Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
A.S.No.933 of 2018
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
RESERVED ON
PRONOUNCED ON
: 20.11.2025
: 09.06.2026
CORAM:
THE HONOURABLE DR. JUSTICE A.D. MARIA CLETE
A.S. No. 933 of 2018
Loganathan, M/48 years,
Son of Palani Naicker,
D.No.1/139, Perumal Kovil Street,
Kanjapalli Village,
Annur Taluk,
Coimbatore.
..Appellant/Defendant
Vs.
1.Perumalammal,
Wife of late Palani Naicker,
D.No.1/139, Perumal Kovil Street,
Kanjapalli Village,
Annur Taluk,
Coimbatore.
2.Eawaran,
Son of late Palani Naicker,
D.No.1/139, Perumal Kovil Street,
Kanjapalli Village,
Annur Taluk,
Coimbatore.
3.Umamaheswari,
Daughter of Eswaran,
D.No.1/139, Perumal Kovil Street,
Kanjapalli Village,
Annur Taluk,
Coimbatore.
..Respondents/Plaintiffs
1/22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.933 of 2018
PRAYER: Appeal suit filed against the Judgment and Decree dated
09.07.2018 made in O.S.No.592 of 2015 on the file of the III Additional
District and Sessions Court, Coimbatore.
For Appellant(s):
Mr.R.Ramaraj.
For Respondent(s):
Mr.K.Myilsamy.
Mr.R.Dillikumar.
JUDGMENT
This Appeal Suit is filed against the judgment and preliminary decree
dated 09.07.2018 passed in O.S.No.592 of 2015 on the file of the III
Additional District and Sessions Court, Coimbatore whereby the partition
suit was decreed.
2. For convenience, the parties are referred to as they were arrayed
before the trial Court.
3. The case of the plaintiffs is that the 1st plaintiff Perumalammal is the
wife of late Palani Naicker; the 2nd plaintiff Easwaran and the sole
defendant Loganathan are the two sons of Palani Naicker through 1st
plaintiff ; and the 3rd plaintiff Umamaheswari is the daughter of 2nd
plaintiff . According to the plaintiffs, suit properties were the separate and
self-acquired properties of late Palani Naicker.
2/22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.933 of 2018
4. According to the plaintiffs, the ‘A’ Schedule properties originally an
extent of 5.82 acres in S.F.Nos.434/2 and 435 of Kanjapalli Village was
jointly purchased by Palani Naicker and Karuppa Naicker. By a registered
partition deed dated 22.03.1971, the said properties were divided, and an
extent of 2.91 acres was allotted to Palani Naicker. The plaintiffs further
stated that the ‘B’ Schedule properties was jointly purchased by Palani
Naicker and Chinna Naicker
about 3 acres out of 3.47 acres in
S.F.No.277/1 of Kanjapalli Village under the registered sale deed dated
14.07.1978. Subsequently, by oral partition between Palani Naicker and
Chinna Naicker, the southern portion measuring 1.50 acres was allotted to
Palani Naicker.
5. The said Palani Naicker purchased an extent of 0.75acres in S.F.No.
434 of Kanjapalli village under registered sale deed dated 17.10.1969
from one Kalimuppan. The Palani Naicker purchased the said 0.75 acres
as undivided portion and orally divided with other co owners. The Palani
Naicker's land of an extent of 0.75 acres was subdivided as
S.F.No.434/lA. The said Palani Naicker purchased an extent of 1 1/2 cent
natham land under registered sale deed dated 03.04.1978 and he occupied
adjacent natham land an extent of 1 cent in the Kanjapalli village and
3/22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.933 of 2018
build a titled house and resided with the plaintiffs and defendant. The
government issued Natham Patta to the Palani Naicker's house in his
name and the same was subdivided as Natham S.F.No. 750/10, which is
the C schedule properties.
6. Thus, according to the plaintiffs, the suit properties comprised 5.16
acres of agricultural land along with the house property. Palani Naicker
died intestate on 06.12.2004, leaving behind 1st plaintiff , 2nd plaintiff
and Defendant as his legal heirs. Therefore, each of them became entitled
to 1/3 share in the suit properties.
7. The plaintiffs further pleaded that 1st plaintiff executed a registered
settlement deed dated 11.03.2011 in favour of 2nd plaintiff, settling her
1/3 share in the A-Schedule property. Consequently, 2nd plaintiff claimed
2/3 share in the A-Schedule property. They also pleaded that 1st plaintiff
and 2nd plaintiff executed another registered settlement deed dated
11.03.2011 in favour of 3rd plaintiff , settling their combined 2/3 share in
the B-Schedule property, described as 0.74 acres in S.F.No.277/1E.
4/22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.933 of 2018
8.
The plaintiffs claimed that after the settlement deeds, 2nd plaintiff
was entitled to 2/3 share in the A-Schedule property, 3rd plaintiff was
entitled to 2/3 share in the B-Schedule property, and 1st plaintiff , 2nd
plaintiff and Defendant continued to have 1/3 share each in the CSchedule property. They further stated that no partition had taken place in
respect of suit schedule property and that they were in joint possession
and enjoyment. They alleged that the defendant refused partition and
created a false Panchayat Muchalika by using signatures obtained under
pressure.
9.
The plaintiffs also referred to the earlier suit filed by Defendant in
O.S.No.194 of 2011, later renumbered as O.S.No.2485 of 2013, based on
the alleged Muchalika. According to them, the said suit was dismissed for
default on 07.07.2015. The plaintiffs pleaded that the alleged panchayat
muchalika was not true, valid or binding and that it could not defeat their
legal shares.
10.
Case of the Defendant: The defendant admitted the relationship
between the parties and did not seriously dispute Palani Naicker’s
original title. His principal defence was that a Panchayat Muchalika dated
5/22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.933 of 2018
24.04.2011 had been entered into among the parties. According to him,
under the said arrangement, 2nd plaintiff and Defendant were each to
deposit Rs.50,000, making a total of Rs.1,00,000, in the name of 1st
plaintiff , and she was to maintain herself from the interest. The defendant
further claimed that the properties were thereafter to be divided between
2nd plaintiff and Defendant, and that 1st plaintiff was not entitled to
claim a separate share. The defendant denied the allegation that the
Muchalika was false, fraudulent or obtained by coercion. He contended
that the plaintiffs have signed the Muchalika in front of the witness and
that they could not later resile from the family arrangement. He therefore
contended that the suit for partition was not maintainable in the form in
which it had been filed. He prayed for dismissal of the suit.
11.
The trial court framed the following issue “Whether the reliefs
sought for in the plaint is to be granted?”
12.
On the side of the plaintiffs, the 2nd plaintiff Easwaran examined
himself as P.W.1 and Ex.A1 to Ex.A15 were marked. Ex.A1 is the
certified copy of the partition deed dated 22.03.1971; Ex.A2 is the
certified copy of the sale deed dated 14.07.1978; Ex.A3 is the certified
6/22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.933 of 2018
copy of the sale deed dated 17.10.1969; Ex.A4 is the certified copy of the
sale deed dated 03.04.1978; Ex.A5 is the notarized copy of Natham Patta;
Ex.A6 is the death certificate of Palani Naicker; Ex.A7 is the legal heir
certificate; Exs.A8 and A9 are the certified copies of the settlement deeds
dated 11.03.2011; Ex.A10 is the computerized patta; Ex.A11 series are
tax receipts; Ex.A12 series are water receipts; Ex.A13 series are
electricity receipts; and Exs.A14 and A15 are the certified copies of the
decree and judgment in O.S. No.2485 of 2013 on the file of the Principal
District Munsif Court, Coimbatore.
13.
On the side of the defendant, no oral evidence was let in. The
defendant did not examine himself. The only document on the
defendant’s side was Ex.B1, a Xerox copy of an unregistered sale
agreement dated 20.11.2010.
14.
The trial court, on considering the pleadings and evidence, held
that the suit properties originally belonged to Palani Naicker. It relied
upon Ex.A1 to Ex.A5 to accept the plaintiffs’ case regarding the
acquisition of the properties by Palani Naicker. It further held that, after
Palani Naicker’s intestate death on 06.12.2004, his widow 1st plaintiff
and his two sons 2nd plaintiff and Defendant each became entitled to 1/3
share.
7/22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.933 of 2018
15. The trial court then considered the two registered settlement deeds
dated 11.03.2011. Under Ex.A8, 1st plaintiff had settled her 1/3 share in
the A-Schedule property in favour of 2nd plaintiff. Therefore, 2nd
plaintiff became entitled to 2/3 share in the A-Schedule property. Under
Ex.A9 the settlement deed dated 11.03.2011, 1st plaintiff and 2nd plaintiff
had settled their combined 2/3 share in the B-Schedule property in favour
of 3rd plaintiff. Therefore, 3rd plaintiff became entitled to 2/3 share in
the B-Schedule property.
16.
The trial court rejected the defendant’s defence based on the
alleged Panchayat Muchalika. It held that the Muchalika was unregistered
and could not transfer or extinguish rights in immovable property. It also
found that the Muchalika had not been proved to have been acted upon,
since the defendant had not shown that the alleged amount of Rs.50,000
was deposited in favour of 1st plaintiff or that any partition was effected
pursuant to it. The trial court also noticed that the earlier suit filed by the
defendant, namely O.S.No.2485 of 2013, had been dismissed for default
on 07.07.2015.
8/22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.933 of 2018
17.
The trial court further observed that the revenue and house-related
documents, including patta, house tax receipts, water receipts and
electricity receipts, did not establish any prior partition. On the contrary,
they supported the plaintiffs’ case that the properties continued to remain
undivided. The trial court invoked Order XII Rule 6 CPC, observing that
the quantum of shares was not seriously in dispute and that the suit could
be disposed of on admitted shares. It passed a preliminary decree
declaring that the second plaintiff is entitled to 2/3 share in the A
schedule property, the third plaintiff is entitled to 2/3 share in the B
schedule property, and plaintiffs 1 and 2 are each entitled to 1/3 share in
the C schedule properties, with no order as to costs, with liberty to the
plaintiffs to initiate final decree proceedings if the defendant failed to
divide and allot their shares within two months.
18.
Aggrieved by the Judgment and decree, the defendant preferred
this appeal and contends in the ground of appeal that the trial Court
failed to properly consider the panchayat muchalika. According to the
appellant/defendant, the muchalika was executed before panchayatdars
and witnesses, the plaintiffs did not deny their signatures, and therefore
the burden ought to have shifted to the plaintiffs to prove coercion. The
9/22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.933 of 2018
appellant/defendant further contends that the plaintiffs did not adduce any
independent evidence to prove that the muchalika was obtained by police
pressure or coercion. It is argued that no prudent person would remain
silent after signing such a document if it had really been obtained by
force. It is also argued that the plaintiffs did not lodge any complaint
before higher police officials. The appellant/defendant also contends that
the trial Court wrongly relied on the dismissal for default of O.S.No.2485
of 2013. According to the appellant/defendant, the dismissal of the earlier
suit had no bearing on the merits of the present suit, and efforts may have
been taken to restore that suit. Another ground is that the trial Court
wrongly invoked Order XII Rule 6 CPC. The appellant/defendant submits
that even if the quantum of shares was not disputed, the title and binding
effect of the alleged settlement deeds and the muchalika were in dispute.
Therefore, according to him, the preliminary decree was premature. The
appellant/defendant further alleges that the registered settlement deeds
were executed behind his back and that, had he known about them, he
would have challenged them. He also contends that the trial Court ought
to have placed the burden on the plaintiffs to prove that the settlement
deeds were acted upon. The appellant/defendant also challenges the trial
court’s reliance on the dismissal for default of his earlier suit, referred to
as O.S.No.194 of 2011.
10/22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.933 of 2018
19.
The learned counsel for the appellant/defendant submitted that the
suit properties originally belonged to Palani Naicker and, after his death
intestate, devolved upon his legal heirs. According to the appellant, there
was a Panchayat Muchalika between the plaintiffs and the defendant,
pursuant to which the parties divided and enjoyed the properties. Based
on the said Muchalika, the defendant was in possession of his share. The
defendant relied upon Ex.B1, sale agreement dated 20.11.2010, executed
by the 2nd plaintiff in favour of Mohanasundram in respect of her share
in the ‘B’ Schedule property, contending that the said document shows
that the 2nd plaintiff had acted upon the Muchalika. It was further
submitted that though the Muchalika was marked in O.S.No.2485 of
2013, the relevant documents were produced during the crossexamination of P.W.1 and questions were put regarding the same.
20.
The learned counsel also submitted that Exs.A8 and A9, the
settlement deeds, refer to oral partition and separate possession, which
supports the appellant’s case that the Muchalika was acted upon.
According to him, the trial Court failed to frame a proper issue regarding
the Panchayat Muchalika. Therefore, relying on the Muchalika, Ex.B1
and the evidence of P.W.1, the appellant contended that the defendant is
entitled to 1/2 share in the suit properties.
11/22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.933 of 2018
21.
The learned counsel for the respondent/plaintiff submitted that,
after passing of the preliminary decree, an Advocate Commissioner was
appointed and he submitted proposals for division. The appellant filed a
reply memo suggesting certain alterations to the Commissioner’s
proposal, which amounts to acceptance of the preliminary decree.
22.
It was further submitted that the alleged Panchayat Muchalika was
not marked in the present suit. The defendant did not enter the witness
box and did not examine any panchayatdar, scribe, attestor or
independent witness to prove the Muchalika. Even the alleged deposit of
Rs.50,000/- in favour of the 1st plaintiff’s mother was not proved by any
receipt, bank record or other evidence.
23.
The plaintiff also contended that the Muchalika was created only
to defeat the plaintiffs’ lawful rights. Ex.B1 sale agreement was executed
on 11.03.2011, whereas the alleged Muchalika is dated 24.04.2011.
Therefore, the defendant’s contention that Ex.B1 was executed on the
basis of the Muchalika is factually incorrect. The plaintiffs do not deny
the defendant’s 1/3 share in the suit properties. However, the alleged
Muchalika is unproved and cannot be relied upon to claim any larger
share or defeat the plaintiffs’ rights.
12/22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.933 of 2018
24.
Points for determination :
The following points arise for determination:
1.Whether the Panchayat Muchalikka pleaded by the defendants is true,
valid and binding on the plaintiffs?
2.Whether the suit schedule properties are in the joint possession and
enjoyment of the plaintiffs and defendants, as pleaded in the plaint?
3.Whether no partition had taken place among the legal heirs of the
deceased Palani Naicker?
4.Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to the relief of partition in respect of
the suit schedule properties?
5.Whether the judgment and decree of the trial Court are liable to be set
aside?
Discussion
Point No.1:
25.
There is no serious dispute that the suit properties originally
belonged to Palani Naicker. It is also not in dispute that, after his death
intestate, the properties devolved upon the 1st plaintiff, 2nd plaintiff and
the defendant as his legal heirs. The plaintiffs claim partition on the basis
of such succession and also rely upon the settlement deeds executed in
13/22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.933 of 2018
favour of plaintiffs 2 and 3. The defendant, however, seeks to resist the
suit mainly on the basis of the alleged Panchayat Muchalikka dated
24.04.2011 and claims that, under the said arrangement, he is entitled to
1/2 share in the suit properties.
26.
When a party relies upon a document as the foundation of his
defence, the burden is upon him to produce and prove the said document
in the manner known to law. In the present case, the alleged Panchayat
Muchalikka was not marked as an exhibit. Though the defendant appears
to have been in possession of the document, for reasons best known to
him, he did not mark the same. The defendant also did not enter the
witness box. No panchayatdar, scribe, attestor or independent witness was
examined to prove the execution, contents, voluntariness or binding
nature of the alleged Muchalikka.
27.
The mere production of the alleged Muchalikka during the cross-
examination of P.W.1, and putting suggestions based on the same, cannot
amount to proof of the document. P.W.1 did not admit that the alleged
Muchalikka was true, valid or acted upon. Therefore, in the absence of
proper proof, this Court cannot act upon the alleged Panchayat
Muchalikka.
14/22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.933 of 2018
28.
The defendant also relied upon Ex.B1, the sale agreement dated
20.11.2010, executed by the 2nd plaintiff in favour of Mohanasundaram
in respect of the ‘B’ Schedule property. But Ex.B1 is not the Panchayat
Muchalikka. Further, Ex.B1 is anterior to the alleged Muchalikka dated
24.04.2011. Hence, the contention that Ex.B1 was executed pursuant to
the alleged Muchalikka cannot be accepted. P.W.1 has also stated that the
sale agreement was not acted upon and that the consideration amount was
returned to Mohanasundaram.
29.
Therefore, the Panchayat Muchalikka pleaded by the defendant is
neither proved nor legally sufficient to defeat the plaintiffs’ rights. Point
No.1 is answered against the defendant.
Point Nos.2 and 3:
30.
The plaintiffs have pleaded that all the suit properties remained in
joint possession and enjoyment of the 1st , 2nd plaintiffs and defendants.
31.
In respect of the ‘A’ Schedule property, Ex.A8
registered
settlement deed dated 11.03.2011 shows that the 1st plaintiff settled only
her undivided 1/3 share in favour of the 2nd plaintiff. Though there is a
15/22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.933 of 2018
reference to oral partition and enjoyment between the 1st , 2nd plaintiffs
and defendants , the operative portion of Ex.A8 does not establish a
completed partition by metes and bounds. Therefore, the ‘A’ Schedule
property cannot be treated as already divided and continues to be
available for partition.
32.
Similarly, in respect of the ‘C’ Schedule property, no document or
independent evidence has been produced to prove any earlier completed
partition or separate allotment of definite portions. Hence, the ‘C’
Schedule property also has to be treated as joint property available for
partition among the parties according to their shares.
33.
However, with regard to the ‘B’ Schedule property, Ex.A9 the
settlement deed dated 11.03.2011 executed in favour of the 3rd plaintiff,
contains specific recitals that, after the death of Palani Naicker, there was
an oral partition and separate enjoyment among the parties. More
importantly, the schedule to Ex.A9 the settlement deed dated 11.03.2011
states that, out of the total extent of 1.11 acres, the 1st and 2nd plaintiffs
settled their 2/3 share, namely 0.74 acre on the western side, in favour of
the 3rd plaintiff, excluding the defendant Loganathan’s 0.37 acre on the
eastern side. The boundaries mentioned therein also show that definite
16/22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.933 of 2018
portions had already been identified and separately enjoyed by the 1st
plaintiff, 2nd plaintiff and the defendant.
34.
The trial Court observed that the undivided shares under Exs.A8
and A9 were settled in favour of the concerned plaintiffs. However, on a
careful reading of Ex.A9 the settlement deed dated 11.03.2011, it is clear
that, in respect of the ‘B’ Schedule property, the settlors dealt with a
specific portion of an already divided property, with definite boundaries
adjoining the western side of the defendant’s portion. Therefore, the
recitals in Ex.A9 the settlement deed dated 11.03.2011 cannot be ignored,
especially when the plaintiffs themselves rely upon the said document.
35.
Ex.B1, the sale agreement dated 20.11.2010 , though not sufficient
to prove the alleged Panchayat Muchalikka, also supports this limited
conclusion regarding separate possession of the ‘B’ Schedule property. Its
schedule indicates that the western portion was treated as belonging to the
2nd plaintiff and the eastern portion to the defendant. Though the 1st
plaintiff is not a party to Ex.B1, the document may be looked into only
for the limited purpose of corroborating the nature of possession in
respect of the ‘B’ Schedule property.
17/22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.933 of 2018
36.
Therefore, while the alleged Panchayat Muchalikka is not proved,
the recitals and boundaries in Ex.A9 the settlement deed dated 11.03.2011
, supported by the limited reference in Ex.B1, show that the ‘B’ Schedule
property had already been orally divided and separately enjoyed. The
plaintiffs, having relied upon Ex.A9 the settlement deed dated
11.03.2011, are bound by its recitals and cannot seek partition of the
entire ‘B’ Schedule property as though it continued to remain joint.
Accordingly, the ‘A’ and ‘C’ Schedule properties are held to be available
for partition, whereas the ‘B’ Schedule property is held to have been
already divided and separately enjoyed. Point Nos.2 and 3 are answered
accordingly.
Point No.4:
37.
In view of the findings under Point Nos.2 and 3, the plaintiffs are
entitled to partition only in respect of the ‘A’ and ‘C’ Schedule properties.
In the ‘A’ Schedule property, by virtue of Ex.A8, the 2nd plaintiff is
entitled to claim the share settled in his favour by the 1st plaintiff, without
affecting the defendant’s share. In respect of the ‘C’ Schedule property,
the 1st plaintiff, 2nd plaintiff and the defendant are entitled to their
respective 1/3 shares.
18/22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.933 of 2018
38.
However, in respect of the ‘B’ Schedule property, Ex.A9 the
settlement deed dated 11.03.2011 itself shows that the plaintiffs’ side and
the defendant were already in possession of definite portions. Therefore,
the 3rd plaintiff, who claims under Ex.A9 the settlement deed dated
11.03.2011 , cannot again seek partition in respect of the ‘B’ Schedule
property as though it remained undivided. The relief of partition in
respect of the ‘B’ Schedule property is therefore liable to be rejected.
39.
Accordingly, the plaintiffs are entitled to a preliminary decree for
partition only in respect of the ‘A’ and ‘C’ Schedule properties. The claim
for partition in respect of the ‘B’ Schedule property is dismissed. Point
No.4 is answered partly in favour of the plaintiffs and partly in favour of
the defendant.
Point No.5:
40.
The trial Court was right in rejecting the defence based on the
alleged Panchayat Muchalikka, since the said document was not proved
and was not shown to have been acted upon. However, the trial Court
failed to properly consider the effect of the recitals and boundaries in
Ex.A9 the settlement deed dated 11.03.2011
with regard to the ‘B’
Schedule property. The finding of the trial Court that the plaintiffs are
19/22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.933 of 2018
entitled to partition in respect of the ‘B’ Schedule property cannot be
sustained.
41.
The judgment and preliminary decree of the trial Court therefore
require modification. The decree granted in respect of the ‘A’ and ‘C’
Schedule properties is confirmed. The decree granted in respect of the ‘B’
Schedule property is set aside. Point No.5 is answered accordingly.
42.
In the result, the appeal is partly allowed. The judgment and
preliminary decree dated 09.07.2018 passed in O.S.No.592 of 2015 are
modified by confirming the decree for partition in respect of the ‘A’ and
‘C’ Schedule properties and by dismissing the claim for partition in
respect of the ‘B’ Schedule property. There shall be no order as to costs.
Consequently, connected miscellaneous petitions, if any, stand closed.
09.06.2026
ay
Index:Yes/No
Speaking Order /Non-speaking order
20/22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.933 of 2018
To
1.The III Additional District and Sessions Court, Coimbatore.
2. The Section Officer,
V.R.Records,
Madras High Court.
21/22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.933 of 2018
DR. A.D. MARIA CLETE, J
ay
PRE DELIVERY JUDGMENT
A.S. No. 933 of 2018
09.06.2026
22/22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review