
19.10.2022 Photostat copy of the order passed for change of pattas in favour of
temple in proceedings e.f.82/2022/m by Special Tahsildar,
Kancheepuram
26.01.1929 Photostat copy of the T.D.No.1042 in favour of temple, issued by
District Collector, Kancheepuram
For Petitioner
:
For Respondent-1 :
For Respondent-2 :
For Respondent-3 :
Mr.K.Hariharan
Mr.T.M.Hariharan
Mr.RA. Gopinath
Standing Counsel
No appearance
CMP NO.16630 OF 2023
M.Balasundaram
S/o. M.Mani
No.10-A/9, Negareeswarar Koil Street,
Kancheepuram Town.
… Petitioner /
Appellant
Page No.3 of 34
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1892
A.S. NO.731 OF 2018
Versus
1.A/M Vaikunda Perumal Temple
Kancheepuram,
Rep. By its Executive Officer
Having Office at A/M Katchabeswarar Temple
Nellukara Street, Kancheepuram.
2.Kanchipuram Municipality
Rep. By its Commissioner
Nellukara Street,
Kancheepuram.
3.Superintending Engineer
Tamilnadu Electricity Board
Anna Maligai,
Olimohamedpet, Kanchipuram.
… Respondents /
Respondents
PRAYER: Civil Miscellaneous Petition filed under Order XLI Rule 27 of
the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, praying to receive the document set out
in the Schedule to the petition as additional document in A.S.No.731 of
2018 and to mark the same as Ex-B.15 on the side of the first defendant /
appellant.
Schedule to the petition in CMP No.16630 of 2023
S.No.
Date
Description of the Document
26.06.2023 Proceedings of the Commissioner of Land
Administration, Chepauk, Chennai – 600 005, in
K1/2935124/2022
For Petitioner
:
For Respondent-1 :
For Respondent-2 :
For Respondent-3 :
Nature
Photostat Copy
Mr.T.M.Hariharan
Mr.K.Hariharan
Mr.RA. Gopinath
Standing Counsel
No appearance
Page No.4 of 34
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1892
A.S. NO.731 OF 2018
CMP NO.25998 OF 2025
M.Balasundaram
S/o. M.Mani
No.10-A/9, Negareeswarar Koil Street,
Kancheepuram Town.
… Petitioner /
Appellant
Versus
1.A/M Vaikunda Perumal Temple
Kancheepuram,
Rep. By its Executive Officer
Having Office at A/M Katchabeswarar Temple
Nellukara Street, Kancheepuram.
2.Kanchipuram Municipality
Rep. By its Commissioner
Nellukara Street, Kancheepuram.
3.Superintending Engineer
Tamilnadu Electricity Board
Anna Maligai,
Olimohamedpet, Kanchipuram.
… Respondents /
Respondents
PRAYER: Civil Miscellaneous Petition filed under Order XLI Rule 27 of
the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, praying to receive the Order of the
Commissioner of Land Administration, Chepauk, Chennai, dated
September 15, 2025 in R.O.No.K1/2935124/2022 set out in the schedule to
the petition as additional document in A.S.No.731 of 2018 and to mark the
same as B-16 on the side of the petitioner / appellant.
For Petitioner
:
Mr.T.M.Hariharan
For Respondent-1 :
Mr.K.Hariharan
For Respondent-2 :
Mr.RA. Gopinath
Standing Counsel
For Respondent-3 :
No appearance
Page No.5 of 34
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1892
A.S. NO.731 OF 2018
JUDGMENT
R.SAKTHIVEL, J.
Feeling aggrieved by the Judgment and Decree dated December 22,
2017 passed in O.S. No.208 of 2010 by 'the learned District Judge, District
Court-II, Kancheepuram' ['Trial Court' for convenience], the first defendant
therein has preferred this Appeal Suit under Section 96 and Order XLI
Rule 1 of 'the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908' ['CPC' for brevity].
2. For the sake of convenience, hereinafter, the parties will be
referred to as per their array in the Original Suit.
PLAINTIFF'S CASE IN BRIEF:
3. Case of the plaintiff is that 'the Arulmighu Vaikundaperumal
Temple' [hereinafter 'plaintiff-temple'] is an ancient temple built by
Pallavas. It is a public temple governed by the 'Tamil Nadu Hindu
Religious and Charitable Endowments Act, 1959' ['HR & CE Act' for
brevity].
3.1. The vacant site comprised in Survey No.847/49-B and C, having
Door No.33-A in Vaikundaperumal South Mada Street, Kanchipuram is the
suit property herein and the same belongs to the plaintiff-temple. It is a
Page No.6 of 34
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1892
A.S. NO.731 OF 2018
minor Inam granted to the plaintiff-temple. The suit property forms part of
a larger extent in Town Survey No.847 totally measuring 8 Acre 37 Cents
which also belongs to the plaintiff-temple.
3.2. On April 29, 1941, the plaintiff-temple represented by its then
Devasthana Dharmakartha - M.Thiruvenkadamudaya Iyer executed a Cawl
(lease) Deed in favour of one K.K.Venkatrama Iyer for a monthly rent of
Rs.2/- for the Suit vacant land, for the purpose of house construction.
K.K.Venkatarama Iyyar transferred the Cawl to one Kodadhanda
Mudhaliar on March 22, 1948 on the condition that the transferee shall pay
the lease amount to the plaintiff-temple as per the original Cawl Deed. On
January 17, 1957, the said Kodadhanda Mudhaliar transferred the Cawl in
favour of one R.S.Natraja Mudhaliar, who in turn on February 12, 1959,
transferred the Cawl in favour of one R.Natraja Mudhaliar.
3.3. The said R.Nataraja Mudhaliar, who is the only a transferee of the
Cawl, without any legal right, as if he is the absolute owner of the suit
property, sold a portion of suit property to one Deivasigamani Mudhaliar
vide registered Sale Deed dated April 30, 1991 (Document No.608 of
1991) and the remaining portion to one R.K.Krishnan under registered Sale
Deeds dated April 30, 1991 (Document No.609 of 1991) and February 2,
Page No.7 of 34
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1892
A.S. NO.731 OF 2018
1991. In turn, said R.K.Krishnan and the legal heirs of Deivasigamani sold
the suit property to the first defendant herein vide Sale Deed dated August
3, 2009. The sale in favour of the first defendant is not valid and binding
upon the plaintiff-temple. It will not confer any right, title or interest on the
first defendant or anyone else for that matter.
3.4. The aforesaid R.Nataraja Mudhaliar, during his lifetime claimed
Ryotwari Patta before the Assistant Settlement Officer, Thanjavur. As it
went against the plaintiff-temple, it filed an appeal before the Settlement
Officer, Chepauk, Chennai. The first defendant and his predecessors are
under the erroneous impression that they had become the owner of the suit
property after passing of the Tamil Nadu Minor Inams Abolition and
Conversion into Ryotwari Act, 1963 (Tamil Nadu Act No.30/1963). The
plaintiff - temple continues to be the owner of the suit property even after
passing of the said Act. The suit property is not vested with the
Government. The defendants who purchased the suit property from the extenants of the plaintiff-temple cannot set up title themselves and they are
estopped from doing so. As they are claiming title against the plaintifftemple, they have forfeited their tenancy rights, if any. They are to be
treated as trespassers of the suit property.
Page No.8 of 34
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1892
A.S. NO.731 OF 2018
3.5. Further, the first defendant purchased the suit property in August
2009 and started to put up construction there in January 2010. The
plaintiff-temple raised objection immediately for the construction. Despite
objection, the first defendant is proceeding with the illegal construction
work without obtaining proper permission from the Municipality. The
plaintiff-temple is trying to get permission and electricity service
connection from defendants 2 and 3. The plaintiff-temple has also raised
objections to the defendants 2 and 3 not to accord any sanction or service
connection to the first defendant in respect of suit property. The first
defendant does not have any right to be in possession of the Suit land.
Hence, the plaintiff filed a Suit for recovery of possession of the suit
property after removing the superstructure put up by the first defendant and
also for permanent injunction restraining the first defendant from putting
up any further construction in the suit property.
FIRST DEFENDANT'S CASE IN BRIEF:
4. The first defendant filed written statement stating that after
passing of the Tamil Nadu Act No.30 of 1963, vide proceedings conducted
before the Assistant Settlement Officer, Thanjavur in S.R. No.2512 of 1967
dated January 29, 1968, the Settlement Officer granted patta to the first
Page No.9 of 34
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1892
A.S. NO.731 OF 2018
defendant's predecessor-in-title in respect of the suit property. The revision
preferred by the plaintiff-temple in S.R. No.3/KPM/79-13 was dismissed
on December 21, 1979. In the revision, it was also ordered that the
plaintiff-temple is not entitled to enforce any Cawl Deeds from the notified
date.
4.1. Aggrieved by the order, the plaintiff-temple filed Revision before
the Special Commissioner, Commissioner of Land Administration,
Chepauk, Chennai in R.P. No.49 of 1980. In the said proceedings, the
claim of the plaintiff-temple was negatived with regard to the suit property.
In the meantime, the plaintiff-temple had filed a Writ Petition in W.P.
No.13642 of 1996 before the High Court. The High Court remitted the
matter back to the Assistant Settlement Officer to examine whether
anything further survives in the claim of the plaintiff-temple, vide its Order
dated February 25, 1997.
4.2. The Assistant Settlement Officer after due enquiry, dismissed the
plaintiff-temple's claim petition on April 29, 2008. All the patta
proceedings went against the plaintiff-temple. So first defendant's
predecessors had valid title from whom the first defendant lawfully
purchased the suit property. Since the date of purchase, the first defendant
Page No.10 of 34
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1892
A.S. NO.731 OF 2018
is in uninterrupted possession and enjoyment of the suit property. Revenue
records which stood in the name of the first defendant's predecessors-intitle, after purchase by first defendant, were mutated to his name. After
Tamil Nadu Act No.30 of 1963, there is no tenancy between the plaintifftemple and the first defendant or his predecessor-in-title. First defendant
did not pay any rent to the plaintiff-temple at any point of time. Further,
the first defendant invested huge amount in the Suit construction.
Accordingly, the first defendant prayed to dismiss the Suit.
SECOND DEFENDANT'S CASE IN BRIEF:
5. The second defendant filed written statement stating that no
building permission was accorded to the first defendant for construction of
the building on the suit property by the second defendant till date and the
second defendant is ready to abide by any Order of the Court. There are
no merits or bonafide or cause of action in filing the Suit against the
second defendant. Stating so, the second defendant prayed to dismiss the
Suit.
CASE OF THIRD DEFENDANT:
6. No written statement on the side of third defendant.
Page No.11 of 34
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1892
A.S. NO.731 OF 2018
TRIAL COURT:
7. Based on the above pleadings, the Trial Court framed the
following issues:
'1.
Whether the plaintiff temple is entitled to the relief of
possession?
2.
Whether the first defendant’s vendor had title to the property as
alleged by the first defendant?
3.
Whether the plaintiff is entitled to the relief of permanent
injunction as prayed for?
4.
To what relief the plaintiff is entitled?'
8. At trial, one Vajaravelu, Executive Officer attached to the
plaintiff-temple was examined as P.W.1 and Ex-A.1 to Ex-A.10 were
marked on the side of the plaintiff. On the side of the defendants, the first
defendant himself was examined as D.W.1 and Ex-B.1 to Ex-B.14 were
marked.
9. After full-fledged trial, the Trial Court concluded that the
plaintiff-temple is the owner of the suit property and they are entitled to
recover the suit property after removing the unauthorized construction in
the suit property and also entitled to get patta from the Government. The
Trial Court further concluded that since the plaintiff-temple is the owner of
the suit property and entitled to recovery of possession, the plaintiff-temple
is also entitled to permanent injunction against the first defendant not to
Page No.12 of 34
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1892
A.S. NO.731 OF 2018
make any further construction in the suit property. Accordingly, the Trial
Court decreed the Suit as prayed for by the plaintiff-temple.
APPEAL SUIT
10. Feeling aggrieved by the Decree and Judgment, the first
defendant therein has preferred this First Appeal under Section 96 read
with Order XLI Rule 1 of C.P.C.
11. In the Appeal Suit, the plaintiff-temple filed a petitioner under
Order XLI Rule 27 of C.P.C. in C.M.P. No.15359 of 2023, praying to
receive three documents viz., (i) Photocopy of the Order passed by the
Settlement Officer in Na.Ka. No.1/8553/2010, (ii) Photocopy of the Order
passed by the Special Tahsildhar, Kancheepuram in Na.Ka. No.82/2022/A
directing issuance of patta in favour of the plaintiff-temple and (iii)
Photocopy of Inam Fair Register, as additional evidence.
12. Similarly, the first defendant filed two Order XLI Rule 27
Applications in C.M.P. Nos.16630 of 2023 and 25998 of 2025, seeking to
receive the proceedings of the Commissioner of Land Administration
Chepauk dated March 26, 2003 in Proceedings No.K1/2935124/2022 and
that dated September 15, 2025 in Proceedings No.K1/2935124/2022.
Page No.13 of 34
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1892
A.S. NO.731 OF 2018
13. Heard either side on the Order XLI Rule 27 Applications.
Perused the affidavits filed in support of the Applications.
14. As far as the Civil Miscellaneous Petition in C.M.P. No.15359 of
2023 is concerned, the earlier patta proceedings relevant to the petition
mentioned Document Nos.1 and 2 are already marked in this Suit and the
documents sought to be received as additional evidence are of proceedings
pursuant thereto. The petition mentioned Document Nos.1 and 2 being
Orders passed by a Statutory Authority in which the first defendant is also
a party, he cannot deny the same and there may not be any impediment or
prejudice to him. Therefore, this Court is inclined to receive the petition
mentioned Document Nos.1 and 2, and mark them as Ex-A.11 and ExA.12 respectively, without resorting to Order XLI Rule 28 of C.P.C.
considering the nature of the documents. As far as the petition mentioned
Document No.3 - Inam Fair Register goes, the same is already on record
on the plaintiff-temple's side as Ex-A.8 - Extract of Inam Fair Register,
and hence, there is no need to receive and mark the same again.
Consequently, C.M.P. No.15359 of 2023 filed by plaintiff-temple is partly
allowed. Petition mentioned Document Nos.1 and 2 are received and
marked as Ex-A.11 and Ex-A.12 respectively.
Page No.14 of 34
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1892
A.S. NO.731 OF 2018
15. As regards C.M.P. Nos.16630 of 2023 filed by the first
defendant, he thereby seeks to receive the Interim Order of the
Commissioner of Land Administration granting status-quo inter-alia in
respect of the Suit land. In effect, Ex-A.11 - Order was stayed by the
Commissioner. The document sought to be received being an Order of
Statutory Authority in pursuance of Ex-A.11 - Order, this Court is inclined
to allow the Civil Miscellaneous Petition. Accordingly, C.M.P. Nos.16630
of 2023 is allowed and the document is marked as Ex-B.15, without
resorting to Order XLI Rule 28 of C.P.C. considering the nature of the
documents.
16. As regards C.M.P. No.25998 of 2025 which is another Civil
Miscellaneous Petition filed by the first defendant, the document sought to
be received is the Final Order passed in Revision over Ex-A.11 - Order.
Again considering the nature of the document, this Court is inclined to
receive and mark the same without resorting to Order XLI Rule 28 of
C.P.C. Accordingly, C.M.P. No.25998 of 2025 is allowed and the document
is received and marked as Ex-B.16.
Page No.15 of 34
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1892
A.S. NO.731 OF 2018
ARGUMENTS FOR APPEAL SUIT:
17. Mr.T.M.Hariharan, learned Counsel appearing for the appellant /
first defendant would submit that though the plaintiff-temple has both
Melvaram and Kudivaram on the appointed date, the Suit construction was
already in existence on that date. Hence, as per Section 13 of the Tamil
Nadu Act No.30 of 1963, an occupant has the right to get patta. He would
rely on the Sale Deed dated April 30, 1991 and submit that the first
defendant established that on the date of commencement of the Tamil
Nadu Act No.30 of 1963, there was a building in the suit property. Hence,
the plaintiff-temple has no right over the suit property in view of Section
13 of the Tamil Nadu Act No.30 of 1963.
17.1. He would further submit that the Trial Court failed to appreciate
the fact that the patta was issued in favour of the predecessor-in-title of the
first defendant vide Tamil Nadu Act No.30 of 1963. Referring to Ex-B.16,
he would submit that the patta proceedings under the Tamil Nadu Act
No.30 of 1963 reached finality in which patta was granted to the first
defendant.
17.2. He would further submit that the plaintiff-temple filed similar
cases against the adjacent land owners and the same ended against the
plaintiff-temple. After commencement of Tamil Nadu Act No.30 of 1963,
Page No.16 of 34
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1892
A.S. NO.731 OF 2018
the temple lost its right and the building was vested with the Government.
The Settlement Tahsildar rightly held that patta has to be issued outside the
purview of the Tamil Nadu Act 30 of 1963.
17.3. He would further submit that the right of the defendants have
been recognised by the Authorities constituted under Tamil Nadu Act
No.30 of 1963. Hence, the Statutory Orders recognizing the rights of the
defendants and his predecessor-in-title, clearly creates a cloud over the title
of the plaintiff-temple and hence, the relief of possession without a prayer
of declaration of title of plaintiff is not maintainable. Accordingly, he
would pray to allow the Appeal Suit and set aside the Decree and Judgment
passed by the Trial Court.
17.4. In support of his arguments, the learned Counsel appearing for
the appellant / first defendant relied on the following judgments: (i)
Sathyanarayanan -vs- The Sub Registrar (W.P.No.12053 of 2023 decided
on July 16, 2024); (ii) K.Somasundaram Pillai -vs- R.Dorairaj, reported in
(1979) 1 MLJ 443; (iii)K.S.Thirugnasambandam Chettiar -vs- The
Settlement Thesildar, reported in 1996-1-L.W.19; (iv)R.Surendran -vsArulmighu Ekambareswarar Thirukoil (S.A.No.32 of 2019 decided on
October 18, 2024); (v) R.Manicka Naicker -vs- E.Elumalai Naicker,
Page No.17 of 34
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1892
A.S. NO.731 OF 2018
reported in (1995) 4 SCC 156; (vi) Jagdish Narain -vs- Nawab Said Ahmed
Khan, reported in 1959 L.W. 268 (PC); (vii) Brahma Nand Puri -vs- Neki
Puri, reported in AIR 1965 SC 1506; (viii) Moran Mar Basselios
Catholicos -vs- Most Rev. Mar Poulose Athanasius, reported in (1954) 2
SCC 42; (ix) Anathula Sudhakar -vs- P.Buchi Reddy, reported in (2008) 4
SCC 594; (x) Sudha Ravi Kumar -vs- The Special Commissioner &
Commissioner, reported in 2017 (3) CTC 135; (xi) D.Satyanarayana -vsP.Jagadish, reported in (1987) 4 SCC 424; (xii) Mangat Ram -vs- Sardar
Meharban Singh, reported in (1987) 4 SCC 319.
18. Per contra, Mr.K.Hariharan, learned Counsel appearing for the
first respondent / plaintiff-temple would submit that the plaintiff-temple
has both Kudivaram as well as Melvaram. Reiterating the plaint averments
qua Cawl Deed and subsequent transfers of Cawl, he would submit that the
Suit land belongs to the plaintiff-temple. R.Natraja Mudhaliar who was a
mere Cawl transferee had no right to execute Ex-B.6 and Ex-B.7 - Sale
Deeds in respect of the Suit land in favour of the predecessor-in-title of the
first defendant. Hence, Ex-B.6 and Ex-B.7 - Sale Deeds would not bind the
plaintiff. As the first defendant himself has admitted that he did not pay
rent as per the Original Cawl Deed, he is to be termed as a trespasser and
had no right to put up construction, that too without permission from the
Page No.18 of 34
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1892
A.S. NO.731 OF 2018
plaintiff-temple. When the Suit land belongs to the plaintiff-temple, the
plaintiff-temple can maintain the Suit without seeking the relief of
declaration of title. Further, patta proceedings issued under the Tamil Nadu
Act No.30 of 1963 cannot decide title, Civil Court alone is the competent
forum to do so. The Trial Court after considering the entire facts and
circumstances rightly granted relief of delivery of possession and
permanent injunction. There is no warrant to interfere with it. Accordingly,
he would pray to dismiss the Appeal Suit and sustain the Judgment and
Decree of the Trial Court.
18.1. In support of his contentions, the learned Counsel appearing for
the
first
respondent
relied
on
the
following
judgments:
(i)
K.S.Thirugnasambandam Chettiar -vs- The Settlement Thasildar, reported
in 1996-1-L.W.19; (ii) Subramania Gurukkal -vs- Shri Patteswaraswami
Devasthanam, reported in 1996-1-L.W. 166; (iii) R.Manicka Naicker -vsE.Elumalai Naicker, reported in (1995) 4 SCC 156; (iv) T.K.Ramanujam
Kavirayar -vs- Sri-La-Sri Sivaprakasa Pandara Sannadhi Avargal, reported
in 1988–2-L.W.513; (v) State of Tamil Nadu -vs- Ramalinga Samigal
Madam, reported in AIR 1986 SC 794; (vi) Srinivasan -vs- Sri
Madhyarjuneswaraswami, reported in (1988) 2-L.W.189; (vii) Sri-La-Sri
Sivaprakasa Pandara Sannadhi Avargal -vs- Smt.T.Parvathi Ammal,
Page No.19 of 34
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1892
A.S. NO.731 OF 2018
reported
in
1998-2-L.W.188;
Subrahmanyaswami
and
(viii)
-vs-
K.S.Sundararajulu
Devasthanam
Sri
Kumarakattalai
Chettiar,
reported in (1975) ILR 1Mad 501.
DISCUSSION ON THE APPEAL SUIT:
19. This Court has considered both sides' submissions and perused
the evidence available on record. The points that arise for consideration in
this Appeal Suit are:
(i)
Whether the plaintiff-temple is the owner of the Suit land ?
(ii)
Whether Exs-B.6 and B.7 - Sale Deeds are binding on the plaintiff-temple ?
(iii)
Whether the patta issued under Section 13 of the Tamil Nadu Act No.30 of
1963 would confer title to the first defendant's vendor and the first defendant ?
(iv)
Whether the plaintiff - temple is entitled to the relief of recovery of possession
as prayed for ?
(v)
Whether the plaintiff - temple is entitled to the relief of permanent injunction
as prayed for ?
(vi)
Whether the Trial Court's Judgment and Decree is to be interfered with ?
Page No.20 of 34
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1892
A.S. NO.731 OF 2018
Point Nos.(i) to (iii)
20. The plaintiff's side marked Ex-A.8 - Photocopy of the Inam Fair
Register issued by Inam Commissioner. From Ex-A.8, it could be seen that
an extent of 5 Acre 28 Cents was originally a Devadayam land granted
vide Title Deed No.1042 by the Deputy Collector, Inam Settlement
Commissioner on June 22, 1961. Further, in Column No.2 thereof, it has
been mentioned as "Devadayam". Column No.3 thereof reads as "an extent
of 1.32 acres Dry Poonthottam and an extent of 3.96 acres Tope totaling
5.28 acres". In Column No.8 thereof, it has been noted as "for the service
of Vaikunda Perumal, the service is rendered to this day". In Column No.9
thereof, it has been mentioned as "Sarva Inam". In Column No.10 thereof,
it has been noted as "so long as the service is rendered". In Column Nos.16
and 17 thereof, it has been stated that "Parameswara Vinnagharam
Conjivaram Sri Vaikuntha Perumal’s Tope manages for the time being
Kodandarama Nayak Guruvamma, Adilakshmammal priest for the time
being Aiyatari Bhattar". In Column No.21 thereof, it has been mentioned
as "To be confirmed to Sri Vaikuntha Perumal Pagoda so long as the
institution is well maintained". Further, from the perusal of Ex-A.8, it is
seen that an extent of 28 Cents was acquired for the purpose of
construction of a school building and Rs.0-4-7 has been deducted as Beriz
deduction.
Page No.21 of 34
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1892
A.S. NO.731 OF 2018
21. A conjoint and careful perusal of entries made in Ex-A.8 Inam
Fair Register would show that the Suit land along with the larger extent of
land is a service inam land given to the service provider of the temple viz.,
Kodandarama Nayak, Guruvammal, Adilakshmammal and Aiyatari
Bhattar. It is apposite to mention here that the first defendant did not claim
right through the aforesaid Service Inamdhars. On the other hand, as
detailed supra, he is claiming title through the Cawl Transferees from the
plaintiff-temple.
22. As
narrated
in
the
plaint,
the
plaintiff-temple's
then
Dharmakartha executed Ex-C.1- Cawl Deed in respect of 'land measuring
north-south 90 feet X east-west 44 feet in Survey No.847' (Suit land) in
favour of one K.K.Venkatrama Iyer, whereunder the then Dharmakartha
on behalf of the plaintiff-temple received Rs.50/- as premium, the ground
rent was fixed at Rs.2/- per month, the Cawl period was agreed to be
renewable every 21 years, and the Cawl holder was permitted to put up
construction and also to alienate the superstructure to anyone other than
Muslims, Christians and Panjavars as long as the ground rent is being duly
paid. For ready reference, portion of Ex-C.1 containing relevant recitals is
extracted hereunder:
Page No.22 of 34
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1892
A.S. NO.731 OF 2018
"XuhtJ ghh;l;oahh; i# njt!;jhd ed;ikiaa[k;
yhgj;ija[k; mgptpUj;jpiaa[k; cj;njrpj;J i#ahh;
RthjPdj;jpy; ,Uf;Fk; moapy; fz;l fhypkidia
tPLfl;o mDgtpj;Jf; bfhs;s 2tJ ghh;l;o nfl;Lf;
bfhz;lgo XuhtJ ghh;l;o xg;g[f; bfhz;L 2
kidf;F i# njt!;jhdj;jpw;;fhf gphpkpak; buhf;fk;
+ 50.00 vGj;jhy; Ugha; Ik;gJk; 2tJ ghh;l;o kfh
kfh kfh | rg;hp$p!;lhh; mth;fs; Kd;ghf 1tJ
ghh;l;of;F brYj;Jtjhft[k; xg;g[f; bfhz;l tifapy;
i# 1tJ ghh;l;of;F nrh;e;J tpl;lgoahy; ,J Kjy;
21 tU#';fSf;F 2tJ ghh;l;o tPLfl;o mDgtpj:Jf;
bfhs;s i# kidia 1tJ ghh;l;o 2tJ ghh;;l;of;F
ehsJ njjpapy; !;thjPdk; bra;J tpl;lhuhifahy;
ehsJ njjp Kjy; 2tJ ghh;l;o i# mokidia
ifgw;wp mjw;f;F khjk; 1f;F thlif + 2.00 ,uz;L
tPjk; khjk; gpujp khjk; 30f;Fs; njt!;jhd jw;fhy
jh;kfj;jhthfpa
1tJ
ghh;l;oaplkhtJ
my;yJ
mjpfhuk; bgw;wth;fsplkhtJ brYj;jp urPJ bgw;W
moapy;
fz;l
,U
ghh;l;ofSf;Fz;lhd
epge;jidfspd;go Mz;L mDgtpj;Jf; bfhs;s
ntz;oaJ/
i# kidf;Fk; i# kidapd; kPJ fl;Lk;
fl;llj;jpw;Fk; KdprPgy; thp Kjypaitfis 2tJ
ghh;l;ona brYj;jpf; bfhs;s ntz;oaJ/
i#
kidiaahtJ mjpy; fl;oapUf;Fk; fl;olj;ijahtJ
ouhd;Rgh; KjyhdJfs; bra;jhy; 1tJ ghh;l;of;nfh
mth;gpd; tUk; ou!;of;nfh bjhptpj;J bfhs;s
ntz;oaJ.
Page No.23 of 34
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1892
A.S. NO.731 OF 2018
2tJ ghh;l;o i# $hfhitahtJ mjd; nky; fl;Lk;
fl;olj;ijahtJ $hjp ,e;J kj!;jh;fs; jtpu
Kfkjpah; fpwp!;Jth; g";rkh; ,e;j $hjpahh;fSf;F
Flf;Typf;F tpl;lhYk; my;yJ vt;tpj guhjPdk;
bra;jhYk; mJ bry;yjf;fpdjy;y ,;e;j epge;jidf;F
khwhf
2tJ
ghh;l;o
elf;Fk;
gl;rj;jpy;
mg;nghJ ,Uf;Fk; njt!;jhd jh;kfj;jhfSf;F ,e;j
ft[is uj;J bra;J i# $hfhit mjd;nghpYs;s
fl;olj;ij mg;g[wgLj;jp RthjPdk; bra;Jf; bfhs;s
mjpfhuKz;L.
,g;gj;jpuj;jpy; Fwpj;j 21 tU# fhyKotpYk; mjw;F
gpd;dh; xt;bthU 21
tU#';fs; KotpYk; 2tJ
ghh;l;oahtJ mth; thhpRfshtJ ,d;bdhU 21
tU#';fSf;F
ntz;oaJ.
,;e;j
ft[is
g[Jgpj;Jf;
bfhs;s
1tJ ghh;l;oahtJ my;yJ mg;nghijf;fg;nghJ
Vw;gLk;; jh;kfh;j;jhf;fshtJ ,e;j j!;jhnt$py; fz;l
#uj;J go moapy; fz;l mokidia kWgoa[k; 21
tU#';fSf;F kU gphpkpak; nfshkYk;/ mg;go
g[Jgpj;jhy;
njt!;jhdj;Jf;F
mf;fhyj;jpy;
yhgfukpy;iy vd;W brhy;yhkYk; ft[is g[Jgpj;J
bfhLf;fg;gl;lth;fshthh;fs;/
2tJ ghh;l;o fpuago njt!;jhdj;jpw;F mo kid
thlif brYj;j jtwpdhy; 1tJ ghh;l;oahtJ
my;yJ
mjpfhuk;
bgw;wth;fshtJ
ghf;fp
thlifia ,e;j kidapd; nghpy; fl;oapUf;Fk;
Page No.24 of 34
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1892
A.S. NO.731 OF 2018
fl;olj;jpd; nghpy; Kjy; rhh$;[ nfhh;l;L Kykhf
tNy; bra;Jf; bfhs;syhk;/
2tJ ghh;l;onah my;yJ mth; thhpnrh i#
kidapy; fl;olk; fl;odhYk;/ fl;lhtpl;lhYk; ,e;j
j!;jhnt$;;
#uj;Jgo
thlif
bfhLf;fg;gl;lth;fshthh;fs;/
vf;fhyj;jpyhtJ
,e;j
kidiaahtJ
my;yJ
mjd;nghpy; fl;oapUf;Fk; fl;olj;ijahtJ fpuak;
Kjyhd guhjPdk; bra;jhy; guhjPdk; bgw;wth; Kd;
RthjPdj;jpy; itj;Jf;bfhz;L ,Uf;fpwth;fs; i#
kidf;F
nkw;go
ghf;fpapUe;jhy;
mij
brYj;jg;gl;lth;fshthh;fs; ,e;j Fj;jif epyj;Jf;F
tU#k; 1f;F 0.15.0k; fl;olk; fl;lhky; ,Ue;jhYk;
2tJ ghh;l;o brYj;Jfpnwd;.
,e;j
gof;F
ehkpUtUk;
Vnfhgpj;J
.Vw;gLj;jpf;
bfhz;l g[ஞ்bra; epy njhl;l kid ft[y; gj;jpuk;."
23. From the above recitals, the plaintiff-temple did not deny Ex-C.1
- Cawl Deed. It could be easily discerned from a cogent and conjoint
reading of Ex-A.8 - Inam Fair Register and Ex-C.1 - Cawl Deed that the
Suit land was originally a Service Inam land and probably as the Service
Inamdhar failed to render service, the land got vested with the plaintiffPage No.25 of 34
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1892
A.S. NO.731 OF 2018
temple and subsequently, the plaintiff-temple's Dharmakartha had executed
Ex-C.1. As stated above, the ground / Suit land belongs to the plaintifftemple and the Cawl Holder / Transferee is entitled to put up construction
thereon and enjoy the same perpetually (renewable every 21 years) so long
as the monthly rent of Rs.2/- is being paid duly. Further, the Cawl Holder /
Transferee is also entitled to alienate the Suit land subject to the conditions
stipulated in Ex-C.1. The validity of the conditions stipulated is not a
subject matter here.
24. Under Ex-C.2 - Cawl Transfer Deed, the Cawl Holder K.Venkatrama Aiyar transferred the Cawl in favour of one Kothandarama
Mudhaliar on March 22, 1948 on the condition that the transferee shall pay
the lease amount to the plaintiff-temple as per the original Cawl Deed (ExC.1). On January 17, 1957, the said Kothandarama Mudhaliar transferred
the Cawl in favour of one R.S.Natraja Mudhaliar under Ex-C.3 - Cawl
Transfer Deed, who in turn on February 12, 1959, transferred the Cawl in
favour of one R.Natraja Mudhaliar vide Ex-A.3- Cawl Transfer Deed. The
said R.Nataraja Mudhaliar, who is the only a transferee of the Cawl,
without any legal right, as if he is the absolute owner of the suit property,
sold a portion of suit property to one Deivasigamani Mudhaliar subject to
the Cawl, vide Ex-A.4 - Registered Sale Deed dated April 30, 1991 and the
Page No.26 of 34
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1892
A.S. NO.731 OF 2018
remaining portion to one R.K.Krishnan under Exs-A.5 and A.6 Registered Sale Deeds dated April 30, 1991 and February 2, 1991 subject
to the Cawl. As all the above transactions were made subject to the Cawl,
they are valid in nature. The problem begins with Ex-B.6 - Sale Deed dated
August 3, 2009 executed by the said R.K.Krishnan and Ex-B.7 - Sale Deed
dated August 31, 2009 executed by the legal heirs of Deivasigamani, as
they both are outright sale of suit property without any heed to the Cawl.
Both Ex-B.6 and Ex-B.7 were executed in favour of first defendant. The
first defendant is claiming right through the aforesaid documents which
originate from Ex-C.1 - Cawl Deed, and thus, he admits that the plaintifftemple is the owner of the Suit land as well as the landlord -tenant
relationship in respect of the Suit land. The first defendant qua tenant /
lessee cannot turn around
and deny the plaintiff-temple's title; he is
estopped from doing so. Suppose, had first defendant derived any right or
title from the Service Inamdar / Service Provider to the Temple, then only
he is entitled to claim valid patta under the Tamil Nadu Act No.30 of 1963.
Hence, the patta proceedings under the Tamil Nadu Act No.30 of 1963 will
not be a bar to decide the plaintiff-temple's title. Even while assuming that
the Suit building is vested with the Government under the Tamil Nadu Act
No.30 of 1963, even then the Government alone is entitled to deny or
Page No.27 of 34
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1892
A.S. NO.731 OF 2018
question the plaintiff-temple's title. Therefore, this Court concludes that the
plaintiff-temple is the owner of the Suit land in so far as the first defendant
is concerned; that Ex-B.6 and Ex-B.7 - Sale Deeds would not be binding
on the plaintiff-temple; and that the patta proceedings under the Tamil
Nadu Act No.30 of 1963 would not confer any title to the first defendant or
his predecessor-in-title. Point Nos.(i) to (iii) are answered accordingly.
25. Whatever may be, the first defendant has a valid Cawl right over
the suit property, as admittedly the plaintiff-temple did not terminate the
Cawl / lease as per Section 106 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882. He is
in possession and enjoyment of the suit property qua lessee. Had the first
defendant or his predecessor-in-title violated any of the terms of the Cawl,
the plaintiff-temple is entitled to file a Suit for recovery of possession as
per law. Without terminating the lease as per Section 106 of the Transfer of
Property Act, 1882, the plaintiff-temple is not entitled to seek the reliefs of
recovery of possession and permanent injunction. Since patta proceedings
under the Tamil Nadu Act No.30 of 1963 eventually went against the
plaintiff-temple, the plaintiff-temple ought to have filed a Suit for
declaration of title adding the State Government as a party. The Trial Court
is not right in granting the reliefs of recovery of possession and permanent
Page No.28 of 34
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1892
A.S. NO.731 OF 2018
injunction. The Judgment and Decree of the Trial Court are liable to be set
aside. Point Nos.(iv) to (vi) are answered accordingly.
26. This Court has considered the case laws relied on either side. No
quarrel with them.
CONCLUSION
27. Resultantly,
(i)
C.M.P. No.15359 of 2023 filed by the plaintiff-temple is partlyallowed and the petition mentioned Document Nos.1 and 2 are
received and marked as Ex-A.11 and Ex-A.12 respectively.
(ii)
C.M.P. Nos.16630 of 2023 and C.M.P. No.25998 of 2025 filed by
the first defendant are allowed and the petition mentioned
documents are received and marked as Ex-B.15 and Ex-B.16
respectively.
(iii)
Appeal Suit is allowed. The Judgment and Decree of the Trial
Court are set aside, however, leave is granted to the plaintiff-temple
to file a fresh Suit for declaration, recovery of possession and
permanent injunction after terminating the lease as per Section 106
of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882.
Page No.29 of 34
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1892
A.S. NO.731 OF 2018
(iv)
Considering the facts and circumstances, there shall be no order as
to costs.
[N.S.K., J.]
[R.S.V., J.]
03 / 06 / 2026
LIST OF DOCUMENTS MARKED BY THIS COURT, WITH CONSENT OF
BOTH PARTIES, VIDE ORDER DATED FEBRUARY 26, 2026 IN A.S.NO.505
OF 2016
S.No.
Date
Description of document
Nature of
transaction
Nature of
document
Exhibits
29.04.1941 R/Kanchipuram
II/Book 1/1774/1941
Joint Cawl
Transfer
Certified copy Ex-C.1
22.03.1948 R/Kanchipuram
II/Book 1/1166/1948
Joint Cawl
Transfer
Certified copy Ex-C.2
17.01.1957 R/Kanchipuram
II/Book 1/286/1957
Joint Cawl
Transfer
Certified copy Ex-C.3
LIST OF ADDITIONAL DOCUMENTS MARKED ON THE SIDE OF THE
FIRST RESPONDENT AS PER THE ORDER PASSED IN CMP NO.15359 OF
2023 IN A.S.NO.731 OF 2018
S.No.
Date
Description of Document
Nature of
document
Exhibits
29.06.2022 Order passed by the Settlement Officer
in Appeal e.f.<.1/8553/2010
Photostat
copy
Ex-A.11
19.10.2022 Order passed for change of pattas in
favour of temple in proceedings
e.f.82/2022/m by Special Tahsildar,
Kancheepuram
Photostat
copy
Ex-A.12
Page No.30 of 34
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1892
A.S. NO.731 OF 2018
LIST OF ADDITIONAL DOCUMENT MARKED ON THE SIDE OF THE
FIRST DEFENDANT / APPELLANT AS PER THE ORDER PASSED IN CMP
NO.16630 OF 2023 IN A.S.NO.731 OF 2018
S.No.
Date
Description of the Document
26.06.2023 Proceedings of the Commissioner of
Land Administration, Chepauk,
Chennai– 600 005,
in K1/2935124/2022
Nature of
document
Photostat copy
Exhibit
Ex-B.15
LIST OF ADDITIONAL DOCUMENTS MARKED ON THE SIDE OF THE
FIRST DEFENDANT / APPELLANT AS PER THE ORDER PASSED IN CMP
NO.25998 OF 2025 IN A.S.NO.731 OF 2018
S.No.
Date
Description of the Document
15.09.2025 Proceedings of the Commissioner of
Land Administration, Chepauk,
Chennai – 600 005,
in K1/2935124/2022
Nature of
Exhibit
document
Photostat copy Ex-B.16
[N.S.K., J.]
[R.S.V., J.]
03 / 06 / 2026
Index
Speaking Order
TK
: Yes
: Yes
: Yes
Page No.31 of 34
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1892
A.S. NO.731 OF 2018
To
1.The District Judge
District Court – II
Kancheepuram.
2.The Executive Officer
A/M Vaikunda Perumal Temple
Kancheepuram,
Having Office at A/M Katchabeswarar Temple
Nellukara Street, Kancheepuram.
3.The Commissioner
Kanchipuram Municipality
Nellukara Street,
Kancheepuram.
4.Superintending Engineer
Tamilnadu Electricity Board
Anna Maligai,
Olimohamedpet, Kanchipuram.
Page No.32 of 34
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1892
A.S. NO.731 OF 2018
Page No.33 of 34
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:1892
A.S. NO.731 OF 2018
N.SATHISH KUMAR, J.
AND
R.SAKTHIVEL, J.
TK
PRE-DELIVERY JUDGMENT MADE IN
A.S. NO.731 OF 2018
03 / 06 / 2026
Page No.34 of 34
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review